Oranges & Lemons - 4p - The Discussion
Transcript
all right so what do you all think of the game I would buy it except I already did okay fair enough all right that sum it up that's it that's all your thoughts no that's just where I'll start I'll pass the Bon just want to get early shy bought it so there's that I'm not going to buy it CU they bought copies absolutely I mean and and and the funny thing is like when we read the rules and we were going through it I thought thought this was going to be boring I didn't think the tension would be here and the tension of the of the actual actions and how they how placement of the action is so important you know and obviously Tempo has been our word for 2024 in this game 25 yes this current year even um it's it it has really nice EB and flow I mean the game is really I I I'm trying to find a lot of fault with it because um I felt like I kind of did similar stuff that I did last time I didn't I didn't do too much different but you what your opportunities you're presented with like any worker placement game you have to kind of take advantage of what what's available and what you can possibly do with that puzzle yeah no I I the the game is is really enjoyable the tension is is great I I I was I was a little concerned about the four player versus five player seeing like since there was uh there fewer fewer workers out there um but once we got you know halfway into the game it like it like it ramped up like it did absolutely ramp up the tension throughout the game and that was great um trying to trying to figure out what people you're always like looking to see
what people what people need that that that that that work placement interaction is there right there work placement games where you're where that doesn't happen but it absolutely is there um the um the chat is pointing out that scoring is a little bit of a chore and maybe yeah it sucks I hate it I really do it has nothing to do with sour grapes or anything I that just tedious and no fun and it some of it doesn't make sense so that's on the negative side yeah I agree so if you used your board game app and you just put all the numbers in then it's still still it's it's it definitely is there's a lot of little stuff that's a lot I mean any game that again it's a point solid like this I did not enjoy the game I enjoyed uh my favorite thing about the game is the the the action uh planning in both directions the fact that it does it coming and going right for uh both where you place out there for you know the initial and then it has an impact on the next round based on where you are um I think is awfully awfully clever and the only game that comes to mind that even remotely does that is Dominus species Marine there may be others I'm not sure but dominant species Marine you go and take the action immediately as opposed to like in dominant species you do all the programming and then you activate
top to bottom left to right this has that but then it has the whole where you place dictates where you're going for the next turn I think that's genius I love that I think it is super clever and I hope other games use that CU I think that was that's the star of the uh that's the hook of the game I will say though the game without oranges I think the Orange is the most important thing in the game I think that going going early was very helpful for me so there may be no oranges in the game but the Orange is super important um also just wanted to say that mean the downtime is great you know or lack thereof right it just moves even if even if even if you're low on the on the turn movement you you still have you're still watching everything you know it's not you're not you're like oh now I just now I recalculate you know planning is changing yeah the um yeah there you will have a turn or a round or two where you maybe like have an action early and have actions later and you have you do have to wait for like way through like 10 yeah but but but you knew that coming into it right you know cuz again where you place the previous round dictates where you're going so you know what to anticipate it's not bad yeah you are planning but it's very tactile yeah because you you are like Crystal Palace you're you're choosing those places where you're going and everything is resolving one by one so you have to remember what you want later you have to plan to have the res I have the
resources and the money to do the thing that I want to do later and it's funny you bring that up cuz we are playing Crystal Palace later on this week and thought that kind of you know book ends I thought appropriate because that one it's all about money and this one it's all about placement right you had mentioned it halfway through the game or so but that tension between needing the money at the start of the turn to rep your workers versus being able to collect the money early and turn to spend later is really interesting and how that flows from turn to turn to turn I started two rounds with no money and I realized very quickly that starting with at least having $4 or $3 gives you some as the game ramps up having $8 having four six and even just a couple of bucks to be able to go into ke having a couple of dollars to get into these locations that are super important yeah yeah it is vital uh or it's not until it is and yeah it's smart though because this very beginning you there there's areas in each place you can kind of get money like getting some money get some money but you can't get it for the initial place cuz you get the money but then you'd have to do it here you sell it there CU it's like bricks was the only thing the resource I saw in the first game that went in order so you could get money you could get the bricks and you could sell the bricks right away and nothing else really had that resource movement um uh everything else you kind of have to buy it I mean this one was not bad but it's more expensive but yeah yep and there's a there's a
there's a pleasant amount of Randomness in the game right you have the flip of the cargo tiles and the flip of the EIC shifts I'm totally perfectly fine with all of that yes like the Caro tiles like you might have some resources uh to maybe grab something that flips later or or at the end of the round you see what flips and you're like okay well that's what I'm going to Target that's that's something I'm going to Target or maybe you side against it and the EIC ships are uh a little bonus if you if sometimes it works out really well sometimes it works yeah reasonably well reasonably well but it's a it's always a none of them are bad well the 50% down ones you collect just for the end game scoring which is not great fair but odds are you're not going to draw two of those and if you don't like it that's where the bell comes in right well we didn't get any two people stuck here that one person would get the crap right um my honestly my only real beefs with the game I have three and one two of them I would argue are kind of trivial uh these the bells like that's just components um the second thing is some of the iconography could have been clearer and uh this was not a great idea yeah uh it's clear but we're also in the brightest gaming space on planet Earth well particularly and then also and then why not have it with all the different colors on there for the Wilds difference for my mind between these two and there
it's just so graphic design wise that's not great also if you're going to have oblong workers have oblong worker spots like when they're standing up oh sorry there like that doesn't make sense right same with the round spots it's they're little quibbles but their quality of life that it's 2025 and at this point I realized this is a this is a small publisher this is a mom and pop publisher but this stuff should have gotten caught um also just while while we're at it those are rectangle the cubes are square also don't have like I'm okay with the price being underneath before you go you know you cover it problem here you cover it how much do I get it shouldn't be again it's little quality of life little things like that but otherwise I love that it's a small footprint yeah it is there's a place for everything yeah literally everything like we don't have to have these off camera like we could have piled all of them up right there like I I mean it works in general we when we play games we we find some things that are wrong with with the game we spend most of the time uh talking about an issue with a mechanic or something in the game that didn't really feel right or this one we're nitpicking the graphic design because the game's mechanics and how it flows is actually really really really
solid yeah and and and the only thing that's really in our way is some of the visual cues and if those visual cues are fixed then this game will sing even more agreed yeah the um so speaking about the shares the shares feelit little bit odd um um so in the first game we played um it shot up to 10 and stay Stayed in the in that range the entire game y in the in another game I played it never got to I think I think maybe got to six wow and I was surprised because I sort of expected based on my based on the experience that it trended upwards but it and but but it did in that it stayed in the middle and then maybe went down a little bit hero was shot up again um my issue with the stocks are if your markers here you get an extra one point not per stock it is one point yeah two point it it this feels undervalued like like underpowered as opposed to the votes you draw the right tile boom four points off the top yeah yeah right yeah I I I wonder like yes you pay for it I get that you're later turn order I get it but you're also paying for the stock and that the selling of stocks feel during the game for money right you like is that some is that a valuable thing to do is it worth spending we have to do it so maybe we're just not see BU don't have that many workers buy two shares six three three each and then sell them for 10 that's you know it's a bit of a it's a good profit but you have to wait for it to get all the way up there and then yeah it it just doesn't
feel like a great option so that's that's that also feels a bit off to me but um I think stocks in general take time right just stock games is like there's a thing that happens back and forth and if you're not always here then that's not happening like not that everything needs to be have a like have a real good uh benefit like payoff but um but it it does feel a bit odd um but the game overall I thoroughly enjoy the experience yeah yeah and we've played it at five we played it at four um I have you played in any other player count um OB the the only scaling in this game is blacking off spots right and and number of uh ship tiles you remove some with with a higher count short and and they do have Varan in rules for a short game and a long game if that's your thing not many spaces are left when you're playing two players right it gets tighter but it should it's a worker placement and I think there's also like asynchronous powers in in the box that we haven't are looked at so yeah all right so anything else so overall I'd say I mean I I want I would be down to play this again yeah it wasn't on my radar either which is like interesting because we usually put I mean for me as a Euro game I always put worker placement games always on there but this it's it's been such crapshoot lately and it was really surprising that we pulled something that necessarily looked like something Bland but with all those pieces together it kind of felt new yeah the the the action selection and programming the two direct bir directional aspect of it I think is
really great so well done now um I promised and I haven't forgotten James take it away what oh my quadrant oranges and lemon say the bells of St Clements bullseyes and targets say the bells of St Margaret's brick bats and tiles say the bells of St Giles half Pence and fire thingses say the bells of St Martins pancakes and fritters say the bells of St Peters two sticks and an apple say the bells of White Chapel made in white aprons say the bells of St Catherine poers and Tong say the bells of St John's kettles and pans say the bells of St ANS old father bald plate say the bells of adgate you owe me 10 Shillings said the bells of St Helen you will pay me now say the Bell so the bells of Old Bailey When I Grow Rich say the bells of short ditch Pray when will that be say the bells of stepne perhaps when you were old say the bells of St Pauls I do not know said the great Bell of B I'm glad the murdering version yeah the Mur yeah yeah yeah so I'm I'm curious that was wait I'm waiting for it and it didn't it wasn't there so here the original you oh yeah right here is oranges and lemons say the bells of St Clemens you owe me
five farings say the bells of St Martins when will you pay me say the bells of Old Bailey When I Grow Rich say the bells of short itch when will it be say the bells of stne I do not know say the great Bell at Bow here come oh yeah here comes a candle to light your bed and here comes a chopper to chop off your head chip chop chip chop The Last Man is dead I like that version better I'm just saying so there yeah see Tristan he's English he knows CH chop so there we go it is a work rep placement game and there is some pet chopping right so there you go hey big thanks to these guys for taking the time to do this thanks to all the patrons uh who support the channel certainly appreciate it thanks to everybody that watched if you did enjoy it please like And subscribe it really does help the channel and it is a patron drive so your patronage is much appreciated patreon.com HQ it you get access to the slack Channel tons hundreds of patreon only content videos uh and other stuff we have a merch shop that's coming for patrons so on and so forth so yeah lots of reasons to support the show if you find Value on what it is we do we are doing 29 streams in 29 days this was day whatever it was I think it's three I think right uh tomorrow we have Ezra and Nehemiah yeah y looking forward to that so I'm Edward James Trey Derek all right
y'all have a good night thanks everybody take care bye y'all thank you for watching the video y'all go check out some more more of them if you were so inclined but while you're here take a moment subscribe it really really really helps the channel I appreciate it y'all thank you