Merchants and Marauders: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to this discussion for merchants and Marauders we just got done playing a he epic game as with any pirate game that I start discussions Jeremih what do you think did you yeah I mean absolutely the previous one more the battle battle battle battle or about shipbuilding we have what you're into yeah this one there's two ways to win and that I just either you focus on that one and win in that way or you don't and I kind of buy first I was like I'm not gonna focus on anything but then I had fun like got into the routine of selling stuff realizing this little like island is like some paradise yeah it is so cool for you because you got benefits in the French different ports so it's just like I stay there whatever right but I don't know I guess I was open for more like role-playing game which is what I was expecting but it was not as much roleplay it was just like there's more mechanical energy than the others yeah your your little thing your little thing thing question if he was not here would
you have one how much would compromise gold yet storage I the only way I would want actually it's F I had probably two more turns and so instead of like if you were not as close to me as he was because this was my trump card was to get down here and get 15 more gold I have 40 in here dang it so this would've gave me but then I have to go back to port so that for your room Oh change it to a story yeah so that's all that was my trump card and how come you went this way instead of going there well I still needed I think it might not be 40 I was trying to get yeah it's only 30 34 okay so I still needed to sell another batch of goods Plus this 15 and get back and Toby then yeah yeah the UH okay so that I was stressed out because you kept putting go and I was like and you kept selling you sold so much and I'm like oh my god so him going there I was like oh thank god actually unless he fights it and wins because he was I was I was like my biggest downfall was my big getting out of the game rookie mistake says I started buying upgrades I would have already had money if I did buy these upgrades oh yeah but I wanted upgrades to know that I had almost insurance and battles which also had those glory cards out the wazoo
I had a [ __ ] time too that none of them helped the see the reason why I like this one and I played it three times now won the first time this was actually all my top ten games I hate until I did a revised edition because I played it again and I was like you know I actually held all the fun this time with four people I think it is - in my opinion the best pirate game that I've played because you do act like a party you go and in real like real warhead pirates you go and attack other nations and get bounties and stuff like that you stash your gold you buy your ship upgrades go on rumors like there's just a lot to it the biggest problem that I still noticed was sometimes you don't have to play and I uses this sorry and I use this phrasing weirdly because in my in my mind I guess it's more the player interaction part is you didn't interact with any of us and ever you played the part of a merchant you just went here but and you just kept selling and going around which is fine and there were probably a couple times where I know there's one time I could have won you know yeah maybe other times where they could have but I I was like well I could fight him but it's kind of out of my way and I want to do my own thing and now that's the problem that it brings me to specialists and and rumors and
basically anything extra the selling part is almost easy cuz you'll most likely be near something or closer to something unless you're like oh [ __ ] I need for my cargo I had rum and you'll never run what's up here and I'm like that's way out of my way but you don't have enough actions to do what you want to be able to go out of your way join but to say that's like you know what actually what would probably make the game a little more fun because you'd have a little more from you get a little more done in your turn and I knew that would make it more fun if you had one more action as or actions instead of three I think so too you could get a lot more done and it just kind of speeds up the game because of like a lot of our turns work alright your turn which I guess makes the game go by fast but nothing happens so for those watching I mean that's boring it is old watch with rumors like the rumor I had was I had to go to Havana I got that down there I'm like [ __ ] I'm not going all the way up there to potentially get recruiting and acquiring rumors is free you can always enter Havana so I mean it's cool like it's a cool it's a very it's thematic in my sense that means what do you think I feel like a lot real quick you can correct me if I'm wrong I feel like once I went on my way to attack you could you get the most gold and I attacked you and I want I feel like that killed it for you
well yes no I'll start off with I like the game but I also I do not like the game go over both reasons I will also go over that real quick okay at that point there was almost no way I could catch back no matter what I would have done I'm gonna have to say if I would have played it after that point where you did that there was probably no way I was gonna be able to catch up especially with the guy afterwards because he was awful yeah there was no way for me to catch back up to even be in the running so I like fun so you know and then I once he that guy I can't find him I only kept fighting him because he had only one one of the sword was one leadership one leadership so boarding was the best option and it always hit me with the cannons beforehand which lowered everything right that's what was killing me was he was hitting me beforehand right and that was just promotes my goal of that so yeah just go who I'm gonna kill this guy and you never worry about can I add to what you said yeah in this game to not play the merchant at first it makes being a pirate rough because if you don't get money you can't make a partnership worth having that's actually
I should the point is get - yeah why I'm I can also do not like the game and I do not like the game because as everyone that was watching will notice and as I kept track of in my head the only other person besides me to ever get a bounty was cat I got a bounty because I was trying to be straight-up pirate these guys he almost got about him I almost got about he what was it be that a Cardian whatever he did yes next time but this is why I don't have the ambition this is why I don't like the game though because this game actually rewards you for not fighting because if you look there's only ever going to be two pirate ships mm-hmm there's going to be four giant ships chasing around whoever's attacking these little merchant vessels yeah doesn't it make sense I mean it does but in terms of balance we've have smaller ideals there is no way to be a actual pirate without getting [ __ ] because not only did for about the four it will eventually be as we can see pretty strong for anyone that doesn't have a whole bunch of stuff and even one of my guys heads and they some stuff still lost you should have to worry about the other players that might want to fight you that's true it's a lie against you I agree with in your little gold return compared to the what 24 gold who are you guys are easily at 18 gold out for selling yeah easily raking in way more than you can get for any ship yeah the easily right right the is they order you for not fighting and
not doing anything but the merchant stuff that's that's a bad play honestly because it really limits what you can do this is what we can say about it kind of ties in is his little thing and also you can win by not playing the game almost it's helped merchants and Marauders so like what you just said being a pirate is like why would I when I'm not gonna win that way now granny if you win because at the beginning we're almost all uneven playing terms you and unfortunately the combat relies on dice and so whenever it comes to there's no strat I mean there is strategy based on okay well based on your ear abilities but it's like oh my leadership stew okay if I shoot or board it doesn't matter because oh look oh okay that was man oh you got more successes nevermind so the the fact that combat hinges on die rolls this is one of the things that it's just yeah that's and I feel like you've you yeah um you've he almost beat a man up or like had he boarded and had I not actually been able to shoot him it's possible I've taken on Man O'War is playing this game and once if you had taken that that would have been your ship that's how you upgrade then you take it and you repair it and stuff like that and but you're right you're right being a merchant is way way more easy
but you the downside is your ship is stronger if your dire goals go your way you take my ship and you my cargo you take my gold so but I mean other than that yes you're right the way I'm looking at it is you you start off the this is how the game more than probably nine years at the time will be played bumps anyone that's smart about the game we're going to start off being a merchant you're going to be a merchant until you've bought upgrades until you've bought a bunch of stuff then you'll go it will probably only either kill other players because you don't want someone to beat you or you'll only attack the big ships because you think you can win yeah that's probably 90% of how this game is replayed they're going to be a merchant for as long as you can to get tons of money which is going to be like two three turns if you're know what you're doing yeah to have easily fifty gold yeah which that's well you're not going to get fifty gold no like yeah you see my point doesn't take many times weighted there's a lot of my code this way it took I only had to get to six cool I could have only had five but luckily I got I got six you know the mission to be able to be like oh I have five I like the idea of stashing I think that's cool I think that's unique but I also feel like it's more balanced it leans more towards the merchants it's easier for me to go let's go I'm a store all my gold whereas you you're not going to get unless you raid merchants that's where you get your gold you raid these
guys which is why I attacked you because you attack these guys and you had 20 gold and then you had more than all of us in the beginning in the beginning and that's the only reason I when I was no like vendetta I was like oh I need 20 gold and because you had bounties I wouldn't have gotten the bounty to fight you and I got more gold because you had bounties but to be able to store it and only potentially only have to go up to five whereas you have to pretty much go up to ten unless you do rate these guys then you get your gold that way even though we'll look it this way you let's say you have two to three to seems to be very common again two items are in surplus that's how much cool 6oh in surplus sorry twelve well twelve gold for what could be that one right there that could be 12 gold right there I can attack one of these ships which will be three guards real quick let me three nine that's nine half this scene you roll your leadership to get a success you can add one more at the cost of more damage the closet for escape you can run what they don't at this ship yes yeah but if I pirate no yeah no the pirate ship you see my point yeah at best that's why one of the better things I can get on average their work I will say this though I did know this there's only if taking a lot of risk yes you guys are doing zero risk doing that that's true that's true you still take damage and which automatically makes sense but mechanically ie how you completely agree but there were times in the game where you went with the safer
bet even though it wasn't gonna damage your ship you could probably I would say two maybe even three times you could have gotten twelve gold which would have put you up there which would still put you in the running and you'd have a whole bunch of gold possibly by the riders I remember one in particular you were like okay I could add one but I'll say all the damage to my ship and you just and you got like seven gold good as part as well I also to worry about as we say the damage if I'm damaged by one point that could ruin my chances anywhere else I think you actually attacked me after I was still damaged from a fight I don't think so there was last time I played this game there's a rumor and they're called a ghost ship which means if you go and you find it you get I think of a galleon or a frigate but it's heavily damaged yeah my friend who we were playing with it's he was the one who brought it over after I already hated it I'll give it another shot he went there completely damaged I swung by attacked him ordered them took a ship in and I was able to take off because he started somewhere else take off and and and repair it yeah one thing I want to see to almost balance out the there is an expansion it balances but there it's the one thing I would do to like balance out the pirates to the Marches because the problem is with the pirates is you just don't get enough gold to make a ship worth being a part so I almost add like to defeat one of these have like a little symbol that gives you one of these cow yeah which we make so where if they had some on there if you go and like destroy a ship or something you
didn't like you take their stuff what you do if you attack it it's a vegan Arya man the attack nobody think it also take something that like greats of fighting my chance will do will do this so that's nine and we'll say my leadership which was two will say I got one so that's gonna hit my crew okay at this point I was a galleons abut that hit my crew but I got one success draw one it hits my crew again so that's nine that's twelve and then I get these spices all right and you get the cargo which then enter in human yeah what you're also looking using Kelly yeah flute so you have to worry about him running away because he had that's true he had enough to run away whatever yeah that's my point though basically the game this is this one er this is what I don't like about the game basically though is that it pretty much is encouraging exactly one style of play there is almost no other way to efficiently do it if you want to win you want to just win it's not impossible to win that's the pirate but now it's very much fun oh yeah it's so stacked against you and we only have three giant vessels out here but you can already see the board the Dutch never came out what but you can see the board that look how much of a pain it would be for any pirate to get around if these guys are automatically targeting you whereas you have to worry about this little thing and that as a merchant to one is a shitty ship that you can easily kill that is true the other is a decent ship whereas I'm looking at right now three
big ships plus a big ship event two man Awards you're looking at a frigate and then if I wanted to I could go out and attack you you write it with other players and ships I'm sort of missing one more ship it is so stacked against being apart and I know that's automatically makes sense yes but it wasn't that hard that's why so many people were doing it alright if actually was a thing because it was possible to do yeah there was risk but there was greater rewards then I did a ship my ship was half way damaged I'm gonna end up spending about four of the twelve gold maybe I got to repair it yeah would you say no much risk of course would we didn't see this because I was the only one that got that upgraded my ship yeah but would you say that have you been able to upgrade to a galleon or frigate that which the forget is the pirate ship of the upgrades besides the mantle or would you say that then it's been balanced you get a stronger ship to be able to raid and handle these guys man wars still my hands on dice tell us though that up there to say let's just say dice work well for everyone that it's not impossible it's not impossible and it becomes a lot easier but you have to try you have to work your ass off at that point you should accept the trip higher wage as a fire yeah at that point after you got your frigate you should kill it the players that's the one way to play what you mean yeah I have to or the other players as players should be your focus yeah how pirate has to be played and this is what I'm thinking and this would be the only way you can
win is to literally be a dick hit a couple merchant ships take whatever money you can buy whatever you can if you can and then immediately try and kill another player that's the only way to play everyone's gonna hate you for it well the only way you'd be able to get away with it that's Perez Danny what the merchant ships go for I'd say more than two rotations if you have merchant ships do it for more than two rotations they probably already have enough money that they they've bought some of these upgrades and I bought a couple of these upgrades and they probably have some rumors or something else they are strong enough to fight you easily at this point to where even if luck is my other side big abroad schedule in in my almost like my jerry-rigged I can get my full rotations of goods and three times yeah that's it that's a lot of money if everything worked out your face well here's the thing here's the thing that isn't a lot dependent on your end being a pirate is these are always here yeah those are always there other people are always going to be nearby where you can fight them these guys are gonna be around where you can fight them our side oh we have another merchants are know is there you kill merchants oh yeah yeah but they're literally on every spot they are but I have to hit every single spot but no wait for eight essentially twice you can get one for gold would you start out with ten which gives you enough to and there's places you can go you can go here and there there and I got my gallon for 25 possible right there's boss here's what Jeremiah and I had to do which sucks
it's like okay what's in demand near us Oh bananas that's where I'm at huh didn't get bananas okay my turns over and that's [ __ ] annoying cuz it's like okay well white wetland let's see let me look at the snakes I got okay so there's two rum we're good - rum oh look there's none on the board nevermind I guess so that's very luck dependent is what is with the cards because how many times will really like probably for the first time because I was trying to go after it was like this at the beginning I don't know what that was but I was trying to get [ __ ] tobacco I had two cards I think I went back and forth like two or three three or four times and I was like hmm look no tobacco I actually got a hand that gave me three of these and I could have bought all three of them nothing but we had none of this on the board Oh was just like exactly the options we get for the for the stuff it meant to get our money is we have to one I hope it's in the man if it is hope it's near us and hope we get enough to one because yeah we get the money but this is how you win if you beat a well unfortunately if you be the merchant if you do marginal rate you have to score twelve both gold yes but if not then but you beat other people because I beat you they can't make it work like this is how you win but still I understand yes--that's endgame obviously this game though it does prove that basically gold is the biggest Victor without it you can't buy
leadership without it you can't buy on your upgrade yep basically the fastest way you can make the most gold is go away one thing I don't like is I was noticing this earlier is unless I missed it in the rules you're if you were a pirate let's say I don't know where your guy is so let's say I was important I just realized ships give the one Spanish ships no no that's your color okay yeah um so here's a you're a pirate right if this was here and I moved out he tries to Scout me if you were here you're a pirate I can move past you you have to be you have to scalp me on your turn I felt I was really annoying because before this guy showed up and I wanted to actually sit here and I guess that they don't have that as a puppy guarding but if Jeremih wanted to make it and I knew he had a lot of money and he had to go here to statute I could just sit here and just be like all right okay you can try like especially with if I had my galleon alright try and make it back home but that kind of would make sense if I know where you live and I'm against you even though I wouldn't I'd get a bounty for fighting you but let's say I'm on the pirate I should be able to at least be like oh well there is no okay and you go into your port yeah but I that was super annoying because you're
you're safe in port which makes sense and with his little routine it was I've been I'm gonna go here and hidden does he which worked really well which was awesome yeah um for a free dork I was kind of all over the place my my goal at one point was to do a mission and I got I got lucky with my guy and then eventually our cards killing you and then getting all that gold but I'm a according to the mission a just the Dutch West India Company seeks help in establishing for trade posts make influence rules and non Dutch ports it doesn't say anything about different ports the only so looking at sends only loophole don't only like allude to it meaning more than one specific one is it said non Dutch ports it did have the plural in their sloop I would just take that you could allude to it saying it means the multiples that's honest equality a somebody have rule ordered someone has a dignity to the book right right because that's what I was I was sitting there and I was like cuz if that was the case and [ __ ] that I would have started going after you but I was like okay if I can just make trick of its trading post so you can have more than one automatically in a in a town or whatever somatically yes doesn't make a lot of sense but it can't be it could be like a ones over on this end the other ones on the other end of the oven yeah so that's if that's if that's not the case then I didn't win if that is a case that's technically how the card reads I did but what do you guys feel about the
events are kind of stupid typing first of all we were talking about combat what do you guys think about these guys do you felt they were stagnant okay yes and no I felt they were stagnant but they still have the Timnath intimidating right I would say they were stagnant but not for you guys or yeah it's not for me actually they were saying it for you because they're not looking for you you guys lose just like oh hey hey guys and just keep going like you know mother once they suspected once these really started to come out too that makes you even less likely to go man I'm gonna attack this guy why would I yeah this guys right here he ain't gonna attack me I got a big guy backing me up there becomes even less likely for you to do that once the big guys start rolling out basically wait for him to go after you and if you get weak but don't die yeah i'ma come after you even if you had weakened a Manowar and taken it over you would have just will potentially yes I still would have ended like if I was here one day I couldn't do that yeah but I mean if it was lines which puts into play yes for us or for actions is probably actually a really good thing to have but for scenarios like that and I'm far away now I can get to you and Scout you to destroy you yeah potentially still die rolls yeah be on it what do you think about actual comment I actually really like combat I think it's so much did you know yeah yeah where's your ex I bought the strongest thing on the board yeah combat
I liked it it's takes men to get used to because you have to remember like what the symbol means which is like switching I was just obviously no I mean like first thing you do this a good thing you do this yeah first you first you scout then you seamanship and you leadership if you're doing a cruder about yeah if you're going if you're gonna board but all that stuff that wasn't yeah in in any other part and what we have done the other one but it's just like the other one was literally oh okay and but in this one I think it's really cool how you can potentially board and then now it comes to crew combat it's kind of weird though how your leadership like your captain's leadership is what's based off of Rooker so if I I have four crews or if I couldn't have five crew that's still based on to die rolls it's like but I have five guys that should be five rolls you would think and that's what you guys kept doing you're like okay so I'm shooting so she did my cannons like what at first it was a little confusing once you got that hang about the pretty simple because it's just like Scout okay cool and then just jumping between either seamanship or leadership I I figured the way I think to look at crew because I kept trying to look at it as a the way you should look at it is it's basically a health bar that's it I looked at it it's like okay I succeeded
in this in this boarding thing how many I have do a role for now that's not it basically it's just a health park that's it yeah that's the way to look at I was looking at thinking my brain kept trying to do some weird stuff with it because of all this stuff they kept confusing with cannons like you said yeah yeah they kept going like wait here they sell a spy knife fork and a social role for dice I wanna get any hits I have three guys or something no you don't really for that like right right yeah okay you're old you it's and it makes sense it's like seamanship if you're captain's ability to maneuver around the battlefield and then if you okay he lined up the shot now fire so when you think of it that way it's actually really cool um with dice you have to think of it the magically yeah okay well you're not just standing there with your boats hit me if you're moving and like I [ __ ] went to shoot and hit a wave or something and that's what makes the game cool because then you think of it like just just swirling around each other yeah until you have moments where it's like alright guys let's do this alright cool nothing happened yeah well yeah well both ends oh okay all right three three tries later we both [ __ ] oh so I still have a stick which uh one more thing enough high schools in general that happens in like most other games too so I'm not gonna be mad about that yeah nice games anything who uses dice for combat I thing is the other thing I don't like captains are super imbalanced captains necessarily choose Li as exactly and as soon as we looked at Kats
first [ __ ] pirate and she was supposed to play as a pirate like she got abilities to fight no I'm pirate ships which means she attacks merchants and she's find just to stash gold like what the [ __ ] was that about think that makes no sense I didn't I didn't know at the time but after a clipped game a while I actually felt like the baby's at Gold's courier is like a special ability that can be chosen to be used anyone could pay five gold to stash their that was what I thought that meant oh that's what I thought it meant I wasn't sure at the beginning but then as the game came along I realized I was like I think that's actually what this means so because that's what I just seemed it to mean yeah it absolutely makes sense and the I guarantee that's probably how it's supposed to because that would make sense you go over there and you know what anyone can do it there but if it's not her she doesn't for free we would pay five gold just yeah it's not our home which makes sense but that's why I was like white because it doesn't say other pirate and like other people stash gold Yeah right I only thought about it because I looked I started looking at this all right this is rules cost no gold it's not like you're going to choose do I want to pay for that rumor roll or do I want to just not that's true that's interesting like that
I mean there's there's a couple others - it doesn't it feels like you have choices and I feel like that one is is for other people that that would make sense one last thing is I do like how each box that's a Caribbean city has different abilities but I feel like that is not new player friendly like even me I've played this game or that you have been at the time I'm like okay what does I usually go to a spot and then I'm like okay it doesn't benefit me no I'm not sitting here okay I'm gonna go there next time yeah that's actually what I was trying to do with these I was trying to a you or looking at I thought I have been trying to play before I dug the first time I literally was trying to plan everything I was looking at what could be bought and sold once a while I checked by goods and what's near me I'll buy this even it's only one right by this and I'll just go here real quick right even that okay so scale 1-10 for our game which I max I really sprite you didn't play as pirate I couldn't yeah yeah alright scale one to ten I think we'll keep my nose I probably you a second six because it's a fun game I'd like it don't get me wrong was limited choices and play and kind of lower it and this is just nipping and just mean and there's some aesthetic things that I don't just like I'd have liked every major like these have these be a completely different ship oh yeah oh yeah that would be really cool and just
like us a completely different style of ship view completely different style there's some aesthetic thing yeah I wish it was a bigger map like you said maybe just like one row here one over there just just a little bigger one thing I was actually disappointed in is the Caribbean Sea there's nothing in there I was actually kind of hoping there'd be like some Kraken event or something they're trying to keep it realistic yeah something like something happening in that form a triangle is something like that but yeah it's more one of those things it's like a center almost it connects it's easier to get around yes is extremely nitpicking but I pointed it out before they illustrate it the the flag going backwards when the sales are going forwards oh wow I hate when anybody like tries to draw pirate ships because they always think that the flag goes backwards but that doesn't make any goddamn sense wind is blowing that way right oh that's just anyway uh so that was our thoughts on merchants and Marauders I'll probably think of other things to say but let us know what you thought in the comments below like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you Hey thank you for watching and I hope that you enjoyed the video if you want to help out the channel I on my patreon link right there if you want to make some suggestions on more games you'd like to see us run through I have my board game equalist right there and when it does you don't like the Facebook fan page at my facebook link right there that was wonderful whatever time of day
it is free