Skip to main content
Loading video...

Solo Thoughts | Call of Kilforth (and comparing it to Gloom of Kilforth)

Transcript 30:26

hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I want to discuss call of kill forth and I previously made a video about Gloom of kill forth uh and here's what I've done so far Okay so um I received my Kickstarter copy a few weeks ago uh played a couple games of this uh and I had uh some doubts about the new mechanics so I went back and uh tabled Gloom of Kil for the original in the trilogy because I wanted to uh compare it a bit more and you know just kind of refresh my memory on how the original plays before I played this further okay uh so uh I made a video there where I describe G of kill for I still love Gloom of kilforth by the way and I played it for the first time couple years ago that hasn't changed uh and if you want a bit of a breakdown of that game a bit more feel free to watch that video uh so now that I played that a few times now I went ahead and put this on the table again and played a couple more games okay and uh now I want to uh discuss the pros and cons of this versus uh GL Gloom of kilforth and uh how it Compares in C how it Compares in certain areas all right uh so I want to first start uh by mentioning the new mechanics okay so there's a new couple new mechanics here so uh there's going to be

uh a ship mechanic that encompasses a couple of things so you're going to get a new uh card that you start a game with uh and it's going to be called the gallion card okay uh so this card gives you a couple more actions so you can bail it to gain a new sorry to gain a a move action point okay so this effectively gives you an extra move action every turn and that drastically changes the pace of the game all right uh that's something that you don't really have access to at the beginning with the original more simpler Gloom of kill forth okay uh so that's uh so that's one of the aspects of the ship mechanic but you can also use it to sync ships that are distributed around the map randomly at the beginning of the game okay uh so now much like in Gloom of kilforth the structure of the game is the same you generate a map uh and you have about 25 days to level up your one hero character that you control uh in order to uh beat the ancient at the end so the Knight deck act as your timer and you have to move around the map and uh you need to level up sufficiently and you have to complete your Saga chapters to defeat the Ancient uh so that that um uh that Foundation from the original still there so on top of that you have the ship mechanics now you also have the uh resource uh the resources which is

new all right so uh these resources are going to be distributed so there's six of each uh so there's fish metal Stone and wood all right four types of resources and they each each our each map area will have a one resource token uh of its corresponding type added at the beginning of the game so the forest areas will all get one um and they will all get one uh a wood token all the ocean areas will get a fish token the plains areas will get stone and the mountain will get uh the Mountain Area will get the iron or metal okay so uh now what do these tokens do uh you can spend an action to collect them uh and the wood token lets you remove obstacles the fish lets you heal one uh health health Point uh the stones let you gain one gold uh and this lets you uh load your Shipe with cannons to make it more powerful or you can also uh you can also use it to add uh one um extra die to your fight okay uh so uh so that's what the resources do and there's many cards that reference them and reward them okay uh so it's not the only way you know you don't only access them by picking them up from the map all right uh and they are also

intrinsically tied to the ancient all right the new ancients when they uh when they um uh when they're specific specific type of U territory uh gets uh turned to Gloom they they'll also take the uh they'll also um you know manipulate the resources all right uh depending on the type of location that's removed all right so they'll mess with the resources in the map okay um uh there's uh so yeah there's the resources and the shipes like I said at the beginning they're going to be distributed around the map and uh you'll also have um rewards when you sync them right so you can use your gallion you can Veil your gallion to sync a ship that has equal or less power than your gallion all right and there's ways of increasing your gall's power that your gallon starts with two power and there's ways of increasing it so that you can get the ship rewards okay and also the ancient will um you do have you you have an extra incentive of um syncing ships because the engine will be more powerful at the end of the game if you don't sync ships of a certain faction the ships that are randomly distributed around the map um come in four factions okay uh another new mechanic also is the faction aspect you flip this faction token all right at the

beginning of the game and you start with uh the SE dos or the blue Dres all right um so SE dos blue Dres and that's going to influence the outcome of certain events certain night cards um and so on so there's definitely a lot of more layers here compared to the original Gloom of kilforth right on top of that there's also certain territories that you have to pay attention to for example if you move your character card here you get an extra action point when you move in it so you have to pay extra close attention when you move around the map uh here for example enemies have an extra health uh here when you move into this territory you lose an action point okay so it's uh it's um labeled there so uh there's a lot more layers that you have to pay attention to another new interesting mechanic is the the outposts all right so uh when you level up your class okay uh you're going to have uh at level one you have the option of taking uh a a card that lets you build an outpost uh and you have to uh you have to collect certain types of resources so let me show you here so uh you so that's if there's an alternative level one card that you can pick if you decide not to pick that one right uh so you can pick that one or you can pick this one for the first level of your character so when you pick this card uh you then have to make sure that you collect those resources and it will

let you build this Outpost all right and you can uh establish that outpost on one of the territories and and it'll let you do Market actions in that territory and also you're going to be able to uh you're going to be able to um uh Veil The Outpost and all outposts depending on your class they'll have a different abilities so for the Wizards Tower uh for my character which by the way um I had to flip my character because of the ancient uh the ancient battle it it tells you to basically get rid of your uh class card uh at the beginning of the battle but uh I got this um class right Arcane for magic user that was my molk magic user okay uh so um I went ahead and picked this okay uh and you can Veil it and you can add a success to a test in the same territory or in any adjacent location uh so there's an interesting layer there where if you decide to go this route uh it does take work orhe it's a lot of actions that you're going to invest in Gathering the resources uh and then putting that uh Outpost somewhere okay on uh the map all right uh but if done right uh it can it can pay off right it can pay um uh dividends but um that will your mileage will vary all right uh and in some cases like with this um this uh

ancient that I decided to face for this game all right uh the uh point point of dread uh if you read their um if you read their ability it says that you have to uh sacrifice your uh class card which I just show you there I just flipped it basically uh and you have to sacrifice one metal and if you can't uh then uh if you can't then you you're eliminated from the game all right um and you also have to pay attention to other ancients because you might be requ required to build an outpost right if you can't build an if you don't build an outpost before you face the ancient uh you're going to be required to lose all right so uh do if you do decide to get this game and face ancients you have to pay extra close attention to the ancient ability at the beginning of the game all right because uh it will influence uh the the route that you take all right uh also the factions of the ships so for example this guy uh he uh he gains uh one extra Health uh for each Sea Dog ship and these are the sea doogs right so if you don't for any sea doog sh ship that you don't sync he's going to gain an extra Health at the end all right so as you can see there's a lot of extra things that you have to pay attention to uh in this all right now are they worthwhile okay so that's the question all of these new

things uh are they worthwhile versus just the more uh streamline experience of Gloom of kill forth uh and my answer is that uh I do I do think that uh they are but it depends all right so uh if you want a bit more of extra a bit of extra metin and just at the cost of a slight amount of extra visual clutter and rules uh this does really shake up the formula of Gloom of K kill forth really well all right it really it really offers a distinct experience um is it is it better I would not say necessarily that it's better but it is different and I do I do like the pirate theme and I will I will say this the the um Mar marine and pirate theme does shine through here okay uh between the flavor text the choice of cards the type of loot that you're going to acquire the races that you were Prov provided the classes okay uh the quests uh the the Allies that you gain the shine the the the theme Here does shine through I'll say that all right uh and once you do get comfortable if you're already very comfortable with this system and you rarely have to reference rules uh this is just a a nice breath of fresh air uh however the reason why I originally went back and

played uh Gloom of uh kill for before um you know putting this back on the table is because my initial Impressions were not that great and that's because I had a two-year Gap since I came back to this system all right and you know a couple years ago I played this extensively I played this like I think six to eight times the original Gloom of kill forth right so I thought I had a pretty good idea and refreshing myself on the rules was not very fun to be honest but even after reading the rule book uh you know I'm making a little chit um my initial Impressions were not that great because gosh there's just so much going on with there's so many things that you have to pay attention to and it almost I might as well just had just had been a a new player to the system because it had been so long since I played uh Gloom of Kil forth that this was a bit overwhelming the first game that I played I did not play with the extra mechanics the ships the resources I skipped I skipped that okay um I just kept the game simple just to kind of refresh myself I did have a nice time however uh you can't you really can't do that here maybe for like one game just to familiarize yourself but uh beyond that you're really missing out on a lot of the interactions here there's many quests uh and loot uh titles spells allies um you know rewards there's a lot of things that reference uh resources ship tokens your gallion ship the

there's affects that on on Veil or ontap your gallion or interact with your gallion so if you decide not to include those resour those extra mechanics okay uh that you're going to find uh you're going to find at the end of the uh rule book here okay so the new mechanics it's all just couple Pages which I appreciate all right uh you know if you want to add the new extra mechanics just you just have to read two pages in the rule book that's it okay so at least that's not that bad all right uh but so you're going to have to uh read only those two pages and integrate that but uh for a new player that could be a lot all right and U I almost feel like a new player coming back to this system because you have to pay attention you know when you do your turnto turn uh decisions all right you're going to have to factor in uh the ships so your gallion when to use your gallion ability um the resources and the EXT you know the ancient abilities and also the extra uh you know when you when you look at the maps right so in the original the only thing that you have to pay attention to was there's certain um uh territory cards that are uh linked okay so I can move from here to here as if they were adjacent basically all right uh so when you lay out the map that's the only thing you have to pay extra attention to but here now you have to pay you have to pay really close attention because you might have a you know you're laying out your plan of how you're going to move around the map and then uh you know uh there's

a certain spot where you'll lose or gain an action when you move so you have to pay extra citation and that can be a lot for a new player all right um and I had a bit of a poor experience on my second game of this all right so I play that first game with the simple rules great I go to play my second game I add all the resources on the ships and I I I was just a bit overwhelmed and the ship mechanics were not super clear initially all right um I was having a hard time uh understanding the the the uh the action economy and whether it's even worthwhile spending actions to sync ships but um you know that was due to my uh you know rustiness with the system okay so I I am glad that I went back and play Gloom of kilforth okay first because once I played that a couple of times and then came back to this uh I I thoroughly enjoyed this a whole lot more okay uh so I I'll say that um I I really uh appreciated how the uh the gallion re really changes the the you know the the fact that it gives you that extra movement point at the beginning is really powerful okay um now I'll say this the pacing of the game does change significantly because of that uh a lot of the times in the original Gloom of kill forth uh you know it it came down to the wire to the Last Action you

really don't have a lot of time to mess around exploring because you know the days you know the the ninth deck is is going to run out okay and you're going to uh you're going to be pressed to uh you know complete all all of your goals before you face the engent but because of that extra gallion ability uh I do feel a bit more free to explore and um in all of my games I didn't really go past 15 or 16 days before facing the ancient and you know there's 25 cars in the night deck okay well I I think up to 20 I think I think the the longest I went was was 20 uh and I even saw a play through by mid mid on the table where he completed the game on on 11 days all right when I saw that for the first time I was like no wait he play something wrong uh like U that sounds insane to me like when I when I saw that he finished he game and beat the engine within 11 days I thought that that could not be like how can you beat the engine in 11 days and it's all because of this folks the the gallion just that extra movement point just it just drastically changes the action economy here another interesting thing is that gold F felt a lot more plentiful um I reached I had a lot I had amounts of gold that I would never have in the original Gloom of kilforth because gold is just so tight when you play without variance right like I said in the original review I don't I don't play with a variance right

I just play with the pure game and gold was very tight it was a commodity here uh it still is tough at the beginning uh but um you know like there were points where I had more gold than I could do anything with all right so that felt kind of empowering not going to lie all right because it it's kind of sucked sometimes in the original that you really didn't have a lot of gold to mess around with you had to be very calculating with how you utilize your gold but but here uh you know there were and I play with different classes uh you know different races and yeah every time I had a lot more gold than in the original Gloom of kilforth okay so I'll say this about uh call of Kil for and just the system in general right um the more that I've played it all right because I went through that um I went through the trouble of like learning the system and I still stand by that the system is just not easy to learn it's very prone to making mistakes there's ton of of exceptions and fiddlin and weird like interactions that you have to memorize how it works um I still stand by that but now that I went through you know I've played this a bunch and I went through the trouble of you know internalizing the system properly I have just enjoyed this purely the last game that I played before recording this which is this one with the molk um magic user uh it was just pure gaming blade I basically uh just lost myself for a couple hours just no music no nothing

just playing this exploring uh and you know planning out my turns and the experience that this offers is amazing but you do have to be aware of the caveats the rules I still think that unfortunately it's just a poor experience like you know you know internalizing and learning this system and one thing that doesn't help call of kill forth unfortunately is that the the new rules the new Advan rules with the ships uh they felt kind of vague at times uh there were I did have other rules questions like there's some card interactions like the way some of the cards are written right um just kind of thinking from like the perspective of someone who is picking this game up for the first time right and they don't have a whole lot of board gaming experience so uh if you read the cards verbatim some cards say uh you know search for a card in the deck and and put it in you know in where you're where in a place on the table and they don't explicitly say that you need to shuffle the deck after or sometimes it says search sometimes it says draw uh so the way that some of the effects are written they're not super clear and like of course I if you've played a ton of War games I think you can infer or assume that the designer meant You're supposed to shuffle the deck after or you're supposed to draw cards from the top of the deck before uh putting it and in your territory or whatever and then uh shuffling the deck after uh so I think you can infer it but

that lack of clarity and that that muddiness with the rules and the mechanics like I just really wish I'll put it like this uh I really wish that the clarity of the rules and the attention to detail with how the cards are written was as good as the art folks if it was this would be a 10 out of 10 like no question to me I gave the original eight out of 10 I don't tend to disc C ratings in my games all right I just tell you whether I like it or not and uh things that you might like that might you know things that you might not like about the game right uh so that was the original that uh that I what I gave the original great game just rules wasn't a fan of the rules basically but um this is a bit exacerbated here with the new mechanics uh but okay now to counter that I'll say this all right um like I said once you get past the rules um this this is pure gaming Bliss I did thoroughly thoroughly enjoy this and I'm not going to put the game away after I'm recording after I'm done recording this I'm going to play this one more time at least and the the only reason why I'm gonna put it away after is because uh there's a few other games that I want to play before the end of the year all right um but uh I do recommend this so just to summarize okay I do recommend this but only if you are already familiar with the Gloom of kill forth system and you just want a you you want the new mechanics this does really shake

up the formula tremendously all right and adds more you know and it's not just the new mechanics you know it's more the the the the setting the the theme the pirate and Maritime theme and uh the and the mechanics you have the resources the ships uh the action economy is just different uh the the economy with gold period is just different the cards are interesting they're pretty punishing sometimes so this really does shake up the formula but I only recommend it if you're already comfortable with that system okay uh I strongly advise against this being your entry in the system and that's because it might leave a bad impression okay uh it might leave you with more rules questions and I don't want you like the the the foundation of the game already um it it's prone to having rules a weird rules interaction that are not answered immediately by the rule book and I don't want you to run into more of that stuff with the new mechanics uh I think your first entry should be Gloom of Kil forth now I do wish I had tried Shadows of Kil forth and I'm I'm really considering getting it just because I I do love the system so much folks I I just have to I just have to be honest about the shortcomings okay but I do love this a lot and I do want to get Shadows of kill forth and I want to see how it Compares okay even though the Asian theme doesn't attract me that much I do want to get that eventually but uh do get this if you're already comfortable with that that system and you just want more of the

same to some extent and uh you you want um uh you want new mechanics and and you want to like keep the system fresh this really does a great job at that it just it's just not the best way to introduce it to a new player and you really don't have the option I mean you could but uh like if you want to play this without the resources or the ships U you're it's just not going to work very well so many of the cards reference the new mechanics so it you're going to have rewards and loot that you're not going to know what to do with them and they're not going to help you push forward the towards the goal because these these cards reference all this stuff and you can't really do anything with them so so uh yeah so keep keep that in mind uh only get to the system if you uh into this entry I recommend personally if you are already familiar with Glo of Kil for okay but uh for if you're a Gloom of kill for enthusiast and you like the first two I I can recommend this 100% all right I do enjoy this I'm going to play this more uh before I I put it away after I'm recording this uh once you get past the rules it is pure gaming Bliss uh I and as I mentioned earlier I just wish had the attention to Theo with the rules clarity and the rule book was as good as the art oh God like this this would be Godlike 10 out of 10 if it was if it was the

case folks but uh a lot a couple other n PS by the way before I I log off um so they didn't include a um stealth token all right U like the original uh nitpick apparently what people do is they just put their model face down like this but uh I don't mind that it's not that big a deal but keep in mind there's no stealth tokens in this entry um and also another nitpick is uh I thought that the the reference the new reference I wish that they had included um I wish that they had included the uh the new steps all right because uh you know the setup doesn't include the advanced rules steps all right so the reference guide that they give you here is a in complete honestly uh because they don't they don't include the new Advanced setup steps right so you're still going to have to reference the rule book if you want to do the full setup and uh it also doesn't include the uh what each of the resources do it would have I I really would have appreciated if they included in the reference guide what each of these resources do okay so again like attention to detail like I don't know how they there's enough room here they could have included a little cheat to remind you what each resource does okay um and uh so and finally uh and this is

just from like the kickstarter right uh I was a bit I have not used the Miniatures that I got yet because um the Apparently and I didn't realize this the Miniatures are mostly based on or I think all of them are based on the class cards and so there's no molk there's no centor like so if if you prefer the illustration from the race card uh you're going to you know um you're not going to be able to really have your miniature reflect the race that you're playing as only the um only the um class card so I was a bit disappointed I have not used the Miniatures yet I've just used the standies because I I typically just lean more towards representing my character as uh the race not the class but that's a net peeg that's just personal preference okay um uh but yeah folks so that's that's my thoughts on Call of kilforth um just love love this but u i do I had to list those caveats because I don't I don't want you to have a a negative impression of this system if this is your intro to it because this system folks it it just it can offer such an rich and amazing experience uh once you get past the couple uh shortcomings with the rules uh and it and one thing that I didn't mention in my Gloom of kill forth review was that in the one I shot earlier was that this is one of the few adventuring RPGs that

has the benefit of being suable with just one character you don't have to comp control multiple characters very few games in my collection allow for this right typically you're supposed to control a party of characters but this doesn't need that all right so this has a huge Edge in that regard okay and uh so yeah love this love the illustrations love the theme makes about the rules and some of the lack of clarity in certain things and the um the accessibility for a new player into the system those are the things that I have an issue with for for the most part but uh but yeah folks that's my those are my thoughts on Call of kilforth uh so uh I want to thank you so much for watching if you have any comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comments section and if you enjoy this content make sure to like And subscribe I'll go ahead and play this again before I put it away after recording this and I'll see you in the next

one

Progress saved