Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tinners Trail Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:17

Hey everybody, today I'm talking about Tinners Trail, which is a board game designed by Martin Wallace and published by Alleycat Games. This one accommodates one to five players and takes around 90 minutes to play. Now, if you didn't know, Tinners Trail is actually a reworking of an older game of the same title. I believe some small adjustments have been made from that old version, including new artwork and a new player count as well. So, um if you aren't familiar with Martin Wallace games, he is very known for his economic style games, his industrial style games, and this one is certainly of that ilk. As we take the role of these uh I suppose these mining tycoons in Cornwall in a bygone age. So, um we have this map of Cornwall here where we've got this bunch of tiles, some placed face down, um a couple of them placed face up. This is all depending on the player count, so with a bigger player count, some of these regions will be filled up. You've got this part of the board here which shows which resources are available to be bought. You've got almost this time track system in the top left-hand corner.

You've got this points market here in the bottom right-hand corner, and this um this little gauge here that shows the value of tin and copper, which are your two resources in the game. Uh each player is also going to be given a number of cards. Uh again, depending on that player count, so in a in a bigger player count game where this region is um is up for play, then you're also going to have D cards as well. You're going to have a bunch of these mine these mines here which is going to show your areas you control on the board. And you've also got all the different resources at the side of the board here such as water. You've got your copper, you've got your tin, and you've got these drainage tokens as well. So, the game is going to take place over four rounds, and the idea is at the end of those four rounds, you want to be the player with the most of victory points. Now, the way you gain victory points in this game is quite unlike anything else because in this game, as you'd expect with a with an economic style game, money is extremely important, and money and victory points are tied hand in hand because you are I'm going to have the opportunity to exchange money for victory points at the end of each kind of round, um depending on this market here. So, for example, in the first round, if I ended up in this spot here, I can exchange 10 pounds for 22 points or 5 pounds for 10 points as many times as I like, but there could be a lot more reasons why you might not want to do that and might want to save money um in to go into the next round. So, the main mechanism in this game, or kind of the main driving force, is this time track here which is going to determine the order in which players take their actions. So, ties are always going to be broken by the person furthest furthest

to the left and furthest to the top. Um so, for example here, the yellow player would go first, and they are going to take an action out of these possible nine. And all these actions are going to have a certain amount of time relating to that action. So, you've got time um actions that cost one time, and you have actions that cost up to three time. So, let's just say just to go through the motions here, uh yellow took an action that took three time, they'd go up three spaces on this track. Then it would go to the pink player, let's say the pink player also took an action that took three time. And now the blue player is going to have the go, but let's say they took an action that took one time. They're going to keep taking their turns until they catch up and um eventually maybe overlap like this. So, it's always going to be um except the person furthest to the back and furthest to the top. So, even though it's it might be someone's turn, they might have a goes back to back depending on how many time they've spent. So, let's talk about all the different actions and how they are going to affect the game.

So, the first action you can take is to start an auction for one of these mines on the board. So, you can either bid for a face-up tile or a face-down tile. It's completely up to you, but of course, the face-up tiles has more open information for the other players to know the relative value of that tile. So, the the tiles have three bits of information on them, the how much copper is in that mine, how much tin is in that mine, and how much water is in that mine. Of course, the more metal, the better because that's what you're going to need to collect in order to sell to get victory points, but the water could be quite a big obstacle and make extracting the metal from that mine a lot more expensive. So, generally, the lower water, the better. So, when you want to take this action, the player whose turn it is is going to select which tile wants to be auctioned for. So, let's just say for random sake, let's just pick this one here. And now that player is going to start with an opening bid which has to be 1 pound plus 1 for each player that's already passed.

So, in this example, nobody's passed yet. So, it's just going to be a straight-up start at base value. So, um the first thing you can do is you can either choose to play one of the cards from your hand um as long as it's a wild or matching the tile's letter. So, I could play this A card, for example. Let's just say I do that. Um which means that the player whose turn it is is going to actually get to peek at that tile to see what's in it. So, this example is not the best because it's got a lot of water in there and not too much metal. So, it's going to be a relatively cheap tile, it should be. And then this player is going to start the um start the bid. Um but bearing in mind that not only are they going going to be able to peek at that tile, they are also going to be able to get an insurance policy which means if they didn't win that tile when it when the bidding finishes, then they are going to get half the money of the winning bid rounded up. So, again, these these cards are really good. Um you've got to use them quite carefully because not only do they give you those benefits, but they also increase the productiv- the productivity of that mine by giving it more metal. And some of these cards do different things such as, you know, maybe maybe they're not so powerful, but they also might be able to like drain water, for example.

So, uh once once you've selected your card and you want to start the um auction, then it's going to go in a round robin style auction until there's only one person left, and the winner is going to uh reveal that tile. They're going to place the number of cubes uh corresponding to to that tile and the cards played on it. So, for example here, I place three water cubes, two copper cubes, one tin cube, and add the ones to the card as well. So, that's another tin and another copper like so. You can remove the tile. You can add all these cubes over here, and you want to place one of your mines on that to show that you control that particular part of the world. So, once that's done, if a card wasn't played, the winning player can actually choose to play one of the cards from the hand again abiding by these restrictions about about being a wild or matching the letter in order to boost that value. So, what once you've got it locked in, you're going to have to pay though. So, if you play the card beforehand, you've got that speculation of, you know, am I going to win it? You get the insurance policy and you get to peek, but you might you again, you could still end up losing that mine and therefore not gaining the benefits from the card. But if you play the card after, you definitely get the benefits, but you do have to pay to get that benefit.

Before you start taking the main actions in the game, you're going to determine the value of each of the different minerals. You're going to roll three of these dice and weigh up the values. You've got a value of seven here, so therefore the tin is going to go on this spot here, be making it worth 6 pounds in this current round cuz as you said, the seven to eight value is there. And then you're going to do the same thing for the copper. And which again has landed on seven, meaning the copper is going to be worth 8 pounds this round. Now, if it ever lands on one of these extremities here, so the lowest value or the highest value, in the following round it's going to be boosted or subtracted by one, meaning that it's unlikely to be on the same spot twice. The next action is to extract minerals from the mines, and that's going to cost you one time to do that. And when you do that, you're going to have a look at your relative strength of that of that particular region. So, all the mines are going to start with a base strength of two, but you can choose to boost that by investing in all these different things here, which I'll touch on shortly. And then you're going to have the option to take as many um as many cubes up to that strength, so again, two. So, let's say I want to take two copper here. But you have to pay a a number of pounds equal to the number of water cubes in that squ- in that section. So, for example, for each cube here, I'm going to have to spend three because there are three water cubes for a total value of six, meaning that I'll have to reduce my money down to 14 from 20. And then I'm going to add these cubes to my supply ready for selling at the end of the round. And before I move on to the next player's turn, whenever

you extract um metal from your mines, you're going to add a fresh water cube there, um meaning that it's going to be more expensive to extract any more metal from that particular region. The other two actions from this top row here are pretty simple. The first one being to spend one time in order to gain a pound by selling a pasty, so you'd simply just move up the track like so. And the other one is to pass where you'd move from the time track down to this section here, which I'll touch on a little bit later because that is quite important. The bottom row corresponds to all these different investments you can make in order to make your mines more productive and to drain water. So, the first one is to buy one of these miners which cost you one time. And I should say these are all limited, so depending on the round you're in, so in the first round, you have a strict um limit of only being able to buy um two two of these workers or two of these boats. But later rounds, these um these trains come in, and you could buy these pipes as well. Um but that's amongst all the players, so there's a real tight kind of contest to get these down onto the board because they are limited.

So, yeah, when you take one of these um miners, you're going to put them in a region, and that basically increases your extraction value by one. So, I could take up to three cubes as a single action if I had that one there. Uh the next one is to place one of these boats, and these boats cost you two time, and you can put them on any of these coastal regions. Let's just use this one as an as an example again. Um and that is going to not only increase your extraction value by one, but it's also going to get rid of a water cube, which is going to make extracting that minerals um a lot cheaper. You've got the trains here that come into play a bit later, uh which like let's just say I just use this one here. And let's just say I placed it on here like so. It's going to get rid of two water cubes from the current region it's in, but also one water cube for each adjacent region. So, this one would go.

Whenever there is anything's affected and it's not been revealed yet or it's not been purchased yet, then you're going to put one of these drainage tokens on there. Or two two in this example. Which means that in the future rounds, whenever these tiles are revealed, then the any water there is instantly going to be drained at equal to the amount of drainage tokens there. So, these are really good and actually can increase the uh the market value of any regions that have not yet been purchased. The penultimate action here is to build one of these tunnels and they cost three time. And when you build one of these tunnels, you're going to place it at in uh on the kind of corresponding line between two different regions like so. And that is going to add a cube to each of each of each of the different types into the adjacent regions. So, like like so here.

And it's also going to drain each of the um each adjacent tiles by one. So, that's a really good one to place if you've got two adjacent regions already under your control. You can get a lot more out of your investments and they can be really useful. And the final action here is one that costs one time, which is simply to use one of these pumps. And you're going to take the amount of pumps equal to the round it's on. So, in the in the later rounds, there's going to be up to three pumps. And you're going to take the one furthest to the right. So, this is how I've already got one here, but I'll take the one pump and then I would remove an equal amount of water from any region. And you can even split them as you like. So, that's a real nice quick grab to get rid of water quickly. So, once once all the players have decided to pass and place their tokens on this part of the board, you're going to have to sell all of the metal that you've mined this turn. So, for example here, the yellow player has taken two of these copper cubes out of their mine.

They're going to sell them for a combined value of £16 because the copper is worth £8 a piece. So, again, they would make they'd move their money token up like so on the track. Now, once players have all done that, in player order, you're going to have the ability to sell or get rid of your points. Sorry, get rid of your money either in denominations of 10 or five in order to get the points here. So, for every £10 I spend, I'm going to make 22 points if I'm the yellow player. But every £5 I spend, I'm going to make 10 points. And as you can see here, this is why passing is so important um because if you pass earlier, you get a lot better conversion rate than if you pass later, or at least slightly better. And in future rounds, you are also going to diminish in value of of each of your selling. So, as I said, if if I if I sell stuff or £10 worth of goods in the first round, I'm going to make £22, but if I do it in the fourth round, I'm only going to make 13. And that scales for all the different passing order as well. So, let's just say for example, the yellow player wants to sell £10 worth of goods here. So, they'll send they'll move their marker down to 20 and they would move up 22 points on the score track like so.

And once all players have chosen to cash in their money or not, they're going to have you're going to have to re-roll the market and set the new prices for the different ores here. So, 4 5 6 7 8 9 10. So, the actual this would go up one and again, let's do the the copper which has gone down to six, which would actually make the the copper worse worth less money in the next round. And once that's done, again, the passing order is so important because whoever passed first or the first two players are going to have the ability to peek at a different tile each to to basically know what that mine is going to be worth. So, the yellow and blue player are going to have a look at a tile without the other people knowing to see, you know, is it worth me starting an auction for that tile or not. So, that's essentially how the game is going to play after four rounds. And then of course, the player with the most points at the end is going to be the winner.

So, let's talk about my thoughts on Tinners' Trail. And let's start with the basics. So, first off, let's talk about the actual time system here, which I think is fantastic. So, generally, I like time track style games where the person furthest in the front has to wait until all the players behind them catch up. And this one is probably one of the best examples of that that I've seen. I really love the fact that you have to weigh up your decisions not only on what you want, but how much time it's going to take. So, let's just say for example here, I really want to buy one of these one of these uh tunnels here. That's going to cost me three time. But I've got to bear in mind that if I'm if I'm taking that, I'm going to spend me spend my three time and all the other players might have the the time and opportunity to whip up and snap up all the other resources before I get my turn again. So, that's a real strong decision to be made and I absolutely love it. I also love the actual pressure of wanting to pass before the other players to get the best conversion rates here, have the ability to peek in the um in the next round for example. That is a really great thing. And of course, being first in the future round as well. So, I love it when you have that tension of, you know what, I've got loads of actions on the table here that I could use and exploit. But if I do that, the other people are going to likely pass before me, I'm going to going to get a lot worse conversion rate and I'm going to be almost subject to being last in the next round, which means I'm going to get the dregs of options available. I think that's a fascinating mechanism and this is a great example of that being used.

The auction mechanism itself is pretty basic. You know, you're just selecting one of these mines and then going on a round robin style auction. But I do quite find the the blind bidding sometimes in terms of, you know, you're not knowing what you're bidding for quite fun. You can take some punts and see what you get. Sometimes you're going to strike gold and get an absolute bargain. Sometimes you're going to get a bit of a going to get a bit shafted by spending too much. But that's all part of the fun. It's almost got that kind of Storage Wars style feel to it where you just don't know what you're going to get in this particular mine. That's all the fun. But of course, that is all mitigated by the card play because you've got a very strict limit of cards here. You can choose to spend them and get that peek and have a good information on what you're going to buy. But of course, the other players are going to be led on what you're willing to spend on it. So, if they know that you're spending a lot of money, then they'll probably know there's going to be a good mine there. But who knows, you could be bluffing and making them spend more money than they want to.

And you've got that insurance policy of taking half the money rounded up as well. So, I do like the way these cards are used not only to bolster the um the strength of those mines, but also the mind games that can come into it and that insurance policy. But I think the thing I find the most fascinating and interesting about Tinners' Trail is the actual extraction system itself. You know, not only do you want to have the manpower in order to get as much as you can out of a single action because as soon as you take one of those um uh mining actions, you're going to have to refill it with water, which is going to make things a lot less um a lot less cost efficient in future rounds. So, you want to get as much as you can out as cheaply as you can and while there's as few cubes available as you can. But you want to do that while the iron is hot in terms of um in terms of things being worth their full market value. Because, you know, if you've got a mine with a bunch of tin in it and tin is at its most value, and but there's still water in there, you think, you know, am I going to try and wait in here and try and extract as much water as I can and hope that I can maybe wait until tin's at its full value again. Or is the the market value of tin just going to keep plummeting, meaning that I I should just pay the money anyway even though I've got loads of water in there because I'm still going to be making a profit. And that kind of commodity speculation is absolutely fascinating and I love this very simple but engaging market system where the value of these two simple resources fluctuates drastically.

And on top of all of that, this scoring system might just be one of my favorite scoring systems I've I've ever seen. I love that incentive of wanting to pass quicker to get the better conversion rates, the way things diminish as the game goes on uh is absolutely brilliant. And although it's a very slight, those slight differences can make a big difference particularly if you're selling a bunch of of things at once. And you know, you've got to be careful about not to just get rid of all of your money because you're going to need that money in order to extract minerals in the first place and in order to bid for new lots. So, that that that money management is just absolutely fascinating and has so much depth to think about. While the player interaction in this game isn't so much in your face, it is pretty much embedded in everything you do. It's an auction game, so you're going to be competing in terms of getting the best lots. But that passing on the actual time track mechanism has a lot of player interaction. So, you're thinking about what your players your opponents are going to do, how quickly are they going to pass, and you're going to be competing in terms of getting to that bit of the board as quickly as possible. So, yeah, I do like that competition, the tension getting all the resources as well. You do have to bear in mind what your opponents are going for and you can't just do your own thing uh willy-nilly. So, yeah, a good amount of player interaction here and exactly what I'm kind of looking for.

Uh the aesthetics and production of the game as well, I think is fantastic. It's spot on for me, not overly done, not just superfluous things for the sake of it. It's all just very simple, very toned back, but still being beautifully done. So, you know, you've got very simple resource cubes. The actual meeples and things themselves are really well done. They're nice and elegant without being too fiddly. Uh you've got the um you know, all the symbology on the cards is just dirt simple. The artwork is nice. Um and I really do like the way that this game is set in the part of the world that's not really explored too often in terms of being Cornwall in England. So, I really like that. So, yeah, I've got no issues whatsoever with the production and in fact, I would give it two thumbs up because this kind of production is affordable but still feels high quality.

The progression in this game, I think is amazing. By the end of the game, you've got mines all over the place and it's that efficiency puzzle of wanting to get every single bit of metal out of those mines as you can with as few water cubes in there. And that is really a timing issue, literally in terms of this track, because you want to make sure that you've got enough time to get as much as you can out when profits are the most. And as the game goes on, that really does ramp up in its tension. All without nagging tension of wanting to pass earlier to get these things here. So you want to get as much as you can with as few actions as you can. And that is a really great puzzle for me, and it certainly is engaging from start to finish. And you know, by the by the third and fourth round, you know exactly what you want to do, but it's really taxing in order to get it achieved. And weighing up that decision, you know, am I willing to pay this money to get this metal out? Yes, it's going to be profitable, but will it be more profitable next round? And that is just such a great decision to be made.

So overall, I am absolutely enthralled by Tinners' Trail. This is way better than I thought it was from reading the rulebook. Every little element here has me just absolutely fascinated. I love the the timing system. I love the scoring system. But more importantly, I love this water system. It is so thematic and just so interesting. And just weighing up what these lots are going to be worth. Have you got the time to drain that water? Is now the time to do it while the resources are worth more money? Or am I going to just, you know, am I going to wait too much and the the market is going to plummet, meaning that it's just not going to be worth it for me, meaning that that investment was a dud. Absolutely brilliant. So many things to think about while still being digestible. You've got nine actions to consider, and they're all very simple in their own right. But the depth of gameplay behind those decisions is huge.

So yeah, this is exactly the kind of game I like. And you know what, the more I'm talking about it, the more I kind of appreciate it. And I want to get it back to the table instantly. So to hell with that, I'm going to give this one my Elite Shield, cuz I think it deserves it. I am absolutely thrilled with this game design. It is fantastic. Thank you so much for checking out this video. If you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining, then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already. Additionally, if you wish to support the show because I am a one-man operation and I don't I don't get any support from publishers, then please consider backing on patreon patreon.com/chairmanoftheboard, where you can back for as little as £2 per month. Thank you so much. I'll see you next time.

Progress saved