Catacombs - A Catventure Game - You got me with that art - Kickstarter Critique Review
Transcript
YouTube. I'm back again today for another Kickstarter critique where I take a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. Get my honest thoughts on how that project is being ran. And today we're over on Gamefound and we're checking out the 12th most popular project currently on Gamefound, which has to be um kind of disappointed with the outcome here. I mean, let's just be quite frank here. 2.9,000 people were signed up pre-launch or were fans of this and 151 converted. And I'm pretty sure they've been up for a few days. And that's that's a rough rate, right? That's a really rough rate. So, I'm curious to see what is not hitting the mark with this Kickstarter or this game fan campaign. Also, if you enjoy this sort of content, please be sure to click on that subscribe button down below or consider supporting my Kickstarter launching in 5 days. I'm trying to raise $3,000 to help me go to conventions this year. Pretty much not much else. What? Catacombs is a cooperative adventure game featuring dice rolling mechanics and procedurally generated dungeons where you play as a hero venturing into the darkness of a catacombs to slay and defeat evil. All characters are cats. It's designed for one to four players with a play time of around 30 to 120 minutes. Wow, that is a very wide gambit. Games will be available in five languages, English, Polish, Spanish, German, and French.
It's also quite a lot of languages. Always a bit concerning. Reason being that's a lot of work, right? especially for, you know, this game which is a 30 to 120minute game which means it's probably got some decently complex rules. That being said, I need to see more here. A box, some mechanisms, you know, some some components, anything would be better than, you know, the art cuz the art it's distinctive. Like I I'm here for the art, but other than that, you got the languages. I can't even see what that is. Like, show me something else here. And I'm sure as we go through this, it'll be apparent like, "Oh, maybe we should spotlight that instead." So, nine playable heroes, four unique bosses. Oh my gosh, is there not a video? There's an Instagram link. Okay, give me a thanks for the QR.
Like, really? No video? Okay, good, good, good. Why would they think that's like I wonder how this is ordered? Cuz like you choose to order these in a certain way, I would imagine. So, what do we got? We have the introduction. We'll start with that. 2:30. Lucas and Alex, the creators of the game catacombs. We would like to welcome you to our profile. Together we created a board game. In the game, we focus on the history of watch, a city where great evil comes out of a capital. See? So, I like that. Like, that showed me some cards there. And there's a decent amount of text on the cards. Like, oh, that that see I don't see the I don't speak that language, but that still gets me excited. Cat gathers a team. who will rise into the dungeons to defeat the greater evil.
The game mechanics are very simple and mastering the rules will only take a few minutes. Okay, if you sit down and study the instructions in 10 minutes is enough for you to take a full game.
So immediately I would mention that, right? Like if you have a 30 to 120minut game that I can learn and be up and running in 10 minutes with the rule booklet, that's that's impressive. Like I would I would totally
I would mention that somewhere here. You play both solo and two, three or four players and a simple mechanics without without challenges. So, everyone will find something for themselves. Three modes difficulties where you can play with younger or casual players, but there's also something for hardcore bored players. Game is the basic version. It has nine playable characters. We have a lot of enemies to defeat and a few bosses. Each game leads us through a randomly generated dungeon. Every game is totally different another experience. We encourage you to follow our profile on Instagram. There's a QR code where you'll be able to keep up with the progress of the game. We're about 80% completion soon.
Wait, the beta version. Do you mean the prototype? Is that what are we the beta version? That's just weird. That terminology is weird in board games, right? That's a video game term. Um because what are you talking about the prototype like prototype?
I don't know Instagram timelapse time lapse for the process and I'd love to show you this process in the next videos. The game is almost 80% completely finished such boring things as instructions boxes designed and hopefully it will start soon. Personally, I have much idea about that. I learn something new into this world every day. Learn something new. Oh no. Oh no. No. No. No. No. No. That may be true. This may be true, but no. Don't tell me that your board game rulebook writer is new to board games. That's not good. That is not good. That explains why this is not a board game geek. That explains a lot. That is concerning.
Hopefully they have a rule booklet. Like there's a full point grade bump down for that. The full third of a point grade bump down for them being too honest right there. If they do not have a rule booklet for me to gander like those two combined might be a two-thirds of point grade bump down. Like oh no I would not mention that. I would not. That's not a good thing for the process. I want the skin to be different. At the same time unique we created it from scratch. I'd love to process. Okay, it's not our last project. We're going to do other stuff. Uh, we're outsiders and we're not board game people. That's why it's going to be great because it's going to be different. And that's the pitch. I need to see more of the game. This is not going to be what I want. Is it? What is this? Why is this? Why is there nothing here? Oh, there is.
What? Yeah, I'm ready. Why is this here? Okay, it was it wasn't me. It's just silence and blackness and then a jump scare at Where is it? Where are you? Is there not even a jump scare? What? You didn't even jump scare me? You're going TO WASTE MY TIME? WHY is that here? What? Yeah, that that's okay. So, 151 backers have made this uh almost across the finish line. One new single-use item token if we hit 25,000. So, 5,000 over and we'll get one single use item token. That's going to be a hard one to get, I would imagine. How many days we got left? 20 days. Okay, so we do have a good chunk left. Good. So, this one's probably definitely going to get across the finish line. Uh, also, judging by their background, they might know some people that get them across the finish line. So, 140 bucks gets you the ultra set. And that is a terrible picture of the ultra set. Like that is just objectively terrible. Like half of this picture is literally nothing. Like I want you to see this. I don't this I think that's just you opening the board.
So we're not even going to count that. This and then combined with this that is literally half of this square. That is just nothing. And that's fine, but zoom in. Show me how many boxes am I getting? Am I two boxes? What are these? What are these things? I don't know. It's not obvious. What's that? I don't know because you're so far zoomed out. Is that a plastic mini cat thing inset thing? I don't know. I'm excited to find out cuz I'm sure you're going to do different things cuz you sp Hey, we're different people. Like we're not from the board game world. We're going to do things different. I'm excited to see what all that stuff is. Uh so yeah, Catacombs is cooperative adventure game featuring dice roll mechanics and procedure. Okay, so this this is the they are first time publishers. Good to know. So this is the trailer.
But now it has become necessary. We cannot allow our city to tremble in fear at
who's ready to go on the hunt.
Okay. AI generated. I shouldn't say that. Animated whatever. I don't care if it's AI generated. A a an animated thing of the the theme of the cats. Moving on. I see it. Uh where cats are the heroes and villains. Entirely handdrawn. So it's not a generated. So they're just showcasing their artwork. Cool. Uh you're ask I want you to showcase the game though. That's what I want to showcase. like whatever this is like. Oh, I've seen tons I've seen literally over a hundred probably beautiful games, very good-looking games that were just so incredibly meh to worse. And it's like it it's not enough anymore. It's just not. Since Kickstarter exploded this hobby a decade plus ago, it's just not good enough anymore for most people. That now that's going to get me. Look at that. the artwork combined with the like the theme is coming across in the graphic design.
That's what I want to see. A decent amount of text here. Roll the dice. See what happens. That's what I want to see. That's the game play. I don't care about your fancy looking art. Despite simple mechanics, catacombs could be quiet. Just show me a gameplay video. Is this the intro? What is this?
You had this up there earlier. No need to show me it again. Did we mention that game is entirely handdrawn? You did. That's not enough. That's not enough. I don't care. I'm not buying a painting. I am buying a 30 to 120 minute game with a bunch of other random things that you have not even begun to tell me about. So hopefully we do it here. Work in progress. Okay. What is this? What is all this? Is this What is it? What are these things? These are just random images presumably from your game. I don't know. And this is this is why I in I say this all the time. Before you launch a Kickstarter, go look at a bunch of other Kickstarters that are just live that are in your lane, Kickstarter board games, and just see the industry standard, right? Just just browse through say 10 of them, five of them, and see what things you see consistently. You're like, "Oh, that's pretty good. Oh, they did that, too." or oh someone else did that too and that's how you learn the industry standard and this is not it and I don't think it will become it. This is now the fourth time I have seen your QR code for your Instagram and the zero time I've seen the rule booklet a gameplay video a how to play video um just just so many other useful pieces of information. Hey, here's the people who made it. I don't care. There's a reason this is typically at the bottom.
I'm here for the game. I'm not here for you most of the time. What is it all about? 1 to4 90 120 minutes. Cool. Cooperative dungeon crawl. You said that. Okay. So, oh, hey, that's that's what it looks like. That looks neat. That's the first time I think I've seen that. Why back us right now? Not AI generated. And see, that's Oh my gosh. And that's exactly why you shouldn't focus on your I literally was just like, yeah, it's probably AI generated because I just like I just assume now like give me really nice hand illustrated AI generated stuff. It's like You gotta You gotta focus on what's important and it's not your art. A unique world and style. Show it to me in the game. Ultra set 140 bucks. 51 people took this. This is in theory your deluxified. That's not great. That is very bad.
Okay. No, it's one. It's a third of your people. I take that back. A third of your people. No, that's still not great. That means a 100 people did not take your deluxified version of the game, which means you did not sell it well. Because as I say in this, if you crushed your deluxified version of the game, you will typically sell 7 to 10 times more of that version of the game than your standard version of the game. That's just typically the averages that we see. And this is you're not hitting it. You're not going to hit it. Corridors of Doom expansion. Why is this here? Who just needs this? This is an add-on. There's a whole section. YOU EVEN HAVE AN ADD-ON SECTION. Why would I just want this expansion? Who the hell? I just really want the Oh, there's acrylics. I did not even realize there's acrylics. Third of a point grade bump down. Like, come on.
Like, that is such a selling point. And then like I have to click on this random box to see. Oh, but I know you did handdrawn art. I've seen your QR code four times. I haven't even seen your acrylics. Oh, that's what they are. They're here, but they're so foggy. LIKE, LET'S PUT FOG IN FRONT. LET'S GET OUT. LET'S SHOW FOG EVERYWHERE. More fog. Yes. Let's see less of your game. Let's see less of your components. More mystery is what I want when I'm going to give you $170 most likely when it comes, you know, time to shipping because that's $140. So, yeah, we're looking right around 170 200 bucks probably. Here's the core box. That's not the kind of box I was expecting. Um, what size is it? So, you got 13 acrylics, a generic die. Well, it's it's a weird die. It's interesting die. It's just I don't know. I like the die, but it seems uh here's tester reviews.
This is weird to put it here. I would have these scattered about. I would have these, you know, when you were telling me the second time about your handdrawn art, maybe like some quotes from anyone is better than from no one. Like because if I am to this step of the process where I see this, I'm probably gonna give you my money, I would guess, right? This needs to be on the outside. The game is interesting, engaging. It's great that there are many characters to choose from, which allows each player to different try different strategies and new playthrough. It's asymmetrical. Cool. Considering its complexity, the rules are quite clear, and you can get the hang of them relatively easy after the first game, which is a big plus. You can get them relatively easy after the first game, which is a big plus. That's nice. You don't have to always play with the same group. The design itself is thoughtful and consistent. The main characters have distinct personalities. Here's some quotes for some people. OB I Okay, so no one has back. Oh, no. Three people took your core box. Okay, so I take it back. You have crushed it. You have absolutely destroyed Bower's law.
You have sold what? 17 times to one your core box. 53 bucks seems reasonable though, honestly. Like I would lead with that. I would say this is a $60 game. I go back to that main image and how it's just eh like 60 $53 whatever that $60 roughly. That's such a low amount of money on Kickstarter and Gamefound. Especially if I like the cut of your jig and I want this weird game from you know a different part of the world where you speak different languages with the crazy awesome amazing art artwork and all that sort of stuff with the cats. Like people eat that sort of stuff up. Show me that I can get in on that at 53 bucks. And I think you'd get more people just like oh what the core game plus the expansion 65. That's very reasonable and that's why more people have taken this than your deluxified version. That's how poorly you've sold your deluxified. More people are like, "Nah, I'm good. I can just get the core plus the expansion."
That is not how people like to shop on Kickstarter. And if anyone at Catacombs is telling someone else that that's how people shop on Kickstarter or GameF, that's not how you shop. That's not how they shop. People always want to give you more money. And the fact that like that is that is spotlight your game, not all the other crap. full set of vampir. Okay. A custom dice tray, which now now I'm getting concerned. Right now I'm getting concerned about the 20,000 euro asking price because we're not just making one game. We're making two games essentially because we have the expansion, but we're also making these these pointless little dice rollers. And we're also going to make these vampire figurines. And then we're also going to make whatever's in the ultra set, which what's different about the ultra set?
Oh, card sleeves for the oversized cards. Okay. And uh what else? Core game A4 premium art print. Oh, art print. Cool. They're making some good money off those. Good for them. Uh custom playing mat. So, there's a playing mat. Okay. Way to not really spotlight that. Well, and it looks very like like that is a terrible playmat. Like I absolutely despise that playmat. Either make it functional or make it artsy, but you manage to make it neither. And just to put your name out there, why you couldn't you couldn't have made it all cool dungeonyy themed or cat themed or litter boxes or something. You're just like, nah, our name. No wonder no one wants this pledge. It feels halfass.
And the way you're selling it to me does as well. Just click on it. Find out what's in it. See if you want to pay us $90 more than the base game because that's what it is. 87 if you're a stickler. But convert the currencies and it's probably over 90, right? Like are you serious? Yeah. Nobody's like your game is not special. And that's one thing you always need to remember. Your game is special to you, but you are the what was it? The eighth most popular project on Gamefound. And if you run Kickstarter, you might be the 200th most popular project that is live right this moment. And now we have stretch goals that you know, are are we hitting these? Probably not. And they're they're huge chunks, too. That is 25% of your funding goal to get a single item token. Are you freaking kidding me? as someone who literally worked for a manufacturer and gave people quotes on their game. It's like, "What's in your game? I'll give you a quote. I'll figure out how big your your components are going to be, like how the size your components and the cards and all of this sort of stuff." Yeah, these are literally just tokens. So, here's a dirty little secret. That's probably just extra space they had on their token sheet cuz it's like, "All right, we need two 8x10 in token sheets." And what it would be like, so that's going to have all your little your gems and all the different things that you're going to pop out.
Then they'd be like, we have you also have like a 2x6 in square left over here where you could put in extra stretch goals or various different things like that that can add value to your game or play raids or various different stuff like that that I always would suggest. So the dirty little secret is that extra 25% probably isn't costing them anything and you're going to get it for free no matter what. I would be willing to wager. New villain. So, this is a new villain. And that is like a big deal. That one's like an acrylic, right? So, that one's a big banger. And I wonder if that's why because that's actually going to need more than the I don't know. Either way, I am concerned. Apologize for the drinking sound. Oh, hey, there's that massive vampire figurine you did a really poor job of selling me. It's 15 cm. Thanks for not converting that to inches for the majority of people who are going to back this who most of the time will be from the United States of America. Now for this one I imagine it's going to be where you are from like whichever whatever region you're from is going to be so it's yeah that's a 6inch tall cat.
Okay. Yeah. I didn't feel like that was sold well. It's just kind of blends in like Yeah. Throw the card sleeves in front of it. throw the these art prints behind it, but make them so small that you're like, are those cards? What are those? Like like a custom leather patch that Oh, that's Yep. You got to get that in the ultra set. That one just feels like it's straight up for the artist, honestly. Which I can understand that one. I could to banking on that cuz you know that Yeah, cuz you're getting two of them them as well. Good for them. Good for them. They're going to be able to make a lot of swag they can sell on the side. Like these acrylic standes, like if you're running an art booth right there, like just like, "Hey, here you go. Just throw that in there with you. You like the the art like throw this in." Awesome. Good for them. Excellent game. Oh, low hopes for the game though. I got to say, based on what you've shown me, it is just like that's just me. So, that game. Okay. It looks like it's roughly the size of like a like a like a like what is that?
Villainous. Maybe that is that roughly the size of the box. Okay. It doesn't feel like a game I want to go spend $140 for the ultra set on with one expansion. Like, not at all. Not even if you sold it to me. Well, there's the rule booklet. Love how that's just an actual book, which I'm I'm assuming you're not going to give me because that would be stupid, right? Like that would just be dumb and count like that would cost so much money. Let me tell you, books. It's a whole separate ball game. Characters, cards, three pieces, kind of. Okay, so this is all the expansion stuff. Cool. I want it. I don't I don't just because I like I want to play the Oh, hey. How to play? Wow. Why is this buried just And I get it. It's here. You can It's clickable, but [sighs and gasps] it just feels buried. This should be led with cuz look, it's so low on the page. Hopefully, this is great. Welcome to Catacombs. This is example for two players. The expedition has begun. If luck is on our side, we might still see the sunrise. Faced with events we know nothing about. The dungeon is full of surprises. Not necessarily pleasant ones.
We have to hurry to find the chambers with the ritual candles. There isn't much time. If we hurry, we might make it out of here.
I don't need to keep seeing your art. Like, I don't need to see the cat. I'd rather see the board in your how to play video. Like, this is where it should be. Business business. Either way, it's nice it's there. Not knocking this at all. I would put it higher. How to play. Cool. How to play Uno F1 Elite. I I don't know. I believe that's in that new series though that's similar to the uh the NFL Uno Elite version. So, I imagine if you watch my video on NFL Uno Elite, most of that will probably translate to Uno F1 Elite. Um that'd be my best bet because I do not own it unfortunately. But I am curious if you do end up uh playing it. I would be curious to know if it is compatible because that would be fun. I'd want to get it if I could combine NFL Uno with Hey, there's cats with F1 Uno. Look at that. Is a different languages.
Is a content creator.
It's just somebody talking in front of a picture. Oh, it's like a darkest dungeon for cat lovers, but not quite because despite many similarities, the game has a lot of things that set it apart. For example, the adventure cards description. See, so that's what I'd lead with. Like honestly, if that's a quote from someone, Catacombs is like darkest dungeon but for cat lovers. I'd cut off the but not quite. Like just leave it there. Leave me at the what? And then hit me with a $57. Hit me with some gorgeous artwork, some nice looking acrylics. This should be easy to sell this honestly. Like this feels like the kind of thing. This feels like one of those hidden gems that people on Kickstarter and GameFound love to find. the game you bust out at the table and you're like, "Oh, what's that game? I've never seen that game." Oh, well, there's probably about a thousand of them out in the existence because I backed the game found. I was like, "Oh, that artwork's gorgeous." The acrylics.
It's like, "Yeah, like that's that's PART OF THE APPEAL of this." Like, it's like the snooty nature of the hobby. And that's how the hobby got big in the first place. Eurogame literally, there were people like they're like, "Oh yeah, these games from Europe way better than our games." And they're like, I just And I love it. I love it. Catacomb. It's about the artist. I need to know more. Uh developers He gets his own video. They don't. Shipping. Uh, so Poland 7810. Great. 31 3352. Not great, but to be expected. So I'm ending up paying like 90 bucks for the base game with the expansion. We're up to around what, like 120 something. Let me check that. 100. Yeah. So yeah, 100ish. Wish they would have convert the currencies for, but whatever.
Okay, it feels Kickstarter reasonable. It does. Honestly, the shipping doesn't feel great. The price doesn't feel great. Let Let me rephrase that. The shipping does not feel great. The price of the ultra set feels like you are stabbing me in the eye. And the price of the other ones, they feel fine. I don't know, funny, but I don't know. Game. Uh, yeah. Sorry, man. I don't own Uno F1 Elite. I was looking at it on Amazon, though. I know it's hot. Oh, it's a hot game right now. comments, updates, FAQ. Give this one a grade. We tried again and from our phones a poll and the project does not show up on featured. Very weird and that does not help you guys. We're extremely grateful for all your support. We're working on polishing the instruction and release it in new update in a few days. Yeah, people expect that. Hopefully that's up there. You'll be able to download and have a look. Stay tuned. Thank you so much. Have a good weekend. Just come on.
Like just you should know you need that when you launch and you should want that when you launch because people will look at it and people will make you feel bad because they will tell you did you did a bad job and if enough people tell you you did a bad job in a specific way you'll be like you know what maybe I did a bad job and fix it right or they'll give you ideas or tweaks or be like that's a little unclear here or that that language translation doesn't quite work. So the earlier the better especially with you having five languages. I want to reiterate how concerning that is that you do not have a rule booklet when you have five languages. You do not have a full gameplay video when you were saying you were going to have five languages for this game that plays up to 120 minutes. I and two rule booklets no less because you have an expansion.
It's very concerning. I hope so. Actually, when is this one shipping? I do want to see. So, this one hopefully I'll feel a little less conservative like this one's like not coming out for a while. Why isn't it just front and center? December 2020. Oh, no. This is coming out in seven months. Okay. Yeah. No, it's not. It's It's not with a great rule booklet. I can't imagine. Like, wow. Seven months. That's a really quick turnaround time. Um, it's very unrealistic. Not not negative, like whatever. Most projects are late, but it's just like that's like wow. Like people I would market that then if you honestly believe you're going to get out in December to then tell people you know have have it under the Christmas tree catacombs for the holidays like have honestly lean into that. Put have your gorgeous looking cat artwork. Put on a Christmas hat on it. Say it's shipping December hopefully. You know like little stuff like that can go a long way. Please add playthrough videos. I don't get what gameplay is like. Yeah it's not clear at all. We're working on finishing instructions. We'll be posting with next update. Wow. Hey, I know you want that other thing, but instead I'm gonna give you this thing that I should have already had up there in addition to the thing that you're asking for that I should have already had up there.
It I hope it's on the updates. Oh man, I still cannot see the project on my phone. Um, just visit board game page and there's pictures up. Do yourself a favor and get those gorgeous artworks uploaded. You ask it's something we'd like to get that fixed. Oh. Oh, I thought it wasn't on BG. Perhaps it is now. Awesome. updates. There is no update. Oh no. Are you kidding me? Are you kidding me? You've been up for eight days and you can't say anything to your backers. They launch at 428. One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. THIS IS DAY NINE and you have no updates. And you know why? I bet you have no updates because you don't want to post AN UPDATE WOULD HAVE THE RULE BOOKLET that you're saying that you had up there. So if you wouldn't have said it's in the next update, you should be like coming in the near future. Like even your choice of wording eight days that JUST REEKS OF, WOW, WE REALLY THOUGHT WE were going to make a lot more money. What the hell do we do now? That is never a good look. I imagine these comments uh there's got to be a couple honest ones in here. Uh we're extremely grateful for all support. We're working on polishing the rule booklet. Hopefully this gets funded. Still cannot pass.
Just finished the board game somewhere to see a gameplay video. Uh but trying to find this project on my wife's mobile phone. Is this is this is this the same person? Just really wants to find it on his phone. Seems very strange. Yes, I see someone from P. Okay, whatever. Is this a reprint? I literally have this game in my collection with slightly different art. What? As far as I know, it's the first game, so no, not a reprint. Cool. I wasn't asking you. I want to hear from the company. Yeah, brother Uriel. Uh, what? Good for you. Say the name of the game. It's made from scratch. It's not a reap or anything. There's no way you could have a game somewhere, my friend. Winky face.
Huh? Uh, who is Carrie Harrison? I am I am curious to see what game Carrie Harrison has in their collection because Carrie Harrison has bath myth wins which which means that I believe and she has backed dragon Eclipse room 25 fth edition netherwatch Marvel United Witching Hour, Hell Legends, Dice, The Flame of Fire, Below the Asylum, Massive Darkness. This is someone who has backed a lot of projects saying, "I have this game on my shelf." And then this other random person who just keeps insisting on bringing up the status of their phone, which by the way bumps all previous comments and discussions further down. If you want to use it as a tool in a negative way, which you shouldn't, but you can. um is like nope.
This is so weird. Uh sorry to keep this but I try to find this part my wife's mobile phone. Is this a reprint? Uh thanks for doing a gameplay video. Eject some parts of it. I do understand it correctly that combat is basically just roll a die then roll again. There's no tactics or way to influence the outcome. Also in a previous comment you mentioned loot equipment or at least that's how I understood it. But I didn't see anything like that in the gameplay. I mean things like swords, armor, shields, torches, whatever you could equip to improve your character. Pretty standard fair. You'd expect it to be there. Hey, it's just a roll of the dice, but remember that you have skills. So, dice mitigation. Uh, potential generated by these skills rarities. You can use members, you can use equipment. Okay, this seems to be a problem. I'm using my game found on my phone. I can only see it on spotlight. Are these all in like the same period? Was this This was just really popping on day one. Some chains for check language.
I find this project hard to find a brother Yuriel. This looks like a fun game. I'm not into campaign games. I just don't have the time. I hope you guys succeed and that you created something to be unique and fun to play. Looking forward to this funding and getting my copy. Who is like this is such okay is wait 1840 agent blinds. That one caught my eye for a different reason because it was AI generated. It looked very AI generated and I was curious to see how that one was going to do. Yeah, they embraced it. So this person has not backed uh anything else. Oh no, they have. They have follow.
Okay, they backed onward. Okay. Okay, the next show. It's just weird. It's weird. That whole comment section is just weird. And I really want to find Carrie and be like, "Hey Carrie, what what game are you talking about?" So hopefully if and honestly if you are seeing this in the future and you also are curious, you go check out that game found it. Please post it in the comments. I will pin it. I want to get to the bottom of this mystery because I I believe Carrie like after looking at that what games they've backed, I'm like, "Yeah, yeah, I could see that." But then again, I also could see them just having a very similar game and a big stack of other games that were backed on Kickstarter or Gamef. I could see that either way now that I've talked about. Okay. Uh, final grade. Yeah, I guess we're out of here. That's a weird one. Do I want it? Um, not really. I don't feel like you did a great job at all spotlighting your game or really your components, which is so insane to me because you have acrylics, which people love acrylics. There's a whole camp of appeal the people that love acrylics over minis. I'm in that camp personally. You have an acrylics game. You have a reasonably priced under 60 bucksish.
You have a unique art style theme. But it's just do I want it? No. you didn't you didn't show me anything really tangible or of value that was like helpful in my decision-making purchase if I want to buy a great game and that comment of like hey the boring thing about doing the rule booklet and like I'm I'm not from the board game world and I'm making the rule booklet and then like the fact that the rule booklet's still not here and you said it's going to be here and you've launched 8 days ago and got 16,000 Do you know how many other Kickstarter and Gamefound campaigns would just be over the freaking moon to have 16,000 freaking bucks? And it's just that's that's when it gets put in perspective.
You think Disodah wouldn't be like just over the like the like just [sighs] Yeah. Yeah. And it just doesn't feel like you like eight days. Not a thank you, not anything at all except Yeah. We're coming with the rules. the bare minimum we're coming with because you know inevitably people are gonna ask for the expansion rule booklet next final grade is not great. So do I want it? No. Can you do it? Uh I don't feel comfortable with it at all. I hate to say it but no. Cut your jig. I don't like it. The focus on the art. I don't like it. The just everything I've spotlighted just there's so many minor red flags that if you ignore them all and you get burned, you can't be surprised. And and when I say by getting burned, I do mean I think this game will probably see daylight probably, right?
Like because at the end of the day, you got to look at it from the artist perspective. They're going to be making a lot of stuff that they can sell on the back end that they are going like you buy buying a hundred of those, you know, leather leather things, right? Stuff like that. So, but will it be a great game? You might want to wait for 2.0 or or read the rule booklet when they finally get around to doing it. So, can you do it? I don't feel comfortable with it at all. And then how much is it? It feels fine. I feel like that honestly was one of your biggest selling points that you just neglected to just like when I your first impression is 140 bucks and my first impression is no thank you and then wait what am I even buying over here and then I'm like oh it's just it's just $57 for the base game or what like 60 for the base game and the expansion. I'll just get that.
And that's what most people did. That is the initial reaction that you and then this why is just h [sighs and gasps] like that's one of those red flags like it's not a big deal at all but it's just like it's it's why is it it's it feels like a little mistake and you're like those add up those add to money and when you are cutting it close on getting funded potentially and you're making a 6-in mini and this and card sleeve well I guess maybe the card sleeve probably aren't custom. I don't think the card sleeves are custom, are they? Let's Let's get in those. Uh the and the art prints without spotlight. Yeah, just just final grade. And then final grade is not good. It's a D.
Just And that not spotlighting the things that really you should get to earlier. Just not having the basic things that people would expect you to have. not posting for eight days after you get 80% of your funding goal. Yeah, you got us 80% of the way there, but we still have nothing to say to you. Like, what? That's just wild to me. You got 32 thumbs, 32 people excited. Look at those. Look when you zoom in on your acrylics. Oh, you're making with long pack once again. Why isn't that on your page that makes you look more credible?
Like little things like that and you just FY ministers the project. I'd love to but I understand if not considering that you said it's a small team. We're a small team and everything looks so Yeah. Okay. Well, they're making one but whatever. Final grade is Yeah. D let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Catacombs a cat venture game. And if you have a suggestion for an upcoming Kickstarter game found or backer kit project, please be sure to leave it in the comments below. or if you want to not see me stress out at all, please consider supporting my upcoming Kickstarter. I'm trying to raise $3,000 next Tuesday we launch to uh help me pay from the cost of going to Origins Gen Con and shoot some more board game coverage and uh just really not have to pull out of the family account with three kids uh to go do more Bowowers Game Corner stuff. So, get yourself a Kickstarter critique for 30 bucks or two for 30 if you sign up early in the pre-launch link down below. Or let me know in the comments below if you have this game on your shelf as well or if you are Carrie, please. I want to get to the bottom of that mystery, but have yourselves a good one. Bye-bye.