Beyond Solitaire Podcast 60: Liz Davidson on Gladiator Games
Transcript
hello welcome to the beyond solitaire podcast as always i am your host your only host the only one who has ever been your host i am dan thoreau and i am joined for the very first time a novel guest on this podcast in her very first novel appearance liz davidson welcome liz yeah it's such an honor to be on this podcast your work has been fantastic for the last couple seasons thank you i i you know this is my baby and i fell i invest a lot into this podcast it was my covid project and so i'm just happy that you're here thank you so much i've interviewed 57 people um and i hope that you will be the finest interviewee of all of course how could it be otherwise so so lately you have been writing this wonderful series of articles wasn't it six is it six entries uh yes six parts okay so a six part series and this is a series that actually has been one of the series in board games board gaming that i have been most excited about all year this is a series on gladiators yes it is about gladiators wait were you actually excited about this yes of course no you know i didn't i didn't know about it until you linked me like the second one but from that moment through the conclusion yes this is one of the
projects i was most excited about this year in board games i am not lying i really appreciate it exaggerate but i never lie a true critic yes so my first and most pressing question liz um is why and i and the reason i asked this is uh because i bet this is what's on a number of people's minds why are you such a scold aren't board games supposed to be fun so why would you tell us we're not allowed to play a game about gladiators i never told anybody they weren't allowed to play anything also who said that games who said that games were supposed to be fun i'm an educator my entire job is to take the fun of everything okay no so actually the real reason i wrote this is that um first of all i just okay so i haven't been writing as much on my site this year i didn't i realized i wasn't really enjoying doing written reviews and it was making me unhappy to try to push myself to write them but i do like to write and so then the question becomes what is it that i want to write and it turns out that what i want to write is like pseudo academic work about board games which i suppose makes sense because you can take me out of the ivory tower but you can't take the ivory tower to me like but um i think um i just wanted to try something that would interest me as a project
i've been thinking about the fact that hapo marcus had just come out with haplomarcus victorium and i was wondering why i like this gladiator game so much above all others um you know the latin world is kind of roiled all the time right now about how to teach roma culture in a way that is sensitive to our students who have no other blueprint other than what we give them for roman culture and so everything just kind of came together into what what does everybody want to talk about and play about gladiators what should i do ruin it for everyone and no and a series was born so i was i was i was curious because you actually open with that disclaimer in your very first piece where you say i'm not trying to tell you what to play or not to play why did you choose to open with that uh disclaimer why did you feel that need i felt that need because i think that we are currently in a spot in our industry where if you criticize something or you have some sort of nitpick about it that might mean that you think that no one should ever play it that no one should ever buy it or that you know it should that is problematic which is a word that you and i you know have talked about before um i i that's not really where i'm trying to go with my series right it's it's sort of like what we talked about last time you know historical criticism is not cancellation and it's not trying to tell you that you can't you know play something you need to make your own choices about where you're playing anyway for me it's more of just i really like looking at the way that roman culture plays out in our culture because i think
that it's a way for me to think about myself and my world through the lens of the ancient world where i also spend a lot of my mental and emotional time and i wanted to see what would happen if i kind of smooshed them together and brought something out of that experiment yeah so where did the experiment come from so you mentioned haplomachus was there a moment or a game that made your your you know the math come out of your mind and everyone was and you were going this is something i have to talk about actually part of it too is that so i'm not a game designer but and sorry mike i'm not trying to break any news because there's no news but he and i joke all the time that we're gonna make a gladiator game at some point that we should make a solo gladiator game and that would be really fun maybe someday it'll happen hopefully you know because i think actually it would be really fun but it also got me thinking about okay but i don't want to make a game that is just straight up gladiators fighting because i don't i mean would we have it be like you own the gladiators will we have it be like and then i realize that nobody else thinks about this the way that i do so for those of you who are have not read my series how dare you first of all but um but second but second of all basically um i wrote a series of of blog posts like an article in parts about um how gladiators were the majority of gladiators were slaves they did not have bodily autonomy when they were forced to go into the arena and hurt sometimes kill each other
and that um you know that is something that we have not been particularly sensitive to in our board games because we want all the fun and blood with none of the guilt and when i was thinking about what would it be like if i made a gladiator game i realized that i was hitting a mental block because it would be unacceptable to me to make a game that ignored that and so i wondered why and i started poking around at other gladiator games that were out there and then decided to put it all together into a series yeah so speaking of bodily autonomy and things that are taken out um so you mentioned for instance the genesis of this gladiatorial combat actually comes out of roman funerary rituals oh yes i love that you mentioned that because roman burial and funerary practices are actually what i wrote my thesis on so so why don't you give us the short version of how that occurred because you know i think a lot of people would be like what what does that have to do with what does a have to do with b well i think what's what's sort of interesting is at least in my reading so far it's somewhat mysterious how this started people seem to think that the romans got this idea from the etruscans that there should be some sort of almost like a blood sacrifice a ritualistic fight at a funeral and there's lots of ways to approach this right the idea is that the dead aren't uh it's not like you die and your awareness goes away the dead are hungry the shades are hungry so people would bring food and wine to tombs that were outside of the city
every year if they still give a crap about their poor ancestors okay if you read the iliad and the odyssey and the aeneid um blood is a very likable sacrifice for the dead because it reminds them of being alive and so this idea of sort of bleeding for and like dying for a death isn't that weird if you think about it in the context of larger roman culture the problem is that as rich people um are want to do a lot of times they also have very fancy funerals so you know you also have this situation where roman families with famous forebears will have what are called the embankments so just imagine that your great-grandpa was a really famous person so when he died they made a wax mask of his face and it's in a prominent display in the front room of your house like welcome to rome and so and then people in the family would like wear these as part of the funeral procession and you'd pay mourners to pretend to be sad and like you know beat their chest and whale and rip their hair out and go to this big public funeral and people were expected to kind of go it's it's a it's a a spectacle and so part of the spectacle is gladiator fight and then the spectacles get bigger and then you end up with julius caesar honoring his dead father many years after the fact but actually gaining a lot of popular favor by throwing the biggest gladiator games ever and off we go yeah don't you feel like you've haven't you been to a funeral that would have been improved by having like not a fight to
the death but a fight you know honestly it would be better than the tension of like slowly simmering family resentments and quiet weeping i'd rather just have yeah i feel like you could really like break through the ice right right especially didn't somebody's uncle right into his will that he wanted two hot girls to fight at his funeral yes yes i i know a lot of people who would be in support of a hot girl fight at a funeral i i will have to make no comment on that that sounds like the kind of thing that could come back to bite me so so here's kind of this weird so gladiators to me as someone who studied a little bit about gladiators and who's now read your series there's kind of this weird tension there because we have this perception of gladiators and board games support this that they're these ancient rock stars right they're big they're burly they've got 57 chest muscles that they flex in inappropriately suggestive ways the crowd goes wild for them people want to bed them but the reality is kind of complicated because uh they're also uh what what's the word infamia yes yes and so in farmis yeah so what's that tension and why is that so interesting and why doesn't that show up in board games so i think part of the reason it doesn't show up in board games is because we don't understand it it's so when you talk about gladiators as rockstars right you are in fact getting the truth it's just half of the truth
gladiators were sex gods people made graffiti of them you know in pompei we have one who's suspirian oh he's the heart thought of the girls you know people absolutely paid to have sex with gladiators and gladiators who wanted to live longer would often very deliberately wear less armor and make sure that they oiled their chest muscles up real good so that all 57 of them are gleaming in the sun so that if somebody has to decide if you're going to live or die they want you to live so they can look at you next time you know there's definitely like a uh like a you know i'm hot aspect of being a gladiator they had you know relative like if you think about slaves right we think about people who aren't allowed to go anywhere aren't to do anything gladiator's weapons were locked up but like you know from our perspective it just seems quote not that bad because they had a lot of i hate saying it this way because it's so gross right and that's what makes this such a hard topic like they had a lot of privileges and freedoms it's just that they also had no real legal rights and also you know romans are very finicky about people who sell their bodies for entertainment that is not just about prostitutes so like in the united states when you say that you think of like sex workers but for romans it was just as bad to be an actress to be a dancer to be a gladiator to be a charioteer to be any of these jobs where you are essentially selling your body for public consumption and entertainment and people are transfixed by it but they're also deeply repelled by it and like you can't
be mr sexy gladiator and then go marry a well-off woman without it being a massive scandal and if you are an aristocrat you cannot i mean we have all these stories ready to focus right like oh commodus thought he was a gladiator he wanted the arena and maximus killed him okay that's actually completely historically accurate but he was into the gladiator thing but um you know it was bad for him to be into that people would have looked at that and been like oh that's uh like if you're going to get canceled for something in ancient rome it's that kind of thing that gets you canceled like you don't do it and so you know it's really interesting to see like oh fame and glory and wanting the best gladiatorial house and everyone loves you and you are thrilled by the roar of the crowd and it's kind of like well that same crowd ain't gonna have dinner with you they're not gonna look at you in the street and treat you like a friend really you are entertainment meat that is you know they might have an action figure of you but they don't want you do you think there's any modern parallel to that i mean even just speaking now um you know i'm thinking about like tick-tock influencers or something you know like someone that you you like to watch but you wouldn't want to hang out with them necessarily okay so how political do we want to get it's my podcast still even though you've you've searched no it's my podcast i i think you can get political okay so here's what we're gonna talk about then let's talk about politics and sports so i love to go to baseball games and at
baseball games i'm a fairly liberal person i'm surrounded by a lot of people who definitely aren't and we all know there's social signifiers in this country for you to tell somebody's general political persuasion who love to go watch immigrant athletes play ball they do sure you know and look at football look at what happened with with kaepernick people want you know look at shut up and play with was that lebron who was told that when he had a political opinion we don't have i don't know like we don't have something that says dramatic right in our culture as like i own your life and also you're kind of hot like that's it's not quite like that here right yeah sure kind of close enough sometimes like we have people who love to play sports who make big money to play sports but then when they want to assert their opinions or their personalities or their needs beyond that sport in ways that are culturally uncomfortable for people who watch their sport then they get slammed and i mean what is that if not a reborn version of the idea that you shut up and play for my entertainment and you don't matter outside of that yeah sure i was gonna say that's a way better example than mine yeah i mean you know the thing about influencers too though like i think that everybody we we live in a culture where we're all kind of selling ourselves a little bit does that make sense like you know we're sitting here on youtube making a podcast that we hope people will listen to yeah um you know we're selling some sort of product even if it's not for very
much money uh and you know we we commodify so much of our culture now like you know it's hard to have a hobby without trying to commodify it some way um you know we we have a combination of love and scorn for our actors who also we like you know just like the romans right we want to watch them perform we are often emotionally moved by their performances maybe we want their autograph want to touch them they're famous but that doesn't mean that you actually respect what they have to say yeah sometimes for good reason but sometimes not sometimes it's just because it's like shut up and be a movie so could you walk us through um so you've established that there's kind of this myth how does this play out in a board game i mean you even mention like a board game called gladius which apparently has received plaudits from an art historian uh seth mccormick for its focus on you know honestly being representing anyone other than julius caesar um and you still have some some critique to offer about this game that even though it's received plaudits yes okay so we'll do the lead up to that this is actually the most interesting case study for me and i didn't want to wail on it too hard for reasons that we'll get to right because i think this is like the essence of talking about history and talking about yourself at the same time and having a hard time slicing that so okay there's a few different ways that board games deal with with gladiatorial fights you know within them so one is to kind of pretend that the whole slavery thing
isn't happening um a lot of times people will be like wow the best fighters and even emperors love to get into the arena and sometimes slaves you know it might not show up at all or like oh let's make a gladiator game that's overtly roman and that mentions roman things and has latin in it but these are all people who you're hiring to be in your gladiatorial show which is complete bull if you you know you might hire a laniesta to bring his property to your show but like gladiators aren't free agents like that that's not how this worked um so you get kind of this element of erasure where we kind of pretend it's not there um sometimes you just sort of get like well you know you're in this for the fame and glory of it and that is true whether it's one where they kind of erase the reality or one where you know it's like oh you know you're a la nista and you want to bring glory to your house and they kind of don't talk about what exactly that means in the human trafficking that would involve or you get people who are honest about it but somehow the fame and glory is still the most important part like i'm i can't speak for gladiators like they have tombstones they're completely proud of the the careers they had and their women lost records and you know some of them are free and some of them were slaves and died in a condition of enslavement and like you know they probably had their own very varied opinions about their lives and what all that meant but what we're doing is we're assuming that the glory and adulation of the audience was enough to justify wanting to go into that arena all the time and
fight for the fun of fighting and even if it's like oh you're trying to earn your freedom like you have like quest for the rudest as a game that's about a gladiator trying to be free um there's still very much like a you know you want to play to the crowd element of that and like you know even within the gladiator of the movie right win the crowd and you'll win your freedom but like we we're complicit in that right like we we enjoy putting ourselves in that role for some reason and i think it's because we're not really thinking about what that would actually mean yeah and um so for gladius gladys is an interesting case so for everyone out there i've never played gladius i have no problem with gladius like actually i don't have a problem with any of these games for the most part uh unless they're bad i haven't played them off they're not soloable i typically don't i went and looked through you know rules text flavor text you know i don't need to know how the game plays to know how i was presenting historically for this particular kind of project but gladius is a bidding game it won a whole lot of praise because of the diversity of its art and because it showed both men and women so basically it is a game that reflects values that our current gaming culture has we want to see more inclusion we want to see more people represented in the games we play and that is a good a net good desire for us and i completely believe that myself in my gaming life however it was interesting to see this mapped
out on gladiators because basically we were this game was receiving a lot of praise and a lot of adulation for its diversity and for how good that is based on our value set but the premise of the game is that you are betting on gladiatorial matches and sometimes you know fake betting and tricking people and causing wins and losses and influencing the outcome in the arena so you essentially are looking at this diverse group of people who are manipulating the potential life outcomes of slaves in a roman arena and no one thought twice about it and i think that's the truth i think no one thought twice about it zero people actually worried about it because why would you if you've played a bunch of gladiator games and you're not really thinking about it how would you know because we don't like to talk about it you have to read pretty deep before you start really like even i think popular literature about gladiators nobody likes to dwell on the slave part too much because we don't like it why would you like it you know it's kind of awful and so i think that it's easy to miss especially because i don't think that people are doing very deep research into their gladiator games because it doesn't feel necessary but then it leads to unintended consequences uh this one in particular that was interesting because by asking an art historian so okay i'm no i don't know seth mccormick really i would not be able to pick him out of a lineup i'm never engaged with any of his work uh we stream his messages once because he wanted to teach himself life
so that will tell you about the degree to which he's roman historian and i will say no more um but they he was pulled for a quote as a professor to talk about this game saying that he thinks that represent diversifying representation in games is really important for broadening perspectives on history and he goes into like a whole thing about how gladius is shifting attention to the agency of the roman people and away from the roman leaders that we normally tend to talk about in our games which is an entire other article series that will be really interesting one day but um you know he turns into this whole thing about agency and about the people and about how popularizing this is and how great that is in terms of perspectives on rome and no one stops to think about the fact that we're betting on a bunch of slaves yeah and that is the most exquisitely uncomfortable thing i have ever witnessed in terms of like a historical misfire personally like from my perspective as a roman historian i'm like like is this really here and again like i don't know this game i don't know these designers i'm not saying this in like a personal way or like you shouldn't play it or you can't enjoy it i am saying everybody missed the boat on this because no one knew anything about roman history and we just went with it yeah well one thing that i i feel like you mentioned in there a couple times is this idea of you know earning the adulation of the crowd glory so to me board games one of the things that makes them exciting as historical tools is their ability to model
incentives right and one of the things that i feel they do great at is modeling the value incentive behind because that's the victory condition right that whatever your victory condition is that's what you value oh yes um and so in a lot of these gladiator games you're going for uh you are going for glory so talk us through a bit so are those accurate incentives things like glory or money or do they only capture a portion of this historical dynamic so i think what makes this such a thorny problem and one of the reasons i'm so attracted to writing about it is that it's it's like a both situation like yes people would have cared about glory and money like the whole point of being gladiator and wanting to be that instead of you know being one of those unlucky slaves who dies in a salt mine is that at least you get to maybe you know make a little money um get some love in because people really like gladiators uh you know get a little bit of crowd adulation because with that comes the possibility of freedom so none of these things are in themselves i think valuable enough to be gladiator unless there were people who kind of got so caught up in the idea that people really liked to watch gladiators if they wanted to be one i think that that's i think everybody kind of fantasizes about like wow people really love to watch x thing maybe i want to be that and it certainly happened but it's a notable case i think for most gladiators this is really more about okay well this is the
essentially the career that i have so i need to i can't get out of it so i need money and i need fame so that i need to be famous enough that if i lose this fight nobody's going to vote that i get killed and i need this money so i can buy my way out if i ever want to yeah and i think that that's a really different kind of motivation than like i'm the best yeah you know what i mean and right it's just it just really adds levels of nuance and like complexity to the problem because pure people love me is not enough when you're in that situation or at least it would not have been for me and it certainly was enough for spartacus which is why you have like the largest slave revolt in the history of rome is among gladiators i mean you know to me that kind of speaks for itself and the fact they felt the need to crucify every single captured gladiator when that army ultimately lost and string them up along the roads i mean they wanted it to never happen again because it was terrifying for the establishment that was so used to kind of having these people fight but only for entertainment purposes for them and you know i think that we don't you know i it's so easy to ignore and actually in my ultimate conclusions to the to the series right like the reason it's easy to ignore well there's a couple reasons why do we want to get into this now am i jumping to the end i don't know why don't we pause on that for just a minute yeah
so i mean another representative question that i have that maybe predates that a little bit is uh you you contrast two different approaches for example uh to representing uh lunisti so the trainers of gladiators so in many cases you argue for instance the less savory aspects of running a gladiatorial school are played down or emitted entirely so what would some of those be that we just don't even see in board games all right so let's uh let's look at my own work because you got to start somewhere right um i i also have to write things out because i just forget to be honest which is kind of weird but um let's see okay so one thing that i do want to point out is that laniesta are considered infamilies as well just like gladiators are and so you know when we are talking about having a gladiator school right this is not like some some gladiator schools were like government owned but there were also government-owned slaves actually which is sort of fascinating um but uh you know you have this idea of kind of linnie's as a manager and i think that makes it easier to kind of pretend they're not doing what they're doing because they're responsible for training the gladiators and setting up the teams and booking the you know assignments and all that kind of stuff and so i think it's really easy to be like oh that's all they did no they went and bought people like that old guy that bought maximus in the gladiator movie that dude's elenisa he's a former gladiator
who turned around and bought other slaves to make them fight to make him money and you can think a lot i think about you know he's kind of presented as a likable almost heroic character in that movie no he's jerk just like everybody else other people but like so for example there was one that was called um moonera familia gladiatoria so one thing's kind of interesting about rome is that familia could include the actual nuclear family and blood relatives um slaves were also called part of the familia in the larger sense so this is roman terminology but i'm not sure that the people who make the game know that does that make sense right right so you're told to play the role of elenista who is an entrepreneur who is investing wealth in you know a gymnasium of gladiators gymnasium is a very interesting term because you would never call you it's called a ludus a gladiator school a gymnasium is where normal people go to work out and it's fine actually gum nadzo is like the greek verb i work out naked so like go forth everyone but um but you're doing it with the aim of making it the most glorious of the empire you'll recruit trainers armorers medics and even prostitutes you will train free men slaves criminals and war prisoners so note that they're we're talking we're using the word recruit here you will recruit these various people you will train free men and slaves where did you get them no it's like it's just kind of hidden in there and so like this is something i'll link all the actual article parts below
for those of you who like that subtle read on things but for me what really catches my eye is that really subtle way that the wording erases what's really happening right and it makes it so easy to skate over it's not you will purchase slaves that you will then train to send to their potential destiny arena and make money this is very glorious it's you will train free people slaves criminals note that slaves is kind of in the middle there too it's not even they led with free people and before that they led with armors and medics and trainers it's information that they know in this description right but it's not information that's gonna be fronted and i think that that kind of linguistic choice is meaningful yeah i always tell my students right when you write you're not you're saying something even if you don't think that you are right and and i actually like a student example very recently is that one of my students wrote about um you know the triangle trade and talking about slaves traveling across the atlantic ocean and i said well so you're right your paper is very good but they did not travel passengers travel cargo is shipped they were shipped and and you need to be very clear about the terminology you're using because this was not some tourist you know movement it was they were not willing colonists who would have traveled they were packed as cargo they were treated as cargo they were shipped so you're i
think that there's you're exactly right yeah the words you choose means something um the other thing is very interesting is that you have these games so like um this is a gliding request for the rudest game for 2016 right it was like a little kickstarter project was very concerned with accuracy which is why i picked it up and it's about gaining your freedom in the first volume and then there's an unpublished volume two that was supposed to be where you're free now and you take on the role of elenista and you turn right around and start getting some more gladiator slaves that you're going to deploy in the arena and i thought that was just fascinating because if you've done this whole arc about earning your freedom why does it make sense to you that the next arc would be about you turning around and doing what was done to you that you clearly did not like because you wanted to fight your way free like where where is our mental disconnect where that seems like a good idea and then you also get games where like the knees the linings are printed are you know presented probably as close closer to the way they really were even though it's definitely salacious which is like spartacus game of blood and treachery right i okay judge me i love that game you're a complete in that game like you are not a good person and you do not play that game to roleplay as a good person it is ridiculous it is silly the show is ridiculous and silly i watched the hell out of that show oh yes me too yeah like i am not saying that you cannot enjoy
problematic entertainment does that make sense but you have to be aware and one thing i actually sort of enjoyed about this game was that it was so aware of how filthy and awful they were like you could even pit a helpless slave against a real gladiator to like bet on a match it's foul it's real yeah and so like you know the only thing that bothers me about it is that people think it's funny because it's so shocking but actually that's probably the most historically accurate of the games in terms of attitude towards your cargo so to speak right and that actually bothers me that like all these games are really like making these big claims historical accuracy and like armor stats and gladiator types and names and you know all those sorts of things don't capture the heart of the enterprise in the way that i personally feel that spartacus does because at least spartacus is real about how foul it all really is right it's very lurid in its honesty and and and and it it depicts so much uh you know you you you acquire slaves in the exact same way that you acquire a shield yep uh you just put them on auction and you buy them um and that can include slaves who are good earners or slaves that you just kind of want to throw into the arena and prostitutes it it just makes no bones about what it's about and it's a hell of a good time um it is it is a really good game um so it is it's it just knows itself it
does it knows exactly what it's doing do you feel bad about liking it so much i want to say that i do because i feel like that would make me a better person but i don't i don't like okay so i i feel like this is a really good point for a disclaimer right and so roman slavery slavery is wrong no matter how you paint it there's no such thing as ethical ownership of another human being period however um roman slavery did not work the way that the slavery that kind of continues to impact our modern life did not racially based there is a system within rome for slaves to be freed and then within a couple of generations to become more integrated in society although people who know you're descended from slaves will always judge you as less than like a finely bred roman um and you know slaves lived in the household with the family in many cases they you know a freedman might choose to do take he the freedmen might take his master's actual family name and become a member of his family in a legal way and then turn around and continue to do business with him um freedmen from the imperial household actually ended up becoming the most politically powerful people in rome because emperors like claudius trusted them more than they trusted senators who did not owe their right their their good luck in life except i don't know how you can call that good luck but romans might um to an emperor and so we're talking about a very
different system of understanding ownership of other humans and the relationships that we can have with them that is not to say that it was okay or that slaves had it pretty good because they didn't they died horrible deaths they had no autonomy over their bodies they were raped they were killed for no reason um you know there's nothing good about it but i think it's really you know i think it's important to bring this up because it's it's easier i think to detach from the reality of what you're doing because it doesn't resemble what we understand as the purest of evils in our own society right so was it was it common for gladiators to become freedmen um or was that how common was that sort of thing i don't have the perfect statistics in this i'm going to say that it was mostly the dream it happened yeah but you had to be successful if you're just kind of like a mediocre gladiator you live a short unremarked life and away you go there always has to be filler for the show so they're actually disgustingly right like the big matches at gladiator fights would be like between this champion and that champion champion and everybody was really into it but like during the bathroom break part of the day it could either be just paired fighters that nobody gave a crap about and like whatever and so that's horrible like you just fill the arena with a bunch of randos you have to fight each other and like that's just terrifying um or they might be filled with beast fights where romans also imported lots of exotic animals from throughout the empire and just had them killed in the arena
so you know this is about blood and abuse and just general awfulness i so when we think about feeling bad about playing something like spartacus right like i think i don't think there's anything wrong with enjoying something that you know is a game on it's just base level i do think you have to be aware though that like it's really not okay it's sort of like in skyrim if you go get the daedric artifacts right you have to like do human sacrifice you have to perform you have to commit cannibalism um you have to do horrible things in the game in order to get all the danger artifacts right and they're evil um i think it's okay to role play as evil under a lot of circumstances i also think that you can't pretend that that's not what you're doing if that makes sense you can't brush it off you can't act like it was just innocent fun you have to be honest and you know that's where i think gladius made its mistake right it's you know very much look how inclusive and wonderful this is this is a wonderful reflection of autonomy etc but actually it you're doing the exact same thing that happens in spartacus yeah so so i've written a little bit about some some pro some troublesome historical issues as well and one of the questions that is is often thrown out and i think that often this is meant sort of rhetorically
dismissively is people will ask well why do you care about colonialism but don't care about like egyptian slavery or something like that and usually you know it's pretty easy to see that this is a rhetorical tool that is meant to dismiss you know it's kind of saying well you're a hypocrite right that you care you you don't care about egyptian slavery you only care about this slavery right um so what how does this apply to you and gladiators uh you know why is this an issue that you feel so strongly about that you've written a six part series and looked at a lot of board games uh why this and not some other issue why is this one important to you i guess because first of all yeah i'm a hypocrite i'm aware of my own hypocrisy and i don't i don't deny it does that make sense like i think that being in denial about it is the part that's the problem um but i i actually for me what's interesting about it is that me is a latin teacher okay so this is a two-part theme right that kind of shows up on my conclusions first of all the effects of colonialism are still obvious in our society they are visible in the borders of countries on this planet they are visible in the structural racism that exists in our country they're visible in the you know oh it's our culture historical obsession with confederate monuments that were put up nowhere near the civil war and were in fact from a much later period when you know racism was
still alive and being expressed this way yeah and so i sort of see all of these things as the continuing inheritance of colonialism that we have received and that we continue to live with you know we live with colonialism we just don't always identify as such so to me a game that is okay with colonialism is a game that's okay with what we are all dealing with as a society now which is inherently not okay sure does that does that make sense yeah like i feel like i feel like it's it's it's different to be okay with the thing that led to the mess we're in now yeah whereas with roman stuff on a human level nothing was okay about the romans julius caesar went to gaul and committed a genocide like there's no other way around it um you know the romans were fascinating but they were not good people in our sense of what it is to be good nor do they care about being good in the way that we think about being good and i think as a latin teacher i have to reflect on that right because okay i teach in latin program that is a very diverse latin program i teach latin to students of all backgrounds i teach latin to students from all social you know positions as they come into my class and i have to make sure that i am not glorifying something that is painful to them i need to make sure that i'm not revisiting generational pain on them because of things that i've imbibed in the past that i haven't thought about
and it's so easy to do so if you look at when textbooks including the ones that i use when i was a child ones that i was given by districts to use in my classrooms like there are stories told about slaves that are almost like cute as if slavery is just sort of an okay part of roman life like yeah you know like in the cambridge latin course which i love because i learned latin from it um you know you've got slaves who have like there's a slave who has a girlfriend and he sneaks out see her when her master's out and it's like oh he he on kill i grew me and i'm delek taught like the girl pleases groom you know you know i mean there's a there's a story that's cute that's since been taken out of most recent editions of this textbook so they finally changed this particular part of the problem right but um the master of the house goes and buys a woman named melissa and ever she's beautiful and everybody in the house is like ooh melissa except for the wife who is angry that's not cute that's scary and it's gross and like you know there's um there's an essay in ek romani which is another really popular textbook i don't know if it's still there but it wasn't the most recent when i taught in north carolina in 2017-18 it was still in the books that i was given by the districts kids there's an essay by a slave named davis who was so scared the day he got bought but now he's an overseer and he loves his family and he didn't understand why they paid so much more money for the re the the guy who had rhetorical abilities and they paid for him because they didn't understand he'd understand he was buying they were buying a teacher for their kids they bought a t-shirt for their kids like and it's presented as sort of like
a cute oh davis you don't know how the world works you're just a laborer and this guy knows creek that's why he's worth more money than you like what and like this this it's my podcast we're just gonna go for it it's just you know throughout texts about latin you have to get and like we all grow up taking latin in high school right with this idea that rome is great the empire is so cool look at how advanced the romans were look at how amazing julius caesar was and then where do you go with that what does that do to you what values have you decided to imbibe yourself and impart to your kids like i am no doubt very poisoned in my way right by what i have got like i love roman stuff i like reading about the political exploits of julius caesar and i feel moments of admiration for him when he does things that are clever or when he outwits somebody or like because that's we we imbibe that cultural perspective of the romans we take them on we we want to see through their eyes and not through the eyes of the people that they hurt and we are naturally inclined to do that because we're not teaching punic in school we're not teaching ancient celtic in school we're teaching latin and i feel like as a latin teacher it's my job to i want to preserve this history but it's also really important for me to think about the way that i'm teaching it making adjustments to my curriculum
being honest about how foul a lot of this stuff was and if you don't do that like what are you what are you communicating you're siding with empire which we don't like to do given that we now realize that colonialism is bad and like you know why are we taking the side of the empire instead of the rebellion but we do yeah so what conclusion do you draw from all of that is is that kind of the succinct statement or what do you hope that a reader would take out of this series that you've offered so i hope that what a reader would take away i mean i'm inherently selfish right most of the work that i do is for myself like i was thinking through a problem that i was having like inside of my own heart and mind right and i still haven't fully made peace with my feelings about rome or about gladiators or any of that because it's an it's a process what i hope is that somebody reading that series will think about things that they were uncritical about in the past and maybe look at them with new eyes or accept the possibility that you're not as independent a thinker as you believe you are that sometimes you fall for what the people of history are telling you because you wanted to identify with them and you wanted to see a historical hero and maybe that's not what you actually got and having the ability to know that your perspective might be off having the ability to maybe start looking at things with fresh eyes i think that matters in board
gaming and out that matters for personal relationships that matters in politics that matters you know for the people sitting across the table from you as well as the historical simulation that you're playing out um you know it's it's it's not so much that you're supposed to get some sort of dogmatic conclusion from this it's supposed to make you think about stuff you didn't think about before and wonder why you didn't well it certainly has done that for me uh and i'm and i'm saying this is somebody who uh has spent some time studying ancient rome um well so thank you so much liz for your series and for speaking with me today joining with me on my podcast um so if listeners uh don't know you very well where can they find you on the internet you can find me on the internet as space biff i write these uh i write these uh very thoughtful critical reviews of historical games and also articles about things like uh colonialism and games and you know i've i've been working you know if you if you contribute to my patreon you might get some goods about comancheria but uh yeah space biff well thank you so much for joining us today liz uh i can be found anywhere on the internet as beyond solitaire and happy gaming
you