City of the Great Machine is the Hide and Seek Board Game You Need
Transcript
city of the great machine puts exactly two spins on the hidden movement genre these are games of hide and seek but still cool for adults to play where one hidden player tries to move in secret and the others try to find them and that's trick number one in city of the great machine it is the many who are hidden the Rebellion the resistance the blocky Heroes who try to overthrow the shackles of an evil AI and here comes trick number two this is a hidden movement game okay that didn't make any sense they're all hidden movement games what I mean is that the people you are looking for are not hidden you know exactly where they start their movement and eventually you'll find out where they're going but the movement itself is hidden and I'll explain why that's cool after you eat your vegetables what I mean by that is listen to the rules hello welcome to the resistance please abandon your hope here and this is your requisite and in our cup full of gruel relax as long as no one notices you eat sleep or breathe you're gonna be fine as Rebels you're trying to turn citizens from various social strata of the city towards your cause ultimately instigating free riots if three of these tokens are ever on the board congrats you overthrew the shackles of always having to accept cookies when you visit a website these citizens are unknown to the machine or to you but you can travel around the city finding out what social
class they belong to like artists or scientists who join the course even when the discontent in the city isn't very high or merchants and industrialists who hashtag Tories out only when things are getting really bad the way you choose where you're going is by picking an access card depicting the District of the city you want to move to that is each round all Rebel players will pick one of these cards from their hand and play it secretly face down now this card says the that this Rebel player will go to this District this turn then the machine player will take its turn doing its actions and moving its agents but it will not know what is on this card and only when the machine player is done will these cards get revealed and then the rebel players get to go about the city and do whatever it is they want to do and I already have to interrupt the rules teach because there's just some very cool things happening with these access cards all Rebel players have to conduct their discussion out in the open if you want to ask your teammate if by chance this time they predict a riot this is definitely something the great machine can hear and it will send its splunkies to stop you but you do have one tool for secrecy you can show the other players your access cards and obviously you all have the same set of cards with the names of the district written on them but when discussing where you should go you could use your pointing devices and observation balls to be very Coy about it 4 for example do
you think I should go to maybe Roger should visit other sort of things you'll say a lot but the beauty of this show and don't tell is that the machine player has no idea whether what you're saying even means anything in our very first game of city of the great machine I was the machine and the rebel players started using the phrase we need more glitter in their discussions they'd often point to a card and say is this enough glitter do you think and this is probably going to make me sound stupid but I sincerely thought that they developed some sort of a code for a specific action that they planned on carrying out and of course when the game was over I said so what's glitter and I think you know by now that it was nothing deliberate gibberish to confuse me but because they had something to point to something that only they could see it felt like a real threat oh and speaking of being the machine humans with their feelings and taxes and organs it's time for a little bit less bits and a little bit more bids the machine itself does not appear on the board instead it has access to guards which are these dorky orange meeples polluting the game's districts and servants which I kid you not are named Lex Hackett phantasma and my favorite judgmentor I love that the little bit in the rulebook says oh yeah they're like totally subservient absolutely no will
of their own but clearly they don't think that they think that they're free thinkers because one of them named himself judgmentor and they would think that because they can pass laws arrest citizens and calm down on dissidents with raids in their eyes they've got the power Just out of spoons anyway so as the machine player you get to move these things from District to District in anticipation of where the rebels will go most importantly the servants can then also perform actions they can come up with new laws and then also pass them they can instigate raids in locations where the machine thinks the resistance will move to they can arrest citizens which have revealed themselves to be sympathizers and they can literally reshape the city flying a district from one side of the board to another and you're sitting there thinking cool actions literally doesn't mean a thing to me I know that's because the impact of what the great machine does only reveals itself when it's the resistance turn again hey you're back good and resist to grow get it resist never mind I'll explain later first every resistance player needs to move their miniature to the district depicted on the access card so if I pick the Grand Studio for Mustafa I would need to move him from here to here I can plot whatever route I like but for each district I leave I have to pay one trust per upright Orange Guard in that District this likely isn't a problem if you're staying in the same place or moving just one District over but
remember between you picking where you are going and actually getting there the machine player did things like for example rearranging the districts of the city um uh oh so I have a question what happens when you haven't got enough trust to pay for moving nothing don't worry it's fine as long as you roll this result on this die the die you never want to roll and each time you leave a district and can't pay for it you need to roll this die again unless you roll this result in which case you don't need to roll anymore because you've already been detained but let's pretend that you avoided all my traps and guards and successfully arrived at the destination District the district my servant put a raid token in congrats you're once again detained which brings us to the last concept I need to explain to tie all of this together how do you win as the great machine each time you detain a resistance member you have a choice you can either immediately end their turn and get some bonuses or you can advance the master plan once the master plan reaches the final spot you can resist all you want doesn't matter anymore everything is as it should be so let's talk about those two tricks again the hidden being the many and this stop start hidden movement and what that does to the genre there's a promise in each
of these boxes of a tantalizing cat and mouse game one player making secret moves confounding and confusing pursuers the others stalking surrounding and capturing their prey it's as good as adult hide and seek can get but they don't always shake out like that the premise is true but the execution often leaves one side wanting many hidden movement games seem incapable of escaping the fact that playing one of the sides either The Hider or The Seekers is just a a bit dull and it is mostly playing as the hidden Blair that is filled with Tedium when the stakes are High when they're about to catch you those moments are tense but they tend to happen towards the end of the game otherwise most of the time you're just drawing a route and executing it you do get to listen to The Hunters disgust and scheme and you can adjust your plans according to that but when I hear that that to me sounds like you're listening to other people play the game rather than doing much play yourself city of the great machine flips it on its head and by doing that you still get to listen to the resistance scheme and cavort but you're also deducing because every time you figure out where one of them is going you get to advance the master plan and that's obviously one step closer to winning but you also get to turn this wheel around but that's just the first layer of braining because the climb on the master plan ladder is long and strategies for reaching the top are plentiful you could Notch this dial one step up every time you catch them but then you're leaving them to do what they
want instead you could just focus on one resistance member and constantly raid all areas around the make them feel isolated and like you know what they're doing and like you constantly one step ahead and then every time you catch them instead of advancing the master plan you just stop that turn they don't get to do anything but also you get to take away their access cards restricting their traveling options to just a few predictable locations and of course the other trick of making only the movement hidden is that you're having the big reveal of where everyone is a constant part of the game instead of catching someone once over the span of two hours you get to catch them 10 times that's a thousand percent excitement of an average hide and seek so probably too good for humans I'm just gonna make it illegal as resistance players you'll pitch an access card and then tense up for like a good five minutes watching the great machine decide where to put the raid token but as soon as the machine finishes its moves you go even if it caught you because unless it was an absolutely disastrous turn you can still do things you have actions too you can disband The Machine's directives you can move districts just like the machine you can peek at the secret identity of citizens move the citizens around the map and you can start a riot
three successful riots will immediately win you the game permanently dethroning the AI Viva resistance etc etc every time you start a riot you'll flip over the secret identities of the citizens in that District I mentioned at the beginning of the game that citizens belong to various social stratas and whether they support you or not depends on the level of discontent so when you do flip them over during a riot you will count up any citizens that do support you ignore any of the ones that don't and then subtract from that number any spy citizens and then guards if you still have a positive number at the end of that congrats that's a successful Riot this needs a lot of build up to successfully engineer you want to make sure you know the identities of these citizens because a failed Riot could be disastrous you also want to bust up guards but you only need to succeed three times two if the discontent is all the way at the top but just like with the machine player there's a lot of layers of strategy you can of course try to confuse it have fake conversations but you're also watching for it to slip up if the AI was careless and left the district without guards that's a guaranteed ride if you send a supporting citizen there and that's very doable you just need to sequence your turns where one person goes to a location with a known good citizen and then makes the move and the other person waits to catch the pass and then starts a ride it's like a game of secret basketball which
is a very good game that I just invented and it does have to be secret because if the robot gets even an ounce of weight of what you're doing raid raid and the party is over wait a minute why did despot GPT leave that location without any guards oh no it's a trap isn't it unless it wants me to think it's at the beginning of the game all these locations and citizens are sort of meaningless and nebulous and since it's very open and there are a lot of competing strategies it could be hard to know what to do which is where we arrive at the event deck and I can't believe I'm going to say this but I love the event deck these cards are an extra layer of story and puzzle that make each round feel distinct you draw them at the beginning of the round and they will change up a cardinal rule of the game and also offer a way for the machine to advance the master plan once and very often both of these elements are tied together for example the ostentatious amnesty events is that if the machine player frees two arrested citizens at the end of the round that's one step closer to World Domination at the beginning of the game three random citizens are arrested by default and because of various bakeries when you encounter onto this card that number is probably going to be the same the card also says that a resistance player May free an arrested citizen as long as they're in any of these four major blue
districts so the resistance plan is clear go to Major districts free citizens stop the master plan but the problem with that is that the resistance plan is clear they will go to Major districts free arrested citizens stop the master plan so then as the great machine I can go raid raid except if they know that I know that they know do then you know that I know that they know that wait I see what's happening you're trying to confuse the robot with a logic Loop not gonna work I know exactly what to do I'm just gonna
city of the great machine is not alone in putting a spin on the genre pretty much every hidden movement game does that but when you start comparing them that's when you start to realize whether this is going to work for you mind MGMT for example leans heavy into deduction if the hidden player was here on turn 7 and here on turn eight then then must have gone there and then there and then there and so on in Beast just like in city of the great machine the hidden movement is also segmented by forcing the hidden player to constantly reveal themselves but the screen encounters the track there movement still rooted in root tracing whereas here the deduction is for all intents and purposes absent you're not hand selling grattling the breadcrumbs you're reading tea leaves and poker faces and even cards do add additional complications and puzzles but it's never about logic it's about getting a feel for the game State and what your opponents are trying to achieve and in that way it's more akin to a social deduction game like the resistance I see what they're doing city of the great machine reminds me of the sorts of designs that Fantasy Flight games used to make you know before they ended up in their own logic Loop of Marvel Star Wars horror rich in ideas Innovative never before seen mechanisms very thematic in execution often Great rule books which this also has I rag on bad rule books a lot so nothing brings me more joy than saying wow this teaches the rules well and it kinda needs to
because a lot of ideas means a lot of rules and innovative ideas means never before seen rules there's a lot to wrap your head around and if you've never played a hidden movement game might I recommend steering closer to something like white hole Mysteries just to dip your toes in also like many FFG games it's long a PlayStation can drag up to three hours each round being a new puzzle helps with that but I feel like this could have easily shaped 45 minutes of play time and been the better for it and you might say okay just reduce the Play account it's shorter but if I had to call it I'd say that this is strictly a four player game it thrives on people showing cars to each other and talking out loud about them in a two-player game one person controls all three resistance Fighters so for that to work you'd have to ask them to talk to themselves out loud and hey that could be fun but I just don't think most people are comfortable with that yet three players is probably better we didn't try it because then there's that weird split where one player controls two characters and another one doesn't just a touch awkward as any Kickstarter game it's full of modes solo mode co-op mode and they work they're fine but the strength of this game is when one player is pitted against three others I do have to give the theme points for giving the AI roll to a deck of cards but it turns a stodgy game that's Lively into a stodgier game that's more mechanical whilst among criticisms I quite I'd like
many of the pieces but there's a few accessibility quirks that make the production feel very 2013. tiny fiddly tokens vast play areas with murky art and no iconographical reminders of what these areas actually do that sort of thing but you know what despite all of this there's just something about this that works thematically straight erianism comes in Spades with evocative events and if you've got a great machine player who's good at giving an evil stare winning combo what's even winier is that you'll hand the role of the scheming AI to yamate Colin who in his spare time likes to go on Hikes and gets very heated in his opinions about Eurovision it's a fine lad but he's got no master plan and there's something very Wizard of Oz about that that just Rings true authoritarians want us to think that they're so much smarter All-Seeing and Powerful but really they're just calling mostly I'm just very impressed with how many clever tricks this design holds and how it subverts expectations of an established genre to make every role feel exciting tense and deliver a finale that feels like a culmination of a master plan well executed if you want to find out about more hidden movement games we've chatted about these two games on our podcast talk cardboard and if you become a member of our patreon you'll get a bonus episode of talk cardboard every time a
main episode comes out plus access to our exclusive Community Discord server I think that's a pretty good deal if you'd like a video recommendation we have a review of sabotage that we did a while ago this one is a team hidden movement game and we think it's a bit of an underrated gem so you should watch that finally I've hidden a very secret subscribe button somewhere on this page and if you can find it first you'll get a prize more MPI videos delivered straight to your browser so start looking in three two one