Hansa Teutonica Review
Transcript
welcome to John gits games today I'm going to talk about Hansa Tonica this is a game of intense player interaction skill upgrading and lots of ways to get victory points first I'll explain how to play the game and then I'll talk a lot about what I think all right so how do we play haunted toona to begin with I'm going to try and do a general overview of the game and try not to go into too many of the specific rules just to give an idea of how it plays so at its core this game is about getting cubes and discs out onto this big board here here and it really all comes down to this player area that you have in front of you there are three important locations here we have the supply up here which are cubes and discs on top of your desk we have the desk that's kind of in the middle it's got a bunch of cubes and discs on it and some uh stats and then down below we have the stock which is going to have cubes and potentially discs down there as well uh so what here what we have here on this desk is the five different stats that the that the game tracks and it does this in a really cool way where it blocks the uh the spots so that you can only see your current level of these five things so we have keys here I have one key value we have privilege I only have white I don't have orange yet because it's covered we have the book skill here it starts at two uh we have the bag skill it starts at three and then we have actions which starts at two so you uh know the power of various things that you can do in the game based off of how many cubes are stuck on your player board so let's jump right into a turn
uh on each person's turn you take well you don't you don't necessarily take two actions in the beginning of the game you take two actions on your turn but as you start bumping some of these cubes off you're going to be able to take three four or even five actions so that's pretty powerful so what are these action choices we have we have the five different options listed at the bottom of our player board and the first one is the simplest that's to do a bag action where we look at our bag we see the uh the value that is the rightmost value that's uncovered it's a three and we take that many cubes or discs from our stock and we bring them up to our supply boom just like that that's one action done and what this does is it allows us to use these cubes and discs we can't in general do anything with them when they're in their stock the second uh action that we can do on our turn is we can take a cuboard disc and place them to any location any empty location on any road on the board on this big big board here so I could take this Cube and put it I don't know here uh there's no restrictions so for instance if there're happen to be a blue on this road as well that's fine um but for this action you have to put it down into an empty spot and you see that every single location on a road has a square and a circle indication so that means you can put a square or a c or um a cube or a disc uh on any of those spots so that is the uh just Place action so that's the second thing uh second type of action we can do the third type of action we can do is displacement this little iconography is a little comp uh confusing so I'm just going to do an example Le this is where
we want to be in a spot that has an opponent's Cube or disc so in this case let's say I'm like ah I I really want to complete this road maybe I already had this piece out here and now I really want to fill this road in so I take a piece from my Supply and I Bonk that disc out but it's not just as easy as that to do that first of all you know blue is now going to need to relocate but in order to do that in order to bump a cube I have to pay a penalty of a cube or disc from my Supply into my stock because it was a cube if it had been a disc then you just you uh increase the penalty by one so when you bump a cube the penalty is one when you bump a disc the penalty is two and so let's say I bump this Cube I already paid that penalty down here and now I get that spot and blue is kind of floating out here blue is not necessarily unhappy now though because first of all uh for every penalty that you pay the opponent gets to take that many cubes or discs from their stock so the below area of their player board and they get to add it to that Cube that or disc that just got bumped and then they get to place it on an empty spot on a road that is adjacent to the road they just got bumped so this road this road or this road so they might go down here and boom they just completed an entire Road themselves by the act of being bumped they they may not be super jazzed about it but they get that bonus and of course if you bump a disc then they get the they move the disc and they pull two out of their stock so discs are uh much better at planting planting and blocking
locations on the board cuz they're expensive to bump so that is the third thing that we can do on our turn uh the fourth thing that we can do on our turn is to do a book action so we look at our book area of the board and we see that the value right now is two uh what this means is we can magically teleport two cubes or discs From Any Road empty road spot to any empty road spot on the board uh so I could just you know take I can take these two and I can put one down here and one over there I could do whatever the heck I want in this case I don't want to do that for uh the case of the fifth action but the the book is just teleportation and as you can see you can get up to five which means you can really just suddenly move cubes all over the place but they have to be on the board already uh so the fifth action that we can take on our turn has to do with completing a road segment so in this case we've completed this road segment here and for an action we pull the cubes off and at this moment a couple things happen uh the first thing that happens is if there was a little bonus disc associated with that road segment see a little arrow was pointing at it then I would get to take that little bonus disc and uh usually kind of put it off to the side in my player area and I'll explain that in a little bit um also I usually draw a new one from the stack and I put it in my hand I don't look at it I just put in my hand to remind myself that I have to put a new one out and then now I have these cubes in my hand so they come back to the stock except one
of them potentially could remain so I pulled them from this spot right here which means I could put one of these cubes from that road either on this city or on that City uh notice that they are square locations so that means only cubes can go there uh as you can see down here some cities have uh circular circular location so only discs could go there and you'll see the colors so we have a white square and a black Square well that has to do with the Privileges look at this the Privileges all the way down here are very hard to get to and I haven't I haven't even explained how to get these yet but I will in just a minute so in this case when I pulled up this road segment I could put this Cube here or here and that's pretty cool uh so let's the third thing that could happen would only happen if we had pulled up a different type of Road segment uh oh first things first though if for instance Let's Pretend blue had already had this uh City occupied when I pulled these cubes up this is where victory points start to come into play Whenever a road is completed whether or not you actually place a cube down or whatnot every person every player who has a control of a city that's adjacent to that road is going to get a victory point for that so in this case blue would get a victory point for me pulling this up even if I don't place a cube down and if I did put a cube down here then any future uh time that this road is completed well then red and blue would both get a victory Point uh so that's one thing to keep in mind uh the last thing that can happen when you pull
up a uh Road segment is there are five special cities on the board we've I'm going to back out right here we've got this city right here with a scroll and a horse guy with a little letter on it that looks suspiciously like the actions we've got this guy over here who's holding a key also suspiciously similar and then we got a guy over here with a bag we got a guy over here with a table and a bunch of privileges on it we got a guy over here who's reading a really big big book so these five locations are the spots where you can start to upgrade your player board uh so if I had pulled the cubes off of this location here since it's adjacent to the city that is associated with the guy who does the actions then as a alternate option instead of placing a cube down into a city I put all of them down into my stock and now I get to upgrade that action so if I did this one right here I would take the leftmost cube from the actions area put it into my Supply and boom I have a third action even on this turn and going forward through the rest of the game so this is how we make our different actions better and if you look down at this board as you get the bag action better I mean if you do it three different times you're going to be doing complete that means you just always take everything that's in your stock and you pull it up here uh so this is really important it makes these individual little actions better by just improving how effective they are and you know privilege it uh unlocks a whole bunch of new spaces on the board you can play I'm going to talk about these
little uh discs real quick uh first of all I would have this one that was in my hand at the end of my turn I would have revealed it and then placed it somewhere else on the board has to be on a road that doesn't have any um any cubes or discs on it already and I probably put it next to a city that I control so that when someone takes that then I'm going to get victory points so there are five different types of bonus chits I'm just going to talk about them real briefly this one you it's a onetime use you get three bonus actions this one just automatically upgrades one of the things on your desk so that's awesome this guy right here lets you build um cities kind of to the side uh or little offices and cities to the side not going to go into the details of that this guy lets you swap positions in cities actually I'm going to explain that real quick uh let's pretend that blue had awesome privilege and we were both in this city here the person who controls a city is the person who has the most cubes and if there's a tie in this case it's the person with the rightmost so this little um chip right here lets you swap two cubes in a city so I could burn that disc to do that and now I control the city so pretty important and all these are onetime uses and then finally this one right here it's just a it's just a dick move tile it just you remove uh three cubes or discs from anywhere on the board back to those player supplies so there's no like displacement they don't get any bonus it just removes them from the board all right so let's let's talk about how we win this game uh well or how the game ends there are three technically uh three different ways that
the game's potentially can end realistically there are two uh the first way the game ends is kind of funky we see the score track this is all like a deep red and then the 20 Mark is black and then the rest of the track is kind of different that's because once any player reaches 20 in-game points so you know when you pull these cubes off and they're next to different cities once any player hits 20 in-game points the game ends immediately and uh so that's one way that the game ends and then there's going to be lots of bonus points uh at the end of the turn at the end of the game the second way the game ends is once all of these bonus discs right here have been used placed on the board and you go to grab a new one it's not there Boom the game's over the Third Way the game ends I have never seen get even close but I put it out here just for uh kicks it's this little complete building track this shows you the number of um of cities that are completely maxed out with cubes if you get to 10 then the game ends I've never seen it get anywhere even close to that even with a five player game so uh all right so the game is over uh how do we get all these big points how do we win this game the first thing is we get two points for every city we control so swapping control is a very big deal but the biggie is uh over here this key area right here we see it starts with a value of one then goes to two two three and four and this is a multiplier for the size of your biggest Network um real quick quickly if I was to just uh let's see put a cube here and put a cube here and put a cube here and let's put
another Cube here uh and so the largest network is the largest number of cities that are connected by one road that have at least one of your uh cubes in it you don't necessarily have to own it and uh you just count the number of offices in that area so offices are cubes or discs so in this case I would say 1 2 3 4 and then you multiply that by your key skill so in this case 1 I would get four points for that if I had unlocked all the way over here then that right there would have been 16 points and a lot you also get an exponential amount of victory points for the number of bonus discs that you've uh taken when you spend them you kind of put them over here meat and potatoes kind of funny and so there are points there too so there are lots of different little ways to get points but really it's all about making points in the middle of the game and then cashing out really big points at the end and making your actions as efficient as possible uh one quick note there's also a red City here and a red City here here you get seven in-game points if you're able to connect them uh with just cities that have your offices in them it happens rarely but it's another way to for the game to suddenly end you know if it ends at 20 points and someone gets seven points that often ends the game all right I'm going to jump over and tell you uh my review of this game I'm going to start this review off by talking about some of the things that I really like about this game shift into a couple neutral potential issues and then go into a couple negatives but uh spoiler alert behind this blandl looking box and Bland looking looking board lies one of my favorite games of all time so now I'm going to explain why I think it's so awesome the first thing
that really stands out about this game to me after playing it this many times is that every turn is so satisfying because every turn is about figuring out where the weakest link on the board is you know there's going to be cubes everywhere they're going to be plugging up all the good stuff but on your turn there's always a little spot that you can jump into to a little a little crevice a little weak spot on the board that no one else has maybe looked at or maybe they've overlooked it and haven't really taken into account how good that might be at this exact moment to jump into and those moments finding those little spots is just really really great and uh I love all of those moments and uh that's one of the main reasons why I love every single turn for this game mechanically uh I think that the displacement mechanism is the first standout really interesting thing that creates everything else that's awesome about this game because it incentivizes people to get in other people's way which turns this into a Cutthroat Cube pushing game where you're just constantly aggravating the person to your left aggravating the person to your right the person across the table from you just totally hoses you over it's just one of those really really intense um lots and lots of player interaction games even though it might not look like it it on first glance and the reason for that um the incentivization of displacement is that you actually get to be more efficient by
getting in other people's way if I was to put a cube over here now in order for blue to get his action they're going to have to displace Me by sacrificing one of their cubes which makes them a little less efficient and I get to pull a cube from my stock out onto the board which makes me more turn efficient or action efficient because I don't have to pull that from here to here for an action and then from here out here for an action it just all kind of happens magically because my blue opponent decided it was in his best interest to get rid of me so that they could take the spot uh the discs are also really interesting in that they double that penalty so it costs two to displace a disc and they other person gets a bonus of two uh and so sometimes you might want to put a disc down here to block someone but that might almost over penalize the blue player and they might say well you know what I'm just going to take these disc these cubes and I'm going to go somewhere else and I'm going to do something with them because now paying two and giving you two is a little too much sometimes it isn't too much and you can really make out with knowing when to drop these into people's way to really uh to really squeeze a lot of turn efficiency and groans out of that player which is really really great the next thing I want to talk about is the player uh board that we have have here this kind of Zone we have in front of us and how interesting all these things all work together uh first of all the fact that we have this Supply up here and the stock down here and the way they interact for getting stuff going getting
stuff out on the board is just really really satisfying for me you know you have to spend actions to get the cubes and discs out of here up here so that you can use them it's all about balancing you know what you can do on this turn what you can do on multiple other turns sometimes you'll have a big setup turn where you might just bag twice you know pull you know six cubes out you know three time two or you know if you start upgrading your bag you can pull even more out to just set up for a big turn later which happens early in the game but if you've upgraded the bag a lot well you know you can pull seven or all of them out and that really makes you turn efficient in that aspect so upgrading these different uh tracks on your player board is also just really really fascinating and deciding you know when I pull these cubes off the board in one of these spots do I want to like let's say for instance I had this uh and I was already at the three action spot do I want to pull these off and pull this off right here which is going to give me another three but gets me close to getting to four actions or instead do I want to just leave this Cube behind here so that every time any other player in the future goes here to get more actions I get a victory Point you're constantly thinking about essentially shortterm versus long-term you know when do I want to cash out victory points from people people versus needing to actually get my own little engine going which I think is really fascinating it's also very interesting the way you can actually start to really dry up on cubes and discs in the mid game if you are not making sure you're at least unlocking
some stuff because you just you start to lose the cubes because they get locked out on the board in the different cities and you could get to the point where you desperately need to unlock cubes and discs from these different spots on the board from your player board because it puts them into your system so that you can use them which is a very interesting kind of side uh mechanic that I didn't notice for the first several games I played but I think that's um that's really really interesting uh I also love this book mechanic it's completely themeless I'll get to that later but being able to teleport your cubes from one location to another part of the board lets you uh well first of all you know if you get displaced from a spot you know blue bumps me off and I get this bonus I can put these cubes here and on my next turn for one action I can take these and put them elsewhere I could put one over here one over there to block two different people or I could take these plus another one somewhere else and fill up an entire Road of three as long as you know I had gotten that many Book locations and most of the road locations on the board are just three long it's really great because this game is completely open knowledge you know what everyone has they know what you have and so you're trying to sneak around and get things done and having the book action allows you to you know spend a turn where you might just kind of punk down some cubes and some spots to try and just kind of get in people's way and on a following turn spend an
action to pull all of them into one big Master stroke move and you place them down here and you pull them up to put an office in the Central City and you know you're going to get a lot more points for that kind of stuff so it's really interesting being able to try and obscure what you want to do by putting cubes in other places getting in other people's way in the process like I talked about earlier and then being able to do your big turn by just kind of teleporting your uh your cubes around so you're blocking people and people are blocking you but going back to the first thing I said using those teleports you can jump at the weakest link that happens to have opened up on your turn really really interesting the last thing I want to mention as far as things I really love about this game is that it seems like all the victory paths are relatively balanced and it seems like the um the upgrade paths are also relatively balanced you know at first glance it seems like oh you have to get more actions that's obviously the best action the best thing out here but that's not necessarily true you know being able to pull more cubes out of the stock and put them in the supply means you have to do it less often which is going to effectively generate you more turns more actions as the game goes on because you have to spend less actions doing the bag so people might be clogging up the actions and you might go over here to get some Bag scale there's um there are other ways that these things all seem to kind of balance out and you know I've played this game 21 times and it really seems like they are all relatively viable I mean the key thing doesn't give you any in-game uh engine building but if you jump on the key early in the game when no one is
thinking about endgame points you could get it relatively easily there's not going to be much competition but late game this is just constantly just it usually has like at least three player different player colors in here and it's just constantly locked down because people desperately want to double their points by just doing being able to pull that off once well if you do that early in the game then you're just sitting pretty cuz you did that when it was easy so that's that's again could have been a weakest link in the early game so really really interesting the way all that works out uh so now I'm going to shift over to a couple kind of neutral points that are potential issues but they're not they're not terribly bad uh the first thing goes along with the balance I was just saying the only caveat to that is every player really needs to get this third action and they need to get it as soon as possible uh it is you just cannot win the game with two actions I've seen someone try it a couple times it just doesn't work you can easily win the game with three actions you don't need to get to five actions in fact I've many times seen a three- action person beat a five action person but getting to this third action being able to pull this off the first time is really really crucial and that's a little less interesting than I'd like I I almost wish the game just started at 3 actions and just went from there because that's viable and gave people other options but but it doesn't and so what that means is that kind of leads into the second kind of neutral potential issue I have about this game and that is that the first turn feels very scripted almost every time I play is that the first player
will put their two cubes down let me get rid of these over here they'll put two cubes down on the action track because the action track really is very important the second player will put down one Cube here and then probably put the other Cube either on the track that has the remove three because I didn't mention before but this is always one of the starting three bonus chits on the board or they would put it over here on the bag so that's a slight differentiation and then the third player will always kind of like take the other two spots I mean always is a bit of an overstatement but this is pretty much the way the first turn always goes and the second turn the blue player will almost always displace the green who will then go to the Keys and then the blue player will pull this up to get that action and then the second player will Rush In And there the first two to three turns are very syy every single game I play but once you get to like the fourth turn it really branches out and it's just awesome so that's not a terribly big deal but it's definitely a thing the next thing that I'd like to mention I didn't actually specifically talk about this when I did the rules is that there are two different boards for this game there's this board here which is for two to three players and and then there's also this board over here on the back side which is for four to five players and they are different in a couple key ways if you've been noticing on the other side there's only one road that led up to the action spot and we see here that in the four to five player game there are two roads that come up to it there's also two roads that go up to
the privilege um uh City unlike the other side and there just more connections to be had on this board uh but those are the two main differences so when you do the scripted first turn for this side then one person usually goes here and then one person splits up between the both roads and then the third person goes here and then the fourth person usually jumps on wherever the uh minus the remove three tile is so that's kind of how the scripting works over here which is a little annoying but it's um I really like that they have two different boards for how the game plays because this game is all about being tight and being on top of each other what that means is that the four player game is a bit lacking uh this game is best with three and five uh I'm not saying four player is bad this is not a negative aspect of this game this is the the neutral zone just with four players you play on this map and you're you're not in each other's way as much and this game is all about getting in each other's way so it's a little bit of a bummer when I play for I usually try and push for three players or push for five players because that's when it's really really uh nitty-gritty just kind of punching each other in the face with these cubes five five player can get a little long but I still I still love five player with this game The Last kind of neutral thing is it's it's kind of annoying I mentioned that you get exponential points for these chits and the only place you can find that is on the rule book right here kind of on the side on page 20 so I really wish they just printed that on the board they have this huge board they could have easily
put a little rubric this whole track here for ending the game is pretty much pointless in my opinion so that's a little Annoying anyway now I'm going to shift into the negatives that I have for this game and the most prevalent negative for this game is that the two-player game is terrible uh it's got some extra pieces and like a pawn and some guard tokens it's totally slapped on it's totally bad just I I've heard uh rumors that the uh expansion that's going to be forthcoming might fix that I haven't heard the details just two-player is terrible do not buy this game if you want to play it two player three is just amazing five is amazing four is decent don't go with two uh also this is the first edition of the game there have been a couple editions but this rule book is terrible it was probably 8 n 10ish games in by the time I could say that I was 100% playing this game right I was playing many things wrong because the the translation was just horrible I think hopefully they fix that in the future but there's lots of nitty-gritty little details and it it just takes many games before you can pretty much say yes I'm doing this correctly and about a year in I found I'd been doing something wrong for an entire year of playing this game so that was a bit of a bummer and the final thing that's probably really really obvious that's a negative for this game is that it looks boring it looks this theme of like 1400 Germanic Traders setting up offices in different cities is just terrible it I put this up on the table and people run away screaming
because they think it's going to be the just the the driest g game they've ever played when it isn't it's a battle it's slugging each other in the face it's intense it's interactive and and it just does not sell itself that way it should be in space It should be I don't know magicians because you have teleporting like the theme doesn't make any sense why are you able to read a book and then move cubes from over here to over here the theme is just so bad and so anti to all the mechanics I really think if they' packaged this up with a different theme it could have sold even more so that's a bit of a bummer anyway I I'm kind of scrambling to find negatives for this game it is astonishing it's a gem one of my favorite Euro games one of my favorite games period I will play it any day of the week any day of the month I love this game to pieces and uh I hope you've enjoyed my review uh if you have any questions or comments let me know and I'll see you guys next time