The BoardGameCo Conversation | Crowdfunding, Conflicts & Ethics | BGSS ep_009
Transcript
If I'm incentivized to boost a game found game, I'm also incentivized to trash a Kickstarter game. It makes my job easier if you have a Kickstarter failure.
You like game found games better than Kickstarter clip it. Right.
Yeah, that's the short version. That's the short version. Um, so the thing I actually care about is never the thing people bring up.
Kickstarter was so dominant in tabletop crowdfunding that nobody seriously talked about alternatives. Kickstarter's tabletop numbers have fallen three years in a row. My guest today says Gamefound now holds 50% of the tabletop crowdfunding market. That's his claim at least and he should know he is the CMO of Gamebound. But where he makes this conversation incredibly interesting is that he's also one of the most watched board game reviewers on YouTube, which means the same person whose job it is to bring creators on to Gamefound is the same person who is reviewing Gamefound campaigns. Don't worry, he knows exactly how that looks. And we're going to get into that. We're also going to get into what the job actually looks like from the inside. the creators they quietly say no to or the creators they've shut off late pledges on when a creator goes dark or even the self-funded pledge they caught last month that came from the same IP address as the creator. We're going to talk about the accountability infrastructure that exists behind closed doors and whether the fact that nobody knows it is a feature or a problem.
There is so much more outside of game found. We're going to talk shop around YouTube. We're going to talk about toxic commenters. We're going to dive deeply into the ethics of making board game reviews. We might even talk about Quackaloupe. And without further ado, Alex Radcliffe, CMO of Gamefound, also founder of Board Game Co., welcome to the Board Game Secret Show.
It's a little oddly a little Starruck. Does that feel weird when somebody says that stuff to you? because they just wa you I watch you watch you get that parasocial relationship with people right I've watched so many hours of you does that weird you out
uh not at all because I mean I've been on on both sides also are we already going because it's fine if we are
yeah this is I I cold open what I'll do is I I cut up some of the most controversial things that you say and then we lead right into this
beautiful uh no so by the way I'm going to pull some of those out of you by the end of this
that works any everything's on the table there's nothing I I love the the the spice Acier the better, the more interesting. Uh cautious interviewers are are boring. It's not bad for a conversation, but it's boring. Uh people who are willing to like give you a hard time like Tim Metver from uh he runs out west. He used to do a um interview segment. He did not pull punches. He would like ask the card questions and he wasn't there to make friends. And I'm a good friend of his, but he wasn't there to make friends.
Yeah.
Um but to to answer the Starruck aspect, so I I got into board gaming in 2011 or so. Uh, I remember my friend when I started doing uh my online store, Board Gameco, the origination of Board Game Code, the channel, uh, my partner at the time went to Gamma one year and he took a photo that he got with Tom Vassel. Like he managed to like see Tom at Gamma and he sent me a photo. My mind was blown. I was like, Tom Vassel, you got a photo with Tom Vassel. Like my partner got a photo of Tom Vassel. Like that was insane to me. I didn't go to conventions. I I knew him from YouTube and it was so cool to me that there someone I actually cared about. Like I don't care about celebrity actors, but my partner got a photo with Tom Vassel. That was cool to me.
So if that's my bar that my friend gets a photo and that's cool. I get being starruck. I I get anytime. I mean, one of the best things about what I do is the fact that I get to interact with people who I could never have in the past. I get to talk to companies who make the games I love. I get to talk to content creators who I used to watch and just watch. And now I get to like text them and be like, "Hey, you know what? Whoever pick a pick a content creator." I have talked to them at some point whether email, text, in person or whatever it is and like we know each other and we get along. So like this well not with everyone but some of them. Uh that's the spicy stuff that who do we not get along with. Uh but anyways but no it's I I I completely
we can start clipping this up right now. Like if you want to start throwing names out there
I I think that I I welcome every single hard question. Uh I think that's a dangerous game to start getting into a a film video of which content creators I don't drive with. But but I think we are human beings. I mean, at the end of the day, we're human beings and whether it's a in-person interaction, uh, like there are there are people who I like their content and I don't like them in person and I don't hate you. I just we just don't jive. Um, and then the reverse is true as well. There's people who I really jive with in person and I don't like their content. We are human beings with tastes and who we are friends with and how we operate as well as tastes in the content we prefer. Uh, there's people who hate me online. There's people who love me online and that's going to be true for anyone and everyone. So, it's just part of it's part of life.
Well, yeah. I I know you've appreciated my videos in the past, but we've only had about 30 seconds or so of FaceTime. So, I hope I'm not one of those people you dislike in person, but uh like their content.
Not based on the 30 seconds, but it is 30 seconds of Dice Towers, those who are watching. Uh we finally ran into each other. We've had an emails, emails here and there, back and forth. Um and those 30 seconds were were stellar. You were taller than I thought based on your videos. For whatever it's worth, you knew that about Tom Vasel going in.
You were taller than I'm not. I'm 5'8.
I know.
And I must look really short on
I don't know why I had I had like I had pictured you short. I have no 5'8 seems too short relative to what I remember. So
uh
but yeah, but but 30 seconds was great. I I did not write you off in 30 seconds. So but we have plenty of time for that. Don't worry.
Yeah, that for sure. Speaking of Tom Bassel, I know everyone said he's tall, but yeah, that was my first time at any convention. So first time seeing Tom Bass. I was like, "Oh my gosh, yeah, guys. Super tall." But everyone said that about me. One one person came up to me and said, "Dude, I did not know you were a giant." I was like, "Oh, I didn't think of myself as a giant."
It's it's that weird parasocial aspect. You see someone on camera and you kind of just develop this like perception or sense of things that's based on
half of a picture. Uh, and then from there, that means anything that that that veers from whatever you mentally built up in your head is going to be a shock.
Well, that's kind of one of the reasons I'm doing this show. First of all, it's just to meet other people and get to know them. But I feel like in like the long form content getting to know people it hopefully it it humanizes everyone and I think I don't know I don't know about your experiences and actually I do I read your comments um you know people just like have this weird disconnection around decency when they're commenting and they have such strong opinions and I just wonder like if they knew who Alex was like would they say that actually to his face or like if you sat down and played a game with him, would you actually still have that take about, you know, I this isn't a direct quote him being a shill or whatever it is, you know, we all get that it it so I'm trying to like humanize people and and including publishers and designers as well. Like I, you know, we can we'll talk about a video I just made um recently, but it is I'm I'm still astounded about like the callousness that some people have towards designers and publishers who are in reality in the tiniest little business and they like they like perceive them as like this big corporation. It's like no, these are people in literally like small town businesses. You're essentially yelling at the top of your lungs at somebody that owns a liquor store, if that, in a small town, you know? Yeah, I don't know.
I I for sure I've seen it. There's there's different aspects. There's the disconnect that the internet provides. And then worse than that is the people who actually would be like that in person, which I don't know how many there are, but there are some who are
Have you come across some that are aggressive in person?
Not directly in person, but I've certainly seen I've certainly seen I guess the way I put it is there's certain types of interactions that I can at least understand how you can do that with the anomia that the internet provides. And then there's certain interactions that feel a bit too like direct like when you actually the content creator is like actually responding to your comment and engaging with you and then you're still like a complete tool to that person even though they're trying to be kind and decent like like sure things escalate. So somebody says you're a shill and you're like well you shouldn't watch my videos and then like if if things escalate sure but then someone might say you're a shill and that content creator might reply hey I'm really sorry you feel that way and I'm just trying to give my best opinion that I possibly can. Like I I understand that it's always hard to measure who's like adding value and who's like, you know, taking a paycheck. I I don't take money for my videos and I'm just really trying to do the best.
I'm sorry that you took it that way. And then the person will reply back instead of like the other person's like deescalating. And the person will like reply back. Well, then you shouldn't be on the internet like your stuff is terrible like whatever. They'll they'll escalate. And that's an area where I'm like I understand the comment where your vent of frustration just kind of goes out there, but then there's levels where there's extra engagement that I just can't I can't understand. But like
I've always advocated for a degree of understanding that I think is going to be very hard to achieve. And understanding does not mean agreement. The most basic example I can give uh to this kind of concept is there's a lot of frustration towards crowdfunding companies that run a campaign and aren't truly honest with their backers about the financial state of the company. They might be like they might be struggling. They might be like $100,000 in debt, which also sounds like a lot of money to a lot of people. If you're a business, it's very easy to be $100,000 in debt and even be in a good place with that kind of thing. It's it's totally fine for that. Um, but you might have a company that's running a little bit on debt and they have perspective things in the works and they're hoping to get out of things and then you're like, "Well, you took money from me on that last campaign and you didn't tell us the financial state of the company that you guys weren't on rock solid footing." And I understand that frustration. I really truly do and I'm not even saying that they shouldn't disclose that. But there's also those weird conversations of if you're running a business, if you have seven employees, if you're close to being able to make everything work out and all you need is for your next campaign to just hit a bare minimum, you just need a campaign to hit like 200,000 and that's reliably what you could have expected. And so, you know, make the decision based on the information you have and then turns out that campaign only makes 150 and you're like, "Wow, that was like below our worst expectations." There's that weird aspect of what would you have done? What would you have done when it's your income on the line? And it's people whose salaries you're paying when you're making decisions about how to just make juggle all the balls and make it work.
And I'm not advocating for agreement ever. I'm just advocating for like understand that decisions are so much harder than you give them credit for. It's easy to villainize people. Um disagree with them. Again, I'm a fan of disagreement. I'm a fan of saying that's the wrong thing to do. But also recognize you might be in that same situation and make a very hard choice yourself.
100%. Right. I we're going to go in down deep down into the the crowdfunding abyss for sure a little bit later. But in terms of the hot takes on the internet like that's just kind of been bothering more me more and more lately. So you know I hope I don't know I'm probably
not your hot take. You can plug in I'll say I'll say it now and you can plug in the beginning. Turns out I am a shill because here I am defending companies that are literally going under and crowdfunding and being like but understand them but understand where they're coming from.
Right. Right. So, I I guess I'll pause there because we could just go, you know, splinter off. I actually want to start with I I don't think after all the videos I've heard I think I've heard part of the origin story, but not the actual board game origin story, right? Like
where did you start? Was it Katon ticket to Rise? Like what was the first entry for you?
So, you can course correct me in terms of if I go into too much detail, there's tons of stuff. Go wherever you want. I can do whatever. Um, so the the origin story to board game and I have actually a history on my I have a series on my channel like the history of me or something like that. It's like four videos. I probably should do an update at some point. Um, but inspired directly by the Dice Tower. Speaking of Tom Vassel, he has a history of the Dice Tower series and I was like I should do that at some point. Um, but the the semi-short version is I got into the hobby in I want to say late 2011, early 2012. I had played a handful of board games before I quote unquote got into the hobby. I played Game of Thrones the board game first edition. My brother loved the books. He bought the board game. We played that. I had played Carcassonne. My brother-in-law had um bought it at some point and we had played that. I had played Katan as well. Katan was like a well-known game. So, these are some samplings of board game games that I had played before quote unquote getting into the hobby. Uh in 2011, u my brother-in-law came home with um my brother-in-law came home with uh what was it again? He came with not Arkham Horror. He came home with Stone A Stone Age and then Small World. And I think I think the order was small world then stone age. But he came home from college with Small World and I played that. I was like this is a really fun game that I've never heard of. And then 3 months later he came home with Stone Age and I was like this is a really fun game I never heard of. Uh and then and then from there I started exploring. I was like these are two games in 3 months that are fun games I've never heard of, never on my radar at all. Like what are these games and where do they come from?
And so I started googling and googling led me to stores and then I found that Small World had 17 expansions. And then I went to Cool Stuff Inc. which back then sold board games. And I made an order from Cool Stuff Inc. I made an order from Miniature Market and I made an order from eBay. I made three orders at the same time. Spent probably around $300 altogether. I justified this purchase because I had just won a PS4 or PS3, depends how far back, whatever was popular in 2011. I had won in a local auction a a console basically and I was a PC game player at the time. So I sold my console on eBay and funneled that money directly into board games. That was how I justified spending $300 in board games. Nowadays, I don't need to justify it. Back then, I need to justify that kind of thing. So, I did that uh and bought a bunch of board games. Very few are there for my original order. Uh the original orders I made, I still have Seven Wonders and I still have Castle of Burgundy. Uh everything else and new versions of both by now. Um but I have those. And then everything else has been long gone for for a while.
Did you get your favorite board game of all time in your first order?
Yes. Yes.
How wild is that? you wasted so much time trying to find a new favorite game of all time and you just you could have stopped at the very beginning.
I could have and I I mean it should have is a relative term. I love like I mean Drews of Adore his newest game is so good. There's a reason I keep hunting for new games but Cast of Burgundy has held up. It is the game I have the most plays of almost certainly uh well over 300 plays for not a short short game and I still love it every time I play it. It's just a really really good time. Um but yeah, it was my first order. It was not the first one I played. I held off on playing it for a while because uh it looked like it looked uh the original version looked
also complicated, right?
Yeah.
Relative to some of the other stuff.
I played Pandemic as one of the first games from those orders. I I don't remember what else I played right away, but like there was Jambo, there was Senseless Multiverse. Uh I bought Guillotine, never actually played it. That's one of the few games I bought in the original order that never got played. Anyways,
to this day, you still haven't played Guillotine?
Uh no, still not played Guillotine.
That's That's actually really funny. your first order, you got a game that you've never played, and now you've probably played it thousands of games,
if not, you know,
Yeah.
a thousand for sure. Um, but and you got your favorite game of all time and a game that you still have never ever played.
Yep. Lots of fun things. Um, but then from there, that kind of started me on a uh that that's kind of started the board game aspect. From there, it went into I started trading for games, buying games. I used to buy games. Uh there was a company called Oneey Jocks that sold ding ding and dent games and I bought those all the time because they're basically getting games for half the price you can buy them otherwise and they often at a small corner dent. Uh eventually that turned into trading games on board gamege geek and eventually that turned into realizing I could turn that into a little mini business that turned into a full business. Did that for like I guess that was in 2014 so I did that for eight years. Um but it round five years into it. In 2019, I started an Instagram and then in late night 2019, I started a YouTube channel and here we are.
Was there ever like a a moment where you're like, "Oh I did not know board games could do this." Like,
I mean, as soon as I played them, as soon as I played, not one in particular that was just like, "Whoa, that's like I didn't I could never even have imagined a board game being this thing."
That as I don't know if there's a particular board game that gave me that kind of feeling. uh the the general feeling cuz like I had dabbled as well in good games. I just thought things like katan and carcassone were like exceptions that they car some some good games. There's monopoly, there's risk and then there's the good two. Um I just didn't realize that there was this world of well past the good two. Um maybe maybe party games like I guess code names is a good example. Here's something code names did just to give you like a random semi aspect to what you're saying. In my experience in tool code names, party games were cheap tricks that as soon as you went through the deck, you'd seen it all. Whether you were playing I don't know what's what's not not mad gams was that big um cranio. Cranio is that called cranium. Whatever it is, there's cranium. There's uh not um again not is it called taboo? Taboo is the game where you can't say the words.
Yeah.
So like taboo is a good example of a game system where there's a cute like party game aspect, but then as soon as you've gone through the cards, people keep doing the same thing. Like I a thing that stuck with me is there's Arnold Schwarzenegger was a card,
but the the the version I had of Taboo existed before he was the governor of California. So whenever Arnold Schwarzenegger came up, all you did was said governor of California because of course the card has like the five things you can't say. You can't say Terminator. You can't say whatever. I don't even know what the words were, but governor of California, you could say. So be like governor of California, Arnold Schwarzenegger. Boom. Card moved on. That kind of concept of it's a single card. So this once you've done it, you can kind of figure out your own in-groups words. um as opposed to something like code names. Code names had that feeling of I have to be clever with word association. I can't say the c the words, but I have to figure out how to give you that information. But not just that, it's like infinitely repeatable because it's not like I can just figure out that the optimal clue for banana and apple is fruit. What happens if orange is on the table? Now I have to figure out a new way to do banana banana and apple. What happens if banana is yours, orange is mine, and apple's the death card? Like, so it has the puzzle of of a it has not it has the puzzle and the joy of something like Taboo, which I used to say Taboo was one of my favorite party games, but now it's infinitely repeatable and not just as soon as you run out of cards, the fun's over. And I remember being impressed with that aspect.
Yeah. Like the social dynamic of who you play with also just continues to add replayability because the meta is technically different as you bring more people in. I'm I'm starting to to enjoy social games more and more where very much I was like I know very euroey or solo head down um you know but those those social aspects add to such depth of the game that can't be described in a rule book and you know even will lead somebody to think one way about a game until they get it you know get code names playing with a different person that has a totally different style that's way more fun or vice versa. Um, but yeah, it's that that's that's pretty interesting.
Um,
my taste has changed so much over the years because you mentioned like, you know, you're dabbling more in this and like I when I first got into this, I got heavy into Euro games pretty quickly. Uh, eventually I switched to like a lot of miniature, not Switch, I added miniature games. I added area control. That became a big thing. And now like I'm kind of back to where I started right now. My main focus, the games I love the most these days are those Euro games, are those ones that give you a crunchy meaty puzzle to solve. Um, I find that area control I still love. of my group just doesn't play it as much and big box games with miniatures. I'm getting a definite degree of fatigue of how many different rule sets do I need of how to move that miniature and how, you know, escape damage works. Like I'm getting getting fatigued with like just too many versions of the same exact system. Yeah, those those types of like dudes on the maps games have probably been the the the least interesting to me because it felt like the depth wasn't there. when I found something like Too Many Bones where there seem to be significantly more depth and and like this this um kind of cerebral puzzle to it, those are the types that really engage me. But um like the unmatched system, for whatever reason, just doesn't do it for me.
I never cared. Never cared.
It just it just seems too obvious. And people have argued with me against that. And I'm sure there's there's meta layers to it. They're just less obvious, I guess, to me. Uh but yeah, the euro, this the taking the time to figure out the euro and all of the different levers that a designer has put in there uh has always excited me, but I do find the staying power is a little difficult. I take um u one of the most recent examples is Galactic Cruise for me. I think it's a it's a good game. I don't think it's a stellar game. I have oh gosh I started playing a ton on BGA and then it and I got really good at it and that's how I know that it's not a particularly deep game because I'm not that good at it. I'm not that good at playing board games actually and when I start beating a bunch of people on BGA I know that there is a known it's solvable. It's it's a it's a relatively straightforward puzzle. um my enjoyment of it started to go up as I started to win, but then I just got bored of it and I felt like the design's a little as much as it feels pretty multi-dimensional. It's it's it's not it's it's doesn't have the dimensions in which that create this dynamic play space for plays over and over and over for me. So, it's falling off for me or at least like
the entire puzzle of that game is refiguring out the game based on the combination of action tokens, which is fun, but the problem is it's a three-hour game, and I that puzzle I've kind of established in the first hour. Uh, and so it is one that I I like I still think it's a very good game, but I loved it and it went down to liking it. And for a three-hour game that's I like, I'm going to play other games instead.
Yeah. I felt like as I get into that, it's kind of rinse and repeat, rinse and repeat. It's my brain isn't fully engaged unless I am winning. Um, but yeah, but that thing's gotten an insane amount of praise, which I can understand. I wonder how much of it is like the toy factor and how beautiful the production is and the art's incredible. I really like the theme as much as you can say a theme. I guess the idea of what it's trying to do, I wouldn't call it particularly thematic other than um, you know, it's pretty or whatever it is.
They they checked all the boxes. They did everything right with that game and no matter no matter where it is, it's a massive success for for where they were as a first- time publisher. So, kudos to them for that.
Yeah, I will I will definitely continue. I I will own it. I've got the M I bought literally everything. Um, they actually gave me the game to be honest, but then I went and bought everything.
What's that?
Why will you own it?
Um, that's actually a really good question and one in which I want to get to you a little later on with your 200 game limit. But that's a really great question. Um, I have I'm a collector, but also I've run out of room, so that's that's the difficulty. And I can get the full experience on BGA. I played it more on BGA than anything in kind of leading up to my review for the game. Um, so that's it's a good question. You've actually
How long have you been in the hobby?
Well, okay, that's a good transition to my origin story. You are fundamental to my origin story. I've I played a lot of little random games for many years. Take it to Ride. We played Into the Ground until it just like my wife will still play it. Um but it, you know, it it's just so annoying continuing to draw cards and not have not have the right thing. But what Ticket to Ride did is it had me start to like look for games and mostly two-player games. And I even at that point I was just like googling, Googling, googling and I never found the hobby. I never found it as it is now. So, this was years ago, probably 2015, 2016 or whatever it might be. And there wasn't, at least from what I could find, two-player games. Like, I bought the Katon two-player card game or whatever it is. And I and I started playing that a little bit. I was like, "Oh, that's kind of cool." But my wife was just like, "What is this? This is stupid."
Um, but I one day I came across Wingspan and I bought Wingspan and um what was it? It must have just been Amazon or something like that. But I got it to the table and I was just so like, "What the hell is this thing? Look at this tower, these eggs. This the the art on this is beautiful." I had no idea the artistry that could be held within a game. So that was blowing my mind at that point. Wingspan was my number one game of all time. You know, that's it was it was it the idea of engine building. I had no idea what any of that was, whatever. But I was just like, "Oh my gosh, this is great." So I started, you know, going down the YouTube and I found an Elizabeth Hargrave and Quackaloupe um interview. So then I started watching all of Quackaloupe stuff and what did I come across? His Root coverage. So I went from I just told Cole Worly this Wingspan to being totally obsessed with the idea of root.
not playing it because I had nobody to play with, but just the idea asymmetric factions like the juxaposition of these beautiful this beautiful art and these woodland creatures and then war and like oh my gosh what what is this world I stumbled into? And of course if you watch Quackaloupe back then you very quickly watch you and you were the second creator that I started watching that just kind of spurred all of this. So it is essentially you and Quackup um
that that did it all to me. And after that was like it was Everddale which I still like which I won't talk to you about Everddale actually a little later as well. There's so many things I want to talk to you about. Um Arnac Great Western Trail I think basically in that order and then it's a blur. It's a complete blur after that. It's like board game co telling me to buy this. Okay, I'll go ahead and buy this. Uh
don't do that. Don't do that. There's too many games.
There is too many games and I think I for the most part I don't think you've really steered me wrong. The only one you got really hyped at that I still like and I still own and you'll probably say, "Why do you still own it?" was Endless Winter.
And I think it's a pretty good game,
but the problem with that is you were really hyped on Lost Ruins of Arnack
and also Dune at the same time. So I got both of those, of course. And then by the poor Endless Winter, like they
they hit the cycle at the same time as the worker placement deck building game. And then they just didn't, you know, they had to deliver, you know, a year later or whatever it is. I always feel bad about that one and I still have it as well. And honestly, but but when I say as well, I mean
it doesn't get tabled the same way Dune and Arnack do. Um I still like it enough that I have a hard time getting rid of it and I still do play it, just not as much.
But it's your winter.
Yeah. Yeah, it's my 200. Absolutely. Absolutely. I say absolutely, but for now, everything's hard because every time I find a game I love, something has to go.
Um Endless Winter really is one that I thought it was brilliant. I still think it's brilliant. I will play Arnack over it any time of the any time of day. Um, also the followup, have you played Unconscious Mind?
Oh, yeah. Yeah, I
Unconious Mind's even better.
I had a I had a very positive review on Unconscious Mind
for sure.
So, it's a tricky. And then the other thing that that kind of was a nail in its grave is to me, Endless Winter, the expansions don't really add anything I care about. They're fine. They're medium. They're like they're not bad.
Uh, everyone's told me I need to play the River expansion and it's in there. I have the full mine.
You had me back at at fullfledged. I got everything with it.
And the expansions I never played. And so the problem is you have Dune and Arnack where the expansions elevated the game. And then you have Endless Winter where the expansions didn't make the game better. Not worse, but not better. So between the cycle, the release cycle, and between the expansions of the others elevating it, Endless Winter is one that I do feel bad about. I feel bad I don't feel bad about my hype. My hype and love of her are there, but it's that weird aspect of I guess I feel bad for there's other games that I have been hyped on and my opinion actually cooled. Endless winter is not really in a situation my opinion cooled. It's other factors changed where it lay.
Yeah, I think Endless Winter was like a it felt too modular. Like the the the full design didn't fully flow together. As much as I like to go play with all of the different levers in that game, they don't feel particularly connected. I actually think I had that criticism with unconscious mind only for what was it the set collection aspect
of the books or
yeah was like the it felt like the books weren't particularly integrated but I do think thematically it was actually I called it one of the best thematic Euros I've ever played because the the that that thought board in in particular idea board was just just brilliant very yeah so uh so yeah I don't know that you steered me wrong there I still enjoyed that I own it. Um, and I think unfortunately I think their timing was a little bit off as well. You know, you you have to come out earlier because everyone by that time had already fallen in love and found their favorite worker placement deck building game and then you bring this other one that feels more disjointed, probably needs a little more work to enjoy. It's also more work to continuously table. That's one of the reasons I don't bring it out is because it's it feels so fragmented. I have to I feel like I have to relearn more every time I I go and grab it.
I feel that way with the expansions, but the base game I got pretty locked in,
but I play it enough. So, honestly, I'm kind of surprised now that we're talking about this. Why are there not been since then more deck building worker placement games or at least of note?
That is a really good point. in an industry where a I mean we we kind of went back and forth about about this via videos like where you know there's a question on is new coming out like is you know or are we continuously standing on the shoulders of the designer before us. You would think that worker placement deck building would have had more legs. Nothing else has been particularly successful and sure there's got to be it. Is there has is there another one that comes to mind that's come out since then?
Not to mind. Obsession is Obsession came before them. It is technically a deck building worker placement game, but I don't think it feels the same. But I don't I'm sure others have done this. I just don't know what they are off hand.
Interesting. So that leads me to a question I didn't know I was going to ask, but you said everything was on the table.
Everything's on the table.
I I really fell in love with your relationship with Quackaloupe.
Oh, you're taking me seriously.
You recently opened up slightly about this. I can't remember what the video was and I actually honestly thought about
most certainly what was it? It was talking Gosh darn it. I must have been talking about the uh watch and play situation.
Maybe it was Yeah, I was surprised you actually went a little bit further there.
So
yeah, what happened? So I uh this is this is always tricky one because again everything's on the table from my perspective. It's when you loop in other people I'm suddenly more mindful
and he's still trying to do it and and doing his thing. I I mean it comes and goes. He does it in waves right now where he puts out a few videos then stops for a month. So I don't know if if we're do for another wave. Um the the short version and this definitely is I guess what I'm going to answer is definitely is the types of things I would be more willing to say publicly. Um but I would say that Jesse genuinely was a very good friend. Um 100% there's no question he was a very good friend. Um and the way I tried like I used to call him when I when I first like you know started interacting with him I used to call him daily. used to hop on the phone like we lived in different cities, but I'd like once a day I'd like go on a little walk at work. This is when I had had a full-time job. I'd go for my like lunchtime walk and I'd hop on the phone, talk to Jesse. We talk about the ecosystem, games we were covering, things we were excited about. Like we were very into the the things we were doing. Um, at a certain point in time, while we were still friends, it did become clear to me that we had different ways that we approached the industry.
Um, and the way I always say this is I try to say this with no judgment. And the example I give I in order to say it with no judgment and to mean it, the example I give is I will do things that others would judge me for. That's how life works. So for example, I just got a comment on a video the other day that was um it said like you never you never say when you have a review copy. I'm like you're right.
Most review copies, but I don't specify when a game is a review copy. Um I cover games that are on Gamefound and some people will say how could you possibly do that? I will, you know, go on a publisher trip and still review the game and some people will say how can you possibly do that? And I bring up these examples to genuinely genuinely it is there are there are other content creators out there no pun included would hate me would hate me this thing they they just roasted someone else like a few months back for like someone saying that they sell review copies that they get um and I'll say it right here right now I give away to my patreons and coof members review copies. I put review copies in the level up library the retreat I want run and I also trade and sell review copies. I do all of those copies kind of have this large smorggas board of where they go. Some people would hate me for that. They'd say, "How can you possibly review a game and then sell it and you're financially benefiting from that copy you got?"
My main point of saying this is we all will have different ways we operate. And I give a lot of credence to that because when I say that Jesse had a different way of approaching the industry, it would possibly be similar to let's say no pun included and I were best friends and then he found that I sold review copies and he started pulling back because he didn't want to operate that way. So that's kind of what what happened where there was a shift in the way we approached the industry and that resulted in a little bit of a pulling back over time as we kind of just had different approaches to space. Um this all happened uh you know a year and and again there's there is more details there more personal back and forth that's where it gets into like I'm not going to publicly broadcast all aspects of our relationship falling out. I don't mind saying and it's just the way it played out. The way the way it played out, there was definitely a a shift from we were best friends to we were friends and collaborated less often to we started pulling back in collaboration and friendship al together. Um, and then everything blew up, you know, 8 months later. By the time things blew up on on his channel, he had the whole like public drama. We had already stopped being
mostly friends and stopped most interactions well before then. Uh, but that's kind of like that's kind of the long and short of it. The long and short of it without getting into too much of the messy details is we we viewed the industry differently. We had different ethical standards. I say that with no judgment because others would judge me for my ethical standards. We all There's a line I heard once about religion. Uh where everyone who's more religious than me is way too stringent. They've taken it way too seriously. And everyone less religious than me is a heretic. So basically I'm perfect.
It's all relative.
I'm not I'm not here to say that I'm perfect and I'm not here to say that Jesse's perfect or that no pun included is perfect. We all have different lines of where we are and Jesse's and mine were different. Is it safe to say that as much as it happened much later on that the the behavior that we all saw around the AON trespass odyssey debacle was um in the lane of what you didn't agree with?
100% 100%. And I I don't view that as blackmail. The way I call that situation is I call it unintentional blackmail. Meaning I do think it that situation hit the points necessary for something to be blackmail. I don't think the intention in his thought was I will charge someone money and then scrap the review unless they like I don't think it happens to work out that it's it's a it's a weird blackmail situation. But I guess the way I'd put it is I found myself in this situation in the past where sometimes I've said, "Hey, I'll review your game." Okay. Um and then like if it's a crowdfunding game and I really don't like it, I don't I don't cover it. I'll be critical of a crowdfunding game, but if it's really really not for me, I will say, "Hey, this is not for me. I'm not interested in playing it a second time. I'm not interested. like what do you want to do? And I've had publishers say, "Oh, can we pivot to sponsored content?"
And that gives me an ick feeling. It gives me a strong ick because like, okay, so because I didn't like your game, you're now giving give me a check to I mean, it's it's a little different. It's marginally different cuz I'm not saying I will cover your game negatively. I'm saying, "Hey, I don't want to cover it." But then suddenly there's this weird financial incentive and I'm motivated to tell a publisher, "Eh, it wasn't for me." And then hopefully they pay me money for a preview video. Now, it's it gives me a strong ick factor and I really try to avoid that. So, I try to for the most part I have made exceptions here and there and I don't like it, but my general rule is whatever you sign up for is what you're getting. You sign up for a review, you're getting a review or nothing. You sign up for sponsored content, you're getting sponsored content. I don't like the pivoting mid situation. And so, like that's kind of like that kind of dynamic around different types of situations. It wasn't only that. There were just areas that fall into a range where Jesse was clearly willing to dabble with. And I say with no judgment and I wasn't. And that just resulted in me being like, "Hey, you know what? I'd rather I'd rather not be as involved.
Did you know Shira before Quacko?
Yes.
Shir was uh my friend and that's how she met Jesse.
Ah, so do you talk to Shira anymore?
No, no, no, no. That was I would say she and that's one way I always feel bad about uh Shira had
Shira struggled emotionally with um the fact that Jesse and I were having she was with him like she was his partner um and Jesse and I were clearly having a falling out at the time.
Um and they I don't remember if they're engaged or saying they're like they were clearly going to get married. They're clearly partners.
Um and she struggled a lot with like the slow fallout of our relationship. Um, and that was like a weird thing where we went from being best friends to like Jesse and I started like deescalating our relationship and and and it was very hard and shared to manage that. And so it kind of just ended up feeding into the whole thing. But like nothing happened there. It just, you know,
balancing collateral damage.
How do you struggle? How do you balance like your friend and your previous your your partner and your previous friend not being on the same page? It's sad from a viewer's perspective, and I I you know, people may agree with this or not, but like I really enjoyed watching all of the interactions that you all had. I really loved the game plays. Um I loved Quackaloup's gameplays and and um with the people that he had brought around. It's honestly it felt like it felt like a this huge breakup of a family that that I was uh parasoially a part of and that was in fact even when I you could tell before anything was said between Jesse and Shira that there was like a spark there and I was really I was like following the love story you know and and you know saying stuff in the comments and all of that and it's just um it's sad it had to work out like that uh overall and I know a lot of people have been curious over time so I
it is it is very sad. I have I have wondered at points in the past um about like almost wanting to like make amends so to speak.
Uh there's many reasons I have not uh but like the main reason I'd say is I tricky. I I value the relationship we had. I don't know if it's redeemable at this point and I don't know if the if the trust would be there in that relationship, but it was a it was it was there were good times. There were good times. There were good game plays. There was good like collaborations. There was good getting along. We were friends outside of board games. We'd have meals movies together as well.
Yeah.
Yeah. Quack and Co. Quack and Co. Which technically still exists.
Does it still Does Jesse own that one?
Jesse. Yeah. I gave it to him on the way out. I I was not concerned.
Yeah. and the divorce. But it's Yeah. I don't know if he I don't know if he's done anything on that channel in a long time.
I don't I don't think so.
Yeah. It looks like last video was a year ago. So, yeah, it it it is it is genuinely sad. Um I wish things had played out differently. Well, you know, I'm I'm hopeful that you all might reconcile someday, you know, just just on a personal not not on, you know, YouTube or anything like that, but you know, you never know. It's you can't it's tough to put yourself in somebody else's shoes and pressures that they're feeling and and why they're doing what they're doing. And and I I think you you have a good perspective in that you also as there's big caveats and because you could point the um the lens towards yourself and and criticize you know some practices as well. Um but yeah I don't know
for to get into why I think we wouldn't would involve getting into some of the more personal details about the areas that I did not love. Um, and those go down to they kind of intrinsically go down to character judgments might be the harsher way of saying it,
but opinions about to the nature of like
yeah, it would be I I again I don't mind getting into some extent. I don't want to speak ill of others and it's definitely a perception based thing, but I I wouldn't trust the relationship. That's what it comes down to.
Fair enough. We'll leave it at that. We'll pivot to maybe another sad story. you ran board game co for many other eight years.
Um what what was it that you saw in the market that you were trying to fill when you opened up Board Gameco and maybe give a brief overview of like what the what the business was?
I wanted free games. That's what I saw in the market. Uh Board Gameco started because I I had I started collecting games because I got I fell head first into the market um into the into the hobby and I started trading tons of games because I just wanted all the games and so I kept trading. It kept on getting this game, getting that game. And one thing I realized as I traded is I realized there were people who quote unquote had the power. Meaning what I mean by that is a weird dynamic, but you'd come across trade lists of people who had 400 games for trade and you would go after them and try to talk to them and then they would be like they'd be like, "Oh, no, no, I don't want this, don't want that." They kind of had somebody
they had so much hot stuff that they weren't really it was all up for grabs, but they weren't motivated. I have what you say you want and you have what I want. Is it a value thing or like I hate when they're like saying I'm not particularly motivated to get rid of this. What are you saying? I have to
Why are you doing it?
Yeah, exactly. Then why is it on?
The answer is if you have a hot game on that list, if you have enough of your collection on the list, you will eventually land people who are willing to give up more than they possibly should. You're playing a numbers game. You're saying this is appealing. Enough people find it appealing. someone's going to offer me three games for it. And I realized that there was power to having a large list both in the fact that you have um uh you have hot stuff on your list that other people aren't cuz you have let's pick up popular game. You have what's a what's a new popular game? What's something hot these days? I don't know. Um I don't know. You you you just got the new Puerto Rico specialist for realms. All right. So you got the special edition and you're trying to table it. Meanwhile, I'm putting it on my trade list and seeing who cares enough to offer me seven games for it. So, there's power in hotness and there's also power in numbers. When you trade one game for one game, you're swapping a $30 value, but you're losing 15 bucks on shipping. What if you swap five games for five games? Then you you're paying $25 in shipping, but that cost per shipping on a game is much better. So, there's this weird aspect there where there's a value game to be played to get larger trades. The problem with larger trades is you both you both have to want five games from each other. That's harder to do. And I realized that if I kind of put my entire trade list up for grabs and I didn't worry about whether I was actually getting rid of it, suddenly it opened up the door to these kind of okay, I will get rid of three games that I never played that I still want to play, but I'll get back more games assuming I'm willing to cater the offer to be in my favor. So the best example I'd give is I would trade $60 worth of games for $90 worth of games. I would pay 12 bucks in shipping, whatever it is, and I'd end up with $30 in games. I just netted $30 and I paid $12 in
shipping. Why is the person giving up 90 for 60? because I have popular games they want. And they realized the economies of of a barter that you're getting multiple things done. So I did this for a while just to get free games. This was my way of being like I'm going to grow my collection at a discount by kind of engaging in the trade system. Uh and then it kept working. I what I what I what I did to kind of my goal was a smallcale bump and the clear demand for this was insane that the people who were doing this like on their trade list, they weren't really doing as a full business. they were just kind of like willing to engage and I was like no I'm a motivated trader I will I will I'm trying to make a trade happen just on my terms and there was huge demand for even imbalanced trades because I was offering as a business and growing games and they were benefiting from economies of scale and being able to shift a lot of stuff and it just took off. It absolutely took off despite the unfair trades. There was such a demand for it. Uh to the point that after, you know, eight months of doing this, I had to move it to a warehouse and start hiring employees. Uh and that changed everything as well because it also removed that sense of unfairness. There is this weird sense of unfairness when if I barter games with you, um there's a sense of unfairness as to why are you getting the better trade?
But if I do it with a business that has employees and taxes and accounting and all these and warehouse costs, suddenly there's like, oh yeah, a business has to make money. So it removes that persontoperson unfairness around it, too. Uh, I did that for a while and there was always a huge demand for it and nobody was nobody other than Noble Knight Games was dealing with used games uh the way I was. So it's me and Noble Knight, the only two people in the industry doing this really um past individual game stores running their thing. And so I did it for a long time. Um it always was a side income. It was never a big amount of money despite like we had decent amounts of revenue like we had four or five employees but they were getting a paycheck and I was making whatever was left at the end of it which was less money. Um I got uh so I did it for a while and the the impetus for finally stopping was I started board and co originally to market this business although that didn't last long. Uh but eventually uh between the extra work that board game co is put putting on my life and the fact that there's this weird reputational aspect of running a business has issues. You have issues especially with used games is even more issues. So we had like I think we tracked at the time was like less than 1% of games had issues. But when you're trading a hundred games a day, that's an issue every single day that's being created.
And so that's one person who's upset about a missing piece or a component. Uh and then they'd have frustrations, reasonable frustrations around the the the fact that they were that one in 100. And the problem is now there's a face to it. Now I'm that guy on YouTube reviewing games and talking about the value of a crowdfunding campaign. And I'm also missing short of them. Yeah. And that added an extra level of pressure in addition to the lack of time. And I was like, I have to pick a lane.
Right. and the ROI for it wasn't big enough to actually incentivize you to continue to do it.
It was a business still there,
a business or that business.
No, no, no. A business like do you think there's there's still a need for that?
I I think there will always be a need for people to be able to turn around their games more efficiently than the current options. And when you sell games when you sell games to Noble Knight or when you sell games to Board Game Co, you got pennies in the dollar if you sold Board Game Co games. And this is true for Obnite or Boring Co. It's just again, it's just the math of how a business to run. If I sell you $100 worth of games, I'm only getting 25 bucks back. You're usually getting made between a quarter to a third of the value of the games because I have to get the games. I have to go through the process of like some degree of inventory or some degree of checking for you might not inventory every piece, but some degree of general check. Uh you have to deal with the fact that there will be losses and damage. Again, I'll get the game. I'm going to have to suck up that $30 when that game it was missing a piece, an essential component down the road. So, there's loss I have to take into account. There's the shipping it to me. There's the shipping it away from me. There's so much cost involved that for me to offer you and again and as a company I can buy the games new for 50% of the value. So why would I offer you even 50% for a used game? Realistically, you have to offer a quarter of the value for it to be even in worth talking about. Uh but the problem is that means there's not a lot of money there.
Trading is a much more efficient uh economy. You just have to build up that weird scale. So again, if I trade 60 for 90, I'm paying $12 for $30. I can hit those numbers and it seems better. you're not getting 25% of the value, you're getting two/ird the value. So, a trade changes the construct of how it can be perceived as fairer for them. Uh, right now your options are you can sell to Novanite. That's the only option. So, do I think there is a margin for this business, a demand for it? Yes. But it's a lot of work. We had a there's a lot of things we did and we did them well and we spent time building them up and improving upon them, but it takes time.
Yeah. One of the reasons I don't trade so much on BG is I'm I'm waiting for the multiple game trade and that's because it's the the the shipping eats everything, you know, and that's that's that's the killer. Like the you know, board games held value and increase value at for a little bit, but for the most part, unless they're a select few at this point, they're kind of a you know,
it's hard for me to justify getting rid of it because selling it, I'm paying I don't know what the percentage is on eBay anymore. plus that you're having to deal with the shipping. People I put stuff on eBay and I hardly have sold um games there at all that you know for a price that would just you know I would rather keep it even though it's taking up all of my space. Did you recently do a video on how to sell games or is that a difference?
I did I did I redid my It's one I did a while ago but it's been four or five years so I did it again.
Oh, it has. I thought I had just seen that but
no I'm saying I did I did it four or five years ago it again. Uh, so then you know if I want to know what, you know, how to how to get rid of my games, I need to go look at that. How would you fix the BGG trade system?
I don't know. Is it that broken? I'm not sure if it's that.
I mean, well, I mean, part of it is a lot of wasted time and like emailing people and in the negotiation like you know, math trades as an example. I'm sure you've probably heard of Math Trades where you know, although the values associated are are questionable. Um, like how would you match people? I guess that's that's trying to fix part of the the sol part of the problem and then it's kind of matching people based upon you know values that I think they are prescribing at least.
Yeah. Master trade basically is ultimately you say I'm willing to take this for that and then the system tries to orchestrate a trade to common as many people as possible. Um it is a gamified it's a game it's a system you can game and I know that because I did so until enough people got upset that I stopped doing it. Uh, and it's tricky because in a weird state, the way a math trade works is ultimately you will only get something you said you were willing to get. If I say, "Hey, I have game X," I can say, "I'm willing to cape take game Y, Z, and whatever." So, you only will ever get a game that you are comfortable with. But what you can do, which I did for a while, um, again, until people felt taken advantage of, and I was like, "Hey, I'm not here I'm not here to bother people, so I'm not going to do it." Um, is I take really popular games, really hot games. I'd buy them full on buy them. put them into the math trade knowing that people were seeking out those games and there aren't going to be too many copies of Puerto Rico special ed special edition because it's new.
It's exciting. So if you have four copies of Puerto Rico Special Edition and a whole bunch of people say they want it because the system is optimized to ensure maximum number of trades effectively it'll loop trades in a way where even though people will still only ever get a trade they said they were comfortable getting it kind of ch it chinks away small amounts of value from each trade to get more trades in the system. So to give a hypothetical example, you might have been willing to trade for a $30 game, a $35 game, and a $37 game. But once I throw Puerto Rico into the mix because of the math of a math trade, you are more likely to get your lower value game as the system seeks to optimize. So in a weird way, you're just you're stealing a dollar from everyone in the system and walking away yourself. So there's no theft. You're engaging in a system by the rules, but it can be gamified. Um, and I did that a few times and people didn't love it, so I stopped because I wasn't there to upset people. But it is
they didn't love it on math trades or was this brought up publicly. Okay.
It no publicly. Someone would be like, "Hey, why is Board Gameco like I wasn't board game co back then? I was Alex SR." That's my original BG name, which I haven't checked that account in years. I probably have so many messages. Um, but Alex Sr. They'd be like, "Why is this guy putting five copies of Sulken?" This is like the first time I did it. I think I did it with Sulken. I did it like twice, I think, maybe more. I wasn't that long. But people people again, the arguments are always the same. On the one hand, you're only ever getting something you said you're okay with. On the other hand, I'm technically gaming the system and taking a little bit off the top. Um, which I think is fine. I think I mean, I think it's fine. I think it's fair to be upset at that.
So, I went back to I went back to trades that were direct one-on-one only. So, there wasn't this almost voluntary but also not voluntary participation.
Yeah. It's the laws of supply and demand. Yeah. You found something with high demand there. Um, so when you closed board game co down, it wasn't that long ago, was it? I think I remember the video. 22.
Was it 22? Uh, was it sad
or a relief?
No, no, no. I quit. Was not boarding. Boring. I don't know if I did a big announcement. I did. I did. I quit for my job.
No, I remember. No. I remember you uh click baited me. I thought you had quit YouTube. I remember that.
Yeah. But listen, I left my day job. It's still pretty big. It's not like a small thing. It's not like I quit falling for those thumbnails. Actually,
did you leave
day job and close down Board Game Co at the same time?
Roughly the same time. Those unintentional board game card is trying to close down for a while. Um, and the challenge was just I had I had employees. Again, this was back to the decision like sure there was a person getting their game without a piece that I will then make, right? But I also have an employee who needs a job. If I close down Board Game Co, four or five people lose their jobs. I don't love that. So, like there's always multiple parts to a conversation. Um I ultimately again weighing up all the things I made the decision I worked my way towards it. It was a slow process. It took months to close it down because we stopped doing trades and stopped doing purchases just focused on sales. We had to liquid out our inventory which I think we did to Noble Knight if I recall correctly. Um but it was it was it was a slow process. Um, and quitting my job was a little faster because and so the timing ended up being both in 2022, but one of them was coming for months and the other was others was I guess you could argue was in the in the works for months supposedly, but I just didn't know what was going to happen, which was effectively once YouTube took off to a certain point. I knew that I wanted to quit my job to do YouTube full-time. Um, but I had like a four-year plan to do it. And at the time, my job hired a salesperson who was very, very toxic.
like everyone knew he was toxic, but he was very good at getting sales in a postcoid timeline where things were were challenging. Um, and so he was very good at his job and very toxic. And it resulted in uh two people being fired because of interpersonal stuff and then two people quitting and I was the third person who quit. And I told my boss, I was like, because I just it was like, hey, I have this other thing I'm doing, YouTube, that makes me happy all the time and I have this job which does pay the bills, but maybe I can make YouTube work. Uh, so I jumped off that that that cliff a little sooner than I planned on, hoping I can work it out. Um, and it Yeah, I'm happy with both decisions. Both both them.
No regrets. You're glad to be in YouTube/game.
Well, so YouTube itself was not able to sustain my bills. Like my the community was amazing. I like I got a bump of like I can't remember what it was, but I got a decent bump. It was maybe it's an extra $800 to $1,000 a month because I quit my job and I was like, "Hey, I'm I'm just relying on you guys now. Hope I can do this." Uh and for like 6 months I just had YouTube which was not enough money to pay the bills unfortunately. Uh it was this YouTube is always going to be a tough place to make enough money. Uh and at the time I wasn't even doing sponsored content. I was not engaging in sponsored content at all. Um and so it was it was not viable and that's when game came along and offered me a job. I had both I was a COO of my last company. So I had the management experience. I had the knowledge of crowdfunding and they were just taking off. which is becoming a competitor to Kickstarter at the time. And I was well suited cover like I had knowledge in both spaces to be able to to be able to actually step into that role. And I love my job there.
I I didn't at first. I liked it at first, but I love it now.
So why at first? Like why was it why was it a tough transition? And how long between quitting your last job and and getting the game found gig was there where you were
six months till the conversation started? Maybe maybe like 8 to nine before it like officially happened. Um, but it was just a YouTuber for like eight, nine months. Um, but it the first part was that when I first took the job at Gamefound, the thing I used to say was, "This is the second best job I've ever had. The only problem is I'm doing it simultaneously with the best job I've ever had, which is YouTube."
Uh, that's how I felt at first. Um, and at the first year, I actually almost quit at one point because it was a struggle to get people to use the platform. And I'm not salesy. I'm very data driven. I'm very I'm here to talk about the numbers and what makes sense. and if I can't show you results, I'm not going to be as convincing. And it was a struggle that first year of like a lot of conversations that didn't always go anywhere. And I felt like I wasn't necessarily providing value for those first 6 months, 8 months. Uh but then things turned around. Uh the c the platform was new. It was starting to grow. It was getting the results. And my job shifted to being able to actually show results and really believe more in not just the the potential promise of the platform, but the actual results the platform was driving. Uh so that definitely helped the first year, but that wasn't when I shifted to loving it. I would say over the past year and a half, in fact, this is circled back to the beginning of our conversation.
Something that is a constant drain on me in YouTube is the people who are unhappy, the people who are, you know, who I'll sit there and put tons of work into putting out a video and like that video like like some videos like will get like a thousand views, which for many channels is a ton, but for my like for my channel's at might be like a low performing video, might not do whatever and then somebody comes in and is upset at me for doing the video and I'm like, why why am I doing this? Uh, this is a review. I didn't get paid for it. I did it just so I can give you content. And somebody's in the comment being like, "Ah, blah blah blah blah blah, whatever the blah blah blah is today."
And Rodney Smith always says, and he's right, you we we we're we're intrinsically primed to focus on the negative. And I'm I do a good job of not engaging as much as I want to. Uh, but at the end of the day, it kind of just sits there and builds up. Like there's this little aspect of like there are people online who are angry at the thing I'm doing for not enough money. Like I had a six-f figureure job like like I I was financially I was fine. I quit that to be to do something I was passionate about. And then there'll be people who hate on you for being a publisher show for doing the thing wrong for not doing the thing that they like the way they like it. And like listen I'm not here to make people happy but like it still weighs on you. Like the thing I always say is when someone on Reddit posts a comment about how they hate that guy. It doesn't bother me. The thing that bothers me is the 27 people who thumb up the comment. you like 27 people thumbmed up a comment, I hate that guy. Like, what am I doing and why? And and again, this is just a numbers game. You're on the internet. If 90% of people, if 97% of people like you, but you're getting 400,000 views a month, you're going to have some amount of people who are upset at you every month. It's a numbers game.
And the larger you grow, the larger the percent. If I if I was getting 10 million views a month, and if 1% of those people are upset at me, that's a lot of people. So, the larger you grow, it doesn't make the problem better. You have to be able to turn it off. that that that that thing and I can't turn it off. In a perfect world, I want everyone to like me.
That's what people don't realize is people on the internet are humans, not robots. Yet, by the way,
I've come to the conclusion that actors or any famous people, one of two things happens. You either become one of the very many sad cases about overdose, suicide, whatever, or you figured out how to turn it off. Because I can't imagine when I see like when I see like nowadays, again, I don't I don't have real fame. I have board game fame. just a tiny amount of fame. But nowadays when I see tabloid stuff, I'm like, how how do these people live their lives when everyone's commenting about everything they're doing all the time? I can barely focus on the fact that again, a small amount of people on the internet don't like me. Now, all this to say, I still love YouTube. I still love what I do. But over time in gamefound, I continuously get to interact with people who are happy with the conversations they're having with me. They're happy with with what I'm doing with them. They are people who make games that I care about. I get to talk to companies like I get to talk to like the people from as running all their crafting campaigns on game right now. I get to talk to freaking Asay like they they announced the seven wonders reprint or whatever.
I'm involved in the conversations with them about like okay great what are we doing? Are we doing this? Like yeah like like it's one of my first games I ever played. I'm talking to the company as they bring back a third deluxe edition of the game and I get to be involved in those conversations. That's insane to me. And like it's so cool as a fan of as a fan of these games, as a fan of the space, being able to have real conversations where I get to provide value to people who provided so much value to me and everyone's happy. They're just like adults. They're not here to be like, "Oh, blah, blah, you shill, whatever." They're like, they're happy. And so, I get that love that I I want out of being involved in an industry that I care about that I've been so involved with and so invested for like a decade of my life, over a decade. It's 15 years at this point. That's a long time and I get all that at Gamefound and I do so without the small 1% of people who don't like what I do for no reason.
It's funny you say that, right? Like small 1%. I just did an interview with Chris Porter from Chris Couch Games and it was such a great conversation, such an awesome person. Does so much, you know, between YouTube and graphic design, creativ creative publisher, designer, all of this great stuff. And I got one dislike and I'm thinking, who the hell disliked this? like what in here? There's zero there's nothing that was that was um you know there was no controversy, nothing. It was just a great conversation between two guys. I just I I I sit there and I go like who the hell is this person? Is this a person that just hates me and they go through for the longest time I would have like one dislike that drove even on my super small videos and I was like is this one that's out there that's just messing with me? And then I wonder like do these people realize like the and maybe they like it. Do they like that they are doing just a teeny bit of emotional damage? You know, even the dislike,
right? Like it's just like why why dislike this? There's been other videos where it's just like there's no reason for anyone to actually, you know, not like this enough that they have to go hit that button. Just leave. Just don't watch it. You know,
yeah,
we we operate differently. The thing that Ronnie Smith has said that most resonates with me and I try to hold on to is the people who do the things that hurt us the most inherently we would never do those things. So like I if I didn't like someone's video, I wouldn't go attack them. I would think this video or this content creator is not for me and I would move on with my life. So the way these people are acting are inherently not the way we would act. So now what we're doing is we're putting emotional value into someone who's taking an action we would never take, which is a weird way. That's like being upset when someone invests. So when someone tells you, "Hey, you're investing your money poorly and you take a look and you find out that they sold their house and put it all in Bitcoin, which actually might have made the money, but whatever." But it's still like a bad decision to like leverage your entire net worth. Like when someone's giving you financial advice and they spend their money poorly, maybe don't put value in their financial advice. So when someone posts something about how you did something that's not to their standard and you're like but that you're not operating how I'm operating so why should I put value in that?
But again all this to say like I I still love what I do. I love the community. I just ran Level Up a Treat and like having so many people are part of my community like you know uh thanking me for the videos I put out you know whatever it is like so many people who I've gotten so many stories from over the years of of of really heartfelt moments of which people have been impacted by my videos and I'm like I'm just reviewing a board game. You know what I mean? You've been you've like like I had a father once who who like his his son was in the hospital for months and every day he'd look forward to my 10 a.m. video like while he's in the hospital with his son and like such like a strong thing to hear and that's worth so much more. So, and I I don't plan on going anywhere on the YouTube side. I love what I do and I still plan on doing it. It's just been that there's been this shift over time of I used to love YouTube more and now I like GameFam more while still liking YouTube. Well,
it's funny you say that about the the father in the hospital. I've spent a ton of theos ton of time in the children's hospital with my kids, specifically my son. I have two children that have cystic fibrosis. It's a a genetic lung disease. And I did watch a ton of your content because he really had some of his worst um episodes basically through the COVID time and I watched so much of your content and it's uh it did it helped me get through it. It helped me just like forget for just even a short period of time. So yeah, it is kind of interesting how you can make an impact even with just a board game video,
you know.
So yeah, we connect.
You did you did do that. Um yeah, it's one of the one of the things I try to remind myself is they probably are having a really bad day and they there's probably something way worse happening in their life. And I try I anytime I interact with somebody that's just kind of nasty, I try to remember that. I try to try to think like, you know, there's probably something really bad that's going on in their life to make them want to come over and do this or something that's happened in their history or whatever because at the end of the day, we are we are just human beings. But it also I just wish they'd realize that it's also not that serious to get that mad about board game stuff, you know?
Yep.
So, you're a Game Found, you're CMO. What does a day look like for the CMO at Gamefound? And is it go
five days a week? I mean, is it you're working a full-time job plus YouTubetubes, so you're back to where you started.
Yeah. I recently did a video uh uh said called I'm I've been playing Factorio and it was about it was a conversation about how when I find something that and in this case it's a good thing. It's Factorio is a game that I really enjoy. It's a video game and I've gotten sucked in recently. And sometimes it's a bad thing like I'm doing my taxes which takes some time or I'm moving some other things. But my life I'm able to do everything I do until interruptions come along. whether an interruption is good or bad, that's when I fall apart. Oh, I have to paint a bunch of rooms now. Well, I guess my life is going to fall apart because I don't know where that's going to fit in. Um, but as long as everything's going smoothly, I can do Game Pound and Board Game Co, both of them. Uh, but yeah, my a day in the life wakes starts with me waking up uh somewhere between, you know, I don't know, 8 to 8:30, whatever. I'm up by 8, but like my my day starts usually uh with 8:00 or 8:30 or 9:00 calls because a lot of the the team game pound is in Poland, which means they're six hours ahead. Soaken to get a lot of calls in.
So it's not it's so Awakened Realms started Gamefound and they both they have shared ownership. So the CEO not the not Awaken Realms but the the CEO of Awaken Realms is the CEO of Gamefound. Got it. Marson Marson is the CEO of both. Outside of that there's no shared um there's no shared employees behind the companies. There different entities. They are certainly friendly. I'm not going to try to pretend they're not friendly companies. Like they're all friends but they work in different offices. is they they are again no overlap other than the CEO and a good working relationship. Um but so yeah, so they're all in Poland. Uh which means I have to get most of my calls done, you know, early in the morning because that's when I have my inter inter office conversations. So like for example, this morning I had a call at uh 8:00, I had a call at 9:00, I had a call at 10:00. Uh and those are basically a bunch of calls. And to give you an idea of what my day looks like, uh you know, some of those calls, well internal calls will often be work working with people who report directly to to me. Uh we have a new hire on board. some Hortum helping uh introduce him. It's actually the first time we hired someone on the game found sales team who is not a gamer first. He's a he's coming in as a salesperson, not as a gamer. In the past, we've hired gamers and taught them sales.
There's a lot to the brain there.
Correct. So, we've been going over like these
might be harder. What's harder? Teaching someone about board games or teaching someone how to sell?
Teaching people about board games. Teaching someone the culture of what goes into board games is so much harder. like to know to understand like like to understand what the top crowdfunding campaigns are, how the space operates, it's so much more work. Um, now he has to be to be fair, he has played real board games, but he's friends with people who are into board games. He's not like he doesn't own board games himself. He's friends with people and he's played some heavy hitters. Um, but anyways, going through that, but that means it's a lot of day-to-day calls like kind of introducing him to the ecosystem. Uh, walking through like, you know, the way we operate internally. So that's a lot of internal stuff usually happens uh before let's say 11 cuz 11 again 6 hours ahead 11 is 5:00 their time which means um I'm an EST which means that's when the day is ending. So from 11:00 to to 5:00 is when I get to do all the the uh you know more US-based things or and that my day is usually going to be a combination of emails and then calls, emails and meetings with a degree of also time just spent on internal processes coming up with the next thing we can do that like you know in some case helps improve the sales team's job because our job is reaching out to creators trying to get them to use gamefound. Uh so for example I just had a call this morning uh with a with uh launch boom they run this crowdfunding seminar uh you know every I don't know every once a quarter whatnot and I'll be doing a presentation on them. So I was meeting with the team to get some general you know what the presentation looks like it's going to be May 5th. So if you want to run a crowdfunding campaign launch was doing a seminar May 5th and I'll be part of that. Uh so that's like kind of like some of the other things. Then I'll hop on calls with the creators. cuz I had a call right before this call where like literally half an hour before this call.
I was on a call with the creator where they're trying to figure out where they're going to run their pledge manager for the next campaign and I'm trying to introduce them to GameFound and talk about the tools and why they might want to use use the platform. So, it's mostly meetings and outreach uh towards creators and then internal processes. But ultimately, the main the main designation of what my job is is to get people to use the platform who are the right fit for the platform. Uh we believe in long-term relationships. Not everyone's going to be the right fit at the right time. And uh the way I always put it is it's not my job to beat what Kickstarter would do for you. It's my job to beat what you think Kickstarter would do for you. Meaning, in other words, I want people who are happy. If you think your campaign is going to do 500,000, it doesn't matter what it would do where. It just matters that I want to meet your expectations. Whether those expectations are realistic or not, I want to meet them because if I don't, you're not happy. So, I I want people I want people to be happy with what GameFound is doing for them. Uh and fortunately the vast majority are like the vast as a platform I think we have like an 82% retention rate something like that and my personal claim to fame is so far everyone who I've brought on board uh has continued to use us every single person. And I don't think I've lost a single the I've had people who run campaigns on both um like they dabble with like different types of campaigns, but I don't think I've had a single like truly unhappy person because a big part of that is I I am very specific and intentional about choosing to chase people who I think will be happy with the results they get.
Have you been taking market share from Kickstarter in the space?
Yes,
yes. Uh that's an absolute. I mean the the the crowdfunding market was I have to double check my numbers here. Don't quote me on any of the exact details. Um but the crowdfunding market uh overall was like down 10% last year like as a as a whole crowdfunding was down 10%. Uh I think that means Kickstarter I think Kickstarter was like down like 20% or something like that year-over-year. Uh and Gamefound was up 30%. Uh Gamefound's effectively when you if Gamefound is growing and Gamefound has been growing. Uh you know two years ago we did 53 million. The year before that we did like 83 million. Last year we did like 115 million. So gamefound has been growing every single year and the volume of crowdfunding it's been bringing bringing in and the only way for gamefound to grow is if the market as a whole grows or to take share uh from the other creators and depending on the year the two years prior the market grew and gamefound grew more than the market.
Last year was interesting in that the market went down uh and I think a big part of that's tariffs which makes sense. Uh but game found still grew even in a down market um every single year. Uh, and what's interesting is like last year, this past year, we posted a blog update where we said we think that we have more than 50% of tabletop. We think we finally eclipsed that aspect. And we said we think because some data is not visible. Kickstarter only shares some of its data. You can't see their data as far as um you can't see the data as far as the pledge man stuff that they've collected. Uh Kickstarter's response to that blog post was not to comment. They just hid all of their data instead.
So instead of like revealing, they hid all of the we were like, "Okay, okay, we're right then." Cuz we weren't sure. We're like, we think we have 50% in the market, but like some of Kickstarter's numbers we can't see, so like whatever. It's it's still pretty good. And Kickstarter's like, oh, let's let's turn off all our numbers just
Yeah, you're the opposite. Kickstarter does not have an API that I can access, but GameFound does, which I do access, which is is that is that transparency kind of part of the culture at Gamefound
and we we try to do everything we can as far as just giving the best tools to our creators, to our community, to to everything. Right now, we just introduced a new thing. Um, this this this call is now sales pitch for GameFound. Sorry. Um but uh we just introduced a new thing uh checkout as guest which is not an exciting feature the way something like endgame or stretch pay is but effectively as a crowdfunding backer you can now check out and purchase a crowdfunding campaign without having an account. No crowdfunding platform currently does that. It's a standard e-commerce feature but crowdfunding is different because of the way crowdfunding works and the ongoing cycle. And so that means to access your pledge you'd have to like put your email and get a code sent. It changes the whole way you you work with crowdfunding. But we're the first platform to have checkout as guest. And again, it's not a sexy, cool, flashy feature like something like Endgame is. But the flip side is like at least on GameFound, like 56% of people uh ditch out of the platform as soon as they're asked to to to log in. So if you're check if you're checking out right now, 56% of people when they're presented with that login page bounce. So allowing people to to buy the thing without logging in is going to change that number. We don't know how much, but it's going to change that number. And and backers are less engaged than you would think. Like we see crowdfunding is about the crowd, but it's usually a smaller percentage. I I think if I recall correctly, our stats are only 25% of backers look at a single update, let alone all the updates. A single update, only 25% of backers. So, you're here as a creator putting out all these magnificent long updates, only 25% of backers see even one of your updates, let alone all. Uh, and that's because most people back and forget. Most people walk away. The ones that are sticking around, the ones that are passionate,
they're upset at you when you do things wrong. They're excited to spend tons of money, but they there's a lot of people who are involved. there's a lot of people who just back and don't ever come back. And so having something like check out as guest, having something like this tool, this um this uh check out as guest feature, it further engages the ability to uh to engage a lot of people who are just kind of peripherilally there.
It's funny you don't they don't look at the updates. I'm actually building in Cardboard right now. It's an unreleased feature, but to it's analyzes analyzes campaigns and one of the things it does is it looks at updates and aggregates what that update was about. What's the sentiment connected? I believe you took comments off of updates, right?
No, we should have It's Kickstarter. It's the other way around. So, it'll
Kickstarter took comments off updates.
Yeah, one of one of you had no comments on updates. I just had to work around that in the app. What was that?
That's interesting to me.
Oh, specific update.
Oh, yeah. You have comments. Yeah, we definitely have comments.
Either way, it it analyzes the sentiment uh of all of those comments and gives a user a kind of quick like, hey, what was this thing about? Do people like it? Do they not? Are they here's a couple quotes on the people that like it, people that don't or whatever it might be. So, yeah, I could definitely see people um not not fully engaging and including myself totally forgetting that you even back something in in the first place. that the another point of difference that gamefound has is the stretch pay. And I've recently looked at a Kickstarter campaign. I think it might have even been a gamefound as well where because not all not everything stretch pay, right? That's an individually individual decision based upon
stretch pay is our name. Oh. Oh yeah. Every creator can decide how to improve.
Yes. So I have I have actively not um backed campaigns because there wasn't stretch pay. Has stretch pay been a boon for you? a huge hu absolutely huge um stretch pay was a and it's one of those things Jamie Stegmire had a great article about it that mirrors my own thoughts about it because from my own sense of of things like it feels almost a little predatory like if you can't afford it don't buy the board game like don't don't don't do this pay over time thing but everyone is different and Jamie Seagar had a great article that kind of he comes in starting from the same frame of mind as me but other people have different ways that they spend or balance the money um and people prefer it and it's not just about affordability it's it's Yeah, great article to read that. But overall, Stretch Bay is something that has been used by a lot of people to budget out a $400 game. They want the $400 game. They they might back one or two projects a year, and they can make this fit within their budget, or they're just trying to be efficient with how the money is spent, so holding on to it for longer periods of time. Um, and it's it's been it's been used. I mean, it's only been two years now, so it's not a ton of time, but it had its usage has continued to grow on the platform, and it continues to be a selling point. Like Kickstarter does have pledge over time, I think it is, but it's far less robust.
I think it's specific to like I can't remember if it's 100 or $125. I think it's $125.
They have that. I haven't even noticed that at all for Kickstart. Is that new?
So, it's I mean it came out middle of last year, I want to say. So, like a year and a half behind stretch pay.
It It must not be used as often.
It's not used as often for several reasons. The main one is it's just not as robust. It It's a $125 minimum, I think. If I'm wrong about the exact number, I apologize. Uh but I believe it's $125 minimum and it's three payments including the first, which means it's really only two further payments. Um, and it's set to like a month out and that's all. You can't change it. You can't edit. There's no flexibility. Uh, on Gamefound, the creator gets to set the rule. You can set the minimum pledge. You can set how many payments. There's a lot more flexibility
and the creator not getting the money until it's paid. You're not fronting anything from Gamefound.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The creator gets the money as it comes in. And because of the nature of crowdfunding, normally when you have these pay overtime options in traditional e-commerce, there's usually an interest charge because you have to account for the risk. You're paying for this thing. You might not pay. has to be someone has to make money to account for the risk. Uh in crowdfunding, you don't have to do that. Your game is not delivering for 6 months to a year to more than that anyway. So, just make sure that your stretch pay is set to a period of time where you're delivering the game. You're fully paid up before you deliver. Then there's no risk involved. So, no one has to charge extra money.
How many creators are using this? Um
I assume most at this point, but I don't know the numbers off hand.
So, a lot of them. Does that hurt their ability to fund their project by not getting all the money up front?
No. So even if a 100% of people if let's say if 100% of your backers use stretch pay and let's assume it's four payments everything every campaign is going to be different. Let's assume it's five payments. If 100% of your backers use stretch pay you'd still be ending the campaign with 20% of the amount needed which in a perfect world should be enough to cover again if you're if you're running crowdfunding properly uh then you should have your money you know segmented it properly goes to the bank account. You have to hold on to it because you need it for delivery. You need it for all these things. So you should have 20%. Again, if every single backer, which it's not every single backer, I don't know percentage off hand, but it's not every single backer. Every backer you start people are using it.
I think it's something like 40% of users use it. I think
I would have expected even higher.
Yeah, it might be a little higher, like maybe mid-40s, but it's somewhere in that range. But if 100% of backers use Stretch Bay on a five payment pledge, then the day your campaign ends, you're getting 20%. On $100,000 campaign, you're getting $20,000. A month later, you're getting another 20%. You now have 40. So a month after the campaign, you now have $40,000 even if 100% use stretchbay for your the way you have to div up profitability as a creator and the way you have to like, you know, be able to use your money to actually pay for production, then to pay for shipping, uh then to actually make money, you should be able to run a campaign with that. If that's not something that's viable for you, you're probably in that situation where you're not necessarily handling your money responsibly in the first place. Um, and also that's a that's if a 100% of people use stretch bay. So, it's a theoretical risk, but the biggest risk of stretch pay is for creators who need every cent to pay for the last campaign, and those creators shouldn't be doing that anyway.
Yeah. I mean, there is kind of that thought that some publishers are using crowdfunding kind of as a Ponzi scheme where you're just shifting money around, the next project is paying for the next one. Um, do you get the the feeling that some publishers are doing that?
I mean, we know some publishers
I mean, we know some that have that have fallen, you know, right? That's essentially what it what it comes down to. I'll say this. Do you think it's a big problem that we have or was it an intermittent problem because of tariffs and all that?
I think it's a big problem, but I also I mean tariffs and co definitely contributed, but I think it's a big problem, but I say that with the context of
anything more than like an edge case is a big problem for me. Edge cases will always happen. You have 1% of creators doing something like that. Sure, that's an edge case. But that we've had several high-profile failures where it became clear over time that creators did not have the money to deliver campaigns. And unless the next campaign was a smashing hit that covered this campaign and last one, you got into trouble. And whether it's Sean, whether it's Mythic, whether it's a Wise Wizard, whatever campaigns that have had their issues, I mean, they've been campaigns that went belly up when they have plenty of campaigns that they still to deliver. So, it's clearly not a complete edge case, which me to me means it's a big problem. I I don't I understand how a creator gets there. I really do. I think there's a point in time where it should be course corrected before it just too far. But like if you have a single bad project, I understand the next project partially pays for that. That that kind of makes sense. But at a certain point, you're just playing a desperate game of we need we need to like the way it works is the first campaign that goes wrong, okay, you roll a dieice, you just need anything above a one.
Okay, great. But then you roll a one, but then you roll a one. So the next campaign you need anything above a one or a two, which is fine. You can make that work, but no, but now you roll a two and the odds keep getting worse with each failure. The first time you run that second campaign, you don't need that crazy of a situation to fix things, but at a certain point it becomes a problem. But um we do we do have checks and balances at gamefound. Those
jumping my question, tell me about them.
So So we we don't get into the exact details of we have a we have a team and sales is disconnected from that team from that trust and safety team. uh where effectively they're there to make sure that we can't run a campaign unless projects have been delivered. I am part of many conversations where we say no to creators who will then go to other platforms or not launch at all or sometimes wait depending creators will respond differently but we say no to business because we don't consider that creator's current situation to be trustworthy or sustainable. Uh the main problem is I would say that creators usually get the biggest brunt of investigation with their first campaign. The problem you usually run into, at least on Gamefound, is that as you build up a reputation for reliability, there is a degree of less and less checks on how frequently we check to see is everything kosher. Um, and that's where the problems arise. So, like we are very good at saying no to first-time creators who are trying to move from Kickstarter to Gamefound, possibly because Kickstarter said no, or possibly because they want to try it out. We're very good at that. Um, once you built up a reputation, it's not to say there's no checks. We still have checks. You still have processes, but it's not like every single campaign gets the same rigorous level of inspection into your books and your finances and your checks and balance and your balance sheet. So, it's not a perfect system, but it is a system where we say no to creators.
How many campaigns should a creator be able to have open across all platforms at one given time?
It's there. I don't think there's a specific limit. I I really don't. who I think I mean if you're asday how many as using crowdfunding right now as could viably run a crowdfunding campaign every two weeks and it wouldn't be a flag
should it be relative to cash on hand
it yes so that's now now it gets relative so relative to cash on hand relative to the size relative to the scope and scale
uh the problem is if campaign reputation well that that problem is reput Sean was was fine until they weren't they had run again like
of course they were what did they do wrong
I don't know well they had gotten I mean maybe maybe the a lot of the criticism was around the the FOMO practices and
Yeah. Yeah. No, that's around all of that stuff. So, yeah. So, yeah, maybe that's unfair to say,
but but they were fine until they weren't as far as deliverability. Um, and the issue is like the outstanding the amount of outstanding projects kept growing, but so did their active projects. Of course, if you if you go from running four projects a year to six projects a year, it makes sense that your outstanding projects will start creeping up. And people will sit there and say, "Yeah, but you were wrong. We've been calling that SEO's going to fail for a while now." Sure, but for the first five years, you were wrong. you were wrong for five years. Unless you're saying you were right the entire time, Simon was never profitable. They're running a a scheme the entire time. I don't think after making $8 million on Marvel Zombies, like I think that there's a certain point where there's a point where if you keep calling for the failure of a company, at a certain point, you might finally be right. When did it actually start? Uncertain. I don't I don't know.
Should a publisher be able to create a new campaign where they have late current late projects?
Yes.
Meaning they've already missed it. Why?
I believe so. So that's an unfort so late is a is a tricky part because the issue is that late is not taken seriously uh in crowdfunding late is an estimate uh and and unless unless things drastically change in the way those things are run I don't think that meaning when you say a project's going to deliver in 6 months okay or a year let's say you say a year an estimate of when a project's going to deliver is generally an estimate if things go well uh and now creators have two ways to handle that they can either say we're going to give a safe estimate because an estimate of when things go well is a we're going to say 18 months. But until unless every creator says that, you're now stuck in this ecosystem where the creators who choose to pad their numbers are the ones who get penalized because you're saying 18 months of your projects, everyone else is doing in a year. Like unless they're penalized, unless they're held accountable by the crowdfunding um platform,
it becomes very tricky. Uh I think there are things I would be supporting, there are things I would be more supportive of for the overall crowdfunding ecosystem to change. I think an estimate on a timeline. That's the nature of crowdfunding. This is a project. It's an estimate.
And do they fudge to sell more pledges? Just like you said, if they said 18 months, there's going to be less people that want to give them an interest free loan for 18 months.
The the flip side as well is if you say 18 months, it becomes two years. There's less pressure.
I think that it's always that aspect of of when you're running things internally in a company. If you have 10 projects in a pipeline, you're always going to have estimates and you're always going to hit some of those and miss others. The difference with crowdfunding is you are you're doing so with a degree of public eye upon you in a way that normally isn't there. Now, should there be something for like a
No, it would be there if you were getting a loan from a bank though that that it's just it's just actually a legal problem instead of oh, I'm getting this interest free loan from a group of people that can get pissed off, but they actually have no they can't really say anything about
crowing is not a loan. Crowdfunding is not a loan. You're buying a product.
That's not how people look at that though.
Crow No, no, no. I'm not saying crowdfunding is not a donation. I'm not saying you're not buying a product. You are buying a product. That's what I'm saying. But it's not a loan. You're buying a product and you're hoping it'll be available on time.
I don't think I think this this is a regular problem in any industry with any degree of deliverables. It's just that it's public here.
But it's effectively used as a loan though. Like there there you do have a responsibility. There's an SLA that you communicate when you are trying to get that free loan from your backer. You do are going to just like a bank, you promise to pay back with interest to be able to take that loan. I'm just saying should people should these creators be held accountable at all relative to future projects, right? Like let's say they just biffed it, should they be allowed to continue the Ponzi scheme until it gets totally out of control, which we've seen. No, no, these are different conversations. There's So when a creator is consistently late and getting later, that will trigger game fans. Again, we don't talk. We don't publicly announce our decisions, but there are many times there are many times backers are like that creator shouldn't be allowed to run more campaigns and we're like, they're not.
When was the last campaign you saw from them? We we've taken that decision plenty of times. Meaning, if projects are way over delayed, uh again, there's several creators who I'm not going to say, but there are creators who have run campaigns on Gamefound that you have not seen a campaign on Game Pound for them in a while. And a big part of that is because we say no to people when there's a clear potential issue. That's very different. That type of situation is very different than, okay, this creator runs a project twice a year and they always say it's going to be a year and they always end up delivering it 18 months later. Mhm.
I mean there's the difference between a regular issue where you're telling them one number and it's being a different
No, I would just mean like open like open late, you know, should there be a a a constraint against creators from trying to juggle a bunch of things to kind of create cash flow?
I think you have to look at the full ecosystem. So a good example of this is if you're a creator, um let's say a good example is might be even Sean. Sean had a lot of projects that were delivering even while Trevang Legends was late. that was a specific project that was outlasting others. It became to a point where it was two three years late and they were very public. We did like this is a big uh you know a big uh you know narrative project. It's been taking much longer but meanwhile they're delivering other campaigns in that hypothetical situation. There's a clear track record of progress and a specific edge case that is a much bigger project. If everything starts ballooning outwards, if everything starts becoming more delayed while other projects start um you know going up, there are things that you can look at and say okay these are problems and again those things those things happen internally uh uh on a regular basis. It's yes I guess depends if you if you're just saying are decisions taken based on current lateness they already are. One thing we're actually working on as well which is relative relevant to this
is because I I I think that I think it's okay for a creator to be late. I think it is. I don't love it but I think it's okay I'm not saying it's not. I'm saying the juggling of multiple late campaigns and then starting a new one is the the problem.
Yep. Well, one thing we're doing is we are I'm not sure what it's going to look like yet, but we are working on some sort of a better creator visibility on when you back a creator, seeing how many things are in the pipeline and seeing how many things are overdue. Uh because we want at least backers to have that information more easily because again going back to backer involvement, some backers know intimately every decision going on. not just every situation going on at a with a a campaign and many more back a project and they may not know this creator's name. They may never have backed something before. They should know when they're backing this creator is overdue on three projects. They should have that information.
Do you take that into account Kickstarter at all
if they're working on both platforms?
It's going to be a complicated conversation as to how to best do that because the question is does it become an automated process or a manual process and what's the best way to do that? And we're still figuring those things out. But in theory, yes, Kickstarter should be taken up into account for greater visibility.
Yeah. Is Game Found concerned at all with like responsiveness and comments or just, you know, because sometimes they'll ghost forever and the number of updates. Is that something you're like actively engaged in when somebody is not okay?
So again, we don't talk about all of our internal processes. Um,
no, you don't have to, but it's just
No, no, no. I don't like saying these things on a call. It's we we are always we always vague as to the exact actions we take. And it goes into that whole aspect of if you say the exact actions you take. First of all, you teach creators how to gamify the system. Also, backers will may not be happy with your exact actions, but we take actions. So, one thing I will say is we do have a system where creators who are overdue on a project, we require regular communication from that creator to their community. You can't simply ghost your backers. And if you do, that results in actions. On Game Pound side, uh we have turned off late pledges on open projects because the creators were not active. like if you're not going to be doing what you need to do, we're not going to allow you to continue to take money from the community. Um, and the thing I always find funny is so often we get people who are asking gamefound to take actions they have already taken. They're like, why are you allowing late pledges? I'm like, we're not we haven't allowed late pledge on that project in 6 months. I don't know what you're like. It happens all the time because because people are so focused on the thing they want to see, they're not even looking to see if that thing has been done.
Uh, game found is very
nefarious. I'm not saying we're perfect. We are not perfect. I do believe we take I guess the way I put it is don't trust that we are goodwilled. Trust that we care about our own best interests if for our own best interests to last long term. Yeah. Crowdfunding as a whole needs to be something that the community feels that they can trust in. There's a reason we put up the stable pledge process. There's a reason we've taken these steps and the reason we're working on a backer community on a a creator kind of accountability dashboard. Uh where it's like we want do we want the s the system to be safe? If a creator goes under in crowdfunding, regardless of which platform it is, it hurts crowdfunding. If a Kickstarter creator goes belly up and doesn't deliver three projects, it hurts crowdfunding. It hurts us. We don't want creators to fail fail. We don't want backers to lose the money. Uh we would rather say no to business than have people never trust this the ecosystem.
100%.
Yeah. I mean, it sounds like based upon what you said there, those are all things that I don't I didn't know that you all were doing. That's exactly what needs to be done is is you know there has to be some even if it's internal not public facing some form of accountability for uh whether it's nefarious practices or just mismanagement overall you have to protect the interest of your customer
and they have to have confidence on the next campaign or you're oed
like people really don't know it's it's and like there's no reason they should and we don't broadcast things but like I'm part of our compliance chat internally we like like a few days ago we got a message being like, "Hey, suspicious um funding jump on this campaign. We took a look. There's a campaign that suddenly had a $5,000 bump in it all of a sudden from a single pledge that happens to match the same IP as the creator and we removed that pledge. We took that. It's like a self-unding bump and we we we deleted it. We removed it. We don't allow that. You're not allowed to selfund your campaign that way and make it look successful, more successful than it is."
So, there's there's plenty of actions we take and we just don't broadcast them. We we try not to rock the boat, but we do care about the safety of the ship. I do think of people watching this, a lot of them might say that I would love to know about what C gamefound is doing to increase accountability with creators. Like that might actually help instill confidence. Um, you know, I I get the feeling that there is, you know, a certain level, and it's always, you know, the the loudest people, you know, create these echo chambers that feel like they're giant on the internet, but people are very, you know, um, loud about not trusting, you know, crowdfunding or, you know, whatever whatever their their their gripe is at any given time. So, I would say that would be good information to have for sure. But I do see that you don't want to draw lines in the sand because the game everything there's nuanced and highly complicated and you know putting those exact kind of standards out there might hurt your ability to um to manage it properly. So
I I think both things are true. I understand why we don't announce every single thing and also it draws a light to think the balance of balance as well is like you're like oh wait there's creators there who are selfunding their campaign. You're like yeah but we're on top of it don't worry. Yeah.
Um, but
that's a different Yeah, I wouldn't put that out there, but yeah,
but in all cases, I agree that I would have I would rather have more transparency what we're doing. It is complicated, especially when it comes to the creator side of things. Like we have to be we we are playing a delicate game of trying not to upset creators, trying not to upset backers while trying to care for the overall ecosystem. So yeah, I I don't disagree with you that more transparency about the specific actions would be better. I still think there's a way to do it. Yeah, speaking of concern about crowdfunding, it seems like there's been kind of this this underlying concern about crowdfunding fatigue. Too many campaigns, too many games, you know, it's it's it's hard to hard to keep up with. But then you also pointed out recently in a video that we had maybe a record-breaking week with, you know, three or four insane campaigns that would completely just like, you know, throw that thesis out the window.
What's true? Is it thriving or is there fatigue?
So there's there's our individual senses which I think we should not trust at all and then there's data. So individual senses just to give you some basics is any person who's feeling a sense of fatigue and crowdfunding. It might be their own fatigue depending on when you joined crowdfunding you have such number of big boxes around something that was exciting once upon a time starts to become this overwhelming. I I remember the first time I got a zombide game I backed. I played it so many times and the last time I got a zombie game back I played white death twice now like twice I got six months ago more than that I played it two times like it's a whole different conversation depending on where you are with different things and so I think individual fatigue is very different um as far as the industry I can say different things that are certain truths um I can say with certainty that crowdfunding was down last year overall um I believe that's more tariff related than anything else because every year prior has been an increase tabletop has increased every single year-over-year. Uh last year as the first year saw a decline, which lines up nicely with the tariff situation and the whole state of the world being a war steel. Um I can say with certainty that this past month has been possibly the biggest in tabletop crowdfunding that has ever existed. I have to check the numbers that like there's a weird way of phrasing it. I can say with certainty that it has possibly been the biggest week ever.
Most likely in the top five, four, three.
No, I think it's the biggest month ever. I'd have to like you have to figure out when the campaigns ended, but like between between Brass and Slay the Spire and Cyberpunk alone, you're talking about like a $25 million month in crowdfunding. Like it's in absolutely insane. I don't know if that's ever happened as far as tabletop. I'd have to like and that's just those three. I'm saying besides what else is out there. So I'd have to pull up numbers, but I think it's in the biggest month. A single big month has not changed the overall flow. Uh what we have seen in general as general trends is we have seen that even that even as crowdfunding has grown year-over-year has become more widely distributed. Meaning it's been less topheavy that we've seen less campaigns that broke you know $4 million and a lot more campaigns that were in the anywhere from 50k to a million. So like a lot more widely distributed as opposed to topheavy which again this past month with these three four campaigns is changing that right now.
Um, so overall it's I think the trends are that we're seeing a wider distribution while the space still grows. Um, and this month is just an exception.
Yeah, that's what I was talking to um Chris of Chris Couch Games and and he had a a sort of lackluster start to um Garden Club and he's like, "Well, I launched it next to all of these behemoths and you know that does that does hurt you for sure. There's a certain wallet share that was out the window. I don't know that they were all garden club um you know customers but you know is that
our yeah our data shows that a single big campaign you should not be afraid of it'll actually draw people to the platform. You have 30,000 people joining the platform because they're interested in Slay the Spire and sudden they see Garden Club along with it. But there's a difference between a single B campaign and multiple B campaigns. A single B campaign draws attention. Multiple B campaigns saps while it's dry.
Right. And is that Well, I'm surprised that they all launched at the same time. Like, how many of How many of those did you have on Gamefound?
Uh, we've had from the It depends how big you count, but uh we had count like over million, for example. We had we had we did not play Slay the Spire. We had here to slay,
brass Pittsburgh, and we had what was the third the other multi-million was Old King's Crown.
Um and then Kickstarter had
Cyberpunk.
No, Cyber Punk and Slay the Spire were on Kickstarter.
Yeah. And then if you go down to like million-dollar projects, we have brothers in arms. Kickstarter has arcs, you know.
And do you how how much of a concern is it from creators and launching next to other people and wanting to like move their data around and how much are you helping them with that decision?
I get the question a lot. Uh we don't tell other creators other creators dates. We can say things like this is a month that has a bunch of other campaigns.
We can we can be vague. We're not going to tell you, hey, by the way, Brass is launching this date. Like I mean game has countdown timers. often see
maybe try week three instead of week two.
Absolutely. Absolutely. But it's a delicate balance. Have that conversation with three creators and suddenly they're all launching week three. So you have to like there's a weird balance to play here as far as being like hey things can change at any point right now this Tuesday like yeah we have two big campaigns launching. We've had things and actually the last time this has happened that was relevant is gamefound has something called the game found feast where we basically highlight a bunch of projects and we showcase them all. Um, the last time we had the game found feast, we had two creators who were launching that day, the same day as the feast. And one of them chose to launch that day. The other one said they wanted to push off their campaign by a week because for the first few days after the feast, the homepage is taken over by the feast. Completely taken over. It's like all showcasing the feast projects.
What's interesting is post the campaign, the only two projects, we didn't do a full test of a millions or whatever. But from those two projects, the one that chose to launch the same day saw significantly higher funding and their percentage of driveby traffic on the platform was significantly higher. So they actually got boosted by the fees based on what we saw in the data relative to the other one that pushed it off by a week and got much less they got more homepage placement, but they got far less dry by traffic of people who were just there for the exciting announcements.
I wonder how much of that was wallet fatigue also the next week. You know, they had just backed a bunch of stuff stuff on the feast. They probably should have went the week earlier. Well, the feast technically doesn't actually have things that are available to buy. It's it's a press release.
So, that's they're going to be upcoming. So, that one's a little different there. But, yeah, in general, again, general data rule is
try to launch side by side with a B campaign. Genuinely, try to do it. Just don't try to launch side by side with three B campaigns.
How do you balance this conflict of interest that you have with Board Gameco in Gamefound? I know you you've talked about it a lot and you I always hear the disclaimers. like what are your thoughts and like how do you manage that?
You can't make everyone happy. We've already established
the short answer is this goes back to like the beginning of the conversation where I was like everyone has different lines of what they're ethically okay with. Um I have who is it? Oh, there's another cont. I'm not going to say who it is. They at one point they were on blue sky being like and of course Board Game Co. is you know completely like lack of any ethical guidelines and like okay again everyone's going to have their own line. Um the the way I like to put it is there is certainly a conflict of interest for me covering again people it's so interesting people care about because people will say you the people who care which not most people don't care the people who do care will say like well you shouldn't cover a gamefound game by that logic I shouldn't cover a Kickstarter game either if I'm incentivized to boost a gamefound game I'm also incentivized to trash a Kickstarter game it makes my job easier if you have a Kickstarter failure I guarantee that
should we do the meta analysis on your perspectives on gamefound versus kickstarter games
do it absolely Absolutely. Check out my reviews. I have three reviews going up today for 20 strong. Uh do you want to know what my least favorite 20 strong decks are? The Awakened Realms uh you know set of decks.
Really? Are you serious?
Absolutely. Absolutely.
I just I have an interview going up tomorrow. They didn't give me any decks. Um which I'm a little hurt on. I thought the reading the rules and going through them and speaking to the designers about them, they sounded so fun.
So I like the Tate Grail one. That one I like a lot.
Okay.
The either feels nemesis.
I like the deck building. The nodes on that.
Yep. The nodes are fun. The Ether Fields is basically feels like a regular 20 Strong game except I don't like the map. I don't like the maps. The map
Well, you have to like the map if you're going to like like that one.
The map feels boring. It feels boring. I'd rather play
I was hoping there was a sense of exploration in that map where you were excited to explore and you didn't you didn't find
I'm not excited to explore. It's it's a part of the game, but I I'd rather just play Hopus. It felt like a better Have you played Hopkins Strong?
Uh that's my favorite one. That's one of my favorites and like I'd much rather play that one. Much rather play that one.
I think that was up until these that was the best designed in my mind.
Or the slay the spirees nodes in Tangle Woods. Would rather play that. Um but uh what's it called? And then the Nemesis. I think Nemesis fans will enjoy it. I'm not a Nemesis fan.
So like it just feels like they took 20 Strong and made it more Nemesis than 20 Strong. Like
that one looked like the closest recreation of just like porting a game
that you can go to the park and play and get the Nemesis. But I was still excited. Not as a solo player though, which is kind of like
Well, you you can play solo. The solo mode I prefer.
No, I No, I'm saying I wasn't excited as a the traitor mechanic is always kind of like the thing that
Yeah. You know,
so from those three games to the the Awaken Realms collaboration, uh which again awaken realms game, have a friendly relation, all that. Uh, so and those are games that are on Gamefound and they are my least favorite 20 strong deck so far. Granted, two individual reviews because again I do like Tainted Grail. Two reviews does not make a pattern, but I I encourage people to try to find a pattern. I've got
How many times did you play each one?
Oh, so um Tainted Grail I don't know exact count. I'm going to go by rough estimates. Nemesis I played three times. Uh Ether Fields I played twice and Tainted Grail I've played a lot but that's cuz I really like it. before my review. I want to play I want to say I've played Tent Grail maybe four times before the review, but I've played it multiple times after the review. That's the only one I've played post review. The other
the interview I did with him was super fascinating and the way they explained the design process was uh was cool and got me excited about them. I am glad you like the Tainted Grail. That's probably the one I'm the most uh easily excited for because of the deck building aspects and the node system that they have in there. So, my big complaint that I will say, and that's an opinion that has changed as I played it more, is in my review, um I said that I I gave it a 4.5 as like a micro. Um I don't think it's going to grow. My only question now is whether it will shrink. Uh cuz I've already played it several times post review. Um and part of the problem with it is I still like the system, but there's not enough variety in the cards because I've played it more so quickly. I've kind of seen all the cards already, and I'm a little less excited because of the way the the decks are split out. But I still like it. I still like it a lot. I think for me that's the that's the problem with the 20 strong system just me as a consumer for that particular product. I really love diving into designs pulling levers exploring what's there and there just naturally there's not a lot. Although there was I did like the legacy Etherfield idea of the the card flip that happens as well.
It's cute. It's cute. I talked to my review. I said it's a very cute concept, but is it semantically different than just more cards?
Well, so one of my questions was like, does this like thematically have connections, which it does apparently.
I don't know if you saw that from card to back. I like the idea that there's different types of cards on the other side. So, you're like unlocking other things there.
I love the idea of it, but it's just a gimmick. It doesn't change the way you play the game. It's just a gimmick.
Do you think that's because you didn't play it enough? I don't think so. I don't think so. Like again, there there wasn't a clear there there was there were definitely um occasional theme tie-ins between how a card flipped. You're like, "Oo, it's a shadow. Now it's following you." Whatever it is. Like the theme tie-ins,
but like from a from a balance standpoint, it's cute. It's cute. But from a balance standpoint, it can't be that the game gets significantly harder with one card or the other. Otherwise, any game is going to be all over the place.
I was I was I forgot to ask him that about balance. Was it difficult to balance it? But to your point, it's probably not a big you're not increasing difficulty by flipping a card.
I I didn't weigh up every single card, but I I absolutely did not go to every card and weigh up the pros and cons. And I haven't played enough to know that for sure, but from at a glance, some cards were definitely better. I did see some cards, but like as I'd say more cards seemed like it was just different as opposed to better or worse. And so, I don't do like it. I think it's fun. I do think it's fun, but I think it's fun with the caveat that like I don't think it's improving the experience. I think I'm just charmed by it.
Okay. All right. Well, you know, I do do you tend to like does that 20 strong system have staying power for you anyways?
100%. So, it's you are the customer for 20 strong.
I believe I am. I think I like all of them. The first two that I'm considering not keeping are either Fields and Nemesis. Um, those are the first two I'm considering not keeping. The rest I I've kept all of them so far. I will grant that like maybe Too Many Bones I shouldn't. I don't actually despite loving Too many Bones. The too many bones system is not my favorite one from the from 20. So maybe I shouldn't keep that one. But I think I would I think I would keep it right now.
And either fields.
Do they really count 200?
No, no, no. Absolutely not. I cheat them. I I count 20 strong as one for sure.
Okay. So just keep it.
Yeah. Whether whether I keep them or not. And like the problem is like I like Nemesis more than either fields because even though I'm not a huge Nemesis fan, at least Nemesis feels different. Either fields I would just rather play a different 20 strong. Nemesis at least like, hey, if you want to play a slightly more traitorous game and I don't want to own Nemesis, like I can at least see the appeal there. Yeah,
I do agree with you. I think
I came away with that just saying like, oh, I'd rather play Too Many Bones, but the Hoplo system and it's been so long ago I can't kind of speak to nuances, but I just remember
feeling like the system was doing something new and interesting and I was excited to It's the pyramid version, right?
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, for sure. But we we veered way off course. So, going back to the original question about biases and all that. So, the short answer I'd give is there's no short answer. This this is the short answer. Um,
you like game found games better than Kickstarter, clip it, right?
Yeah, that's the short version. That's the short version. Um, the short version is uh if I was being strictly speaking trying to be 100% ethical, which I am not, and I'll give context to that. Um, I would not cover games. I would not cover game or Kickstarter games. I have a conflict of interest. I absolutely should. The reason I'm not concerned with being 100% ethical, and I did a video on this a while ago, which I actually never released a follow-up, but it's been too long that I don't think I'm going to bother, where it was basically a poll. It was saying, "How far does that line go? What bothers you?" Like, "Where do disclaimers start and end?" And I don't think you can be a 100% ethical in a proper sense without being just crippling. Uh, it means and I I what I did is I I kind of went through a poll where I asked the audience, "What do you care about? Do you care about if the game was if the review was paid for?" Personally, I care about that. I don't want to do paid reviews. Paid previews, sure. paid reviews I don't like. But but there are channels that do paid reviews. Everyone has a different line. Uh what if you know what if I did sponsored content with that publisher in the past, but this isn't like do I have to disclose that? What if a game is on the shelf behind me and I've done sponsored account around that game? What if a game is on the shelf behind me and I done sponsored content for that publisher but not around that game? What if it was 6 months ago? What if it was a year and a half ago? There's like this infinite line of ethical standards to try to figure out what is okay and not.
And I'm not saying that you shouldn't be concerned with ethics. I'm saying that for me at the end of the day I try to be mindful of what makes sense to me and I recognize that people won't necessarily agree with that. And the thing I find I consistently say this every time this question comes up I consistently say that also there's a lot of unintended consequences which you can get into a second but um I consistently say that the thing that I find the most fascinating is the thing that people care about is never the thing that actually matters to me. The thing that actually matters to me is nine times out of ten I know the people behind the game
and I just feel like a jerk knowing that they're going to be watching my review
and I feel like a jerk. I feel like I'm like oh like board game code put out a 3.5 like and like I mean I like the people at Chip 3 games. I like them.
You think I care about the fact that it's a gamefound game? I couldn't care at all. I do a good job for gamefound. I'm happy with what I do. But the fact that Chip 3 games, who I personally like, most people on their team, they be like, "Oh, well, Alex didn't love two of those three." I feel like a jerk. And it feels worse when they're a smaller creator and it matters more. You mentioned the Garden Club, Chris Gouch. I felt like a jerk. I I I covered pedal. I loved it. I covered a garden club. I thought it was ran too long. I'm on camera with this campaign. It's making $4,000.
I disagree with you, but we can talk about it.
I garden club. So, yeah. Either way, I'm happy you liked it. I'm happy you liked it. I like Pedal Farm more. Garden Club is whatever. But the thing is, but I feel like a jerk covering a game that's making $40,000 barely like, you know, not hitting the numbers that wants to see, I'm sure, and here I am covering this. You think I give two thoughts at all about the fact that the game's on GameFound? No. I give two thoughts at all about the fact that I'm about to hurt this creator by not loving his game and it's a Kickstarter game and like that's Yeah. So, the thing I actually care about is never the thing people bring up. People are like, "Why didn't you say it was a review copy?" Because I couldn't care less. Why didn't I say that I know the person who gave me the game? talk to the person who gave me the game. I understand that he's just trying to make it. That's what I care about and that's the thing no one cares about. So like if we want to talk about ethical standards, I agree there's a way to do it ethically. The best way to do this ethically would be to not be involved in the industry, to be completely removed, not go to conventions, not go to people, not meet people, don't have games in your background. There are I'm not saying it's not doable. I'm saying I don't care enough. I don't. I will do the best I can and you'll learn to trust my opinion over time or not. I would love for someone to do a meta analysis on my game time as a Kickstarter. I would love it. I'd be so shocked if there was anything there. I'd be I' Yeah, I would love to see it. Um I I have people like, "Hey,
I could do it. I've got the API and everything set up. I could do that." But
well, this So this is a great transition to something I wanted to talk to you about. So I think it was yesterday I released a video that was in response to Total knee-jerk. I wasn't planning it. I was actually planning a video responding to you about basically needing um you know, nuance in in your reviews. So, what and just for the people that haven't, I came across a mini review and everyone wants to know what it is and I'm not going to say what it is. Um, that you guys are kids. Like, it's not the point. That's not the point. The point is I came across a video where somebody clearly didn't give the particular game a good enough shot because the nuance in which they were speaking about was really not even like part of the main design. and some of the criticisms they gave clearly did they didn't play it a particular way basically I and I didn't realize how big of an issue it was until I've recently you know made friends with some people in in the industry and I really like this person and then I re and then I figured out exactly that they spent thousands of hours on this project and this person is pretty big in the uh in the space and this then they have a lot of sway and just like they can shoot something to the top of the top one of the hotness and BGG, they could also sync something and it like hurt my heart that this person so frivolously kind of like did this on a mini review and I I know because I played it so much that they are not at least giving it its fair shake. I get the feeling they played it once, maybe twice, whatever it might be.
So that relationship thing and I've been answering a lot and been very active in the comments and I just answered one today which was if you want true exactly what you just said. If you want true transparency, you need to understand what the relationships are because that has a significant and they're not even likely tied to monetary benefits. It's just liking people. But also, I think that's okay. That's also what makes this hobby so special in my mind is being able to kind of like live in community with these other people. And everyone is so like stuck on like, did you get paid for this? Guess what? Everyone gets paid for this. relative to the number of hours that everyone spends on a video, a free game doesn't matter. We don't value the games like you do because we get so many of them and we spend hours upon hours creating the content for it. It is so misaligned and that was one of my points there. So I'll I just saying that because I agree with you that full transparency is almost impossible. I would need to know who are you texting with, who is do you call a friend, who is an acquaintance on top of like who you've taken money from in the past, who you have a deal with in the future. All of that stuff is just totally unknowable. I would rather us to look at this and just like from a human perspective, like how are we kinder to people and understand that these are all individuals? However mad you want to get on the internet, like go yourself, honestly. It's these are real people trying to make your hobby, which is the nichest thing you could possibly
think of with the least amount of monetary reward. If they were trying to scam somebody, they would do it somewhere else. Like, let's lead with love and just understand that these are individuals. So,
so where I with the crowd, no, I agree with everything you said. I But where I where I agree with the crowd to an extent as well is
if you're calling yourself a reviewer, your allegiance isn't to the people who are struggling. There's a reason like I have specific rules and I follow those rules and that's how that's how it goes and the rules are consistent. So for example with crowdfunding even this actually is relevant for your meta analysis actually by the way. Um with crowdfunding generally speaking there have been a few exceptions in the past but I think that's like before I mentally put together these rules. Um if the game is less than a three out of five I won't cover it or at least I'll offer not to cover it. I'll say hey this is not for me. I don't feel the need to play it a second time to like get to the review part. Would you like me to go forward or not? And sometimes people say yes. Most time they say no at that point. With final retail, I will cover it across the board. That's my own rule. And the only reason it gets that grace is because if you are a work in progress and I really didn't like you, I have to give grace to the fact that you're a work in progress. But otherwise, if it's a trashy game and it's a final product, it's a trashy game. It's a final product. I hate the fact that I will um I hate the fact that I'll hurt a creator, but my my allegiance is to my audience who trusts me to tell them. So, I have to choose who do I want to do a favor to. Do I want to do a favor to that upstart guy who's putting hours into the game or do I want to do a favor to my audience who's trusting my opinion on what makes sense to get or not to get? Um, and ultimately my allegiance to my audience, my emotions are with the creator. There's no question. That's why I have to like overcome that bias as much as possible and like put out a video when I I would love nothing more than to just give every game a five out of five, which is a lie, by the way, because if I do that, then everyone says every game you give us a five out of five. But in theory, if I
That's a lot of criticism.
Yeah. and and and it's valid if every if you love every game like whether Roto like if Rattle genuinely loves every game to the extent that he he he puts out okay but it just makes you less useful all I need to know is you covered the game I don't need to watch the video um but I yeah I if not for that aspect I would love to give every game a five out of five I just I I it's a balance it's a balance I don't know how to
totally valid like and and I do you know you have an infinite more relationships than I do and I can imagine it becomes really complicated and really tough. Um, but at the end of the day, like it's fine as long as you're transparent. That's that's my call, right? Is in this particular mini review, they did not say how many times they played it. They didn't say that they didn't lie about it or whatever it might be. They didn't try to try to like um, you know, act like they had played it a ton, but it was just definitely omitted. And the nuance, the the analysis that they can give in a game wasn't there. So I know they have the ability to give highly nuanced takes on designs. It wasn't here. It was like it was just you know. So where do you think a creator what responsibility does a creator have in u number one the number of times they play before they call it a review or a first impressions? This was called a review.
And should they be saying how many times they've played it? um giving kind of like the context of of their experience with the game rather than just it's a review and this is how I feel about it.
So, it's complicated. That's what it comes down to. A long time ago, I did a video called can you review a game you've only played once? And my takeaway at the time was yes, I believe you can. I personally called it a first impressions. Uh but I believe you can do you can review it under any circumstance whatsoever because otherwise we just get into gatekeeping. Do I have to be concerned with the pacing of did you play it all the same day? Did you play it across a week span, a two months span to give the game time to settle? Did you play with people who liked the game? Because group vibes matter so much. If I play a game with a bunch of people who didn't like it, I am more likely on all this 100%.
So like all of this stuff comes down to like there's there's a never- ending. I went through a phase in the channel uh where I did say how many times I played the game. I went through a phase. It was a short phase and I stopped doing it at a certain point because like I I can't remember the exact reason. Part of it was like I wouldn't always remember. Some games I played all in a week so it was easy. other games I've been playing over the past few months and I'm finally getting around to reviewing it and I'm like I don't know. I'm not looking up BG stats and then I'd almost feel the need to but I can't just like not say it because I made a trend of saying it. I found it almost set this weird bar of transparency that I almost didn't want to make for myself even though if you ask me I'll tell you uh the one rule though you do mention though that you try not to review a game unless you have like three or four plays I believe.
So the specific rule the specific thing I say is and I it's always the same thing. It hasn't changed. Um, I guarantee you a minimum of two two reviews, two two plays or I call it a first impressions. That's my rule. It's not a rule that I necessarily feel to impose on others. I personally will play it at least twice or it'll be called a first impressions. The second thing I say is that the more I like it, the more two plays was probably three or four. And if a campaign games are longer because you have to like really engage it. But I want to see all the mechanics. So even like you mentioned, but and the less I like it, um, the less I like it, the more likely it is to be two. If I I'm medium on a game, I'm just not interested in rushing into it that many times. So, a good example is either fields I play twice because I'm going to review it. So, I played it twice, but I only played it twice. The reason I played Nemesis three times, even though I'm equally like both of them are medium to me, both of them are 3.5s. They're not bad. They're still 20 strong.
They're just so much better 20 strongs. The reason I played Nemesis three times is because Nemesis I played the first time without any objectives, which is how they suggest it. I played it solo that way just to learn it. Then I played it solo with objectives and then multiplayer with objectives. So, the only reason I got that third play is the dynamics of the game kind of I wanted to see more to have a more rounded opinion. I'm not going to say fully rounded because what counts as fully rounded, but I wanted a more rounded opinion. And Ted Grail I liked a lot. So, like again, I don't remember the exact number of plays I played before reviewing it, but it's like at least four um because there's just easy to play. So, every game is going to be a little different, but my personal rule is two two games. And the less I like it, the more you should assume it's only two plays. If I give a game a two out of five and I called it a review, I guarantee you it got two plays. There's not a chance I played it more than that. Got a two out of five.
Um, and then occasionally I just do first impressions. Um, but to do a first impressions for Khara, it wasn't even bad. But honestly, it was too long of a game to be
really. I've heard good things. I I keep looking at the lackluster box. I'm like, should I get that? No, I'm not going.
There's a reason to me two years to get to playing it. But like I played it and like everyone at the table is aligned that like we're like nothing was bad, but like it's not a 7.8. Now, if it's a 7.8, it's 7.8. That's other people's opinion. Our group opinion was not. And I was like, I can't be bothered to play it again. It wasn't even bad. It was just so medium. It was so medium. But anyways,
do you think you have too much experience? Meaning, and I think you talked about this in your video a little bit, right? Like your relative experience with board games matters. And we'll take 20 strong as an example. If it's if somebody's picking up 20 Strong for the very first time and they haven't played everything that you have played, let alone the thousands of games you've played, is it possible that that might be a 10 out of 10 or a five out of five for them? I say this, yeah, in Etherfield specifically, I say that I think I'm probably being too harsh with my 3.5, but I am weighing it up against other 20 Strongs. Either Fields is good. It has a lot of the elements that make 20 Strong good. I just the way it's structured, I just can't see a reason that I'd want to play it over other 20 Strongs. But I did specifically say like I think I might be being too harsh in my rating, but it's it it's it's hard. Is that a fair bar to say that to say like, oh, you know, you measuring it against the other like individually?
The one other thing that I like that you do is you talk about what you think others will like and and and dislike, which is it's it's tough for you to say, frankly, but you you have a general idea. I like that at least that um that spirit where we are we're putting ourselves in other people's shoes, which this person that I was talking about did not do that. It was just like I played a billion games. There's a ton of other things that I've played and I'm trashing this one thing in a 30-cond. You know, there was there was no like, hey, I could actually see this type of person liking this.
Was it a 30 to 90 second review?
I don't remember what it was. It was it was very short.
Why do you ask?
There's a particular person who likes to do hot takes.
Yeah, I don't know. We can cut it out. You can you can ask this. I'll 202. Uh, cut this out. I don't know the channel name, but they're 90 secondond hot takes. Basically,
if you don't know the channel name, it's not that person. Uh
Oh, okay. Interesting.
Uh where the heck were we there? I was ranting.
Uh you just said 30 seconds. I I like paused. Uh but you're saying just the I don't exactly know the exact You were ranting about the lack of accountability to the review that
Well, no. Well, I actually specifically in your instance, I guess I'll I'll move on to sort of a related new question. Like are your reviews relevant to the normal person?
I assume so, but I don't it's hard to say.
You played too much.
So I this one of the things I always Okay,
remember Wingspan was a 10 out of 10 my favorite game of all time for a moment.
I understand. But the flip side of this here's the flip side of this conversation. I don't know what your experience has been like. Okay,
here's my experience. Okay,
when I first started watching reviews, if the Dice Tower gave something a seven out of 10, that was permission to buy it. that was absolutely permission to buy it. 7 out of 10. I'm interested in the game. 7 out of 10. That's pretty good. I'll buy it. The more games I played, the more I was like, a seven out of 10 is a waste of time. I needed to hit a minimum of an eight for me to pay attention to a Dice Tower game. So, as as my own experience with the games changed, my need for a higher score changed, too. A 3.5 is a 7 out of 10. A 3.5 is a good game. Most games are like, it's still good. I'm not saying to again, the debate is maybe if the official should get a four out of five. Maybe. I don't know. It's a good game. So is Nemesis. They're just my least favorite from 20 Strong. But I also think that in the shoes of someone who's not that experienced, I think that's permission to get the game. The way like if you like a game, if you really like a game and it has a 7 out of 10, by all means get it. Just it don't touch it if you're on the fence at all. Like wait for again everyone's going to have a different score of different anything.
But I also try to be mindful of where games are. Like part of people often have said you should be like lowering your average score in the context of the full picture. I'm like, I don't I don't do that. I can't say I'm not in some way affected because I'm a human being and I can't fully separate out my emotional range. But if a game is good, as a game is good. That's that's ultimately what it is. Uh the the times I do struggle the most is the more comparable the more directly comparable a game is to another is when I struggle the most because I'm like, why would I play this when I could play that? But is this good? Yeah. But it's basically just
you had that conflict with Everddale recently
with Ev Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The Ever the all the Ever games again. And that's such a I guess such an interesting one. It's like my my least exciting five out of five I ever gave. It's like it's a five out of five. It is a five out of five. I'd rather play I would rather play Evidel whatever the new one is called. What's
or or Emerland?
Emerland. I'd rather play Ever Emiland over dozens of games. Dozens and dozens of games. But I'm also just not excited about it because I already have three versions of Everdell.
Hot take. I want to get rid of the Everddale collection and just play a different Everddale every year instead of having to sort through a bunch of expansions.
I don't think it's the hottest take, but I'm not there yet. I might get there.
I thought Silver Frost just the I love Silver Frost. I thought it was great. I'm a Everddale fan. I hate going into the big box. I hate trying to figure out what expansion I'm going to play with. Some people it's like their favorite game. That's not a big problem. But for me that just wants to kind of casually get into an Everddale. I'd like something new. I get bored of games relatively quickly. So, by the time I'm bored of Silver Frost, I'll be happy to go pick up Emerland and just try the whatever the new gimmick is in the mechanic. I'll be done with
possibly my second favorite evidel. It is possibly.
Yeah,
I think it does some things really solid. Um, I like Silver Frost a lot. I really like the variety of the creatures you're engaging with. Um, but the snow mechanic does drag it down a bit. Like it does
the snow mechanic does drag it down. I don't like that snow becomes more expensive over time. Like in a game, you want to feel like you're getting more power over time. It's one of the problems I have with Wingspan where you get less.
I was about to I was about to say, but you love Wingspan so much.
No, I don't. Now I don't. I mean, Wingspan's good. I'll play Wingspan anytime. It's not I'm not a I'm not a hater. I'm not an elitist. I will happily play Wingspan, but I like to feel, you know, you and I I know are aligned in powers and abilities.
There's a power ramp power fantasy that feels really good. It doesn't feel good to feel like you're have you're doing less. But I will say about Silver Frost, because of the nature of the the creatures or whatever on the mountain relative to a normal Everdale game, I feel like I'm getting way more done. It feels like there's there's more there.
They are very very solid.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So, oh my gosh. Like we we went off on a couple side quests in the midst of this one one conversation around board games and transparency. I think we were kind of talking a little bit about like relative experience related to where the um you're you're reviewing games. I wonder are do you have and something I do measure in cardboard is somebody's ratings drift? So if they're getting more lenient or or opposite over time if they're tending to rate games higher or lower as as they go on. Do you feel like you've you've
not meaning adjusted yourself over time?
I have so I have data on this. I have to pull it up. I would have prefer this. I have a PowerBI spreadsheet of all my reviews over time and my average rating. My average rating has gone down minimally a little bit over time, but like these are rough numbers. They're they're in videos. They're actually like published, but I just don't know. They are off hand. But like to give an example, I think my average score was like 3.6 and then it drifted to like 3.57 and then down to like 3.51. So like I am experiencing a slow and that's per year, not the whole average. Per year my average dripping. Um, so I have experienced a slight shift over time downwards being slightly harsher, but it's very minimal.
But you also have a really tight window because you're only on the what the one to five scale. So
yeah, it's a one to five scale with 0.5 increments. So like it has 0.5 increments, but we realistically speaking, it's not a 1.1 to five scale. It is effectively a 3 to five scale with exceptions. That's what it is. Because most games are good. This is where I am like fair to the fact that like I'm not trying to have my experience come in. the mo the vast majority of games I ever am willing to dabble in are going to be good games. It is rare for a game to hit 2.5 because games are fun. You put time and effort into making something based on a general rule structure because you're a designer who's in the space. Amazing games are fun. Um but occasionally occasionally things disappoint me and they get that 2.5 or lower. But yeah, so my scale is basically 3 3.5 4.5 5. I have five numbers and then I have exceptions. Granted,
I pro actually, now it's a good question. Do I have more five out of fives every year or more 2.5 out of fives? It might be close cuz there are enough I play enough games that 2.5 is definitely slipping. I think I have more 2.5s.
Yeah. Like what's your relative percentage of two 2.5s compared to fives would be interesting.
3.5 is easily the most common score by far, but I believe it's 3.5 then four, then three, then 4.5. And I I think but I'd have to check. It's all in a spreadsheet somewhere. Another thing that I I believe in and I built into cardboard is is what's even more important is um how your perspective changes over time. So when you rate a game a second time, you're not overwriting. You are adding you can override if you want, but you can add a new data point. So we can track like hey how quickly does a game fall off on a from a particular person's perspective. I also track in plays enjoyment. So you can also see how their enjoyment changes uh over time as well. How important do you think that is in the hobby? Because it's super easy, at least for me, to be incredibly enamored with a design and literally four plays later, I'm like, "Oh, that's it."
Yeah, that's common. That's very common. If a game has variability and keeps me engaged or not, um, I think it's important if it depends the goal is important. As an individual person, it's not that important at all. um as a reviewer who's offering review reviews es especially here's what the area it's the most important is unfortunately unfortunately an area you'll probably never see which is if a reviewer is consistently rating a game on their second play and consistently experiencing drop off on their fourth play that's helpful information to have but that's a very specific edge case uh otherwise it's like it's good to know it's good to know for you as a reviewer for sure
well also just from like a like if we're trying to measure uh games overall like right on a site like Cardboard or even BGG. You look at a game
game.
Yeah. Yeah. For the specific game. So you look at Brass for example, how many of those brass reviews were onetime reviews? How old are those reviews? Number one, are they relevant and still the same now? If somebody were to go back and actually change them again. Like BG doesn't have an ecosystem around like what re-reviewing or even like tracking enjoyment over time. Like screw the review. I just want to know, are you still tracking at a nine enjoyment in brass on your 50th play when it was a 10, you know, in your first play? That would still be a really great game. And that's I've had an interesting experiment. I mean, we only have 1,600 people on Cardboard, but the number one game of all time using a very similar um system that BGG uses is Castles of Burgundy, specifically special edition.
Number two is Slay the Spire, which I was like, what? wild. And it is it's this combination of volume and average score. It's the Beijing average that that BGG uses. I take some other things into account, but um but I thought that was so interesting. We I just got a a a current
like sliver and granted it's my audience for the most part and and all of that stuff. It's not not like the perfect perfect sample size, but I do I think that that review or perspective over time is so important. We're just not really capturing it. And as creators, we're not incentivized to always go back on every single review and say, "Is this is Endless Winner uh still a buy for me, Alex, or should I have not bought it?"
It's not a buy for me. I I still like it. I'm not willing to get rid of it, but at this point, the com
Yeah, but you had me buy it, though.
I know. I'm sorry. I apologize. Send me a bill.
I know, right?
I meant every word I said at the time. That's like That's the There are again, there are some that I do feel bad about. there somewhere. My opinion changed over time and I definitely feel like I was buying into the hype. I don't think Endless Winter I bought into the hype. I think that was an ecosystem structure. Uh but there are some games. What's the go?
Is it valuable for a game to just have a shelf life and just be fine with it? Meaning like
yeah,
I know this thing is only going to get me 10 plays or it might get me one play a year.
Um
100%.
Right.
I view games that way. I like trying different games. I enjoy the process of trying games. But does the do you think the audience looks at it that way when you're telling them a score?
Everyone's different. I think that I think that and again I'm not saying don't get me wrong if I if I think a game's only good for a few plays. That will usually be said in my review. I will very often say this started off high and then it got lower. The thing I feel the worst about not the worst about in general the thing I feel a little bit unsure of how to handle is I will regularly come back from a convention and be excited about, you know, five games. And almost every time when I come to the reviews of those games, you know, two months later, at least one of those five, I'll be like, "I'm sorry. I know I just told you my post."
And I love those videos of yours. And I bought so many about your your excitement coming out of those.
But I but but post any convention, pick a convention, there's always one game that like again, there's usually like 10 games I liked, whatever it is, and like three or four I'm really excited about. And then I'll come back like three months later, I'll be like, "Um, I'm sorry guys. I played it four times and I'm not excited about it anymore." I was excited after one play. So sum like now the question I the thing I struggle with is I always say it I say it when I do it. I say like one play does not a review make. I say that very clearly but you still might go buy the game because I just came back from Gen Con. I'm excited about it. I gave you a disclaimer. A disclaimer only counts for so much. So now I have a choice as a creator. Do I not tell you my Gen Con experience and give you information down the road when it's less relevant, less exciting
or do I stick with the fact that I gave a disclaimer and sometimes things change after you play a game for? I think the disclaimer is important and you know we have smart people they should they should understand you know
no that's the thing it's not about us being smart I don't care if you give me a disclaimer if you come back from a convention if you say I just went to Dice Star West Alex I tell you right now it's only a play so take it with a grain of salt but this was my favorite game of the year based on one play
if I go out I will go out and try to hunt down or play that game tomorrow okay and then when you say oh yeah yeah I don't like it anymore I'm sorry I played it three more times but I gave a disclaimer Alex I'm like I don't what now granted it happens all the time. Now, it's a pattern with me. It's not all the time, but it's it's I would say that there is definitely a trend that if you pick five games that I liked after one play, one of them I won't like four plays in.
You know, likely at this point that's one.
Yeah. Do you think we have
a duty to come back, especially games that we've reviewed really high and in 6 months, a year later re-review or at least tell, did I even play this thing again? you know, Unconscious Mind you mentioned, I really loved and I probably got people to buy that. I actually have not played it since I reviewed it. It's the nature of what I do, but
yeah,
that's the truth if I'm honest.
It happens. It happens.
Do should we do we have a responsibility as a as a tough word. Um I think is valuable content to reapproach stuff. It's why like I have a series again. I have a series. Um I don't think it's essential. I think at that at honestly at that point like the if somebody bought a game based on your review the damage is done so to speak. Yeah.
I think it's helpful for people for people who aren't going to buy based on the cult of the new it's helpful content. If I'm someone who has learned that I shouldn't always buy every game that came out. Maybe I do watch content from a bunch of channels and I see that those games are holding strong a year later and I go out and buy them. Hey, Alex is still playing this game a year and a half later. This is not like Cult of the New. I think it's worthwhile.
Then it's less exciting.
It's like Yeah, it is. It is. into
I could do 17 essays on how hard it is to be a content creator and make everyone happy and that I would get very little sympathy for them as I should. Um it is complicated. We have we we chose this option and we chose the things that come along with it and the fact that we can't make everyone happy and we have to choose between call to the new and being I can be steady old reliable and get no views or I could engage the cult of the new and get the hate that comes along with it.
Mhm. It's it's we we we make choices in life and we have to take responsibility for those choices and we we can acknowledge that the ecosystems sometimes suck, but it doesn't make that problem suddenly go away.
The video that's cost me the most money or the series from you are and I don't know if you still do these, but it's the um you can still late pledge videos.
Those will get me so excited because not only is it fueling FOMO, but it's also like, oh, I'm I can still get in late on this thing. I didn't have to go out of that monthly budget, you know, months ago or whatever. It would get me so excited. Now, if you do the re-review or the update review, I don't think I ever bought anything from any of those videos from anybody, you know, but if you tell me I can still late pledge, woo,
has a weird magic that makes no sense. The same thing that you will happily spend $100 on on Kickstarter or Game Pound, if it's on the store in front of you for the same thing, suddenly less appealing. I don't know why it is. We're already over our two hours here, but I you I want to I want to hit on two quick games. So, you recently added Shallow Sea to your collection.
I love it.
I love Shallow Sea. Um Shallow Sea is probably taken over for me uh from Cascadia. I've done some really successful videos in the past where I I kind of basically compared Cascadia, Calico, and Harmonies. Um Cascadia has always won out. It's not my It's not my soup dour. It's not the, you know, that I play a lot of these because my wife likes them, but Shallow Sea did something
really incredible and I can't quite put my finger on it, but just the moving the fish around and that like puzzle is just so engaging to me. I also kind of just love Bad Comet, so I'm probably biased towards them, you know? They I just I' I've really loved kind of like basically everything I played from them. So, um, but you also did not like Garden Club, which was another tile layer that has, uh, is on crowdfunding now, and I was able to play it. And, um, the meanness that my wife and I experienced, and it's tech technically a totally different tile layer because it's a duel.
It's not just kind of like you do your own thing. Um, the meta that has that has propped up and I told Chris I'd send it back and my wife's mad. She wants to continue to play Garden Club. Why is is uh uh Shallow Sea so great and you didn't like Garden Club?
The biggest problem I had with Garden Club is the sheer amount of movement maneuverability you had in the game I felt slowed down the game and also the
tools because of the tools.
Okay.
And also the opportunistic like the amount of tools like you don't have like one tool in your hand. You can have a handful of tools and then you're sitting there analyzing
the tool economy might be a little heavy.
It's a little heavy for me. Like that's why I really like pedal the other game from them. you kind of have one tool the whole game. And I thought that was a great amount. And so you combine you combine toolheavy together with a meanness aspect where you're trying. It's like if I don't see a good play for myself, then I may as well screw up your board. Like if I I mean I'd rather do a good play, but I'll screw up your board if I can. And it felt that it slowed down the I did like the trelluses. The trelluses were a nice touch to anchor things a little bit so you have something.
My wife always used them early and I forget about them.
Yeah, I know. I know. And amount of times I've forgotten to use them. I get to end the round. It happens. But the the the end end result is not a bad game for me, but a game that I really liked. Like each time I played it, the first round was tons of fun and then the more the game went on, I was like I kept wanting it to be like I kept wanting to have the three round arc but be a two round game. Uh it's not that I didn't enjoy it, it's that each time I I had small complaints about the amount of AP, the amount of meanness, and it felt like each round each game outstate its welcome a little bit. Whereas a shallow sea is like I don't know what it is about the game that does it for me, but that game is like the box says 45 minutes. I never play in 45 minutes. It's always like an hour and a half like whenever I play it.
Yeah. Well, it depends on who you are.
It is so satisfying to me that particular puzzle. I find it more rewarding. Uh but also like the movement there is very different cuz like you're moving fish but you're not constantly adjusting tiles. Like your tile placement really matters. Sure, you can move some fish around the board. So you have some degree of optimization but the tiles are kind of locked which I
Is the best tile layer? Is it your number one?
I not yet, but I might well. I see it going. Cascadia still.
Oh, Cascadia still.
Cascadia is still I think with all them.
So, no. Landmarks is kind of meh for me. I'm not okay. I It's a fine add to the game.
Yeah.
Yeah. It doesn't improve the game. I will say Alpine Lakes is the more thinky version of C. If you like if you like Shallow Sea,
Alpine Lakes might be worth checking out for sure.
Do you think Okay, so do you think a shallow sea do you think Alpine Lakes is a more satisfying puzzle than Shallow Sea?
Yes. Yes. Interesting. Currently
because it has verticality, right?
It has verticality and it really messes with your head in a way the same same kind of way that shallow sea does. I will say I right now if you ask me what I want to play right now, I would pick Shallow Sea over over Cascadia. But I have to weigh up in my score the fact that I've played Cascadia 50 times and Shallow Sea eight times. Like that weighs like I'm not in a rush to give it a five out of fives. I do give a five out of five. You know, every every year like five to seven games get a five out of five. I think Shallow Sea will be a five out of five. It's not
I think so too. I was gonna make a kind of an update to this tile layer video because they've always done very well for me. And I think it clearly to me has beaten out the others that I mentioned in the past.
That's our that's our number one. Um that's what we'll go to. You also added and you said this might be a kids pick. A game that I've enjoyed, but I have one gripe. Layers.
Oh, it's fun. Yeah.
Yeah. Layers was like I just thought would be a gimmick. Um, you know, sort of like terrible quest was, you know, I was just like, "Oh, I kind of like the idea of this thing." Uh, but it ended up being I really enjoyed building the dungeon much more than I thought I would.
Like that as much as that's like setup, that's totally part of the game. And I was like thinking like, "Oh man, I could do this next time. That would be really interesting." Um, and I immediately went and saw, okay, there's got to be expansions for this. And there are expansions because I felt like the offering was so incredibly thin on the base game. You get one ma, you get one monster, you get one trap. There's so much to me. There's so much uh like space here for really interesting design asymmetry. The bigger the multiplayer game that I think is in the expansion as well. Have you played the expansions?
I have. I've opened the first box, so I know the expansion stuff, but I haven't played it yet. Um so I've seen the stuff I'm going to play with next, the next time I play it, but I haven't done it yet. But I I completely agree. And uh Helena from uh KTBG, if you're listening to this, I apologize. Um, I I I really enjoy Larry so far. Um, I do think that the retail offering feels a bit incomplete. Um, I think that I have the Kickstarter game, so I don't have that problem, but I do think the retail offering is a good tease and you should get expansions. I think they a single
if I would and again I'm not trying to hear I'm not here to judge other people's decisions because like running a company's hard but with the benefit of you know hindsight and where I am I would say if the retail game should have come with like one extra trap and one extra monster and that would minimum
that but that would have been good enough to call
it would have been at least variety yeah because you won't know what kind of trap you're running into and
100% as as it is it feels like a a tutorial game even if it is a good tutorial game even if it's good and it is good It's fun on its own. You don't have to play it. You don't have to add more stuff, but it does feel like an intro as opposed to a full experience. Had you added a single monster and a single trap, it would have changed the conversation.
You You hit that one right on the head. It feels like what the rule book tells you to play first before adding in all of the other stuff. To me, this felt like an expansion money grab. It's one of the few though that I will say where I play it and I go like, "Oh, I actually have to have the expansions on this." As much as I don't love,
you know, Helena, I love the expansions. I bought the base game. Uh, as much as I don't love the the the practice or maybe it wasn't intentional, whatever it might be,
I don't think it was intentional because KTBG I think this is the first time I've had that complaint against them. So, it's not a trend that they regularly do. It may have just been that decision. It may be a decision of being too close to it as a creator and not necessarily seeing how it might be perceived. But I've never like KTBG has never come across as money hungry at all. Yeah. Um, this one is the first time I felt that it comes across as like you have to,
right? And that's like if I were to make a review, which I won't um just because I don't have time to do it, but I would say I probably wouldn't recommend the base game. As much as I really enjoyed the first two or three plays that I've had, it quickly goes like, "Oh, I wish I had something else to put there. I want to build a really cool dungeon." And it seems like that's kind of what's coming in the expansions, which I don't think are available in retail yet, but I will I will get them.
Um, okay. That's that's it. You You did it. We went 21 minutes over, and I really appreciate it. It's been great finally getting to talk to you, man. This has been awesome.
Yeah, I can safely say that at this point, um, if combining the first, you know, 30 second interaction we had and now two hours and 20 minutes later, uh, you still still haven't gotten bored yet, but it takes three to four plays, so you know, time.
Yeah, don't review me yet. Oh, and by the way, I want to speak for myself and how I roll. I don't know if we had I had an interview with him as well because I met him through through your channel. Another incredible guy. Really, really cool guy. Thank you so much for supporting small creators. You know, it absolutely matters. It's one of my missions as well on Cardboard. Like, these are just regular people trying to live their dreams, busting their ass to go put out fun and cool stuff for everybody. And when you go out and mention and give us a few hundred subscribers, it makes our day. So, that is that's awesome. Do more of that for other small creators because um it's it just, you know, it it makes absolutely makes a difference. So, thank you for that. Yeah, Ryan's great.
All right, Alex, I'm going to stop the recording now.