New York Zoo – Board Game Dad Review
Transcript
since today i'm going to be talking about a zoo themed board game i wanted to make some awesome artwork the only problem is i didn't finish all i have is a rough giraffe my name is ben and today i'm going to be talking about new york zoo by juve rosenberg now i'm going to talk about how the game is played and my thoughts about it at large but i'm going to be giving a specific focus on how the game is played with children especially young children i have two girls aged four and six and both of them are able to understand and engage this game which is why i say board games with bad game it's extremely well qualified no but seriously two can played this game and three and four and five and there's a solitaire version but i know what you're thinking enough with the dad jokes let's set aside the puns and finally address the elephant in the room see there it is the purpose of the game is to fully develop a zoo by being the first to fully cover your zoo board with enclosures and attraction tiles strategically acquiring and breeding animals will help you do this faster set up the common playing space looks like this with three zoo tiles in each space the tiles are sorted and stacked from light green to dark green which helps large tiles come out early in the game and small tiles come out later there are also animal acquisition spaces and there are brown areas that aren't spaces but trigger animal breeding when they are crossed by
any player empty spaces also don't count as spaces during the game if a board looks like this and i can move one to four spaces that means i could move one two three or four each player has a board and every board is different depending on the number of players and the player order this helps keep the game balanced and compensated for the starting player advantage these are called zoo houses and each of the houses can contain one animal and this is the zoo board where you're going to be placing your enclosure tiles also on the player board is a reminder for a few of the rules it tells you how far you can move on your turn what to do when you breed and a reminder for what to do whenever you place an animal in an enclosure this brings me to my first criticism of the game this area is not adequate to remind the player of all the rules personally i feel that if you're going to have a player guide it needs to describe everything you can do on your turn otherwise you face the challenge of remembering what else you can do and what you can't do this guide is truly terrible so while i would usually refer to the guide to teach the rules in this case i'm going to ask you to ignore this while i try to do a better job and by the way at the end of this video and in this description i have a link to a graphic that i think is an improvement on the player guide which you might find useful if you want to print it out and use it to help your own kids learn the rules effectively the boards are passed out in numerical order and the player with board number one goes first during her turn she can move the elephant one to three or one to four spaces this is the one thing that the player board does well
the top corner tells you how many spaces you can move and that varies based on how many players there are keep in mind you will skip spaces that have been emptied as mentioned earlier there are two types of spaces enclosure tiles or animal acquisition if you use your turn to take an enclosure tile you must also take one or two animals of the same type from anywhere on your board to live in the enclosure you have to put an animal in it right away yes you do you may not leave another enclosure empty by doing this however this does not mean enclosures can never be empty it is possible to empty enclosures during the game and you will find out how shortly if you don't have an animal or you can't move an animal without leaving an enclosure empty then you may not take this action and you must take animal acquisition when you land on an animal acquisition space you may either take the two animals shown or one animal of your choice and place it in your zoo they can go in a house an enclosure with animals of the same type or an empty enclosure one of the side effects of doing this and in fact whenever you add an animal into an enclosure you can always move an animal of the same type from one of your houses into the enclosure as well this is a critical tactic for getting animals out of houses and into enclosures also you may not store toast in an enclosure the animals are penguins flamingos arctic foxes meerkats and kangaroos none are bred in captivity
after completing your action it's possible that an enclosure will be completely full this is when you empty an enclosure take all the animals off put them back in the supply but keep one and put it in a house if all of your houses are full even the last animal gets thrown into the supply my wife actually manages her zoo enclosures very effectively which i enjoy because it's reminiscent of the day we met i knew she was a keeper as a reward for filling an enclosure you may immediately take an attraction of your choice attractions are the only way to fill small spaces in your zoo board so you cannot neglect them and the strategy of managing your animals is all the more important in order to complete the game by filling every single square there are also a few large attraction tiles which creates an incentive to be the first to fill an enclosure at the end of your turn you can see if an animal breeding line was passed if it was then every player may breed one or two of the animals in different enclosures that match the animal crossed by breeding we mean that if an enclosure has more than one animal of that type you may add exactly one more animal to that enclosure as well as exercising the benefit of taking one of the animals from a house and moving it into the same enclosure in a two or three player game whenever you breed you can repeat the event one more time with exactly one other enclosure after breeding it is again possible to have completed an enclosure but this time it may have happened
simultaneously for multiple players in that case players select their attraction in player order beginning with the player whose turn was just taken by the way when it comes to the bonus breeding as they call it here the rules have a few special cases for example there's turn order when multiple people are doing things at the same time or how the remaining animal from one enclosure can be chained to bonus breeding to make effective combos these are all exceptional cases and interesting for highly competitive play but when i play with my kids no one really cares about special cases in turn order we the parents say you got a baby penguin and then the family just celebrates the new birth in fact we usually play this as a four player game without bonus breeding but when i did play a three player game with my kids i found the bonus breeding overwhelmingly complex and the next time i would definitely consider just leaving out bonus breeding entirely the winner is the first person to fill the entire zoo board and second and third place can be determined by the fewest number of remaining spaces with ties going to the person with most animals there is a solitaire version but i won't be talking about that in this video that being said let's look at the player board the part of it that i told you to ignore as i mentioned earlier this part is good it tells you how many species you can move based on the number of people playing the game this part represents breeding and it's a good graphic except breeding happens after your action so reading from left to right this is misleading this is a reminder that whenever you place an animal you can
take another from the houses that can happen when you're either taking animal acquisition or breeding to improve the game especially for kids i would use this player guide here you can read it left to right move take a tile or animals and follow placement rules check for completed tiles and take an attraction as needed breed and then check for completion and take an attraction tile as needed final thoughts on the game so i'm going to break this down into two parts how is the game as a family game and how is it as a standalone board game or if you're just playing with adults among hobbyists how was the game and as you're about to find out my opinion in these two contexts differs uh first as a family game i absolutely love this it's amazing to have a game that is challenging and interesting and engaging for me that i can have fun with it but also my kids can really get on board and feel like they have um a strategy that they can launch on to i know my six-year-old understands the entire game like she can strategize through it uh the game says ten and up and it's not a problem for her at all my four-year-old struggles a little bit more with uh the spacing especially one of the accommodations that we make for her is we just allow her to shift her pieces around on her zoo board as she plays and she really likes making the animal babies so she's having fun with us um
i really like just having that experience with my kids and i like that it's a challenge for them where even for kk the youngest one um even though strategically she can't prepare for one turn ahead what she does do is as pieces go outside of her limited area she will readjust them to get them to fit and she will just keep moving things around until she gets her zoo pieces back in alignment and during the course of the game she's either nudging it or she's just like not satisfied with it and she readjusts it many times which i think is very good for her spatial development now as a standalone board game uh i can't say that i think it's very innovative um unfortunately i'm familiar with other games by juve rosenberg and it kind of feels like he was thinking about releasing something new and he said well you know what's selling these days everybody likes baby animals maybe i can put baby animals on a game oh patchwork because that's what the game is it's it's baby animals on patchwork and uh well and you know patchwork i guess is a two player game and this one is one to five player and guess there's that aspect of it um but like there's there's definitely this aspect i i want to see something more um i would say in terms of writing it it is
it's very average five in mechanics five in strategy five in luck probably like a three in complexity which is good because sometimes you want a game that's not very complex but for theme it is like it's low i'd probably say a two and the only reason i would give it a score that high again this is a ten point scale the only reason i would give it a score of two is because at least when you have baby animals it takes two parents to make a baby animal so there's that um but it really just feels like the theme is slapped on um also in terms of gameplay uh this is a game where you're doing your best to plan ahead and you want to make contingency plans and so it can be very strategic but it feels like there's not enough control for the task that you have to complete now having the animals and getting the bonus style or the attraction tiles really helps you to fill out the whole zoo board but there are so many factors now maybe in a two-player game you can kind of pay attention to what your opponent's doing and like use that so you know okay well if i jump four spaces ahead i'll pass the piece that they need to finish and kind of be offensive in that regard but in a three four five player game by the time it goes around and it's your turn again the board that you're going to be left with is going to be pretty much random at that point like you're not going to uh
you can't you can't plan five moves ahead in this game um and so that can be kind of frustrating maybe too much luck but like the illusion that you should be able to do more um it does feel like you are basically just doing the same thing over and over again so it's that kind of game where you're like wait whose turn is it again hey it's your turn you know play your turn and it doesn't really have a dynamic changing like uh momentum to it you're just you know taking zoo tiles putting animals on them and doing that over and over again now the components are delightful the game is beautiful it's it's actually a lot of fun to do the same thing over and over again when it looks so nice but um i mean i've got to say like if it wasn't for how attractive the components are we probably never would have bought it in fact my wife bought this game which i think is a credit to the game she bought it though because of the flamingos so well i highly recommend as a family game not so much as a game without kids involved if you're interested in it uh go ahead and check it out on theperfectboardgame.com where all of these ratings are there you can actually modify those ratings and you can download the resources that i'll leave you which is the player guide and other things if you like this video though
do subscribe because this is actually the first episode of my entire channel and if it goes well i definitely want to do more board game reviews targeting families so let me know what you think in the comments below and thank you very much for watching i hope to see you again next week take care bye-bye you can choose with animal or you could just get both animals like you could get this and this and then if you wanted you could drag your two kind of blues into this