Skip to main content
Loading video...

Igor's Variant (Abomination: Heir of Frankenstein)

Transcript 19:16

viewer discretion is advised everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free on your book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video interesting topic over the abomination heir of Frankenstein which is a game that came out this year by plight at games I have done a run-through forth and I've been discussion for it but spoilers uh we did not like that game like at all they were very very in our opinion in our opinion and only our opinion it there's very little redeeming qualities about it and you might be thinking this is another discussion or another video just a bash on that game but it is actually not I'm going to be praising this game for a couple reasons one after I published the review and or are the discussion and the run through with the creator of the game messaged me on BoardGameGeek and he said hey thank you for covering my game I know it wasn't your cup of tea but I still appreciate that you you you know did a video over it which that is actually awesome like for this is one that one of the reasons why I love the board game community because there's a personal connection to the designer to the game the game to the player and then the player to the designer because it's typically one person who has designed it

unlike video games where there's a whole team of like artists and sound designers and then riders and all that and is a huge production there's most more than likely one person's name tied to it for example Isaac Childress to glue maven like he's the made glue maven so it's like everyone ties that to him so you can actually meet him you can meet the designers for abomination of frankenstein you can meet the

for or glue maven you can do all of that and I've never had a bad experience with with meaning a creator of a game they're always very friendly and it's one of my favorite things to do whenever I go to conventions like Gen Con you get to meet them get on a peer-to-peer level and that's that now some people throw fit if I mean but that's not what I'm here I just want to say that that was awesome for him to reach out even though because we we did not like abomination at all in our in our eyes and for him to still reach out and not be like you know [ __ ] you and [ __ ] your channel and and you guys have no idea we're talking about you just you're just hit you know he didn't he didn't do that and I just wanted to get that out of the way that this was awesome now the second thing was they released an update for this and it's actually very very interesting they basically created a variant for the abomination error for any scientist cover two of the biggest complaints and these two were complaints that we had as well was the length of the game and the randomness at the end of the game I so the game once again was with way too long for what it was there wasn't enough options to you know and variety for for things to do throughout the game and then after playing the game for at least like two hours it came down to the role and luck of luck of dice for the whole

thing you're doing you're trying to build a body of brain Stein spoilers I guess for the game even though it's a replacement but you're trying to make you know get resources to build these body parts that you roll dice to get them alive and then you are try and that's how you get a bunch of points and it I'll run through and once again spoilers for that but I mean it is what it is i won only because dice did not go the other players way like literally he rolled so bad that he got no points for his final creation and i and I did [ __ ] that whole game so those were the two biggest complaints that we had but the creator's applied high games and the designer has to have created a variant the egor variant which addresses both of those so I'm just gonna go ahead and read us and we'll go over it after abominations release some players expressed a desire for a shorter version of the game while others asked for more ways to mitigate the luck element in an effort to address these requests but without compromising the experience we developed the egor variant it's significantly shortens playtime while giving players more control over the dice rolling aspect of the game feel free to use this as your official set of house rules or this bar the elements you think are best suited for your playgroup so the reason why I wanted to do a interesting topic over this is cuz I want to talk about the fact that they went out of their way created a variant to address the main players complaints for it which is awesome like a lot of people don't do that a lot of people

can't do that so the fact that they heard the complaints listen to their customer base and actually made the changes to accommodate what the majority of players wanted is fantastic and because this isn't like a video game where they just you know a few people complain so here's here's how it is for everyone if you didn't have those issues if you like the random disappear or you dip up the length of the game was fine great then just play the game but for the it sounds like for the majority of people who wanted to like this game but hated those two elements you can play this and then you can experience it who knows like unfortunately I will probably never try this variant so personally I actually don't know if this fixes the issues of the game but I still wanted to do a shout out for it because I just don't want to play the game again um but so the setup changes let's see let's see so there is an event rounds with police tokens are skipped in an execution event automatically occurs whenever this happens during the reset phase so the first player still draws on the bank card at the beginning of the neuron but ignores execution icons here so now you can actually cause like the the rounds to go quicker like actually if they have a what was that what they say a execution event it automatically skips it which is awesome so at the end of round one here's an example the captain is advanced to round 3 skipping round 2

which is covered by a police token and the captain was essentially your round marker and there are very few ways to get him to go forward and if the the round tracker was already so far ahead you couldn't advance it even further so it law you have to go through like 13 rounds or something um an event card that's drawn and resolved normally but an execution event also occurs regardless if an execution icon is present or not so if an aid captain Walden card causes the captain to move past 2 skipped around during the city phase no new event cards are drawn so basically he just goes faster which is awesome because like but he doesn't do really anything he just is your round marker so that's awesome the fact that they they now have you go past that so then there is a city phase if you buy ice you must place it on your half-melted side that now only last one round instead of 2 when players use a scientist action to charge late in charge they may charge four jars instead of three so now you have more attempts to roll the dice and then the lab face so throw the switch charge Leyden jars can be used for rerolls after a player rolls dice during throw the switch trades they may spend one charge Leyden jar to reroll any number of those dice it may repeat this for each charge Leyden jar they have remaining this mitigation is an addition to any of research cards they have to play that's awesome because the Leyden jars were literally I basically used to roll dice and you also had card to let

you roll dice and that's kind of hey what you guys what you got sorry you spent six rounds collecting all these resources to build these body parts you know [ __ ] you and that's you wasted so player a has four charge Leyden jars they may choose to flip one over to uncharged side and roll two dice same as for however they may now reroll one or both dice up to three times performing one re-roll for each remaining charge late jar they have if player a 100 to roll six dice flipping three lane jars it may spend their last Leyden jar to re-roll all six of those dice or any quantity up to six that's fantastic like the fact that you get AI even now have four Leyden jars instead of the three so now you have even more options to dice to roll because you can roll hey okay I have four charts once I'll spend two of them roll four dice man okay I I really needed one more result okay so I'll keep these three and then I'll spend the chart and I'll roll that hide and get it but you still have one chance and then you guy then at that point I mean you can't really get I mean you can still get frustrated but at least you had opportunities versus just the okay I got my four dice okay well those are all [ __ ] so Wow and by my body parts you know dad said yeah just look them over and it's just it's just awful and the fact that this can be used like towards the end of the game or at the end of the game is even even better black hearts on grade arts are an optional alive trigger if a player rolls a tub party it basically they got wounded they may

place an eye marker on one monster part at the cost of one humanity for each result otherwise they would ignore this die result and receive no penalty if playing baptise to this psychopath they must pay to reputation instead of one he managed to receive this benefit hey that's fantastic they actually like Baptiste was absolutely broken like he was a guy who he couldn't gain or lose humanity and initially you might think oh okay well he can't get any therefore he's not getting to 20 points but so much in this game causes you to lose humanity that the fact that he could do whatever he wanted and not take that penalty was a bigger benefit than him able to potentially get 20 points because you as another player have to work really really hard to get the 20 points for Humanity because so much of stuff causes you to lose it so either the fact that he has to now pay reputation to do that is is good players cannot place an AI marker on the head of their monster until all other five other monster parts are built and fully alive the head must be animated points great great the end game scoring alive markers ignore endgame points on the anatomy cards for AI markers instead earn five points for each AI marker on any monster part except ahead earn ten points for an iron marker on the head so basically it's if you have your full body alive by the end you get 25 points this is absolutely fantastic the fact so

the thing I wanted to talk about was the fact that they they listen to their community here so here's a perfect example because right now the fallout 76 thing is doing a how the dollar subscription like for player fallout first to basically play that hot hot garbage game and but that's that is just like you know [ __ ] you give me money and not listening to their fanbase in any way that's obviously one example there are many many very very very good video game companies that that do listen to their fans but like I said because board games seem to be on a more personal level and you're kind of like I can reach out to high-end you know designers and most likely get a response back I can reach out to higher-end you know more popular reviewers like the dice tower or Rado and get a response back it's just on a more personal level even though those are technically celebrities within the board game industry there's they're still they seem more human it's weird because these just cuz we have the opportunity to talk to them more than talking to designers of a videogame and it's just it's amazing that instead of being like like plaid hat games for example props to them for even making this as well because they could have just been like okay well people didn't like the game that's that but I'm assuming plaid hat and the designer really wanted to make this game work and they wanted to

appease as many players as possible so they created the variant why this variant wasn't added to begin with I don't know maybe maybe there wasn't enough play testing or maybe I there could be a hundred reasons why that this wasn't included but it doesn't it is it is and this is free to print you don't have to buy a it's not an expansion thank god this is not an expansion to be like oh yeah now here's an expansion give us an extra 40 bucks and now this variant decided to make it shorter no they didn't do that so it's free of charge you can easily just go print this or hell it's a PDF I have it on my phone and just like oh okay now will be worth a chance because what abomination did do right was it had an awesome theme like that's really the reason the only reason why I bother I didn't know much about it decent worker placement and and it had story element it's kind of like almost like hey this event happens and then if you choose this option then you go to a story spot in the book and then something happens with with Frankenstein the Frankenstein monster or or with the captain er something happened that made the game feel a little more alive and had the variety with the story element so you had a really cool theme where you are trying to build a body basically Frankenstein's bride and and then you had like the story elements and a decent worker placement but the work replacement aspect of it was ruined by

the length of the game and the whole game was ruined by the randomness at the to get points so just those two things that they fixed in this and this egor variant almost I mean I I would I do want to try this variant but I mean I just I have so many other games to play but if you're like me and you thought that the game was trash because of these reasons then these variants this variant it sounds like that this absolutely fixes the and the best burger I've always argued that an expansion shouldn't fix a game the game should be good enough on its own but I never would consider that a variant being free and a print a print off or a PDF could also fix a game and I think that that's awesome like I think that's in a different league besides an expansion can you wants to pay them you don't have to whatever works for me enough to beg them it's just like hey you know I heard you guys we heard you guys here's a variant go try this let's hope let's hope you enjoy our game and honestly because plaid hat was I was like man that's like why would they make this this game sucks and it almost deterred me away from kind of like a but the fact that they made this variant is like ok fantastic then well I will continue to look to plaid hat for games because for the most part they make they make really good games and they do put a

lot of love and care into it and just this shows how much love and care they they put into their product how much they put into their designer and how much they want their games to succeed and how much they want their family so definitely had to give it a shoutout for this because this was just awesome and it's it's just it's this is this raises the bar and sets the exam for other companies if you if other companies make bad games but the majority of people are complaining about the same thing and you can fix it for free then you should do so because then what saves companies is is brand loyalty and if you're gonna be like okay hey we thought it worked it clearly didn't here's a variant that can fix it you don't have to buy anything extra you don't have to do anything different you just have to print off these rules and and this will change it play with these rules from now and then the game should work and then if you try it and you're like this game is fantastic like I I would argue we gave me and cat gave it gave this game a three and and Josh gave it to the lowest scoring game that he's done and it's been a low the lowest scoring game that we've done but I can guarantee you even though I haven't tried it just the way it sounds and from understanding the way the game plays that this would probably bump this way way up and I'll never get to try it

because cat and Josh don't ever want to play it again but I can almost certainly just from my experience of playing games and and reviewing games and doing run throughs for games that this this variant would probably at least bump abomination air for a sign up to its six at least it just depends on how much it's short in the game but the game was way overly long and if it just jumps like that like if it takes if it jumps list from 13 rounds to like seven maybe eight at the most that cuts off five or that cuts off six to seven rounds and I mean you have to be way more efficient with your workers you have to work really hard to be able to get your resources and and then charge it and get them alive and then you have to like actually be efficient and to play the game which would make it a solid work replacement so I could see this easily going above a five at least for for this variant so those are my thoughts had to do a shout out for it because it's just awesome it's awesome this is a huge thing what makes me love the board game industry but that's it everyone let me know what you think of plan hat and man I cannot remember his name I want to say Chris and I don't think that don't quote me on his name but the fact that plaid had released a variant for this game let me know what you think of that in the comments below other than that like I'm insurance subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day that's for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like

this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button is a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day it is for you

Progress saved