Wingspan Pocket is more than you might think - TCbH Review
Transcript
Since its 2019 release, we've played, puppeted, and pontificated quite a lot about Wingspan. It's one of our all-time faves, our baes, our desert island games. You know, cardboard comfort food. However, with its extreme success, it's grown, and we're kitchen sink kind of people when it comes to our birds. And what used to be an approachable lighter side of midweight game is now one heck of a board, which brings us to Wingspan Pocket. The newly announced as of publishing this video, and actually still unannounced and under embargo as of recording this video, 30-minute Wingspan game that purportedly is perfect for that leaner, meaner, grab-on-the-go type of experience. But, is it perfect for that? And is there any case where this is better than the other, or vice versa? I have some thoughts.
In most ways, Wingspan Pocket is a direct, more condensed, more efficient translation of the original game. You got bird cards that you put into play from your hand for their abilities, effects, and egg capacities, which, yeah, you also have eggs as a non-food resource and a point generator, and food as your primary resource. But, here's where the twist really start. You only have one lane, starting with the nest, no longer splitting habitats. Birds are always played to the right of your row, and the sixth by any player triggering the end of the game. And the food you use is no longer from tokens and dice, but on the backs of the bird cards in four decks, likewise supplying four revealed birds. As you claim cards, birds will always be on the bird side, and food is food. But, in a skookum bit of design efficiency, taking one or the other is always turning the available food on display. What makes it snappy, though, is all four primary actions from OG are consolidated onto this lane, and all four, even playing a bird, activates the brown powers for all your birds in play. Now, from left to right, play a bird, activate your chain. Lay three eggs, importantly modified to three eggs on three different cards, and activate your chain. Draw a card, which, yeah, it can either be bird cards or food, better believe that activates your chain.
This is probably my favorite part of the whole deal. You're spitting out little micro engines, which of course give you more resources, bird cards, tuck different cards for points, or house a myriad of other effects. And there's something that feels kind of wrong in a deliciously devious sort of way about playing a bird to the end of your row and immediately activating that row as part of the action. It gives it a bit of a flighty pepper, an edge to it that the original never had. Now, don't get me wrong, I love Wingspan, but where the original felt methodical, this one feels a little bit more on tilt in a way that I really like.
Of note, while there does seem to be a lot of great combos you can eke out of the game, the sheer efficiency of the design cuts down on the ferocity of certain broken wombo combos you can fall into in Wingspan. In the older game, you would look for ways to eliminate the need for wasting precious actions on one row or another, card draw in the forest, or food in your grasslands. And while the common raven makes a return, it seems to be nowhere near the menace, the absolute goblin of his earlier appearance, primarily because there's no rows to break out of.
That's not to say you can't have some serious imbalance of scores, but for the most part, it seems like you're given so many opportunities to cobble something together, and the maximum capacity of birds and their paltry capacity of eggs, that it more or less seems reigned in. And speaking of our old pal, the common raven, it seems like there's a mix of old and new illustrations and birds in here. I seem to recall some being slightly different, but iconic looks like my girl Gloria are obviously recycled. And while those illustrations are great, I do wish that it had a different visual identity. I'll get a little bit more into that in a bit. Mechanically though, there are some interesting passive persistent powers on birds now that are welcome additions. While the range of bird effects is greatly simplified to the point where most powers are now simply reliant on symbology, it doesn't seem dumbed down either, just less nuanced to fit the game it's going for.
So, as you can tell, I'm not in my studio. I'm not even in Alaska right now. I'm at Nye Beach in Newport, Oregon. Serendipitously, I was sent this game for review right before we were going on vacation, which shout out to Kingdom of Nye and Lock and Key, two awesome FLGSs here in the area. But, it gave me a unique case scenario to test some of the selling points of the game. It's a game that packs light, slightly easier to teach if family wanted to get in on the action, but could also deliver the goods for Christina and I when we want to just get our freaking gaming on. And for that, it works perfectly. I'm the type of guy who does bring games with me on vacation because I'm a game guy. What am I going to do?
My family wants and expects me to bring some games. And even when it's just Christina and I, I want things that play in about 30 minutes, something that I can play at the end of an exhausting day of doing other things with other people, and I don't necessarily have the head space for a huge amount of complexity, but I still want something that's tight, efficient, clever, curious, and you know, you can bang out and still have a really good time. And this fits that duck bill just right. Add to that it has the typically excellent Stonemaier Automata Factory solo mode, and you got yourself one heck of a time. Now, would I choose to play this over the original?
If all things are equal, honestly, no. If I'm given an equal amount of play space, I have the mental acuity, I have the time set aside, I have the players, the wherewithal, I have everything set up in the perfect conditions, then I'm reaching for the original. I freaking love Wingspan. I especially love what some of the expansions do for it, even if they ratchet up the complexity. Good for us, things aren't always equal. I find myself tons of situations where I don't have the time, space, or that mental energy for a full box game, or I'm traveling for camping, or for work, or vacation, and I want to pack in something small, or I'm meeting a friend for lunch. Wingspan Pocket is in no way redundant in my collection, and is honestly better than most of the games of this size that I have. So, I'm thrilled with it. With only true disappointment being that this is a missed opportunity to have a fourth brand new span game that was all about bugs, insects, the world of the small things in the pocket-size edition, giving itself more of an identity, and furthering itself from direct comparison, but
[snorts]
that's not the game we got. So, yeah, if you're just looking for a great small box game that plays up to five and gives you a lot of goods in a short amount of time, or you're a dedicated span fan, and you want it to be that sort of experience, but grab on the go, or maybe you liked, but didn't love the original Wingspan, and you wanted it to be a little bit tighter, leaner, meaner, leaning in, then I think this is going to do it for you. It's just It's just a really, really great game. And that's our review. But let me know, what is your favorite Span game now, and what would you make as the next Span titled game distinct? Not birds, not worms, not fish, you know, what what what's the next Spaniverse game that you'd love to see? Put it in the comments, and as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help us. We never accept any money from publishers, so we rely on you for the likes, subscribes, comments, talking about us out on the internet webs, and of course, checking out our Patreon. But above all else, thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack or The Cardboard Harold.