Skip to main content
Loading video...

Great Western Trail Review - The Great Bovine Adventure

Transcript 14:33

cows Nature's greatest gift to humanity but if there's anything better than a bow Vine face staring at you with an equal mix of sadness and bewilderment in the morning it's got to be a cup of fresh milk straight from the cow's utter but in these mod Fast Times of Interstate commuting and Millennial tweets it's not always practical to keep a cow in your living room but what if I told you that there's a way to simulate the experience of having fresh milk in your trusty cup of joe introducing the utterly fresh Mantic simply part the entrance flap and pour your fridge milk into the fresh aromatic container cleverly designed over a period of years that's way too long by our team of scientists and now you're ready for the best milk in your cup of coffee a city Snicker can it doesn't work H and cattle is not a theme that anyone's asked for but Great Western Trail gets away with and that's because it might just be one of the best strategic games of this year and that's because it comes from none other than Alexander Fister the designer of mombassa which was a runnerup Game of the Year for 2015 will Great Western Trail live up to his expectations or will the deck building element sour it in my opinion we'll never know actually we will that's what this video is about all right then uh cup of tea Lane oh good jolly good cup of tea cup of tea then all right in Western Trail you're a

cowboy and on a steel horse you ride you're not really wanted neither dead or alive you're just delivering cows to Kansas City like any good old Euro game set in the American West you're trying to score points because we all know that Cowboys often Ender their lives right smack Dak bang in the middle of town square with that slip of victory points in their hands at ready here's the thing ideally I would explain to you right now all the ways you score points in Great Western Trail but frankly explaining relativity would be easier or teaching you the basic concepts of ancient Hebrew instead I'm going to try and give you a framework of what it is that Great Western Trail does because it is one heavy ball of chili of a game through the course of Great Western Trail you will un ironically be traveling across a trail stopping at various points and eventually reaching Kansas City with a number of cows in your hand and when you reach Kansas City you will make a delivery now ideally you'll want cows that are of different types because cows of the same type don't actually score you additional points then you will be able to get some money depending on how good your hand was and also remove one of these Pips from your player board and put them onto one of the stations either scoring your points or potentially depending on how bad your hand was even losing them but as these things often are it's not so much the delivery that accounts it's how you get there on your turn you will get

a number of steps and you can use these steps to move your cowboy man across the board to various locations whatever location you stop on will let you do a certain action that's printed on it or even multiple actions for example this location will let you build a building and when you build a building you take one of your special buildings and put it anywhere on the board now that's an action that is exclusively available just to you but also is an extra step onto your opponents making it harder for them to travel you can also move your move field train onto new pastures and when you reach certain spaces you will be able to do a station upgrade station upgrades are basically taking a pip off your player board again unlocking an extra action or extra ability that you didn't have but also score you victory points at the end of the game finally you can improve your hand by buying one of these better faster harder stronger cows they are cows with higher points values but also with victory points printed on them these cows will let you do better deliveries once you reach Kansas City get more money and finally unlock better slots on your player board and and and you can also buy staff now staff doesn't do anything immediately necessarily but they will improve the actions that you have making them either cheaper or somehow more profitable or just maybe better what makes Great Western Trail really crunchy is that

when your turn comes up and you're trying to figure out where to actually move within your reach you're not just figuring out what action you're going to be doing you're figuring out whether you want to do an auxiliary action instead see the main actions in the game are engine building actions which increase your ability to do things better whereas auxiliary actions are actions that often revolve around mitigating the rubbish in your hand so if your hand is full of jerseys you don't necessarily want to turn that in and want to make it better so you might do the auxiliary action of drawing a card and discarding one meaning that then when you turn them in you can get a better Stak not Stak station there's too many cows in this game so what stops me from moving onto every single location on the game board and doing every action possible well every time somebody reaches Kansas City they will put out new workers onto this track and that will immediately Advance the game clock so let's say I have these card s in my hand and what I want to do before I hand them in is go here and buy myself a new Cowboy well a new cowboy in that case would cost me $6 but I only have four available to me however this action also lets me discard a gery card from my hand and gain two bucks and I will redraw a card at the end of that turn the problem is knowing really what's in your discard pile and figuring out what's left in your deck so if I know that all my deck has left in it is just I might not want to go for that cowboy

and Shri simply shrimply go straight on to Kansas City and then there's this train track which is an odd little thing you see because your train always keeps moving forward it never really comes back to pick up the cows that you deliver to Kansas City just ever so slightly convulses backwards every so often but here's the thing I think what it's supposed to represent thematically it's not so much a single train moving forward but you your Railways expands the further your network is reached the less of a penalty you have to pay when eventually you do deliver cows that are supposed to go a long distance but thematically this can be unintentionally quite funny like in any other deck building game you want to remove cards from your deck from the game to make your deck more thinner and more manageable you want to do that because the cards you start with are a bit rubbish so you want to get rid of them so not only that your deck is more manageable but so that you increase the chance of drawing good cards and decrease the chance of drawing bad ones here's the thing though whilst in other deck building games deck Finning is a no-brainer in Great Western Trail it comes with a great counterbalance so deck Finning becomes less of a given and more of a choice every time you want to remove cards from your game you have to move your train backwards so in the very first aim I played my train kind of never left Kansas City yet thematically

I still kept delivering cows to it and still kept getting paid and the cows just stay there lounging in the train wondering if they're in Kansas anymore and now for an educational intermission from Ela one thing that gets me really excited in games is when they have an educational element and this game certainly does it teaches you about cows like the Jersey the Texas Longhorn the west highland the airshare the Black Angus the Dutch belt the Holstein the Jersey the west highland again which is very useful if you're ever on a game show about cows now interestingly this game does not feature the wonderful bovine creatures of Al and sck which is my main criticism this concludes the educational intermission from laay okay let's be honest here I don't like deck builders I never feel challenged by the decisions and the randomness of card draw leaves a sour taste in my mouth and whilst I never thought I would be disappointed by an Alexander Fister game I did feel worried and my first first game did nothing to assuage my fears I was drawing badly every so often and I my opponents went

and I thought look if I just drawn the right cards at that one particular time my game could have gone a lot better and this was me trying to remove as many cards from my deck as possible however there's something to be said about managing your deck in Great Western Trail knowing when to draw cards knowing when to discard cards and in my second playthrough I found that you can predict the outcome of your final hand and there's a wonderful feeling as well of uncertainty and satisfaction when you edge your little man into Kansas City and lay out a perfect 18 and say ROM and weep boys so well done Alexander Fister you have done the impossible you have made me like a deck building game and now I will eat my hat

I can't SW it oh but boys and girls we aren't even close to being done yet see when you first play Great Western Trail on your first playthrough you'll often feel like you're playing Solitaire because you're trying to wrap your head around and take this game by the horns whilst you're figuring out all the strategies available to you but once you've got an inkling and kind of figure out how the game flows you'll find that great West and Trail has an amazingly tactical element to it there are a lot of tiles on the board and some of these are buildings and some of these are your buildings and some of these are your opponent's buildings and there are also different kind of tiles called either hazards or Tepe tiles which I guess is a way of the art Department figuring out how to represent making deals with Native Americans but but the thing you should notice is the hand that's printed on these buildings see every time you get a turn you get a number of steps and moving a step is moving through any of these tiles but if your opponent lands on one of your buildings or passes through them that has one of your hands on it they'll have to pay you money from their account to your account however if they pass through neutral tiles that have hands sprinted on them such as these Hazard tiles they will have to pay money to the bank so when you place your buildings you want to place it in such a way that they will decide hm I think it's more profitable for me to give EA money rather than to give more money to the bank but but then there are buildings like this which basically give

you $2 for every building you have built on the board that is in a forest space so if someone builds that building you already kind of thinking to yourself hey I want to deny them as many Forest spaces as possible so I should probably build on Forest baces as well whether I'm going to profiter from that or not there is a lot to consider when you play Great Western Trail and especially because if there is a route that goes through these Hazard tiles you can build a building at the end of them and then when you land on it you will get extra actions extra bonuses and then of course you can clear these tiles and you can clear the hazard tiles for victory points or you can clear the Tepe tiles for money but that doesn't mean if you're not tactically minded that you will not enjoy this game if your group doesn't like tactics there is so much scope and this game is so vast that you can just play that solitire game of Great Western Trail and enjoy that pure Euro experience there's so much in it that you can do anything the question stands is Great Western Trail better than Mombasa no not to me but that's like saying I like Sergeant Pepper less than I like Rober Sal both are great shining examples of their craft and really as to which one you like better it's just a matter of personal taste still I think there's something to be said about the unified holistic feeling it's like the dur gentley detective agency of board games but in Great Western Trail there is a lot of hidden depth to Plum let me tell you about

these buildings see right now me and my group we think these buildings are the thing that is the most important thing in the game and you must watch what you building and your opponents are building a couple of games ago we were thinking that if you have a good hand you must turn in as soon as possible and now we think actually Turin aren't even that important and I think that in a couple of games we'll be thinking something else entirely especially especially I didn't even mention there's a whole second set of buildings in Mombasa and there's a whole objectives deck that can score you extra points there's just so so much to go into I think it's one of those games that will Astound players for a long time and maybe even rival ter mystica and how much people are going to get obsessed over how best to play this game so if Mombasa is Empire Strikes Back Then This makes it a New Hope which makes of Sky the Return of the Jedi and broom service that weird Ewok cartoon from the80s and all my goods the unspoken Christmas special get Great Western Trail if you like heavy strategy games you will really really enjoy this one my mama's watch in Venezuela mama like Cinderella Mama's got a by it

Progress saved