Anno 1800 Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hi everyone today i'm talking about anno 1800 which is a 2020 release board game designed by martin wallace and published by cosmos this one accommodates two to four players and takes around two hours to play now if you're familiar with martin wallace he's pretty much known for his pretty epic industrial and economic star ball games and this one is certainly in that style of game and you also may recognize the title as that is a pretty popular video game i'm called anna 1800 and i will say this review is based solely on this board game i've never played the video game so i can't compare or contrast with the video game so uh let's take a look at what anno 800 is all about so the table is going to look something like this when you play a game of anno 1800 where you have this massive board in the center of the table where all players have access to and as you can see there's a bunch of these tiles and two tiles of each and all these different spots depicting a wide array of different goods and boats and warehouses you've got overalls you've got trains you've got silk sausage all these different goods and they all kind of synergize with each other because this is essentially a massive tech tree where they all link together and you need certain goods to build other things but i'll touch on that a bit later you've got all these different population cards where you vary in the kind of sophistication as well you've got the basic farmer and worker cards and you've got the more kind of engineering ones and these ones here that you get when you visit different parts of the world you've also got these other objective cards here these these endeavor cards which can give you potential points at the end which i'll touch on a bit later
um every game is going to start with five of these objective cards which are going to give you end game points or abilities to use throughout the game these particular cards are used or recommended for your initial game and they do different things such as you know every animal you collect you get an additional point for or every one of these um new world titles that you discover you're going to get six points for this one lets you take bonus actions if you cash in these exploration tokens or gold uh the person with the most engineers is going to get victory points and um for each of these kind of really hard to get industries that you build you're going to get victory points for as well so just something to build towards there also every player is going to have their individual player boards which are all identical and a little workforce here so you've got all these different cubes depicting different types of workers so you've got your farmers your workers and your i think these are like um i don't know what they are craftsman or something and um you see they've got different colors and they can all kind of activate different worker spots on your player board here so as you can see um the the wood here to get these um to get the wood you need to move one of these farmers to this spot but to use um you get these crates here you're gonna have to use one of your craftsmen because you need the craftsman to actually make the crates and you've also got at the bottom of the board you've got these different ships you can use and you've got these dockyards on the kind of waterfront here and that's where they're kind of limited to be placed so obviously boats can only go in water and the dock guards have to go on the coastline but buildings can go pretty much anywhere except the water of course and every player is gonna also gonna start with
a bunch of these population cards so you've got pretty basic ones like this and you've got the more difficult ones like this and the idea is that we are trying to get through a whole bunch of these cars because the first player who gets rid of all their cars is going to activate the end game and get a bunch of points as well so let's talk about how the game actually plays out so if you can't tell by now this game is all about getting victory points and the main way you're going to do that is by fulfilling these population cards and by keeping your little um you know colonists happy i suppose and as you can see these cards are pretty easy and quite easy easily broken down in terms of what they want so this one for example let's take a look at this one this one wants crates and beer and once i fulfill that as an action i get to get um a new craftsman as a reward and get this many victory points and these very difficulty and as you kind of get more cards they're going to be a lot more hard to uh to achieve and to fulfill their their needs basically so let's take a look at what the actions are because while this game is pretty involved there's a lot going on the actions themselves are pretty digestible and there's only actually a few of them that you can choose from each turn is going to consist of taking one action i'm out of a possible six or so and i will say even that in that case that um most of these actions are going to be repeated and a few of them you're not going to use very often at all so again pretty easy on the face of it so i suppose the main action you're going to take is to expand which is where you're going to bring new industries
into your little town um so for example we knew that population card needed a beer so i could take a look at the beer card here and i can see from the from the um symbology here this card needs a wheat and it needs a coal so in order to acquire this tile i'll go back to my player board and i will spend my resources on my workers to get that particular resource so for example the wheat is going to need a farmer to farm it so i'll move it down here and the um the coal is going to need a craftsman so i'm going to have to move one of these red cubes to here to get that one as well so as you can probably tell already this game has a slightly different way of gathering your resources because you're not actually collecting physical resources you're just getting them here and now and using them instantly and by moving these cubes around so i've done that i've got what i need so i can take this beer tile now and i can flip it over like so and put it on my player board like i have here and as you can see now this allows me the ability to create beer and to do that i'm going to have to use one of my blue cubes to activate it another action is to play a population card so now that we can make beer and we can already make crates because we've got that symbol already on our board we can actually look at completing this population card so what i'll do again is i would um move a red token down in order to um fulfill the crates objective and then i need the beer one because again this card needs beer so i can move a blue card a blue cube down and do that one
so now essentially i've completed the criteria of this card and as a free action i can choose to activate it when i want i can i can use it now or later but i see no reason why not to do this now so i flip it over which means i get this many victory points but also i would take the reward shown on the card so it's pretty simple contract fulfillment and as you can see here i'd get a new red cube ready to be um ready to be used and deployed elsewhere however a bit of a twist on this game is that whenever you increase your population like i have here so i used to have you know nine cubes now i have ten i will take a matching card of that type so for example a red one in this case and add it to my new i'll add it to my pile which means i got a new population card to fulfill so this is a pretty strange pacing about this game where you are constantly chasing your tail where you whenever you increase your contracts you are increase your population you're going to keep acquiring new cards so you know at times you kind of feel like you're kind of um swimming in trico or not getting anywhere but that is really part and parcel with what this game is about you also have the ability to add new population or to improve um the skill set of your of your population by paying certain resources for example to get a new farmer i just have to spend a uh a wood so i could go like this for example and then i could add a new pharma cube to that set here like so again drawing the corresponding card if i'm increasing my population or i can actually upgrade one um one kind of skill to another so i can move these green cubes up to a
blue cube if i spend some brick so again i can look at my sheet here spend a red cube and then shift this chap up here like so converting it to a blue but of course in this case i haven't actually added any cubes i've just shifted one to another so i would not have to draw a card and i will say that these can actually be used up to three times per action so you can actually get a quick grab of population should you need to do that as the game develops you're going to quickly run out of space so you're going to need to expand your town and to do that you're going to have to use the action to explore new lands and to do that you spend these exploration tokens so um let's say for example i spent my first exploration token um i just exhausted by putting it off my board like this and then i would go to a different tile that i need so i can either explore the old world or the new world and the old world are going to be pretty simple where it's basically a new um module to your player board like so which gives you more spaces to build into and will also give you an instant bonus for example another red cube here and as you can see it gives me new sea land to build my ships into new coast and new building spots so pretty simple now something that's different about this though is that whenever you want to build the next one because that'll be my second old world tile i need to spend two expiration tokens and then three and then four and so on as long as i could afford them now also you could explore the new lands or the kind of other colonies i suppose and to do that you draw the top three of these and pick the one you want but let's say for example i just chose this one
again i'll add it to my player board and this basically gives me the access to um these different colonies where i can trade or spend these trade tokens as you can see i've got two trade ships on my exploration ship that i've just used and to do that i could get these certain type of goods or these exotic goods such as you know you can get like coffee or tobacco or cotton all these different things that you'd need to go to exotic places to get so that's a real nice tool to have it gives you the flexibility of not having to buy the industry um but actually having to just trade with other places to get access to those you also have the option to spend two of these exploration tokens to draw up to three of these endeavor cards so for example let's say i've just drawn one here as just an example these are ways to get additional points at the end of the game depending on the workforce you have available to you so as you can see in the left-hand side you've got like an animal and in the right you've got an artifact and all this means is that if i had these cubes left in my kind of population i can assign them to these um different spots in order to get victory points so let's say i had a you know a red left at the end of the game i could put it here to get an additional point but of course if i have these really hard to get workers then i can get more points here and these will often synergize with the end game bonuses here so for example um in this particular setup all my animals are going to give me an additional point if i have that completed so a nice incentive to go for there another action is to switch some of these population cards if you're not happy with them so you can select up to three of them which maybe you don't think you can
fulfill or just too difficult for you and you can put them to the bottom of their respective decks and draw that same amount back to hopefully give you something that you can achieve um so it gives you a little bit of flexibility there and the final action you can take is to celebrate a festival and that is how you reset all of your cubes so for example here i've allocated all my different um workers all over my village so i could as a single action i can switch all of them back to their starting spaces and um be ready to go again um and something i should say as well is that when that happens all your different tokens from your ships will also refresh giving you the options to explore and trade which i'll touch on now so let's talk about how trading works so let's say for example i wanted to fulfill this population card and as we knew from earlier i can produce beer but i can't produce these bottles so as normal i would allocate my beer like so but in order to get that bottle i can have a look if my opponents can make them let's say for example this player here has already invested in making these bottles i can actually spend one of my trade tokens by just by exhausting it and i can choose to basically piggyback off the investment of other players now this player would not have any say in that at all they can't say you know they can't v to it and can't say no however they will be compensated if i do that by getting a gold and gold is really useful because it allows you as a free action to reallocate your kind of allocated workers back to their initial spot so for example if i spent a gold
i could shift this blue cube straight back up to here ready to be to be deployed again i mean i don't have to waste a whole turn to celebrate a festival so um trading is a big part of this game you want to have the ability and the capacity to build more ships to trade more and more so you don't have to waste your time investing in industries that you don't particularly want but just want to use maybe as a one-off and a quick smash grab so that is pretty much how anno 1800 plays in its kind of purest form um it's all about trying to get these people fulfilled you know the first person to complete all their cards is going to take this um seven point token and trigger the end of the game um however there is quite a few hoops you might need to jump through in order to actually satisfy these people and for example this trap here he needs some cigars he needs some steel and he needs a penny farthing as well now you know cigars you can build but you're going to need the tobacco to put in those cigars which means that you're going to probably have to explore a new world in order to trade to get that so it's not something you have interest yeah if sorry instant access to you're gonna have to go find that tobacco in the first place so you can probably imagine that's gonna take a bit of work because you might need the ships in order to do that and to buy the ships you're gonna need steel you're going to need sails you're going to need cannons if you want to go explore somewhere else to build cannons you're going to need steel and you're going to need different things so it's all about these tech trees and i'm also talking through another kind of more involved tech tree so as you can see he also needs penny farthings i take a look at the main board here yes we can build penny farthings which needs steel it needs rubber but it also needs one of
these investors and investors are basically the rarest type of cube you can get um and to do that you're going to need all these different resources in order to build one one of which is being one of these um kind of rich clothes or these gowns and we can build these gowns but to build these guns we're going to need a sewing machine and to build a sewing machine we're going to need brass we're going to need an engineer we're going to need steel and we're also going to need um silk etcetera and to get the silk we're going to need the cotton which again we're going to need to go explore somewhere else to get that so you can probably imagine there's quite a few hoops you need to jump through a lot of things you need to line up and start building towards things and actually to uh to get these done and as you go through these things you might be acquiring more population which is getting you more cards um it's all about tinkering your the population to get the ones that you need you know get the engineers down so you can build the more sophisticated equipment but also get the investors download to to get the real luxury goods that you might need as well so yeah there's a lot of um there's a lot of nuance and a lot of paths you need to follow in order to get these things fulfilled so there are a ton of decisions to be made throughout anno 1800 you know how you're going to deploy your workforce and whether you are going to keep using your goal to refresh them or of course you're going to waste your whole time to refresh everything and potentially give your opponent the leg up and the heads up in the race to get those cards fulfilled and also the order in which you're going to get these done because of course they all have different bonuses some of which is going to give you more population some of which are going to give you gold which is of course good because it lets you
refresh your workforce and even ones like this that let you actually get rid of cards which again will give you that kind of leg up in getting all your cards completed you know they're all going to need different types of goods so it's all about trying to invest in the type of industries that are going to get give you the most benefit you know for example i've got a few cards here that need these tins so of course building tins might be useful for me so i'm not so dependent on trading with other players and giving them a bit of a bonus by giving them gold so it's all about the order in which you do these as well and of course you know you're going to get advantages by getting new cubes and stuff and different bonuses such as more trade tokens which are all going to be great but again the order is going to be so so important now i will say that something that is kind of unavoidable and something you're going to have to get your head around is the pacing of this game because unlike most eurostar games you don't have a certain set of rounds or anything like that it is until somebody completes all of their population cards and you know you've got to appreciate that this can be frustrating at times because you're going to start with nine cards and there will be times where you almost double that value and have so many cards you just think you cannot get through and i can appreciate why people might not like that they might find that a bit frustrating and it feels like you're kind of chasing your own tail and not getting anywhere but i think you've got to trust in the system here trust in the design prowess of martin wallace and because he does know what he's doing and um you will actually end up catching up on yourself and building an efficient engine in terms of getting these people happy getting them
getting them squared away as points so bear that in mind that the pacing is a little bit weird it can feel like it's dragging on and on and on and you're not getting anywhere but you will eventually do that and i think that's going to be one of the most polarizing parts of the game people are going to find that maybe boring going to find it a bit overwhelming i do enjoy this resource system where you are shifting cubes around rather than having to have a big cache of all the different um all the different resources so it's a nice different uh and a refreshing approach of how to um handle resource management i think it's really well done and you know not only are you bearing in mind the things you can produce but also the people who can use them in the first place because you know if you have a bunch of industries that need engineers to use them and you only have one engineer then you're not going to be very efficient so you're going to have to start investing in you know upgrading them or bringing new engineers in which of course is going to cost you more time and more resources and more investment to do that so it's all about kind of following these pathways and trying to map out what you're going to do are you going to focus on a strong workforce are you going to focus on the strong kind of naval kind of approach in terms of getting more traders in or more exploration and to explore those new places to get these endeavor cards so lots of paths you can take but of course you are somewhat tunnel visioned and um you know guided by the population cards that you need to fulfill and something that i should say as well is you know just because um somebody might fulfill all the cards before you do and get that bonus seven points it's not purely a race game because you know even though you don't finish your cards you could still have acquired more
points than the other players did so bear that in mind i appreciate the way this game is condensed down into just a few actions because you know this is a broad game there's a wide scope here very very lots of things going on and this could have gone down that rabbit hole of you know having loads of rules minutiae loads of fiddliness and it actually got around that very well so i'm actually quite impressed about how you know just those six or so actions we can take and most of them being the same um in terms of you know just using youtube to build things to fulfill cards and to reset your workforce so yeah i love the way that the actual rules themselves are easy to explain um however the tech trees are a different story completely but that's where the gameplay really shines the game does take around two hours to play but of course that could go longer it could go shorter based on the idea that you know it's the first person to fulfill these cards um and that's something that's going to be to a personal taste you know if you've got the two hours to spare then you know you can sink your teeth into it you can enjoy the process um however because it's not that deterministic you know it could end up going three hours it could end up just being one hour then you've got to make sure you have that free time to explore this game to its max and i will say that for me it did maybe slightly outstanding welcome um in terms of being um just a little bit too long um especially because you do feel like you are you know constantly battling and going through the motions to get these cards completed um that's probably one of the only criticisms i have is that that game
length is a little bit too long for me um a nice maybe 10 20 off that game length would have been a lot more comfortable for me personally and i would actually like to see a different endgame trigger because i don't feel like this system is entirely necessary i think it could have been something else in order to um to trigger the end game to give you that more fixed time that time frame but um maybe i'm missing something maybe um there's some bounce issue there but um i actually i actually yeah i'm not sold on this um on this endgame trigger and i think it could have been different the replayability is relatively good i mean while you know you are going to have access to everything at all times um you are of course subject to the cards available to you so you're gonna have to go down different routes in order to get them done so you will inevitably have to go something else do something different from game to game of course you've got all these different end game scores here bonuses you can do and that's a pretty there's a pretty wide um variation once you can get you've got a nice big deck of cards to change it from game to game and these do change the flavor quite a bit and give you different things to work towards so i like the um different ways you can expand your replayability here um additionally the player interaction is you know you can't ignore it although it's not terribly strong um because you know you you are pretty much doing your own thing building your own engine um building your own little network that idea of trade is you know it's unavoidable you need to piggyback off the other players um because you know you
need the access to the industries they have because there is actually only two tiles of each of these industries meaning that if you're playing more than a two player game at least then um you're gonna have to use somebody else's and you know while that's not massive interaction it's just enough to give you know just to give you a little bit of a thought you know am i going to use my trade token to do that because these trip tokens are pretty pretty scarce but also my opponent is going to get a gold gold bar which is going to make them more efficient so just that little wrinkle of player interaction is is nice and i think it's pretty well done the production of the game is pretty decent you know all the actual components are of a good quality um the the uh the woods sort of the cardboard stock is pretty good and the cards are okay they're a little bit flimsy um the play boards are decent and you know all stuff like that is absolutely fine um the artwork itself is somewhat polarizing now i don't overly dislike it but i can see if some people would because it almost looks like they're renders from the computer game i don't know if this is the case or not um you know it's not exactly real inviting and endearing artwork it's pretty much um pretty soulless and almost feels like it's uh he said a rendering of a graphic image or a computerized image now it's nice that all these cards are individual they're all independent of one another there's no repetition or anything so that's all nice you've got nice character full art here and um yeah that's quite classified goods but yeah i'm not overly sold on the artwork but i don't dislike
it either but the production in its entirety is is more than fine the scalability of anno 1800 is also pretty good i mean you know you're gonna be able to play this two to four players and to be honest each player's turn doesn't take particularly long so you're not gonna extend the game length two too much by inviting more players into it and because ultimately the turns are quick you know you're going to take your or resolve your turns quickly um but the game is dictated by the fastest player of course you know the first person to complete all the objectives it's going to trigger the end so again you're always going at the pace of the fastest player so slow players aren't going to slow you down if they're kind of still doing their little engine and you've finished yours so overall i'm actually really impressed by anno 1800 particularly by the way these tech trees work i think they're fascinating and it's just i said it's real logical behind what you're doing and um i like things like that i like the way that things are strung together and you have to go down these certain pathways in order to get all these people done in the most efficient way possible i like how you can piggyback of other players but give them a small incentive i like the way you have to manage your workforce i'm at the same time considering the endeavor cards at the same time considering these endgame objective cards so pretty much all the euro goodness that you would like with that martin wallace sprinkle of industry and economy which you which i personally really enjoy and i'm starting to really um you know dig into that style of games and kind of find out that that kind of game is for me so
yeah i'm really excited about you know trying more martin walls designs especially if they're up to this standard now despite all those great things i'm again this is a great game um there are a few little things that i have you know particularly the pacing of the game i would have like again i'd love to see a different way this game ends and i think there is something out there which is going to do that and maybe an expansion in the future is going to fix that um alternatively the setup of this game takes quite long as you can see there's a whole bunch of tiles here and you know it's going to be somewhat of an obstacle to overcome and it's a bit a bit of a faff in order to get all these down on the table all in their matching spots and you know of course they're all completely um necessary for the game i think it maybe it could be argued that this could be condensed down into maybe two-thirds of these and create smaller tech trees um but i think if you're digging into this style of game you're gonna want the whole plateau and the whole um buffet of different industries available to you so personally i don't i don't dislike that but i can see why a lot of people might but yeah overall um you know this is such a solid game it's streamlined to a great degree by just boiling them down into those few actions i love the way you kind of ignore things you know building your building yours kind of see force building your more um you know your your warehouses and your shipyards on the waterfront in order to build more boats i'm getting the industries you want i'm knowing what your opponents can have and knowing you have the trade tokens to use them um but you're having a steady income of gold yourself so you can not have to waste turns in order to
refresh all your actions just so much to enjoy here um just loads of decisions from start to finish and it's just a great game that you know you'd expect from my own wallet so this is certainly a shield of quality candidate um and i'm really excited to see what this game has to offer in the future because i think there's a lot of scope for expansion content here and um i'm excited to see what that is so that concludes my thoughts on anno 1800 definitely check this one out if you are a martin wallace fan um it's a good one so if you have enjoyed this review please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye