Skip to main content
Loading video...

Under the Leaves Review: Thank You Very Mulch

Transcript 12:19

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal.

I'm Zee Garcia.

Today we're looking at a game called Under the Leaves.

Under the leaves.

I'll tell you what, Under the Leaves is a thing I don't Like if there's like a

You don't go You don't mess with Under the Leaves.

I'm not messing with

world. There might be a portal down there to a snake pit.

It's not that. There's like, you know a pile of bugs are under there or something. But here sprites. Cute sprites. It's a tile laying game in which you are trying to accumulate the most sprites. Here's how it plays. In this game each player is going to get a starting tile that's going to show different types of terrain as well as puddle puddles. A type of terrain, but it's a little bit different than the rest of the different terrains. You're going to have leaf dwellers, puddle dwellers, and mushroom dwellers as long as well as hummingbirds and bumblebees out in the middle of the table. You're going to draw a card for each of the different dwellers or you can pick which card you want to use that shows how they score. There's a big bag full of tiles here and you'll have three tiles face up and on a player's turn they're going to be taking one of these tiles and then connecting it with their board. When you connect a tile, you connect tiles adjacently like I did here. You check to see if you can put out any of the creatures. First, you'll check to see if anything is pollinated. That means there's three of the same type of terrain not including ponds.

There is. Whenever you pollinate an area, you put a bee. And it's possible to pollinate multiple areas. See, if I put this tile out I'll put a pollination what there. If I put this out, that's four, but it still counts as pollinating. Now, when you pollinate all the terrain types that are on a tile, then you get to put a hummingbird on that tile. In fact, if you put three hummingbirds in a row, whether it's a row or a column, then the middle one will get another hummingbird. If I did all these, I'd get a third hummingbird on that spot. Not only that, whenever you pollinate, so let's say I place this tile here. I made a new pink area and I pollinate that, but I already have a pink area, so I'll put another one in that spot and that will keep going. If later on, when I place this tile here, I get to put one here. I will also get to put one in this spot and a third one here, which I'll just represent with this level three.

You also will follow the rules for the other ones. For example, leaf dweller says if I have four different terrain types forming a square, which I don't have right now. Um here I have one, two, three, but if I had four, then I would put this one in the middle of them. The diver here that I'm using says if I have two water terrains, a puddle next to each other, then I put this in the middle. And then the explorer here for the mushroom dwellers says if I have three mushrooms in a row, so if later on I get a tile and I put it like this, then I now have three in a row and I put this guy on the middle. And you'll follow all the other rules. You will continue to do this until the bag runs out of tiles. Everyone will have placed 12 tiles and then you simply take all your creatures. You're going to be comparing all the different creatures that you have with one bonus. Whoever has the most of each type of creatures will get two more of that type of creature.

So ties don't count and so you'll add them all together and whoever has the most is the winner.

The first thing we can talk about Under the Leaves is they are they have dialed up the cuteness factor to a million like you will love these cute sprites cuz they're like these little things and every time I played this where in a public setting someone has come by and like what's this? What's this? And I think it will sell on that alone. Maybe not from the cover cuz the cover is it's it's it's cute art but the cover does not match the game almost.

I feel like the cover's cuter than the game. The cards are cute. The car and the cover but then the the board is pretty

[snorts]

plain. The board that the tiles

I'm talking about those little

The little wooden like guys? They kind of look to me the they look like that video game where the the aliens come down. Oh, a little bit the

Space Invaders?

Yeah, or Galaga or something. Yeah, something like

though that they break easily.

They do.

There's a few in here that are broken again because they're cutting those holes in them so it makes them weaker.

A little piece right here.

Oh, yeah.

Yellow guy.

This game on the side of the box says 30 minutes. That is 100% on the high end.

Yeah, it's very quick.

It's going to be a quicker game with the exception there's going to be some people who never get to play this game with me because they're going to sit there and look at the three tiles and look at the number of ways they can score. And I don't think you should play this game that way. You're I mean you're trying to win but just this tile goes there gets a lot of points. That seems good. Yeah, you know what? I'll do that instead of calculating every possible thing.

Because there is no hidden scoring. Um there's nothing hidden really then you can if you are prone to analysis paralysis you really can't calculate every potential combination and as you are building up to those 13 tiles or whatever the those those options compound. So yeah, absolutely.

Yeah, you can you can literally figure out the most points you can get. The only thing you can't do is you can't guess for what tiles will come out in the future.

Right.

Um but

That's worse though because I get to see a brand new tile right before I go which means if I am someone prone to that, I have to do the permutations for that one now. You know, um I don't love that part. I don't love games that don't have any hidden scoring, that don't have any Again, that there is no that obscurity of of choice. I like that in a game. It keeps the thing going. This one doesn't have any of that. The flip side of that is it's small enough where even with someone who is who falls prey to that, it shouldn't be too bad. I agree.

You would think it almost would would it would improve if there was like a set of hidden achievement cards. Like if I get

I always find I I always feel that way, to be fair. Um any game that Yeah, any game that you I have my own thing, I have a hand of tiles and then I draw a new one. How often do you draw a tile in a game like that and then go, "Yeah, this is the one I'm playing." You kind of have a plan, especially if you're someone who's prone to that. You have a plan. So, yes, I I feel that way. You know, I I think it would benefit from that. My biggest issue with this game though, unfortunately, is a visual clarity of what is on pollinated or not pollinated on the board. Because when you have a a grouping of three or more, you put a single bee in any one of those spaces, that whole area is lit up. And I can't always discern that very quickly or very readily, and I find that visual sort of disconnect very off-putting.

Very off-putting. In fact, to the point that I often, when I play this, find myself thinking, "Man, this would be a neat little app."

I was just going to say, I I doesn't doesn't bother me nearly as much as as you, but I do think this would like on Board Game Arena or an app, this would shine a lot more. And I get that they were trying to make water something different because there's the water sprites, but that does muddy the waters cuz water is the one thing that doesn't need to be pollinated right and have that area. That [clears throat] being said, I found that if I follow steps, it probably that pretty I'm like, "Bee first, other bees, hummingbird, other hummingbirds, then the other three scoring things. Um and also your thing never gets that big. You are maxed at 13 tiles, so it doesn't get out of control because your last few tiles, sometimes you're like, "Ooh, I got four or five people."

Yeah.

And the majorities are a big deal.

Right.

That's two more, but the scores are not going to be particularly wide in this game. Like on your first turn, you're probably getting one. On your second turn, you might get two. And after that, you're getting three or four, maybe, or two, three, four. And you want to make sure you're even with everybody else.

Yeah.

Yeah.

And so any little thing can break it, and that's majorities.

And I do like the the feeling of, you know, trying to accomplish multiple of the goals and the fact that there are different goals in the box, so you can try to with a single tile placement, you know, be like, "Oh, I can do this and this." And hey, look at that, I pollinate this. That's fun. Um the middle of this game is my favorite part because of that sort of thing. Um that middle's also just 10 minutes or so. But overall, I find the game sort of pedestrian, I think is the best way to put it. There's a lot of games out there in which you're doing the lining up things to score points. Um there's a lot of games in which you the if you do more of the same color, you get sort of cascading points, you know, you you the the the next time you do a purple group, then your previous purple group scores.

I I like that all right. But every one part of this, especially right now that there's so many of these kinds of games, the Azuls and the um um the one with the lion face,

Harmonies.

What is it? Harmonies. The Harmonies and the like there's so many of these kinds of games right now that I find this one among them to feel pedestrian, visually muddy, by the numbers, um not no no high highs, like not exciting. I Yeah, I find this to be I think forgettable.

What would you give it?

Five. I mean, it's very Well, that's not you know, a five is like middle of the road, right? I would not be angered by playing this game. That's you got to go below a five for that. But out of five it's not real I'm not sucking any sort of juice from the marrow of this. I'm not getting any real enjoyment, you know? Um it's fine. But I would much rather play any of these other sort of tile laying, cozy-ish, point collecting kind of games that have come out over the last few years.

I'm getting very tired of this genre in general. But this one I liked a lot. Well, a lot. I liked it I liked it. I very much enjoyed it. Uh I'll give it I'm giving it a seven. Yeah. Um I feel that there's a several reasons for that. Yes, there's a lot of these put I love the cascading thing. I don't think I see that as much. Definitely the tile and the patterns, I've seen that. But I like the idea if I put a yellow here, I can get some over here. And the humming birds. And that crisscrosses with those other three.

Yeah.

You can get caught up, but having that majority, you might say, "You know what? I'll give up a couple you know, an extra point here to control this cuz that might get me, too." And it does play differently from two to four because with two, I only need to worry about you. It's probably better at two than four.

I can't keep track of I wouldn't be able to keep track of majorities at four, you know what I mean? It's just that thing of like I'm not I'm not doing this mental load like the mental load's not worth it.

But also the game is so short and it's so cute. I can get a lot of people to play this. I really think this is a a lighter harmony. That's what it feels like in many ways and a lot easier for me to teach. This is a game that I can bring out and play with almost anybody who's playing games first time. They might run into the things you said with that visual stuff. But also, for me it's not a problem cuz I just be like, "Here, you get this, this, and this." I can help them along in that regard.

Right.

So, I enjoy the cuteness of it. I think that cuteness and the speed is going to kind of determine whether you're interested in or not. It is a crowded thing out there. Um I like these designers, Trevor Benjamin, Brett Gilbert, and the things they do.

I like them. Yeah.

Um I think I don't know. I think this one might have some legs. We'll see what happens. But that is Under the Leaves. I'm Tom.

I'm Zee.

We'll see you next time. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games. We do top 10s. We play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved