Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arkham Horror (3rd Edition): Discussion

Transcript 25:41

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for Arkham Horror 3rd edition so goddamn I can't just freaked me out uh all right so basically this is the third edition yeah this is a third edition um I'm trying to think of where to start with this because there's there's a lot that they do different in in this edition / 2nd edition but I will say nothing in this game is original ideas like everything that they have like the mechanics in the game they took from their other games so it's not like they stole from like other companies they have it's basically learned from all their other games and incorporated into this because second edition was so clunky eldridge horror became clunky and even though it was supposed to be streamlined when Eldridge horror came out they were like no where this isn't going to be like Arkham or we're gonna keep it streamlined and simple high link and then they just kept pumping out expansions and adding more and more and it's just like okay well this is just as convoluted as Arkham Horror at this point so what I am going to do is we are going to talk about the things that are different in this that they did versus

Arkham or second edition and we're going to talk about if you like them so that is actually the obvious one a modular board what do you think of the fact that it's a modular board instead of just a regular board like Elder Chaura had the whole map they may not and Arkham Horror had Arkham with literally just like circles for their spots and then just this lame-ass town these lines that determined how they get from place to place do you like the modular board yeah I think it's yeah I did too um I I think it's pretty neat because the game is scenario-based versus just hey here's your game play it yeah I like the modular board I think it can add to it feels more I think like a town for some reason like you have the street locations and stuff like that I don't know I think they kind of took their idea of eldritch we know it's the different cities you can go to and go by train or by sea - yeah I I really like the modular work grant I always like modular boards granted my initial thought with the game was you actually explored out so you started assigning names and yeah yeah you just added tiles if you went they didn't do that but yeah these are double-sided so there are like south side and the Miskatonic University and other places that are familiar if you're

in the game absolutely otherwise you'd be like I don't care I that's true yeah no I agree I think they did I think they went the right way with this one or they would have had to do basically mansions and just redo that which they're not gonna do this can keep pumping out expansions for that that's not my pose okay so the modular board but so we like that what do you think here's the biggest difference honestly between this game and the other ones is this one is scenario-based unlike arc more and eldritch where it was just here's your game here's your ancient when you're trying to stop move around find clues and do that this one actually has a scenario that you start with certain cards from this archive deck which they took from their Fallout game if you've played their Fallout game you're gonna easily recognize this it's just a deck of essentially story elements that they take similar to the encounters and fallout where it's like okay this happened pull card 12 and now this is what's going on or pull cards you know 19 and 30 and add those and then you have and they kind of unravels the story of the scenario and the base game comes with four scenarios what do you think of that yeah I like it you like the scenarios yeah I can't wait for them to make more because of course if you just blow through it you're like and like you're right right so I have

mixed feelings about it I liked I liked the scenarios I think that's really really neat and this is our second time doing this one and we even cheated to to just win it because last time we played we just got our ass you're right you're and there was that but I mean whatever I I couldn't care less about that because we were literally once that one turn away yeah so it was a faux wind bite it's bittersweet because if with scenarios and this is the same way for mansions for me is that great we've done this one I don't want to do this one again like now I have three more to do and yeah if you and luckily we won't blow through these four because I we've just placed so many games all the time it's hard for us to come back to to them again unless we like her like okay I want to do the next one so luckily if you space it out four is enough but if you don't have a lot of board games for won't be enough and that's where I think it also hurts it because in Arkham or an elder tour you it was always new content yeah the game was the same and the game is the same here but you never ran out of meet those cards or you never ran out of encounter cards they it was always fresh and something different so I liked it but I still think I prefer the open world of Arc more second edition and

Elder tour on the way to think do you like this better than just hey here's your ancient one because that you don't know how to win in these which I do like I think that's neat I feel it yeah it's more thematic I think with the scenarios but it almost has to be like if it didn't if it wasn't the mattock he'd be like well what the [ __ ] is this it's a point of this lame-ass tener so I think they did a good job with this opening one it's just a ritual that you have to go figure out where it's at to stop as the top versus the other ones of just reality gather clues and prevent the in Eldridge's to solve three mysteries Arkham is just it's been a while there are a couple ways you can kill the ancient one or try to or I think it was like get five closed gates or have no gates on the board or something like that mmm-hmm I think you're right so what do you think you look the scenarios more you do okay okay even though it could get kind of lessons replayability

doesn't play board games as much as you do know where people don't play games like this anyway I mean but like you know it's kind of a good like it was fun just doing me but like it is fun to have more these two people playing and so I think you know sometimes it's hard to get a group together like that are people like that's in a certain like times of the month I go we're gonna have game night tonight then we'll do it then if you're doing that like theoretically that's that's four months of gameplay by the time they're probably gonna pump out expansion ten expansion names on for yeah yeah no yeah no that's a good point um I think for a game night yeah I think it's also easier to draw people in versus just because Elder tour and Arkham can be very daunting just like oh my god what's all this stuff all these cards all these tokens yeah I think a scenario setting is better that way okay alright so that's the biggest difference between this and the other editions I would say what is first ups

a couple more characters well there's all these there now oh no they're all saying like yeah yeah I think at this point it's um like it's everyone from the lore so yeah you are gonna always see yeah the same thing yeah you're you put him back in the world and you're like apparently they thought direct Murphy yeah they really did like he is permanently blessed first while resolving into only six of you cannot become blessed or cursed yeah yeah that sucks I mean they made it more thematic so let's see just ramble off some differences Oh so you say you like this deck like the fact that this goes through I do too and I think that's probably the only good thing about the fallout 4 game um what do you think about how Clues come out because in Arkham Horror you just get them Eldridge [ __ ] you have a clue encounter if you're in a spot with a clue you have a clue encounter what do you think of the fact that assuming that Clues get shuffled into the encounter decks I mean I guess that does make it more realistic because like you're not just gonna walk into a room be like a clue you're gonna have to look around yeah somatically you're gonna have to actually yeah I I agree right right

I think yeah I think in the other games especially Arkham or a second edition where you just got them or if they popped a bigger spot you just grabbed them it was like - thematically represent that you were spending time so this is kind of like it was just cutting out the middleman hey you get it the game was already hard enough as it is eldritch or I think elevators still did it better because you had to have a specific encounter like you didn't have to hope that that you found it so while I agree with you it is more thematic and I like it for that I think it's probably my least thing about the game because Devin said it last time maybe as Rex Murphy his whole center of as a character is centered around research and finding clues and the fact that all you can do is hope that the card comes up and hope that you can meet the requirement and if you can't that you're just like well I'm [ __ ] useless it sucks to be that person so or if you run to like downtown hoping to find these clues and open opus tetanus card isn't it if you almost at least for me I didn't care like what was happening if it wasn't the clue card yeah like whenever we were both in downtown and it was like great that wasn't the five [ __ ] it it's like I we need these clues at this point it was becoming frustrating and whenever we played this last time when Devon was like he I mean he only succeeded on sixes grin he got all the luck the cards

in the world that helped him reroll and mitigate his his luck he it doesn't matter if you don't draw the cards that help you get the clue so I think it's incredibly frustrating wild formatic it's it's still my least favorite part about the game so yeah and if you don't know I mean if you want to run through read and clue cards come from this event deck weights get which spawn based off of this Methos tokens which I'll explain which will probably go to next and then they get shuffled that's the top two so you know it will at least be the top three one of the top three cards so at most you're gonna have to have three encounters but that sucks because that means you're just wandering around the same area and if there's no doom token - you're literally just guess I'll go here guess I'll go here and you're becoming increasingly useless to the team yeah you are helping and you really are like even if it's like I'm only removing one ward it's like good because if three spots are in or three doom we're in a spot and anomaly sure look if five total are in a neighborhood and anomaly shows up and those suck because the doomed is ramped onto the Aereo card and that happens quickly yeah like we're like oh great yeah no we're kicking ass and we were then it's just like oh three happen in an oak gate burst boom now here's three immediately on this spot so if you even let up once

you are you are hosed or if you let koltes live and it's like [ __ ] it then it becomes you you just think spiral out and if that's how every Arkham and eldritch is if you're not on top of it it will spiral out of control and then you were just playing catch-up which is thematic and I like it at the end of the day even though I'm frustrated I still love it so there's only really a couple things that oh okay so here's a quick one there are no gates in this game and there were gates and eldritch and Arkham and to close them you had to go and have an Otherworld encounter do you like that you like the anomalies over the gates yeah neither do i I thought the gates were cool in thematic and you got to have this weird otherworldly encounter that is like oh my god what's happening here yeah and I felt like it and I oh yeah an arc or a second position it was you could be lost in space or time and then disappear and you're all [ __ ] up Eldridge Tory you actually had otherworldly like specific counters with choices as well the anomaly tech isn't bad it's it's based off how much Doom is in your spot and that's a way to remove tomb which I like that but I think it actually lacks theme I wasn't engrossed into the story with the anomalies versus the other world encounters so I don't

hate them and they are helpful and they are kind they do kind of make sense because hey anomaly is weird things are happening in this neighborhood but I just like the idea of gates over over over anomalies so that was a quick one what they're gonna say next oh the event deck so no not the event I started to meet those coming do you or do you like this or do you like amita's deck Arkham Horror it was literally just a made those deck I'll only say that I like the meat so stick more because passing the cup around got really [ __ ] it does get old it was like I don't want to have that cup handed to me one more yeah I mean you could easily do a bag where you could toss the bag to some of its like oh my god just handing it back and forth um so they took this token idea from their card game where but it was more than that I mean there was really me those things that or the the tokens in the card game are your tests there aren't die rolls or anything like that but they still do the draw on tokens I don't know I I think this is harsher I think the tokens are way more mean than any me those card can be and I do feel like this yeah and it's like yeah it sucks any other ablaze yeah so uh I

don't like I don't like this more than the other two so Arkham Horror second ish and just have the deck and there could be weather effects or or other effects like somewhere one time but at that point the art namizo staff is like this [ __ ] big I think El Detroit did it way better each ancient one had their own Mito stick organization they didn't have their own cards but they had their own okay we're you have level one and you have one blue and three yellow and one green and that's level one you shuffle and then you go through that tier system where it shows just gotten worse and worse as the Methos deck went on I like that way better I think this is a neat idea um I just think it's way way harsher cuz I returned your everyone's drawing too and that's bad so I feel like you're constantly trying to play catch-up with you look I did you Hey she blinks yay okay well the blanks are out now so great burst Oh two monsters spawn instead of just having cars where it's like okay well here's my meat so stack all right and Elder tour anyway it's like okay clue show up monsters spawn and then this happens than the effect I just I like that way better than the Mito scope let's see okay so that was pretty much it the monsters are there they're just not tokens they're cards with their own kind of effects doesn't really that didn't really change much now those were

the main big differences between this and the other game what do you that what don't you like about this game no I guess you like it okay okay oh what do you think about the doom tokens they took that directly from their card game really oh yeah because in the card game you have like a scenario and an act and over time doom will get added to one of the cards and it has a threshold so you're on a timer kind of similar to this one where it was like okay there's seven doom on this then you'll flip it and then something will happen whereas you have to place clues on the act and once you have a certain number of clues you advance it so it's similar very much to this where it's like hey once there were three clues here flip it and then Oh once there's three doom flip it read this card and stuff like that yeah what do you think of that I think they're just part of the game just like I mean it's kind of like asking me how you like the doom counter don't like that mechanism or do you just like the free flowing okay I mean that's literally what I was asking you yep yep Devin answer is here well yeah it doesn't like I'm just the wrong person asked about mechanics sometimes like it just did it did its job and I guess I mean I like it

because I like it because it's a visual counter that you can realize how good or bad you're doing so yeah but it wasn't oh you talked about the doom and eldritch correct but that one I felt sometimes was just negligible like there are there's multiple games and elders where that thing never moves whereas this one this is gonna constantly happen at some point like in one way or another like the news news articles where it's like hey take three horror for the doom in your space it's a crap I don't want to do that I love you either those but I I don't know I personally like it I very much like it in the card game so it works for me here let's see what's your what's your favorite thing about this game its Arkham or here's the actual question do you now that we've played it more we've played eldritch and Arkham way more but do you think so the first part is give me a two-part question do you like this better than those two you do yes interesting probably a couple years ago yeah but we've played it so many times interesting you're boring well I mean I

just don't really remember much about it to be honest because it has been so long since we played it we mainly played into the madness now so I'm stuck on mansions of madness how it works so yeah I guess alrighty uh for me I don't I do like this game and I'm definitely going to keep it but I'm trying to I I think Albert or is my favorite just because I like that openness more I think it adds more role-playing I think it has way more customization even-steven the base core game i felt like was just more engrossing even though i do think this is way more streamlined now that is to say the second part of that question if your answer was no is do i think over time will this one replace them and i do i do think at some point this will become more streamline because all they literally have to do is add more scenarios more locations and you're good to go like this is probably an easier one for them to add expansions to than the other ones because all you do is add way more cards more clue cards more all of that and more scenarios and then it starts to become a fantasy a fantasy flight game where it's it's like all right here's the streets deck here's the downtown deck here's the scenarios and I mean and then you're good to go here's more islands and stuff like that but yeah I think over time they can just

do I think they can do so much more with this one that it revolves around the scenarios first it's just all the encounters that you have so I guess I do like I do like that um yeah yeah I think I think that's it I can't really think of anything anything else I like the fact that every character has their own starting cards the other ones had that but they were just your generic cards there's these are specifically tied to the characters and yeah yeah I just think they did a lot of a lot of good things so you have anything else either calm Oh combat I should actually mention that combat is so much better in this one it is so streamlined and so smooth versus like okay so I need to roll the I do make a sanity check and then okay so it did I get that cuz combat eldritch was [ __ ] confusing Arkham it was a little bit easier but it's like and you make a sanity check okay so I think I take some horror there and I need to make a combat check and minuses this one is just okay this is how much damage they do to you BAM that's it this one guy will always deal you if he's engaged with you which is also thematic he deals one-one damage to you alright you need to fight them make a strength check there's no Sandman there's none of that you just roll your strength against his modifier and then each successive the damage great and when you have a shotgun apparently you can just [ __ ] and kill everything so oh

sorry when you're blessed and have a shotgun yeah oh yeah in these dark packs oh yeah it conditions I think they very much need to bring in versus the dark pack I like the conditions a lot in Eldridge like all the different conditions you can have I think those are always somatic these are probably really [ __ ] bad no sales like I always like taking on the dark pack yeah when's it gonna happen exactly so so yeah um scale one to ten babe dang ol a that's I think that's where I'm at - I think and I I think it's probably sitting there with Arkham man I just love all these games for different reasons but I think over time this will surpass eldritch but eldritch is still my favorite this one is probably I think I would rather bring this one out over a second edition I would say that because it's one it's easier to teach and I don't have to haul a [ __ ] crate around for all that stuff but man nostalgia for our more second edition it's just it's just there but if I were to be honest with myself I would say that I would like to I do like this one better than second so they are on the right path this can be really really good but let us know what you think of Arkham Horror what is wrong with me horror third edition in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of datas for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to

enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button it's a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day of this for you

Progress saved