Furnace Review
Transcript
this video is sponsored by skillshare hello capitalism fans i've got some great news for you the holiday is coming what holiday doesn't matter what holiday celebrate whatever you like as long as you keep spending money furnace is a gorgeous board game designed by yvonne larson and published by hobby world and as long as you're buying things for the holiday you might as well get yourself a copy because it's a great board game with barely any rules and despite its appearance is not in fact a lump of coal in furnace you'll take on the role of a capitalist those are not my words the rule will cause them capitalists who acquire new factories use them to convert resources and tussle to see who can eke out the most coins wait a minute efka that sounds like one of those stodgy strategy games named after metals like steel or great western aluminium well you're in luck because furnace is anything but stodgy in fact with some practice you can complete capitalism in just under 30 minutes a game of furnace takes just a scantily four rounds each with two distinct phases in phase one you'll compete with other capitalists to purchase the best factories available and in phase 2 your machines will grind their oily gears to spit out the most valuable materials helene why don't you tell the viewers at home how players will be buying new factories in phase one please effort what do you take me for the proletariat i don't buy things i
simply bid on them like any self-respecting capitalist you won't actually be spending money in this game you'll use it as an obscene yardstick to measure who wins instead you'll get four discs of varying sizes to impose your leverage over other players each bidding phase and number of factory cards based on player count will be dealt to the table each card is something you can win and want to claim because later in phase two you can use each ability on the bottom of the card to convert your resources let's say there's a card that lets me convert to coal into oil two times i'd really like this card as i already have cards that let me make lots of coal and i also have a card that lets me convert oil into money so in that case i would put my maximum capitalism disk on it and then no one can outbid me this auction follows very simple rules i can put my disk on any card as long as it doesn't already have a disk of my color or a disk of the same value one by one players will place these ownership pucks populating an array of cards until none are left at which point everyone with the highest value disc on the card wins it which is where you ask if someone placed a level four disc on a card meaning that they would inevitably win it why would i then place a disc that is lower this is a very good question because it leads us to a delightful mechanism anyone who doesn't win the
card at the end of the bidding round but does have the disc on it will get the consolation price at the top and they will get it a number of times equal to their disc the juicy little secret is that sometimes getting the consolation price is better than getting the card itself elaine putting that level four disc and declaring the card pretty much as her own is the best thing to have happen to me converting two coal into one oil isn't bad but it's not super efficient either yes oil is a rarer resource than coal but i wouldn't want to do that too many times thankfully if i put this free disk on that card i will get to do it as the consolation price exactly three times the more perceptive amongst you might have noticed that this only works if there is already someone's bidding disk that is higher than yours on the card had i just plonked my free on there in the hopes that someone would outbid me the other players would surely shaft me but there is one more complication if there's one thing i've learned as a british it's that exploitation needs to form an orderly queue once everyone has staked their claims then the consolation prizes will be resolved one by one left to right meaning that if you suddenly won the booby prize of converting three iron into three upgrade tokens and you don't actually have a single iron much less three you might have just spent a powerful puck to do diddly squat it's a
delightful oligarchy waltz the rich and the powerful swerving and careening throwing their influence about for petty squabbles there's an array of big prizes and you want more than you can have and since everyone at the table is as mean as you are you can guarantee that they'll take every opportunity to rob you as soon as you become over-ambitious put one somewhere without a disc on and you think i'm never gonna win that but you just never know let me get this right so far we have theft greed exploitation a rhino kinesia style auction and we've only explained half of this game can it get any meaner than that well actually as we all know it's very hard being a capitalist which is why in phase two you get to go on a little holiday whereas the first phase of furnaces bright innovative and interactive the second phase couldn't be more the opposite and it's better for it once you've done the hard labor of acquiring things you now get to enjoy them and what better way to enjoy things than some classic board game resource conversion here you'll take each card that you've acquired in previous bidding rounds and use them to convert resources into other resources better resources or into money which is the end goal of this adventure there is a hierarchy here that becomes very clear once you start tinkering with these cards coal is the most common resource iron is rarer and oil is the hardest to get but as soon as furnace
establishes that hierarchy it lets you have fun by constantly breaking it convert one coal into one oil that sounds like a good deal but the trick is that every card gives you something and has its downsides yes this card will let you convert one coal into oil but it will only let you do it once is that better than a card that lets you convert iron into oil but lets you do it twice who knows it all depends on the array of cards that you've collected crucially by now it doesn't even matter which card is better it's too late to change things you already got these and phase two is purely about taking one type of cube and converting it into another type of cube card by card don't write me a letter i know this is not a cube it's an octagonal prism but my point stands phase two has a veneer of decision making a wispy thin blanket covering up the fact that all you're doing is typing the word execute and pressing enter this might sound like a criticism but it isn't in fact we think this is excellent game design you've already crunched the crunch here is where you just indulge yourself there's something very pleasing about navigating paths of efficiency if i generate five coal i can then spend four of that coal to become oil then the leftover coal can become iron then that iron can become oil then that oil becomes victory points the mouse on these cards is all weird hodgepodge numbers that don't quite add
up i spent five things to get two things to convert into three things and now there's leftovers what do i do with them there's more than one way to skin a coal and finding the optimal solution is the coin at the end of the stick while we're on the subject of sticks here's one that's not stuck in the mud to break up this monotony of efficiency one last puzzle populates phase two which cards do you upgrade the final resource in the hierarchy are upgrade tokens they're perhaps the hardest to get but the most rewarding each of your capitalists start the game with a factory that they already own inheritance it works a starting factory will always give you an upgrade token whenever you activate it it'll also let you convert some resources into coins and then it'll let you spend resources to upgrade tokens to upgrade your cards most importantly this is the only card that you'll ever have that will let you upgrade other cards you'll want to line up all the resources for upgrading before running the starting factory this gets particularly tricky with some cards for example this card lets you convert one iron into an upgrade token meaning you want to run it before your factory card but the upgraded side gives the highest coin output per card in the game meaning you want to run it after your factory card who knew that bits of rich and powerful could be so tiring it's almost like having a real job is there anything in this game to make my
wealth acquisition more palatable well elaine yes what if i told you that yeah in furnace yeah yeah as a variant yeah you could have capitalist superpowers right tony stark did you just mention a marvel character so he would get more views yeah okay what'd you call iron man without suit i don't know what what do you call iron man without a suit tony starkers i think we better go to the next scene there are in fact two variants in furnace each zoozinger play that can sometimes get a bit stale and reintroduce the same puzzle under a new light or at least as much light as pierces the smog the first gives starting abilities that fundamentally break one of furnace's rules but a different rule for each player one player might be able to activate the same factory card twice per round so if i activated this twice i would get six iron instead of free iron that's pretty nice another player might be able to ignore bidding restrictions normally i can't put a disk where there's already a disk of my color now i can do that i also can't put a disk where there's already another player's disk with the same value as mine here once again i can do that and that introduces all kinds of funky complications finally there's even a power that gives you an
extra disc to do more bidding each feels powerful and interesting adds variety and complications it's great when you're getting to grips with the system it provides direction and pushes you down that path but ultimately it's the variant we enjoyed less i'm glad it exists because it's fun to tinker around with and if you're playing furnace for the first or second or third time i recommend you try it out but the core puzzle feels stronger furnace has a tendency to have inconsistent rounds sometimes an array of interesting cards appears anatas battle ensues over who will get what other times it's just a splay of junk and everyone dejectedly pushes the discs on top to just get it over with the capitalist super power variant reinforces this design flaw because pushing you down a path also limits your versatility it's barely noticeable if one round is a bit lackluster for everyone involved you still all have your toys and you're all having fun it's a lot more noticeable if the round is bad for you but more consistently rewarding to other players not to mention that not all of these powers feel particularly even and then there's the more british cues variant which i think is my favorite way to play furnace instead of resolving each card in phase 2 in whatever order you like you now
have to slot in each card in an orderly line as soon as you receive it and then in phase two you can only resolve the cards from left to right i can only attempt to depict the look of horror that was on my face when i realized how this variant worked and i will attempt the depiction now because robbing you of the ability to tinker with this engine feels monstrous not only do you no longer get to figure out your own route to efficiency but it offloads the decision making from the second phase making it feel shallower than it already was to the first phase making it feel crunchier than it already was it makes the design better though reinforcing the strengths of each phase the highs are even higher but snappier too and the lows are more chill relaxed now phase two is just you resolving a single card one by one in a row which is nice you're not worrying about your decisions you're just eating your top hat each new acquisition adds a layer of puzzle that feels right in place right where it should be unless of course you botched it and then you curse yourself for the rest of the game for that one bad placement and that's part of the fun too it seems monstrous only in comparison to the standard mode because you feel what's been taken away from you but actually it just re-jigs things to complement each phase and make them more cohesive which brings us to the last quirk of furnace player count where once again the game feels different based on
how many enemies you have at the table three and four players are much of a muchness but the free player game introduces a funky quirk since there are exactly four rounds and the first player token simply rotates from one person to the next one player gets to be first twice oddly it is the same player on the first round as it is on the last round which can feel a touch and fair because they pretty much get to pick the best resource conversion card on the first round where that is important and then they also get to pick the best resource to points conversion card on the last round where that is once again important it's not a big thing and most of the time it might amount to nothing but i think it highlights the general feel of furnace when percent of the game is bidding a genre that relies on higher play accounts than fifty percent of the game suffers when there aren't more players capitalism is only fun when others play along what of two players then not much in fact to spruce up the bidding a third player is simulated by the roll of a die each bidding turn one disc will be placed wherever the die falls and that's that it's clean simple and perhaps to simulate the chaotic nature of people attached unpredictable and arbitrary i wouldn't purchase furnace to play with just two players but in a pinch it does fine enough to have a nice time ah we
had some good times making fun of capitalism today what i thought you're being earnest no i was being afghan i might have to fight you for that joke there's a preponderance in board games to adapt these pole-faced sincere this is how economy works and it's great settings but i'm not sure that is what's going on in furnace don't get me wrong this game is mostly abstract but i can't help but feel that it might be a bit just a little bit tongue-in-cheek you start the game with a working established business you have to do absolutely nothing for you never need any money in this game for anything yet it is ultimately your goal you spend your entire game shifting well from one corner to another corner you expand your empire but only by the virtue of playing the equally privileged in a silly game and hey yeah this could of course be unintentional this could much like what we discussed in our video about kanban be purely a product of a faithful simulation and you might be right you might be weary of that you might be tired of the endless conveyor belt of industrially draped cardboard satirical or not and i wouldn't blame you for that despite finding humor in the bleakness but set all that aside for a second because i think the actual trouble with this game setting is that it sets expectations it cannot deliver on when
you look at furnace you think you're going to get something like brass or arc right or one of those other similarly dressed top hat simulators when you actually look under the emperor's clothes you find something closer to century spice road again we covered a very long time ago i think if you go in with those expectations finest will delight you it's cleaner leaner and more fun than century or splendor or any other game where you collect resources to convert into other resources to convert into other resources but what if people want something bigger grander and louder than any of them well elaine i will never miss an opportunity to big up our 2017 game of the year sidereal confluence yes you heard me right sure it's nothing like furnace and scope sidereal confluence is a massive strategy game that takes hours involves a large play account and diplomacy negotiation and is only a holiday game in the sense that you're most likely going to end up playing it at board game conventions but that joy of inputting less and or worse things and outputting more and or bigger things is what drives both of them leave that alone that's mine so pick your poison you want big grandiose and crunchy sidereal confluence is most similar to it in terms of what you get out of it you want it light and breezy furnace will let you pour your sweat and tears doing absolutely nothing and still having a grand time winning capitalism but what will it cost 35 pounds
no i meant like will it cost you your soul it'll cost 35 pounds i think we're done here i think we are this video is sponsored by skillshare the online learning community with thousands of inspiring classes i know that everyone in life has this feeling you see something like a cool photo or you hear someone singing or it's a really nicely decorated room and you think to yourself i wish i knew how to do that but i don't even know where to begin well skillshare is where you begin it's the website with thousands of classes on almost any subject great for beginners or anyone wanting to spruce up this skill set i get a bit jealous when i see a youtube video that has a really nice animation because i have no idea what i would even do to animate something after watching libby vanderplug's class animation for illustration adding movement with procreate and photoshop i know not only what i need to do to start i felt like hey this isn't that hard i could give it a go so in the future if you see an open included video with a little doodle you'll know how i got there plus there's subtitles available in spanish french portuguese and german a really nice addition if you'd like to join skillshare well i've got some good news the first 1000 of you to click the link in the description will get a one month free trial of skillshare premium so you can start your creativity today do you want to do you want to play furniture do you want to play furnace so this so okay look this is
a bidding disc right you no you don't eat it you can't no it's not for eating it's forbidding it's for winning capitalism right so this is a four bidding disc which is as you can tell bigger than a free bidding disc yes right and and these are even smaller this is a two and a one right so what you do is you want these factories and what no pay attention pay attention oh you want to come to mom i don't think she wants to listen to the board game explanation oh sh look i made this display and she she stepped all over it