Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 21:16

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Hanabi, which is an older game. Oh, I didn't realize it was by Antoine Bauza. I don't know any of his other games off the top of my head, but that is a household name. So, obviously this game is relatively older and it's known to for being the Is it trick taking? No. Well, no, probably not. Set collection. Yeah, set collection where your cards are facing away from you, which I don't believe I have seen anywhere else. I feel like there might be one other game that came out recently that did something like that. a variant on like Headbands or other games where you're given an identity and you have to infer from everybody else's clues.

Yeah, it's This is a very strange game considering the fact that it feels like it should fit in that lightweight party filler game. Yeah. But I don't I do not view this game as that. No. Um because it's it's one it's too long. Like it's about Our Our game took about an hour, especially if you're trying to give adequate adequate clues and space out what you're playing and what you're discarding to try and obviously not run out of clues to give. Um but at the same time if it's like, "Well, they know who cares. Let's just be reckless." Hard that then don't play this game. Cuz you're going to lose like that. Cuz you're going to lose like that. It's either going to be Yeah, it's either going to be over quickly and not very satisfying or it's going to be, you know, you're going to take some time and really think and really work through. Right. This game, I remember the first time ever playing it. This was would have been obviously years ago. I've only ever played it at three. And I think these is kind of silent very vague information games. I only want to play at lesser player counts. Like the crew and stuff like that. I can't do a large crowd. That's just too many people I'm going to be mad at.

I hear you. Um because it's also it's it's so cuz I'm so into co-ops that I just want to help and whenever people like start making assumptions, it's just like Well, that's But have you thought about it? It's the wrong And it's like Um cuz it's funny towards the end of our game, um Kat, the last card that she drew, she put it at the end and then you're like, "What do you know?" She's like, "I know this is yellow." And you were right. It was the yellow four, but it wasn't the yellow three that he had told you about previously. know anything about a three. You just said yellow. Well, he just said two yellows and then you put it the new card in and I was like, "Oh, no." Um Mentally you placed it in the same position, but it had shifted. Yeah. Right. Um And everybody does that.

At one point you had put a five I think like a four, five, and six No, it was a uh three, four, five. Yeah. next to each other in a row and I was like, "That's fun." Oh. And early on you got blues and I said, "Okay, those are blues." Then you played those blues and then you kept insisting Oh. And then you played one and you were like, "This is blue." And it Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's okay. like, "That must have been it, but I couldn't remember." I was like, "Oh, maybe I got a a new blue." Um at one point when you guys had pointed out the ones to me, I remember I remember them being the one and then I remember Brett telling me the color and then time had passed and I was like, "I don't remember which color I have left." Well, because you're so this game you're so foggy. I mean cuz you could you couldn't give two shits about what's in your hand cuz you obviously can't see it. So, you're so hyper-focused on what your teammates have that you're also forgetting about what they told you. Yep. So, whenever it comes back to you, you're just like, "Oh, no. I forgot everything." So, then you're holding your cards like Yeah. All right.

Hold this. Hold this. So, this one's a Yeah, this one's yellow. This one's blue. This one's a four. This is my five. Yeah. And and then you're like This one is not green, red, or Literally the part which I don't even know if it is legal, but whenever I knew I'm like, "I need to play this one and discard this one." I don't know if you can actually take them out of your hand, but like when it came back to me, I was looking I'm like, Which one do I "Oh, no." "Which one do I play?" I was going to ask you when you did that. I was like, "Do you remember what you just put down?" I I hadn't I remembered it like the what I meant to do with them, but I was like, "Crap." Did which one did I put to my left and which one to my right? Luckily, I did keep it, you know, memorized, but I feel like this game is also a really good like therapy tool because you can really just figure out like what your insecurities are because the whole time I was JUST LIKE, "I DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU GUYS EXPECT OF ME AND I DON'T WANT TO DISAPPOINT ME ONCE." YEAH, there's out of all the clue games, the clue giving games, um I mean obviously I can attribute this to Codenames because you're trying you can only give so much information so you're in your head and it makes the most perfect sense in the world.

Yeah, roller skates. you. Uh it was speak easy. And uh and it was it was speak easy it was speak easy seven. No, it was like speak easy five. And roller skates was on the board and he thought that that would get me to speak easy. Yes, 100% because the train of thought for that I let me explain what I know. It's no longer Hanabi anymore. It's me explaining to you my Codenames clue because I my thought process was, "Oh, roller skates Sonic waitresses wear roller skates. Sonic is in the same vein that you have that same era as speak easies." Which they don't. But In your mind it worked perfectly. And and as my wife, she should know that. Yeah. Oh, and turtles was also one because of the turtle club for Master and the Sky. Yes. I forgot.

And that directly links skating with turtles. In which the turtle club was not in a speak easy. It wasn't, BUT IT WAS A CLUB WHICH ARE relatively Speak easies in the world. Yes. The speak easy club. Yes. Which they're not, but Um Kind of I could kind of kind of See? Anyway, but that's how this game is. But nice thing in contrast though, and that's a good contrast I think to make because there are a lot of similarities. Difference is you're far more limited in the information that you can give and the ambiguities you can have. Right. The meta game is more obvious than in Codenames cuz it's like I had no idea how you made that clue. There's no way that would have happened. This one's like "Okay, why did you tell me that this was this color at this moment?"

Right. Maybe it's very very important that I No, you made me forget to throw it away. Well, because that's that's the thing though is like obviously the way that that we all think is different because Seth is going to give me a hint in a completely different way than in a horrible way. I'm horrible. I suck at these games. Listen, it's okay. It's going to give like I'm going to give him a hint though and and I'm going to be like, "Oh, yeah, I think he just needs to know the colors." And in which case he's going to be like, "Oh, she said green so she wants me to play one of these greens." Immediately when really it's like, "Oh, well, no, he only has like a They're They're already five. You can throw them away. Right. Well, yeah, cuz giving a specific color at a specific time it's kind of like, "Okay, well." Well, like whenever he's like, "This is white." And the entire time I was like, "That's the most perfect clue he could give her." Cuz that is the like it doesn't benefit you in any way to tell you it's white if it's a two, three, four, or five.

That one scared the [ __ ] out of me the most because I was like, "Oh, I'll play it." And then I was like, "But what if?" Yeah. And then you start to like second guess yourself because you don't know what you have. Yeah. So, then you start burning clues cuz you don't want to play it and then it's like but everyone else is like, I I I mean cuz this game is one of the most um either pandering games cuz you can just come off as this biggest dick where it's like, "Okay, let's spell it out for them. That's a white. My turn. That's a one. Now you know, what is it? What is it? Yes, very good. A white one." Not in that particular you forgot. Where hole. And so, but then you're burning clues and then it's like, "Okay, well, I had to waste my turn to tell you what I believe you should have already known."

Oh, and great. Now And now you're crying. All right. And it's so easy to know what what you know because you're staring right at it. And so, you're like, "How can you not know that YOU HAVE A FOUR AND THREE REDS?" RIGHT. When you've only said like, "Oh, hey Seth, you have a green in your hand." Yeah, and it Well, yeah, cuz you're like the in my mind with giving clues in this game is it's all about it's all about action efficiency, really. So, Resource management. Yeah. It's like until you have enough to then spell it out to someone, you tell people what's not useless. Like so, Oh, well, at the beginning the only thing I could give you a clue was fives. Yeah. Um Which are good. But that was it. to them as long as possible, but at some point Which you never got to play. Yeah. Um I knew and I knew the two I was holding. I just didn't know which was which. Right.

One of them Maybe I could play the blue, green, whatever it is. Well, it sucked because your entire hand was the two fives and then you had like twos, twos and threes of colors we didn't have. And it made it even more difficult because she kept getting red. She kept discarding the ones that you needed to have out to play. So, then it was like, "All right, well, Brett's not really playing so Um And then actually there was a point whenever you were like, "Oh, I know what's in my hand." I forgot that there were two fours. So, whenever I was like, "No, that information that one card that was left was the yellow four." And I was like, "No, that's wrong information because like it can't be a yellow." But it it very much was. But obviously I knew that in my head. Oh, she has the two and three. Yeah. So, who cares what it is.

moment. I was like, "You guys know what I have. I don't. Like I Well, that's exactly what I said is that, you know, as soon as you drew this card into your hand, I know exactly what Oh, crap, I can't say that because you don't know you had that card. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, here's here's a question. Do you think that this is a game for a very specific group of people? Because it it it almost like feels like it wants to come off as like like again a family party game, but I don't think it is. to say that this is a game for very analytical people, but I feel like the game would get real hot real fast. Like people getting angry at each other because like again not everybody is the same and and you get a bunch of left brains together and I can't imagine that would be fun. Um but then you get a bunch of silly goofy people together and they're just like ah WHO CARES AND WELL, THIS THIS I'M GOING TO PLAY IT AND IT'S JUST AND IT YEAH, it's just sort of like okay, well then my need four plays the game's over. Yeah.

Yeah. So, I almost say I don't know who this is for because then you mix it up. You're very analytical. I'm very bad at math and ratios as we found out. And I've known it for a long time and then I'm just like sweating bullets trying to be like Yeah. And it's very vague on how much you can help one another. Like realistically the game by rules are you can say two things to one another. And you realistically can't even like process your hand out because that gives out information to other people. Mhm. Um I don't even know is the discard pile open information? Okay. Which is Which is good. I've never played it that way. Um I've also never played it where you're constantly communicating. Usually I play it the almost quiet way, which is why I typically lose.

has just silent tears streaming down their face. Well, I just wanted to make fireworks. Yeah. It's it's a very strange game. I I do like this game quite a bit even though It at one point literally upset my stomach. I was getting very frustrated and and at myself. I mean like I was just just like Well, it's like people also give involuntary facial clues. Like it was funny because the very beginning Like poker. Sure, I guess. the game is I'm figuring out your life. This game is I what are you telling me? I just pulled a card that's either really good or really bad. Well, cuz I think I think you Oh, well Oh, it was you had you had a yellow one and you drew the other yellow one and so that was the face I made. And then at one point you were like, "Oh, I know this card is bad." But then you got rid of the one that I didn't do a facial clue for. You got rid of the other yellow one and I was like Disgusting.

And then in my head I'm like I I gave you a clue on accident. Get rid of that one, not the one that you're like I had probably thought that I did get rid of the one that you made a face at. Probably just mis- mis- shuff- Yeah, so that's why at the end I was like And then you play something and then you're like, "WHAT?" AND I'M LIKE, "I'M NOT EVEN GIVING A FAKE." AND IT WAS LIKE, "NO, YOU LOOK LIKE YOU HATE ME." THIS IS A GAME TO BE PLAYED ON VALIUM. YEAH. YEAH, MAN. Whatever you want to do. Whatever you Okay. So, who's the game for? I'm going to say first of all people with excellent memory skills. Ooh, yeah. Not me. That was another thing is I'm I have a very bad memory and I was like Yeah. I don't really remember what I have. Yeah. And and and people who can organize things like I don't Spatial awareness of what's in their hand, yeah.

Yeah. And I hold my cards in weird ways to remember and I usually do a pretty good job and then every once in a while something goes horribly wrong. Right. You you just like nonchalantly put a card in your hand and then you're and then you're like, "Oh, no. I have" and it's been too long that you're like, "Ah, nope. There's no saving this." So, so the attitude for me would be still the fun like silly party game, but this is definitely more strategic and mechanical. I put in the same vein as The Crew. Yeah. I wouldn't I in terms of clue giving it's it's Codenames. Um but Codenames is still party. It's still a party game. I do not attribute this to a party game. I wouldn't break this out as like, "Hey, let's drink and you know like I I can drink and play Codenames." Yeah. What I'm thinking is the the attitude to approach it with Yeah. is light party.

It doesn't matter if you really do well, Yeah. but the actual gameplay is much more serious and strategic. Yeah. And it depends on your personality. Yeah. You know, like some people get very mad. like-minded. That's how it works best for me because I Like like once again I'm I'm going to hearken back to like Codenames Duet is the only person I've played that game with that I actually have done well with is my friend Steven, but we were on this almost the same wavelength for everything and it worked out. Is there no speed bump? But different types of personalities like even like slightly like type A to type B it's like now we're we're totally thinking different. Yeah. Yeah. Similar to The Crew. Like in my mind oh, I'm giving a hint on this. Yep. And because that's the best hint I can give and then someone's like, "I have no idea why you gave that." You're like Or great. Well, that play just ruined the hand. Yeah.

We can't win now. Yeah, exactly. Oh, [ __ ] I hadn't thought of that. Right. Right. Cuz it's also like Cat was saying it gives you self-doubt whenever it's like this is the best clue I can give. Oh, they didn't get it. Okay, so what's wrong with me? Like why did why did they not get it? Am I You start like hearing the phantom voices of like every time a teacher told you you could do better like Mhm. Compared to like I was going to say like whenever the teacher walks by looks at your test score and then gives up the whole room a clue. "Remember guys?" AND YOU'RE LIKE, "OH, FUCK." OR LIKE THEY'RE THEY'RE HANDING OUT TESTS. Everybody gets theirs face up and she puts yours face down. Mhm. Your teacher handed your test face down, didn't she? What? Which No. No, my tests were not like that. But yeah, I think yeah, good memory skills. our tests. But other than that, you know, similar attitude. They did because we all sucked. Similar attitude, high memories. It's so strange. Um Compared with the the crew though and that's an excellent comparison to make is this is a lot more forgiving of mistakes.

True. It's built in up front that you can throw things out. Yeah. They're not crucial yet, but they're about to be. Yeah, well it's also because The pressure mounts, but it doesn't break. I think the game gets easier Yes. as it goes on. The more information you have. Right. Because then it's like, "Okay, well we got you know, we got two two of the sets completed. So now hey, by the way, you have three whites." Oh. Okay, great. So, that's one clue. Now you can do something and then that person is kind of just set for three turns to kind of buffer. Now I can give a clue. You can give a clue. She can get us one back. So, you kind of have better efficiency that way. Yeah. Um but also the final scoring is just kind of a total. So, it's not as like yeah, you can just outright lose if you just start playing poorly. Yeah. But because it's like, "Oh, we got 18 points. That's good. That's a good fireworks show."

Trash. It's so bad. The theme is fine, but it has nothing to do with the game. No, I know. Um I would have honestly rather had a deck of cards like just numbered like Phase 10 kind of cards and not even worry about this being fireworks. I mean like really you you the the fireworks could just be a decoration. They didn't even have to say this was a game about fireworks. It really is just a color-coded number game. Yeah. Honestly yeah. I would have actually I'd really like a deluxeified very like intricate designed cards. Like they're just super sexy like cards instead of fireworks. I think there is They made Hanabi 2. Really? Yeah, there's a second Hanabi and it's out of print at [ __ ] everywhere. What Hanabi? Um Hanabi 2. The Hanabi Unless that's the tile version that you're thinking of. Maybe. I've never played the tile. That's what you're thinking of. I've never played the tile.

that they both exist. I've never seen the tile. Yeah, I have never I've never played it. I remember there was I think there is a deluxe version of this game. Maybe that's what it is, but yeah. This is the only one I've ever had. Very tiny. I've kept it forever. But but yeah. Um and it does have a bunch of variants. I have played with the rainbow ones um like as a as a sixth suit. It's Just our It's rough. It it's a rough time. I have never played with them as wilds, which I mean And that's why I like these games is is just how you're giving clues is depending on I mean the variants that are coming in or or who you're playing with. Mhm. Um You guys got anything else?

I don't think so. All right. On a scale of 1 to 10 what would you guys give Hanabi? Start with Cat. I'm going to give it a six. Six? Yeah. I was like I started with you cuz I figured yours would be lower. Yeah. Um not only did it give me anxiety, which I don't find enjoyable. find anxiety fun? Um I just didn't vibe with it. Like it just kind of gets less fun every time I play it. Okay. That's interesting. Um Especially with how long it took. Mainly because of me. I will say I took Brett gets mean when he plays Hanabi. He's a mean Hanabi. Oh, does he drink? No. He just MAKES HE WOULD. THAT WOULD BE BETTER. The Brett? Uh I'm nine. Nine? I think it's great and I think it's exactly what it tries to be. Yeah. Yeah. I agree.

I'm not going to go as high as nine. I'm going to give it I'm going to give it four. You did not go high as nine. No. Hanabi is an eight for me. Uh I also sorry. I just know like you should like I don't know. We were joking about how like you should drink instead. I just come home like that. The lights are like some are on some are off and like the Hanabi box is open and like strewn All the cards are strewn out and I'm just like mum- mumbling to myself. Okay, so so it's three. Yellow three. You're here like you you're playing them the video back in the background. It's just on loop. I'm just like clue that I've been giving you. It's just like like I just my board games are ALL STREWN ABOUT. WHERE IS SHE? IT WAS A WHITE ONE. A WHITE ONE. AND I'M JUST LIKE YOU'RE SO STUPID.

YEAH, SO IT'S AN EIGHT. FOR JUST that reason. The abuse potential is really up there. Yeah, it's very very good. Like, "Hey, if you've thought about being abusive, uh here's your excuse." Here's your kick start. People will understand. Yeah, Kickstarter Hanabi, the abusive edition. Oh, there's a little speck of blood. Oh my god. Uh all right. So, that's our thoughts on our our our our That's our thoughts on Hanabi. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching. I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved