Bohnanza Review: Chili Beans?
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vasel. Uwe Rosenberg is one of the most well-known designers, board game designers, in the world, having designed such mega hits as Agricola, Le Havre, and A Feast for Odin. But years before he designed these games, a decade earlier, he was most well-known for designing a game about beans called Bohnanza. Well, actually, he designed multiple games about beans. There's Space Beans, etc. But, Bohnanza was the most famous game of his. In fact, when I first started playing modern board games in the hobby, it was one of the first games pointed at to me. Uh this came out in 1997. Well, Pandasaurus has reprinted Bohnanza, and they've redone the artwork and made a few rules changes, but for the most part, the crux of the game is intact. I'll mention the rules changes at the at the end of this video. But if you've never played Bohnanza, it is a game of interaction, a game of trading Well, not beans anymore. Now they are chili peppers, which kind of takes away the pun in the name since Bohn was bean in German, and it mixed with Bohnanza.
But, no matter. It doesn't matter. You're trading chili peppers or back and forth with each other trying to get the most points, harvesting your bean fields, I'm sorry, your chili pepper fields. I'm going to make that mistake multiple times. Here's how it plays. This game comes with a deck of jalapeno peppers. You can see Big Robusto, Dr. Scoville, Jalapeno Joe. We have Josephine Pepper. Each of these peppers is a different color and picture. They show a number at the top. That's how many are in the deck in total. And then this shows how many coins. So, two of Josephine is worth a coin, while six of Josephine is worth four coins. What's going to happen each player is going to get this little bean paper that I'll show here showing your two bean fields, one and two. And then each player is going to get dealt five cards. So when you get dealt cards, this is very important, you cannot change the order of cards in your hand. So here I have Josephine Pepper, Granny Peri Peri, Sheriff Pimento, Granny Peri Peri, and Black Cobra.
On a player's turn, the first thing they do is they must plant the first card in their hand. So I plant Josephine Pepper in my field here. You may plant the second card in your hand. Yeah, why not? Now I can't put Granny Peri Peri there. I need to put Granny Peri Peri in this field. Then you're going to draw two cards from the deck and put them in front of you. I got Jalapeno Joe and Big Robusta. Now I can trade these cards with other players if I want to. I can also trade them cards in my hand. And so somebody says to me, "Hey, I got I really want Big Robusta and I'm going to give you a Granny Peri Peri." Well, that's pretty easy. I say yes. So I give them Big Robusta and I put Granny Peri Peri in front of me. By the way, I'm the only person who can be trading at this point in time. Someone else says, "Well, I want Jalapeno Joe, but and I will and I'll give you another Granny Peri Peri."
But I don't know, Don. I I don't know if that's a worthy trade. And I'm like, "Well, I'll also give you Black Cobra from my hand." Sure, so I trade them two for that. Now my trading is done. Now I don't have to trade the cards or I might not be able to trade the cards. But when you're done, all the cards that have been traded will be planted automatically. Now sometimes, let's say I got Sheriff Pimento and I have to plant him. So I'm going to have to put him in one of these spots here. And so then I'm going to harvest this one. Sometimes when you harvest you get nothing, but here if I have three cards for Granny Peri Peri, I get two coins. So I take two of these cards, turn them over in the coins and put them here. That's how I'm going to score at the end of the game. And now Sheriff Pimento is here. If for some reason I'm forced to harvest Sheriff Pimento, I'm going to get nothing because I need at least four to get one coin. The rest of the cards are put into a discard pile. And you're just going to keep going through, uh, playing the game this way, going around the table one at a time. At the end of your turn, let's say these are the only two cards left in my hand, I would draw three more cards and again put them in my hand without changing the order. But the game will end when the draw pile has gone been gone through three times. The second and third time will be much shorter because cards will be in people's piles or in their fields. And that's how you play. Whoever has the most coins is the winner.
The new artwork is fantastic. The card quality is good. Pandasaurus did an excellent job at bringing this package back to life. And in fact, I'll say even this, this is a better game than the original. So, let's talk about changes from the original Bohnanza. The original Bohnanza went to seven players. That sounds like a feature, but it was a bit of a bug. If you're playing with six or seven players, it was too much. There was also a weird two-player variant that no one really liked that much. So, now the game's three to five players. Perfect. That's the way it should be. The original Bohnanza also allowed you halfway through the game to spend three coins to have three bean fields in which you could plant because two was a, you know, pretty tight because you're like, "Oh, I need to plant another bean, but both my fields are filled. So, now I need to harvest one. I didn't want to harvest this one." That sort of thing happens. But if you pay those three coins to get that bean field, that tension goes away, which sounds good for the player, but doesn't really help the game much and a lot of people surmise that the three coins wasn't worth that price.
Doesn't matter. That's a confusing rule anyway, and it's out of the game. And like I said, they changed them from beans to chili peppers. But these changes work really well. The bean artwork, uh, Stephanie Bom is the artist here and has done a fantastic job. The names are silly, but the game is all about that trading. Now, Bohnanza is a three to five-player game, which I think is a very, uh, a tight fit and I think it works at all of them. but my favorite is five. I really like that player count. There's not a lot of games that work well with five. And this whole idea of trading with other players, it's very simple. I want that bean, you want this bean. Do you want to trade? No. I'll give you two for that one, says someone. Oh, now that's interesting. But all those trades have to be planted, and I everyone at the table might go, "You know what? I don't want to trade with you." By the way, I should mention that if you're playing with only three players, you do have three bean fields, so there's a little bit more leeway, so trading isn't as as horrifically bad as it could be. But this trading back and forth is fun. It keeps you involved on everyone's turn.
The idea of keeping your cards in a specific order is now done in many games popularized by Scout, but Bohnanza, I believe, was one of the first games to ever do it, and it works well, but you might trade with someone just to get that card out of your hand. This is the bean I have to plant next turn. You have to plant the first one in your hand. So, I want to trade it with another player, so I get it out of my hand so that I can now plant the second card in my hand. It just works. It's smooth. It's like it It just I I remember playing the original Bohnanza, and I got burned on some seven-player games of it. I got burned on it taking too long. I got There was It was fine, but it kind of dipped for me in, you know, how much I liked it. But this new version has reinvigorated it for me. I worry that a lot of people who are looking for big grandiose games or are caught up in the endless trick-taking cycle of games that are out there will miss this game. It's not trick-taking. It is not big and grandiose. It's a small card game, but that offers really good negotiation back and forth between players. So, uh yes, it's chili peppers now, which are fantastic if you think about it, anyway, but I like this concept. I think they made some good changes. I give this an eight out of 10. It's definitely a great game to have in your pocket to pull out uh to play. It's a good after-dinner game. It's pretty solid. I If you don't like negotiation, you may not enjoy it because you will need to trade with other players to make things work.
It's also a game that when you're going through that deck, you're like, "Man, we've been playing the the game here. What does it say? It's 45 minutes. You'll be like, "We've been playing for 25 minutes and we've only gone through the deck once. This is going to be a long game." Nope, those second and third times through the deck happen very quickly. Check it out. I'm glad this classic is back. Bohnanza. I'm Tom Vassal and you've been watching The Dice Tower.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever, you can just watch. It wasn't an amazing. Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.