Lord Of The Rings Sauron Expansion Review - 1 Vs All AND modules some great, some Poopy Lollipop
Transcript
Lord of the Rings, the Sauron expansion is the second expansion released for the Lord of the Rings popular cooperative game from Ryder Nitzia. And honestly, for most people, I think some of the components in this game you might as well just chuck out the window as you drive home from the store with the game. And it's a really hard expansion to recommend overall, unfortunately. You might kind of like it. Let's talk about it.
What does that even mean? Powers game corner. Ohoy there YouTube. I'm back again today for another game review and today I'm very excited to be checking out the Lord of the Rings Sauron expansion. This is from Fantasy Flight Games. It takes the original two to five player game and makes it a three to six player game for ages 12 plus. It actually says it adds 30 minutes to the game. However, I don't know if it necessarily does because you probably will be dying earlier with set expansion. So, in this review, what we're going to do is we're going to go over each of the modules bit by bit by bit and give you my thoughts of it as we go on. So, the name of the game is one versus all. That's the big thing this expansion adds as someone is now going to be Sauron and they are going to get this Sauron card right here. At the start of each turn, and by the way, when they say turn, they actually mean the start of each board. So, every time you start one of these boards, Sauron gets to take a turn. Uh, you get to draw one Sauron card or play one Sauron card or play one Naz Ghoul card. Now, there's two types of cards, obviously, as you saw, Naz Ghoul cards and Sauron cards.
Sauron cards are uh going to do stuff as move this horse, which we'll talk about in a second. They're going to make you draw cards or add foes, depending on which style you're playing, move uh down the darkness track, move Sauron, lots of different stuff like that. Give away, you know, your valuable shield. Now horse because this is the big addition to the game, the nauseoul riders because Sauron is going to be controlling these nauseoul riders. They're going to start at 15. At the end of every board, they'll go back to the 15. And anytime you see the horse symbol, that's how many spaces the nasool rider is going to boom boom boom move along the board. Now, what the naschool rider is trying to do is get to whoever is the ring bear for that turn. if they get to the ring bear for that turn. Let's say the ring bear is on six and Froto's they turn around they Sauron first gets to take another turn which he doesn't get a lot of turns in this game uh and then he's racing back and if he gets to Sauron then he will end the game and Sauron will win and that is really really difficult so it adds a whole new way to lose the game with the black rider now coming after you. So, at the beginning of every board, Sauron will get to take one turn, we'll play a card or uh draw a card. Now, the other way that he's introduced into the game is by making it so that instead of rolling the white dye, oop, that's the wrong one.
Rolling the white dye, you're going to give Sauron a turn. And that would be the instead of die roll right here. And pretty much how it works is, uh, you'll wake that person up or get them from the phone, say, "Hey, hey, uh, we need you to do something." And they'll be like, "Oh, yeah, look at the board state." And then they'll be like, "All right, uh, let's see. Is it is it Sam's turn? Is it Froto's turn?" Because Sam's special ability is that he gets to only pick one of the bad things on this card instead of two, which is very useful, right? Cuz, uh, it essentially makes it a lot harder to play these cards on Sam because, you know, like, oh yeah, Sam can move the the horse three spaces. He doesn't care at all because the the the board's about to be over. they make their decision and then they go back to their phone and uh yeah, so that's that's that. You're going to anytime you would be forced to roll a dieice, which are these squares right here, he's going to take a turn instead. These four tiles are also going to get added to your standard tiles with the sword player.
Those aren't the standard tiles. Get out of here. I mean your standard tiles. Those are tiles. Oh god, I don't talk about those tiles. So these are going to get mixed in. Now everything goes into this nice little bag which actually has the Sauron logo on it right there. So these go in with your regular ones. You draw them out as per normal. And that's the gist of the Sauron one versus all edition to the game. There is it's not very fun. Like that's I literally played with my kids and I told them beforehand I was like I don't think you guys are going to want to play a Sauron and you're going to want to play again. And they people thought I was, you know, full of baloney cuz they're like, "Oh yeah, dad just doesn't want, you know, dad doesn't have time to play." I was like, and then they played this game with me as me as Sauron. And and it was it was not fun. Like there was huge massive downtime between your turns, which makes me wonder if uh if Matt Leok from Pandemic fame took that into consideration with the bioteterrorist getting to go every other turn. Uh whereas this one, you know, when you put that board out, he gets to play a card.
Other than that, the the hobbits obviously try and avoid any time giving Sora a turn as they should because that's their only way to play it. So essentially, the the player playing a Saurin is not going to have that much fun with this game. And the other players are going to be going out of their way to make sure they don't have fun. And that that kind of makes it it makes it not fun. And it also makes it incredibly difficult, especially if you decide to mix this in uh with friends and foes, which I would not recommend because the foes on top of the black rider on top of Oh, it's it's just it's not fun. So, the one versus all aspect of the game I think you will try out once or twice. Actually, I take that back. There's one specific group of people I think will absolutely adore this, and that is if you love high score games, like if you're like, "All right, last time we got 74. This time we're going to go uh try and get get past the 74." if that's your jam, especially if you're a solo gamer, like this one might be one that you add to your repertoire for like forever. It's like, oh yeah, I remember I had the friends and foes and the eyes of sworn because I'm going to give it a shout out. I haven't tried it out, but somebody mentioned it in a different video I made. There is a solo uh a module that you can that you can print off from Board Game Geek that someone made a fan made one that allows you to play Sauron as just against like Sauron's part of the game. So someone doesn't have to sit out and play Sauron, right? So yeah, and I don't think you're going to want to add it either because it just makes the game so insanely hard.
It's just it's not fun. Like at no point was I like, "Oh yeah, I think we're going to win this." Like maybe maybe like in Brie when things are going kind of well or like but like by the time I get to Eisenard, it's like no, we're going to lose. It's just how quick are we going to lose in Shalab's layer? Are we going to get lucky? No, probably not. Uh it's just it takes going with this expansion just takes away the possibility of you winning for most people. And that's why this unfortunately is not an expansion that I can recommend. But there's other stuff in this expansion, different modules. So, let's go on to the next module, which are going to be these cards right here. So, these cards, they give you a one time per use special ability. And unfortunately, most of them will uh will be like Sauron related stuff like the Brack Rider does not move, which means that these are only pretty much good if you are playing with the Saurin expansion mixed in where someone plays a Saurin, which once again, you probably won't want to do unless that solo module is great. Like, try that module out.
It's not a solo module, a module that controls form. However, some things that you will want to add in. Let's talk about the good stuff. We've talked about the bad stuff enough. Let's talk about the good stuff, which is these cards right here. here. These two blue cards, which I think you're going to add in every single time, the one ring. The ring bearer may pass the ring to another fellowship player. And you can do this after you've already put the ring on, which means essentially you could put the ring on twice in a round or a board as they call it or whatever. That's huge. And then this one, Sauron moves back three steps on the corruption line. Absolutely massive. Extends the length of the game and you lose the 10 points if you use it. And then we have two new Gandalf cards. Foresight, draw five tiles from bag and display them face up while they remain. Players must choose from the tiles instead of drawing from the bag. And then protection, ignore all consequences of one Sauron or Nazoulool card. Once again, not stuff that you'll be using unless you're using that. Now, my favorite addition to the game though, actually, let's talk about first my least favorite edition of the game and then we'll talk about my most favorite.
So, least favorite are these tiles right here. These tiles are stupid and I don't think you will ever honestly play with them. Like unless you are foolish enough to play with these your first game, I legitimately do not think you will ever want to play with these tiles. This is why this expansion is so hard to recommend at all. Like cuz what this is is you add these into the bag with the regular ones and potentially with the Sauron ones. If you're playing with Sauron, I guess you don't have to. Yeah, I imagine you probably do. No, you don't have to. If you just want to make your game harder, these these could be added in. Uh, which anywh who I just it's you pick the first one out and if you So now this is where it changes from the game. You pick the first tile and then you get to decide do I want to do this tile or I want to go to the next tile which adds a fun aspect of it. But the problem is there's so many of these hard tiles.
There's like 23 or something and they're all bad. Every single one of these is bad. They're like quests and you got to give up cards and you got to give up specific cards and it's just bad bam. Which is not what this game needs. This game doesn't need to be harder, right? Unless you're a high score fanner, it's just frustrating with this expansion. But the thing that you will want, honestly, I think they should just I wish they would have bundled this off in its own little side expansion because this is the thing that you'll add to every single game ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever. And that is the resources, which are these right here. These are really simple to use, too. You get your board. When you get your board out, what you do is you just put two of them blindly over the one, two, or it's one, two, three, four, the fourth spot. in the seventh spot. And then the fourth spot, one, two, three, four. And then uh I guess well, you wouldn't never have it on Shalab's layer because you you wouldn't have it on Shalab's layer, but the fourth and the seventh slot. And then these are good things that happen to you. And you could play it for the good things like they give you the shields or they let you move to white on the track or they give these cool cards like the black riders push back. Well, that one's that one's specifically for Sauron, but you could get rid of that one. Like the red arrow. Active player may add to their hand one feature card displayed from the scenario. Like these are great great great cards that I think you will add every single single single time. Like those legitimately are bangers. If that like if they would have just cut out the whole one versus all and just released a mini box expansion that was just that people would speak belovedly of this expansion and now they don't because all the Sauron dark hard stupidly impossible
stuff is in here. And that makes it like because that's it. That's what we got. You got the two blue cards. You'll add those every single time I think going on in the future. They're fantastic. Check mark. A+. Moving on. Resource cards. Same thing. More strategy, more cards, more chance of you actually surviving. Like like three cards is a huge deal in this game. A+ once again. But then when we get to the na like the just the Sauron expansion itself, it's fun. I want to love it. But it just takes out my like when I play this game, I'm already suspending disbelief that I'm actually going to win. Unless we have the foes. Sometimes when we have the foes in, I'm like, I think we could punch our way to winning. We We never do. But with that expansion mixed in, I just at no point like realistically believe I'm going to win. And it's not because I'm bad at games. It's just because this game's insanely difficult. And now there's someone actively working against me. And really, they have great tools like to work against me. and it just it strips away a lot of the fun, which is a bummer. So, the end of the day, final grade for this expansion out of 10, I'd give it I'd give it a I'd give it a seven and a half. I think I think if your friends and foes one billion% get that one first. I cannot speak to the other one, which by the way, if you have a copy, you want to trade me for something for that, that one's crazy high price on the aftermarket. I'm trying to get a copy so
I can review it and play it. But that one I can't speak to. But this one, I think this is going to be the last expansion you get for this game. And I honestly uh I don't think that anyone most people are going to want to play it unfortunately just because it's just unless you're a solo gamer who loves the high score in which case, yeah, I think this is uh honestly a must own expansion, right? Like if you legitimately like high score games and like yeah, I'm never going to win this game, but there's always the teeny tiny fraction of a chance, then this is a great game to check out. And yeah, this is this gets like a nine out of 10 at that point. But for everybody else, nah. Steer clear. Lord of the Rings Sword expansion. Disappointingly, there's great stuff in here, but I don't think you're going to want everything else, the big stuff to get to it. But let me know in the comments below, what is your favorite Lord of the Rings game of all time? For me personally, the living card game from Fantasy Flight Games. I know they refined it and did like an app version. I've never checked it out. One of these days I will. But the living card game, let me know what's your favorite. And as always, thanks for your time, YouTube. Bye-bye. Oh. Oh, yeah.
And if you enjoy the channel, please consider clicking on the subscribe button or supporting the Patreon for a dollar a month because it really does help support me and my family a lot. Bye-bye. This video is brought to you by all of my amazing Patreon supporters, and I would love it if you would join their ranks and HAVE YOUR NAME IMMORTALIZED in the end of many of my videos for the end of time. But consider for only a dollar a month. And as always, thanks for stopping