Scholars of the South Tigris: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Zack and I are doing a discussion over Scholars of the South Tigress this is the newest game in the South tiger series at the time of this recording and boy oh boy is a South tiger series weird yeah this is weird I you know I figured it out I figured it out so shim we're on a first name basis we hang out all the time exactly uh chemini uh I I imagine when he was designing the uh West Kingdom series he was like he was coming into his own with Architects and he like oh wait I can actually make good Euros with paladins and VI like boom I got it nailed it and then he got really into hard drugs so then he started doing fat lines of coke and then he's like what if I made a game that is that every single action is very Loosely tied together but still very important to each other yeah uh and then I just put it in a different area and call it the South tiger series and it's like Shen please we like go to rehab we like we care about you um and that's where SJ McDonald comes in he was his uh like rehab partner got it and then they designed the series that's my head Cannon anyway because the South tiger series well the games are not bad like they're clearly they're so unique
they're super unique I just don't know if I like them I will say I like this one better than Wayfarers yeah but at the same time I don't know if I like it I like the theme of wayfar is better I like the theme of wayf far better I think think it looks better I mean I personally felt like I almost exclusively had to worry about the tech track just to get resources yeah cuz that's kind kind of how it worked was a lot of the cards that you played basically when you went to sleep you got income based on where you were in Tech Tree so it felt very Tech heavy for me um definitely two players it's a little bit rougher yes uh two players the the deck is thinner uh for the uh uh God I already forgot what they were called the Cal cff the Calif Cal uh yeah the CIF cards or kff cards um the way they're seated it's based off number of players The Guild control is uh basically highly dependent on kind of turn order yeah uh because there as long as you do one action card this is kind of a thing it reminds me of the journal thing where it's kind of like player owned on how fast they want the game to go because honestly if I had like one influence in purple in the purple Guild and I've done an action I might rest right just to maybe maybe it pops up right maybe it pops up and I'm going to
obviously grab the top one for three points right um more players would allow for more contention of Guild control meaning that it's not always up to you know just first player getting y getting the three points but the biggest thing I think and you might agree with me here is is a huge portion of this game and for endgame victory points is something very neat I've never seen this in a game before uh with translation yeah and how you have to hire translators to come down and actually like script out of uh whatever it's it's called I mean the scripts yeah whatever the researches that they're doing they have a transl from some language to Arabic to Arabic so everything goes to Arabic yep in a two-player game uh there's there's too much going on in too short amount of time for that to basically be constantly on upkeep so in a in a multiplayer game it's more people being hired more uh translators coming out more translators retiring meaning they're coming to you making your action economy way better right uh and you're not sitting here going well I really would like that endgame victory card uh well it's Chinese and I there's not a single translator that speaks Chinese that speaks Chinese to translate yep um cuz I I mean the entire game I was eyeing like this one cuz I had a bunch of influence and green and I'm
like perfect that's five points and I'll actually have four there that's ninepoint swing on top of being able to just Place one right in there that's awesome that actually gives me control meaning that it's a 12o swing just from that alone oh wait I need someone who speaks Chinese which means I need an action to go and hire them down here which means I need money and to get money I have to either travel it's like you see you see you see where we're going yeah and I will say that is kind of interesting how they did it um with the translators and stuff because again if it is let's say Chinese it's always a fivepoint card now the card might be valued because they have other objectives on that card once you have it so like I had ones that depend on what level you're Tech gave you extra points yeah so it helped you focus the rest of your game theoretically to go for certain ones yeah um I feel like this is actually a lot more honed in than way fars yeah it does feel more focused and the biggest reason for that is because from the very get-go you actually have a goal card you have a goal card um workers are basically just dice mitigation that's all they are um your your true workers are dice again yes which I think it's probably just going to be the the series dice which again in wfs if you had really just used dice as workers it would work better yeah um and here I actually like the use of workers because nothing felt I mean
things felt tight but it didn't feel like stupid impossible to get money gold was the only thing that I felt was pretty hard to get aggressively um like if you wanted an influx of gold uh yeah but I mean by the end of it I had eight gold um because that was kind of I just okay it's like I don't think I ever had more than three gold anytime um well I mean that's because I was building up for that uh too because I knew it was like oh this the my starting card let me use two gold for that so it's like I actively went on my way and then I had money to turn it into gold but yeah uh throughout the game I think the most I had was four right yeah yeah for AME scoring wise you know knowing the fact that you can at the end of the game two basically four coins was a point is really what it boils down to true and then end the game yeah but in the game because a lot of things do take gold I couldn't like I never had more than three gold ever seeing down in front of me um because basically the only time I would get like go out and seek gold was because I needed to spend on something else yeah but also to be fair that the one track in this particular game that we didn't go for was the orange one and the orange one is how you get gold and I actually really like that I like the fact that each um tree Tech Tree or whatever you want to call these uh is hyper specific like you want to go high on green um that's going you to research other ones to research other ones yeah if but that's going to take some because it's like going up on
green isn't super easy right um but the biggest thing well oh so I was I was commenting on your thing about the workers yeah it wasn't like egregious to go out and get uh but but they did something which may or may not I know they say it in the rule book neither of us are color blind uh I know they used icons and stuff to tell what colors are which uh I still feel like this would be very difficult for color blind players I um I think it's going to be difficult for color bind players because of it's a color wheel so for instance you have primary and secondary colors M okay if you don't have some conceptual understanding that um red and yellow make orange right from understanding some color theory it's going to be rough then to just kind even mentally like start working through and here's the thing whether or not your color blind or not the workers are all one set of Colors oh you're right there is no orange workers there are no green workers or purple workers there's no icons on the workers yeah so if you have color blindness for you know again there's no green so but I know people who are red or blue color blind yep and so that's a problem like honestly this is not a game that is going to be colorblind friendly yeah they do mention it at the very beginning um of the rule book mhm uh so they say now again
neither of us are color blind so we're not playing this from that perspective we're just assuming that it would be difficult right um but it does say primary dice are opaque and secondary dice are translucent right okay yellow and orange dice have black Pips while other colors have white Pips right okay um I know people who are white black color BL that's not true the research track the pass on the map and the three guilds are all ordered in the same sequence yep so purple is always on the left uh each research deck has its own unique icon to represent it um it also worth noting that not everyone is familiar with the color wheel there was a diagram on the last page of the RO book tell players remember the sequence and how primary colors can be mixed to create secondary colors and to be fair one one of the things that I think they did Think through so again even if you look at it yellow plus blue equals green yeah yellow plus red equals orange and so forth so the color wheel idea is all there it's just it's constantly I do think you hit the nail on the head though with the workers though that they're not shaped differently so they're not shap differently and because what's really cool this is something that is also extremely unique uh which is also what leans me to like um Scholars more than Wayfarers is uh that it's like you utilize your workers which is something that's familiar from his other games where it's like you go to the inn and you're drafting those workers Hadrian Wall uses like a bunch of combos of different types of workers to get different workers and different actions right you use these colors to modify these the the shitty white dice
yeah to be like okay I want to take this um translated uh script from the orange Greenhouse okay well I have a yellow worker and I I drew a red Dy because it's it's a Dy bag Builder it's like so I drew you know a red dye so I can use this red and this white um and use the yellow on my white Dy to change it to in Ence for that round that turn a yellow d uh yes so then combining those makes it Orange right that's super cool yeah know it to me that side like The Taking of the color whe using two dice to be able to change it to secondary colors um it also makes the die value instantly to a six so it's not only does it change a color it maxes out that pip value right which I think is also cool because you can use a uh um one just like if I have a red but I really need it to be a 10 value I can use a white Dy and a red dye and bump up my red to a six to make it into a 10 yeah yeah exactly so it's it's something that's extremely fascinating because I can't think of a single game that's not like a party game or that utilizes a color wheel Scoville does oh you're right does he use a color wheel not really well it does it just doesn't describe it call I guess not I guess it does combinations to make well it does primary to secondary and then the secondaries all make black and white and
then it does make clear but so it doesn't describe as a color wheel but it it's using the primary colors for the six Prime peppers yeah that's right you are correct it's been a long time since I've played Scoville yeah um so yeah okay so it has been done it has still uh it's still not done very often it's a very unique idea right uh but I think still this is one of those games and this is just going to be probably a thing with the self tiger series is if you're one of those players that just kind of just wants to be able to do something you're going to either have to just do a lot of slow methodical turns to then be able ble to do one big thing even though nothing in this game or wayf fars feels big right it always felt like okay I just want I just want to take I just want to move up that track right to move up that track I need I like it's like okay one way is to just get a bunch of scripts that have the move up or you know get a value of 10 or higher and two gold well I have the value of 10 or higher I only have one gold how do I get one extra gold it's something over here it's 10 different moves that you have to do exactly um and it's like I I don't know there's something about the these games in this one and Wayfair is that I'm just like annoyed whereas in other games I don't ever feel like annoyed by the fact that I have to do a bunch of little baby steps maybe because it's like it's always building to a big like oh boom I finally got it so most other ones that I
feel like that you have to do baby steps here I feel like I have to make three moves to do the move that I wanted yeah most of the others it's one maybe two moves to get what I need almost always here like you said well I need gold okay that means I have to do move to go get gold but there aren't enough translators out so now I have to go get the translators out that I need to go do it and oh can he get it before I can get it right or if I take it he's already set up to get the card from over there to there that he wants yeah and is going to get bonuses from it right and and and yeah and honestly it almost always feels like every action I take to benefit me also in a bad sense helps my opponents like there are games where a lot of times where like I do an action that benefits you I get better action so like Concordia right you flip over stuff and you make lands more and more valuable for someone to come over and then they flip it so everything they get tons of coins but now everybody's resources are reset and they can go collect those resources again it feels good when you help the opponents with those yeah when you have the actual decision to be like man is that worth it and typically as a player I I will almost always do a decision that will never benefit my opponent regardless of the ability that I get if I get some Mega awesome ability but my opponent gains something it's like hm can I do anything else that doesn't give them anything right and here yeah it's kind of like I getting
these uh script cards feels like getting endgame bonuses and like paladins like recruiting people to be like hey I converted you but here it's like you took a card that's like okay that's worth Four Points yippe uh and maybe an extra two like you had one well it was worth one but it got you an extra two yep uh so it's like that's three points but then and you had to work your ass off to pay a bunch of gold to translate all that to get the card and then I go oh I have four money okay yeah I'll travel and then I'll just boom boom boom pay that there and it's like oh now I get first dibs on the so you four coins you got to put two a spot which is going to help vastly get you control and you got a gold from it right for four coins yeah exactly which coins are easy to get you had basically I had to get I had to dig more out I was like Oh I thought I had I had like 18 coins at one point or something I mean something dumb it took a while for me to burn them through exactly um where as I was over here like I was like I never had really an influx I always kind of had what I needed and then whenever it stalled out it was like well all the all the translators are gone right okay well I don't really want to get any more out right and that was my thing like once I realized that coins were so much easier to get I gu use them and then it was kind of like oh how much should I get in and what goes out and comes in and goes out and it flows nicely yeah and that was it yeah this
game I will say when it ended I was like I you know I I was I was ready for it to end Wayfair is it's like oh it's over just whenever I was getting stuff going that's annoying um but at certain times especially in this game it's kind of the opposite where it's like oh it's still going huh yeah cuz there's not a lot I mean at least with Wayfarers yeah you're kind of like oh man I'm exploring I'm doing all this and here it's like yeah translated some stuff well and that's other thing like you are rewarded for playing more actions on your turn but that's not how you get a ton of resources so I'm like all I want to do is pass so I can get all that stuff but I don't get any of that stuff until I put all those action cards out to get those stuff right why do I care I know I know I I do like the Action System though I like that you play them in certain areas and that if when you're when your hired translators retire which is when they get get enough gold I guess you you keep them and then now you have like a special ability down on that specific action spot I like that and I like the fact that whenever you play a card down it's like okay boom when I rest it kind of reminds me a little bit of endless winter you know whenever the eclipse phase you kept certain cards and eclips to get bonuses right uh it kind of reminded me a little bit about that it's like hm well I never really want to worry about money so I'll really go up on purple yep so that and I'll always play this card right it felt more free to do action like you I I felt
like I had a lot more control versus wayf fars where it's like I don't know and that was the thing like I always played the three same three action cards because those are the three tracks I went up on exactly exactly uh kind of like and it's funny cuz these are color coded it kind of makes me think of like teot walk-on with the colorcoded things where it's like M which ones do I want to go up on well I really would like Coco because I have this Tech that makes Coco wild or whatever it might be um it it had it had similar feeling that I was able to grasp and understand and uh no I'm not saying this game is like oh yeah no you can teach this to anyone no no uh it's still a complex game I still think both of these are more complex than both paladins and Vic counts and definitely more complex than Architects yeah uh just because for some reason the West Kingdom series feels like you were always just getting something and it always made sense with what you were doing like yeah cuz even paladins every time you place something onto the board like filling a spot you got a reward for that and you increased the flag which made it next time easier to do those type of actions exactly and not that not that specific action but one of the other six possible actions MH and so it was like this pretty decent and again Paladin is so great it literally was a folded board like just single full the left hand side of the board was how you get resources the right hand side was how you got point points yeah every single time true
that's all it was yeah that's before he got into the hard drugs and started making weird unique games uh cuz that's the thing is like this game is weird like I wouldn't ever like say it's not bad by any means but it feels like it's two separate games like I want to make a tech tree game in so let's try to build a tech tree game and then but I also like this idea of building pathway type thing where I'm getting this message all the way over here like a delivery game where it has a complex system of how you make that delivery where like a lot of delivery games is like oh it's point A to point B you just have to have enough movement and get there and you go deliver this is like okay this is the delivery game I kind of want remove the tech tree from it right this is the delivery game I want yeah because in in every Euro game like the best way like I just played uh Barcelona day that game was so free to teach and so rewarding on every action you did I mean it's one of those where you have a thing that's like it can go up to 400 points it's just an insane game but in every Euro game it's like the question on everyone's mind is how do I get points right and in this one it's just like well it's not a point salad because you're not getting points just for doing every little thing but you're also not going to get like a big swath of points it's like well you get those from translating right okay well how do I translate right you need to get
Dice and specific color Dice and workers and specific colored workers and you need money and you need uh you need gold right so it's all it's a bunch of like it's 10 different things that eventually boil down into I get to take one card for four points for Four Points uh potentially eight if I got if I had seven recruited people so yeah that to me was my weak spot with it um but the things that it does do I do like MH um but I think it comes down to is it all worth the effort and if if wayf farers was like longer and it was like a set number of rounds and I got to actually get my engine going and feel like I'm like I actually explored and you know the Sea and the land and the stars and all that I'd be like ah fulfillment right but I don't get that it basically blueballs me Scholars on the other hand I don't find fascinating in terms of theme like if you really boil it down it's like wait a minute so all we're doing is just hiring people to translate stuff yep uh okay I mean in this case uh like I got a majority of my points again from the Calif cards right uh just for it going from left to right and I had
influence there and then you had um most my points came from actually getting them translated exactly uh but I mean we had saying is if you actually play the game the way it's supposed to be play you're going to lose you're going to lose cuz and you did wa here's the other thing I've played games where it's like I've won but I had to work my ass off way more than other pie and it's like but I didn't feel I didn't have fun doing that yeah uh and then I mean but the reverse is kind of true it's like I won but I felt like I didn't really do much I'm looking at it I'm like yeah I look at my board I didn't feel like I did very much for the points you do kind of rinse and repeat you do the exact same thing it's not that interesting of a dice it's not of a bag Builder uh they have these white Dice and they have they have they almost want you to um Mill out your white dice but the only thing is like oh in a two-player game you get two points and I don't yeah okay so I was like okay really you just want five you want five white dice in your back and that's it because you'll lose an extra three points yep so just I think you had seven yeah I had seven you had seven white dice I had this many I had a handful 2 4 6 8 10 12 I had 13 I had double that and we both lost the same of points Y which is extremely annoying so I had no incentive to ever Mill it except for the fact that obviously you want the color dice because then you can
just use but here's the thing if you have another engine to get Workers it doesn't matter cuz the white dice are whatever color honestly if you to me the better option is having a way to get colored workers because then my white dice or whatever color I feel like I need that moment not the one I drew that was kind of my thought was so whenever I was like okay man what color do I need okay I need need green well I have oh never mind I have a blue and a and a yellow worker which makes sense so like my entire strategy for it was I need I needed to go up the yellow path which was giving me color die primary color dies so I was like I'm going to go up red because it gives me workers of a you know color so now all those white dice that I have in my bag I have workers to make them into anything I don't need a ton of whites like you just had tons and tons of whites game workers what colors I'm missing I will have a worker to replace that with a white Dy and golden right and a lot of actions are kind of like spend a worker of any color to get a benefit yes and so like our complaint with wafs was there was no way to like kind of seed through cards at least that's here yeah uh you for whenever you do a hire action it's just kind of a you can either hire a translator or you can dispatch them right and it's like huh I need a red I need a red worker right oh well okay I'll just uh I'll just play this card on the there's two recruit actions play that down oh this one just has a five already on it so boom yeah I'll get rid
of that one two money and now I'll get my red yeah and I have a bunch of dice because I took an action earlier that let me draw to yep so again like it's not as restrictive but you still end up feeling like you're doing a lot for a little yeah which some people might like I can see a lot of people liking this game I I feel like I feel like people are going to not like this as much as wayer is though yeah CU I'm going back and forth in my mind on which one's better really yeah yeah I'm still I'm I still think that you know obviously these are brand new so maybe recency bias or whatever but I think the West Kingdom series is still going to completely Edge out this series yeah I think so I'd be very surprised that people are like oh yeah the South Tigers Trilogy obviously there's only two out now uh but it will be a Trilogy like it was already announced a Trilogy um that's how he does this set of games as he does it in Trilogy format yeah uh I will also say that uh they that he brought in the influence system where it's like you place influence on stuff I felt like it mattered way more here I I like the fact that you kind of owned or you hired these translators so it's like oh you want to use my person you pay me a gold or not uh you pay me a coin that felt like it mattered there were very little I mean there only nine or um 15 options total but mainly you're kind of hiring over here that was way more manageable than just kind of being like I get to place an influence out out of 20 yeah
okay I'll place it here oh you have 19 other options to take yeah I guess uh yeah I felt like it mattered like we were kind of avoiding uh what people at least a little more still just kind of like eh yeah I I wish that if you influenc a card and like you got you know it got brought over to there like if you took it okay give me a silver for it mhm but if I got it then it increases wherever it got placed yeah CU that would encourage you almost to try to stop me from doing that that's true um which still benefits me because it would took some reward that I got to do that right otherwise I was like well I just don't want to take that card yeah okay yeah and that was pretty much it what's funny is like every time I have three influence on the cards I wanted and every time I wanted to translate it I was like like okay we have no one who speaks Chinese uh there's that person I don't want to hire him okay so I guess that's that right yeah it's it's weird in this entire these two games where you kind of just don't want to do stuff yeah well you're not it's not rewarding to always do stuff like okay I kind of realize why like if you use my translator you pay me a coin but you still put the gold cuz you might might get like they might retire because of that M well the P you know cuz you have to pay a coin to basically put them under your board yeah if your opponent didn't have a penalty of giving you a coin to do that they could just ruin the people you bought
like oh I really want that guy well I can't afford them anymore CU I have no coins right you at least I always now have a choice if you did that to me to be able to spend the coin that you gave me to be able to use him or take him well that's the other thing is there's literally an action on here that you place gold from like your own Supply onto a translator and that's another way you can kind of be an is like here's your person like that you get to use for free to translate I'm actually going to take this action like let's say I happen to get or you happen to get all the way up to seven oh boom boom now they're retired right so yeah you're going to get two points but that's two points versus you know potential five yeah and it's like oh I wanted to use them sorry it's kind of like the same thing in uh uh brass yeah where it's like oh yeah I know you want to use those resources but I'm actually going to use them yeah you get a benefit it's like rather have the resources it's like I'd rather have the translator here but you somehow I guess pay them off well they got enough gold to just retire and work anymore so yeah like this one who I wanted like I put them over here cuz it's like oh it only cost one gold to get them out here but you get a good benefit it's like oh okay so every time I do this action I get a yellow worker or a yellow die pretty badass y uh slot him down there two points oh wait now I don't have my Hebrew Persian translator right I guess I'll get him out again yep I don't know and I feel like that the
only the Calif cards the last two actions or events put neutral ones out there there there should have been way better ways to get more neutrals out uh so that well I mean there would have been if we actually hit the Third uh or if anyone chose the third if or if anybody chose the third yeah there would have been more um so again I do think this is one of those games where it honestly might need a third or fourth person to play like yes can you play this at two sure yeah should you play this at two it's like Architects should you ever play that game at two right no it is not a game designed for two it's a game designed for in my opinion four um that's my sweetest spot that I've played it at it's at four yeah I've only played at three which is which I understand might sway my opinion of it CU it's I played it two three four and five I think four is the sweet Z five is just it's too long between turns yeah three there's not enough feels like yeah there's one person that's was kind of out of it just bad yeah two is I have so much Freedom there's nothing you can really do to Sol well it's like champions of midgard I made that comparison where at two players it's just like like oh well I'm first player so I'm going to go to the troll shame you so you're going to get a ton of negative points there's nothing you can do about that right whereas as soon as you play that with three or even more it's like okay you're getting shame you're getting shame we're all getting sham so everyone gets negative five points it's the same uh here it kind of
does that with the with the cff where it's like more people are just going to be able to split more people are going to have influence meaning that okay yeah I got three points but now you're actually incentivized to put the translator out for free which means they're out there uh so you're going to have more more special abilities yeah I I agree um so yep it is what it is um on a scale of 1 to 10 were you giving Scholars of the South Tigress seven seven yep you give W fars a seven didn't you yep yeah so you're putting about the same yeah um I am also going to give Scholars a seven I I like it slightly better than wayf farers it felt less I had I felt like I mean just for the sheer amount or sheer fact that I had direction from the get-go versus where it's like I don't know right I don't know oh wait I know what I'm doing oh the game's over yeah here it's like yeah I know what I'm doing I've been doing it the whole game when is the game over that's kind of how this one went yeah so slightly better but I think I'm just going to keep paladins and Vic counts and just have a great time with those that's my opinion I'm just going to keep those be happy uh all right well that's our thoughts on Scholars of the South Tigers let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken
to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time upd is for you