Nucleum: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Zach and I are doing a discussion over nucleum yep um now what's interesting about this review specifically is you can actually see normally we do a review after we get done playing the game but this time we didn't play This Together NOP nope this is one the first time and actually a very rare time that we're doing a review where we played it different games we played completely different games yeah uh I think we both played this with our wives though yep um so I I played this yeah with cat and then also did the solo got it um but I didn't want it normally when that happens I just do a review like by myself but I specifically wanted you involved because uh one we did brass together uh you've played barrage Y and one of your favorite games is done by this designer Simone Luciani who did Zulan yeah and did he do barrage no no he's involved in so so many many great games uh hu fantastic designer absolutely fantastic design David tury kills it um so this design team if I had known that they yeah he did do barrage oh he did yeah okay he's he's uh Lorenzo IL manifo which I've only heard good things okay that that's what I was thinking um yeah barrage Zulan Voyages of Marco Polo yep um he
did another one that was on my top 10 Darwin's Journey oh that's on yeah this guy that's not my top 10 as well yeah this guy is killing it yeah um so with us I don't remember what I think you give brass an eight I think so and I'm I'm at a seven I think it's a good game not quite uh worthy of being number one but honestly what game really is right uh and then there was this one so this was at Gen Con I believe it was able to be picked up I didn't pick this one up I picked up Barcelona uh and then got this one secondhand this game is fantastic I think this game is super like um it's amazing like so I'm going to go out on the limb here um I'm looking for the other the other sideboard yeah I personally think this game blows brass out of the water um yeah and mainly well obviously this has more going on has more going on uh but mainly if you the big delineation is if you don't like people stealing your resources then play this and not brass or barrage be so that that was my biggest thing with the difference of this game is and my wife said the same thing it
feels more Euro than brass and barrage does because brass and barrage both encourage you to steal resources from other players right this there is no way for me to steal resource I can join you on a project for the rails and we can both benefit from it yeah but I can't steal a resource from you yeah you can't like and not that there's like a a bunch of resources there's money and but in terms of like how you power your buildings is through your nuclear reactors right so I bu Ste your uranium yeah you cannot steal the uranium um at at most you can indirectly make it more more difficult by I mean I mean once someone kind of gets a a mine created for the uranium that's theirs until they get it within their Network to be able to get it to a building that they really want right because you can't even hinder their path to it you can't be like oh nope I blocked this route so you can't go there it's like no thanks you made it way easier for me too right uh so that I personally enjoy because even even though in brass you are rewarded I guess for like oh you use that metal uh which flips this I'm getting points I'm getting something like so the stealing isn't as painful it's still like well I had plans for those resources and my plans weren't for
you using them especially like in brass the um beer um yeah losing the coal losing the iron there is still a Marketplace so I can always normally go and buy it yeah but you steal my beer and I can just you over that's true yeah uh but here it's it's kind of like you have a little bit of cooperation yep with your railroads where it's like hey anyone want to you know help me finish this out because we're going to get points for it right you're going to get value out out of it on top of the fact that the cool one of the other coolest thing about this game is the wait actions work that Domino kind of effect which I've never seen um it's just such a brilliantly designed game yep with tons of replayability as well like yeah that's kind of where also like brass is like kind of like I've played it multiple times and I'm like yeah I've seen this game and maybe that's why people like it so much because it becomes more about playing other people than the game itself this one has the fact that you're different milestones in game scoring contracts you know tiles coming out because you pull a bunch out you don't see right um different purple objectives uh asymmetrical player Powers with like the Tex so again if
you're playing at less than four people you're going to have different combinations per game um I like the fact there is two boards automatically so you have a three and four player boarding one two player board and that's nice yeah what's also really cool is like you which I mean there's not a whole lot of player interaction honestly like in a two-player game specifically there's very little player interaction yeah at the end only it kind of really determines well it depends on where you start because at the beginning you can start wherever so you can have as much or as little player interaction as possible right if you start down here and then I also start down here right but if you start down here and I start way over there then we're just having our own separate networks I think we did we started in the two bottom white location I start the rainbow and she star in the white gotcha yeah I think I last time I played I started up there no I started down here and Cat started up here so we never interacted right um all right so let's see what what might be easier uh negatives got any negatives I figured you might have a little bit more than I do cuz you've played what these are supposed to be based off of if you're not familiar the new glim is supposed to be a blend of brass and barrage right um I've never played barrage so I don't know um I think it's closer to brass and
it's definitely closer than to Brass than even barrage um yeah this is one like so this section is the barage part of it um this track the mileston the contracts okay that very barrage feeling um this side of it is very brass feel okay um negatives for me and this is just again once you start getting to more and more complex games I always have this issue there were so many spots for like bonuses so your turbines gave you bonuses your Tech gave you bonuses we were playing by the end we were going so fast on turns to always remember all those bonuses that you had options for MH um there were a couple times where I was like I was playing out like for three four turns ahead and I got to a point like oh but with all these bonuses I need to do the next three steps yeah and and it's that click that for me and that's I play enough of these bigger complex games that that's where always I have a problem with this all my bonuses are scattered yeah and so then for me to remember all of them is a little more Troublesome okay um I like the freedom of this compared to like brass for like railroads I still like the in network for your buildings have to be built in a network location but realistically because you can then build a rail wherever you like your network is almost wherever you want to be yeah I was going to say they they
really hammer in the rule book and also in the um I watched Paul Grogan play and he was really emphasizing what a network meant and I was like well really it's wherever you have a piece right which is almost anywhere you want it to be like if I have a railroad just there my network are these two buildings right uh or these two cities so it's like the real the real thing I guess for me was reminding was if I have a rail here this is my network this is not yet my network yeah but once if you built a rail there then these are my network exactly and so again it felt like okay I could practically go wherever I want it I might have one step to get there yeah now if for instance you built rails all in four of those spots yep that spot's now locked away I can't get to it right that might be beneficial for you that might not be beneficial yeah I think that is the biggest thing is like you you can pull energy through completed railroads um however like yeah if this is completely closed off with specifically yours or in a three- player game you and someone else's right but I don't at least have any presence there then yeah I can't build in there which again if somebody's going to the work to just eliminate you from a spot okay yeah it's not that big of a deal or it wasn't a priority for you in the
first place like in a three-player game like if you know you go there and then uh Brett goes there and then you and Brett go there well that went to me multiple times and I chose not to even bring that right into into my network right um some balancing things that I didn't understand completely um so again my wife went on that side so she her area had a power plant non nucleum on that one but she was automatically connected to coal and on this side of the map there is no power plant that cuz there's a coal location connected Direct ly to a coal site so oh so there was but on this side of the map you also have more mine locations mhm um and so it was kind of one of these things where it's was like okay I have a better chance in the later game to do bigger moves but she in early game can get going a little faster yeah that's actually interesting I didn't even make that um make that connection I think I down there right the only reason I did was because the first time I realized I ran out house and couldn't get a single uh I'm trying to with a little star um that oh uh I always want to say progress token but it's not it is uh I I was morale but it's not morale it's on back oh achievement tokens achievement tokens I had none when I
went for my first star and so I got the made negative three points from it oh yeah the the Great Western Trail you spot right um and so for me it was that just kind of like oh oh there's no I mean I have really build stuff now there's also a ton of ways for you to get stars outside of that though like I mean granted your opening certificate starts down there but if you can complete it then at least going there will get you another two stars yeah um what's actually kind of fascinating though about being down here though now that you make that connection yep is yeah the early game she's is going to be able to you know use coal as electricity but that means that if her network is down here and she doesn't have ways of getting free energy from her turbines or from M's uranium her coal is going to be insanely expensive whereas yours is still going to be super cheap if you've started up there right and so that's what that's what I meant unless she starts building all the way it was one of those things where like cuz I was kind of looking through it's like okay so your players are a little asymmetric even your board States a little asymmetric a little bit yeah and i' like that just because good I like the buildings um in that okay well the the yellow buildings the housing that gives you more workers right you know the industrial ones are going to give you more uh money and then the labs are going to get you more Tech right and your Tech are really what differentiate you from and I also like the fact that oh I have five money let me build my
level four I love that you don't have to go in order uh like like brass makes you makes you do um I like the fact that the second turbine is asymmetric itself MH um and that was a good decision cuz normally I'd think oh I wish they were all asymmetric but I think that might on top of the Tex on top of the uniqueness of the Technologies would probably be a little much right and again it was one of those just little tweaks where um they definitely did cuz like I think I played B and B was definitely a little bit achievement or able to get up that track a little bit faster okay and one its uh final Tech goal was if you had three stars above 10 you got 21 points um and like that second turbine was every time you do energy get two stars yeah and one of its bonus tiles got you more stars as well is like okay like I I think I can see what this thing like this player's power is trying to go for the four different Technologies are um are very much geared like and what's really cool about the text is like you have instant text you can just get as well as passive and kind of like when you get to level three TCH it's like I now have a broken power right which if Simone was in void of Marco poo he's very familiar with broken balanced Powers right that it's like I think the tech a he can just now build buildings anywhere he doesn't have to have a
network and it's like that's disgusting so you you already have a cheap energy resource that's just like and I'm going to build here and it's enered and it's like and player a gets the second turbine gets all Co NE another2 yeah so both that means $3 off of any coal purchase per round so your yeah your first coal is always free yep and then if you can get the other two you have three energy y essentially four right it's it's so brilliantly done without and the cool thing is we were talking about kind of like early game to end game game stuff and I was saying okay well late game the player over here is going to have really expensive um coal and I like how this game struck a really good balance of tight resources but not starving right like you will eventually probably get to a point where you have some way of getting money like if you went up that track it's like okay time for me to reset boom 10 money two points right um You can actually go up like one time I've played where my money was all the way up and I barely moved my workers cuz I was like well I'm not I got my network so I mine I was pretty heavy so I had the points maxed out and the money maxed out by the end of the game and workers was one before the three okay pointer yeah um and what's also fascinating about these tracks is that you yeah I mean you can get your Victory Point track maxed out but you cannot score that 21 until you do every single action so you can't run you can't just
constantly be recycling right um so one negative that I did have about it is a table hog like absolutely uh I have a big table and it was okay I need to put this like this direction M and this is just in the middle between the two of us just to have enough room to put my tiles here at the top yeah yeah cuz you have to have your action tiles over on the side then you self have room to slot them right and so and I have a big table Yeah like you can play eight TI on it and not have a problem right yeah it is a weird table hog with all the all the extra components right I mean the board is pretty big by itself and then your player board is really big and then it gets even taller because we're talking like a 2in tiles that the size right here um so again it's it's pretty decent size yeah I I was actually I ran into that issue whenever I was um playing solo was just kind of trying to keep everything in order yeah uh with all the action tiles right um yeah like honestly negatives for me I don't really have any because it's like I mean because just nothing nothing's annoying like no no one is like like if they I mean yeah if
they take a spot of a railroad that's part for the course of these kinds of games yep um typically yeah if they build a building somewhere that you might want to go that's Again part for the course right money and workers are a resource that you're not ever really in abundance of but you have ways to get them yeah you can as long as you do one action title up here you can reset uh I will say I like the way the game ends but it is a little weird one I still have no idea why there's Five Flags even though in a uh two-player game you're completing three of them right so it's like why have the other two like I don't understand I mean I guess in the last round if you complete them I think that's why uh because we almost got a fourth one out okay by the last round I think there were two tiles left here and it just wasn't see and I think if it was different one so like if it's the 70 point uh or your eighth Tech yeah then those flags come out right um this one wasn't going to come out because there's you don't get anything for having more of these and spending money on those nothing um yeah I think the game is really well paced like for 60 to 150 minutes I think that that's a very solid it's funny cuz I feel like there are games where it's like here are certain conditions have to be met then the game
ends right and it's like the game isn't anywhere close to ending until all of a sudden it ends once one condition's met you know another one's right after um I uh yeah so it's like if you're if you're expecting the game to be like okay someone hit 70 points and then in another 30 minutes the certificate deck's going to run out that's not how it's going to be everything's going to be super low uh By the time someone is doing something I guess the ones that are the hardest to complete potentially is alltech we were really like I was one Tech short I think I got in my solo game but in terms of like certificates like objectives are always my go-to yeah so that deck runs out that deck ran out this one most people are resetting yeah that one ran out pretty quickly it was the next two that took us a little while um and it makes sense in a two-player game that you have to go through three of those instead of instead of two normally it's shorter um yeah well I think some of it is like okay so like the star one if you play with more players and one person is buying tiles more aggressively so they're just taking more actions they're going to be slower MH sending their stars out and so people as a table are going to get more actions in totality um you get more of these here in a you know three-player game so it's going to take longer you get more contracts it's going to take longer so a lot of the things that
um like again I focus pretty heavily on contracts but other players in a three-player game might not focus all it heavily or they're going to choose like oh that one's good but they're not going to try like I almost had like my entire thing filled all the time of contracts oh okay yeah of just planning out contracts as one gets you bonuses you have potential for a way upside with basically no negative of taking those contracts that's true yeah the only time it can be a negative is if you f get the action tile that gives you double the resources I got both of them oh you did that's but yeah but then if you're not completing them then you're like this is a wasted tile cuz I'm not getting the double bonus that I want but some of them I got like because I was taking tons of these as well cuz I was I went really heavy into railroads so I got um ones that like asked for having just tons of the action tiles oh okay so I was compling those nice in specific cities just having building had tons of those that's true yeah you can get to a point where you start top decking objectives which I just like yeah I got that which can be kind of annoying where it's like I'm just going to take that and immediately complete it which I did like three times by the end of the game by the end of the game I guess it is necessary I love the fact that those are the ones that people can take but they're the purple public objectives that no one can take but once it's completed it's gone right uh just having that that sense of like here's what only I can do and here's what everyone one is that uh sing um
publicly um the Milestone track is fantastic yep it's so good it's great um because again that's all public knowledge so you can just be like okay well I'm going to aim for that one up at the time to get time six right and that's variable so if it's like oh for every turbine right get all four out get to the time six right like it's a huge chunk of points and you're getting you know um first time you get up here you're getting a level three Tech yep um so I mean there was one times there's still a nucleum here but I could get up into this range I was like you know it's better for me to get over here and get that level three Tech at this point than to put out that nucleum on the reactor yeah and sometimes you want to reset right because you're like well I have nine right achievement points okay I'm the first one there and I now I have you know I get the bonus for placing it in a certain section yep I'm going to place this over in my network so now I can use uranium right just high energy right because I've already been building turbines I've been building and so it's just all those kind of sweet zones of it yeah and that's also kind of why I I really like this one over brass because in brass I never felt like I was doing well
even though I think every time we play like my score is good yeah um but I'm always sitting there like okay how am I going to get these resources and how can I put it in a way where it's not going to be taken from me CU I really need to build this building um yeah so my first comment when we finish this game was this game compared to the other two felt more free yeah so brass to me is much more straightforward and I'll call it simpler it's not simpler in the sense of it's not Grand planning yeah but your choices are vastly limited compared to this that's true I understand you only have three possible actions but inside those three actions are massive choices that you're making right in brass you have a hand of card to what you can do and there's only a couple of actions that you can do with those yeah very restrictive on like well I'd really like to build up in that City oh I don't have a card to do it right so then at that point your choice is do I go basically forfeit my ter for Wilds yeah um do I build out from where I am and just kind of hope that I'm going to get that card that's true yeah you know and and to me that's where brass is it's that gamblers dilemma of what do I take with the limited actions that I have and do and then and try outpace my opponent with choices here it's more like it's a
Sandbox almost I can go do practically whatever I want it's the order I want to do it and how much am I going to get influenced or Changed by someone else yeah and um cuz their other game that bordon dice made this year is is Barcelona which I don't know if you played played so that is as point salid of a game as you can get like scores are like 3 400 points so it's like it doesn't really matter just take the zeros off and you could have easily made it oh this gives you two points instead of 20 right but sometimes every now and then those feel good right it's nice to be like oh my score was 600 points instead of seven it's like well Seven's high in this game it's like shut up right um but with this one this isn't a point salad game and there's not really a term for it so I'm going coin it here this is a bonus salad game cuz everything you do gives you something not points uh points kind of hard to come by is gave a little bit of Carnegie Vibes where it's like your score in the game isn't going to be that high but end game scoring SC I had 17 points at the by the time endgame scoring started and I got 92 um and that that can feel really really good you take you take a uh or you place a railroad that someone else placed oh it matches your Railroad and the city so I'm going to do my actions but you also get a bonus cuz it match colors right I'm going to take a objective tile that I can complete and I'm going to place it
here get two money oh and then now because I place the tile here I can complete that right um like the the turbines are just like okay I'm going to run electricity it's not this like meticulous okay I can afford I barely have enough electricity if I afford to spend all my money right it's like oh wait now I have the these two so that's just three and I need eight right and there's enough viable tiles that give you another plus one yeah and it's like okay so realistically I have plus four energy I need 10 so that means I only need three nucleum but I already have two um turbines or I have one turbine and a tech that gives me a free turbine yep so we're golden yeah and it's like okay then that's that's filled flip that over that's going to run this track up oh whenever I reset I'm going to get 12 money and four points right um it's so good yeah cuz what's also neat is you have the anytime action of being able to turn money into workers no was it it's uranium to workers workers to money y but also what's kind of interesting is uranium isn't uh that's the like the only very restrictive yes resource super restrictive if you don't plan well for it yeah so either you can go for the turbines and the tiles that give you a bunch of free uh stuff and just hope you have bank because what's
also cool is I can't remember in brass if that can the market ever run out of coal or will that always be there no it can run out it can run out yeah I've never seen it run out but uh cuz I'm assuming yeah cuz it just gets insanely expensive uh that you're probably just not going to have the money to have it run out right here I like the fact that coal is cheap at the very beginning yep and then gets expensive and then it gets expensive but it never runs out right it's like yep if you have it is Limitless resource yeah um as long as you just have the network to it right which I don't know why but it helped that they thematically told you where it was coming from like I think up top it says in the rules that's coming from Poland OH I don't even remember saying that I swear it says it's somewhere in it probably does cuz they put all these little notes and stuff and tidbit stuff and again I watched a video to learn it um that's fair so I would not even have any idea where but I know for a fact it mentions it's probably an energized SE oh hey it does right here I found it coal production areas rur to the west and celesia of the northeastern side of the map these represent coal rich areas in Western Germany and Southern Poland respectively got so I don't I don't know why that matters but it's like oh hey it's actually coming from somewhere right um so while it's a game that rewards you on almost every action you
take it rewards you on meticulous planning you're never starved for resources and if you are you're not in any worry that the limited resources you have are getting taken from you right um and it's Bor and dice like yep it's not a T-Series game either like they uh like they've just like they've just been killing it lately um and what's also great is an expansion announced oh already yeah nucleum Australia I think or austri what was it called hold on austri would make sense let's see nucleum Australia Australia interesting welcomes the latest invention in alternative Industrial Revolution um it adds I think a new board okay let's see comes with a new map they introduces several New Concept and Rule changes to the nuclear base game use shipping lanes to expand your networks build your own coal mines and try the expert variant with bidding for the experiments so yeah yeah that was one of um cuz again I only play it once there is a little bit of a fear that there could be experiments huh okay that's kind of cool right there could be the experiment boards that are a little bit
better overall than other ones I I could see that uh especially given given a specific player style of play sure um but again I haven't played it enough so I don't know that how balanced they are but I just know from asymmetrical games very very few do I find like oh everything is just perfectly balanced I would take it from if this was any other design team design Duo Simone and David I would agree with you I think with Simone having a hand in Voyage as a Marco Polo he's very familiar with making sure broken powers are balanced right they're brokenly balanced it's defin yeah it's like one of those where if you hear that someone can build anywhere then it's like well that's disgustingly broken but then you have your Network which I mean I haven't played with every single Tech I've only played with a few and the solo variant doesn't use text got it um so it would be let's see uh so if for experiment D your Railway tiles are considered to be a wild card on both sides on turns when you place a railway you are allowed to fulfill a contract so obviously you can't whenever you displ a railway so that's again op yep uh yeah because I think D is all about yeah they're they're huge on Railways yeah is their their big thing um experiment C during energize actions you
can transport coal uranium and electricity ignoring Network restrictions thus you can use any one power plant and you can energize buildings that are not connected to that power plant that also means that you can use coal and your uranium that are not connected to that power plant um action experiment B gives you oh that's right they have their own unique special action tiles yes they're pretty good they look like it looks like oh plus two energy and they're Wilds on both sides they're Wilds on both sides um and then a urbanize actions have a discount of two ther and ignore any network requirement right you can build anywhere right so and that's just super cool not only do you have I mean some of the experiments are the same for everyone it's just dep ending on where they're at right but I like that experiment level three techs are unique are unique yep um and they're thematic to they like their board so it's like this is what I'm really good at but you don't have to follow it but you're probably going to you you should it's at least a nudge in the direction that they think you should go yeah so I'm I'm excited to see what the expansion brings I think the Bing on experiments maybe that gives you some variety of having different types of level one two and three um and then obviously a new map is going to be cool and apparently new rules so yeah I really don't have many many negatives if any really
uh from from the the game yeah I think you might have a a decent point on potentially the experiments being slightly but I mean just from Reading those four level those text it's like well all those sound really good right um and this game has tons of variety which is what I look for in a euro game I don't really want to play Euro games where it's about playing the people yeah um that's where my asymmetric games kind of come in where it's like B Tama isn't really about me playing the game it's me playing you right here it's like oh okay what are the three you know public texts what are the three Milestones what action tiles are out and how am I going to utilize that for a winning strategy right um you got anything else no all right on scale of 1 to 10 what are you giving nucleum a solid nine at this point um don't think I'm ready to give it a 10 just yet that is also where I'm at I gave it a nine as well and I'm like what is keeping it from a 10 and I don't know think for me another play or two would require for me to give a 10 um cuz again first play through only um it is pretty meaty it's pretty big um so I think I want to play at least one more time before just giving it yeah cuz yeah cuz there's there's other
games that because it's like it's not the variety but maybe maybe it is maybe I think what the expansion with a new map will bump it up because I think that that's the only thing that would get stale is the map right and I get your kickoff point will be a little bit different depending on your starting objective sure but even then it's like there's only four to choose from so it's like well this wants me to have a building in white white cities okay there's all I think they're all specific to colors I think so too so it's like well that's probably what I'm going to do right and the map and I've played I'm playing it to so it's either here here here so that was actually one of my big problems so I got the uh buildings in white locations mhm but all the white locations were practically Filled from the oh from the neutral tiles and the um broken zones oh that's right and I was like so there's like one space here that was completely closed off half of that was completely closed off and Ashley immediately went to that spot I was like well well I guess I'll start here in in leap Sig uh I will say I like the way this game is set up though ofs which is main what thees but that was kind of a fresh way of kind of it was to do it uh the neutral tiles but yeah it was a good way to randomize it I think so but yeah this one I think the expansion will probably
bump this up to to a 10 I think so y uh I'm I'm just pleasantly surprised with it this was uh at my cuz this might go up is going to go up after my top 10 this was my number six for my my top I don't know I don't want to know if words out on yours yet but we'll get we'll get to your top 10 we'll get to mine um but it it jumped up to my six which was huge um but yeah got anything else nope city names are impossible to pronounce yeah uh do it by numbers it's 15 10 7 that's funny funny enough the numbers are there for the solo variant um which I do have a solo review so definitely check that out but other than that let us know what you think of nim in the comments below like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful what every time upd for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you