Skip to main content
Loading video...

Two Reviews: Lord of The Rings Duel for Middle-Earth & Fellowship of the Ring Trick Taking Game

Transcript 23:34

Welcome to Allies Arene Enemies. I'm Jess. And I am Sean. And today we are journeying deep into Middle Earth to chat about two different Lord of the Rings card games. And both of these were provided to us for review, but the thoughts in this video are all our own. Let's get right to it. The first game we'll be talking about is Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth. And this is a two-player only game designed by Antoine Baoza and Bruno Cthala. And Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth is very much a kind of remake is more than a reskin here, but it it really is taking the groundwork set by Seven Wonders Duel, which is also by Antoine Bowser and Bruno Cthala, and putting that into the Lord of the Rings universe. And there are quite a few differences though, so we'll quickly go over how that plays. And so what happens in this game is there's going to be kind of a pyramid of cards there. That shape's going to change through rounds.

But really what you want to know is that there's going to be kind of a laid out tableau of cards with only some of them available to choose at any one time. On your turn, you're going to pick one of those cards. That's going to do something. either it's going to move your dudes around Middle Earth and that's going to make it so that you can take over these these different um areas of this map. It's going to there's going to be ring cards that's going to move your either your fellowship or your Naz Ghoul along this track either for the fellowship to bring the ring down to Mount Doom or for the Naz Ghoul to catch up to Froto and Sam and steal that ring. Or you're also going to be collecting these different artifacts and there's six of them and those are going to be the green cards and once well there's more than six but once you have six different ones you're going to win the game. So, you're either going to win the game by taking over the world, by getting to the end of this track and either delivering the ring or stealing the ring, or by meeting up with all of the different tribes. I think that's kind of what that's meant to represent and getting those six different artifacts. And that's kind of the like really in a nutshell, but there is quite a bit more to it than that. And it has kept what I think to be the most interesting aspect of Seven Wonders Duel, which is how you get your cards.

Because when you take your card, you then are usually making available the cards underneath. And if those are visible, those may not be cards that you want your opponent to be able to access. So, it's always interesting about which card to choose and which cards you're leaving open for your opponent to take. Yeah, you're often taking cards maybe you don't even really want just because you can see what they're doing. You can see that this is going to let them take this region or this is going to let them it's going to get them closer to getting that set of green cards. And the other thing with the green cards as well is when you get either two of the same or three different, you get these bonuses and those bonuses are huge. Those bonuses make such a difference. Yeah. And they give you usually like ongoing powers and those can really be strong.

They feel almost gamebreaking, but it is a good reward, particularly if you're getting two of the same symbol, or else like why would you bother getting two that you're still getting these bonuses. Another interesting thing is instead of having just your own wonders that you can build, there's now these shared landmark tiles that either player can build. And that's interesting as well because you might be both trying to get the one landmark tile and it's a bit of a race as to who can get it first. The other thing that those landmark tiles do as well works a little bit like that first expansion for Seven Wonders Pantheon where really what it's doing is it breaks up you having to take that next card. So sometimes you really don't want to take any card because you're going to release whatever is underneath there and your opponent really wants that. So, this gives you a way to kind of break that rhythm by taking those um landmark tiles in the middle. And so, that is also a bonus, but those get more expensive as you go. Whereas the wonders in the in the original game are always going to be the same price. You can kind of think about that beforehand. You can still think about this, but each time you get one of those landmark tiles, the next one gets one coin more expensive.

And coins are very hard to come by in this game. Yeah, it is interesting because they've changed the coins a little bit because in the original Seven Wonders Duel, it cost you like one coin for each resource you don't have, but an additional coin for those resources your opponent has. This time, it's just one coin for a resource you don't have. So, it does make it a lot quicker to decide like how much things cost, but coins are really tight. Yeah, money is super tight. There are a couple ways to get it. One of them is you can just discard cards. And also um from that ring track and the ring track I think is the part that is the most interesting cuz like the the fighting is interesting that that's gone from being so abstracted to you know an actual map where you're fighting. That is really neat. But the ring track kind of replaces the blue cards cuz the blue cards in Seven Wonders Duel are just points. But here, instead of those points, you know, just being points you get at the end, the points kind of represent you moving along this track and it being that you get to a certain amount of points. And the neatest thing about that is it it's weird because you move the same number of spaces, but it doesn't feel like it because you kind of see the fellowship moving. And if you're the NAS school, you think, "Oh, they're getting away."

But because of how it's set up and the little like plastic thing that the fellowship's on and then the NAS schools on the back of that, you are always staying the same relative distance. But it's like a little kind of like magic trick. Yeah. No, it's so clever how they've done the components for going along the ring track. And it is nice that you get those bonuses as you go cuz I think it makes those blue cards even more interesting. And thematically, it's just more fun to be getting closer to Mount Doom or closer to catching like Frodo and Sam as well. And speaking of which, in terms of the components, not only does the ring track look really good, but I really like the art, and the art is all done by Vincent Drait. So, the card art uh looks very impressive.

There are also the armies and the towers and those are all screen printed which I think is a nice touch. Yeah, I think th those those are terrific. I will say a couple things. The cards are a little bit thin but that does help this game have you know a fairly reasonable price point. Also the um the bo the insert the insert is terrible. Just chuck it put the stuff in baggies. Put it in that box. You're going to be fine. But otherwise, I think I think all of the stuff is, you know, it does a good job. If you've got Seven Wonders Duel, expect basically that exact same quality. You're going to get that exact same thing except with that really cool sliding ring track. And that is so clever. I'm really interested to know like what other iterations they had before they came up with that really cool solution. And I'm interested to see if anyone else copies that because it's such such a clever solution. There is also a handy cheat sheet for what all the different race tokens mean. So, if you ever have to look it up, you can tell pretty easily. And I really like those race token bonus effects because they can really drive you towards doing different things depending on what bonus you get. There's, you know, there's one that lets you take another turn every time you take a money card. So, then you're really going to be gunning for those. There are other ones that let you be able to put out like more characters on the map. So, you'll probably be trying to win using that condition. And so, it is interesting. When I first

played this version, I wasn't too sure how I felt about it compared to the original one. And I think part of that is I think our first game went very, very quickly. I think you had a really strong bonus from one of those race tokens and it felt a bit unbalanced. But now, tons of games later, I've really appreciate it and I can see like how many different paths and different ways this game can play out. Yeah. I think also one of the problems was with that particular power, we played it wrong. Okay. So, so that didn't so it was way stronger than it should have been. But yeah, I think those first few games I it took me a little bit to kind of get my head around some of those changes. How that money the economy is so different now. how the blue cards, I'm not really collecting those up because that was something I would do a lot because you would really rush for the other two. I would just save up those blue cards and hopefully win with those points at the end. That's not really the strategy now.

Now everything is a race. And I do like that that everything is a race. So I think after having played this now, I don't know, a dozen or so times, this is probably my preferred. I think base game versus base game, I would probably go with this one over regular Seven Wonders Duel, but I still do really like Seven Wonders Duel with that first expansion. With that second expansion, it almost makes it a bit too big of a game for me. But I would be interested to see if they add an expansion to this and if that does, you know, tighten it up, maybe make that ring um the the delivering the ring wing condition maybe a little bit easier. I'm interested to see if other people are having that same feeling like they're usually winning with the other two and that that one's harder. But that does also make that one the one that I want to gun for. And so it is really interesting having all three of those win conditions be something that you really have to pay attention to that you don't want to give up cards for and that you're often like I don't want to give you any of these. I don't I don't know what to do right now because I can't quite win it. So I don't want to give you anything. But and it's so often too that I think most games that we've played, whoever's won, the other one's been one away. Um, do you think it's worth having both in your collection?

Yeah, I think we'll keep both cuz I think they both do the game differently enough. There are enough different mechanics and also just thematically. I really like the Lord of the Rings theme and I think they did such a great job of retheing it and changing things to match that theme. The next Lord of the Rings game we're talking about is the Fellowship of the Ring tricktaking game. And this is a one to four player game designed by Brian Boruer. So the Fellowship of the Rings tricktaking game is as it suggests a trick taking game. And if you don't know what that is, don't worry, you're not alone. I had no idea what that was until I played The Crew. But what that means is everyone is going to have a hand of cards. Someone is going to play a card. Whatever suit that is, everyone has to follow that. if they have a matching card. Whoever has the highest card wins that trick, which means that they're going to take those cards. What is going to happen in this game is that you are each going to be different characters. So, you're playing through the story of Fellowship of the Ring and each chapter has its own challenge, its own different characters.

The different characters are going to get dealt out and everyone's going to have a kind of a character specific challenge. So, the easiest one to explain is Frodo because you're going to use him almost every challenge. And with Froto, he's going to need to collect up the rings. There's five rings cards. He needs to get four of those in a two-player game. I think three of those in a three or four player game. So, you need to make sure that you win tricks that are going to include those cards. Everyone else is going to have something similar. Sometimes it's win not very many tricks. Sometimes it's win a lot. Sometimes it's win certain tricks, but a trick just means a round of cards that you're playing. And it is a cooperative game. So you either all win or lose together. And this does remind me a lot of the crew, which is another cooperative trick-taking game. And what's interesting is it works very similarly at two players as well, where if you're playing at two, you each have your hand of cards, but there's also a bot that has some of the cards visible, and one person controls the bot cards.

And those bot cards are laid out a little bit like duel from Middle Earth, which we were just talking about, where you can see some of them, but then those are going to cover up other cards that are face down. You'll flip those face up once you get to those cards. So, you do have some idea of what's going on. And like you said, this is very much like The Crew. And let's not mince words here. This is pretty much the Crew Lord of the Rings edition. It It really is. It's got a lot of that DNA. There are differences and we'll try not to only say like the crew, unlike the crew, but please forgive us if if if we do that a few times, but unlike the crew, so one of the big differences here is in the crew, if you've played that, what you've got is a whole bunch of different challenges. You're going to spread those challenges around, especially in the second one, you got different levels of challenge. That means how many cards you have, and a bunch of people are going to have just a bunch of different things that they have to do. Win a trick with a six, win a trick with whatever. Let's not talk about that because it's the crew. In this one, what is going to happen instead is everyone starts with one challenge and really has one challenge for the game and that is just your character. So, your character has something your character wants to do.

Those are fairly thematic, but it is just one thing you need to do by the end. Yeah. And it does work through the story as well. So, at the beginning of each challenge, there is a little bit of the story from the books and then the characters that would be involved at that part of the books. But usually there are at least two, if not three mandatory characters that you have to play. So you do have to try and win the game using those specific characters. And then as you make your way along, it does get harder by introducing like a long game. And for a long game, it means you will have to play multiple times and win every time using all of the characters that are part of like that chapter. Yeah. Yeah. So in those earlier games where you just have those two or three car well where you have three or four characters whatever it is there's first of all they're like they drilling right down there's nothing is missed here if if if the fellowship was or not the fellowship at that time but if the hobbits are like walking through a farmer's field you're going to see that farmer you're going to see everyone that they meet along that path and I do like that the those long challenges cuz the short challenges you've only got one thing so that does feel pretty simple but once you get to those long challenges, you've got nine, 10, whatever it is, characters. That means you've got to win, especially with two players. You've got to win like three, four, five games in a row because you've got a choice of deciding whether or not when you lose one of those, you can retry from that point or you retry from

the start of it. Yeah. And Sean feels like with the short games, it's sometimes maybe a little bit on the easy side, particularly at two players because you have access to essentially like two hands. So if we lose the long game, then Sean does make us reset completely. Yeah, I'm a purist just to increase the challenge. Um, but it is interesting having so many characters to choose from. And there are sometimes some little things that get introduced for different chapters to try and like represent the story as well. So maybe you might have on occasion like two challenges you're trying to do or there might be something just a little bit different for a particular chapter. Yeah. Some of them just in introduce other cards that are used for that chapter. And I think you did say and I I really like it that they've got that little story on the front. We always make sure we read the story. It is obviously directly from the book. So why wouldn't you use it if you've got that available? And another thing I like here is that you can you choose your character other than Froto. Whoever gets the one ring, they've got to be Frodo most of the time, but the other people can pick between either the astric characters they have to use or on occasion some other characters based on the cards that they have. And that is nice that you can look at those cards first and then decide who you want to be. Yeah. And what also helps is that a lot of the characters do let you exchange cards. And that's really good because you might be in a position where you have to be a certain character that you don't think you have a chance of winning given your hand. But a simple exchange can like switch the odds. And

if you exchange that also just gives more information to each other about your cards. Yeah. And that is a big thing in this too is that another thing with the crew is that the crew is like no communication. You have to play very you have to play in silence basically. Here they're a little bit more lax with those rules. So the rules are that you can't say anything about the specific cards that are in your hand, but you can say anything that's open information. So you can be like, "Hey, remember my goal. Think about my goal. Everyone think about my goal right now. I am playing a hill card." You can do things like that, which we do a lot, but you can't be like, I've got a three hill. I've got a five forest, whatever it is. And I think that's kind of a nice middle area because I don't love when I can't speak at all in a game. Partly because I'm always speaking, but also partly because I like the social experience of playing games. And so when a game's all the way silent, something a little weird about that for me. So I like that this is like a middle area. Yeah. No, it is good that you can communicate a little bit and it does play into it being a cooperative game is being able to give clues in a way that will help with without having to be specific. So, moving on into how it looks. I like the line drawing style of the characters. I think that works really well. I like that the obscure characters have a face as well, cuz for some of them, I just couldn't picture what they would look like. And now I have this interesting image for those

characters. Yeah, I like that they they do they look very literate. Like they look like they would fit in a book. They certainly they're not just taking the movie characters and just translating those to the card. These look a lot more like kind of the illustrated editions of Lord of the Rings that I've read that I would have read as a kid. And so I like I like that a lot. Also, the box I think it's really it's nice that it's so sleek. It's exactly the size that it needs to be. And they do that with cuz that fits like snug snug snug. But they've got this great little ribbon that you have under the cards that you use to pull up and that pulls up the cards. And that's great both because it helps you to get out the cards so they don't get too stuck in there. You don't have to dump the whole thing over. And it's like a terrific little bookmark that you can use to just show where you are. Yeah, it's great to save your place between chapters. And the package itself is nice, too, cuz it has these little boxes for each part that you open up.

And I I like that it isn't an excessively large box. They also have included these ring tokens that aren't particularly necessary. You're supposed to use them for the characters that you have to use that round. And there is a giant ring token that you can flip once ring cards are able to be played. And it's probably bigger than it needs to be, but it it looks cool. Yeah. And we didn't talk about that part as well. There is a fun thing in here where you can't play any of the ring cards until someone can't play a card and they have to play a ring card and then that kind of opens up to you being able to start with ring cards. And also that the whoever holds the one ring can choose whether or not to win. But to the components, yeah, I like those those little tokens um aren't that necessary, but we use them to denote when someone has finished whatever it is that they need to. And I think that works out really handy that I'm done my thing. I plump a little purple token on top of it. I think that works really well.

Yeah. So, in terms of like who would like this game, if you have played The Crew and you would like a very similar experience, this is exactly that. It is a cooperative trick-taking game. If you haven't played a cooperative trick-taking game, then I think it works for people who like like simple card games but want something that is like cooperative and not cutthroat. Any other kinds of people who would like this kind of game? Well, I think that this is uh quite a bit easier than the crew. We certainly have found it quite a bit easier. And we're almost I think we've got two more levels that we have to finish. So, we're almost all of the way through. And we've had a few mostly those long ones where we've had a little bit of trouble, but it hasn't been too much trouble. That is partly though a twoplayer thing as well. So, I think if you're playing at two players, it is going to be much more on the easy side, especially because you can see that bot, someone has control of two hands. So, you've got a lot of control about what's going on. We've only had one game end because we just mathematically could not finish it because a certain the cards were in a certain order for the bot or something was buried or whatever it was.

So that hasn't happened much. But I think so I do think if you want a little bit of a more challenging game and I think just in general this is really more of a three or four player game. I think that is where this game is going to shine. There's also a solo mode that we have not touched. We haven't played it at all. I can't tell you anything about it. But I will say two-player game we've enjoyed three or four. I think that's more where this is going to shine. And you mentioned that we only have a couple more games left to go. and we looked ahead and once you're done the campaign there is like a forever version you can play and each of the characters are divided into different difficulties and so then it recommends that you take like six of one group and three of another group and then you play a long game having to use those characters. So we haven't got to that point yet, but it is nice that there is something built in for once you're done the campaign. Yeah, and that does look like it's interesting as well. I know that there's some of the cards you don't use at all. those are like specific to the different challenges and some of the characters I believe you don't use as all at all as well. And I'm not positive that it's in difficulty. I just know that it's like these have like a black symbol, these have a gold symbol, these have a white symbol and use so many gold, so many black. It probably has to do with difficulty, but then yeah, you're always playing through the long game. And I think that would probably work pretty well because that's pretty much what you're doing anyway. And so, and I could see it being an interesting challenge of can we beat all of the characters? And that really would be like this big cool marathon where we're going through each

one, especially if we played that we only had one life, but even if we gave ourselves a couple lives, I think I think that would be a fun way to play. Yeah, I could see us definitely doing that. And I do think they've done the Lord of the Rings theme very well. Oh, yeah. This is like steeped in Lord of This is definitely the Lord of the Rings theme is like necessary for this game. Yeah. So, if you are a Lord of the Rings fan, I think you should definitely check it out. It isn't just pasted on. It really is in like the character powers and like how the whole game works and the stories throughout the campaign. And that is it. That is Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings Trick Taking Game as well as Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth. And I feel like that was a 10-minute video just saying those two titles. Have you played either of these games? And what other Lord of the Rings themed games are you excited about right now? Please let us know in the comments. Thank you so much for watching and as usual, please like, subscribe, and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game.

Progress saved