Jarrod "J" Carmichael of 3 Minute Board Games - TCbH interview
Transcript
Hello and welcome back to another episode of Cardboard Herald. My chance to talk with creative gamers and game creators. And joining me today is the host of threeinut board games. You know him, Jared J. Carmichael. Welcome back to the show, man. Uh Koroto, everyone. This is great because you're returning guest to the show and it was wonderful talking to you. God, it was a few years ago now. Precoid, which sounds like a different era. And now I did not I did not listen back and see what we talked about. Did we just talk about the channel or did we talk about Red Dust back then or Red Dust wasn't even a thing, baby? It wasn't even a thing. You were just some guy and I was some other guy and we were just talking about some board games and some recording stuff.
But now you're a published game designer. You are a a veritable institution on the the board game space. I would say you are a voice of reason and advocacy in the uh social media space of board games. Uh you're a leader in that. Uh one thing I've always admired about you is your willingness to kind of cause it like you seize it. Uh and the reason why you're here is you're also an author. I got your book. It's in my hands right here. 101 board games to try before you die of boredom. I did not pick the name, by the way. Um, you didn't pick. I stand behind that the the concept, but not necessarily the title. Well, yeah. I tell you what, putting out a book.
Um, jeez, it doing a game is so different because I play games. I review games. I know what makes a game good, I think. And when when my games came out, I'm like, I played and tested these to death. Putting out a book like I I have no idea. It could be absolute rubbish. Yeah. Well, it it's not rubbish. It's interesting. And there were moments in reading the book, which I did read and enjoyed and even my wife then uh read through the book um where I did have some thoughts about like hm this is interesting. uh would I have tackled it this way? Ultimately, I haven't tackled any writing, so you know, like your your league's beyond me, but uh we'll get into that in just a second. But I'm interested to know, you cover so many board games. What are you playing for fun these days? Like, what what's getting you really amped up and excited?
you know, the the type of gaming that you might chronicle 10 years from now as highlights of your gaming career. See, this one's this one's really straightforward. So, about two or three years ago, I was getting pretty bad burnout with doing reviews because you're doing like one to two reviews a week. You're learning one or two new games. You're basically churning through them because you want to get three or four plays in for each game. Uh you need multiple groups doing that and a lot of solo plays as well. and you're just like churn churn churn churn churn churn churn and you you you find a game that you think's like this is so cool but I also know in a week's time I might not get back to this game for a couple of years because I have to dive into the next one. So I rescheduled my uh week so that I have like Friday nights and every second Sunday uh for old games that I want to replay or keep playing. And Friday night has almost exclusively for two years now been one game and one game only that I have played every single Friday that I can. And if I can't play it, then we play something else. And it's Arkham Horror the card game. Wow. Now that is a great game and a lot of content to wrestle with. And it kind of sounds like something that uh we did over here. We had an ongoing game night for uh Gloom Haven and then Frost Haven. Um, we we've gone through all of base game, the uh Jaws of the Lion, and then ultimately Frost Haven, and we just reached the
conclusion of Frost Haven, and now we're like, well, I guess we can play a couple couple missions of Sleeping Gods or something where there's a void. There's a void. Uh, what what uh what Arkham Horror LCG uh campaign are you currently playing? So currently I'm playing by myself solo. I'm doing a Dream Eaters uh run through. So it'll be my third Dream Eters run through. And with the group on Fridays we're on the finale of Edge of the Earth. So what I what I tend to do is play them through live with my Friday group um the first time. like absolutely experience with people the first time and then I play it through on tabletop simulator multiple times by myself and then I put out a review. So I think we've done seven campaigns now like seven campaigns through. So um pretty much done everything published aside from Drown City and Forgotten Age now.
So I've just been hammering it, man. God there there's so much content there there's so much good stuff in that. like how how much attention do you pay to like constructing your decks and really getting meticulous about that constructed aspect? Because I grew up playing Magic and other TCGs and I like Arkham a lot, but one of the barriers that I've always found is, you know, like I I just don't have it in me with Arkham to to really fine-tune a deck. And I think that's because I'm wrestling this sort of approachability of having other people who are not the TCG background players uh joining in and I don't just want to make something for them and be like, "Trust me, this is going to be bananas." Um Yeah. But at the same time, I feel like I'm letting myself down if I'm playing precons.
Yeah. No, I absolutely use my phone to browse or do anything. And when I get my phone um stats report every every week, most used app Arkham Cards every single week. I'm just when other people are browsing through social media or whatever, I'm just like flick sort flick. I've got like a dozen designs on the go at any given time. Um which is why I run them through tabletop sim. And then when I'm playing in the group, I turn tend to turn up with the most janky, ridiculous, okay guys, I've got a plan. I think this might work, but it's might be really terrible deck. I'm currently running uh in Edge of the Earth a Preston uh millionaire deck, and it revolves around the Red Glove Man and storing bonus actions and then getting as many Red Glove Man actions as you possibly can.
So, one turn you do nothing as such, restore your actions, and then you bring out the Red Glove Man and do everything. It's like this weird burst uh deck, and it works so well when it's working. Um, and it's just it's so much fun watching the other players at the table going, "What are you even doing?" Throwing cards down. Where do you as an experienced Arkhammer uh fall in the uh the the the perspective of Barkham horror? You know, like it is now a legendary item that is no longer available and you see all the time uh on on like subreddits and that kind of thing where people are like, "Oh my god, you know, like Barham is 200 bucks. I want to get my hands on parkour." And then you have experienced players who are like, "It's not worth it."
It's It's barely even a joke. Yeah. Um I I passed on it when it came out. Um I don't really get it. Um yeah, it's it's not it's not that funny and it's certainly not what $300 funny, which is what it seems to be going for these days. Like nah, I mean there's I had missed out on the return to Night of the Zealot and Return to um Dunich horror boxes. Mhm. Uh, I'd kind of like those mostly for the player cards and return to Dunich. Um, but, you know, it is what it is. Like, I'll proxy those cards if I have to. I'm not going to pay, you know, again, $200 to get 20 cards I might use six of. I would Bandelier 2 is good. It's not that good.
I would love nothing more than just like a a threehour tour of your Arkham collection process, organization, management, debt constructing, just you vibing with Arkham Horror. That would be like my dream video from you. So, you know, you can put that in the the background. I I'm already planning on doing a bucketload of Arkham content once I've played because I've still got to do Forgotten Age and we still got to do Drown City, but that's it of the main campaign. So, once I'm through those and then I've played them through a couple of times on Tabletop Sim, I'm going to do like the big here are my investigators, here are my top um my top scenarios. Uh oh jeez, I've got to play through all the all the standalones cuz I've only done half of those as well.
So, there's still quite a bit to do. I'm definitely going to watch that. That that's that's so awesome. So, let's talk about such a good guy. Let's talk about you becoming an author. So, like what was the impetus of this? How did it begin? Hilariously, um you'll probably know this, but when you've got a YouTube channel uh like like mine, uh you get requests for the strangest things every day. Like you'll get, "Hey, we represent Nike. We want to do advertising." And you're like, M I'm pretty sure you're not doing that from anop.pl email. So, spam, spam. You get so many of those. And then one came in about doing a book. They're like, "Hey, we've we've looked at your Hi, my name's Elliot. I've looked at your I'm a I'm an editor at Page Street uh Publishing.
we've looked at your YouTube channel and we we make these sort of books for hobbies and stuff and um we would like to talk to you because we think that your way of summing up games would make you a good fit for writing up a book that has a lot of games in it. And I just look stared at the email. I stared at the address and and I leaned over to Steph and I go, "Steph, this doesn't look like spam. This looks real." And I had to stare at it for like 10 minutes and she was like, "No, that looks that look that looks real." I was like, "Do do we reply?" And yeah, so I was I I replied. It was they they just cold approached me and um yeah, actually just went from there. And um they basically showed me examples of other books they do. Like they had one with um someone reviewed a whole bunch of horror short stories. and they also do ones with different arts and crafts like a crochet book, a cooking book, all that kind of stuff. So, it was like, let's do a cooking book kind of, but for for board games. So, that actually answers one of my questions or I guess one of my quandries on kind of the the the tone of this book and what it's intended to accomplish.
Um how uh how much freedom and flexibility did you have in the structure and presentation of the game of the the book? Absolutely. Uh almost unlimited. So that's awesome. They were like we don't know board games. That's why that's why we're reaching out to you um right we we absolutely trust you um to pick the games that would fit. Um, that's we got into a normal conversation cuz I was like, I want to do stuff that isn't just it isn't just the usual, hey, this is Scrabble, this is Monopoly, this is chess. Oh, if you really want to push yourself, you could try some serious games like this new game, Katan. I'm like, Katan's like 30 something years old now. It's like 30 or 40 90 uh 95.
So, 30 years old. Yeah, it's not a new game. we should for some reason though we talk about it's like oh it's this fresh new thing you can get in the hobby it's it's pretty old so I wanted to look at games that were a bit more contemporary than that cover ground that hadn't necessarily been done in other board game books cuz I had a quick look around and I was like yeah that one's talking about Monopoly and Scrabble that one's talking about uh Carcasson cool let's do something a bit more contemporary and a bit more modern so the oldest game in the book is Ticket to Ride That's 2004. So, and that nearly didn't make it in. You had to make a lot of cuts. Like 101 games. There there are a lot of people who would, you know, like shiver in fear at having to narrow their own collection down to 101 games. selecting 101 possible games that someone who theoretically doesn't know this hobby very well uh would be recommended as possible things that they can move to. Uh that that's a daunting task. Like where did you start with this? Did you just go like all right well here's a list of 500 games and let's pair this down from here a a little bit. So, um, I kind of went through, uh, every game in my collection, uh, that I'd played. So, I've recorded most of the games I've played on BG and just sort of created short list and then started pairing them
down from there. Um, one thing though with the criteria in this book is because I wanted games that were both awesome to play and looked awesome, several of my all-time favorite games uh, did not make the cut. So, Terraforming Mars is a game that I will play non-stop all the damn time and have played hundreds of games of it. It's not in the book because it ugly. It is disco Thanksgiving. It's crazy. Yeah, it it's it's so budget and they could just do a little bit more with that game and make it so much nicer. like the the Aries Expedition art is just 100 times better than the original um the original Terraforming Mars, but I don't really like Aries Expeditions gameplay. So, that's why those games didn't make it in. Even though Terraforming Mars has never been in the seven years I've done the top 100 on my channel, it's never been lower than fifth. So, yeah. Yeah, there was a very specific uh component of the games having to almost be works of art as well as good games. So that immediately cut out a whole bunch of games. Food chain magnate. That's that's kicked to one side, right? Uh a gria. There it goes. Um well, I mean there's a certain charm, but yeah, I I get it. Um, you know, Castles and Burgundy's only in there because of the new version. Because of the new deluxe version. Yeah. Uh, I I actually had to
explain to a friend just the other day um who he's relatively new to board games and he got the bug hard. Like he's in that stage of acquisition where I'm like, "Bro, you can settle down. Take it from me. You do not need to own every game that someone else says is good. And also, you don't have to own every game that you think is good. Eventually, you're going to play so many games that you're like, "These are so great." But you have nowhere to place them. You know, you you're you're having to export them. And when you live in Juno, Alaska, finding places to get those games to uh becomes a a pretty uh uh enormous endeavor. But I I was explaining to him uh what a beige Euro was, you know, and he was like, "What do you mean beige euro?" And I was like, "Oh, it's like my favorite genre of game." Uh he's like, he loves euros. uh and he wasn't quite understanding when I was saying like well particularly back in the day let's say the the castles of Burgundy day or you know anywhere between Carcasson to you know maybe like 2012 there was a certain brand of Mediterranean trading where it was just beige and you know like dull you know uh it it it really was how do we put the least emphasis on the visual appeal and just have spreadsheets that barely
represent some sort of uh thematic concept. Um yeah, and your player colors were brown or tan or wood. So, one of the things one of my one of my best new games to me from last year was um Hans Tutonica. Oh, yeah. Which is almost almost a definition of a gray um beige euro. My goodness. That's a great game. It's such a great game. But it it doesn't have the sex appeal. No, it doesn't. But oh, when you're playing it, you're just like, this is a rage engine. It's so good. But you have to think of these games as ambassadors because again, theoretically, the person that this book is for is not me, right? You know, like I I know these games. And at first I was like, well Jay, he is a very thoughtful dude and he's going to come in here and he's going to write individual entries on this is why this game is important. Like that that that's almost the the direction that I was going to, you know, like you you were writing your thesis on board games. And what I was confronted with when I actually read it, um, which I think is much more functional, uh, though I become less of the audience for is here's why you as someone who has not played this game might like this game.
And absolutely that is such a cool thing to be able to hand someone who's only played Katana or Ticket to Ride or maybe they, you know, went to an office game night or something and someone brought Lords of Water Deep or something and you're like, "Hey, you kind of liked those things here. This is a great way to start without having to dip your toes into boardamegeeek.com." that that's exactly it. So, I also went very much for this is what the game will make you feel and this is the the sort of the the wow moments of of the games rather than going this is how you scored the victory points, you know, because you don't need to write a book like that for the people uh of Board Game Geek. They've got the top 100.
There's already a hundred list on board gamege geek of the top games as defined by that self- selecting group that that exists. That is ground wellraveled, right? So again, didn't want to do the this is Scrabble, this is Monopoly, and check out this new game, Katan. But I also didn't want to just do here's the top 100 on board game, right? Because board game geek might as well put that book out. So nuts and bolts. Then uh I was looking at some of the things like say complexity. Did you utilize board gamegeeek for measuring complexity or did you decide on your own metrics there? So I used the board game geek as a basis and then kind of shifted them one star up and down depending on gut feel. Right. Right. because sometimes sometimes some Euro games end up being like a 4.5, but if you compared them to a a war game that's also rated a 4.5, they're nowhere near as complex. So, what occurred to me while I was playing is it exposed certain things on boardamegeeek that I fundamentally disagreed with that I did go to Board Game Geek to be like, wait, did BGG actually rate it this way? Uh the the one that first came to mind was Cascadia versus Parks. And you have Cascadia, parks, and harmonies all in here. And I was reading through the section because each of the sections here are uh based
off of maybe not just weight, but you know, the type of gaming that you might be doing. Uh and in the first section, yeah, vibe quick and fun games. I was like, "Okay, Parks is in here at a wait two. Playing time 30 to 45 minutes." H interesting. I I kind of think of Parks is a little bit more meaty. It's got some worker placement, but you know, and then I get through to the next section, which is just a a notch up familyfriendly games. I see Cascadia in here at 60 to 120 minutes with the same level of complexity. And personally, I I know there are some diehard Cascadia fans, but personally, I was like, ah, this is just not enough game here for me. Uh, and the the idea of Cascadia being in a level of dimension that is somehow above uh Parks outraged me at first. I was like, Jay, what are you doing? And then I was like, BGG must have these completely uh the the complexity aligns on BG. And and that made me start thinking about how just like subjective these like star rating systems are for complexity, for best player count, you know, how much of this is user generated. Um, nonetheless, like I I'm not saying that these are inappropriately placed in the book, but
I I wonder if while you were organizing this yourself, if there were some categories where you were like, h I I guess I never really thought of this game as this uh and putting it into this zone, but if I use these metrics that that you're aligning yourself or at least using as a reference preference um that that it made more sense to have it in one section versus the other. I mean, you've actually stumbled on a on a small thing here, and that was that originally parks was in the same chapter. Oh. And I moved forward one uh because I was like, "Oh jeez, this chapter's only got like seven games in it. Which one of the games from the next chapter can I move forward?" That's it. that yeah that's there sometimes there little compromises you make like okay which game could probably fit in quick and fun from this block and like um probably parks. So when you're writing the individual sections for this about how much time would it take you to write a a blurb on one of these games as opposed to writing one of your three minute game scripts.
uh takes much longer to write one of these than it does a script really because the script is Yeah, the script is actually pretty straightforward because my process for doing a board game review is I shoot the photos first. So I I set up the game and I go, "Okay, do an intro shot. Do that. What are the wind conditions? Shoot, shoot, shoot, shoot, shoot, shoot. What are the core mechanics? Shoot those. Okay, let's go through a turn." And we do all the sequence. So, when I'm writing a script, I literally bring up the pictures and go, "Right, then next one." I've already got it because I've written the script in my head while I was taking the photos. That's so smart. And then, well, it's just that's just my process. It's just how it's how it's always been. And it's such a smart process is way better than trying to write like witty banter. uh which obviously is not as uh uh well either I'm not witty enough or you know like uh it's it's just not as valuable as you know like what is this game you know like you you drive to the essence which is I think speaks to the popularity of the channel and and then uh once you've been basically spent two hours two to three hours doing photos and then say 35 minutes, 40 minutes doing the nuts and bolts part of the script. Well, you've just spent 4 hours thinking about that game. So, you launch straight into doing what are the pros and cons. You've already your brain's already been cogitating the how you're
going to phrase those things and they just kind of flow. Like, in many ways, I spend more time writing the last line, which is the witty gag. Yeah. Um than I do writing the rest of the script. Sometimes I'll quite frequently get to that point, shut it, and then go away and do something else and then try for something to pop up. Was there any part of writing this book where you worried about it being dated? Like that that's one of the things when I I see these types of of books and I've seen them my entire life, you know, like I grew up playing a lot of video games. uh you know like I've been part of so many different hobbies you know like uh music you know these are the top hundred you know bands you have to listen to and then the moment that that book becomes 2 years old it's missed so much potential and especially because you're cutting on the the edge of modernity here like you have arcs in here which I was very surprised I was like damn am hot off the presses. You have arcs in this book. So arcs arcs was literally the 101st game added. That's that's perfect. That makes sense. Uh because I it was originally a I'd originally written a chapter on Twilight Imperium fourth edition. Uh that had been in the book, but I struggled to find a copy of Twilight Imperium to photograph. So I own 95 of the 101 games and I borrowed the other
six. Well, yes. Yeah. Um, but the person I tried arranging uh to do Twilight Perion with kind of essentially ended up ghosting me. So, I was like, well, I've got to get these photos in in a week's time. I don't have um a copy of Twilight Imperium. I'm not going to go out and buy one cuz it's like $400 New Zealand dollars. Yeah. Um, and by happen stance that night we were doing the test for arcs for the channel to review it. And we played it through the first time and I was like, "Holy [ __ ] this this game has to go in here. This has solved my problem." uh because it is just um doing things that I find way more interesting and modern and exciting and contemporary than poor old busted ass Twilight Imperium that is just your space cats and turtles got moved to the side. Move over granddad.
And it's almost like the g that game was getting an because of its reputation. Um, it was one of those games that I personally haven't enjoyed playing a huge amount the last couple of times I've played it, but I was like, "Oh, you can't really do a book on big impressive games without talking about it." And then ARX turned up and I'm like, "No, get out of here. You're gone. You're fired. You're out of the building." Right. Um, well, back to the original question, ARX was great. Were you worried or are you worried about this being a a dated resource within a couple of years because you're going to miss the on on potential recommendations? Um, not really because any book's item of its time. Most of the games in there will exist in some form or the other.
Um, even going back to like, you know, I've been knocking on the whole Scrabble Monopoly thing, right? it. Games are games are good. Yeah. Like these games will probably still be good uh 20 years from now. They just might be pretty hard to find. Someone called me out on that. They're like, "Oh, that game's out of print." I'm like, "Games are always out of print." Like, there is there's going to be some games in there that you'll have to find secondhand. That's just that's just how it is because this market's constantly going up and down, up and down. you could only pretty much set your clock that a handful of games like your katans, Dominions, um, and that are going to be in print the whole time. Arkham Horror the card game, it looks like they're going to stop printing some of that stuff. So, yeah, that's a travesty. Like, even as someone who only owns so much Arkham Horror, the card game, and again, I I'm a dabbler compared to the hardcore nutcases like you, um, which I say in the most, uh, uh, honorific way. No offense taken. Um but uh yeah, I when I heard that news, it was like h I'm shedding a tear for the people who like there there are a lot of people where Arkham is their hobby. You know, it it's not like board gaming is their hobby and Arkham Horror is just like another game on the shelf like me. There are people where that is a sizable chunk of the joy that they get. But thankfully there's a lot of it out there still available.
Yeah. So, as far as I'm aware, yeah, it's going to be a um you know, a stake in time like two weeks after I finalized the book, Endeavor Deep Sea came in and that became my game of the year. Uh it's also a game designed by um two of my friends. Uh cuz Jared and Carl are from from New Zealand. Jared I've known since my 20s. Wow. And Carl I met about 10 years later. Um, and they designed this amazing amazing game and it it just missed the card off and so yeah, that's a great example of how it is literally something like August um 2024, right? It's it's a time stamp. Yeah. Well, I guess that leaves the opportunity like if this were a travel guide um then you would have the opportunity for like second edition, right? You know, y if it if it sells well, then you could be like 101 board games to try before you die 2026 edition or something like that.
Yeah. Got to get that money. Got to get that money. You got to monetize, man. Could drop out a handful of games and put in some new ones. Yeah, for sure. I mean, well, I was just talking on my I'm in on my Discord. like if I did 101 more games, um there were like there's been 12 I've played this last 6 months that would go in. There's been some real real good games that I've legitimately played and gone these things were good enough to pop into the book. How much did you think about uh variety of publishers, variety of designers and even uh the the um I I guess the personality of the designers themselves because there are some games out there where you know like the people who made them we found out some real bad stuff about and then you're like oh man this is a pretty good PAX game But jeez, did he really need to put that in the, you know, like manual?
Uh, I I sort of there's a bit of self- selection there. Uh, I did I think Fantasy Flight Games have more games than anyone else uh by a considerable margin, but that's because from about 2005 through to 2020, they put out way more good games than anyone else. Like they're absolutely amazing. Um, aside from that, I don't think any publisher has more than three games. And the two publishers with three games are Stonemire Games, which I think are Viticulture, Scythe, Scythe, and Wingspan. And I don't think there's many people would go, "Boo, those three games don't deserve to be in there." Like, come on. And then, uh, the other publisher with three games is probably a slightly surprising one. It's Level 99 cuz they've got Millennium Blades, right? Uh, which I thought was a consortium. I thought Millennium Blades was an interesting pick. I when I got to that page, I was like, "Oh, okay. We're we're we're not just going with the uh most marketable game to a mass audience.
We're going with some niche stuff. I like this. It's it's it but it's so cool. It's such a unique, interesting, and fascinating game. Argent is another one. And Imperial Spells and Steam, which is um yeah, just a a train game on on crack cocaine. It is something unique and interesting and fascinating and it looks stunning and it's got great gameplay and it's just so weird because Level 99's games are all weird. Uh I didn't feel so bad putting three of them in because it's not like it's not like I've put in um Guy Project and Terrammystica, right? Yeah. Um, no, you you do talk uh about different editions of games or different versions of games like in the Century Golem edition. Uh, which I I also thought was funny because the Beige Euro guy myself, I was like, I like Spice Road. That's the one in my shelf. He's taking digs at my Spice Road.
Death to Death to Spice Road. Um, golems forever. Like, come on. on the little the little gems. Like Steph in particular, she just loves little gems. She like plays with them while we're playing. So, were there any notable snubs to you where you were like, "People are going to hate me for this, but this game cannot be in here." It from Terraforming Mars. Terraforming Mars. Yeah. Like that's that's that's one of the big ones because that is literally a game I I love to death. Um, and also people know you love it, you know, like if you were doing your own personal top 100, people know it's in there and they know to expect it. Top five. Yep. But um, that got snubbed just because it it ugly. Um, and I mean the fraasises, the the the people who behind the game aren't particularly great either. They're very conservative.
They're unpleasant sort of people and they're really into AI imagery as well. Right. That was a big controversy recently. And another thing that I was going to ask about, I didn't see a disclaimer on it anywhere in the book, but I didn't know if the discussion, well, I guess you know, August 2024 the discussion was happening, but you you as a content creator have flat out said you will not be covering any new games that use uh AI generative uh illustrations now, right? Absolutely not. And that is one of the reasons why I picked the theme for this book, why I went for board games as a combination of mechanics and artistry because I'm really legitimately worried about the shovelware slop that is going to be right just pouring onto shelves all over the world um with this AI generated imagery that's just garbage and awful and takes money from creators.
is uh it's a wholesale plagiarism machine and I want nothing to do with it. So, right, that's why there's so much art. That's why a game like Above and Below is in there for for Ryan Lockett because Ryan Lockett is such a beautiful artist, right? Um yeah, it's why I went for that theme. Why um museum is in there? Um because Vincent Dra's um art is for for museum is just next tier. Um, yeah, the the it was deliberately put out that way as a antidote or a counter to the rise of of AI imagery and board gaming. And I won't ever call it art because it has nothing to do with art. I called it illustrations. Um but but but yeah uh it's it's an interesting fact that in this hobby there that it's even a a discussion. I mean I get it because there are some people who are um who in their minds they would never be able to publish a board game unless they used um generative illustrations and uh that they there's creative comments. Yeah, there's creative common, there's clip art, there's plenty of other things. You can draw a little stick figure totally you or not use use art at all. There there's there is literally no excuse, right? And there's um and to me it's a lack of awareness uh and
also a a realization that something having polish uh in the way that there's this uncanny valley with AI uh generated images where it's overly polished and yet completely uh uh unbelievable at the same time. But a good personality uh and something original uh and perspective will trump that every time. Uh and there are so many uh great stories of illustrations that you might initially look at as um amateur-ish uh but have evolved over time and really become something uh beautiful. I mean, even uh Red Raven Games, Ryan uh Lookout's uh original output was much more rough compared to where it is now. Oh, yeah. Um but even then it was charming. It had perspective. It uh you know, evoked a tone uh that worked perfectly with those games. Um so yeah, I'll give you a great example from the book. Uh there's a game in there called Roll Camera uh by Keen Bean Studios and it's got little stick figures all the way through it. Little stick figures make making movies and it's gorgeous. It's absolutely adorable.
It fits the playful tone the game wanted to have. And it's not like it's not oil paintings, right? It's it's little stick figures. It's it's like SK CD sort of stuff. It's but it works. Now you are a game designer now. Uh, Red Dust Rebellion has come out and uh you have another one in the works or is it is it already? Yeah. So, so Shadowman Syndicates uh went up for Kickstarter and it's funded. Uh unfortunately, we went up uh during the US election. So, we I think our our media buys got some somehow a bit squashed, right? So, didn't do quite as well as we thought. We still got in about 150k. Did it did about 900 backers or something, right? Um so, that that's coming out. It's been delayed a little just to sort out this whole tariff debacle. Um, but it's Yeah, it's it's good. I really like the game. Did the I think it's Do you think that the process of you being a becoming a game designer and much more involved in the meats and potatoes of getting these games into reality gave you a different perspective at all on what games that you would have selected for something like this? Like did that give you any new insight into the industry that you might not have had before considering you you've been making these videos for ages and you've been a gamer for ages.
It's this new new transference into the role of publish designer that uh I'm curious if that's kind of changed your perspective on games. I I think the hardest thing for me is even with the book and um especially with the channel I am somewhat of um what's the term polite way would be to say or um the other way would be to say um brusque demanding one vision no compromise kind of I have an idea of what I want to do and I do it. The difficult thing with creating board games is there are other people involved and uh there are publishers and for the most part the the editors of the book were like yeah cool do what you want we'll just can can we change the language here and there and fine. Uh but with making board games you had to make a lot more compromises and it's a lot more of a by committee process than a lot of people think it is. Like as the designer you're not you're not a director. You don't get to make all the decisions and everyone just runs around and do what you say. You kind of more like the the writer where like you you turn up all your stuff and they go cool now we're going to make we're going to make your game and this is how your game is going to look and this is how your game is going to feel and yeah for me that was that was quite hard in places.
You are telling me that you're the Stanley Kubri of the board game world then you know like you need you need your vision to come to life and sometimes the studios over here going like Stanley we can't fund this pretty much like yeah especially like three-minute board games that's why every I I I think I spend like 12 hours making a uh work hours making a threeminute video like it's it's just the sort of level of um finessing and direct vision that I you don't see many other places, right? Like um and I'm a little bit like that with my games as well. I have like a very nope, this is the way it is because this is if we don't do it this way, then it's not the way it's done.
And yeah, it could be tricky. Now, since the last time we talked, you have a daughter and that's awesome. Congratulations. You have a four-year-old. Um, is that your only child? Yeah. Yeah. So, Ann's our only child. And that's one of the really good things about the game design of the YouTube is um I've just stopped working. I look after her. That is that is my job. That's amazing. Congratulations. And looking after her. Steph still has to go to the office, so spare a thought for her. She has to be the the bread winner. But the channel, while it doesn't bring in uh gold-plated toilet money, it's certainly better than um a lot of people's situations where they, you know, if someone wants to stay at home, then you don't have any money coming in.
So, you have to both go to work and then pay for child child care and then you're seeing your kid 2 hours a day, right? Yeah. And we just didn't want that life. It it's it's not great. uh going through uh some of the childc care situation uh myself uh when uh my son was younger. It it's tough and uh congratulations on and also you know shout out for the sacrifices made uh so that uh you guys can arrange that. But um has Parenthood changed your perspective at all on games? I know that was a whole journey in and of itself with me when my son was born and starting to dip my toes into the whole world of Hoba games or you know like starting to see games in a different light uh in you know what I can translate to my kid what I want to share with them even at a young age like 2 three four. Yeah. So it's a it's a little bit different our situation here because uh like my like myself uh an is autistic. Okay. Uh but unlike me uh I was a precocious talker. Uh an is very much at the stage at the moment where she'll talk a lot but she won't necessarily talk to you. Sure. There's a lot of uh internal stuff happening. So we're not quite at the stage where we're sitting down and playing games together.
um and might not be for for quite a while because there's a lot happening up here. Like there is just so much happening, right? It's just she's more interested in her inner life at the moment than she is in necessarily the the outer world. Hey, um you know, like it's fortunate that you have that insight and perspective. I mean, in my in my day-to-day life, uh I work in social services. I work with a lot of kids with um uh different uh neurological needs or you know like conditions. And so like being able to to navigate that and have that understanding and also the understanding between you know your own childhood and how you channeled that versus her. Um, well, one of the sort of foundation things for me is being an autistic kid growing up. Well, they didn't know what it was back then, but um, my parents definitely got me checked out for a whole bunch of things and they kind of came back with a well, he's something. We don't know what it is, but he's something.
I didn't necessarily make a lot of friends uh, particularly easily. What I would do is I would do my thing, right? and I my thing might be playing a board game and I would play it by myself and then people would see that I was busy and occupied and doing something and they would gravitate towards what I was doing and join in. And that's basically been my entire life. I do almost all my gaming in my own gaming space and people come to me, right? Uh I kind of put down a flag pole saying fun here and people people turn up and I see Ann doing the same thing. She'll be just like blocks. She'll be intensely playing with blocks and you'll see the other kids just sort of turn up and be like, "Oh, are we building something?" and join in. And I'm like, "Oh, yeah. No, I I can I remember this."
That that's so fascinating. And that that's also, you know, like without trying to be like a armchair psychologist or anything, like the the kind of deliberate matterof fact nature of threeminute board games makes a little bit more sense. That's a piece of a puzzle there. Uh, but it's also this kind of like I guess you're not just reviewing games. You're not just speaking to games, but it's also like you're collecting a threeinut perspective on games, you know, like you you are speaking to each of these in a very regimented uh and authoritative manner. That that um that makes a lot of sense.
Uh and now you're doing it again with this you're doing it again with this book. Yeah. So, very few people when I when I mention this are like, "Oh, yeah. No, no, we wouldn't have picked that." Everyone's like, "Oh, yeah, that makes sense." The the the guy who's like really particular about his board games and organized and structures everything turns out to be on the spectrum. What a shock. So, uh one more question, uh specifically about the uh games that you included. Um, now that I know that you uh have this burning love for terraforming Mars and you did not include terraforming Mars in here, is Earth a consolation prize in this book? I like Earth. Earth is on my shelf over there, but I notice a lot of people like Earth was popular when it first came out, and I I almost feel like the board gaming space has turned on Earth.
Uh, and uh, yeah, I it it's it's interesting uh, that it wasn't in there or or that it it isn't, you know, in the same discussions as a lot of other games. And then I see it in the book, I'm like, well, hell yeah. Earth got a spot in here. Okay. Okay. And a little bit it's in there because Terraforming Mars isn't, right? Like terraforming Mars could easily take that spot if it looked better. I prefer terraforming Mars to Earth, but Earth, uh, Earth's a chaotic mess. Uh, and I kind of like it for that. It's not a keeper game for me. Like I I've passed on my copy. Um, but it's a game that if someone sets it up, I'll be like, "Oh, yeah. No, I I'll be in for that, right?" But I'd rather play um Yeah. Terraform Mars or It's a Wonderful World uh than I would uh Earth. But there was originally a section almost entirely on games around the natural world. Like when I first did the list, um there were and I think that chapter stayed around as like a chapter on science um science and nature, right? And that's why Earth's in there because I thought that was quite a cool um sort of collection of games to pull together, a whole bunch of games around um the natural world because it's just a it's a cool thing to to to look at. So yeah, Earth's probably in if we're going to rank these in like the first 10 games to the last 10 games, it's probably one of the last games to go in. Okay. Uh but but I don't
I don't disagree with it being being in there six months later. I think it's still a good game. It's an interesting game, and I think the theme and ideas in it will will really appeal to people just cuz it's so chaotic. Now, you don't strike me as someone who relies much on uh being cool. Like, you are cool, but part of that is that it does not seem like you are trying to be cool. That said, was there any trepidation in making this book which very clearly seems to be for the general audience as opposed to the hardcore gamer that you were worried that uh you know there would be fans of your channel that would pick up this book and then go like wait a second this is all somewhat superficial stuff you know like this isn't a a tearful story of why you love King at Tokyo. It's not about Richard Garfield's, you know, uh, transformation from being a PhD professor to being the founder of Magic the Gathering. You have some references to that kind of stuff.
But for the most part, again, the target market for this book, while I found it entertaining and I found it interesting, functionally, the person who's actually going to get the most out of this is going to be the person who knows the least about your channel. Yep. Yep. And that's all that's all deliberate. I have a a sort of theory I kick around that uh 95% of board game content is made for 5% of board gamers, right? Yeah. And the other 95% of board gamers are out there. They're browsing Barnes & Noble. U they're picking up stuff from their local bookstore. They own five to 10 games and they like those games and they play them a lot. Right. Um the 5% are the people who've got like a 100 games who do like three gaming events a week.
Uh-huh. Uh that that's not normal. Like I see people who have like four times as many games as I do and they play practically every day and I'm like, man, this is my job, right? I love board games, but it's also my job. um your opinion when talking about what you think normal is. You are so far from normal um that you're you're in the next county which is why I like talking to my um local post shop owner. So in New Zealand we have these things called post shops. So they're they're new NZ Post. They're part of the postal service. Um they also tend to have a Kiwi bank in it which is a little little banking place and they tend to be a bookstore and a gift store. Everything all sort of rolled into one. I love it. And they have this they have this little shelf uh that has board games on it and they've got maybe 30 games in there including a copy of Red Dust Rebellion and a picture of me standing with the shop owner uh you know shaking his hand with the copies of Red Dust Rebellion cuz I live in a village and I like to talk to them about what sort of games people are picking up because the people who pop into that shop and go, "Oh, this Wingspan game looks pretty cool." or oh um you know I I want to try this uh floating floors game about ninjas.
They're not on board game geek. They're they're not watching the dice tower. They might occasionally watch Shut Down Shut Up and Sit Down because they're they're kind of almost good for entertainment, but they're certainly not watching threeminute board games and they're not watching they're not listening to board game podcasts, right? Um absolutely. They're just out there living their lives. Board gaming is like a tiny part of their life, a tiny part of their identity. And the book in in a large part is written for those people. It's not written for the super users because there's just so much content made for them. There's a sur surplus of content made for the 5%. Where, as I say, 95% of board game content made for 5% of the audience. I decided to make a bit of content that's more suited to the other 95%.
And what are the the aims of this book? like where where is what sort of deals? Like h I guess how much involved are you in the publisher getting it into bookstores? Like I is it going to be available primarily online? Is it going to be available at Barnes & Noble? Like what do you know about the ambitions for how wide reaching this is going to be? So, Page Street is a subbrand of McMillan, and McMillan is one of the five, one of the big five global powerhouses of of publishing. So, the plan is, as far as I'm aware, it's going to be in every bookstore everywhere in the damn well world, physical copies, and I think they're translating it into multiple different languages. It is going to be shipping all around the world. It's just going to be everywhere.
It's already in Barnes & Noble. It's on Amazon. It's in pretty much every bookstore you can think of in the US already. Um, and when it gets to New Zealand over here, it's going to be in Paper Plus and Wick Calls. It's already on pre-order on Mighty App in the Nile. They these guys are these guys are pros. Like, they sent out like when I talked about review copies for the for the thing, they got me to put together a list. They' also put together a list of 30 uh reviewers and I got I got a few more. Um, but then they sent a copy to every single publisher whose uh game is in the book. So that's something like 65 or 70 publishers they they sent a copy to. So, I've already had um Patrick Leer uh post um because he's got two games in the book, Root Arcs, and uh James Hudson posted on his um Instagram and Facebook uh for Druid City Games cuz Wonderland War is in there. Um so, yeah, they've sent them out to to everyone like so that's probably a hundred review copies.
Yeah. that have been sent out. And I board games do not no one sends out 100 review copies of a board game. Of course, I mean, we're we're we're such a a small industry compared to like the the book industry and just the I guess mechanics of getting books out into hands, making sure that even influencers, you know, book, making sure that people get their hands on these things. Um it it's a whole much more mature uh and uh thought through beast than board games. Like I felt the whole way along that the process they it was really tight time frames too. And they were just there and checked in all the time and we just boom boom boom. Every milestone was just get getting ticked off. whole thing felt like it was a Trello board and we were just moving from gate to gate to gate and doing the required work like they were so professional and so they valued my time that and that's there's a level of prof professionalism in book publishing that I don't want this to sound mean but board game publishing is much more of a cottage industry than this.
Totally. And that's that's not I'm not intending to disrespect anyone in saying that, but they just you don't put enough things through the pipeline to get to that level of welloiled. I mean, GMT does GMT is actually pretty good, but um yeah, it's just it's such a very different experience. Plus, the huge difference is advances. Oh, yeah. You don't you don't get advances in board gaming. Yeah, that's true. I mean, maybe maybe if you're uh Elizabeth Hargrave, maybe off of off of Wingspan or something, you know, maybe she gets it. Um Yeah. Okay. Well, I I think this is uh fabulous. I I think it's a it's a book that um surprised me and uh it definitely had that uh effect of me going well I I don't know that this is necessarily a book that is going to make me consider more board games, but it definitely made me interested in the process of coming out with this book.
And initially I was going to do like a review and then I realized like you know what I I'd rather talk to you about like what this represented and how you approached this and and where you went with these games some of the decisions that were uh included. Uh loved seeing Yokohama in here uh as well which was uh great game. It was it was uh actually the game that started the discussion of um uh Beige Euro uh with a friend uh because even though Yokohama is colorful, it's vibrant, it it's it's eye-catching on the table. Um and it's designed by a Japanese person in Japan about Japan, so it's very not Euro. Yes, that that's very true. Uh but um we were talking about how it uh has a very from a certain perspective it would be viewed as kind of a a cold uh abstract game and uh and that prompted me to be like but that's okay because you know beige is my favorite genre of game. Uh um but where do you go from here? like uh do you have the bug to write more books? Like are there other things that when writing this you were like, you know, I could take this a different direction. I really want to focus on this direction that I have here, but
this does get the wheels spinning on what else you could do in as an author. I haven't actually thought of that. Like I'm I'm certainly not uh have any mind to do any fiction or anything. Um, I mean, non-fiction is kind of kind of my jam. Well, I think there's room for 101 board games that changed my life. And you, my friend, have been playing games since you were a kid, right? Your your own kids age, you know, like the these things have shaped us uh in ways. Uh my mom uh passed away at a very young age uh or my young age, which was also uh terribly young for her. But um uh one of my uh few memories with her was sitting on her lap while she was playing Scotland Yard with her uh with my older brother. Um I had no idea how to play. I just knew there was like this Mr. Rex guy and you know she let me move around the bus tokens or whatever. I was probably like 4 years old or something.
But these things shape our lives, change our perspective. And while I think this is a great entry point for a lot of people, I do think that you have a knack for again getting to the essence of these games. And I think there's room for uh these shorter essays uh to collect and curate games in different ways that I I think people would want to hear. They'd want to read it. Well, I I think there's a video I did uh the start of the year. Um, so Board Game Geek and the Dice Tower have their uh board game halls of fame and they put in a whole bunch of games into these hall of fames. And so I sat there, I looked at the list and it's just something just bugged me. No end about them. And I was thinking, am I just being a classical uh elitist geek and going actually I think this game should be in there and you've put this one there. I'm like, no, no, I I'm not this time. Mhm.
you've put games in your Hall of Fame, right? You haven't put people in your Hall of Fame. And once I noticed that, it made me actually quite annoyed. Yeah. Because putting in um June that doesn't really say anything. It's It's a product. Yeah. And are we talk is a Hall of Fame about products or people? And the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. um has bands in it. It doesn't have specific songs. Uh people talk about the Oscars and oh yeah, but the Oscars uh put in a product. I'm like, no, that's their end of year award show. Mhm. Their Hall of Fame is their lifetime achievement award. And that is always people. And so if there was going to be a another book I would consider doing, it might be putting together a hall of fame or a sort of the people who changed board gaming. Not necessarily the games who changed board gaming, but the people who moved the dial. So when I did that list, I not only included designers like the the obvious ones, right? But I also talked about people like uh Christian T.
Peterson for starting Fantasy Flight games, right? Uh Scott Scott Elden for getting Board Game Geek going. Um artists like you you definitely talked about Ian Oul, Vincent Dutrit. Uh you know like you talk uh you speak to artists in here. Kyle Faren uh you know like you make sure to uh mention uh a lot of people uh in these little posts and the things that draw your attention is kind of the human element. you know, the person behind the game and what they are trying to convey through the game, which in a way brings it back to that kind of aour perspective that you were talking about earlier is when you were going into designing a game, maybe you thought about it less as a product and more as a conversation between you, the person making the game and the experience that you wanted to provide for the person who is playing it at the table.
Absolutely. That is absolutely how how I I think about games. Like I I'm a It's easy to make a board game product. Just find a popular IP, get some mechanics, throw some crappy art on it. Make Marvel Pandemic, whatever. Easy peasy. Go print money. Yeah. It's not If you actually just want a board game to to make money, then just, you know, put some put some schlop on it. Make a make a deck building game about uh Harry Potter. Harry Potter deck building game. Cool. Oh, there's already one of those anyway. That will print money. Mhm. Doesn't matter if the game's good. Uh and in fact, that game is not good, right? Uh they didn't bother testing it and by the time you get to the fifth act, it's uh it falls to pieces. But it sold a bucketload of copies because it's a product, right? Uh Funko Pop, that's a product. For me, a a board game something more than that. It's something Well, it's more interesting than that. I mean, absolutely. And I've wrestled a lot with uh is uh are board games art uh or are games art? Are are our games craft? You know, like and how meaningful of a distinction uh there is uh between art and craft. Um but I have I have a great great analogy for the board game art thing. Sure.
People talk try to compare board games to music or movies or whatever. What board games are is sheet music. Yeah. So when you put out a a piece of music as sheet music, every time it is played, it is interpreted by the performers. So if you give the same sheet music to Radio Head that you give to Slayer, you are going to hear a different performance every time or different groups will interpret it differently. God, I want to see this YouTube channel where Radio Head and Slayer are coming in and both playing, you know, some sheet music playing the same thing. And what we have with a board game is you have something like a piece of sheet music that's put down and it is interpreted and reperformed every time it is done, right? But it's not linear like a um sheet of music. So, you're reinterpreting it back and forth and ending up with a different composition.
And this is why I think people can play the same game and go this is crap, this is great when they really what's happened is if you've had a good experience with the same game and you've had a poor experience with the same game and perhaps if you were playing in that game, you'd also think it was great, right? Because of how we reinterpret it. So yeah, I could record a whole like three-hour podcast just on philosophizing about the the nature of art. uh and I I think this isn't everyone's definition but the definition that I have come to is just you know art is something that has to be created and that you there is some intent on communication uh like that there is some intent of communication between what I made and whoever is going to be viewing that and if there isn't intent then it's not art you might not even know exactly what you intend to communicate, but it is an attempt to communicate through the medium in which you're producing art.
And that's why a piece of furniture could be a craft and be very beautiful and it is not art, but very beautiful. Like, I'm not trying to dismiss it, but another piece of furniture that is made with the intent of conveying something, I would say is art. Um, and those two things could look very similar, but in a very complex, crazy, wild world. Um, in which, uh, you know, we could get pedantic about this kind of stuff. Um, endlessly. Uh, that that's what I had to uh to to settle on. Um, the the last thing that I wanted to uh uh bring up um is just, you know, getting back to the design world. So, you got one game out, you got one game in the pipe. What's next on the horizon for Jared as the board game designer?
So, it's been pretty tricky just with with Ann because I I really only get um three mornings a week um with without her and evenings um to do most of that's doing the channel. So, I haven't done a huge amount. I'm halfway through uh designing an expansion for Red Dust Rebellion. Oh man. Um that's probably the the the next thing. Um and then I have like six or seven really really freaking good ideas pinned up on a board and I just need to pick one and do it. And I am tempted to take those ideas and do a full on the channel uh transparent creative process. That would be amazing people involved and go because I don't think anyone's done that to a sufficient sort of quality before.
I know there's a couple of little little channels that have done something similar to that where they're like trying to get their first Kickstarter. So they they go through the whole process, but the people doing that normally haven't designed a game before and they certainly don't have um you know a a big base. And I think it'd be quite cool to do that and try to build up a sort of following or an interest or buyin for a game because people have been involved in the creative process. Uh and then try to then market the game and see what happens. It's like, oh, by the way, uh we've designed a game. Here's a whole bunch of information about it and a readym made audience. Right. Exactly. Exactly. And I I think that would be that would be really interesting as not only creating the product uh in the end, but as an artistic endeavor, as something that people can can buy into and get involved with and also as a creator having this um you know, sea of potential voices and ideas. Um yeah, the the feedback could be could be fascinating. Yeah, it's like one of making a documentary as you're making a film or something, you know, like, you know, it's it's going deep into the process. So, you have the feedback from the audience, but then you can also reflect on it. And I I know I'm the type of person who loves the I mean I started the Cardboard Herald initially to talk to people like you making games or you know making conventions or I I
was much more interested in like what is the human element of bringing these things into the world or or what drove you to do these things? And I've been that with everything. You know, I I'm the type of person who wants to read every aligner note on Pearl Jam's Versus and, you know, like figure out exactly what's going on in there and then learn about like, oh well, where did Eddie Veter grow up and, you know, start figuring out, well, who was his favorite bands when he was growing up? And then learn about them. Like, I love the stories behind the people or or behind the things that I consume and that I love and that I interact with. And I I think that would be an amazing gift to the uh just creative board game community to kind of expose your process there and an avenue for your channel.
Come on, man. You got to get that monetization. Well, it's also just it's something no one else is doing. And I think it's one of one of the things if you if you're making content uh and you're making content everyone else is making then you're probably making the wrong content. Right. I hear that. Well, man, I am uh thrilled uh that uh I got a copy of the book uh for everyone in the audience. 101 board games to try before you die of boredom. Not named by Jay, but written by Jay. Uh, this is definitely like going to be a great uh stocking stuffer, Christmas gift, or the people that I thought of first that I was going to hand this book off to after uh my wife and I finished reading it was actually some of the gamers that I'm meeting at my public game night here in Juno. That doesn't happen at a game shop. It happens at Devil's Club Brewery. And there are a lot of people who go there that are exactly who you talked about. The people who own five games, 10 games, who every time I bring some tried andrue games, they're like, "Oh, I've never heard of that before."
And they just love, you know, one time someone introduced to them Junk Drawer, this little, you know, game by a small publisher in Washington DC and they just fell in love with it. So, they bought two copies and then copies for all their adult kids to play with their grandkids. And they're like, "Well, I heard there's a board game night at Devil's Club. I'll go there on Mondays." You know who gets this? Vicki. Vicki is getting a copy of this. Because she would love just going, "Oh my god, there's so many great games out there." Yeah, this is awesome. Thank you for coming on to the show. Thank you for this book. and thank you for just blazing trails and being an awesome voice in the board game community, Jay.
It's really humbling. Um, I kind of think I'm a bit of a dick, but that's okay. Well, you can be kind of a dick, but you can also be kind of a leader uh while being a dick at the same time. Terrifying. All right. Yeah. Thank Thanks for having me on. Yep.