Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tidal Blades: Heroes of the Reef - Discussion

Transcript 28:30

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for tidal blades heroes of the reef which i gotta say was one of the most anticipated games that i had for this year i'm pretty sure it was anticipated because i positive you showed me i we we're having like weird deja vu where it's like yeah because i feel like there's a game where there's like separate pieces and i don't know it is it is ringing a weird belt because i know sometimes i would go into your office and and like either you would bring it up to quickly go away from my porn yeah or or at least pause it just to be polite or turn it now i switched to this kickstarter thing and you're like yanking it to tidal blades which you know wouldn't be completely out of nowhere because i think this game is fantastic oh i don't think you should gank to it not near that is the highest compliment that me as a board gamer viewer can give if you're yanking it to the to the kickstarter that is it no because normally we want to burn kickstarters yeah i mean this is this is what kickstarter should be lavish beautiful production well this is the deluxe edition as well well yeah but i think that's kind of really what you all always deluxe essentially i think there are standees like instead of miniatures um this is one of those games that i want to get these minis painted because there's like five of them so are there only yeah uh no i think there's actually yeah there's five because we played with

three and there's two others there's other humans we didn't want to play with those we wanted the cool chameleon guy the crocodile and the octolotto the cutest little um but here's the other thing is one this game is huge this box is massive but weirdly enough but inside they have everything organized to with the game tray so everything has its own spot it fits neatly into the box so organization game components are through the roof i even i touched uh your guy and i'm like he has weight to him he doesn't it doesn't feel cheap um the cool the cool squishy fruit i did like the squishy you handed it to me and i thought it was wet and i was like

um with the cool arena dice tray that is only cumbersome if you're playing with more people because you have to always pass the dice bearing when you have a table like this you just want to roll nearby uh i i i thoroughly enjoyed this game it was really cute it was pleasant it wasn't um it is one of those games where you look at it and you're like visually over stimulated yeah and then you start playing it and you're like okay now that i'm now that i'm going to the different places i can separate it easier mainly because there's a lot of dark shadowy elements on the board where um things could be it just gets a little lost visually sometimes but um specifically with like these two over here and really it's just a cohesive look but it gets a little right a little too dark but yeah i mean yeah because the the theming is that we actually have these uh tokens i think these are boat tokens so we're actually traveling along the water to these different locations to europe reading the lore book was actually pretty nice uh because it gave me the like i'm like oh i know what lamar stadium's about i know what the monsters are are here you know what you're doing what we're working toward yeah uh and i gotta say it was it was pretty well written it wasn't one of those things where as you were reading it they they just assumed you knew what they meant about their own constructed world they actually like it just throws you in yeah it was like sure they're like oh yes they uh uh yeah they they some half-assed names went by and it's

like what the [ __ ] is it um like what they did was it broke it out by okay the droska ring here's what this is about the humans are from here here's and then a little snippet at the bottom here's their weapon of choice here's the monster that comes from here um and it explains it all which does a really good job and it also i did not read this far i basically read about the different spots um and the background but they also went even deeper into each character's like backstory

so i i didn't read that far but but yeah uh and and to go off what you said the it this game was weirdly complex but not at all when you're trying to explain it it's just like yeah you go to that spot you get that resource you get a free action and you can also complete the challenge okay challenges here's what you do for challenges you have these dice okay the dice upgrade there's a lot of um like that straightforward path and then it just branches and then that one branches off and it just keeps branching so you're like okay hang on like hang on yeah but i gotta say the rule book was extremely well done uh every component to this is very very except for a few things that uh stood out to me like setting up the fold for monsters i'm not 100 sure how that's done it was weirdly worded so i just put the monsters there and then the outcast tokens on the score sheet it says you know each outcast token scores negative points that's shown on the front so that would mean that you would have gotten negative five and you would have gotten negative six yeah as well as you had the most so you get negative negative five when you had said that originally i could have just missed that wording because i i just thought it was the person who had the highest that's how i read it and that's what it reads in the rule book but then there's these penalty tokens that mean okay i guess you also get a negative point based off the value yeah so you can run the risk of actually taking even more negative points they're awful but devin what did you think what did i think it's a very pretty game

it does look good the components are nice i i mean have a horrible time yeah horrible time i don't know i i felt like i was grasping at straws i didn't know like any specific direction i wanted to go i mean yeah i focus challenges maybe if i read the lore like you did maybe i would have that little tickle of oh this is nice like you had your specific challenge and that's basically you're like okay i will do that because at least i know right where'd it go you got 16 points from challenges and you got your 10 points from from the market or from your special ability i kind of had an aimless feeling for like the first two turns where i was like uh that's fair like i said and i'm not sure how i feel about that sorry no no i was just gonna say i started there because i knew that would give me something to do right off the bat yeah i think this is one of those games where it's there there's so much that you can get points from but and and the way the game kind of explains it is like oh you can do all this stuff but in all reality there's two things that's mainly going to get you points challenges and fighting yeah those are two big things which makes sense behind the theme of the game where you are training and preparing to become a tidal blade champion and you do that by the challenges and then you can also be like i'm not going to challenge i'm going to prove my worth by fighting monsters and if you look at it devon and i kind of did both of those you did you did you mainly focused on challenges but you

you helped a little bit in the the fighting yeah it's devon went challenge heavy he got 16 points from that if we just look at my monster it's he got 16. i got 11. so in that same belt you got i didn't mean you got like 10 i got i have 10 points yeah so in total uh yeah you got 16 and i got 21. but i mean i lost i was like floundering quite a bit because i was just trying to get high level challenges now i did this one which is a four pointer but it got me no points you got oh zero points it was a sabotage that's the one that lost you oh and it gave me an outcast it gave me i was just i was just like doing yeah it gave me you know that's for doing it oh because you moved me back right like if i had completely ignored that one i think i would have been better set because i was more desperate too because it felt the timing of this game felt weird you think like it was only four rounds and that's so weird to me it felt really they're they're felt long they were long how long was that about an hour and an hour and 45 minutes but it was only four rounds so i was like stressed like how the [ __ ] do i do all this yeah there are multiple games where you get more actions as the time as as the rounds go on um but yeah essentially four rounds it's like you have to be really mad like like uh precise on exactly what you're doing i suppose my main complaint is that it felt awkward a lot of it felt awkward to me it's like it's not bad it's like it was it's fun but it felt so awkward

the whole time i mean the the shortness of the rounds i i how i felt like i could do very little but the same time i could do a whole bunch so it's like i have to prep to stack a whole bunch of [ __ ] yeah on one area and then there's the dice it's like if i want to keep building the dice i have to carry them over and then they get stronger and then they are spent i have to recharge them i go kill a monster which i didn't do i lose my dice yeah you lose but i have built this whole game and i think that's the balance is yeah on when you fight a monster you one for each hit you get you increase your um traits on top of you're getting ignored by the invasion and you also at the you get points at the end of the game right and you go up on the champion board so like that's where where i kind of pass there yeah so it's like it's i i very much like that risk reward where it's like okay i'm gonna go there i'm gonna fight the monster i got five hits let's say i roll five dice i spent my fruit whatever um i get five hits that's five traits that are going up that's okay i hit his armor and i killed him i'm moving twice up the champion board and i get the reward for killing him um but it's also but i lose all those dice and now i have to start over again because it's very taxing you know to kill some of these monsters um but you don't have to you got like take away your minus five for the outcast you would have had 38 points

so that is uh what is that two eight eight point difference um which is not nothing in terms of uh like points but i i can see where the uh did you also feel like the game was awkward i actually um i i feel like the concept of it is awkward i feel like i didn't have too much of a problem with it but only because like my challenges were my challenge was pretty easy which is master of uh which was funny enough it says master of time um i just had to go for synergy challenges which is easy for me to like they're out and open i see right if there's a synergy one up there um pretty easy enough to complete so i feel like i didn't have a problem with it but i i definitely feel like the the time concept is it's like i only have i only have four four rounds you essentially have four i mean you have uh four five six seven eight nine ten you have 12 total turns you're going to get in the game right it's um i think it's not a bad game you know it's fun it's well made but it's the layering of the game concepts felt like like comparative to like other games it felt awkward it was different it was unusual yeah just all those different effects the strange rounds the the different the dice leveling the loss of dice yeah how you act was resources the layering of uh area effects yeah so it was just

different different and it was just it had me off balance there's a lot of game concepts that are kind of not like others in other games which are like okay so this is kind of weird i think for the timing what they should have done that kind of help it is that whenever you have two tokens at the beginning of the game you essentially okay i get one action i get another action what they should do is allow you to leave your last one you know so in the first round you get three actions you know but the rules specifically say you cannot go to a location without because you don't have your boat correct oh that's it yeah that's a theming uh yeah that's your boat you have to ride your boat there but i'm aquatic so it's like yeah we're all aquatic so why can't we swim uh i don't know but yeah i mean i think it's like because in in the realm of this game and all honestly the thing that differentiates it from others is its lore and i swear kat and i were talking that there are other games that feel like this so it's like i i'm glad they tried something different i think that they did it in a pretty decent sandboxy way because here's the thing i don't think there's enough of this game to warrant it to be longer you know another round it's like oh man i'm gonna do another challenge you know i'm gonna go fight another monster it it lasts just long enough in my opinion it lasts just long enough for you to feel like you're being efficient um you have to be efficient with your dice

and with your actions and then be like boom this one i can only go fight with one monster because that's gonna wipe all my dice so that's why at the very end i saved it for the very last turn i went there and then i went uh there to go fight it and for me there's never there was never a wasted turn i think cat had that at the very end yes where you're like oh i got my last turn i was like yeah you had no dice left and then i just leveled one of my things right um and i think you were efficient oh no i was super inefficient early game oh i was getting my balance i mean that's when i was doing those shitty challenges they didn't give any points gotcha uh yeah uh especially with with the expansion the anglers cove which is which is a good expansion but i think probably one that shouldn't be played all the time painful just because yeah because of these outcast tokens which you have to go out of your clothes expansion yeah yeah no we gave it give me this guy it helps sagashi he was an expansion yeah oh he's cool he doesn't do any like a nerd he's cool i like him um he's only cool at his school that's fine i have my telepathic person who's looking for his wife totally wipe hunting isopod oh man but here's the other thing that i really like about this character in battleground oh terrible uh i think that the individual character cards are really neat yeah i did like those yeah those were really cute like you and you have to what's really cool is each trait gives

is special in some way so you you can build up your character in a way that's going to complement your strategy okay i want to go focus that means uh i want to be able to roll a lot of dice for challenges and or monsters spirit lets you do stunt cards like a badass resilience gives you your dice back and upgrade like a badass synergy more cards which therefore more special abilities um i like that and i think i think it's a pretty it's chewable it's not like oh god i have 17 different things i have my hand of cards i was really worried that when i was pulling these i was i was just going to get overloaded and be like because once again you're unless you really go high synergy oh actually no you will only ever get three cards out unless you have market cards but yeah like there's only three of the so you're only ever gonna get to pick two interesting and i think they did a really good job at managing the time of this game so you're not you know you don't ever see all your cards you you you get a decent amount of monsters to go fight because you're almost not you're not going to go in and one-shot it unless you plan like okay this is all i'm doing i'm gonna go get dice go get dice go get nice go get ice spend all my fruit six dice and hope i get it to be able to do that which you can but they did a really good job at also

making it feel like hey these are giant [ __ ] monsters one of us is probably not going to be able to go do that yeah technically the only reason i killed this giant mud crab myself was because cat poked it poked at once i licked him and and then i i planned to go out and fight it but then you were the one that was prepped to do that you could you had all the challenges to go fight the whirlpool and you were the disaster you would have gotten a level level three upgrade which was like a uh i actually forgot about that part so you would have gotten like an elite guy to go to go fight it so i'm gonna punched him right now you you actually probably could have one shot that whirlpool weaver with all that with all the dice because he's a son of a [ __ ] yeah that would have upgraded all of those uh your resilience your spirit and your synergy by two you would have gotten to also increase any trait die by one and you would have gone up by three on the uh would have been quite a few old point rooneys so i i don't know i think they did a fantastic job with the balance uh like no one's abilities felt like wow there you go that's good that's the end-all be-all card who's winning yeah um and for a game that relies on dice very manageable the danger die i thought was going to be gross but if you get shields or shells you're like okay i'm going to put it on there it very much

lets you um mitigate your dice which which when you're playing with dice you need because otherwise right it's just going to get mad because you're like well yeah it's like great oh [ __ ] up i failed again just generate shells it's really good i mean just re-roll okay re-roll and then when you get to four after you've been re-rolling okay here you can actually pick what you want yeah but you have now spent your shells i was actually going to say that about the the shield is like oh [ __ ] you have to put your shells on the shield but they're not truly gone at that point like because then yeah like devin said you can spend four and then eventually spend six if you get that many then they're gone but by the time you do that you've gotten shelves and for the record there's a history of the shell shield it's it's basically like a rare legendary item that that they give you to trial when you're when you're going through the challenges to become a title blade so they're like here you go use this um because i never felt like rolling the dice was hard you just had to spend a lot of your resources to be able to get the the successes right that you needed but was there ever a time where people failed a challenge i got that sick ass one that which is boom balance and i was like harry look look i did it um that was amazing i don't think i ever failed one out right yeah so as long as you have ways to get shells or it's super easy to go get it that's like okay for this turn one of my two actions i'm gonna go to the glass forgers and

you know get some shields and or get some shells and then all you always get to complete a challenge the game is very giving it's like hey have fun enjoy our world play yeah it wants you to play and have fun yeah because it's a game and it should be fun yeah and i of course i always love adding up scores it is a satisfying thing to do it's my favorite way of calculating points instead of having a tracker at the end because it's like oh i'm all the way up i'm at 15. i'm already getting actively discouraged right it's like great there's okay seth or whatever cat's at 50. until we all looked over that card yeah i mean there's i just love the art oh oh look drew's presence before finding a monster upgrade one die uh just look at how cute she is yeah i mean this game is incredibly adorable they have like a time travel neat element there is a a part two that they're planning on creating um like [ __ ] it's a fan yeah i don't remember exactly what i think it's in the same world but a completely different game like game style uh yeah cause i was like what the hell is this it's called the rise of the unfolders and i think it's coming out next year uh yeah i don't even know if there's a oh it's a dungeon crawl so players use deck building and deck enhancing to propel their characters through a story arc so it's set in the same world of tidal

blades but a completely different game which i think is neat i think if they if you're gonna do a game world series that's how you do it you you basically you don't make the same game just with a different theming over it any negatives just like my awkward complaint i don't you think that's just due to unfamiliarity it could be yeah um yeah it's not bad i was gonna say yeah it was like i don't really have um it was interesting because devon we were we were slowly moving up the champion board and devon's like how the [ __ ] do you get up there i almost i mean i got a little over half what halfway but it seems like the easiest way is monsters you are definitely supposed to fight monsters in this game i also just i guess what the awkward timing is i don't i didn't feel like i had a whole lot of time to fight monsters with everything else yeah there is this is a sandbox where it's like this is what you're doing yeah like you don't get to do everything yeah um essentially the locations behind the visual locations it's like okay what's my end goal fight monsters or complete challenges okay i'm gonna do that to prep for that final thing you know so if you don't like games that they don't let you do everything then this probably this probably isn't the game for you because it is a very tight game 12 actions but i think for all the negatives of it where it's like okay my resilience isn't high you have locations that give you your dice back you just have to

it's basically upgrading these allow you to to omit go into certain areas it's like okay i don't need to go to the blade advisor because i can upgrade all my dice uh because i my resilience is high i don't need to go to the desert caravan because i bought a car that lets me refresh or whatever right um so you find ways to circumnavigate taking the the unnecessary step uh before doing a big major one but i think that the challenge is being able to that's what the anglers cove is good for is you go there and you can complete any any of them instead of having to go to a specific spot um that could be blocked by other people minus five [ __ ] points yeah but the challenges you can take yeah let you either make other people draw them or give or give them to you uh it just didn't help that you were the one that kept going there and then cat finally went there and i was like i'm just gonna not touch that spot uh i honestly i don't have any negatives um in terms i think the stunt cards were a lot of fun uh they give you that one time bonus where it's like oh yes perfect my last one was useless because there's draw a number of challenge cards equal to your spirit level and i'm like well i don't need any more challenge cards i actually took two all the challenges i took for to give me another another set oh gosh but i ended up fighting the monster instead i uh couldn't get that last uh

right because at least with challenges you don't lose any dice unless it's it's monsters are rough yeah but worth it yeah that's i mean that's where all my points came from so high risk high reward yeah i i really don't have any any negatives i think it's a pretty clean game a gorgeous game yeah that's for sure um all right so you guys get anything else do you wanna that you want to bring up yeah uh let's see scale of one to ten uh who wants to go first you got a cat i'll give it a nine nine wow awesome so this is really effective wow awesome awesome squishy fruit is always a bonus it's not wet i think the dice upgrading is also pretty cool cool mechanism mitigation is my favorite part about the dice yep that is true devin huh i think i will give it i will give it i'm torn between seven and eight again oh man i'll give it up i'll give it an eight an eight it felt good it wasn't too bad i mean it's a lot i don't know how much you know getting other people in on it a little difficult no i mean you've got to play boardroom group which you always have if you're buying kickstart board games what am i talking about

no you'll be fine yeah i think uh that's like that is actually interesting yeah it worked well with three like i don't think there was ever really a time i think there was maybe one time i went somewhere that you wanted to go to uh but you had an ability that's like oh my god there anyway um and yeah i think with more people do they yeah i think they're yeah they're not front and back so it would get tighter uh with more people playing i think that's why this one adds a fifth player because it's another place you go to this would be more prominent as an expansion with more people because more people are going to be inclined to go you have more competition of who has the most um so yeah i think uh i think three was a really good number um four would be really good too that would really make it like okay i have to go here so now you're fighting for the first place token a lot more to ensure you're going somewhere right and probably more people are helping to fight the monsters uh i'm going to give it an 8.5 i'm gonna split the difference between both of you yeah i think the characters are extremely unique except for the two humans it's like oh man yeah i do like their own personal decks i do like the little story card yep and they even give you a recommender recommender recommendation on your play style on what uh strats you should go for which is kind of nice yeah i was all focused and resilient and you know what i was like i'll do just that

mine was uh let's see what was i supposed to be oh it doesn't even say uh but anyway my uh they also come with like i think three total uh end game oh uh like secret goals uh they also have a few other like minor expansions that you can add but but yeah 8.5 so that averages out to what 8.5 probably so you guys got anything else i don't think so cool so that's our thoughts on tidal blades heroes of the reef let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved