Merchants and Marauders Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the ballgames 4k youtube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings generally like to talk a load of bollocks about a total top game in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a part of thing game that was released in 2010 we're going to be talking about merchants and marauders and this is a game where you'll be sailing around the caribbean trying to do a bit of pickup and deliver and maybe beat up a few merchants become a pirate and be the first player to reach 10 glory points that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules i'm telling you what we do like we don't like then we'll come back we'll tell you whether or not merchants and marauders is still worth your time and bother today and in the future so remember if you know it and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you after this
board games 4k so merchants and marauders how did you play this game so merchants marauders is basically a sort of pirate themed game where you'll be going around the caribbean trying to amass 10 victory points to win the game right at the beginning of the game each player is going to randomly select a captain and you're going to have a certain amount of attributes that will affect things that you do throughout the rest of the game right you're also going to select one of two ships you're either going gonna have a sloop which is a more agile extra ship on the water or you're gonna select a flute which is gonna allow you to carry more cargo but you ain't gonna be able to move as quickly in the water right so do you look at your player board and you will place your little cubes corresponding to the attributes of your ship you place your captain in the relevant spot everyone's going to get 10 gold you're going to shuffle the event cards the rumor cards and the mission cards you're going to place the merchant tokens on the sea spaces apart from the caribbean see you're going to shuffle up these ship modification tokens you are going to shuffle up demand tokens you're going to draw two mission cards and place them in the spots where the mission card tells you to do it and then you're going to randomly determine the first player and off you go so first thing you're going to do not in the first round but in every subsequent round you are going to draw an event card and do what it says on the event card okay so the next phase in the game is you're going to take player actions there's three different actions that you can take in this game you've got the move action you've got the scout action and then you've got the port action right on your turn you're going to get to perform three actions if you take the
move action basically one of your actions is going to be able to move to an adjacent space you're going to be able to move into a port and you're going to be able to move out of a port so if you want to take the scouting action what you're going to do you're going to announce which type of player you're going to scout for you can scout for player captains which is another player you can scout for non-player captains which is the navy and pirates and that sort of stuff and then you can scout for a merchant which refers to the merchant tuckers what you're going to do you're going to do what's called a skill check and this is the sort of meat and potatoes of this game we're going to do you're going to look at your scouting score on your captain and you're going to roll that many dice and you're gonna be looking for successes so you're gonna roll six sided dice and on the dice you got numbers one to four and then you've got five and six which are represented by skull and crossbones and these are successes and you'll look for successes if you're successful then you successfully scout that type of player and then something will happen so if you scouted for a player character or a the navy or a pirate then you will have a battle but if you scatter for a merchant you'll be able to raid the merchant right what you do you flip over the merchant token and it will reveal a flag of a country and you've got two options here you can either choose to raid the country that's on the merchant token or you can raid the country flag that is on the port of the region that you're in so when you write a merchant what you do you draw free cargo cards you'll make a seamanship skill check and you'll take the number of successes and this will allow you to modify the
cards that you've just drawn so you can use one of the successes to draw an additional card you can use a success to discard a card or you can use a success to exchange a card what you'll be doing you'll be looking at the number of escape icons and if it's equal or more than your maneuverability then the merchant escapes and you also look at the number of hit icons and you will deduct those hits from the location on your player board that the card says and if your hole's destroyed then your ship sinks and your captain dies you'll have to start all over again but if the merchant didn't escape and you survived then you'll be able to loot that merchant token so you'll get the amount gold which is equal to the plunder value we add up all the numbers on the bottom of cards and that's how much gold you get you better keep any of the cargo cards but you can't have any more than your cargo value and if you plan a merchant and you've got more than 12 gold you'll get a glory points that's super duper in it no i mean after you raid a merchant or you do over the navy then you'll get a bounty on your head because people don't like scallywags do they you know what i mean if you done over so dutch navy ship you'll take a bounty token you'll stick it on your board and that means you cannot go into a dutch port and you're now classed as a filthy stinking pirate so the third action you can do is the port action and this is a little bit drawn out well it's a lot drawn out actually this consists of seven different things you can do you have to start with the cell goods action so you're going to do that first and then you can do every other action once per turn you can't do the same action twice right so to sell goods action is quite simple what you do you
select a certain amount of goods from your cargo cards and you will sell them to the port in question and you'll get three gold for each cargo right but if the cargo you want to sell is in demand denoted by the in-demand token funny old thing then you'll get six gold for that and if you can flog three or more in demand goods then you'll get a glory point and you'll be able to draw glory card and glory cards give you a sort of like a leg up you can never have any more than a certain number of glory cards so if you get more than four glory cards you're gonna have to get rid of some basically you can play these at certain times of the game and they do change the game so you might have the glory card that says fog you can play this card when a battle is about to begin and you may select any combat action the first round of combat long guns cannot be used against you right you might have the ship surgeon which is a specialist which is a bloke or a blocket that you can hire which says sebastian lecroque an accomplished surgeon is willing to join your crew play this card during a port action in curacao and it says here that succeed a leadership role will pay two goal fails and keep this car face up and he gives you a nice little benefit right all you might have to say a master specialist francois de la charete an experienced sailor master is willing to join your crew played his car during a port action in petit gov in petite gowan or whatever it says succeed a leadership role or play two golden fouls and keep this card face up and this this bloke allows you to reroll any number of your dice in a seamanship role so these are really tasty powerful cards that will help you beat up other people so next thing you could do
is you could buy goods right so you'll draw six cargo cards and you'll be able to buy each piece of cargo for free gold right you can't buy an into my goods if you draw any of them you have to ditch them and draw redraw the cards right and then you'll basically put them in your hold right so next action you could do in the port is you can visit the shipyard you can go there and you can buy and sell a ship so you'll look at the price of the ship and you'll pay the gold and you'll swap out your ship you can flog your existing ship for basically peanuts at the end of the day but for every ship modification you got you're gonna get a discount right so you can buy special weapons you'll pay the money you get yourself a special weapon these are sort of like knuckle dusters for your ship if you want to give somebody else a good old slap you know what i mean so you can repair your ship per bit money and you repair ship that's it or you can buy a ship modification to pay money and you'll take the ship modification token that is revealed when you enter a port and you'll place it on your player board and this will give you maybe like plus one crew or give you a bonus to maneuverability no matter what it is it's pretty tasty and you really do need to sort of think about getting these pretty quick you know i mean you could do the recruit action at port you'll pay two gold and you'll be able to fill up your crew to its initial value you'll also be able to acquire a room and you'll be able to pay two gold and you'll be able to pick up one of these rumor cards and this is sort of like a sort of semi-mission in a sense and you'll be required to do a certain skill check to see if the rumor is true and if it turns out to be true you'll get a specific benefit so some of the rumor cards that are in the game go like this you
might get the white lady rumor card it says years ago a magnificent frigate the white lady disappeared it's rumored to be located on a reef near bridgetown right so you go to bridgetown you'll do a scouting skill check and if you're successful then you find a frigate and you'll be able to claim the frigate you'll be able to get a frigate for free which is bloody superb in it you know what i mean fantastic it's just a ship floating in the water and you can pick it up and take it home here lovely you might have the marriage rumor and it says here abigail rose williams daughter of the governor of nassau is getting married you'll go to nassau you'll do a leadership action you'll see if it's true prior to selling goods in the sale and if successful this round nassau will pay you two extra gold for all your type of goods except for wood for some bizarre reason maybe abigail rose williams is a bit of a wood phobe so these rumors are sort of hit and miss if you pick up a decent rumor then it's going to help you along your way in this game so next thing tell me if this is a dragon a little bit because in the actual game it's even worse than this right but the next thing you can do is you can claim a mission you'll go into a space where there's a mission card you can attempt to claim a mission do what it says on the card and if you're successful you'll take the mission you can only have wrapped up one mission right so if you pick another one you've got a dump one and then this will give you something to do so it might here to say go down to havana and pick up some top good take it over to john's right and if you complete the mission you get a bonus and then another mission will appear once somebody takes a mission right so it's very simple it appears in lots of games and you should know what it is if you don't you fix right so the final action that you could do in a port aside from
get a really bad headache is you can stash goals you can stash as much gold as you like in your little tiny treasure chest the little cute treasure chest that this game gives you that always falls apart you don't want it to at the end of the game for every 10 gold you've got in your treasure chest you're going to get a glory point and this is sort of a secret thing at the end of the game sort of farmers in carcass zone right at the end of the game you're going to reveal where you go you're going to count up for every 10 gold you've got you're going to get a glory point so you have to be mindful about thinking about what other players have got in their treasure chest so as everyone's taking all their actions you'll go into the next round you'll draw an event card you do what it says some of the event cards go like this you might have the event card that says war and it says if there's no active war you take a bounty token from each nation randomly draw two and place them on the wall space and this means france or like the netherlands or england are at war together and that means that if you are one of those nationalities you can't go into the port of the opposing nationality because obviously you're at loggerheads and you just want to kill each other so one of the other things we've got to talk about is combat in this game it's a bit of a protracted affair so uh yeah let's let's uh let's try and not wind ourselves out and then butt the wall yeah so what you do when you enter into combat maybe you're on the same space as a pirate or partly navy moves into your space a naval battle will occur and the first thing you're going to do is we're in the first round you're good you've got to choose the shoot declaration right in subsequent rounds you can choose the board declaration or you can choose the flee declaration right so we do you do a semen ship check and the player that wins the seamanship
check with the most successes will get to enact their chosen declaration so in the case of the shoot declaration you'll be able to claim one hit per success that you did if you choose the ball action naval combat will end and then you'll move to the crew combat where it's a bit more hand to hand and with the free action if your opponent made no successes then you get to escape the battle and flee and basically run away from the battle with your tail between your legs because you're a bit of a cowardly cowardly custard type person yeah so for each hit you'll roll a die and then you'll look at the symbols on the die and then you'll move the location on your ship down that number of hits if your hole's destroyed your ship sinks and then you have to draw a new captain and start again if it's a cargo and obviously you can't carry as much stuff if it's a mast then your maneuverability is affected if it's your cannons you're not going to be able to do as many hits in subsequent rounds and if it's a crew then that's going to stuff you up for crew combat so if you do a successful board action you'll do crew combat each captain rolls a leadership check and each success inflicts damage on the enemy's crew if you lose all your crew you lose your battle your captain dies and you're stuffed right you can also use special weapons in combat you've got the grape shot you've got the chain shot and you've got the grappling hooks and this is basically just a mechanism so that you can choose where your hits go instead of the person that's receiving hits so if you get destroyed the game's not over you can come back into the game but basically you lose everything but you stash gold so my advice to you as in life is don't get killed so
basically i've had enough with the rules explanation it's starting to do made in i could go on and on and on but i'm not going to but you're going to keep doing this you're going to keep sailing along seven seas pretending to be johnny depp buy it's not as much cocaine as possible and yeah the person who gets to 10 glory points first will be the winner of merchants and marauders so what do we like about merchants and marauders so the first thing that we really like about merchants from world is is obviously the theme right i mean this comes across in space i mean we haven't played every single pirate game obviously i mean we've heard too many bones it's pretty decent one but as far as the games that we played this the theme comes through the best we do think that jamaica is rivals this for implementation of theme but this one takes that feel of the golden age of piracy and it comes through really really well you've got the characters of your captains you've got the characters of your ships they're sort of like secondary characters aren't they and you've got the different special abilities of each of the ports that is attached to a different nationality so the the fact that it's sort of i wouldn't say accurately mimics the scramble for resources in the caribbean back way back when but the traditional movie type representation of pirates comes through really well in this game so second thing that we really like about this game is that going to port there's a massive amount of things you can do when you can go to port it's basically a sort of a hub where you can do
anything that you want it's where you're going to get your ship upgrades is where you're going to be buying and selling goods and the fact that there's seven different options here each with their own special ability that sort of adds to the law of going to different ports we really really like that in this game so the next thing that we really like about merchants of world is there's no real set path to victory we've said this before and we're going to start again but we don't like the term sandbox game because obviously every single game has got its limitations based on the the physical aspects of the game right this game is in the same sort of vein as xy legends of a drift system you're just sort of plugged out into the middle of the sea or space with zara and you just left your own devices the game presents you with all these different options you can get a port or wherever you want to go with the missions with the rumors you're left to navigate your way through this sea of options did you see what i did there so the final thing that we like about merchants and marauders is that the stash mechanism adds a little bit of mystery to the proceedings you don't know well maybe you do because maybe you've got your eye on everyone what everyone's been doing but you don't really know how much stuff your opponents have got stashed in their wonky little treasure chest it might be the case that you think well i've won because i've got 40 gold that's gonna give me four glory points when you reveal all your gold it turns out that your mate has got 50 gold any picture to the post so like we said in the rules overview this reminds us a little bit of farmer mechanism in carcassonne where you're not quite sure as to whether
you've done enough to win the game at the end and that is absolutely fantastic so what don't we like about merchants and marauders so the first thing and the elephant in the room with this one is the amount of bloody down time that this game forces you to experience it's that bloody poor action i know we're hypocrites we did say that we like the fact that the poor action gives you this wealth of opportunities and a wealth of possibilities but the way that is executed in this game is just mind-numbingly boring i mean in order to get to a point you're gonna have to move there right and that might be one of your actions and then by the time your action comes around again you've waited maybe 10 minutes maybe everyone else that's playing it has done a port action and you're just sitting there doing absolutely bugger all i know i've heard people say other players can start their turn when you are doing your port action but we tried that and it turns out whenever we tried that everyone else is doing a bleeding pull action you know what i mean it's like somebody lights a piece of touch paper and the game just goes up in smoke so the next thing that we don't like about merchants the marauders is that the combat in this game it's absolutely bloody brutal right basically what it comes down to is whether or not your roles are luckier than the next person and if you are unlucky if you're unlucky enough to get that success or get that skill check then
you're going to lose absolutely everything and the player who done you over is going to nick all your stuff and then they're going to be stronger for the next time and you're going to come back into the game with just the captain and all the bare bones stuff with a crap ship and they're going to be riding around on their white little unicorn with nuclear weapons and you ain't going to be able to touch them so that is a major problem is that combat is so wildly unbalanced in this one so the next thing that we don't like about merchants marauders is it seems to us that being a pirate is just not worth the you're going to be more at risk of being attacked because you're gonna get gold for doing over somebody with a bounty on a red and the fact that you become more of a target for other players and also the navy means that the risk of permadeath is all the more apparent and that goes back to the previous point is if you do die in this game you are done for there's no way back you can't win so being a pirate is far too risky and i i just wouldn't recommend it in some senses i just don't see why it's in there and for a game that is meant to be about a golden age of piracy subconsciously tries to move you away from being a pirate what's the point of being a pirate game so the final thing and i promise you this is the final thing we don't like about merchants and marauders is that a thing that happens in this game that can destroy the whole thing and this is something that we call port hopping it's the fact that you got three actions
right and you can use those three actions to move from port to port so you can move out the port you can move to the next space and you can move into the port and if you're in a port you can't get attached there's nothing that anyone can do you can just spend the whole game going from port to port to port if you want and you ain't gonna get touched by you the pirates if you're a part you're gonna get touched by the navy and also if you're apart you're gonna get touched by the other players he's just gonna be going to a port picking up goods hopping over to the next pool selling the goods and if the in-demand tokens are in your favor you're gonna get so much money so much glory and you're never gonna see an ounce of combat and that's good if you know that combat is risky right and i know that combat's risky but paul hopping is essentially boring and it's just basically renders the game down to the lowest common denominator which is basically just to pick up and deliver affair so to summarise is merchants and marauders still worth your time on bother 10 years after it was first released in 2010 so we're going to say maybe maybe not in fact i can't answer that question it all depends on what you expect from this sort of ameritrash type of game it's a highly highly thematic adventure on the high seas that suffers from an insane amount of imbalance too much downtime and it's far too random for our liking it's too long again
to have all these different problems rise to the surface but if you can dedicate a rainy afternoon and not really care too much about what happens just put your boat on the water sail around a bit see what happens take a few risks don't worry if you get murdered a few times then this game can be quite an enjoyable affair and one side of my brain is telling me that i want to play this again and again and again but the other side of my brain is telling me that this is a slog it's unfair and it's just a pain in the ass to play so i don't know which side of my brain is going to win this battle but we're going to give merchants and brothers three out of five it's going to stay in our collection because it is quite unique there's not really anything like it with this type of theme so there you go that's merchants marauders remember if you are newer then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below we'll see you next tuesday you