Skip to main content
Loading video...

Paleo's longstanding identity crisis - TCbH Review

Transcript 11:27

In the past 2 months, I've played Paleo 16 times, probably more by the time this video goes live. And admittedly, this is coming years after release where it was celebrated to the point of winning the Kennerspiel in 2021. But unlike fellow nominee that it beat out, The Lost Ruins of Arnak, which has remained firmly in the public consciousness, Paleo hasn't really sustained its buzz. To be fair, even when it was first released and getting attention, it was still just kind of a blip on my radar. I remember hearing some news about it. I remember seeing it to win, but I also recall some scuttle about it, perhaps reactionary scuttle, saying that it was a little too light or esoteric or random. And I just kind of let it filter through. It never made it to my direct attention on a table, and so I never got my hands on it to really experience it. Fast forward to just a couple months ago when I was at a local game shop while on vacation, Lock and Key in Lincoln City, Oregon to be specific. It caught my eye. I read the back of the box. I realized for the first time that it was a cooperative game, which I definitely should have known in advance, and decided to give it a shot, and I'm hooked. So, let's talk about Paleo, why I love it, and why I think it's faced an identity crisis since its release in 2020.

Paleo is, in broad terms, a card-driven cooperative adventure game. Players each represent a small group of early humans who face challenges contained within a deck of cards randomly dealt amongst players each round. Each turn, players simultaneously choose one of the top three cards in their deck, choosing based on the broad category depicted on the back, either certain environments, encounters, or dangers, among other things. Then, they all flip, after which, and order of their choosing, players can either resolve their card using the stats contributed by their group and equipment, or if their card allows, choose to help another player, adding their stats to the other player's group. Resolution ranges from obtaining more resources for the clan, avoiding danger, or pushing to victory, measured by completing the five-piece Man of Cave Painting. Essentially, completing five cultural advancements largely presented through the unique scenario. Important card resolution though, is most positive outcomes require a contribution at time, shedding without looking at a number of cards off the top of your deck, representing opportunities not explored, including taking damage for each red danger card discarded this way. Which, if any of your humans die, or you fail to have enough food to feed the whole community, or meet the scenario's ongoing demands at the end of the round, you get some skulls. Like the cave painting, these accrue, but five triggering failure instead of victory, with the clan falling to despair. The magic of this game is just how well

everything works in concert together. The encounter deck, which is your primary way of experiencing the world around you, is made up of a standard deck of cards, the standard stuff that you might see on any given day, mixed with two sets from each of the modules that you are playing to make up today's scenario. These modules can be mixed and matched freely, though the game has a recommended series that you can play through escalating difficulty, making an overall arc. But, these modules also come with objectives that establish what you're trying to do in the scenario, and the overall danger that you're facing and have to account for at the end of every round, and make up the general flavor of the world as you are playing in this given session, ranging from hunting a pack of mammoths to surviving cold winters to dealing with hostile rival clans or fording a fearsome river.

Sometimes these cards blend right in with the base set, but sometimes there'll be clues added to their back. With each new module, you're facing the great unknown with only the ancestral experience of your prior plays to guide you, but with failure and reattempts, you have the wisdom of your forebearers, your your ancestors from that previous play to help steer you in a direction, which I really dig. The game becomes, well, not easier, per se, but more manageable with the knowledge that can only be obtained through discovery, but repeated play just is guiding you to the specific things you might want to watch out for, but certainly is not making any given scenario easy. And I love, love, love how much theme is able to be conveyed with such little text on any of these cards. One scenario we had to make a choice about whether to eat or avoid poisonous berries, which in turn gave us hallucinations, adding a dream card to our challenge deck that through pursuing eventually led to crafting the chieftain's helmet, a significant stat boost allowing us to face some of the most important threats at hand. Each of these steps is just one part of a breadcrumb trail that could be followed throughout a scenario and is just one part of a possible victory, and the game is loaded with these little storylines

and nuggets that are presented both by the module itself and chance. The fact that you might have the right stats, you might have the right crew, you might have followed the right thread, and you might have the right card flips that just happened to make things work out. And some of that is predetermined within the scenario and some of that can come out of the standard deck or the equipment that you can craft. There are so many thematic threads that make sense within the culmination of your story. But the thing is, at my heart, I'm a strategy gamer and as much as I like rich, complex theme unweaving before me, I love most that the underpinnings of this game are dictated by choices with cold, hard logic. This is the part Paleo seems to struggle the most to communicate or at least for the wider audience to understand. While this has the grand, immersive, and emergent storytelling of adventure games like Eldritch Horror or Arabian Nights or even Dead of Winter, those games play like you're at the mercy of the story, working under the illusion of control but can be entirely derailed on a dime by randomized elements completely outside of your anticipation. That ain't Paleo. From the cards you choose to the resources you prioritize to what tools you craft, you're making decisions about how to proceed with each bit of information informing future cycles

through the deck. While it's not as concrete as definitive strategy games like the Pandemic series or Spirit Island, this is far from the squishy Mad Libs that adventure games are often known for, which can make it a tough sell for purists of either camp. But I'm not a purist and neither are most gamers, I think. Within us are multitudes and even though I tend to lean more towards the concrete end of the strategy versus adventure game spectrum, Paleo hits an imaginative, almost aspirational equilibrium that I'm continually impressed by. The tight balancing act it manages with the quite elegant system. Look, I ain't saying it's minimalistic, but for what it achieves, it does so with efficiency and less baggage than you might expect. I think this is where accusations of it being too light come from.

Your capabilities, whether from tools or crew, boil down to three stats: strength, awareness, and skill. And in one light, the game could be seen as a flip a card and either pass or fail on a skill check based on what you're packing. But aside from hazards, each opportunity presented is based on reason choice,

and your stats, too. You want to be able to hunt mastodons? Well, use campfire to increase your crew, do more foraging for wood and stone to craft spears, and pay attention to what card types might lead to hunts in your scenario. Sometimes a mountain you hope to gain some granite from might turn out to be a rockfall hazard, but the more you play, the more that becomes a manageable risk you can at least try to anticipate. It's for this reason that Paleo is a game that rewards both repeated play and exploration. Unlike so many games whereby five, six, or seven sessions you start to see its limitations, this is one where I continue to appreciate its nuance, further accentuated with the New Beginnings expansion, adding more modules, of course, a more nuanced deck of humans, and a farm board that allows you to capture men and creatures or grow and harvest food, but all at the cost of investment.

Thankfully, fully backwards compatible to every scenario from the base set. So, clearly, I like this game. And it could be that I'm riding on the Stone Age hype train, having just conquered 16 plays of this, but after those 16 plays and a bajillion other plays of other games, I feel like I've done my homework. For me, Paleo manages to be incredibly immersive with surprising, endearing storytelling while relying on the strategic instincts that make me love my favorite games. Victory feels hard-earned and failure feels like it comes at the culmination of several bad choice-based outcomes. Yeah, sometimes things go soup sandwich.

There were a couple hazards in a row that you couldn't have anticipated or you didn't prepare for, but you take that experience and you apply it to the next generation that's re-attempting the scenario and marching forward. I can see why for some that might be a hurdle. Like some desire, some compulsion to have a completely clinical environment where every scenario you can see all the different levers and weigh out your choices and the possible outcomes of all those choices in advance. Which this ain't that game. You'll have to hunt your mammoth elsewhere. Paleo is solidly a venture game, a game about survival and discovery, about humankind's earliest and dangerous steps towards forming some sort of civilization.

And it captures the guile, danger, challenge, and bravery of that endeavor beautifully. And that's our review, but let me know, what's your favorite surprise hit household? Something that you picked up on a whim or maybe you weren't expecting to be that good, but you got it anyway and man, it just crushed all the expectations. Put it in the comments below and as always thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for being such a great audience, and doing all the things that help us grow. No money ever changes hands from publishers to us, so we rely on you for the likes, subscribes, comments, the sharing of these videos, and of course checking out our Patreon. But above all else, just thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved