Abyss Review
Transcript
welcome to junkets games today I'll be reviewing abyss this is a gorgeous set collection game with an interesting twist on the push your luck mechanic first we'll go over the rules and then I'll jump into my review all right so how do we play abyss on return there are three different options you could choose for your full turns action those are exploring the depths visiting the council and recruiting a lord I'll explain those three things now to explore the depths you first draw the top card from this deck and then offer it to your opponents to see if they want to purchase it from you you don't actually have dibs on this card until everybody's past so player 2 here has one pearl and they could purchase this card if they want to because the first card purchased in a specific turn costs a single pearl the second card to be purchased will cost two pearls and the three cards will cost three etc but both player two and player three are gonna pass on this card because this deck consists of cards ranging from these five different suits from values one to five but there are much more ones than there are five so they both pass on this card now I have the option of taking this card for free or I could draw another card at which point my opponents will again have dibs to try and buy it from me so let's go ahead and do that and so now I drew a four which is not good for me because there are very few fours in this deck and player two is gonna gladly spend one pearl to me in order to take this card now one nice thing is that if player two happen to have more pearls they still would not be able to buy more cards from this round once you grab one card from an opponent on their turn you're out unfortunately for player three here they only have one pearl and the second card to be
purchased in a round is going to cost two pearls so I effectively don't have to worry about my opponents taking good cards from me now so I'm gonna keep drawing all right so this next card here is a monster and this is the only kind of card in this deck that is not the value one through five the way this works is we interact with this monster track over here we see at the beginning of the game this marker starts at the one level when you reveal a monster card you can either fight the monster or you can avoid the monster if you fight the monster then you discard this card and your turn is immediately over and at that point you take rewards equal to the current level of this little token on this track so at the very first level I will be able to take one pearl from the bank or I could take one of these victory point chips and these range in value from two to four victory points for endgame scoring but if I don't want to take this monster because that's not a very good reward for me right now i instead avoid it by discarding the card and then I push this marker up one so the next time a monster comes out it's gonna be a better reward option for the person who drew it so once again let's draw a card so it's a two of seahorse I don't really care about that and nobody can buy it and we got a one of jellyfish that's really not good let's keep pushing our luck okay so at this point I could take this three of shells or I could draw one more card and if I draw one more card it's gonna go onto this spot here and it has a pearl on it now in that spot once a card hits there no ponents even have a shot to take it from me and I am forced to take that card but I get a pearl from the bank for my efforts so let's just do
that draw the final card and I lose so I get a 1 of octopus but I get a single pearl from the bank and I'm pretty unhappy with that turn because player 2 here got way more stuff and it just cost them one pearl before we finish our turn we have to clean up now you don't just discard these cards instead you sort them by their suit value so we got these seashells you put these together you flip them over and you put them on the counsel stack that is associated with that color and I'll explain why that's important right now the second auction you can take for your whole turn is to go to the council and that's really simple all you do is take all the cards from one of these stacks you don't get to look at the cards there you just have to kind of remember the cards that got sorted down or just say hey there's a lot of cards there I'm gonna take them so for a whole action I could just take this stack here look at them and say how cool a 3 and a 1 that's pretty good and my turn is over the third and final option you can do for your whole turn is to recruit one of the Lords on the bottom of the board you can see the numbers on the top left are the victory points that you're going to get for recruiting that Lord at the end of the game and the number on the bottom left is much more important because that is the cost to recruit that Lord now if we look at our hand right now of allies that we acquired through visiting the council and exploring the depths we're gonna spend these cards in order to recruit these Lords though the way it works is you have to hit or exceed the value of the number in the bottom left in order to purchase that Lord however there are also suit restrictions essentially with the colors of the cards we can see with this card right here it has seahorse and then two little white circles this means you have to as part
of your payment have at least one seahorse card and then you must have two other different types of color cards in the payment so there must be three color cards in this payment and then have at least six likewise we can look at this illusionist there are no colored circles so you have to have ten value and they all must be from the purple jellyfish suit so let's say we want to recruit this landlord now we can do this so if we look at the landlord here we see as a 10 a shell and then a single white circle that means we have to use shells and one other color so we can use this three plus one is four five six seven and then we can also spend pearls as a wild essentially to get up to that number you always must have cards equal to these suits that are restricted but you can just fill in gaps with these pearls so this makes ten value we can spend these to the bank and now we have ourselves the landlord there's one more step to this process before we finish our turn and that is we must affiliate an ally from our payment and in that process you simply take the lowest value card which would be this one of seashells here and you put it off to the side and it's gonna hang out with you for the rest of the game these cards here get discarded the way these affiliates work is at the end of the game you're going to get victory points equal to the highest value affiliate for each of the five different suits in the game so you're incentivized to spend cards that have high numbers because the lowest of those numbers is going to get affiliated this is only worth one point but if you could work it so that a four value is your lowest well then that's three more points at the end of the game for you once you've recruited the Lord you're gonna slide the rest of the lords
down but you're not gonna refill this slot here that only happens once this third Lord gets taken so if these both were gone and somebody recruited this then this would reveal these two pearls that player would take two pearls from the bank and then the rest of these slots would get filled in from the deck there's one other way to fill this and however and that is at the beginning of your turn you can always spend one pearl to bring out one Lord and you can do that as many times as you want so it's another way to spend pearls to get more options before you potentially try to buy a Lord before I move on I want to quickly point out a couple more things the first is that this card we just recruited has an ongoing effect we get to gain a pearl during each of our turns there are also cards that have a little air which mean it's a one-time effect the moment you recruit the card and then you don't get to keep activating it lastly many of these cards have keys in the top right corner now what happens is once you get three keys you're going to immediately explore a location and I'll explain that right now there are two ways to get keys in this game the first is to recruit lords and the second is to fight the monster and when it's in a position that actually gives you keys so let's say we just did that we just got ourselves a key we now have three which means we immediately need to explore for a new location we have one that's face-up in front of us already it comes like that the beginning of the game and we now need to look into this deck at one to four more locations the kicker is that any location we pick and we're only going to grab one it's going to be face-up which our opponents could then grab so we don't want to give them too many good opportunities let's just say we grab the top card and we're going to take a look at both of these and choose one this top one gives us two points for each of our merchant Lords which are
these green ones over here plus five and this bottom one gives us two points for each guild that we have at least one Lord in for a maximum of 12 this is currently only worth four points to us and this is worth seven so I'm gonna say we'll leave the abyss out here and somebody else can grab that later and we're going to explore this location when you do that you stick it over the bottom part of all the Lords that have keys that apply to that three level you discard this card right here this means you no longer get that really cool ability that was on the bottom of the card however this is a big way to get picture points at the end of the game the last thing to mention about locations are these ambassador lords which you can recruit they require one of each of the colors in order to make a purchase for them and then they automatically have three keys on them but you don't do a normal exploration with them you simply read the bottom this one says draw three locations place one under your control and then put the other ones available so it's a little bit more of a streamlined location action players will keep taking turns until one of two different endgame conditions are met the first is when on a player's turn they recruit their seventh Lord then every other player is going to get one more turn and then the game is over the other is if during a player's turn they recruit a Lords such that they can't fill that Bank of Lords then that will also initiate the endgame and every other player will get one more turn before we do final scoring each players can have a special affiliation phase where they're going to affiliate the lowest value card from each suit they have in their hand immediately so in this case I would take this true of shellfish put it down here where you can take this four of jellyfish that's great we didn't have any already so that's just four points for us this two of seahorses and then this two of crabs
at this point everybody counts up their points we get victory points again from the value in the top-left corner of each of the Lord's we also add up the victory points that these locations are going to give us based on the different conditions we've met we then look at the highest value of each of these five suits and that is our victory points so it would be four for jellyfish three for seahorses two one and three respectively and finally we get victory points for any of these that monster tokens that we took by fighting the monster track the player with the most victory points wins and pearls are the tiebreaker here for my review of abyss I'm going to explain my thoughts on each item of this list starting at the top and working my way down so let's start with positive number one and that has to do with the integration and interesting twists that push your luck as a mechanic brings to this game let's start with the twist in a standard push your luck game the penalty for pushing your luck too far is you're gonna lose your turn and you're not gonna get any of the stuff that you've potentially acquired throughout that turn as you're rolling dice or drawing cards in this game and abyss you don't have that fear of busting in fact you're always gonna get something on your turn instead you have a fear of an opponent having a better term than you potentially multiple opponents because when you draw those cards they have a chance to buy it from you before you have a chance to even grab it and you know if it's a five of starfish or something like that they're gonna be more than happy to give you one or two pearls to take that car because there are so few of those powerful cards in the deck and it can really kind of pull them into grabbing that amazing Lord before you have a shot to get to it
because remember it's your turn it isn't their turn they can buy the card that they need to get that Lord on your turn so then it gets to their turn and they buy that Lord and you're just really upset you feel like they had a way better turn than you and to a certain extent that's kind of like busting but it isn't quite really this also comes into play with a monster track because when you draw that monster you either get to fight it or pass and if you fight that monster you're gonna get that benefit that's associated with it but you're not going to be getting any cards and you might be like I really need a jellyfish card any jellyfish card but that's what I need so you're gonna pass but that little marker goes down and suddenly the incentive to take the monster the next time it comes up in the deck it's even higher and odds are good it's gonna be one of your opponents that has a shot to get it and that is just not what you're looking for in this game in the final point regarding push your luck is that it's refreshing to see it in a bigger game it seems like most push your luck games or fillers they're very quick they're just a push your luck mechanic with a little bit of frills on top and I feel like this game has push your luck embedded nicely inside a bunch of other mechanics and stuff that's going on and it feels like it really belongs there and it's just enjoyable to see it integrator that way positive number two has to do with how amazing the art and production value of this game is there is just no getting around that it is ridiculously beautiful game it is the first thing that pops out to anybody when they see it on the shelf with that big blick snarling face on the front the fact that there are five different awesome covers to this game and you're not sure which one you're gonna get when you buy it also every
lord looks different and they're beautiful or they're creepy of they're all amazing though and I just love looking at every single part of this game like every single any mini piece is just wonderfully put together is just stunning and I think it adds a lot to the gameplay as well III I think though matically it kind of draws you and you feel like you're underwater everything is thematically connected and I really like that about this game positive number three is how the simple turn decision structure where you pick one of three different things to do on your turn can lead to very low downtime and pretty much constant engagement from everybody around the table if somebody is exploring the depths they're flipping over there those cards and they're they're pushing their luck and everybody else is paying attention because they won't want to jump in and grab one of those cards now if you don't have any pearls that means you're not gonna be able to buy anything on an opponent's turn but that doesn't necessarily mean you're not paying any attention because you want to see what cards come out because you're gonna see them flipped over and sorted into those council stacks and you want to remember oh there might be two three value jellyfish and that one stack and I'm gonna try and grab that if I have the shot to do that on my turn also if somebody decides to take one of those council stacks then their turn is really fast so they just say okay I'm just going to all the jellyfish and their turn is over boom it's the next person's turn so there's no downtime there and finally if you're buying the Lord odds are good you've been thinking about it when it's not your turn you've been planning it maybe for a couple terms in fact you've probably been hoping that your opponent's decide to explore the depths because you might just need one jellyfish it doesn't matter which and
you're just hoping that they flip over jellyfish you can pay him a couple of pearls and you're gonna be able to buy that Lord on your turn which means when it gets to your turn odds are very good boom you're just gonna buy that Lord now occasionally someone's gonna buy the Lord that you wanted to right before your turn and suddenly like oh crap is there anything else I can buy and you might have a slightly slower turn there but on average turns are really quite quick and people are definitely engaged with pretty much everything that's going on and that's a big plus in my book and now for neutral point number one this has to do with how the starting resources per player which is one purl each can lead to a bit of clunkiness in the early game as well as a bit of an unhappy third and fourth player because they definitely seem to be at a disadvantage to the person second player now what I mean by that is this we all start with one purl I'm the starting player I start drawing cards from the top of the stack the person to my left the second player is gonna have first dibs at any of those cards and they can just pay a single pearl to take one so the first good card comes out they take it they give me a pearl I now have two pearls they have zero and the rest of the people have one so I can keep drawing cards and not worry about it nobody else can buy cards on my turn because they don't have enough to afford it they haven't even had a turn now it's the second player's turn they start drawing cards and the third player has first dibs to get one of those cards for a single pearl they might do that the fourth player again cannot buy any secondary cards because the third player had the priority and they still only have one pearl but the kicker to that is I'm the first player I have two pearls I can now jump in and by the second card
that fourth player is really feeling like through a no fault of their own they're kind of out of the game from the beginning because they they just can't jump in because they don't have enough pearls so what I feel like is I feel like they should get more pearls I feel like the first player should get one second player should get two then three then four pearls so that everyone in that first couple rounds of the game can be active they have a chance to get a really good it comes out I feel like that's good for the game as a whole because it means that person who's pushing our luck is continuing to push their luck they don't have to have one card going to me like a screw it I'm just gonna keep on going and hope to get a good thing because nobody else can grab anything and that just doesn't seem right to me also that fourth player and the third player to a little bit lesser extent is probably gonna have less terms of the starting player because this game does not always play the same number of turns it just has an endgame condition and then everybody else takes a turn so I definitely want some incentivization to not be unhappy if you are the third fourth player in this game so I might house rule it I see no reason not to if anything it will just speed the game up a bit by injecting more pearls into the system and while I don't think it breaks this game it's definitely not that big of a deal I think it's something that deserves a little bit of attention neutral number two is pretty simple I was hoping for more engine building in this game when I first read the rules and saw about it online I saw that there were these cards that could have lasting effects that are gonna combine into this and combined into that and when I actually sat down to play the game I realized there really isn't much engine
building here you might have an ability that you're gonna get to use but once you get three keys you immediately have to cover those up with one of the locations now I like that aspect of the game I think it's really cool that just because you have an amazing ability does that mean you're gonna run with it the whole game you're gonna have a decision to make at what point do I cover up that ability to get victory points because I need victory points to win however it means most of the key Lords have that ability that's ongoing and it means you think one and you're getting a second one and that third one you're never even gonna get to use its ability and it's gonna cover up the first two so you're gonna get to a point where you're gonna find yourself just trying to get non key Lords and you're never gonna get a synergistic engine going because you're never gonna have more than two of these abilities active at once the abilities are cool I was just hoping for a little bit more synergizing and cool combos between the different Lords and at the end of the day they just have good abilities that work well by themselves and now my one negative for abyss and that has to do with the victory point monster tokens that are associated with that monster track I just don't like them I kind of don't want them in the game at all I've been thinking about just getting rid of them and trying the game without them because I feel like it over and devises players to cash out on the monster track super early you know one monster will come up and will go down once and the second monster will almost always get cashed in for two of those victory point chips because that's four to eight victory points and eight victory points is quite a lot good good Lords that take a lot of allies will be seven or eight victory points winning scores are usually in the high 80s low 90s so a tenth of your victory points could
come from the second step on this really long monster track board it's just weird now I'm not saying I've never seen it get down into the farther reaches at the bottom but it's been rare it's usually gone one step down and then immediately gone back up again and I don't like how it doesn't add into the decision structure of the game beyond oh four to eight points that's that's a lot I want it to give more pearls and none of these victory points because pearls are interesting pearls you can use to buy cards on other players turns pearls you can use to discount on recruiting lords that is interesting taking the keys from the monster track is also interesting because keys means locations which means victory points which you want but keys also means squashing any potentially good abilities that you spent a bunch of time trying to get so you might not want to take it because of that I just I don't know I might end up trying it without the monster tokens and just saying I that's one extra pearl and each one of those levels and see how it plays because I just don't think those monster tokens add anything that I really want to this game in fact I think it kind of detracts from it an ounce talk replayability this game comes with 35 unique Lords that you can recruit into your domain and their abilities can really change how the game plays each time based off which one's come out for instance the green Lords give a lot of pearls so if many green Lords come out in the early game you know that this game is gonna have a lot of pearls in the system people are gonna be buying cards back and forth from each other a lot versus if there are a lot of seahorses the yellow to come out well those have high victory point values but
no pearls are really no other abilities so that might be a much tighter game because people are not going to be buying things as much because there's a lot less money in circulation and that also goes with all the other suits they add different little hues to the game and how many and when they come out is going to change each and gaming for what I found also there are a bunch of those locations that you can take and every one of those is different as well those are very much going to affect your strategy as you're playing the game because they're gonna tell you stuff you want to do you might take that location that gives you victory points for every green Lord you have well suddenly you really care about getting green Lords there might be another one that gives you victory points for each of the Crabb affiliates you have suddenly you find yourself trying to take crab cards as much as you can and that makes every game play differently I mean obviously you're playing the same game each time but there is quite a bit of different vibes I've seen through different gameplays that I think the replayability is can be very high from this game it's a big thumbs up for me now let's talk player account this game plays two three and four players and I've played each of those and I have to tell you it plays great with all of those player accounts if I was to pick a favorite I would say that four player is the best and that is mainly because there are just more people who can buy cards from you there's just more player interaction to be engaged with in this game and I think that definitely helps the game out quite a bit in a two-player game you only ever have one opponent so the process of pushing your luck is always going to get to the point where they pay you one
pearl take one card and suddenly you don't have to necessarily worry about giving good cards to your opponent anymore because well they can't buy anymore cards and there's no one after them that doesn't mean it doesn't play bad with you in fact it's quite good with two but if you can get four players I would definitely push for that because that is the best setting for this game in conclusion this game hits a whole bunch of points that I really like it as push your luck with very little downtime it's got player interaction without it being mean amazing artwork all this stuff comes together into a great package into a game that I really love I'm very excited to be playing I look forward to playing it a whole bunch and that makes this a very enthusiastic endorsement however I don't normally mention what other people's opinions are of a game that I'm reviewing but this one has been quite polarizing many people have come into it expecting something that might be a little bit deeper maybe a little bit bigger broader longer and they have been disappointed I've seen many people kind of a reaction to this game online mostly my friends have definitely liked it when they played it I think that that is something that you should no going into this that Wow I might be very enthusiastic about endorsing this game and saying that I really like it and I think you should play it you should take a look around and see that there are many people who surprisingly to me have not liked it so much now I did have a couple neutral and negative points in this game that might seem somewhat severe you know I'm actively am thinking about house ruling it because I think that the fourth player is at a big disadvantage and I think that monster track is kind of funky and has some
problems but I don't think that's necessarily detractor to the core gameplay because it really is a great game at its core and if I have to modify a couple things to make myself totally happy with this game I think that is still a very healthy endorsement for it so I love this game and I think you should give it a shot I hope you've enjoyed this video if you'd like to see more like it please subscribe to my youtube channel and thanks for watching