Carpe Diem Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everyone today I'm talking about carpe diem which is a 20-18 release by prolific designer Stefan Feld who is kind of unequivocally one of the most renowned euro game designers I tent like everything he puts out this one he's designed is a tile placement gave for two to four players takes about 45 minutes to an hour to play so it's a good kind of change of pace there for a Stefan bailed game because normally they're a bit longer a bit more kind of involved this one is relatively simple in the way it plays because all you're going to do in your turn is you are going to take your little your meeple that's on this rondell of tiles and move the one place and in clockwise or anti-clockwise direction and take a towel and then you're going to put that tile on your board the reasons or what you're trying to do with these tiles is you're trying to basically match up certain types to get certain resources or bonuses you're trying to put them in certain locations - I would trigger endgame scoring because if you say have a certain type of building overlapping a certain point of your grid then you're going to get more points that way and you're also trying to collect these different scrolls which pushes you up the initiative track in order for you to kind of get first dibs on scoring our criteria so the game actually flows our ultra smoothly really quickly as well because I said you just tick along really nicely and just take one tile at a time there's a kind of a good amount of player interaction in terms of snatching tiles that people want because there's not tons and tons of kind of certain types of tiles that come out each time you know they're quite scarce
in in you know when you're gonna get what you want to get the thing I like most about this game is the is the way that the actual scoring works because what's going to happen is on the main board there's going to be this whole grid of cards and all those cards have unique scoring kind of criteria on them and what you're going to do is depending on the initiative order when everybody's finished kind of mopping up all the tiles you've got to take one of your colored markers and put them in an orthogonal position between two of those cards and that means you're going to score and based on the two cards that you're in between so the cool thing is that once someone's gone somewhere the other person go there so only one combination of cards can be scored once so it doesn't mean that the only one type of cards going to be scored once because it can actually be scored four times but the the actual exact combination of the two cards can only be scored once and this is a mechanism that I'd love to see used more it makes that initiative kind of priority so much more important because if you've really focused on something and the other person is almost gone there as well if you're not in the lead they might just snatch that from you and you can't actually score you'd be building towards I really like that tension in this game it works extremely well and as I said I just love to see this it kind of embedded in a more heavy in a more heavy game that being said I'm not taking away from this game being on the lighter side of things I think it's a really nice way it plays so smoothly this place so quickly as I said there
are a few kind of issues I have with it though number one is I think is that kind of a dispute that a lot of people had about this game is that it does look extremely drab an extremely bland the art is very mundane the colors are all very browns and grays it's very very boring to look at now the quality of the kind of tiles that themselves are actually relatively good and I have the kind of the second version in this game which is a slight improvement on the initial version which I think some of the colors were extremely hard to differentiate between in certain types of buildings and the backs of the tiles to kind of separate them into piles and stuff so particularly for like me and you're colorblind you literally couldn't even tell the difference between some of these tiles but yeah the actual visual aspect of the game is not that good at all the symbology and stuff is absolutely fine it's just the actual the kind of artwork is just so drab I also have a kind of a little nitpick as well as that some of the tiles with that all the tiles the way they kind of fit together is quite boring as well there's not like all the interesting shapes and stuff that you get in Carcassonne or something like that you know when there's kind of a there are diagonals and you know they've got half of a certain type here and half one there and you've got to kind of really puzzle them all together this one is very much just here's building here's half a building plug them together and get you bonus so it's a bit more kind of boring in that aspect but to be honest it's it wasn't as much
of a problem as I thought it would be initially looking at it I thought well that looks a bit drab but when you I should get going because you're trying to UM overlap those different grids to get that you know to get the certain types of buildings over certain lines and it actually does work okay some of the bonuses are pretty interesting as well such as if you kind of apply a certain type of building together you get to pick another tile from a face up stack of tile so you can kind of strategize more that way you've got ones that if you build one you get money which is important which I'll explain in a minute you get ones that give you bread which again is very important you've got the different kind of the ones that gather the resources which depends on how big the section is you put together you get that many tiles minus one of that resource so and as I said obviously trying to get those resources because some of the cars might say I'll have X amount of fish or something like that so yeah so the you know the the kind of produce tiles are very simple they're all the same you get your chickens you got your fish and I think you've got your like your corn as well the other buildings as well some of them like let you convert all your goods into money and as I said money's important because money is a wild resource so you can spend one coin as a kind of a dummy or a replica of any type of resources at all in the game bread equally is important because you can use bread as a one piece of bread in order to go anywhere on the rondelle to get any time you want hour or you can use three bits of bread in the scoring phase
in order to claim an objective that you don't have the criteria for so you can score an objective card without having actually what you need to score it and that is kind of where I I lost a bit of interest in this game because it seemed to me that the main strategies that you want to take are collect gold and collect bread and that kind of completely eradicate the whole need of collecting certain types of resources which you're actually trying to do in the first place to score the cards because why not just collect money because then you can score anything you want you're so much more and so on and Lycos with bread who cares if I have a certain type of resources because I can just trade in three bread in order to score any card I want and I understand if those kind of if the coins and bread was so you know were extremely rare and hard to get but they're actually not I found it quite easy to get a lot of money to get a lot of bread and almost for the whole you know almost every game I played of this that's been the absolutely dominating strategy just get your bread get your money and just do what they owe you one and that just completely makes a mockery of the whole card scoring aspect which is as I said my favorite part of the game so I was kind of it yeah I've kind of a bit hit-and-miss on this one I did I do really enjoy it and I do recommend it it's so much fun and it's quick and it's it's a nice turn of pace I love the tension of getting the towels you want I love the initiative order track but yeah I was just a bit deflated at the fact that you could just mitigate what you
need on those cards so much if it was just half as much I would have found this a lot better now that being said I said I don't want to sound like I'm being too negative on this one because it is another really good stuff and failed game and for a tile placement game it does work really nicely said the decisions are there and what you want to get and hope you get before your opponent gets is there because I said there's not that many tiles and you only move your your porn around so many times before the rounds over the rounds really do fly by the different strategies you can take as well you know they're all good but as I said the focusing on the coins and the bad I think is definitely the best part of this game and if someone really kind of ignores that then you can really run away with it mechanisms so pure and so clean literally I said move your guy round pick a tile up put on your board and trying to get the different points that way time frame excellent I mean to play a game or strategy game in 45 minutes to an hour is a really nice a nice time stamp and it does feel really quick as well so a nice satisfying amount of get date gameplay and depth and strategy in this one for the amount of time it takes up time as well absolute fantastic I'm literally next to no AP with this one it does flow very nicely replayability in some ways really good because you've got so many different cards you can put out in different formations of scoring criteria or the different tiles and stuff but at the same time if you're going to focus on
that bread strategy focused focus on the money strategy and it doesn't really matter what card you bring out anyway there's also a circular dimension as well there's another way to score points it's by putting these villas down which you score points based on the amount of chimneys you have on your board at the end of the game and a very kind of simple almost like a set collection style manner where the more you have the bigger the multipliers become and you can score a whole chunk of points that way player interaction in terms of snatching tiles from people is good getting further up the initiative track is good because as I said getting the getting the cards that you want is so important if someone's gone for the same thing because you can really be shut out and just completely shafted on what you wanted to do and end up losing points because you can actually activate a scoring card aesthetically mayor you know I can't I can't really recommend this and the way it looks I mean I actually quite like the way the box looks and the box cover stuff which a lot of people don't like but the actual tiles themselves are so drab and so boring looking which normally doesn't bother me and to be honest it personally doesn't really act as a negative to what for me but I could completely see why someone wouldn't want to play this based on the way it looks because it does look boring and themed as well it's very abstract there's not much theme you're basically trying to make these different you're a little kind of zone of houses and villas and you know farms and stuff like that not much theme there at all and sapaterre downtime not too much of an issue obviously got your tiles sadly I do each round and stuff like that but you know nothing overbearing so yeah
overall obviously I've kind of erred my negatives about it but it still is a game that I enjoy it is still a good game not as good as I thought it would be I thought it really appealed to me I love stuff and failed games I'd really liked our placement games so the idea of kind of a Euro II tile placement game with a felled feel would really did appeal to me especially considering how shorter is and you know it did it did it did hit that kind of culture and I did enjoy it but just that scoring mitigation did bother me a bit you know the fact that it does take such a quick time and it is so light and airy is a massive positive for me and it definitely means I would play it again happily but yeah not quite strong enough to stay in my collection this one I just didn't have to drop me to keep going back to it because of those few little problems I had with it but yeah still a game I would give a good verlag verdict to you know I would maybe recommend it to someone who wants maybe a little more dimensions to it maybe a step above like a Carcassonne or something like that but yeah just a few problems that I had had with it just took it below what I've kind of wanted it to be so yeah but still gets about a 7 out of 10 for me which is a good rating so you know please don't take all these negative comments as a negative reflection in the game because it still gets a good rating for me but for a Stefan field I thought it'd be slightly better so that concludes my review of carpe diem if you have enjoyed it please
hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else I'll see you next time on chairmen of the board bye