Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tidal Blades 2: Rise of the Unfolders - TCbH Review

Transcript 15:55

Hey everyone, I need to talk about Tidal Blades 2. And the funny thing is is I didn't even intend on covering it for this channel. It just happened to be that after a long period over a year of our fays into Frost Haven and then we played a bunch of Sleeping Gods, our campaign group got a copy of Tidal Blades 2 that wasn't meant for this channel. just one of the members, Mike, friend of the channel, ended up backing the game and we played it. And I expected, for reasons I'll get into in just a moment, not really to think that much of it, but it turned out there's a lot going on in this game that's worth chatting about. In fact, I've been taking notes, which isn't totally unheard of for uh me to take a bunch of notes as I'm playing games for coverage.

But normally I put that into a much tighter, more scripted format for our reviews. I've done these discussion unscripted more open-ended uh reviews particularly for campaign type games and other games that I I wanted to give more of just like a a direct first impression or in this case six impression because we played six scenarios so far and uh you know just kind of give the highlights of what I really like, what I thought was interesting, what I didn't like about the game and then just some final thoughts. If you like this format, great. I I intend to continue doing that for uh more campaign games. In fact, I have a lot to say about Sleeping Gods: Distant Skies and have been thinking about doing this. It just happened to be that Title Blades 2 is the new hotness, so I figured why not put up a video. If you don't like this format, well, also let us know about that, too. And you know what? We're going to continue having our normal scheduled very scripted concise reviews that you've come to know and love the channel for. Hopefully love the channel for. What is Titleblades 2?

Well, to understand this, I think we need to go back to Title Blades 1, which is a game that I backed and owned and then after playing for a little bit, I was like, this this is more filler than killer and ended up getting rid of. It was a competitive kind of worker placement action game that looked like it was taking direct inspiration from the video game ChronoCross. And while the visuals were spectacular, the components were amazing, the game just kind of felt okay. And because of that, I didn't really pay a lot of attention to Title Blades 2, but it just so happened that Mike got a copy and was like, "Hey, let's play this as the the next campaign game that we play." So, the game format is now a cooperative campaign-based tactical miniatures adventure combat game very inspired by Gloom Haven, particularly Gloom Haven: Jaws of the Lion. this game where every player takes on the role of a character who can level up as you play the game.

There's the standard experience point system that allows you to get check boxes to increase your stats or unlock additional cards that go into the combat system. And every character has their own unique little masteries which are similar to Gloom Haven's battle goals except tailored to characters. and they have two different sort of skill trees that they can progress through in these masteries depending on things that they accomplish in an individual game. And that gives some uh flavor and level of acceleration and growth for a character that feels thematic and also tailored to their play style. And that's very cool. Every couple of missions, you end up having an intermission. You go back to a city, you can buy things, you can level up, you can have some town events that may modify your overall campaign structure. Speaking of which, the campaign itself seems very linear so far. We played six scenarios and I think there's only been one opportunity for us to branch into different areas. But I would be surprised if it doesn't eventually have some sort of uh structure that branches out and then comes back in towards the climax, especially with how the game has been presented and leaves room for kind of uh different outcomes to specific scenarios, which let's go ahead and talk about what I think is really cool in

this game. And the the first one of those is that I think the the biggest innovation that this brings to tabletop adventure gaming is multi-tiers of scenario goals. Yeah, this game does have victory and loss conditions. This isn't a failforward type of game. You do have to beat a scenario, but the objectives often have uh different levels of completion where you can either go for just whatever the scenario requires, or you can shoot for getting bonus objectives completed that could be thematic things, but have physical representations in the environment. You're going to move around and collect certain objects. You're going to kill certain enemies. You're going to defend certain characters. you're going to complete it in a certain amount of time.

If you do those, you get cool extra rewards and maybe some additional story moments. That is really cool and something that's well explored in video games, but in tabletop games doesn't come up as often. This allows for certain game design levers that can be pulled and also strategic considerations for you as a player to think about as you're trying to navigate. What is the overall goal? what's going to be the best thing for my team as we try to press forward in this game. And also, I'm trying to complete my own masteries and maybe get these bonus objectives. And inevitably, you're going to have to end up sacrificing on one thing or another. The other thing that I really like that I I think this brings something new to the table is the combat system itself. It's like they were thinking about Gloom Haven going, "Well, this can't just be a visual update to Gloom Haven, Jaws of the Lion, so we have to change the core action system.

They play two cards in a turn. What if we have a system where you have three cards?" Well, we can't just make you play three cards because that would be even more complex and we want this to be a lighter level of complexity. What if you have a tableau and you play a card and then you activate a row or column in this 3x3 grid and any cards that are already in that row or column or the default empty slot abilities get activated. So if you have attacks in there, you can do multiple attacks or combine them into one larger attack. You can upgrade your shields. You can uh give yourself resources that can be spent for free actions. You can do a bunch of different stuff. and your cards that you have are your own character specific deck that gives them a lot of distinct capability and flare. I really like that. And I like that the characters themselves statwise by way of their decks feel pretty substantially different. Some characters are really good at ranged attacks, some are really great at movement. Some are going to be heavy tanks that can endure a lot of attacks and get this uh shield system which is It's very cool the resource management systems in the game of the different combat resources and the the rotating shells that make your shields and your magic points and this reservoir is just very well done. But the cards themselves as you play, if you complete

a row, so you ostensibly have a much more powerful turn because you're activating three cards, then you clear that row. And so the game becomes, how do you play into your 3x3 grid, taking advantage of as much space as possible without sacrificing a row until you really need to do it with a really big action, and then you're building up again for bigger and bigger actions. If you play it smart, you can play a lot of successive turns with meaningful actions. And it gives you a lot of options because you're not defining where a card is put into one of your slots until your character's turn comes up in initiative. But what I really like about this gridbased system, in addition to it just feeling cool to put in your card and feel good about the actions that you took and to build up and have it actually pull off in a meaningful way, is that the game does take advantage of the sort of game design elements that this leaves the opportunity to be played with. As you take damage, you can eventually get to a different tier of where you earn wound cards that end up filling up slots and become dead areas in those slots, representing the continual battle damage as you play the game. And that sucks to have those there and have nothing to do with them. There's also status effects that can come into play that go onto your uh cards that whenever you activate those cards, you also have to activate the status effects from poison and stun.

And you have items that as you play items, then you play them on top of cards and every time you activate the card, you have positive effects. lots of cool interesting things to play with in that environment that makes it a fun puzzle to navigate even independent of everything that's going on in the battle arena. And the last thing that I think is just really worth highlighting here is that again the visuals are spectacular. like the the environments, the personality that the characters exude, the sort of tropical fantasy environment. It looks unlike pretty much anything out there in the tabletop space aside from Tidal Blades 1, except this is a game that I actually want to play.

As far as what doesn't really work for me? First off, the story in this game, just why do so many campaign games have terrible writing? Yeah, some of it is just tone, you know, like it's trying to have almost like a Saturday morning cartoons vibe, but not in a overly self-s serious sort of Pirates of Dark Water way, which would have been totally awesome. this this just ain't it. This the writing feels consistently like I I just want to get through it and that's a huge bummer in a narrative adventure game. I also think that there's a disparity between the uh level of accessibility and intensiveness, the weight of the game when it comes to your characters versus what enemies are doing and the enemy behavior. It feels like there's an attempt again to do something very similar to the fully cooperative card driven system of Gloom Haven, which I think is a noble attempt to have something original happen. But there's just a lot of information going on. It looks busy. uh the boards for tracking enemy health. It just feels like it's going for too much and it could have been dialed back a few notches to make it more fluid uh and a little bit more

in line with the weight of the rest of the game. Lastly, I just feel like the characters, while they're cool in design and in aggregate, you know, like in totality of all of my characters stuff feels cool, there's just not enough direct like personality, passive abilities, cinematic moments of what my character can do with their uh cards, with their effects. Instead, it feels like every character is more or less defined by general tendencies than what their actual fighting style is. And as one last little thing, I would say that like occasionally in the six games that we've played so far, uh there there have been some like tedious scenariobased things uh like jumping mechanics from getting from pillar to pillar in this uh high cliff setting, but it's also kind of convoluted in how you approach it and it just feels bad when you are unsuccessful in it. And I know that was a huge complaint uh for Frost Haven as compared to Gloom Haven that there were much more gimmicky scenarios. I wouldn't say these scenarios are inherently gimmicky, but sometimes there's like one-off rules or specific things that you got to do that are like, nah, this could have been baked into the game a little bit better or been a little bit more predictable. But aside from that,

my overall experience has been very positive with Title Blades 2. So much so that I was like, man, I wish I had gotten Title Blades 2. I mean, granted, I already have way too many games. I don't need to own more games. You probably don't need to own more games, but nonetheless, I'm glad that we have it in our play group and Mike has been part of our campaign group for over a decade at this point. So, I have access to it and I can play more of it. Uh, but I definitely had a little bit of like, oh man, I I'm glad someone got this because I totally would have slept on it. And because of that, it made it so that I wanted to share this with all of you. Overall, my my thoughts on the game are that it's uh really making good on uh what the promise of the visual identity of the first game was. And probably I I think this would be a much more celebrated series at this point if this were the debut of tidal blades as a concept. And I really like that it has taken a lot of the things that were done with uh Jaws of the Lion and Frost Haven and other cooperative games out there uh and distilled it into its own thing that feels weightwise somewhere uh above Gloom Haven Jaws of the Lion but below certainly the main title Gloom Haven

Games um has a completely different visual identity than everything else that's out there uh is uh fun, accessible, exciting, and does it with a ton of style. So, those are our thoughts on Title Blades 2, but I don't know. What do you think? Have you played the game? Have you played the original Title Blades? Were you expecting to like this one? And what do you think of this format? Again, I I don't know. I I don't do a lot of just kind of free form discussion like this, but it's fun and a a great way of kind of talking about these larger concepts campaign games um that I just want to ruminate on for a little bit. Put it in the comments. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for being such an awesome community. You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved