Shards of Creation Review - Taking Tricks & Burning Tin
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal.
I'm Zee Garcia.
Today we're taking a look at Brandon Sanderson's, who had nothing to do with the game, Shards of Creation. Hayden Dillard is actually the designer.
Mhm.
But this is based on Brandon Sanderson's Cosmeres Cosmere. Sorry, the Cosmere. Which is his giant universe
Mhm.
that all his books are based in on one of the different planets. So in each of these planets they have a different magic system cuz he excels at world building and building up magic systems. And these magic systems are created by some sort of deity god-like thing. I'm telling you all this because these gods are the suits in this game.
Of course.
And there is probably some theming of that god inherent in the suit's special ability. And therein the theming ends.
Oh.
So if you're a huge Cosmere fan I don't think this is going to
This is a trick-taking game, kids. There's not going to be a lot of theme.
Well, shows how to play it.
To set up the game, you are going to select four or five of these shards, leaving the other ones in the box like this. You're going to shuffle them up, make a deck of that. You're going to take the cards that correspond to their trump cards and shuffle them up in their own deck. And then these are reference cards you can lay out to help you out with that. You are going to be then ready to go. Everybody gets a scoring aid there. You're going to reveal a trump card and then shuffle up and deal to every player 11 cards in this case. This here tells you what the trump suit is, and if there's any special abilities in play for this hand of cards. You're going to be playing three hands, playing 10 tricks each. The last card you don't play out. Uh and you are over those three hands collecting winnings, collecting cards that you'll be scoring at the end of the game. At the end of the game, you are going to check each of these shards you have. Uh, you're going to be getting uh victory points based on how many cards you've collected of each.
So, autonomy over here that happens to be the trump right now. If at the end of the game I end with uh let's say six of those cards, then I am going to get 21 victory points for the set. I'm also going to be scoring complete sets across. So, if I have say uh two of each of these cards at least at the end of the game, then I'm going to be scoring 16 uh points for that. Uh I'm sorry. Uh yeah, two complete sets, each one's eight, so 16 points. It doesn't matter if I have, you know, six of these. If the one I have the least of is uh Odium and I only have two of those, then it's just two complete sets, all right? So, now to begin you pick a random start player. Uh the start player for upcoming hands will be the one that last won a trick in the previous hand, but it won't matter for right now. We just randomly begin. And I am going to play a card from my hand. Now, many of the cards are going to have abilities.
Except well, Honor right here lets you know it has no abilities. And then at the bottom of this reference card is a breakdown of the cards found in that suit. But the other ones have abilities, and so again looking at autonomy here, it says one of the abilities you'll find in some of the cards are you can discard an autonomy card from your hand. If you do, draw a card. And then the other ability, this card's rank has uh plus two for each autonomy card in other players' scoring areas. Okay. Great. So, it also lets me know here that while autonomy is the trump suit that beats other suits, you may not lead with autonomy unless you have no other shard in your hand. Cards, basically. All right, so let's go ahead and make it happen. I'm going to lead with this card.
And then everybody else around the table has to follow suit. So this player is going to play and they will play this one here. Just put them over here like so. And then this player will play. They have to follow with that. Hey, look at that. They have a higher card. And then this player will play and they have one of them. Okay, fine. They have to play that one. That player is going to win. They're going to collect these cards and they'll take one of these and put them in their scoring pile. They can take whichever one they want to. It won't matter too much right now. So let's say they take that. The rest are out. They are going to lead a new trick. Let me find one that has a special ability. They don't really have too many of those. So let's say they lead this card here, cultivation, the nine of cultivation.
It has an ability. The ability says, "Discard up to two cards, then draw that many cards." Okay. So they will do that before the next player even plays. They'll take a look at their hand. Maybe they'll go, "I don't want these two. I'm going to get rid of these two." They'll discard that. They'll draw two new ones. Put that in their hand and then the next player goes. And this player is going to follow. Maybe they'll play that 16, no ability. Then I will go. Maybe I'll do this one. This has the other ability that you might see in cultivation. And it says, "Reveal the top card of the deck. You may discard the revealed card to add its rank to this card or put it back." Fine, reveal it.
It's a 16. I will do that. I will discard this card and now this is an 18. I'm winning. I'm beating that 16. Sweet. And then this player will play. They will play Let's say they'll do this one. Let's them discard two and then draw two. They'll discard two. They'll draw two. That's it. Okay. Now I'm winning cuz I had the high value there. I would take one of these, whatever, put it in my scoring pile, discard the rest. Lead again. This continues until everybody's down to one card. Once we're all down to a single card, you will also add that one to your scoring pile. So you're getting one for free at the end of the hand. And then we shuffle up except for the cards we've all taken.
Those are out of the deck. We reveal a new one. Shuffle up the deck, deal everybody a new hand of cards. So if the second round's trump is ruin, then it says the winner of each trick must choose the card with the lowest rank to place in their scoring area. You don't get a choice. You have to take the one with the lowest rank. And that's because the ruin cards have a bunch of negative ones and they have some end game scoring abilities. The ones with a dark background like this are going to be end game scoring. So if you have this at the end of the game, if this card is in your scoring area, minus two points. Oof. You don't want that. And ruin being trump will force that to happen. So there's some trick avoidance there. You're trying to not win. You know, the ones that have this in it anyway. Uh so there you go. And then a third round in which a new trump will come out. If it says at the end of the round, if one player has fewer cards in their scoring area than any other player, they may steal a card from the scoring area of the player with the most or tied for most. Okay. So this will happen one time at the end of the round. And that's it.
We won't see the last two because the whole game's only three rounds. Uh score your cards, score sets across if you have one of each at least, score that every time. And then the columns based on the uh, the player aid, like I said, right here, which does have a side for two or three players, or a side for four as we are doing now. And then whoever has the highest score in the game is going to be the winner. Don't forget that some of the cards I'm not showing you have obviously more abilities. And then if they have this in dark background ability, it's just some end game scoring stuff, which some of the other suits have as well. So, there you go. That should give you an overview of what's going on. Let's go ahead and go back up top.
I want to say one thing I hate, hate, hate, hate, hate about the layout of this game.
Yeah.
And it drives me nuts, and I can't believe it wasn't caught during play testing, is the special abilities on the cards
Yeah.
are covered up when you splay them in your hand. You cannot see them unless you take them out and look at it and put it back in your hand.
Yeah.
There's no symbols by the numbers to remind you.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
There's nothing, and I would play a card and be like, "Oh, it's a symbol it's a special card." That drives me nuts.
I agree. There should be something They can They can write it where it is, but there should be a symbol by the by the pip, right? To let you know, like, "Hey, this one has a piece of writing on it." Yeah. I agree. I agree.
enough, you would memorize which ones are which.
No, that's not a bad call. I agree with you. Uh, I hadn't thought of it, but you're right. It does have that feeling of like, "Oh, wait, wait. Let me Let me look through them all." Yeah.
There's a lot of oddities in this one. There's a lot of trick-taking games out there as done by our normal trick-taking reviewers.
But, we've also played tons of trick-taking games ourselves.
Yeah.
But, this one has a lot of weird things. Cards are being taken out of circulation.
Yes, cuz you keep them for scoring. Yes, uh-huh.
Right. There's some oddities in how scoring is. And then each god has a weird when the when the god is the Trump suit it has a weird effect on the game.
Right.
Which spoiler, I'm not a huge fan of this game, but I think it has that one too many. For me trick-taking games work really good when you have a twist.
Yeah.
And then you're done.
Right.
This has like three twists and I think that's too many. It's what's the god's power? What's the power on the cards you played? I'm trying to remember who has what cards. Oh, the scoring. Oh, I don't want to win a There's just a lot going on.
Yeah.
But then it doesn't feel strategic on top of that. I don't feel like the choices I make, I mean they matter a bit, but there's just so much chaos that it's like well, am I just playing?
That's a good point. I don't know if I feel like there's a lot of control and I think the game has so much going on that I'm not thinking about how much control I have because I'm thinking of like, oh, I'll play this card and it does this and then I play that and I draw one and discard one and then I manipulate the thing and I'm just trying to collect sets anyway uh for the end game scoring. Um So, I think you're right. It might play a little sort of a little automatically, but there are so many abilities that it didn't stand out. If I think I I think if I played this game with a regular deck of cards and the answer's always like, you have to play this card every time. There's not a lot of options. I would have noticed that feeling more. Um as it is the the you you follow suit in it and you're doing the thing, but the the little abilities are minute enough that I found them to not grind anything to a halt. I think sometimes these kinds of games and we've seen this in the past uh that try to shove a lot of special abilities into one trick-taking game can grind a little bit. They're a little too slow. In this one those abilities on the characters um are pretty easy to parse. Like it it'll be kind of like draw one discard one sort of stuff generally speaking, you know.
And I like that. I think that's cool. It gives you a little pizzazz, a little something. The Trump suit thing is not too much, you know? It's like play the last card this round or pass two. It's not crazy.
I would be very specific if I was picking I would not ever pick this the the suits randomly. I'd be like I don't like this one I don't like this one. One thing that drove me nuts was there's negative cards. Oh, you won and you're going to get a negative point.
Yeah.
Unless you're playing with the one suit that that is full of those cards.
Right.
You're never going to get those negative cards. So it's like a threat that doesn't exist.
It's only if that card is the Trump, the ruins I think it is, the ruin or whatever. It's only if that one is the Trump that you then have to take the lowest card when you win a trick. So it's like otherwise you will never take that one. I mean You're right. It won't apply.
I have a negative card in my hand I need to get rid of that. No, I I don't know it's it's not an issue. That's kind of a weird oddity to me that that's in the game. I mean I know that someone might mention comments well if you do this this this and this. Sure, but I'm saying basically I'm like after a while I was like oh, false threat. I don't need to worry about that. In lots of trick-taking games there's the whole idea of you play to 400 points and sometimes we're playing and I'm like oh Z has 380 and I have 30. That happens in trick-taking games sometimes. It's more exasperating in this one because you can see what's in front of you and definitely when I played there's been usually one person who is just don't got nothing. You know, because you're collect and sometimes you you feel pretty confident. I got this Nope, that special pa
Yeah.
Thanks.
Right. Right. Right. Um yeah, for sure. The scoring in it I thought was a little limp actually. I I I didn't love the scoring. It's just sort of very like for all this other stuff that's going on, you know, powers and abilities and things and manipulation and the concept of these deities being the ones influencing the cosmos what the scoring is kind of like, well, okay, well, you know, it's pretty standard like like larger sets triangular scoring. They get bigger the more you have. Oh, also, get a set across. Really? That's it? And then the bad card that loses you two points or whatever? Okay. Hmm.
Yeah, like I said there's a few things in there I would try to pick the most interesting ones that interacted well together to play with it.
For sure.
Um,
I didn't think any of them were duds, but some of them change the tenor or the change the game.
Like I think chaos.
Yeah.
Is a really interesting I think that's the one the one I we the lowest card wins. That's an interesting
Right. Right.
I would probably always play with that one cuz it makes all the other cards suddenly It
And the suits are irregular in this game, which is like one of those things where I'm like, really did we need to? Okay, I guess kind of sort of, but I don't
Yeah, this one has a 16 13 12. And then you have to like look at the card all the Okay, what cards are in existence?
Sure. Sure. Sure.
that's exasperated again by the cards coming out.
Right. Right. I like I I'm a bigger fan than you of not dealing out a deck.
I love it, but yeah.
doesn't bother me. I like not having the full deck dealt out. And so I actually like that. I actually like that when that you you are removing things from the deck. You're messing it up on purpose. I I like the deck having holes. I'm not a card counter either. And so if you are somebody who every time somebody leads that the 14 of whatever you're like, hold on. I must know if the 13 exists in play. No, you have it in your score pile. Okay, very well. Then that's going to bother you.
Sure. I Positively, I I'm a big Brandon Sanderson fan.
Yeah, yeah, right.
Even though I'm not very knowledgeable about the Cosmere itself. I like the worlds themselves. The Cosmere everything I'm less enthused about because I'm I'm already have trouble keeping track of these characters, let alone cosmic entities.
Right.
I think the art is great.
Yeah.
I really like the stained glass look to the I think it looks good. But I just didn't really like anything else. This is a five out of 10 for me. Um partially it might even be a four, but I brought it up because I like the art a lot. And I don't hate it. It just felt too chaotic for me to enjoy.
Yeah, it's interesting. Uh I'm giving it a seven. I'm not I don't love it, right? I mean, but I liked it. I I like that this has that feeling of it would suffer in someone's repertoire if they are trick-taking aficionados. This is going to suffer in that person's repertoire. I think this is the kind of game you want to have this game as your trick-taking game that you bring out and play with other people that like the Cosmere or just kind of they're okay with playing this one. And so, they know next time you play it next week, you shuffle up and they're like, "Ooh, chaos is in the game this week. Okay." I think this will benefit from that. There are other better trick-taking games, of course, but that's also there's a deluge of trick-taking games right now. Um but the usage of the world, I think, is well done. It's not, you know, particularly thematic, but it's well done. And I I like the look. I like the abilities included here. There's no duds, like I said. Um I enjoy it. The the scoring is kind of one of my bigger pet peeves because I think it's a little it's a little limp. It's a little sort of a non-starter, but um I guess you have to decide a winner somehow. So, yeah, I I enjoyed it.
There you go. Shards of Creation. Check it out if you like Sanderson. This might have really attract you. It's a taking game. I'm Tom.
I'm Zee.
Bye.
Hey, thanks for watching another video here on The Dice Tower. We really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at The Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support The Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. We have links to lots of other things we do down there. So, definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watch us. Tell your friends about The Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vasel and I hope you enjoyed this video.