Skip to main content
Loading video...

Gaia Project Review - Space Me Baby One More Time

Transcript 17:23

talking about the gaia project without having ever discussed Terra Mystica it doesn't make any sense it's kind of like trying to discuss John Lennon solo career without having ever first explored the Beatles all kind of like trying to analyze Brian Wilson's breakdown in the 90s without having ever heard the pure genius of Pet Sounds it's not to say that the aya project is somehow a breakdown or an esoteric self and dungeon exploration compared to magnificence it is simply to say that Terra Mystica made me fall in love with board games and Gaia well guy as a sequel Gaea project is in space and in space there isn't enough space the only solution is to take your space species and make more space for yourself by terraforming each player picks a dorky Poundland illustrated sheet full of plastic little houses called mines and plops them onto planets over the course of six rounds later those houses can be upgraded to trading stations which themselves can be upgraded interplanetary Institute's which will unlock a special ability unique to your species or alternatively can be upgraded into research labs which unlock technologies and then can again be upgraded into academies which unlock more technologies when I say Terra Mystica made me fall in love with board games that's not to say that only that there is the first board game that I played and put a firecracker down my pants know what I mean to say is that I played many

board games before that and do you know what I loved some of them but it's not until I played this game that I realized that I want board games to be a big part of my life do you ask take Terra Mystica to be your lawfully-wedded board game in sickness and in health forever and ever and ever till the meta game is stale and until the cardboard rots and rots and the worms are poking through it do why I do I do because Terra Mystica showed me just how devilishly complicated games can be or they can challenge me in every single step yet offer me choices in all of those steps how they can be just as competitive as those aims with mini shoes on the map but it's a euro game and in that regard Gaea it's just as wonderful in in garlic your spray species is your space species because it allows you to do something that no one else can do you're given an entire picnic hamper full these are actually not resources they're just pieces and other players colors because resources are tracked on this this board right here but I had to illustrate their abundance somehow didn't I and you can do anything you like you want to build this big stupid dumb planetary Institute on round one you can do that do you want these research institutes or academy's on round one so you could get yourself a new tag yes you can do that and how

about a mineshaft planting them around the mouth also doable and you know what it's not the gist they're doable it's that there are all viable strategies to set you up towards winning the game and now I have to sort out all these resources because I can't just leave the place each time you build something well first you'll have to pay for whatever you're building that's not the exciting part but the exciting part is actually you get to take the piece off the board and don't get down on the map and then you'll reveal a new symbol and that symbol is usually something extra you will get during the income face at the start of each round new resources and that way guys very much like an advent calendar each time you scratch something off you reveal a new toy to mess around with and you go what is that what is it apparently it's a brain stone I probably shouldn't and just this guy a giveth so it diminishes and it diminishes your ability to go on massive shopping sprees the round ends when you say it ends which is usually when you have spent all of your resources and suddenly you find yourself like a student in a giant intergalactic shopping mall and you've spent your entire student loan in day one and you mostly bought things made out of fermented sugar and you're going to have to make the next three to eight years work do you know what you do make it work advantages in Gaia are small and that's an understatement and you have to put in a lot of work to

milk that utter of engine building let's say I want to build a mana can only build mine on planets obviously and first of all if I don't have a yellow planet next to me I have to build on a planet that is not of my type and to do that I have to terraform I can also build planets that are not adjacent to me but that costs Qi seas and there are really versatile and hard to come by resource so the term for this particular planet which is the only planet rather right now is adjacent to me and available to be terraformed I have to spend a number of terraforming steps depending on what species I'm playing and also what type the planet is in this particular case that's free terraforming steps each terraforming step is free or and plus the one all for building the mine itself that would cost me a total of ten or I start the game with seven and then I get about for each round guess what I have to do to increase the number of or I get at the starter very round that's right build more mines you'll struggle in round two you'll maybe muster a single build or an upgrade before you eventually run out of money again but then if you played smart returns will start flowing in small increments you'll notice how diffidence come back like a bonsai tree that shed all its leaves in a bout of stress and then sprang its first new one as if to tell you that you haven't actually killed it when your

opponents build something near you you get to charge power which of these purple disks on your players sheet when you charge power first you have to charge anything that's in ball number one into ball number two and then when there's nothing in ball number one left you get to charge it from ball number two into ball number three and then when those things in ball number three you get to spend it on various goods and resources or taking special actions and race your landlord might find exorbitant and the back to your buildings are the more power you get to charge but at the cost of victory points and suddenly wall displacement all these expensive spaces matter because you want to be adjacent to your opponent so everything has an upside and a downside and you're just a sad space clown on a tight wire desperately trying to hold for balance while struggling razor blades of bankruptcy I'm making this game sound harsher than it really is and I promise you satisfaction is guaranteed somewhere down the line because the more you build the more the cogs turn becoming an example of trickle-down economy that actually works because it trickles down from you to you and then the sixth-round looms in front of you and you can no longer sit in your seat because the anticipation of seeing it all come together burns your bottom every time you park it after telling yourself after sit down you're being inappropriately excited about playing this game

absolutely extraordinary reviewers shut up and sit down whose opinion I enormous ly respect have accused the changes in going up to be mostly fat added to what is by no means a garden salad over a game recommending Terra Mystica overall to those starting out with the series but this time I would have to respectfully disagree by saying that we would almost recommend Gaia over Terra Mystica wait a minute doesn't that just mean we agree no not quite guys changes aren't that they are in fact sugar Terra Mystica has this weird cult tract not really sure what kinds of other cult tracks exist advancing on this track was important to win the game because the players at the very top would earn the most points enough points to make it an essential part of your winning strategy but advancing on this track was just about as fun as advancing in the ranks over real cult where you spent decades worth of earnings for an entirely perceived reward Gaia however like an interstellar tractor or maybe a cumbersome Space Marine Rhino also gives you tracks but these are tracks filled with candy every single advancement either gives you an immediate reward or improves your spiciness whereas here look I moved up the track nothing happens I move the track nothing happens I move the truck oh I got one power I moved up the track

nothing happens fun right you can trade to fly better so you move up on the track that increases the range at which you travel for maybe what terraforming itself to be cheaper go up on the brown track maybe you want more gaia formas and the cost of gaia forming planets to be reduced and you can move up on this track or you can even go up on the track that lets you train better so you can train more so you can increase the rate at which you try and so that you can do more training admittedly some of these things already existed in Terra Mystica but now they're all here condensed into a single board and it feels less flat and more dynamic but the real icing on the cake is the advanced technology trial that you get when you reach the top of any track and bees well these are very much like a glass a cherry but so good you actually want to eat it it's a reward it's like putting down that final sentence on your dissertation and knowing that you still have to edit it because it's rough but the final body of work is done somehow despite all those years of procrastinating and alcohol let's explore how this works in the game say you're playing Terrans who get extra resources for terraforming the special Gaia planets which don't have a terraforming cost of all but rather require you to move all your power to a special area where it becomes unusable for around not only do you get to invest in technology that gives you more Gaia

form as necessary for the job but you also notice that a there's a basic tech tile that gives you three points every time you terraform a Gaia planet an advanced technology tower at the top of the track that scores you three points each time you build any mine and additionally you notice that during round six you'll score four extra points each time you guys form instead of cashing in on your species bonus on round you send out your Gaia formers to work but wait until you reach that advanced tech tile to turn them into mines and during round six you cash in for a whopping 30 points as school as Terra Mystica was I don't remember combo tastic delight of such proportions neither fat nor sugar is an essential ingredient but if we're talking about signing up folks to play heavy euro games who are not necessarily used to heavy euro games that I'd rather give them cake than signing up to Scientology either version of Terra Mystica is a complicated but most importantly highly competitive game that will not just test your wits but also your ability to stay cool under the unrelentingly boring drill of math as you spin out of control or cut it short if this is your first game you will lose but everyone I introduced to the Terra Mystica system via Gaea had fun losing they got to poke and prod and explore they weren't necessarily playing a reactionary game they had a plan and they got to execute it and even if their plan wasn't the best plan necessarily they still got that cherry at the top

but Gaea don't stop there dot it across the system get its system cos its pace a little of quality-of-life improvements such as the revision to the power system which no longer creates abusive relationships between you and your opponent's structures all the new technology tiles which are less of an automatic decision and more of a considered revision but all of this sponge sugar stuff shatters if you've got no one to guide you and not because Gaia is any more complicated it's just not as accessible if you and your friends have never played either version before and you're not generally use to the heavier side of gaming then this might just be a slog you are not ready for and it all comes down to this rule book and how it treats its readers the purpose of this manual is very clear that is to impart all of the rules which is a noble and valiant cause but just like a lone knight riding into battle with neighbored a bucket for a shield against an army of 5000 barbarians that is futile and frankly a little bit stupid and was one admires the bravery well it even managed to do that if I'm honest technically all the rules are there if we count the added clarification but there are so many ambiguities during actual play that Fred's and BoardGameGeek with clarification needed sprung up like mushrooms bring up after a heavy rain in our first game we had a starving through the rulebook every five minutes just to check if we were doing things right or if we got the Gaia forming thing correct and this is coming from someone who could probably teach

you the original Terra Mystica blindfolded right first you need to know that there are eight actions there's a tablet here that's not the tablet this tablet here it tells you what the actions are you want to build a you want to build a mine and you just build the mine you need to spend you need to spend this and I can't find that is that the resource I think that's a bridge anyway you can upgrade the mine into a trading station and there's some great the trading station into a temple then you can get a favor flower I don't think I'm doing let me show you what I mean it's round one and we want to gonna form this transient planet which requires us to move all our power from a power balls to this reserved Gaia space now the income phase of round two comes up and we're eagerly anticipating receiving all the power that we rode except we won't get any because there is no power in the balls to move around which is I guess obvious if you played Terra Mystica before and you read the rulebook but it doesn't specifically mention that it just lists the sequence of events which is not very friendly to people who are new to this game and I could easily see them making that mistake in round one and going will dot that mocked up my game I don't want to play the second game can we restart can we restart this game because and it's laborious and tedious isn't it and can we talk about Gaius theme for a second look I know

that not everyone who likes heavy euro games really cares about theme that much at all but I like to play games not just for the mechanisms but I like to get lost in the worlds that they create and I don't even care if it's something over you like sci-fi or fantasy I just want to see how the game execute that theme and the way Gaia executes its theme is by well it just doesn't there is some space odd co-inky-dink it is the unintentionally funniest board game art since terraforming Mars and that's it I mean her mystical wasn't necessarily the best game in that regard but at least it had something it had a backstory for each race something to chew on and look yeah who are these space bird people what secrets do the Hajj kailash hold to the tickle you into submission with the feathers nothing Gaius theme is as cold as the space it inhabits and yet mechanically it makes me jump like a seal jumps for sardines is it better than Terra Mystica without a shadow of a doubt yes it is look I love this guy I love this guy so much more and should you buy it should you get it well if you've played to her mystic as much as Sonic have you already have this it's on your shelf I don't need to tell you and if you're into heavy games my friend it will set your loins on fire and if you're not into heavy games and you're kind of curious wondering maybe maybe I should try this

then well it's ugly it's got no theme and the rule book is the lead to the SONA of your brain and I'm not going to make that decision for you hello I just broke my wooden insert for Terra Mystica that's just one of the tiniest costs of making this channel entertaining informative and independent from publishers and what we want from you right now is to hit that subscribe button because I it's good for your health and be well you're gonna see more of these entertaining fun informative videos we look out for each other bye bye

Progress saved