Container Review: Cargo Ship? No, Car Go Road
Transcript
Hi everyone. Welcome back to the Dice Tower. My name is Chris Yee.
And I'm Wendy.
Today we're taking a look at Container. This is a new printing of it. This is designed by Kevin Nesbitt, uh Franz Benno Delong, and Thomas Ewert here. Uh art by Adam Allsuch Boardman. I'm not sure if that's a pseudonym or just a really awesome name that for the board game industry.
And published by All Play. And just as a as a heads-up, All Play is a sponsor of our channel. However, we're going to do our best to review this how we actually feel on the game.
Yep. Always try to. Uh this is a big old economic game. Uh it has been around since 2007. So, it's almost 20 years old. Uh it's had two different prior printings, and now this is a third one from All Play. This is the first edition that I've that either of us have played.
It has. In fact, I didn't realize this game was so old until I was looking into it a little bit more cuz I just remember the 10th anniversary giant edition.
Yep.
Mhm.
Which has been in the Dice Tower library. I just haven't played it cuz giant.
Giant.
So, anyway, I'm going to give you an overview of how this game plays, and then we'll come back and we'll give you our thoughts. Here's an example of a three-player game of Container on the table partway through gameplay, so you can see what's going on here. Each player has their own little area representing their factories and their harbor. There is also a central island over here called Container Island where they live happily forever. Uh and also, if you take containers into your player area over there, they'll provide you end game scoring value according to a private randomized scoring goal card that you have. The point of the game is to deliver things here to get the most money value out of them and to have the most liquid cash on you. Uh you combine up those two things, and whoever has the most money and money equivalents is going to be the winner of the game. You'll also notice that there's this board over here on the side. This is the offshore island, which was an expansion module in one of the previous editions of the game, the the anniversary edition. It is now just incorporated into the basic rules of the game, though you can play the classic mode, the rules on the back show you how to play without this. The structure of the game is as follows. On your turn, you will follow steps 1, 2, and 3. First off, if you have any loans, you have to pay $1 of interest. Loans are a free action that you can take any time to get $10, and then you have to pay $1 at the top of every one of your turns. Uh that is the first step. Next up, if you have an outstanding auction going on over here in one of these two areas for money or for containers, you will win it if you still control it and no one has outbid
you on their turn. We'll worry about more of that later. And then lastly, you'll take two actions. Every action in this game is repeatable. You can choose to do the build action twice on a turn, or you can choose to do a build and a sale action, or anything like so. The first action here shown is build. You have factories on the left that you can build and warehouses on the right. If you choose to spend the money, if I paid $12 from the money out of my hand, I could build a factory of a different color than I already have, and now I could produce white containers. If I produce or if I build warehouses over here, then I can hold more containers in my harbor area. Factories allow me to produce and hold more in my factory area on the bottom of my board.
The next action is to produce. So, speaking of these factories, to produce, I spend a dollar to my player clock or to my right, and then each of my factories will produce one container of their color. At this point, I can price these however I would like. Uh and so, I can put as many into any single slot here. And you notice that these prices are facing away from me, and that's on purpose because other players can purchase from my board. I can never mess with anything on my own board for my own benefit. So, the next action is the purchases, Factory purchases and harbor purchases. So, if a player wanted to on their turn provide one of a take one of the containers that I've produced in my factory area and place it into their harbor area, they could purchase from me and likewise I on my turn can purchase from their factory area and place it into my harbor. So, I could spend $3, for example, to this player over here. I give them this and I take this container and I'll place it into one of my harbor spaces. I've now priced this at $4. So, if anyone else comes to do a harbor purchase action from me, meaning they move their boat over and would like to purchase more of these crates on their turn, they will pay me $4 per per crate per container and they'll load it onto their boat.
So, that's the factory purchase and the harbor purchase. Now, the sailing action operates just like in real life. You are either in a harbor spot or you are in the ocean and the ocean is connected to every other harbor spot. So, as one sailing action, you can sail into the ocean and for a second sailing action from the ocean, you can go to any harbor in the world just like in real life. If if you move into someone's into if you move into someone's port, you can immediately do a harbor purchase action. And if you move over to this area container island, you will immediately cause a sale or an auction and we'll worry about that here momentarily. Another action you can choose to do as one of your two actions in your turn, you realize you've priced things poorly, you can spend an entire action just to move these goods around into different pricing spots. You can do that in your factory. You can also choose to do that in your harbor if you want.
The last thing you can do is to call an auction. You can spend containers from your board in either spot onto this board here and you'll claim an auction for one of these pools of money where the loans, the debts, and stuff are being paid off into an increasing pool over here. Or you can call an auction with money for one of the container spots over here so that you can gain more of those containers, which will go over here to this little spot on the offshore island. On another player's turn, they can choose to outbid you, outbid number of crates, or outbid number of dollars to try to take that from you. And you can only be involved in one auction at a time. So, now that we've explained all of the actions, let's talk about one of the biggest parts of the game, which is when someone sails into Container Island and triggers an auction. At this point, all players are going to take their face uh their secret money and they're going to place a bid face down.
I'll put in this money. This player puts in this money. Uh sorry, this is actually the teal player. So, this player over here is going to be auctioning. All the non- involved players, all the people who don't own the ship that has now entered Container Island are going to auction a face-down pool of money. They'll reveal. So, I bid $8 and this player only bid four. So, the teal player whose ship moved here to Container Island is going to take my $8 plus what's called a government subsidy of another $8 from the bank and they're going to earn all that money and then I, as the winner of the auction, am going to move all of these crates into my scoring plot of Container Island. Now, this player over here, if they so chose, could instead of accepting my $8, could say they would like to pay $8 out of their bank. They're rejecting the government subsidy and they would like to take all of these into their own scoring zone instead of accepting my bid.
So, players will continue to do this uh auctioning things off here, gaining containers, shipping, sailing around, buying from factory to harbor, from harbor onto ships, and from ships into Container Island, and then hosting auctions, getting money, so on and so forth. There are different ways that you can win by simply having a lot of money in hand, or by getting a lot of shipping containers over here. But, an important thing to note is that at the end of the game, when players go to score up their value of all their containers on Container Island, they will first have to get rid of a the container that they have the most of, the single color they have the most of. So, for example, I would have to get rid of these blues here, and then I can score my remaining value. This player would get rid of the white. This player would get rid of the yellow. You then score up all of your remaining value, plus whatever money you have left in hand, and whoever has the most is the winner of Container.
So, I thought this was kind of a strange pick up for All Play. Now, as Wendy mentioned, All Play is a sponsor of the channel. We've reviewed plenty of the games negatively, plenty of them positively. We always say what we mean about them. My first and foremost thought was, "What a weird game." That doesn't feel like anything else in their catalog. This cold, dry, hard economic simulation-y kind of a game.
Sure. Sure.
Um one of the concerns with that is, "Will it fit in the box?" And shockingly, this is a little bit wider of a box, but yes, it actually packs away very neatly. I think the production is actually one of the strong standout points for this game.
Sure, especially if you compare it to the 10th Anniversary Edition, which is the only one that I know, which is ginormous. I was really surprised when this fit into such a small box.
It It fit well, a lot of good production decisions. Not No part of it is like physically fiddly. It spreads on the table, for sure, but just little things like the relevant information is very easy to parse. How much is next factory cost? The amount shown on the the square where you build that factory. The pricing facing away from you is like odd to see at first, but you realize, "Oh, I can only purchase from other players." Their costs, like their pricing faces towards me, the buyer. It's it's it's I think it's really well laid out.
Yeah, I think that that is a very clever change that they made that that facing is different. I think that that helps the rules make more sense. Um so I hadn't learned the 10th anniversary edition or any of the past editions, right? I've only played this one. Um but learning it I thought the rules themselves, especially with the way everything's laid out, made a lot of sense. I didn't find it difficult to learn, whereas um I was very intimidated by previous versions of this game thinking it would be so difficult to get to the table, so difficult to, you know, just learn and figure out.
And and like action-wise, what do you do on your turn? You can sail, you can buy a thing, or you can buy a thing, or you can buy a thing. I was like, "Oh, this is this is kind of it." Uh it's an odd choice that that um offshore island thing is actually an expansion module from the 10th anniversary edition that's been folded in, and that's like the basic game, and you can choose to play with or without it. Um but I do really appreciate that in the rules, the back of the they explain, "This is why we've included it as like the baseline. They it prevents the game from locking up at some point." And so I think that they did a good job of also explaining why it why introduce the part of the game that I think is the least straightforward and honestly the most intimidating, yeah, oh it's worth the extra, you know, uh cost of complexity sure in the mind of the publisher, and I respect that.
Yeah, and I think I think that part of it was true, the most complex, um but I think it really adds some dynamic to the game, which the whole thing about this game is the dynamics of figuring out what people are willing to spend and not willing to spend, right? And so, just straight off the bat, that is something that stresses me. I love my Euro games where you tell me that this is $2 and it will always be $2. Heck, if you want to tell me that there is a card that's going to make it somewhere between two and $4, I'm even okay with that. Flip over the card, tell me whether it's two to $4. But, for some reason, if one game I could play and everyone's like "No, we're selling for one or $2." And then you play another game and "No, everyone's selling for four or $5." I don't understand, Chris.
I don't understand.
It's It's
my brain.
I love player-driven pricing as a mechanism Castle Ludwig does that. Yeah, Isle of Skye does that. This game is almost nothing but that and it's very hard to grok on your first, you know, play or two to say like why would I price this at $5? No one's going to buy it. When is it worth pricing at five or six dollars? I have played this a few times and I've still not really seen like Aha, this is the time when I cleverly price it at $6. No, someone else is going to just make the thing and price it at four and get your sale from you.
Well, and then everybody is going for different amounts of crates, but it depends on whether or not it's the most or the not the most at the end that they have. Like, the the seen through people and trying to realize that Chris is going to spend a lot of money on yellow. Like, a lot of money on yellow. But, not if he has more yellow than red, you know? Like, those kind of things to parse out and to read while you're doing all this bidding. I'm sure people that are much smarter than me um can figure that out, but I cannot.
Yeah, it's it's in The game I would describe it as circuitous in a lot of ways, right?
word. You have to define that for me.
It there's no straightforward path. I want to produce a red container and then sell it and bring it to Container Island and I want that red container. That's not allowed. That's called a vertical monopoly.
Yeah.
Uh and so it's an interest it's interesting how it simulates things, but it's also very obtuse at first where I I my factories produce it. I'm hoping that you buy it. Why? So that someone else will ship it so that I can auction for it and put it on my scoring spot at the end of the game.
Yeah.
There's no kind of straightforward path. Maybe the closest straightforward path is when you uh trigger one of those auctions on the side and you're like, "Perfect. I'm going to get two blue and a yellow container." Except when I ship it, it's really difficult for you to buy your own shipment.
Mhm.
It gets incredibly rare and oftentimes a bad strategic move. Guess how I found that out.
It's an expensive move for sure. For sure. I think the other thing that is not sur- circuitous? What is that word you used?
Circuitous.
Circuitous. Um is how to get money in this game, right? You need to price things so that people are willing to buy them. So if you're someone who's doing heavy factories and you're producing a lot of goods, you're like, "Well, I want to produce a lot, but also if I produce them too cheap, I'm not getting enough money influx to bid on things later, but I also need to price them low enough that people will buy them." And so it's like that forever back and forth and I feel like every single step of this game and every single step of that uh creation to selling process of the goods has that moment to it, you know, that that tension and that struggle of how do I make money, which is so realistic. And I think that that is such a key to this game. The people that will love this game are the people that want to have that real economic like real life feeling behind it. Um and I just don't think that's me.
I think a comparison you made maybe after we played it the first time he was like this kind of feels almost like a splatter game.
Yeah.
It has that idea of like oh you made a bad move you would have just lost. But there's another hour and a half of the game left.
Yeah, sorry.
Oops.
Chris built the yellow factory then you built a yellow factory. That was dumb.
Yeah, except for when it's not. You know, it's and it's so it's hard to tell exactly when that is. But yeah, the game gives you plenty of rope hang yourself if you want to with it. You know, and and that's a strength that is going to separate this from so many other games for people and for me it means that some games of it are very fun and other games of it are less fun.
Sure. So coming in we good with wrap up final scores?
I think so.
Okay, so coming in for me I'm going to come in at a six. I think that this game is fine when it comes to something that I'm going to recommend or pull off the shelf and play myself. If someone else wanted to play this and they were excited to play this I would play it again. But I'm never going to reach out and be like hey do you want to play container Chris? This is not going to be my jam. But I recognize that there's so much good design work in this for the style of game that this is and I 100% recognize why people love it and why it fits their taste like so perfectly. But it's just not quite for me.
I am coming in at a seven. Which means that I enjoy this cuz player driven pricing is one of my favorite mechanisms. So a game that does almost nothing but that should be like one of my favorites, right? I really enjoy how smooth and simple the sailing actions are. You sail into someone's port you can immediately purchase from them. That's cool. The game is also pretty heavy-handed in certain areas like to build off of something you said, you know, it's not very easy to make money in this game. It's not really apparent. Well, there is a very easy way. It's called taking a loan.
And then you are going to feel
a lot of that in this game.
You're going to feel in debt for a while, right? So, if you don't like those feelings, I don't think you're going to like this game, right? Uh that being said, I it it's an interesting puzzle. It's something that, you know, trying to read the other players and trying to work towards a situation. But that's a little heavy-handed. The fact that on your container island lot, you have to lose at the end of the game the container that you have the most of that color, it once it's a little heavy-handed on this way of like get a lot of containers, but not the ones you actually want, the ones you don't want. Why? Because game mechanism balances that way.
I don't understand the theme how that fits in thematically, cuz I feel like this game is oddly very thematic.
I think overabundance, right? Like market saturation. It's too saturated.
too much.
People have too much yellow. Can't have too much yellow out there.
But other people don't have too much yellow and their yellow's just fine.
I don't know. And that's what I mean, right? I should love this game and instead I like it. I think that it's a very clever game that is sometimes more clever than fun, but when it's fun, man, it's fun. So, I'm coming in at seven. I'm recommending this one kind of with those caveats. You got to enjoy a game that's a little bit cruel sometimes. So, there you go. That's our thoughts on Container. This is a nice new edition if you've enjoyed it, but never been able to get one. It's more available than ever before. And if all of this sounds terrible, then maybe don't get it.
That's fair. That's fair.
So, there you go. Thanks for coming out to this review on the Dice Tower. My name is Chris Yee.
I'm Wendy Yee.
Go ahead and have yourselves a shiptastic day. Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, you want to learn more about us, communicate with us?
We have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. You can find that in our link tree link below. So, just click that and it will take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook. Join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Vasel.
Many murdering muskrats.
Many murdering muskrats. Many murdering muskrats. Many murdering muskrats.
This is what it takes to get ready for a Dice Tower review.
Got it. I can say all my M's now.
Riboflavin.
Guess how many M's are in container.
All of them.