Skip to main content
Loading video...

Boardgame Designer Diary: Pitching to Publishers Essen Spiel 2015

Transcript 20:31

I'm admin Wales and I maintain a board gaming Vlog on YouTube on my YouTube channel Adams board game Wales um subscribe below if you like this video but this video is not going to be part of that Vlog because in this video I'm talking about um my experiences of pitching to designer uh to to Publishers as as a board game designer now I I made a similar video last year uh and in fact that was a edited together collection of my sort of video diary from Essen 2014 uh I waited a few months to see what would happen over those months and then I put it up on the internet now I'm doing the same thing here and the point about it not being part of my Vlog is because I think this is of specific interest to people who are doing similar things or who aspire to go to these conventions and Pitch to Publishers um to anyone else it's going to be pretty boring because it's basically watching me sitting in a hotel room talking about my thoughts about uh what i' had done that day the people that I'd met the experiences that I'd had and you get a wide variety of different experiences when you meet Publishers um they're all obviously different personalities they've all got massively different budgets and different sizes of booths and so on so you get a very different um reception and some of them like some games and others don't they speak in hyperbole they say this is the greatest game I've ever seen or they say this is the worst game and you'll never sell it to anybody and you get the same thing from two different Publishers within you know half an hour uh so you go in these huge highs and lows as you go through

the fair that's the that's the fun of it it's tiring okay so some of these videos I look a little bit ragged because I've been traping around the massive convention hall and I've been having extreme highs and extreme lows um so I made a video like that in 2015 based on my experiences in 2014 and now what I'm going to show you in this video is my experiences from Essen 2015 current currently it's August 2016 and we're in the runup to Convention season in fact Gen Con is happening right now in the US the biggest US convention and the biggest European convention possibly the biggest board gaming Convention of all SN Spiel happens in October so we've got a few weeks left at this point I need to decide which prototypes am I going to take to Essence Spiel in 2016 and and let the others go by the wayside for a few months because now I really need to be honing those prototypes making sure the rules are right they're written right making sure that the the the Prototype itself looks good making multiple copies and working out I'm going to fit them all in my suitcase to take them off to Essen and then getting the meetings sorted so after I've shown you this video uh I'm going to come back at the end and I'm going to tell you what my experience has been over the months since Essen 2015 um as I say we're approaching a year since then and so there have been some developments um but I'll save those until you've watched my video diary I'm about to set off for day two of the

Spiel fair in Essen in 2015 um I spent the day at the convention yesterday and yesterday I had five meetings um I've brought five prototypes to the fair this year and I have another 12 meetings lined up over the next few days so um yesterday the day started with a meeting with a company that I met with last year um and I came back with some different games which I showed them one of the games they likeed very much and uh and and one of the games last year which they took the Prototype away um i' never received any feedback from this company so it was nice to actually hear what they thought of the game which was basically that they they really like the idea but they' struggled with the rules um so it's nice to know they're still interested in looking at it again they want me to give them another prototype with the simplified rule set and so I'm going to get to work on that um this I found yesterday was a a very different experience with these meetings to what I've had previously in that I was given an awful lot of coffee there there was always coffee and soft drinks and things like this on on on offer which was very nice last year that that didn't happen so much um so I felt very comfortable being taken off into these little booths these little lounges and and sitting and talking through the games the second meeting was with a quite a large company that produces simple games I showed them again my very simple game and uh the guy called over uh his boss um to come and look at it and his boss had a look at it and said we'll sign it said that take it

um on the spot really so um I mean that's that's wonderful obviously I'm I'm waiting on a contract to sign um which they're going to send out to me um so it was very very promising I then showed them another prototype um which they took away a copy of uh and also were very enthusiastic about that and this company was very glowing in their sort of praise which is great they and they were glowing in their praise last year I think they are just very friendly friendly guys but um they seem to be very impressed with the the style of prototypes they seem to like the packaging of my prototypes um and and my general approach which which was very pleasing really then I had a meeting with a um I I guess somebody who would be quite a significant sort of figure in uh board game public ing something very experienced involved with a lot of big companies um and so I had a meeting with him and showed it he only wanted to see one of my protest was very clear it just one of them he was interested in and he'd only had arranged to see 10 people over the course of the whole fair and this was one of them which is a really good start um and uh he really liked it again largely the praise was about the fact that the Prototype really looked very nice and he he felt that my general approach was professional he liked the approach that I taken in the emails and this sort of thing that was sort of really really nice to hear that I I'm approaching things correctly I think um

he did make the point that um he said that a lot of Publishers will tell you that it doesn't matter what the game looks like and he said that's only only sort of true he said it does matter if the game looks nice it's going to be much easier to get people to play it people will have a better time playing it um and so although you know you can have a prototype that doesn't look amazing uh it does help so uh that's good uh I then went to another meeting with a very friendly um publisher who again who I met last year um he was very familiar with me like as if he as if he knew me which was which was really good um and I showed him uh game after quite a we had quite a long conversation about Studio gibli anime films first um then I showed him a game again he really liked it he took the Prototype away I showed him another game which um I did say at the beginning of the meeting I wasn't sure it would fit his line and he agreed it didn't fit his line but he said he thought the game was beautiful he thought it it worked really well he said he selfishly he would like to take away a prototype so he could play it but he said he'd only have to send it back to me so um but he said he was convinced that that game could be published by other um companies so anyway that was day one at the fair obviously hugely positive very very pleased about the potential agreement um with the company does leave me with one slight dilemma in that I have a meeting to show that game to another company today and so I've got

that dilemma of do I go to the meeting do I find a way to cancel a meeting I don't know whether I'm going to be able to find the guy to cancel a meeting I'm not going to stand the guy up and not turn up at all but I'm not really willing to show him the game and pretend that it's still available when it isn't so I think I'm going to have to have a Frank open conversation with this guy but it would be a shame to lose the opportunity to meet um because it's the first time I've come into contact with this company and it's certainly one that I would like to publish for in the future so um that was day one at Spiel day two

today I'm just about to head down to day three of the Essen Spiel Fair um yesterday I had another five meetings so this is my second set of five meetings um started with a company quite a large company um in contrast to the day before this was a much more sort of business-like approach wasn't so friendly wasn't so sort of enthusiastic and actually the games that we played um he didn't really like uh or he he he was he said they didn't you know they didn't fit his line he didn't see anything new or interesting in them he felt um and actually he was more interested in the one that now wasn't available because of the success I had with it the day before so uh so that was a very different field to the meeting not a bad meeting and he was by no means unpleasant or unprofessional just that he was exactly that he was professional rather than sort of uh friendly um then went to another meeting where the man was extremely friendly um and he was very keen on the the dice game Throne um but concerned that they' got a number of dice games lined up over the next year and although thrown is very diff to all those other dice games uh he wasn't sure whether he could continue to produce more and more dice games so that was left as a kind of he's going to go away and look at his marketing strategy and work out where to go from there my third meeting I ended up cancelling I went to the to the meeting and I I spoke to the man um but because the only game I had

to show him was was the one from the day before and ultimately I think um in these situations honesty seems to be the best policy so I went along and I told him he was very pleased and he basically said um if if it falls through get back in touch and he'd be very happy to look at the game again then so that was good um I then had a meeting with a small publisher a sort of Kickstarter type publisher um showed him everything that I had uh that was a very positive meeting um took away prototypes for several well for two of the games but with the prospect of potentially sending all further prototypes at a later point I then had a final meeting with a company that I'm very fond of um and I I I thought two of the games might fit quite well with their sort of range and so I showed it to them and indeed they they they did fit very well um he felt and so um he's taking over there away for testing so I've got rid of a lot of prototypes a lot of prototypes being taken by companies to look at um for all the games except for sunburn at this point um make it snappy obviously still the plan is that that will progress with one company um and we'll see where we are from there so I've got seven meetings still to go I might have a little wander around and see um some of the smaller sort of Publishers um who are doing this sort of Kickstarter type stuff see what that what's going on with those over the next couple of days and

maybe see if I can arrange a couple more things this is the start of day four at Spiel 2015 so yesterday I had um five meetings and today I have two lined up so yesterday was a mixed bag of meetings um I've had the full range uh over this fair from uh having meetings in the little sort of booths where they'll take you off behind a closed door to being taken down long corridors to fancy sort of executive um areas um to having yesterday sort of you know push all the stuff aside on the table and we'll just set up and and play amongst all the customers so I had a couple of those yesterday um and even one yesterday where we would taken down a corridor and we went into this dark Corridor and sat on the cold sort of marble steps and played in the corridor um which was uh unusual amongst all the other sort of experiences that I've had so uh I said it was a mixed bag yesterday um the first um session I played several games with them and it's it's always hard to tell whether it's just somebody's sort of nature or whether it's uh whether it's that they're unenthusiastic um but there was praise in there for the the quality of the designs the guy wasn't you know felt he couldn't see anything new in the games although he did take away a copy of City Rollers to to look at um so I don't have high hopes for that company particularly um the next company was a large German

company um who are you know very excited about potentially working with but they really were very glowing about the G my game Throw um he said that uh it was you know of of the prototypes had' seen over the fair it was the most interesting one he'd seen um and I mean the downside of a big company like that is that it's going to take he said it will take several months and that at each sort of stage at the end of the month I'll get feedback and let them they'll tell me whether I've gone on to the next stage so it's going to be some time before I know whether this is really truly progressing or not um I then had another meeting with another uh big company this time they were interested in sunburn so that was really nice because sunburn has had received less um sort of Interest than some of the other games um over this fair so sunburn now is sitting waiting to be tested by a good company um I then showed uh a game to a small company a sort of upand cominging uh company that have had a couple of big hits recently um again it was sort of push the stuff aside job play on the table guy was lovely um played several of the games and he was interested in sunburn as well so sunburn now sits with him too which is which is fantastic and then finally a meeting with an American company um and we looked at several games and ultimately although they they seem to think the games were good quality um they didn't think it could fit their line because they only really produced either a big box game um and

they said you know City Rollers is too light uh compared to their other big box games so selling it at the same price point people would be disappointed uh or they do a very small box game and they felt this Throne would be too expensive to fit into their two into their small box range so those games didn't didn't fit um and they weren't particularly interested in the other games so that that's it day final day today just two meetings so hopefully I'll have a time to actually play some games today uh and and then I'll be

done so I'm back from the final day at uh the Spiel Fair um I've had two meetings today two formal meetings but I have also wandered around the halls of the fair and talked to many Publishers um from all around the world um who I hadn't really sort of thought about sending games to before just checking how the submissions work for those companies meeting the individuals involved getting business cards that sort of thing and so it's opened up a lot of new avenues I think potentially for me and some of certainly were interested in the sort of games that I was talking about um of the two formal meetings that I had both were very promising one for sunburn one more for City Rollers and ruffling Feathers as well um uh i' also one of the Publishers recognized me from video reviews that i' had done on the internet which was a unusual sort of experience him saying oh I really like your videos and I haven't done a video review actually for a long time so it was quite strange to be recognized recognized twice today which which is a strange experience um and particularly because I've specifically stopped doing reviews because I'm a little concerned that if I do negative reviews that's going to impact on my relationship with Publishers when I come to meet them as a as a designer um so uh it was a very interesting day still again very promising and opened up lots of new avenues hopefully so that brings me to an end of Spiel um I have given the games all five of the games have had a lot of interest um and many many

prototypes given away so hopefully uh I'll be hearing stuff soon from some of those companies but it's just the waiting game now um so that's it for Essen 2015 okay so going way back to Essen 2014 this was my first attempt at showing prototypes to Publishers and I immediately had some um some interest in in the games now that year I only took two games with me one of the games did generate some interest and I even uh um was sent a contract for that game which eventually didn't didn't didn't come through um for for various reasons um over the year then I developed a few more games and I took those last year I took to ESS five games now I had a much more successful sort of year in 2015 in that immediately one of the games was sort of snapped up as you've seen in the video discussion that one uh will be released uh make it snappy will be released by blue orange games at some point over the next year or 18 months I believe I think they have quite a long backlog of games because it's a big uh a big company so I've got a a small Speedy sort of simple card game for all ages uh it's I I like it very much I hope that that that will um come to fruition over the next few months uh I also uh which that the video hasn't mentioned because this happened over the coming months really uh my game ruffling feathers was picked up by brain games so brain games will be releasing my trick-taking game ruffling feathers um and I think that'll

be out probably at nberg in 2017 um and it's it's looking great I've enjoyed you know talking to the company over the last few months and And discussing rules tweaks and and and alterations and looking at the artwork all this sort of stuff it's very very exciting to be working closely with a publisher uh and I'm looking forward to the launch I also had some interest in all of the other games as well all three of the other games that I took in fact one of them came very close I think to to to getting signed you know there was lots of discussion back and forth between myself and the publisher um it was all priced up for components and all this sort of stuff and ultimately I think the publisher needed to make a decision between uh you know a very small number of games and and and mine didn't quite make the cut which was disappointing but also hugely sort of invigorating in that I know that it came close and so I'm Prett this this one I'm sure is going to happen it's just a case of finding the right people at the right time and of course I take on board all the feedback from the various Publishers that I've had and over the last year I've been honing them changing them altering them trying to adapt to what is essentially a changing and growing Market um so that's the position now I have two games which are which are signed I have a a new game which uh I'm I'm definitely going to be taking to Essen this year I I may well have a second new game uh and then I'll take back a couple of those which i' I've shown to various Publishers and try and show them maybe to some more people who haven't I haven't met yet each year I

build on those relationships that I've uh that I've made on previous years so you're starting to feel get a feel for people what they're going to be like what they're going to like and I think they're getting a feel for me as well so um hopefully I'll have another video diary to show you maybe around this sort of time next year um to show you what happened in October 2016 um thank you very much for watching I hope this was of some interest and use to to somebody if you liked it please watch my board gaming Vlog Adam in Wales or Adam's board game Wales uh I'm adam78 on board game geek and on Twitter I'm at boardgame Wales so please come and follow me and please subscribe to my YouTube channel thanks very much for watching all the

best

Progress saved