Barrage Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hi everyone today i'm talking about barrage which is a 2019 release board game designed by tommaso batista and simone luciani this one was published by cranial creations and accommodates one to four players takes about two hours to play maybe a bit more than that if you're playing with more than two players so the idea of the game is quite interesting so we're supposed to be these i suppose energy tycoons trying to harness power from water and we're going to spend the game building dams and conduits and power stations trying to get as much power as we can and um ultimately get as many points as we can so this game came out with a bit of controversy due to the kickstarter campaign for this game um due to some rather un stand or substandard components but i'm going to be reviewing this version of the game which is the kind of the retail version in its own right so i won't be talking about any of those issues or any of those components so um so ultimately this is a worker placement game where you've got all these different spots that you can do and um activate different abilities but i don't think the game really lies with the worker placement aspect of the game it's really to do with the main board itself and how everything interacts with each other because as you can see you've got all these different pools um flowing down the mountain so you've got the kind of pools where the rain initially comes and it flows down the mountains getting caught in dams and ultimately convert it into power so everybody is going to have their own little player board here that looks like this which stores
your um your dams it stores your little extensions for your dams to capture more water they can store your conduits here but as you can see these will be used and your power stations you've also got a little board here which stores all your resources and um and a little resource will here which is quite a nifty mechanism which i'll talk about shortly so as i said you're trying to get as much any energy points as you can in order to get points based on this track here so the more power you generate from round around you're gonna flight this track and ultimately get money and get these different bonuses which you can get points for and there's also an endgame scoring criteria here which again can get you a lot more points but let's talk about how the game actually works on the board because this is a very interactive game a lot of cutting off um other people a lot of um a bit of nastiness you know you've got you've got to be a bit savvy and constantly be one step ahead of your opponent so as i mentioned the water is going to flow down or every from around around the water is going to flow down these um down these pools and get caught in these dams here so for example this dam here which is a neutral dam because it's not a player piece is ready to be harvested and in order to harvest this water and turn it into energy you need to have three components so you need to have the dam itself a conduit which is this one here and that can be of any player's color and ultimately a power station which are these ones here like this and once you have all three of those you can choose to convert
that water into energy based on the value here so if i wanted to convert this one into energy it would ultimately get put through this conduit here and spat out with this pet energy station to get me full energy per raindrop that's gone through it now the interesting thing here is that it doesn't have to be your conduit that you use so for example here uh let's have a look let's say let's say let's use this for an example so if i if i am used this if i had water here in this dam and let's say i didn't have this conduit here then i could still use my opponent's conduit if this was my energy station and um end up paying my opponent one point for each or my opponent would get one point for each raindrop that's come through the conduit and also one coin for each money that's gone through the um quantity of conduit so it's a bit of an interactive game where you know you can really capitalize on other players um other players dams and stuff so not only focusing on your own game is important you've really got to be aware of how to capitalize on other players games as well another thing as well the the size of the dams is very important because here let's say let's say the water flowed here because this dam is only one high it means that it can only actually store one water in this pool and if there's another rain flow over it then it would actually go over that one and get caught in the next dam meaning that this one can only hold two water
and so on so as your building down's higher is important because you can store more and more water but doing so is going to cost a lot more resources and take time because the way you build things is based on this really nifty um mechanism where you spend your resources but when you spend your resources that are actually gone from the game so let's say let's say i wanted to build a dam here so this would be my down action and basically this means that i can build a dam if it's in the mountains which is the top part of the board it'll cost me five of these workers if it's a in the hills which is the middle section it'll cost me four and if it's on the planes it'll cost me three and then what i would do is i would take those resources so let's say i wanted to build it in the planes by spending three of these little guys i would put those on my resource wheel here like this um that would be the wrong one so let's let's use the correct one here like this and then i would rotate this wheel meaning that these resources are tied up until it comes all the way back round and spat out the other end so whenever you buy anything uh you don't actually get rid of the resources back into the pool you actually just tie them up for a portion of time and one of the actions on the board here is to spend workers in order to make that wheel rotate faster so you know you can spend one worker to make it retake one or you can spend you know two to make it a bit of money to go twice or two and a bit of more money in order to make it spend three times so
the you know the more you use this action the workshop action you can actually get your resources back quicker and build quicker and as you can see when you do build stuff not only does stuff become more expensive based on how high it is up the hill because obviously the the raid is going to get caught higher up the hill if you do build a higher up the hill but some things such as the conduits they cost you more resources based on the efficiency of the conduit um actual line it's on so say for example this one here is a strength of three that would cost me two times three um whereas the cheaper ones you know the really rubbish ones down here uh let's have like this one here would only get me two times one so it'll be cheaper to build there but the energy conversion is a lot worse and additionally when you build stuff you start to unlock other abilities as well which trigger at the beginning of each round so when you for example when i built this down here you get three points but also at the beginning of each round you get an additional three points okay this one here lets you get more machinery this one that just gets you seven points this one here uh you know gives you money and you know more money gets you more energy and so on and additionally every single player board like like these ones have uh a unique power on them as well which are quite interesting when you build your fourth conduit you get an additional power so for example this one um when he oh sorry i'm wrong one i'm thinking about the power stations when you build your um third power station you get a unique
player action depending on the player board so this one for example when you when you do the um when you produce uh energy you get to do it again from another power station uh all these different player boards as well on the side which hold your resources have a unique power run as well which are quite nifty and that's basically going to be how the game flows so let's talk about some of the actual worker placement spots here so the top bit here is where you are going to actually choose to harness that water into energy and as you can see there's some different values here that give you bonus points so if you take one of these spots which are i suppose the more lucrative spots you're gonna get a bonus two energy which is obviously going to make you climb up this track a lot quicker and hopefully give you those bonuses you've got the depending on the player count you've got the plus one one you got the one that gives you no bonuses and you've even got ones that give you negative effects as well but sometimes it's more than worth doing it because the conversions can be very good you've also got the water management spots here and these ones basically let you add raindrops to the top of the mountains or let you add a single raindrop and let you make that water flow instantly getting caught in the relevant dam and something i should mention as well is that just because these spots are taken these spots are still usable but they come with a cost so getting somewhere is really important to go there for a more efficient cost but if you really need that action you can still go there but it's going to cost you a bit more money there's a bank which simply lets you
convert your workers into into money you've got the workshop as i mentioned which lets you spin your wheel you've got the machinery shop which actually buy new machinery for your for your resource wheel and you've got the contract office and this contract office is where you're going to get a lot of your points so you've got three different kind of tiers of contracts you've got your easier ones the more medium ones and the more difficult ones and basically what this means is that you need to generate that much energy in order to get the rewards here so for example in this two contract if you generate two energy in one turn then you get five money or two energy three money and two raindrops where you want to put them and so on there's also one kind of public contract here where it's particularly difficult to achieve but if you do you get a rather big bonus to build things you've got your own player board here so to build the first thing is going to cost you one worker then two workers then three workers and then three workers and a bit of money but at the same time you've got to be wary of the fact that you've only got a certain amount of these things you can actually build so you can only have one of each and you've got a wild card as well if you are not playing the advanced game and that's going to be basically how the game's going to flow it's going to be over five rounds um as i said trying to generate as much energy as you can because whoever generates the most money each turn is going to get an additional six points whoever whoever's in second place is going to get two points and if you if you reach the threshold of
these certain um points that i use for each round so for example in the third round if i get to this point here then i'm going to get five points for each extension of my dams but for every kind of threshold that you're behind then you're going to suffer a minus four penalty um to that score so you know getting up that track is really important not only for getting money but also for getting those points as well but something that's important as well is that if you aren't the player who generates the most energy then you are going to become the first player in the next round and that's going to be how you're going to play barrage so let's talk about what i actually think about the game and how it works so first off i really was expecting this game to be very heavy in terms of the rules but i was very pleasantly surprised this is not a difficult game to learn but it is a very heavy game in terms of its decisions constantly reacting to what other players are doing trying to cut them off trying to get the most value out of your dams trying to get the best conversion rates so yeah all the all the weight of the game lies in the gameplay itself which i think is absolutely amazing there is really is no faff to this game whatsoever the rules are very intuitive and basically it's streamlined to a very good degree considering how involved the game is i love the way the the networks and stuff are built on this game board is really fantastic because you can as i said completely capitalize on the state of the board and divert water
to where your stations are you can put conduits and other players dams to get loads of money that way and so on so there is really uh a lot to think about here and it's a constantly a constant game of one-upmanship with your opponents you can go for the really cheap um cheap spaces down here in order to get you know cheap cheap real estate and cheap power stations but you're going to be getting the dregs of the water that aren't captured higher up the um higher up the mountain range and additionally you can actually divert water back onto your tracks by using the correct power stations so let's take this for example so say this dam here you know if i had a power station down here or here then i can actually just divert this water and spit it straight back out into my another another dam here so absolutely great the way the game works um i think thematically it's just so good in terms of the way everything flows and i said it's just logical i just like the way that everything makes sense in this game there is no side rules there are no real exceptions to the rules or anything that doesn't come naturally to the player so i really can't fault it in that respect whatsoever i think it's a a great rule set for such an involved game where normally you know you could be sat there explaining this game for or game of this kind of weight for a long time but this one is so so easy to portray to other players meaningful decisions is just well
it is what this game is all about there is nothing in this game that isn't meaningful you can try and kind of be a bit proactive and try to get some of these more lucrative spots early in the game but then people could just divert the water around you and try so i said it's a really is a game of constantly reacting to other players but yeah i said you've got so many decisions to make you've got to worry about generating the energy in order to get these bonuses you've got to worry about the bonuses themselves in order to get the points you want to get the upgrades on your player board so you can get all these different incomes and so on you want to keep getting more machinery so you can build more you got to make sure your wheels are spinning so that you get your resources back in an efficient time you want to make sure you've got a decent amount of contracts so you're getting the rewards when you do generate that energy so there really is so so much to think about and additionally there is another player board which i've not talked about where you can actually get these other upgraded um kind of resource tiles which give you little upgrades as well also in on top of that you got to make sure making sure that you are making benefit of your power because you know everybody's got their own unique power so this one for example i can spend these resources in order to build my conduits but a much better conversion weight conversion rate so that's a one-to-one ratio where normally it's a it's a two-to-one ratio and again using your player powers to benefit as well so there is so much to think about and at all times you are going to be engaged
and thinking about what you're going to do next while still considering what your opponent's doing because they can really do they really can throw you under the bus and start diverting all your very valuable water away from you the balance of the game i think is is really good i mean i've not fully explored all the player boards but they seem to add up okay um you know all the contracts are proportionate the kind of the the value of the different worker spot seems put spot on really and i like the fact that whoever's kind of generating the least money from round to round is going to be the first player next round which is again very important and i said most most of the balance and stuff lies in the game itself so there's not really any scope for somebody just getting lucky with anything it's not really a game of luck whatsoever you can very meticulously plan how the game is going to play out mechanically absolutely fantastic i said not only because of the simple rules overhead but just this board just works magnificently i cannot stress enough about how well designed this game board is and how it all flows and just the the pure variability that you could have and different diversions you could have depending on the situation time investment the game takes i said about two hours for a two player game um and it's going to take a bit more than that you know when you get into that three or four player account but i must say that if in that in that time period there is no scope to lose interest i mean we
played a game of this yesterday took a couple of hours and it felt nowhere near that it's just so engaging and i think the time is more than proportionate for the amount of gain that you're getting here uptime as well is yeah there's a little skate for analysis process but you're still going to be thinking about what you're going to do next i'm going to be kind of handing or hanging on the edge of your seat in terms of turn angst if somebody wants to grab one of these worker placement spots that you want because as i said they are very lucrative especially this um turbine station at the end of the game you know you want to constantly be generating energy and there just simply aren't that many spots to do it so you know that turn angst of a worker placement game is really there which is what you need and replayability again excellent because you are really playing your opponent you can get better at this game the more you play it um try different strategies and different approaches you've got different setups in terms of the awards here and you've also got different setups in terms of the player boards themselves so you've got a number of these i think the four different of these player boards come with a base game and more than that of these so you've got quite a few of these and of course they combine in different ways as well so you've got a lot of variability there and of course you've got different contracts that are going to come up and and so on so a good amount of replayability here and i can't see it getting boring anytime soon interaction is what this game is all about this is probably one of the most interactive euro games i've ever played in my life absolutely compelling interaction you cannot ignore what your opponents are
doing and just let them have a free ride you've got to be a bit of a dick and try to um start diverting their energy and start making or putting conduits down on there on their dams that you can get something out of their little engine and as i said constantly cutting people up by building further and further up the hill um but paying the resources to do so so in terms of interaction it really does not get better than this game it is the most interactive euro games that i've ever ever played um aesthetically i really do like the way the game looks i think it has a good a good look to it it's got that real kind of industrious um vibe and color scheme and i think it looks great i really do uh the character artwork itself in particular looks amazing i mean you know the detail on these on these illustrations is fantastic but in terms of the components i mean i'm in two minds about how it works so i i'd like the playables you know these are these are recessed they work really well and they're over you know a reasonable quality the board itself is something that i would have liked to see that being a bit thicker cardboard it's quite thin and these playables themselves as well like are quite thin but which i'm quite surprised at because this game really does give the vibe of a game that's built to be deluxe and it's it's really not actually which is quite surprising um in particular these resource wheels um not to go you know into old ground but these ones um they could be better they are a bit flimsy they're a bit cheap feeling but you know if you're
gentle enough with them they do actually work okay and come back round all right um but i said they they i don't know they just don't quite sit right it would have been nice to be a bit more robust but they're fine i think the kickstarter ones were probably probably worse than the one i've got here um i would say that some of these little pieces are too small these are absolutely minute as you can probably see and again very fiddly so that's something just you know just a small complaint there and they come in different sizes as well depending on how many they stand for but not too much of an issue these are all really nice i said the actual player pieces themselves you know the conduits and the power stations they work really well um and the money as well is is a bit flimsy and cheap it just isn't of a good robust quality but hey you know it's a small complaint because if i'm talking about the gameplay itself i mean you know that completely transcends the component quality you know the theme is just so fresh and um you know unique i can't think of anything um quite like this but you know i don't know anything about you know how water is generated into power but i imagine it's not far off how this works so i think thematically it just works extremely well the setup and teardown time is okay i mean you've got your own little play balls you've got to set up you've got to set up the contracts board and so on but it's more than proportionate and the progression of the game is something that i really can speak highly of because as i said the board is being built as you play
constantly getting more choke points constantly building higher and higher up the mountain and yeah it really does progress and then the puzzle of mapping things out to your favor is um a real engaging piece of the game um scalability is i will say this game is going to play a lot better at that three and four player mark however it works perfectly fine at two yes the game is going to be a bit more open um like it is here you see there's quite a few empty spots um but in a two-player game it does have its advantages because the uh the game does play a lot quicker so you know you've got that to work in your favor but i think really to get the most out of this game is going to be um three or four players just for that added interaction and added um kind of cutthroat nature of it and comparisons no there's nothing quite like this board and how it works uh of course you've got your worker placement games there are so many and you know this one that work placement mechanism works you know similarly to to most of them but i said i do like these kind of backup spots where you can go to that cost you more money um but i think if you like these economic euro style games maybe your power grids or something like that then do not give this one a miss you you are going to love it i guarantee it so yeah that's that's kind of my my just on barrage and all the different elements so overall i think this game is phenomenal it is magnificent i've heard so many good things about it people recommended it to me for years i've been unable to get my hands on it for numerous reasons being not available in
the uk but now i've played it and considering the hype was so high this one has actually exceeded my expectations which is quite a rare feat and just shows how good of a design this one is um well so more importantly i was so surprised about how easy it is to play while still having deep and complex decisions throughout this is just right up there with one of the best games i've ever played absolutely incredible you know luciani is one of the best and most prolific designers in the kind of eurogame genre for reasons like this it is just absolutely magnificently put together intuitive great player boards you know good upgrades a great sense of progression the resource wheel is just great and innovative and you've got you know another decision you have to weigh up just so many decisions so many strategies and just more importantly the player interaction is yes it's cutthroat yes it's nasty but it is so entertaining and just brilliantly executed so that is barrage definitely gets my elite shield that is the best of the best for me um because yeah this is one of the best games i've played in a long time so that concludes my thoughts on barrage definitely check this one out if you can get your hands on it if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe my youtube channel and check out my instagram and patreon page for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye