Blackout Hong Kong Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about blackout hong kong which is a 2018 release board game designed by alexander fister and published by edgar schpeel this one accommodates one to four players and takes probably about 90 minutes on average to play though the board does that the box does say 75 to 150 minutes uh the idea of the game is that there's been a big blackout in hong kong believe it or not and we are supposed to be volunteers and specialists trying to help hong kong recover from this uh unexpected change so there are a number of components here you've got the main board which has this map of hong kong and this kind of resource wheel here you've got a bunch of cards that will be your kind of starting hand that look like this now obviously these will be not hidden from other players but everybody does start with the same array you've got some kind of cards you can draft on the side here which will come into play a bit later and more importantly you've got your own player board now a lot of the gameplay does take place on this player board and i will say these play balls do a good job of talking you through about how the game plays out because this is quite a a systematic game where you go from face to face to phase um until the game is over so the the breakdown of the game is quite simple um but as i said there are there are quite a few different things to go through and there is a bit of a bit of a a specific setup for each player and before the game begins so you've got a few cars already placed out onto the board and you've got a few in your hospital here now these are cards that can be unlocked a bit later you've also got a few cards here again
and a few more powerful volunteers than the ones in your starting hand that you can again potentially pay for to unlock there's also an emergency plan these are kind of objectives that you're working through or trying to work on to get points and money throughout the game and you've also got these two kind of unlockable spots here which can potentially allow you a fourth card slot to pay play cards into or give you a bit more flexibility in terms of um having a bigger hand size and i'll talk through those in a bit so the the breakdown of the gameplay is gonna be quite simple so the first uh the first phase of the game is where you're going to roll these dice and allocate them onto their allocated spaces so you've got all these different resources you've got medicine you've got food you've got tools petrol i don't know what that one is and you've got um books as well of knowledge and so whenever you roll these dice you're going to allocate them on their specific spots and after you've done that you are going to out of your starting cans or whatever card you've uh accumulated throughout the game you're going to allocate them one each on these spots here and as i said you've got the potential for unlocking a full spot later in the game if you pay for it using this criteria here so let's say for example i chose let's say my doctor here i put these face down i choose my let's see my blue one here and let's just say for example i chose my um let's say i choose this mechanic here like this so once everybody's allocated them on
their on their spots here they're going to reveal them together like so and then you can choose to kind of activate their powers in any order so the way these simple ones are going to work these volunteers with the cubes on is going to be you are going to allocate one of your resource cubes like so onto the matching spot with the blue dice so for example here i would put one of my white cubes where the uh where the medicine is because that's where that's what the blue dye is currently showing now there are there is potential for a bit of um mitigation here by spending these uh these van tokens where you can choose to kind of traverse around the wheel either way to change the resources that you're getting so if i spend one van i can maybe get one of these if i spend two or in fact this is quite an easy setup for just spending one but if i spent one i can go here you know here or here but let's say i took a medicine in this example and now for example i've got a medicine resource i could choose to activate my doctor now my doctor says that i can pay um pay one medicine so what i'll do is i'll take my take my resource cue that i've just put on their back off in order to unlock someone from the hospital so these cars have been pre-allocated to a hospital spot i can actually choose to pay for them in order to get out of the hospital and straight into my hand so for example let's say i took my leader into my hand like so and the leaders are good because they let you take these other powerful abilities which i'll explain in a bit and also give you wild resources because
batteries here in the center are going to be wild resources and you do actually start the game with one of those um and whenever i take my doctor action i'm also going to get three points or all the points depending on the uh the card value uh you've also got other cards here such as your mechanic where you can get money three coins or if you trade in a tools uh resource you're gonna get an additional three coins you've got your scout here where you can trade in um fuel or knowledge in order to get these grs tokens which help you scout later in the game which i'll talk through in a bit and and so on so you that's the basic kind of actions you're going to play in order to activate your actual um volunteers and specialists now once that bit's done you are going to go on to phase three which is the objectives phase now this is where you're going to start cashing in your different resources and things in order to unlock either further volunteers say for example here if i cash in one of these one of these i would draw this card into my hand ready for use ready to be used going forward and additionally i would i would get to deploy one of my uh resource cubes onto one of these blue diamonds here so i'd actually start the game with um with one on the board but let's say um i let's say i start here because my mission or my card is to go from c to c so at the end of the game you know i'm going to well throughout the game i'm going to get more points if i go from c to c here by connecting the root but as
i said when i drew this that card um it would allow me to place a cue on these blue diamonds and normally i'd have to go from or add on to a region that's connecting to an existing cube but because this one doesn't exist connect to one of these diamonds directly then again i can spend one of my van tokens in order to skip a spot and maybe put it on there like that and surrounding these regions is going to be important for getting points based on this criteria here so depending on the size of the region for example this one here has got one two three four in order to surround this section here if i did so i would get five points all the way up to a seven region which would get me 14 points additionally you can always choose to contribute to your emergency plan by getting these tokens by scouting again which i'll talk about in a bit or by having a certain array of cards in a specific column so for example if i had a two purple card a yellow card and a red card in a single column then i will unlock that ability of getting five coins and when whenever i complete the whole um the whole criteria of the card i would get to deploy one of my resource cubes anywhere on the map obviously restricted to those placement rules and then take this card and put it above my board meaning i've got an almost permanent power throughout the game where i can choose to spend
um the these fuel into into points at certain spots in the game so that's going to be how the objectives are going to play out now then you go on to the scout action and the scout action is probably one of the only parts of the game that's maybe not so uh intuitive so in order to scout somewhere you are going to look at a region where you've got a cube in and and look at one of those adjacent regions so say for example here i've got a cube here so i can actually look in this region this region or this region i would reveal these secretly hidden from the other players and these these little tokens display different information so you've got a certain amount of navigation that you need to get this reward and in order to do that you are going to basically nominate a number of cards on your hand to try and match that criteria so all your different cars here apart from the uh the medic have a scouting value so this one's got a value of two uh one one one and so on and then you're going to basically choose any of those cars to try and match that value and if you match it or exceed it then you're going to get the um going to get the reward so you know if i matched five i'd get two medi kits if i match 10 i'll get two medi three medicates and two points and so on and the reason you want to do that is not only because at the end of the game for each different symbol you have you're going to get points based again on this chart here but also you are trying to fulfill the objective of your emergency plan because the first part here is to get one of those navigation tokens
in terms of getting points as a reward or or getting tools as an award and everybody's is different and whenever you do choose to match that criteria you're going to pick one of the cards that you've dedicated to it shuffle them up and then send one of them to the hospital at random so you know just because you've got someone out the hospital doesn't necessarily mean they're gonna stay out of the hospital and additionally if you ever choose to um take a duplicate throughout the game so say for example i end up getting this this one here if i ever take another one with a medi kit on if i can find one for example typically i can't find one they go for here i can never have two of the same ones on show although they're slightly different they're still ones that offer medikits as rewards i would actually put these face down meaning that whenever i scout from now on i would get an additional scouting point just just piggybacked onto my other abilities so just just um focusing on different ones isn't necessarily always the best thing to do because if you focus on the same ones you get more potential for scouting and again once you once you've taken one of these they'll go face up but if you choose not to they will revert to being face down so that's going to be how the the scouting is going to work and again everybody's going to go around these in player order to do so and then you've got the ability to buy new objectives and new volunteers or specialists and you do that based on these these cards to the side of the board here so there's always going to be or there's going to start with three
available in each of these rows and you're going to spend either four coins three coins or two coins depending on how many there are in that row so if there's three in a row you're gonna place four coins per card if there's three uh two in a row you can spend three and if there's only one in a row you spend two and these offer further objectives so you know for example here you know if you cash in seven money and have two purple cards and a yellow and a yellow um card in a row then you get to add this the checkpoint here which means that whenever you take one of these checkpoint powers you'll get three coins and additionally you'll get a one point bonus and get to deploy anywhere on the board again depending on those research um criteria some of the cards have number a number of abilities here and you can either choose to complete all the criteria and if you do you get an additional five points but you can choose to kind of pay it out early by just having one of the criteria just so you can put it on this checkpoint bonus so it's one of those things where you can kind of go all in and try to get all the all the bonuses and the bonus or all the kind of criteria and the bonus or kind of just maybe look at it as in going for the checkpoint award you've got additional volunteers here which can get you three three resources at a time and again offer you more points at the end of the game based on the value of the cards and so on so as the game goes on you are actually going to get more powerful volunteers um new a bit new objectives to go for
and so on to keep the game ticking along once that's done you're going to clear up clean up all the um all the parts of the board so all the the right hand side of all the cards are going to get replaced uh sorry going to get wiped off and if there's ever no cards in a column then they're going to get replenished every food resource you've got converts into two coins every water converts into one coin or if you've got two water you can spend them in to get a navigation token which can be used to boost your scouting ability now the as i said the the um the food and the water uh you gotta be wary of because of that reason because they are actually perishable so you can't just piggyback or try to just completely stockpile on food and water because it's just going to end up going to waste after that you are going to do the secure districts action which as i mentioned earlier if you've surrounded a region you get to choose to basically cash it in and get the points based on the charts you'd also get to pick up one of these houses from here which correspond to that checkpoint action i was talking to talking about where i could take one of these houses and put it in the region that i've surrounded so let's say for example i did have this one surrounded i put my house in the center here which means that nobody else can go there but it also means i've unlocked this slot here which means that when it goes to the next phase the refresh hand phase if i have four or fewer cards i can choose to take one of these rows or one of these columns of cards back into my hand which sometimes you will want to do but
sometimes you won't because you'll be looking at the criteria of certain cards which you want to go for and again if you choose to take that take um take take a column of cards back you get to choose one of these checkpoint actions that might not only just be on the board but there could also be ones that you've gained through abilities of objective cards and that's going to be how the game's going to play until the deck of cards is going to deplete um based on the number of players so it's actually a pretty a pretty simple game once you go through it for you know formulaically um but there's a lot of different things to go for a lot of these objectives are pushing you in different directions you can choose to do these objections here to make your engine a little bit better in terms of paying 10 coins and having two purple cards and two yellow cards in order to get 10 points and to unlock your fourth slot which will give you more flexibility because you've got another slot to play cards on and ultimately will get you more um more research resources and things or you can choose to um spend four uh there's four of the same resource uh two blue cards two red cards in order to get 10 points and to increase your refresh limit to six cards which means that you can actually choose to start taking columns back not only when you have four cards off you but when you have six cards or fewer so that's going to be how the game's going to play so let's talk about how i feel about the game so in terms of meaningful decisions there's actually quite a lot to go over here now do you want to try and maybe go for the big juicy regions here in terms of getting these almost like set collection bonuses
do you want to maybe go over more objective based um kind of pathway in terms of getting your your objectives done here or getting other missions done and so on so there's quite a quite a few little contrasting abilities there you can really choose to build up your engine and get those uh bonuses here which not only get you 10 points bit will increase your options going forward and make you a bit more versatile as a player or are you going to really focus on getting the you know getting the resources in terms of getting better staff members because the more powerful staff members or sorry volunteers that you accrue throughout the game are going to be worth points at the end of the game as long as they're not in the hospital so it's important that you keep your people at the hospital and you can't really choose to constantly sacrifice them and of course you know sacrificing them to the hospital is probably going to be well it's going to happen because you're going to want to scout some at some points in the game in order to get the different tokens and stuff and so on and of course you've always got your doctor as an option in order to try and get them back but apart from all the strategic things as well you've also got the the way you're actually going to play the cards into these different columns because you can use them to get the objectives and things but you also want to be aware that you've got you want to put things in order so that when you take a take a hand of cards back you've got what you need to go forward in the game and progress so you can't just play them on any row or column you know as you you know without thoughts because you're probably going to bite yourself in the ass if you do so so i do like all the different decisions
that go on here there's quite a few things you want to focus on resources are pretty limited um meaning you're going to have to probably get those more powerful volunteers so you can get more resources per turn you know you've got to be worried about how you're going to use these van tokens because you are given a limited amount at the start of the start of the game and you know using them kind of willy-nilly isn't gonna help you so yeah there are a lot of things to talk to think about and so on so meaningful decision-wise is certainly um a strong a strong game for that uh the balance of the game as well i know all these different paths you can take are more than fair in terms of the points they're going to give you i don't really see a runaway strategy so so yeah i think i think it's a more a more than fairly balanced game the mechanics or the you know the way the game flows and the different things that go on in the game i think it is good i mean i think initially it's going to be a bit choppy in terms of learning phase by phase by phase but when you break it down a lot of these are pretty simple in terms of like just roll the dice and plan your cards then actually use the cards um you know dedicate your resources to the objectives and so on so while it's still a bit phase oriented and said a bit a bit stop and start it actually in their own right all the different phases are pretty simple um i do quite like this little resource world i like how that works and again you've got the manipulation of using those van tokens to if you if you want particular resources you can do so
and also the the dye values or the faces on the die are actually disproportionate so the medicine is quite rare so if you do happen to roll the medicine you might want to kind of stockpile on that and try to get it while you can and develop your divert your plan in almost tactical way based on the resources available and the same thing applies to these here so again if there's something you particularly want you might have to divert your strategy to get a particularly good tactical card at that moment um i do like the the the vast kind of spread of the different objectives you can get they do kind of make you do lots of interesting things such as connecting region to region um i like the idea of having to spend cards in rows and columns and having certain colors to make those objectives and of course you're trying to get all the different scout tokens to get to get the whole sets to get those you know a big chunk of 14 points at the end of the game the the um time investment of the game i think it works about right i said i think the the 150 minutes it says on the board is a bit of a stretch i can't really see the game taking that long and yeah i think it would be a pretty slow game and a bunch of slow players for it to drag on that long i think it's a pretty standard euro time stamp of about 90 minutes the uptime as well because the phases are quite quick in the way they play and some of them you can play simultaneously um i don't really see much scope for being bogged down and waiting for other
players to take their turn it always feels like you're doing something maybe the scouting part of the game feels a little bit isolated in terms of letting other people do their thing while you sit back and do nothing but at the same time there i suppose there's a bit of turn angst there where if there's a particular token you want and someone's taken it then um you know you've got to sit there idly and just um hope they don't take the one you want the replayability i think is good in this game there's a lot of different objectives there's a lot of different cards you know different emergency plans you're starting with so yeah i think replayability is pretty strong and interaction wise it's there's not a whole bunch of interaction um i suppose there's some scarcity in terms of surrounding the regions and interestingly enough when say i i surrounded this region and another player had maybe got two of those four criteria i would get the full points and get to put my house down but the other players would still get their points based on how many buildings they have around that section so just you're not going to get completely shut out of the game and all those all that investment isn't going to go to waste if um if somebody closes it off before you get the chance to so i do actually like that element of player interaction and it's not an all-or-nothing kind of vibe um so yeah in terms of player interaction it's it's absolutely fine there's some passive kind of passive player interaction with some small games by doing things quicker than others yeah of course there's scarcity of certain volunteers and objectives that are available so that's
going to be somewhat important as well um the aesthetics of the game is something i personally like i think a lot of people aren't going to like the black and white vibe it's obviously it's fitting of the theme and the the game itself because it's a blackout but it's a very dark looking game but i think it gives it a somewhat of a unique vibe i don't mind that the way these almost vibrant colors are sitting on on the blackboard i think it looks quite cool um i like the artwork of the cards it's almost black and white with a tinge of color on them i think it looks cool i think it's got a different vibe and it by just by looking at this game at a glance you can tell what it is which i think is a good thing to kind of diversify itself and stand out from the crowd component quality as well is more than up to scratch i mean all the player boards are good quality the board's decent the cards are absolutely fine quality um you know not the best of the best but certainly no issue here and you know if i didn't have to comment on the components it wouldn't even cross my mind because they're more than up to scratch the theme as well it's more of a skin i mean it's not a thematic game but it's fine i like the different approaches taken and it certainly is a new ground and i can't think of any other game about having a blackout so at least that's commendable at least to go for something a bit different um and the setup and teardown time is not much of an issue yeah you've got a bunch of cards everywhere but the setup is a save for every player just do some different starting cards out each deal deal everyone out one of these emergency plans and i suppose the biggest bug bear is putting all these different um
navigation or scouting tokens out because you've got three on each region which is a bit fiddly but nothing too onerous the progression is nice because you are constantly getting better cards into your hand you know going for these new objectives and getting more money and stuff so the game does tick along nicely and has a nice upward kind of incline in terms of the gameplay and scalability as well you can play this perfectly fine at any play account um i i can't really see an issue and it's one of those games where if you do solely play at two players you're going to get the absolute full experience of the game without having to sacrifice anything um the comparison wise this does feel like a fist the game i mean if you do like alexander fisted designs this one does have some of those um kind of signature trademarks that he's known for particularly this little card thing here i mean i like the way that he makes you play cards in certain ways in certain slots this reminds me of mombasa where when you play your cards and you have to take a column at the end of the round whatever so that one's very synonymous of mombasa um but other than that it's got a veil a real vibe of a fist the game but still has some quite different things here in terms of the resource wheel in terms of the almost airy controller of controlling the regions the card draft is a little bit different and so on so uh in terms of that is is quite it's not necessary but it's it's different enough to be to stand in its own regard
so yeah overall this was a really nice game for me i completely enjoyed it um i said i was a bit concerned about it being so choppy in terms of breaking down in the different phases but it actually does end up flowing really nicely the hand management is good in terms of playing them in the different rows i like the different investments you can make um and so on so there are lots of interesting decisions here the you know the addictive the idea when you're when you're traveling or scouting these different regions the fact that you're gonna have to you know sacrifice one of your cards at random that could be a bit of a tense moment and can offer some you know frustrating but in a good way moments where you you know you might use your leader because he's got the best navigation but um end up losing him as soon as he gets out the hospital so that's really cool obviously you want to have everyone out at the hospital at the end of the game because you want all the points available on the characters themselves you want to get all the different um tokens which is attempt something to go for but at the same time as i said going for the same tokens is going to be good because it's going to increase your navigation ability and having these navigation tokens is extremely useful because they really do bolster your potential to scout the highest things which get you great rewards you know for example here the 16 one get you four books and six points which would be really significant so lots of different things you can focus on and um you know increase your potential to do things depending on the different routes you want to go down but yeah overall a really nice game that came together well for me i said just a just a pleasant experience and um certainly another vista game that holds its you
know holds itself strong and just a testament to what a great designer he is um yeah no complaints whatsoever happily play this one anytime um and yeah if it appeals to you and you like your vista games this is another one of his catalogue that isn't going to let you down um i understand that people aren't so keen on this one compared to a lot of the others but maybe because it's that step down in terms of its weights and complexity it's not your quite western trails it's not your maracaibo's but still it's it's still certainly a mid-weight euro game that's a lot of fun to play so that concludes my thoughts on blackout hong kong it certainly gets my seal of quality um it's certainly going to stay in my collection as well so if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too additionally you can support me by backing me on patreon or follow me on instagram and i'll leave the links below for those for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye