Counterpoint Review (New Kickstarter!)
Transcript
Welcome to BoardGameAnimal. My name is Justin. And today we're talking about Counterpoint. Counterpoint is a new cooperative trick-taking game from Ted Mancuso is now on crowdfunding. When I first heard about this one, I was intrigued for a lot of reasons. Most especially that it's a new cooperative trick-taker coming on to the scene. Would this one stand out amongst the other giants that are already in this category? And even if it is as good, would it be unique enough to matter? I can't talk about this one unfortunately without inevitable comparison or at least mention to the crews or the Lord of the Ring trick-takers. But in this case, it's a good thing. So, let's take a look. You're going to be working together to play a piece of music. There will be a deck of cards comprised of as many suits as there are players with each player having a designated suit they're trying to win cards of.
After the deal, a trump suit will be revealed and each player passes a card. At this point comes the bid where going around folks will bid on how many cards of their suit they will win. As the game progresses, as mentioned with the bid, you were trying to capture cards of your color. And along the way you have a rest card and a special power that can be used to assist in achieving the goals of the mission. Because on top of everyone meeting their bids, the game also comes with a collection of pieces to perform that will add challenge and quirks to the play. Different restrictions, goals, etc. And if all players have met or exceeded their bids and any specific goals of the chapter were met, then you have successfully won Counterpoint. Now, first I want to address the theme here because I actually think that this is incredibly relevant. Yes, you do have these anthropomorphic animals playing music, but that's actually the key factor is the playing of the music.
Playing this game genuinely does feel like you're putting on a performance. The structure of the game for me feels less like you're just trying to process a puzzle like a lot of cooperative games, especially cooperative trick-taking games can be. Because normally you're kind of walking that proverbial tightrope trying to make sure you're not making mistakes, and it's all very cerebral. But, here you do feel more like you're all working together, trying to cohesively deliver musical arrangement. And something about the flow of the card play, and knowing that everyone is trying to win and succeed in their own area, just like any musician would be trying to perform their instrument properly into the best of their ability, there is a theme and gameplay cohesion here that you may not otherwise expect. Even as you play harder chapters, and the goals become more challenging, more for the audience of folks who love these big crazy crunchy trick-takers, it still doesn't feel as punishing or leave you as defeated per se as maybe other cooperative games might. It still can be difficult and head-scratchy at times, don't get me wrong, but the whole thing feels smoother, and lending to that theme, again, feeling like a performance.
And the production here for this game really makes it shine even more. Bidding tokens being music notes, having your little sheet music stand for your player, the spiral notebook of sheet music that outlines the details of any given play, it gives the game some whimsy and elegance that helps take the pressure off a little. Because, at the end of the day, this is still a game about intricacy and accuracy of play, but much like, you know, playing music. But, the production and theming here help give you feelings of going with the flow, getting in the rhythm, and getting lost in the trick play, much like getting lost in the music, and not particularly overthinking what you're doing. A subtle thing, but it actually does make a difference. Again, it's not that it's not difficult, or that it's not intricate, but unlike what feels like cold, calculated precision when you're playing The Crew, or the adrenaline of adventure and survival or combat in The Lord of the Rings, this just delivers a different feeling while playing. I think this game though manages to accomplish multiple things. If you already enjoy some of the aforementioned co-op trick-takers, and would like something that delivers this genre in a quality way, but different, then Counterpoint will do just that, but with multiple twists on what you're expecting.
Alternatively, I actually think if you're just simply not a fan of those others, your heart may still have some room for this one. As I said, the delivery is so different. If you want a co-op trick-taker, and the other ones weren't for you, then this is the one I would suggest you try. For me, I think Counterpoint is a massive win in such a specific niche corner of an already niche corner of the hobby. Because when you bring a game into a conversation with other powerhouses, relevance matters, right? So, being able to do something under this umbrella feel wholly unique and satisfying and maybe even have a wider appeal in certain areas, I just love everything that Counterpoint is doing here. Again, Counterpoint is now on crowdfunding, and I really hope you go check this one out. It is really fun. Uh the link to the Kickstarter is going to be down below in the description.
And I want to give a huge thanks for the review copy. And for anyone new to the channel, please know that uh I have a high standard that that I am always brutally honest when it comes to these reviews, regardless of who the designer is uh or how I was able to play the game. So, know that this comes from a place of genuineness, and Counterpoint is really a delight. And I hope you get the opportunity to give it a try. So, please, please go check this one out. Uh it is a lot of fun. If you have any questions or comments, please leave them down below. Thank you so much for watching, liking, and subscribing, and don't forget to play all your board games like an animal. Like an animal who plays a beautiful piece of music.