Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 38:47

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for the great wall uh this will actually be discussion the run-through was for the co-op uh mode um but we we have played this as a competitive and now as a cooperative game and um i don't like either yeah i don't i don't like either mode um co-op was better co-op was better yeah very much so uh because the competitive very much feels um like they wanted to do co-op but for some reason we're probably like well we always make co-op so let's do semi-co-op and it doesn't it doesn't work um and then co-op for me just didn't feel like a complete co-op right like it still wanted you to kind of like not not be against each other you wanted to work but nothing was cohesive really about the cooperative nature of it um because really what they what they did in the co-op was nothing changed except you just can openly discuss what you were doing together but so this game just feels like incomplete on both aspects yep uh so let's talk about the competitive uh sure uh mode a little bit more um i mean i don't i didn't like it as competitive but at least it made sense within the like the mechanics of the

game and like this is a avatar a worker placement game yep and in the competitive it is a overly long work replacement game where you were doing the same actions every single time to attack various horde cards which are really just resource spots um and whoever has the most honor at the end of the game wins right uh i it just it it's it i don't even know where to begin with this one because it just screamed like they wanted to work to go ahead well so a couple things like i have to call a couple complaints so in a co-op game it kind of works so the red spots have to be fully filled before they are activated it makes no sense for that to be right normally in a work replacement game like those red spots would be limiting everybody wants those spots so you limit how many people can go into them right versus you have to fill them to be doing especially like competitive yeah yeah where the green are kind of these general spots so of course everyone can go do it but the premium locations should be but it's the reverse that's weird that is number one yeah um and honestly i'll say that one tweet that they always empty at the end and it's just limiting

would work better yeah that's true yeah because normally the way that the game works is you everyone picks their card and then their cards so they want it to be kind of like a hand management where you try to read your opponents what are they most likely going to do just so you can get a better benefit from it right kind of like a roll through like roll for the galaxy where i'm gonna do this action but i'm a bank people here because i think they're gonna do this action so then i can also do it right kind of what they're wanting here because but really all it is is you just get to place more workers uh you as the active player can fill up an entire spot and you get resources equal to however many workers you have there plus overseers yep um yeah having that as and then the other players get to do something so you're hoping that they also want gold or something so they can put someone there and yeah you can negotiate and be like hey like we can get gold if i put a certain number of people there will you go there and so you can get something but i'll also get or whatever it is but whenever whenever you're like trying to you shouldn't have to try to make a work replacement game with the word you shouldn't have to sorry try to make the worker action spots work in a worker placement game right like like you said oh only a certain number of people can go there like i'm gonna fill that up so i can get what i

need especially if you're wanting to wanting it to be competitive yes but they tried to make this a semi co-op and where it's 75 co-op and then 25 hey i'm actually just gonna [ __ ] you over right now right no real reason oh i see your uh you have an archer build going over there oh i'm gonna take mystic archer because so you don't get it i'm just gonna make it a support person right it it's it's clunky this rule book is dog [ __ ] yeah which is bizarre because tainted grail nemesis uh the edge and this war of mine well this four of mine doesn't really have a rule book uh those those other games are fine like i i mean nemesis is okay is it i thought oh no that's right because this is okay they tried to teach it like as if you were experiencing it like they were telling a story as a rule book yeah it was [ __ ] stupid i do remember that it was all right you could still at least play nemesis and understand what's going on if you were a gamer you could read it maybe once or twice and you would understand that what they were trying to get you to do i remember i forgot yeah because i remember the nemesis it was like johnny is running into the wall he plays a car like it and they tried to make it like you were yeah you're right this rule book is a hundred percent con you don't get to how the game flows until page 10 and that's most that's literally the end of the rulebook yeah so like i understand some games or some rule books want to be like

uh hey here's some key concepts that you understand before reading the rules i get that not here's a bunch of disjointed [ __ ] and then also by the way here's how a round works right it's horrendously bad right uh which makes sense because they even have said themselves they wanted to make a game that they never have before maybe they shouldn't have because you obviously didn't know how to write a rulebook for a game you don't know how to make um yeah so my best like positive note is the components for this game are amazing this game is sexy it's like beautiful like yeah the everything is the artwork is fantastic the you mentioned that the ballistas were historically historically accurate the the the art is uh on the board is amazing um it's not that great of a layout but one of the cool things is like okay so you have work harder i have work hard it's two different art for the different clans yes that's awesome yeah like it's definitely like they they had this artwork and they're like okay let's make a game out of it and then just kind of half-ass a work replacement because it doesn't do anything better like i even like some some major components of hey you can donate resources to to the to the whatever section yep what was it called the warehouse uh you only do one right like oh you get eight you get you know seven nope only one right why not why not be like okay i don't need seven

yeah like why can't i just donate three or four or yeah i have a ton of stuff i mean if you're gonna get honor for it at least be like okay yeah i'll do without these resources other places because then that would make it kind of like you're gaining let's say you could do donate five you get 10 honor okay well now i'm gonna go and use those to build a wall section which is fine because you're still only getting one honor for each of those resources for building the wall section so i'm doubling whatever you got from the resources you spent there right which is fine that's great because i'm using those allowing someone else to get to them and it just benefits the group and it really does because yeah it's the with the wall sections everyone kind of wants to do that because it only further increases the strength of the wall because everyone knows okay well that was about to be breached we're all going to get shamed for it yep so how about we just work together to try and at least defend the wall right uh but then other people can be like no i don't want to do that and then they just put one person on each it's like well i'm not getting shame i'm out there helping yeah it's like i mean technically no you're not you have one spearman guy out there it's it doesn't work as a semi-cooperative most games don't i think i mean the same company i think they hit the nail on the head with nemesis nemesis does work you it's a semi-cooperative um mainly because you you kind of call it as a trailer game which i i can

definitely see um this one it's just it doesn't feel cohesive even though yeah the competitive game you can play it even though it's long and it was need to be like a round shorter at least uh because by the end of it i was like we spent what three hours playing about three hours yeah yeah the first game and by oh because i was looking at like by around like five even by four or five i was like we just what do we do we're just getting the same resources just to put the same soldiers on the same cards and there are a lot of games that are better that still take three hours yeah and listen let's just say it takes three hours eclipse is a better game for three hours worth of my time mm-hmm then this is and all my demonstrations feel good you can play whistle mountain vinnie culture and lost ruins of arnac yes those three fantastic games in three hours in about three hours right maybe a little over maybe those three games oh no they're probably about an hour each probably if everybody everyone knows how to play yeah you had them all set up yeah yeah yeah you probably could in and i mean obviously this game could be played maybe like probably faster but even then all of those have a sense of progression where by the end of the game you didn't feel like like even video culture that's about making wine you didn't feel like oh all i did was

just move grapes around at least i don't yeah uh this one because there's just there's not really that many action spaces four of the spaces are get cheap gold stone or wood so and then we have one to get new action cards yep one to basically say screw everybody else i'm going to go up and go first yeah the t track um and then for what i call in like every pole spot that build soldiers move soldiers build walls get you people get you more workers right uh which layout of the board is i think actually really bad because the all the all the actions are like together except one for some reason it's just over there uh and then in terms of like seeing like horde cards it could be very awkward i mean i have a table that kind of suits it that you can unless well really like you and i were able to always see the horde cards zach when we played like if these towers were here and the struggle yeah it's like oh like what's what's over there in samus when i played over here last time it was super hard for me to see what those cards that's true yeah and then you had the artifact cards that were out and they happened to be closer to me so i'm just so i just had to look over and be like oh yeah those are those were there zach i completely completely forgot yeah uh like and one of those happened to be about having more people but because they were it's just like the board is extremely uh non-user friendly yeah um

the overseers like resources are very tight uh in this game uh not that you need to always have an abundance but definitely in a competitive game anyway uh the overseers are huge to have nothing removes them i will say a positive about the game is there's no [ __ ] you cards there's no like i'm going to kill your overseers i'm going to take your resources there's none of that because the game wanted to be cooperative but for some reason had an aversion to it uh the only thing is you can i call it you can sneak in the soldiers if you know your planet but my orders in the correct spot i can go and take a car out i did that to zach at least twice yeah um where i knew hey we're even so i'll just go up in the t-track to beat the tie yeah yeah that's true um and then that was just going for archers right uh another positive about the game and it's it's actually the it's not really the game like no nothing about the board the cards i love the the cool like uh i want to say engine but combo that you can have just off having a bunch of neat advisors right and that's really thematic like last last night i had the person that her archers could shoot wherever yes and uh she got to activate them multiple times so i was constantly and i had the mystical archers so i was constantly shooting arrows and getting points for it that's thematically cool um and that's

mechanically cool it's the best part of the game yeah by far like but the problem with that there's always a but in this game is to even have something that that's cool it costs so much yeah to get advisors and like i said they're not they're neat but they're not like game breaking like they're all of them i will say are useful and there's no repeats as far as i know there are no repeats um yeah i'm pretty sure they are all completely different now whether or not their abilities are like radically different from one another but like for example we had like the mortician like if i could just i mean it cost it would cost four gold and it's not super easy to get four gold yeah uh like i could have had each time i attack with my my horses i would get three per um supporting archer or support so like if i had like three of those down there that would have been nine so that would have been nine points per horse right my lance master would let me pay a cheat to attack with them again so that's like in one attack i get 18 honor right and then um they were cheaper or they only cost three qi to get with the horse breed and if i got the mortician i got chi if they died if they died would you at that point you almost just sacrificed them because it's not bad expensive to get them back out right no exactly so you can get a really cool combo but probably four

maybe five uh advisors is what you're getting in any given game which isn't bad but it's also not going to win you the game because it's going to be too slow for you to okay well actually you would need three uh 7 12 12 gold to get three more advisors right and it's expensive which is very expensive it's i mean unless you're able to get a overseer max level yep um which once again isn't necessarily impossible because if you play an economy and then you pull it back yeah and then you play your economy again pull it back you're trying to be good but that's three full rounds just to get one overseer in a spot right in the game the last six so you're spending half the game just to get gold yeah i will say and i didn't do it very well this game partially because we have a lot of workers with only two players is spending the resources to them place in overseer right but we were sucking up so much shame like at this point i had five guys left that they had shame underneath them yeah um and part of it was how many times we had to sacrifice people i mean we sacrificed three guys yeah that actually kind of hurts way worse than the competitive version oh no absolutely um like way more even then i'll say like i said i don't like either mode honestly uh co-op was better but i think it was only because the game wanted it

to be co-op right but it's such a punishing co-op and it's a clunky co-op the game is actually really clunky mainly because the rubric doesn't help in any way you have i don't mind the horde cards like as a randomness of coming out that's also a little fiddly for you to not just look at the top one and see where it's coming because it's supposed to be thematic like you don't know you don't know where they're coming so i can't i can be fine with that yeah i don't really mind how these come out yeah because it's like it's like okay well now there's three in here that's eight seven that's but there's nothing competitive or co-op that you can do about that right you're just like okay that's that gonna like i mean yeah if we had a third person like probably he could have come there that would have been a third activation for us to get more workers out well i think what what helped with gone were key resources because like you are both were struggling for gold neither one of us had an overseer on there yeah and then it takes five workers well let's just say we have another player he has five workers to play somewhere on the board yeah and so he's filling up spots and that's where i think because i was trying to figure out why i felt starved in this game for specific resources and i think it was because like when zach was playing we'd both be able to place one worker and we'd normally place them in the same spot yeah and that fills up two spaces and that actually fills up a lot places

for the active player then to finish it off yeah so that's how i felt about it no no i completely agree and i think well because like the way that a two-player game is supposed to work is you have an ai player yeah which is the read clan or whatever um like but the problem with that is it's like you're sitting there and it says oh this can be used with either standard or the co-op sure can doesn't mean you have to yeah so i think it should have said use yeah you like to two player game you must use the the the read clan right um but even then like if people say that in the comments and they're like oh you need the recline to make co-op better it's like but i already don't like the fundamental aspects of co-op and we played it with more than two we played with as what the community says is best with three for competitive and i was like it was too long it was too clunky yeah um uh i don't it just feels like art also in co-op mode or at least with the black powder expansion the siege weapons that like we have the cannon ballista and they were just super [ __ ] stupid to arm yeah you have to build a wall to shoot them once you have to defeat a horde to place a spearman on the tower to shoot them once they're not that good no

like you could shoot them as often as you wanted and pay the resources now i get why you can't like because the ballista was free but um you know what everybody had to do to activate it whether it was a worker you know a clerk or whatever to do it okay fine whatever because what they needed like for those is board modifications like a tile that you overlay that you place a cannon on there and now that's a new work replacement spot right you can go to because i'll say because we put in the horde cards for the black powder and most of them are like blow walls up yeah and so you're like okay i mean because what they do is the wall we get blood that goes into the rest spot right um and some of it was like okay we have to focus on things that kill walls which means you weren't focusing on other things um yeah the towers do really nothing except they're kind of like yeah you have watchmen to be like oh hey i can see the horde okay fire but to me that's a waste because we're taking so much shame so now you're wasting another guy that you can put shame underneath what you use yeah it doesn't add anything no he really doesn't it yeah it's it's a it's a waste of a person right to go up there because i thought this was going to be like the tower like have you ever you probably haven't but have you ever played stronghold yeah oh you have okay fantastic uh stronghold is i mean essentially this but better because it's 1v1 but that has where you can place like

you can place like uh equipment in the towers and put like spearmint in there so it's like walls that they push out and start stabbing yeah that's what i thought this was gonna be which would have been cool yeah because i was like oh man maybe they get like enhanced because they're not out on the battlefield and they just can like freely or it just produces a wound like an archer or whatnot so it's in essence you know honestly if you put orchard like it was archer towers right so it's just another slot for archers to go into or even a spot like because the towers can't be blown up it's a spot for archers but they never die yeah it's only one spot but you can go there and so then everybody's clamoring to get to that which i'm fine with that's right whatever right um i mean because archers are already penalized unless you happen to have the mystic archer because yeah you get honor for them being there but you're also not getting you still get shame you don't get resources you don't get resources you don't get the two on earth that you can claim from hitting half the spots at least if not more yeah um so yeah without the mystic archer the archers aren't very useful you're not getting the full points that you should be versus other soldiers right so i mean i had a particular build that happened to be really good made them really really good because i got a bunch for having on their own because in a competitive game i only benefited because you and zach kept killing things right i just kept picking off the and i'm just like oh yeah man i'm getting like four honor five on her yeah uh oh and now i'm getting and oh i'm gonna attack again like almost at any given

round i was getting like 10 points right from just my archers alone uh and that's the kind of stuff with these cards that make the game cool right but everything else is just so it's so odd it it feels like almost they rushed it they didn't have play testers to be like hey this doesn't really work as a as a semi-co-op i don't understand why i would want to work with these people unless it's fully cooperative oh we'll add a co-op mode it's the same game but you have unrealistic requests yeah so yeah enjoy yeah i think you could make this competitive it would take honestly not even that much tweaking do it yeah like you make the red spots where those are minimum requirements and you just you rearrange like what probably should be the most and gold and stone are gonna be less right oh most of places to go for places to go because wood while being useful is probably the least useful of the resources yeah i mean think everdell like like everedell where it's like all those good resource spots are very limited to go to right uh and it works that way champions does it yeah um oh that's a good one champions made car you haven't seen the exact same spot yeah because here's the other thing is your cards well i kind of like them

i can have eight workers almost none of my cards allow me to play all eight workers you're talking a work replacement game where i'm almost penalized for having to going and buying more workers namely one worker placement game where it penalizes me to go out and have more yeah because usually that's the good thing yeah is you everyone starts with like four and it's like i'm gonna do this thing that gets me my fifth one imperium right another example where having an extra worker is really good because you don't have to pass as quickly right um yeah because i mean the only thing that makes like going down the row is because the way that the areas activate is if there's at least one clerk in a green it has to activate if the reds are full it has to activate yeah and the tea ceremony is really only about what order or the active player gets to decide what order but as soon as it's just like okay i guess i'll do this one first oh you're higher than me okay do oh yeah you're gonna pay 10 resources to build the one wall section i was gonna do right yay exactly um because like most cards because the tactics cards are only for combat right there's nothing you can do where it's like i'm gonna play this that lets me go up on honor first you don't have any event cards that are in your own hand right uh so if that happens because everyone gets a place essentially if you want to maximize all your workers like like let's say i place three of my clerks here and then you get to place

two you're not placing your one there because you want to maximize all your workers so you're gonna go to the tactics spot in the tea ceremony spot just to stall out so that whenever it's your turn next oh you have five workers you can place so now you fill it out right but that doesn't seem efficient really all that does is you just stop me from activating and placing two of mine which is where it doesn't make any sense that that's the way it's done i know no i agree uh it's probably my biggest confusion how this game operates is why that's the way it's played yeah and it's it's interesting because i remember there was a guy on the board game facebook group that he went to he went to a retreat i think and he did like an extensive review over every game he played i think he did on board game geek actually because i clicked on it and i was just saw what games did he play and he ranked him and most of the games he liked i remember he said this one and he was like one of the worst game i played at the retreat right like there's no way i would ever touch this game again and i'm like i was like oh he's probably wrong like awaken realms doesn't make bad games well no not always yeah i mean they're usually this war of mine tainted grail and nemesis are the three games of theirs other my favorites the edge is a subpar skirmish game uh thinking this one i can't think of i can't think of anything else that they've done um oh lords of helles i did not like lords of houses um not a lot of people did

yeah it was uh people online did but they're of course reviewers who need to get paid to say great things the reviewers who didn't get paid didn't like you didn't like it i did play it only at three and it's an area control game so it was all right i know they're doing lords of ragnarok next and i'm like nope i'm good so at the end of the day the co-op or the the competitive is is weird as hell because it's like an area control placement spot for the horde cards the horde cards are random that's fine but then when the horde cards come out everyone has to all of a sudden now scramble to work together but then you don't want to do that right other zach would probably mention negotiation um like he he mentions that he with uh like scythe like they negotiated a lot like do whatever you want house rule games however you want i don't personally house rule um because like i just don't put in the effort like i don't want to stay here and make their game for them like board games aren't a fixer-uppers i paid you 200 something dollars for a complete game and theoretically this rulebook makes it very difficult to learn a simple worker placement yep uh i did not like the black powder expansion i felt the siege engines i felt what we had was significantly weaker than what they had and what they had right especially because they stack right if they cut like imagine if they came out and it could have easily been

three trebuchets right and it's like oh okay yeah thematically that's fine you can they would do that if they're a sieging army they probably have a [ __ ] ton of trebuchets right you know i i've said it multiple times i'll say it again theme doesn't make good game mechanics it's like wow yes they did have three trebuchets i don't want to be i don't want to sit here and be like okay we lost yeah you know i want to have a chance so in the co-op mode like i thought we were doing it all right but once it was kind of like once it was just oh we were getting a bunch of shame because nothing changes it's not like there's a whole nother rule set you still get shame for hordes yep you still get shame for not doing what the emperor wants so it just ramps up so now you're still playing a difficult game because the co-op isn't easy just because everyone's trying to still kill these things doesn't make it any less uh just because we're working together doesn't make them any less uh hard yeah so we'll say again to like the rule book if you need a full half page a fairly large rulebook to just explain the order of steps yeah you have a problem yeah that's true yeah i remember because i had to watch an hour-long robot video after reading this and now because i read it and i was like what do i do like okay so what the hell are clerks oh clerks are your workers

okay yeah and they're just over there also to get more you have to pay gold and gold's already hard to get right so none of the at locations are interesting i don't like to go to uh yeah the co-op mode is a significantly tacked significantly tacked-on idea and hell we didn't even play the what they wanted to do they want you to still pick these like you're competing yeah and then once they're they're revealed we can discuss fog of war i guess because technically gloomhaven does that where you can't talk about specifically sure what cards you're picking even though i don't i don't really do that yeah now i will say the mini quality that you could put this into your dnd match nobody would complain to you oh man yeah like these have a really cool finish on them almost as if they're like sun dropped yeah because they're not like shiny like no uh like most minis uh every clan looks different unless you have an expansion every clan plays the same right you just look different yeah like and i love this type of theme feudal japan is one of my favorite themes beautiful china shore beautiful beautiful asian there we go yeah fuel asia is one of my favorite one of my favorite themes it just works for me one of my d d characters is basically is is a samurai

um like but like you can kind of get into the theme a little bit but then it doesn't make a whole lot of sense whenever it's like hey china is being attacked by a mongol horde oh [ __ ] you like uh i'm gonna try i'm gonna be the bigger clan it's like there won't be clans if you don't help us defend the wall yeah it's like nope nope nope kevin bacon wasn't a footloose it's like why are you so stubborn right and then the competitive game when i because i i don't remember how much i won by like 10 points or whatever it was yeah i look back and i'm like i get i don't know what i did i mean whenever we mapped it out i was like i guess i got a lot of points but i didn't feel like i was really doing anything yeah um and i don't like that i want to be able to look back and be like oh yeah i did this and that was really cool uh really i really want to do that with a cooperative game oh remember whenever we like really strategized um if you want to play a game that the odds are stacked against you and it's very you're already in a hole and you're trying to dig yourself out play co2 second chance it's the exact same where you just not the exact same but obviously that's about climate change and this is ancient great wall but in the terms of concept of how your back is up against the wall as a cooperative game and you have to work your ass off to break even and then start to do better

that is easily it i can't think of anything that this game does better than anyone else um i mean i'm trying to think are there a lot of cooperative work replacements robinson caruso is technically worker placement slash programming um it's really just work replacement it just has an order for what it doesn't right right i'm trying to think they probably are i just don't play them yeah i don't i can't think of a whole lot of i mean granted technically this isn't co-op either uh it's it's semi-co-op which is just maybe that's why it doesn't work maybe just because work replacements are inherently competitive you don't you know really ever i mean kind of because they're supposed to be limited placements for your workers that's the whole point of it yeah that's true so it's going to be competitive it's who can get there first normally for the premium spots yeah best part of the game i think we mentioned was obviously the cool advisors with the i mean you only ever get one general which is fine that's what differentiates you but there's a bunch like to choose from so that's really cool there is a lot of variety a lot of advisors i mean because you had your your build i mean zach had a card tactic build every time he played the tactic he he had ways of getting tactics back played him and then he'd get points for it yours was constantly being able to pull people into the rest and then send them back out right uh and then i just had a

volley of arrows right and that's cool i'd rather play that game like that cool card engine game uh but there's other games out there that do that yep uh i got i got [ __ ] nothing else i genuinely do not like this game so um all right uh on a scale of one to ten i think i'm still gonna go with the four four yeah don't think it works yeah yeah i i agree i actually i do think this is a a below average game slightly below average yeah um co-op i would not give it a five because it's still it feels like attacked on co-op i think i'm gonna keep both of them out of four i was like well let's go we're saying co-ops better but as i was talking about i was like no not really not not really honestly if i were to play it i'd probably play the competitive because that's what the game was designed to do but it's not a good competitive game right honestly i felt like it played better competitively i felt like last night's game was better than this one yeah at least we were able to finish it and have a final score and be like okay we played the game and we're trying to figure out that's just because it was three people versus two or if it really was that it just was not making no put it this way three player game we would have had another request out right

and yeah i mean theoretically we would get to place more workers out and probably wouldn't have struggled so much with resources but that wouldn't have stopped that would have had the i mean because in co-op the plus one is still there yeah so we would have still had way more board cards way more deaths yeah so actually having the plus one with another person here i don't think would have changed yeah that much and i mean to be fair like like that's why i definitely want to bring up that we have played this its intended way competitively and we didn't like either because yeah we did play co-op with only two and didn't include the read clan and people could be like we didn't play with it's like no we played both of their modes and they both suck yeah our grades it's just it's weird go back just i can't wait for iss vanguard yeah that's gonna be their their massive space story driven game so just awaken realm stick to co-op story driven games you guys have their best writing uh yeah um oh man what a what a shame what a shame but i guess a lot of people probably saw this coming like whenever i know a lot of people backed out of the kickstarter whenever it whenever it was on there yep so i don't know it exists i guess yep all right so fours fours across the board yep um

yeah so that's our thoughts on the great wall let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved