Tend: Hive & Cellar Expansions Review - Cellar Ruined Tend For Us...In The Best Possible Way
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Mack from Board Gameco.
I'm Professor Mac.
And today we are reviewing the 10 expansions. We have Hive and
uh seller.
Seller. We have Hive and Seller. We're going to be diving into a bunch of things today. There's a whole lot to cover and so I'm going to give you the information of what we are covering so you can skip to the relevant timestamps in case you are interested. This is Tend. Tend is a rolling right game from Ivy Studios. I'm going to move these box over here. This is Tend. It's a rolling right game from Ivy Studios. I'll start with obligatory disclaimers. Uh first of all, this is a prototype. All rules and components have to change. I should be more specific. This is a mix of a base game that is a final copy and then expansion components that are a prototype. So all of that stuff rules component.
Everything Hive and Seller is prototype.
Exactly. Also, we'll have a link to caffeine campaign down below. You can go ahead and check that out. Uh and with that the sequence of this video because there's so much to cover. I'm going to do like a 30 secondond overview of Tend. Meg is going to then introduce the new expansions. General overview. It's going to be like again just general stuff, not a deep dive into rules. Uh, Ivy Studios has excellent how to plays if you want to check those out and then from there we'll dive into our um I guess I haven't even talked about the order, but do we want to talk about our thoughts on Tend or or thoughts on the expansions first?
Let's talk about thoughts on Tend. We'll give our brief thoughts on Tend because we have reviewed this in the past in the prototype phase way back when. So, we'll give you our brief thoughts on Tend and then finally we'll give you their thoughts on the expansions before final thoughts. So, there's a lot to cover timestamps to everything down below. So, with that in mind, what is Tend? How does this uh mayhem thing work? In 10, what you're going to be doing is you're going to be going through a sequence of rounds. I think it's 13 rounds. 5 plus 4 plus three. What's the math on that? 12 rounds. 12 rounds, you're going to be going through 12 rounds. In those 12 rounds, each of the rounds, you're going to take two actions. You're going to take actions from these cards over here that start off with their starter mode, but then we'll go through beginner, intro, and advanced cards. Basically have three different phases to the game, seasons. So, you're going to have advanced cards that going to be giving you more and more options as you go. The core options you're going going to be doing in the game are one of four things primarily. You're either going to be tending, which means planting crops.
You're going to be fishing, which means going to a variety of fishing areas on your starting sheet and a bunch of areas you can unlock. Uh then rolling dice to see what you get. You can then go ahead and mine and chop. Mining and chopping are two different actions that will take part on a scratch off sheet where you're going to be slowly scratching your way across various regions in order to find all the various uh more wood adjacent and more stone adjacent. It's chopping and mining, that's what it is, uh goods. And then there's kind of another action like because those are the four actions but then there's also animals. Animals are a little different because they kind of end up happening from all these other things but it is a core aspect of the game. So there's like four actions but then five elements you're kind of interacting with. That's the basic idea of the game. You're going to be planting your animals and crops over here. You're going to be dealing a ton of different things on your sheets. The base game is going to be these two sheets, not what you see over here. And you're trying to go through well everything. You're slowly gathering goods to get badges to fill your cargo manifests to unlock advanced tools. There's a whole lot of things that are happening across those 12 rounds and your goal is to get the most points possible which is usually going to be primarily come from the goals you achieve. Each season has a goal at the end of the season as well as finishing filling your cargo manifest.
That is a very high level overview of what Tend is doing
and a huge chunk of points from your badges that you get.
Badges are a way to go ahead and show how much of an expert you are at certain things. You're like, "Oh, earlier in the game I need wood to build fences. Later in the game I'm going to trade that one in and get a bunch of basic, you know, badges or whatnot. And if you get multiple badges in a row, you get points. So again, this is highle overview stuff, which brings us to the expansions. Meg, what are we doing here?
Yeah, so in Hive, uh, players are going to have different apiaries that they're working with. So you're going to have these different, uh, I forget if they're B die or honey dye, but you're going to have these dice here. And at first, you only have access to one of them. But the number that is rolled, you're going to be able to slot into these different apiaries once you unlock them. So you have to be able to unlock them first, then you're slotting them in. But once you do so, you're creating honey and you're going to be able to spend that honey as a regular good in your caros. You have a cargo pod that's added over here now. But you're also going to have these different upgrades that are going to upgrade your different actions for you. So where some actions were a little bit more basic in the regular game, you're going to have some things that will upgrade it for things like, you know, when you take a chop action, you're going to roll a dieice and get an extra thing. So all of these are going to upgrade your different types of actions. And then you're also going to have investments which are going to help you score better when you're scoring those badges at the end.
That is an overview of Hive. Hive is meant as a single expansion in which you're going to play a single game of tend. I'm going to say why the single game aspect in a minute. And then you just have a new way to interact with a bunch of elements.
Yeah, you're mostly going to be focused on trying to make the honey and then use the honey in different ways.
Yeah, tons of upgrades, investments. The investments is a whole aspect where you're basically multiplying uh different rows over how many badges you got. So, it really leans into more of a bad strategy, but lots of ways you can do things. From there, we have seller. Before we dive into seller, worth noting these expansions are not compatible. You are either playing tend or tend with hive or tend with seller. You are not doing tend with hive and seller, which at first I was very disappointed in. Uh, then I realized it would break your brain.
Yes. So, in seller, you're going to be playing over the course of three games. So, it's going to be a little bit different where uh and Alex, you know this aspect a little bit better, but you're going to be adding cards every Yes. game.
The way both Hive and Seller work is a little bit a small amount of agency in terms of selecting a card that will be in the game, the cards matter because they have things like if you've done X, then you get a bonus. So, it's something that if you know there's a card in play, it gives you the opportunity to work towards it. And so, in Hive, I believe in Hive, you do that as well. Just pick one card at the beginning of the game per player. Uh but then in in seller, you're doing that at the at the beginning of each of the three games. And in seller, before I describe what you're going to be doing, you have this uh overall market saw that you're trying to place these different goods into. And it looks really crazy like a chemistry chart, but basically when you start filling this out at the end of the third game when you're fully scoring, you're going to get points for each row and column that you complete based on, you know, the points that are awarded where some of them don't, but they'll give you a bonus instead. Uh but this is what you're focused on. So that means that throughout the game you're going to have potentially a lower scoring game because you're going to be working on unlocking these things and then getting a huge chunk of points at the end of the third game. So first you're going to have to unlock your equipment which is going to help you make better things. And there's just different equipment for all the different things in the game. And then you also need the expansions to have a place to grow it. So there is this chart here where different things take a certain amount of time where you know milk will take this much time but wine takes a lot longer to you know process but once it hits the end you're going to be able to place it not only in your market stall but you can use it for other things as well such as just putting it in your cargo manifest or if you really need to at the very end you
can turn it into money or something like that. Uh, but yeah, you're going to have to unlock the equipment, unlock the expansions, and then you'll be placing things down here into the stall. And then finally, you're going to have this storage system where you're going to be unlocking things for future games. So, you're really going to be future game focused because you're going to unlock this storage, meaning that you're going to start game two and game three with these bonuses already off the bat. And then on top of that, when you finish each game, you're going to log the different things that you've already slotted into your seller. So if you've already started making something like Manny's, you'll start off with that at the beginning. It'll be in your seller, so it still has to like mature again. But you'll roll over and start games two and three with a lot of stuff, but probably not many points from the game before.
For context, a regular game of 10, you generally score in the range of it's it's a wide range over here, but in the range of I'd say 100 to 300 points is a typical score of 10. I know that it's a big range for typical. Uh in a game of seller, at least in our experience, you certainly can score 100 300, you could ignore the seller aspects and play a regular game. But if you are leaning towards that future aspect, it's not uncommon to score 20 or 30 points in your first game of 10, but then to end the entire three game arc between 600 and,00 points. So like it really boosts your overall score uh above that you can get from three separate games. Mhm.
With that, I think this is time to dive into general thoughts on P.
And you know, just before we move on from seller, just like a little bit of like uh the cuteness of it, like you're pickling, so you're making pickles, you're making wine, you're making cheese, so you're making like very cute things too, you know, in in the spirit of diet.
Mayonnaise. Those eggs that are not that interesting are now mayonnaise. And you have caviar. I think it's caviar. I'm not sure.
But yeah. Uh so thoughts on Tend. And again, keep in mind we've done a full review on Tend in the past. I will say, at least in my end, my thoughts have changed uh since then. What are your general impressions of Tend?
I think Tend is delightful. It's absolutely beautiful. I think that it's paced very well. I think that, you know, everything that escalates, you have to upgrade your equipment for stronger actions. And I find that by the time you're upgrading your equipment, you're ready for those stronger actions. That I think it is a game that cascades really well. Um, I think that Alex might echo my thoughts here that certain actions don't feel as strong as others where something like mining I always want to do. I almost always mine. I find it's very rewarding, but some things like actually tending can be pretty difficult to figure out and how to how to get going. Um, so Hive actually does have those different equipment upgrades to kind of supplement that and it gives you extra actions. I don't know if I should be talking about I was wondering whether she talk.
Um, but yeah, I think overall it's great. It's very well paced. I think it is a game that can last a long time if you have someone who's a bit AP prone, but other than that, um, I think it's very peaceful and fun, and it's a puzzle where you get to figure out what actions you like to do and what kind of things you want to upgrade. We didn't really talk about fishing, but that's also a whole mechanic in the game where you fish in one area and you unlock lures to get better at it. you unlock additional fishing action and you can also fish in new areas once you once you unlock those areas. So, you know, depending on what you enjoy doing, you're just enjoying, you know, playing through the game. Uh yeah.
Yeah. Uh for me, my thoughts on tend have evolved significantly. For context, we actually were not originally going to be covering Seller and Hive partially because uh Ivy Studios reached out and said, "Hey, I know you're more mid on Tend. I assume you don't want to cover the new expansions." And I was like, "You know what? Let me dive back into it." I didn't know this at all.
You didn't know this?
Oh, no. They reached out. They're like, "Do you want to cover the expansionist?" You didn't cuz my original rating for 10, my original rating was a 3.5 out of five. I I both really liked the premise of what I was trying to do. Uh, but also I felt like I never really got I I felt every single time I played it, I wanted to do more than I was able to do. And for context, I don't remember for sure exactly how many plays I had. I believe I had played it around four to five times at that point, like enough to like get at least a few plays and experience in, but I hadn't really captured the the full experience. And I was, again, I if you watch my result review, I'm like I always want to be able to do more. For right now, it's a 3.5 out of five, but I want to experience it more. That's where where things left off. Uh, I had a copy of the final game. I had not played it. When Ivy Studios reached out, I was like, you know what? Let me try it. Uh, you know, let me let me just dive back into it. Before we even get to the expansions, before we even talk about the expansion plays we've had, cuz we've had a lot of plays. Uh, Tend on its own was played, I want to say like 10 to 15 times since like I was like, "Let me dive into it." And then just continuously playing it, playing it both groups or solo. I have a solo playthrough on the channel, but I played it multiple times solo. I played it multiple times at two players, at three players, I think primarily those player counts. I played a lot of 10 and I went from like that aspect of wanting more out of it to thoroughly enjoying the system. It there was I always liked the potential and I always felt like I couldn't get enough done and I don't know if it's just more plays or more familiar with the system or maybe just stopping trying to tend. That is a criticism I'll have definitely. But I really enjoy what it's doing. It's a ton of cascading options. It starts off very slow. Every game starts off with how how am I going to get everything done. But at this point at least, again, I can't
say I was there the first three to four plays, but at this point, I have that engine going. I have that sense of like I'm really able to get as much done as I want in the game. I'm really able to get my engine flowing. I'm able to try different strategies, leaning more into badges, leaning more into mining and chopping. I I get to do so much in this game and I I I love it. I would say my rating say something. Well, so I actually think a key to it that I didn't really touch on that I don't think we've like emphasized enough is that the season cards that come out, these task cards, you have your starter ones that are the basic actions, but these ones have certain requirements and then you get the bonus. And I think a key to really understanding tend and chaining really well is trying to meet those and understanding that those cards are going to come back out. So the sooner you meet the conditions that it needs, the more bonuses you'll get from that. that I really think that was especially with seller because you start being able to have
I'm talking about seller but some of it's that
I do think that that gives you a lot of cascading effects if you can do the things those cards want you to do.
Some of it's also something that's trying to do too much. If you try to upgrade too many tools and try to focus on too many areas, it means you're investing a lot into potential and not into actual. Whatever the aspects are, there's a lot to it. There's a lot to to learn and appreciate. Uh but I would say I at this point I love what the game is doing. Uh but not without criticisms. My main two criticisms for the game, at least the base game, are going to be one is even after all the plays I have, I still feel like leaning fully into tend, it feels like the least satisfying. The game's called Tend, but leaning into the tend action of growing crops continuously feels like the least satisfying way to play. It continuously seems to be the way players, whenever I play with any players, it seems to be the one players are least driven to. I hesitate to use the word balance about anything that I've played, you know, 20 times and has been played hundreds and hundreds of times, but I would say that 10 just feels like the least balanced option. It feels like you have to put the most work into it. And the only way like the experience cuz I've tried I've tried really hard to break tend uh not the game, the mechanic. And the problem is the only way to get the most out of it in my experience is to really lean heavily into it. So you're doing almost exclusively tending so you can constantly rotate up these large batches of crops, which works to a point, but then you get to a point where they're useless in your car manifest. So even that doesn't work. So you can't really partially go into it because it's not as balanced to the other actions perceptually speaking. And if you fully lean into it, then you end up getting to a point where you can't benefit because you have too much of that one crop. The game rewards diversification. We haven't talked about that a lot. So tend as an action I feel like is something I dabble in as opposed to really leaning into it.
The other criticism I have, and this is like more of a minor one, doesn't affect my experience in the game, is that I feel that there are so many questions as far as rules and sequencing, as far as can you do this, then that, what if you get this, what if you unlock those actions, can you use these energy bars in this case, almost every single thing, by the way, I can find the answer to in one way or another. Whether it's a forum post, whether it's really digging through the rule book, I do find the rule book to not be well structured for these kinds of questions. Like I have, again, every single thing I think can be answered, possibly even within the rule book. It's just that I I don't find it intuitive at all. I find I'm frequently flipping through at this point less so at this point I have them all all hashed out. Uh but it's something that I've definitely experienced and I want to make sure I don't gloss over that. Uh final thoughts by the way on 10 the base game. I we haven't even talked this. My original rating was a 3.5 out of five. My revised rating of 10 the base game is a 4.5 out of five. I love what the game is doing with a few minor criticisms. Do you have a rating by the way?
I will echo that. I don't remember my original rating or if I gave one. This might have been one that I said I needed more time. I don't remember. But I would give it a 4.5.
Cool. Which brings us to expansions. Expansions. Do you want to give your
thoughts? My one small nitpick because I I agree with like the 10 thing, but to me the trellis one actually is fun to do sometimes.
It's fun, but like
uh it's very pretty. Uh and so but my small thing, which is another thing that we have talked about, is the fishing.
Oh yes. No, I forgot. You're right. Fishing. Oh my gosh. And it just feels I wish you even got a stone. If you got a stone for the empty fishing spots because like that it feels thematic. I don't know.
Fishing is the only action. And I'll
got like garbage or something out of it or something.
Fishing is the only action in the game that you can get nothing. Not you can get not what you wanted. You can get nothing.
Literally nothing from the action
to the extent. And and this is something we have to figure out what we're doing in our playthrough because we're going to be doing a full playthrough of the entire seller campaign. So you're going to see three playthroughs on the channel. Uh it's game one, game two, and game three. We have to discuss internally what we're going to do about this because uh my own house will for the table when I'm playing is if it's early game and late game is a different conversation. You maybe you got a lure, maybe you didn't. You have there's ways to b to mitigate against this. But early game fishing is either an action you don't take because you could possibly get bad luck or you take it and just hope you don't get bad luck. To mitigate that in our group, we've mostly said if you roll a blank and it's early game, let's say season one, you roll a blank, just reroll it. Like you you get something. You get something no matter what. That is not the way the game is meant to be played. That's the way the game is more fun for us.
What's up?
And I don't mind that.
Yeah. Cool. Which brings us to the expansions. Expansions.
Feel free to use that home rule in your own games.
Yeah, please do. In fact, message I studio and see their games.
In my opinion, I think that pond fishing the blank spaces should give you a stone.
Yeah. No, I'd be fine with that
because if you unlock the others, clearly you're going into fishing, so you're you're on your own. But if it's specifically pond fishing,
you get a stone for the blank.
You know what would be even better? I would be totally honest. Perfect.
No. No. Really? Wait, wait till this. What if whenever you went pond fishing, if you rolled a blank, you pick any one of these to mark off?
That's like I That's
broken bridge. Broken bridge unlocks the river.
I think getting the bronze is really good.
Yeah. Yeah. If you roll blank early game, at least you feel rewarded for it.
Okay,
I'm down for We're going to talk about it. We're going to talk about it.
I'll take it.
It feels like it feels thematic. You're working your way towards getting an experienced fisher. Whatever.
Expansion time. Expansions. So, let's start with Hive first. Uh for Hive, do you want to give your thoughts first or should I? for Hive. I think that it's one that again, I feel like I This is what I said the first time I played Tend, but I do feel like I need more plays. And I think that where Alex and I are going to differ is that I want to play it more. I want to play more.
I want to play more.
Okay. Um I at first wasn't blown away by it. And then the after playing it more, I found that the cascading actions, it's a game. time is one that specifically it's like you're on a roller coaster where when you start hitting around here in the order or the turns, that's when you're going to start getting these extra actions where you're going to roll a dieice and get these extra things and then be able to tick stuff up. And once these things are unlocked, you have such strong turns toward the end of the game that it is a different game. It's a different game and you have to approach it differently and think about it differently that I know the last time I approached it I would have done things differently have you know so that's that's my thought
yeah where I am with hive I think we're in a very similar place where I am with hive is it's the exact feeling that I had when I first played Tend meaning my review of Tend is kind of where I am with Hive right now where it's like okay I've played it a few times I feel like I'm starting to uncover how it all comes together but I I like right now if I didn't know that that 10 had progressed, I think I wouldn't play Hive. I'd play more tend or more seller. Uh, but Hive is at that point where I'm just starting to get more out of the system that I think I just need a few more plays to really unlock it. Although, even then, I have possible criticisms because perceptionally at least from the few plays I've had, I feel the best way to play Hive is to fully lean into one equipment type, like get all the mining upgrades or get all of the fishing upgrades because they all reward you for doing the thing you're already doing. And so, getting three times rewarded for doing that thing is just so strong. And so, you really want to lean into that.
The other aspects is the uh the various apiaries over here. These are all going to give you tons of different honey. You need to get them early on. Like you need to get them early for them to have an effect. I still for the life of me cannot like I have not unlock the purple apiary at all in any game. I I do want to get that to happen but I'm not
because you don't tend
I'm not confident. I mean no no I still tend at this point. I'm not confident enough that the purple apiary is worth pursuing that early unlock because you can get that purple honey from unlocking the rose in the the hive manifest the hive module. And so like I'm not I'm not quite convinced yet. Again, keep in mind, few plays versus the play testing that goes into the game. But like Hive is at the point where I'm both enamored with it and frustrated with it at the same time. I will say I love the idea of the investment track. Uh this kind of track over here, the investments you have. Uh the fact that you can uh basically kind of slowly unlock multiples to the various badges you have. It really leans and incentivizes into exploring badges, which something I kind of do peripherally, but the idea of really leaning into that as a as a concept for scoring. Love the idea. All of the ideas of Hive all fall in the category of I love what it's trying to do and I feel um closer and closer to breaking it
in a good way.
Yeah. And it really does just all feed into itself. I was saying those turns will get longer that you'll start rolling a die and gaining these and then you can just start dumping them straight into here. That's the point where it'll just all start feeding into itself.
Yeah. The the specific top equipment on tending, by the way, for those of you who know the game, is going to be the idea that once you unlock the compost bin, when you have a tend crop, you go ahead and by the way, this I'm still upset at this. Uh you go ahead and you roll it, and assuming you don't get a blank, you replant the crop, which is great in theory, but once again, you're still luck of the draw over here. So, you've taken 10 and you've said, "We've made you as good as animals now, or sort of arguably better because you can tick them up, but the other options all involve ticking up a plant or a crop." So, like even with this, and again, I'm not I'm not willing to double down on this. I will say I did one of at least one of my games of Hive, I did fully lean into planting, hoping that would work. Uh, but I'm not convinced that this makes uh tending a viable strategy relative to other strategies based on my very limited plays uh relative to play testing hopefully. So, overall, my thoughts on on on Hive right now is it's kind of the same place I was with. For me, final thoughts on Hive are it's a 3.5 out of five. I want to with a difference with a big caveat. It's a 3.5 out of five with the big caveat that unlike when I reviewed 10 I and I wasn't sure if that would happen. Now I'm kind of like knowing my experience so far, I think a few more plays will really bump it up. So as opposed to where where when I originally reviewed 10, I gave it a 3.5 out of five. Unsure where that would go. Uh versus now my current opinion of Hive is it's a 3.5 out of five. And I'm very optimistic that will bump up, but we'll see.
And you? I for me, Hive I I kind I feel like this is almost like what I said with Tent that I kind of want to wait to read it, but I'm just gonna be crazy and say I would give it a 4.5.
Really,
the way my final the most recent game that I played
Yeah.
The way my most recent game went,
having known how it was going to end with everything I was unlocking and and crescendoing, crescendoing, whatever, um I would have played it differently from the beginning. And it just makes me want to that I think you can do. So I think it's like it's a it's almost more powerful than seller. And in seller you can start off with so much stuff that with this the way it felt at the end I I wish I could have planned it better from the beginning. Um so yeah I I'm very interested in it. But I do agree with the purple criticism that for there's two rows that you can unlock the purple honey here and there's really not many places to do it because you might as well do a beekeeper with these two and then so really you're only putting it here or like in your manifest or I guess like here for that one.
It's also not meaningfully better than red either. It just feels harder to get to. Like I've unlocked red. I've unlocked blue
and if you can get a few here.
Yeah, I'm not quite I'm not quite convinced. Maybe it should go back to the tending. Maybe you're right. Maybe it is tending. No, they just hate the color purple.
That brings us to seller. Seller as an expansion. Um, again, do you want to go first? Second.
I have a lot to say.
You go first.
Okay. I love seller. I I adore seller. Seller has made us that playing tend honestly. The the the only reason I'm not 100% convinced I want to go out and play high four more times to break it. Uh, and by break it, I mean like just to to gro it, to understand it fully, is because every play of Hive could be a third of a game of seller. And I would rather play seller. If that said, I already have plans to play Hive again, like even this Friday. Longer story. I I have I have multiple games of 10 lined up in my future. Uh but seller is
multiple games.
Seller is so much fun. Uh for context, we've already played three arcs of seller. That's, you know, an arc of seller is three games. We've already played three arcs. We are planning to do a full module, a full filmed arc of seller. That's going to be arc number four. In addition to that, we're about to go to Dice Star Retreat where we're planning to play another full arc of seller. That's 15 games of Cellar at this point. That is a lot of games of seller and I am I am into I'm I'm into what seller is doing. The main thing about seller for me is it does several things that I really enjoy. The first is that it really gives a much stronger like by the time you dive into the game two because of the fact that you have all these storage modules over here, you can basically start off game two with most of what you need to unlock a piece of equipment. That's insane. Imagine starting a game of 10 one good roll away from getting a pickaxe. That's on turn two you have a pickaxe. That's crazy.
Imagine starting a game of 10 and you can dump all your saved resources from game one directly into a bunch of fences so that again by turn two you have a cow up and running. That's insane.
Turn one you can have a pickaxe.
Can you
because you could have enough purple badge?
Yeah, you could have enough money to pay for that.
Can you I haven't tried this turn one pickaxe
fully done
maybe. I haven't tried purple turn one pickaxe would be insane. Uh again, so that's a purple pick and I mean you can also do it longer story. There's ways to do it over here by earning something in the marketplace and leaning to those. There's you can have early game stuff that you can never you can only ever dream of intend and then you're doing this where so you literally for me every time I play seller it's mostly just investing for the future in game one it's setting myself up so I have as many things as possible and then how I spend the rest of game two and three that's where I try to branch out and diversify different strategies because it comes down to are you going for the points game to game or are you primarily going for your market stall over here trying to fill this as much as possible with basically everything you can under the sun getting the rows and columns and all the points that are going to come from it. Uh but ultimately there's several things. First of all, you got to dive into multiple games in subsequent games with unlocked stuff. That's so much fun.
It feels like you have a much stronger game of 10, but then also the nature. This is where they have made
and the other stuff you start off with. You'll start off with the goods if you haven't gotten them. So you'll start off with that as well.
The other thing for me is the nature of the market stall over here and how it wants different goods is this does heavily incentivize you to have you exploring different options. It's still this game has you almost I don't I hesitate hesitate to use the word necessary but it feels necessary to explore tending. So even though tend on its own is relatively speaking weaker than other things because of the way it allows you to complete your market stall it now feels like it is now an essential aspect that at least one of your three games possibly more you're going to want to heavily lean into that. And so I still feel like it feels weaker on its own but it feels like a necessary part of your whole strategy. Those of you who have played a Gricola are going to know that aspect of you feel like you need to be balanced. It does feel like you need to be a little bit more balanced. Not necessarily everything, but you need to be a bit more flexible as far as the ways you approach different things game to game. To me, seller feels like a complete arc of playing tend where you get to explore so many different facets of the game. Score game to game, have your seller sheet carry through, and it is the most rewarding way to play 10 to the point that anything that's not seller right now feels like a filler game. It's a granted an hour and a half long filler game, but a filler game uh towards what I want the ideal tend experience to be.
Yeah, seller man, it has consumed my life. It is it is unfair what it has done to me because all of the other games that deserve to be played are now on the back burner. Uh I I had so much fun doing this. It's everything that Alex said. You're building this engine for yourself. So, you do have three games, which feels like so much to get so much done, but even by the time that you're hitting the last game, you're like, I wish I had a few more turns. I wish I could do just a little bit more. Um, but you you definitely have this pacing where you're focusing on the future, especially in your first game, that you have to set yourself up. So, it's a very different game that you're playing even from the beginning. and the different things that you unlock. The equipment is so important that you can unlock things like the way to create wine, which is with the special craft on the trellis.
And even if you just make wine in the first or second game, there are cards that are going to come out that are for the expansion. I think they're specifically for the expansion. Yeah, that are Oh, yeah. Because they'll say like a market soul and stuff.
So, the cards that are for the different seasons are going to reward you for the equipment that you've unlocked. So even if you were making wine in game one, even in game three, you might be able to make like one or two wine because those are going to come out as a reward. So there's so much that chains and works together really well. Uh but this particular market stall, it's really something that the more you play, the more you'll get a better handle on it because it's really pointless if you pay into things that are never going to score for you. So that means that it's a lot more important for you to be putting it in your cargo manifest if you know that it's not in an intersection that's going to be helpful, but that's future planning that like is going to require you making decisions like I'm not going to make that many pickles and I'm just going to decide not to. So I'm going to, you know, not place things here or there. And it really is a balance of points now and points later. And how you
every game I've played has had at least a few goods that were just a waste. I worked towards something that I didn't get. Fortunately, every game has been little enough that I didn't feel too much pain, but just a little pain.
And like here are those the I guess you should we do this way. Here's all of our little bits. I just hold up this camera. Try this one.
Here we go. Our nice little bits. We got our wine here.
So, you know, it's just it's a very good time. And I'm going to see if Alex is going to be editing Alex. But I have a photo that may or may not end up here. But I decided to use like colored pens to color in all of the different boxes. and you can see the progression game over game that you can see what you focus on and how it builds out and like what you can grow that I don't know it's just it's a delight of a time.
Yeah. For me, final thoughts on seller is seller has elevated 10 to a five out of five experience for me. I I absolutely adore what it's doing. I have played this so much. I am excited to play it more. I will be playing it more. Uh, in fact, on one of the things about like I have on the channel a format called a 12 x 12 review where I basically play a game in all its formats, solo, all player accounts, different ways. Uh, I debated calling this a 12 x 12 review. The only reason I didn't is because uh it's a prototype still, so I'm hesitant on that. And honestly, I want to explore Hive more before I get there. So, I do plan on doing a 12 x 12 review when it eventually comes out because Lord knows uh again, if you count seller and regular 10, I have like 30 plus plays of this under my belt this month with another 10 or so coming. Uh, so like that's like in the past month and a half, maybe two months, like 40 plays often. It is it is not healthy.
Yeah. I would say my one negative thing about seller is that it is not a good social game. It is very thinky. It's very AP. You're going to be getting all these cascading things and so many bonuses that it is kind of hard to keep in your mind with the different things that are going on. So, you know, it's not one that's it's definitely satisfying, but you're going to be in your own puzzle. So, it's not one that you're going to be like having a conversation, you know, over the game with or anything like that. There's not much downtime because you're waiting for whoever to finish their turn and then once that's done, you're going to be rolling in into the next turn. So, that is my only thing is that it is so satisfying, but it is a lot.
The end of the game, specifically the end, the last like two or three turns, if someone tries talking to you while you're in the middle of chaining everything and holding on stuff in your head, it it is you like pause for a second, then you go back and you're like, I know I had I know I was spending these resources.
I know I got something. I'm pretty sure I was fishing somewhere. Like it's crazy.
Anyways, that is basically a review of Tend the Hive expansion, the seller expansion with that recommendation. Yes.
No, no, sorry. Were you rating seller?
Oh, seller is a five out of five, I said.
Oh,
I love seller.
I didn't rate seller, I don't think yet. But I'm going to give it a
six out of five.
I was just going to say I'm going to give it a board game coat first on the channel. I'm going to give it a 5.5.
Interesting. One time in my life I gave something a five plus.
Yeah. 5.5.
Yeah. Yeah. It happens. Anyways, uh 5.5 out of five for me. A Does that make this
never before seen on the channel?
If I Studios is too late, obviously it's not going to have this delivered because when we do our top 100 of the year, you can't put seller in there. Maybe you could put 10 in there. Plus seller.
Yeah. 10.
We'll figure it out.
We'll figure it out. But I will Yeah, I'll
We'll see. We'll see.
But there's a potential other 5.5 coming out this year.
Is there? Yeah.
Anyways, with that, uh, if you're looking for other game recommendations, uh, you want to go first, are we?
Yeah. Check out Three Sisters. It's going to give you a very similar thinky feel where you're growing different crops that are very like charming and cute. Uh, but it is a much smaller game. So, it's more of like an intro to something of this genre.
And I was going to say check out Hrien's Wall. Uh, if you're looking for a game that gives you that much going on as far as the intricate uh, roll and right experience, or not really roll and write, but flip and right experience. I think Hadrien's Wall is the only game that kind of captures the same level of of stuff that's happening. Uh the one thing I'll say is my opinion of Hadrien's Wall was actually the reverse of Pend. Pend started off like here and grew to here. Grew, pun intended. Pun not intended. Uh Hrien's wall started off super high. The more I played it, the more I found that the early game was almost too structured that it took a while, but 20 30 plays in I was like, I think I've seen enough over here. Not to derail us, but you know what gives me a similar feel of so many things cascading? Twilight Inscription.
Oh, we should play that again.
That is a good game.
That's been a while. Yeah.
Maybe it's a Dire Retreat.
Maybe. Anyways, with that, until next time, I'm Alex from Board Gameco.
I'm Professor Mag.
And as always, I hope you have a good one.
Bye.