When do you earn the right to call yourself a successful designer?
Transcript
I received a comment recently telling me that I wasn't successful enough to give game design advice. Apparently, my Dice Tower ratings were too low, and in a later comment, the viewer added, "You're no Martin Wallace." Which is true. For context, here are some of my actual Dice Tower scores, good and bad, and here's a photo of me receiving a game design award from Martin Wallace. It doesn't, of course, mean that I am literally Martin Wallace, but that ambition remains curiously out of grasp. I'm not here to defend my credentials. This channel has chronicled my game design journey since 2014, so I'm sure most of you here know what I am, a part-time designer with a fairly regular pattern of new releases. And what I'm not, which is one of the world's leading game designers. The more interesting part of that viewer's comment is the question that it raises. What does success as a board game designer actually look like? So, my goal with these videos is to provide actionable advice to other designers, perhaps allowing an unpublished designer to bring their first game to market, inspiring a gamer to get a lingering game idea out of their head and onto paper, or perhaps even challenging a published designer to think about things in a slightly different way. I'm not trying to sell an unrealistic vision.
Maybe one day I might be able to produce thumbnails like this. I sold 1 million board games and here's how. How to quit your job and design games. I won the Spiel des Jahres award twice. But alas, for now, I have to keep things a little more measured. So, how about this? I sold more than 100,000 board games. Here's how. How I got a game published. Things I wish I knew back in 2014. Reality is that success is whatever you define it to be. Depending on your definition, almost every designer might be considered wildly successful or a complete failure. There will always be someone selling more copies, getting better reviews, winning more awards, making more money. In my book, The Game Designer Mindset, I wrote a chapter called Comparison Will Only Hold You Back. And here's an excerpt.
You are reading this book, seriously contemplating your craft. Even if you never publish a game or never build a finished prototype, that alone puts you on a very high rung of the game design ladder, the top 1%. So, why compare yourself to the 0.5% who are doing better than you, whatever that means, instead of the 99.5% who are doing worse? Better yet, why compare yourself to anyone at all? Now, I thoroughly enjoy watching The Dice Tower reviews of my own games accepted. And I love reading Board Game Geek comments, too. They inform many of my purchases. It's fun watching games rise up the Board Game Geek Hotness, track which games win awards each year, but there is an issue with rankings and accolades like this. Some critically acclaimed games sell very poorly. The best-selling games in the industry receive mediocre ratings. Many well-respected creators aren't achieving a full-time income from design. Some exceptional designers make one or two great games and then disappear. There is no single target that we're all aiming for. My game ZingerZşam, with a modest rating of 6.1 on Board Game Geek and only 73 ratings, is selling really well in the Baltics and in Taiwan, but it hasn't had significant distribution elsewhere in the world. Zuligans is a logic puzzle, so it doesn't even qualify
for a Board Game Geek page. In my very biased opinion, it's some of the best work I've ever created. My most recent release, Flip Pic Towers, is sitting on a very strong 7.6 rating on Board Game Geek with a lot of really positive feedback from players on Instagram. But the news that the publisher Osprey Games is seeking to sell their game division leaves the game with an uncertain future. Compromath never received a Dice Tower review and it sits around rank 5,000 on Board Game Geek and yet it's one of my best-selling games. If judged solely by reviews or rankings, should it be considered a failure? Regardless of the metric, every one of these games has exceeded my wildest dreams when I started out seriously designing games back in 2014. I could never have imagined the number of games I've managed to produce, the publishers I've worked with, the friends I've made and the wonderful experiences that I've had along the way.
In my book, I list 10 types of board game designer classified by their goals or internal motivations. Some designers are engineers, some are artists, some are entrepreneurs, some are educators. And I also made a video on this topic a couple of years ago if you want to go back and revisit it. So, what are your measures of success as a designer? In my board game designer journal, I ask you to imagine a scale of success from one to three with three being the greatest achievement. Describe how each number would look for you. Success could mean making a physical prototype. It could mean enjoying your own game with your family. It could mean getting a game published. It could mean winning awards. So, what's your ranking?
And once you've identified your three degrees of success, imagine what a four would look like. You've got my permission to be as wildly ambitious as your imagination will allow and you don't, of course, need my permission or Martin's. For thousands of new designers, the dream is to get published, but in my experience, once you've achieved that, you're going to want more. Designing games is addictive. For others, success would mean substantial financial gain, but by this metric, very few designers are successful. Some designers seek critical success, but whose opinion is credible is very subjective. Shut up and sit down, The Dice Tower, No Rolls Barred all have large numbers of subscribers, but I know from my own channel that this is a pretty poor measure of channel performance or importance. Reviewers and hobbyists often value different things from casual players, which is why critical acclaim and commercial success don't always go hand in hand, especially at the lighter end of the gaming spectrum. Similarly, for awards, the only one which has a major impact on sales is the Spiel des Jahres, but it's an annual German award, and as such, breadth of distribution and timing of release plays a big part in which games are eligible. We cannot deny our human nature. It's natural to look at our peers and measure ourselves against their achievements, but we're also remarkably good at moving those goalposts. When we achieve something, we
immediately notice someone who's achieved more. When our skills improve, we quietly redefine who our peers even are, and never in our own favor. The only comparison that matters is against your own past self. Are you better than you were last year? Did this project teach you something that the previous one didn't? Did you take a risk that you wouldn't have taken before? The likelihood is that nobody else is going to notice, so make sure that you do. One of my measures of success is making an impact on other designers who have not yet achieved what I have. I've benefited enormously throughout my career from the generous advice of designers with more experience than me. I've always sought to pass that forward. I'm not Martin Wallace. I'm not Reiner Knizia or Vlaada Chvátil. And if the standard for giving design advice is you must be one of the most successful designers in history, then nobody is really allowed to talk about design. By that logic, football coaches can't teach unless they're Messi, authors can't teach creative writing unless they're Stephen King, and music teachers can't teach unless they're Beethoven.
The secret to success as a game designer is to define your own metric for success and then pursue it with passion, commitment, and drive. Work hard, strive to keep improving, and always remember to give something back along the way. And as for the naysayers, well, the only way to avoid criticism is to do nothing. And where's the fun in that? The introduction to Adam Atomic Wells' The Game Designer Mindset opens like this. "I'm not going to tell you how to make a million by selling games. I'm not going to guarantee that you'll even get a game published. This book will tell you the truth about the industry,
or at least provide you with a sincere account of one designer's experience. The information in these pages will sometimes be challenging, but also affirming. My goal is to encourage you in your game design endeavors, whatever stage you're at in your journey." So, that sounds like a mission statement for my channel. I'd be delighted if you came along for the ride.
There are links to the books discussed in this video in the description below.