Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hallertau Review - One Year Later

Transcript 23:54

this video is sponsored by skillshare farms what are they good for us millennials just don't know we get our food from tesco thankfully a kind german man called uve taught me all about it via the medium of board games and now that i know about farming i can show you this is a farm in it you can grow food but very slow and not any of the good ones this for example is pak choy which is kind of like cabbage but somehow even blander now i know what you're thinking can i grow a pizza in here what about a burrito not a chance first you need something called seeds to grow things in farms and after googling pizza seeds all i got was results for coming king moving swiftly on um rosenberg designed a lot of games but he's perhaps mostly known for his farming simulators agricola the bad one aura at labora a farm for odin and now haletau which is where you farm but in halitao i haven't always loved these games but after a while they tend to grow on me long ago i covered a feast for odin on our channel and if you watch that video now you will be able to tell that hair has never been my 40 but also that i wasn't exactly enamored with that game well cut to 2021 and a feast for odin is just about one of my favorite games and now there's halital and i mean just look at it this thing is so

unashamed of what it is it's not here to excite you it's here to tell you no this really is just about farming expert level and you know what i'm down with that i like a game that knows what it is and embraces it and in so many ways halital is preposterous for example there are 13 different resources which is a number i'd normally use as a hyperbolic joke but i'm not being hyperbolic i'm just being regular bollock halitau does not speak in gentle brushes not only are there 13 of them but most follow completely different rules in how they interact with the game's systems the objective of halitau is to score the most points and the majority of points in this game comes from bulldozing this community hall to a better location i can show you because i've prepared a second one so that i don't have to destroy the set so you just go look nice scenery but to do that first you will need to move these other buildings further along this track so this one catches up problem each of them has a resource cost to be moved which you'll have to pay at the end of the round furthermore to even inch the community center one step you have to move all five buildings if that wasn't bad enough these badges are not going to move their butts unless you pay the requisite resources a number of times

equal to the round that we are in so if i want to move the cooling house on round one i can pay one meat or milk if i want to move it on round five and consider that i'm only moving this one building one measly space i have to pay five meat or milk that's at least twice as much wait you didn't think this was a game about chill farming right you didn't think oh i'll get some sheep and saw some flax and then lay flat in a field of barley as i watched the sunset because i did and then this game was mean to me harlot puts the pressure on you to farm and to farm hard each resource is an efficiency puzzle but you don't have time to solve it you have to make concessions you have to sacrifice that efficiency because moving the community house early is a significantly cheaper and b gives you more workers to do more things later as evidenced by the number in this little window to build your engine you have to dismantle your own engine how's that for a euro game let me show you what i mean amongst the 13 different resources you have four types of crops barley wheat hops and flax one of the things you can do in the game is plant crops let me take off these resources so that i can illustrate if you have an empty field let's say on level five you can spend one week to then take that wheat and

plant it into the field and at the end of the round when you harvest the crops you will take that off and that will become five wheat because it was on the fifth level but then that field will go down one level whereas any fields you haven't planted will go up one level plus one additional field will go up one more level one time so then to get things you have to plant them and then you'll have more of them but when you plant them you will then have less of them if halital had a motto it would be don't get comfy the sense of concessions keeps up throughout the game's six rounds because you're trying to move five buildings every round and you can and want to move them further than once by getting these boulders out of the way you're constantly on the precipice of exhausting every resource you have unreasonably more than once i have found myself spending the very last of my flags just to move that big house one inch further to only later realize that i don't have any more flax and if i don't have any more flax there's no more flax to plant next round to get more flax that's flax facts so now i have to magic flax out of thin air like some sort of a tractor magician thankfully haletau shares its design

sensibilities with a magician's chunk of tricks and those tricks come in the form of cards i think there's still some cards in there hey do you like cards well in halo town there are four different decks of cards packed thicker than a bale of hay plus again i'm just being regular bollock two of these decks have each a selection of a further free decks to play with on any given session bringing the total to 10 different decks for another total of 330 cards each with a different ability i'll be honest with you if it wasn't for these cards halita would long be in the bin but it's not in the bin it's alive and well blooming with vigor where's the wires and beams of math and efficiency form the skeleton of this puzzle cards are the meat on top of that skeleton add in some woolly artwork and you've got yourself a pretty sheepy game honestly i'm not even saying anything right now just wanted this analogy to end up in a fully grown bar there's a sense of freedom with halite house cards like throwing caution to the wind and the wind blowing you back a loaded picnic hamper you can play them literally at any point in the game and when you do they will give you things often just cause from meat to milk to wool to sheep to crops to fields to upgrading your fields to harvesting your

fields early not every card is equal and they're split into four decks during the game to give you an idea of what to expect the gateway deck gives you rewards when you meet a criteria for example having free sheep if you have those sheep just play the card and get what's at the bottom no need to murder anything and i know what i sound like i'm getting unreasonably excited about a freebie like getting a free parker pen just for inquiring but i mean come on it's a free parker pen what's a parker pen gateway freebies are nice but they don't add up too much other cards let you spend resources for bigger rewards or even a big point bump or even to establish permanent once around bonus generation and so you have this duality harsh systems that squeeze every ounce of math from your brain juxtaposed by bargain bin jumble sale bonanza romanticized country living colliding with hard tractor toil how do you glue these things together that's right people better yet people represented by blue wooden cubes they're the best kind of people because they never talk back to you apart from graham over there he likes to talk about nfts i just think that once we move to a proof of stake model a lot of the environmental concerns people have about nfds will disappear and if only they could just understand the benefits of decentralized it's quite enough of that

dribble so here on this central board we have worker placement where you take workers from a limited supply and then place them on an action space and then do the action that's depicted on it and you can do that as long as that space isn't taken up by other workers halital doesn't move out of its way to innovate worker placement rather using the familiar trappings of a familiar genre to work as a bond between polarized ideas i feel like i've been trained by other board games including ones designed by mr rosenberg that worker placement is where you get the stuff that you want but here it feels more like a not tying loose strings both the resource multiplication via crops and the strategies emerging from cards feel like they need something to tie them together one final stitch and this is where you thread the needle what if you did exhaust a crop and need to magic it out of thin air well there's a space for getting any kind of crops you like you don't get a lot certainly nowhere near as much as engaging in the crop rotation mini-game but in a pinch it'll do other strategies are a touch more connected with the worker placement board like hey for example maybe you have a lot of sheep in one of the most ridiculous and obtuse moments of simulation uber rosenberg decided that what this game really needs that final lick of paint on its systems is a sheep aging mechanism so in this game your sheep

die if you get them in the earlier rounds if you've got a shep on round one it'll be placed on this slot and at the start of round four it will just up and die but if you visit one of the worker placement actions that somehow magically give the sheep extra age you'll prolong its death where it gets a little bit more absurd is that if you prolong its life past round six then you don't need to worry about it anymore because like after it's left the scope of the play session it's fine what happens to it this is like olivia or something do i die after round six i've asked hallettev but it didn't answer really i talked to a lot of boy games and they never answer i might might have gotten a little bit sidetracked let's reel it back in by discussing the one element of worker placement that hala tau does innovate on each space has multiple spots so let's say sally wants to share their sheep great they place one worker on this space and they get one wool resource for every sheep they own gertrude however also wants to share her sheep but sally already took that space no worries there's two extra spaces on the wool shearing space where gertrude can place her workers but each of them costs one more worker than the one before it nifty but what i think is really ingenious about this system is how these workers

get removed at the end of each round the top line of each action space gets cleared off this might seem symmetrical at first it isn't because the board responds organically to what is in demand and makes those spaces more prohibitive than others it's a simple rule but it connects the players their strategies and the system into a network halitau setting wise is about a place hallelujah and what better way to make halato come alive than to give it character halitau is a region famous for beer production that's where you grow hops and barley although if i'm honest that aspect of the game always felt cheesy did you know that they like beer in germany well i never whereas the game punishing players for exhausting road strategies that made it feel more alive than any wooden barley chochki ever could despite being non-descript as all heck i've been sheepishly avoiding the elephant in the room if i was so excited about halitau the big box of farm from mr board game farms man himself if i set it up not 10 minutes after the delivery person knocked on my door all the way back in november 2020 then how come it's taken me nearly a whole year to get this review out well the truth is that as soon as i played it i realized that halleto was not the game i wanted it to

be is it a good game sure is it anywhere near as good as mr rosenberg's best not a chance each of halitau's six rounds gets progressively longer slower and less methodical that's pretty typical for complex eurogames but whilst other games bloat help because their strategies expand this game bloats up because you're spinning so many plates and then each round each stack of plates gets an extra plate there's a common stereotype that euro games are just accounting in board game form which i always felt was stupid derogatory and reductive well here comes halita and says how about we make accounting for all of these resources into a board game and you're like not now halital you're embarrassing me in front of all my cool friends and hallet is like yes now because we have to meticulously assign all of these to over here and then it introduces discounts which are not complex but they are convoluted and so you spend most of your game looking like this i like getting all my ducks in a row as much as the next person but if there's 13 different types of ducks then guess what it might just take some time for me to do that as you can templatively stare at a pile of resources each unintuitively distributed on this weird board that multiplies each token by one two three four or five depending on what

level it is on just to accommodate the crop rotation mechanism in what the developers thought was a clever representation not only is it hard to visualize what you own but you also have to assign these resources to these buildings in your head because you can't pick them up because you'll forget how many you actually have what's worse anytime anyone takes an action all your math gets thrown out the window this window because you have to be so gosh darn precise about every resource that you own the strategy gets replaced with this weird syncopated rhythm of recalculate recalibrate recalculate recalibrate but quietly in your head because everyone else is in their mind palace and it would be rude to interrupt them but you would be also wasting your time as well halital's duality once again rears its head but this time it isn't quite as pretty remember the cards the 300 different cards with different abilities i know i'm not being original here every critic before me already mentioned this and you know why everyone keeps saying that these cards are just unbearably random because it's true it's not that they're not balanced individually they feel more than fair but together as a whole i mean how do you even balance 330 different cards to play with each other i suppose you could put them into booster packs and assign different rarity

or alternatively just maybe not balance them at all i get that balance isn't halitau's point it's that bright joyous moment of playing the card that gives you the thing that lets you play another card but then chains into another card and then finally you have the thing that you need to play the card that you've been waiting that will let you get the thing that will let you play another card but nothing undermines that moment more than another player at the table drawing dud after dud after another discordant dud halito is undeniably a strategic game that takes time experience and perseverance to master that much is not in contention but whether you'll have a good game of halitau or a bad game of halatau is as sure as throwing a deck of cards in the air and seeing if they land the right way or not it took me one game of hallow to be disappointed by it and never want to play it with another human being again i mean why would i the arc of each game is just seeing how far you can push this community center and then can you get it to the end oh i got it to the end great once you do that there's nothing else for you to find in this game apart from once again chaining these cards into sensible but most often not very sensible combinations and i've also mentioned loving a feast for odin which is in no uncertain terms a better game so why wouldn't i just play that over

haletau any given day surprise it's a turnaround turnaround where i find myself turned around like a houseplant to face the bright german sun fed and watered for a year to grow into a person that learned to stop worrying and just enjoy the mess the one saving grace that stops halitau from ending up in the forgotten mediocrity discount bin is the solo mode boy does this game have a cool solo mode so many new mechanisms so many cool systems let me tell you all about them and we're done nothing will excite me more about a solo game that doesn't have any extra rules it's just score attack okay there's a little adjustment to how many workers get removed from the board each round but that adjustment is already present in two and three player games so i feel confident in giving it the no new rule stamp it was exactly the knowledge that i don't immediately gel with uve's big box games that made me give it another chance and i'm glad that elaine had no interest to return to it because then i got to play it the way i think it was always intended to be played the cards made a lot more sense now rather than being all over the place in an environment where you haven't got anything to compare them to they suddenly felt just fun sometimes you got a good deal

sometimes you got a bad one and that was fine that was just your game and i felt perfectly okay with sitting and accounting for multitudes of grain meat and dairy as long as i was doing it on my own the silence felt natural cozy even you know i think i'm even starting to get a whiff of that countryside air coming through the window on second thought i think maybe a sewage pipe broke last week i did a video on railroad inc a tiny simple game about drawing roots and i almost jokingly melded these two videos together railroading versus haletau which one is best the joke being that they are the exact polar opposites in scope setting artwork size and length but the one thing they do have in common is how they approach solo gameplay with each move you make your own bet and create your own complications rather than playing against some weird ai card system that's meant to feel like a human making decisions but never quite does here you are your own perfect opponent that doesn't make for a strong recommendation for halital especially since a feast for odin is still undeniably a better game even if both are restricted to their solo modes but hala tau isn't as expansive or voluptuous it's also quick to set up if you have a third-party storage solution

and the rules are simple enough for such a complicated game that i don't think i'll ever need to read that rulebook again in my life no matter how much time i spend between plays it's not a slam dunk winner but it's got some charm and it's got some pluck and i think i'll keep on playing it stick around past the sponsor spot there'll be a cool announcement about a cool live charity stream with a cool board gaming podcast this video is sponsored by skillshare the online learning community with thousands of inspiring classes skillshare has classes on almost any subject imaginable from learning how to make videos to teaching yourself everything you need to know how to design a board game and whilst i haven't found a comprehensive guide on managing a crop rotation system it can teach you everything you need to know about brightening up your life with lots of foliage plants at home uplift your spirit and your space by christopher griffin is a class with the sort of energy i need in my life right now i think over the last couple of years we've all learned that we need to value our living space a little more and who better to teach it than the person who has over a hundred and sixty house plants in their apartment and when you finish growing your houseplant it can become a tasty and nutritious treat are you sure that's pak choy skillshare lets you set your own pace and follow along with a comfortable structure there's no ads no barriers between you

and a better you best yet the first 1000 of you can click the link in the description for a free one month trial of skillshare premium so you can unlock your creativity today but efka what about this live stream that you're telling us well on the 2nd of october 3 pm eastern time i will be joining the so very wrong about games podcast on their so very wrong about games twitch live stream to raise money for food banks canada i won't be the only guest joining i hear board game barrage are also going to be guests and we will be playing games of the crew to raise money for a good charity cause but we won't just be playing we'll also be giving away copies of the crew so if you join in on that live stream you will be able to win yourself a nice game if you want more information on the crew you can watch our review somewhere floating around over here uh and if you want to find out more about so very wrong about games i left the link in the description to their podcast and also to their twitch page i'll see you there

Progress saved