The Settlers of Catan VS Carcassonne
Transcript
trailer for sale or rent rooms to let the settlers of Katan is a game for three to four players which takes about 60 to 90 minutes to play players build settlements on the intersections of hexagonal resour or spaces each hex has a number representing a dice roll on each turn the dice are rolled and whoever is lucky enough to have settled adjacent to a hex with the same number will get that resource if a seven is rolled the thief comes out to steal from those with too many resources and renders a resource hex to be unproductive players can openly trade Resources with others on their turn resources can be used to build roads or settlements upgrade settlements to cities or to buy bonus cards like the knights who can trigger the thief settlements and cities are worth points as well as longest road and largest army of knights the first one to 10 points is the winner carcassone is a game for two to five players which takes about 45 minutes to play players lay tiles to grow roads cities farms and cloysters around churches they can also Place one of their meeples on the tile they place to take possession of that which they would like to complete the larger they make the road or City they have a meeple on the more points they score the cloy scores when all tile spaces around the
church have been placed and the Farms score at the end of the game after all of the tiles have been placed final scoring is totaled and the player with the most victory points is the winner but I get asked all the time which is better how they compare yeah oh how they compare Katan and carass own right well they're totally different yeah they're completely different games Katan is got a huge trading element which is it's far more interactive I think people like I think that's what people like about it than most is the open trading you can go after whoever's in the lead and not trade with them well there's I think even to get it even more basic than that there's the familiarity of a die roll right every turn you roll die and people are used to that being part of a game I think that helps but there's no D rle in carcassone no there isn't funny that you should mention that it's almost as popular is it really like I could I mean do as many people come from like just Monopoly in the game of life and that sort of thing to carcassone is they Katan carcassone that's yeah see now that makes sense to me this is just a little too abstract for I mean not that it's an abstract game but I think it's the the the thing that makes this as popular as it is is that it has aspects that are familiar even in Monopoly you have a trading aspect right you can trade properties and stuff so this this touches a lot of
points that other games that we're used to that you know that have been in our culture for a long long time and half and I think that's what makes it so familiar to people it makes them so comfortable to play it whereas this one it doesn't it's it's a weird one then how come it's like the second most most biggest seller because it's simple I think it's simple enough once people see this quite because there's other games that are similar to this they cut yeah they aren't as populars carass yeah I've never really understood the popularity of carcasson actually myself I don't think it's a bad game but I just don't understand why it's as popular as it is well Katan Katan I understand Katan I think is an excellent has really good replay ility yeah Ken's got all sorts of things going for it and I think like I said the familiarity and it's got the trading I think a lot of people don't like to dice rolling them yeah but is that people that are new to games or is that people that have played settlers to death and have moved on to things like carason and then moved on and on and on to other things yeah it's season Gamers the more season Gamers like pure strategy usually yeah but I mean I've been playing yeah and then they find a good luck or a good dice rolling game and they find it refreshing yeah yeah exactly I still like sellers I've played it hundreds of times same with carcasson actually and I would much prefer to play
Settlers think the big difference is Resource Management Area control I think the big difference trading uh little bit of dice world you're you're in this one you're sort of you're trying to build in an odd way an economic engine right you're trying to get your uh settlements out on tiles that will produce resources so that every turn you can build something new and you're trying to you know you're trying to make this little this Little Engine That chugs along um whereas carcassone you're randomly laying down tiles that affect you and other people hoping to draw the tile you need and yeah well you don't have to randomly draw tiles you can put out at like three and take oh yeah but that's different though that's that's your you're changing the the way the rules are WR not really it's pretty popular I mean there's a lot of games like that where you get the house rules yeah no I think there are house rules that definitely help improve this game a lot make it more strategic um but playing just by the basic rules for both of these I mean besides carcassone you're going to have you got what six guys you can put on you out you're going to have you know half a dozen maybe different things you're going on on the board it's not like you're looking for one time no no no true you know and you know I mean it's not a bad game there's no it's it's a good game and it's got a
lot going for it I just prefer sets I think the big uh another big difference is you need three or four to play this true whereas this can play with two carass play just as well with two as it does with six it's exactly the same yeah so that's a probably well that's one of the biggest differences it is definitely more flexible as far as player numbers go and people do play Katan with the two but it's Terri yeah I can't see how that would work well again the open trading is maybe the funnest aspect yeah with two players really what it would come down to with two players is whoever rolls the best whoever rolls their resources the best would win or whoever picks the best spot well that's what I mean who whichever die like even if you pick a bad spot at the die comes up I think the law of average is so well from over a 100 games yes you'll average out but in a single game you definitely can have the games I've had games where I'm on like sixes and eights and N nothing but threes and fives come up it is rare absolutely if you get a good spot you generally you will do well chances are you'll win not guaranteed but generally yeah I mean which is a flaw of the game which is a flaw in the game what it's not random enough no because if if well you randomly put out the tiles if you if you're lucky enough
to go first and get the Primo spot it uh has a balancing for that in the fact that it does have the the ports right and you want to try to grab the port you have have to be able to look at the game I think the big balancing element is trading trading yeah whoever's winning it don't trade with them well see the chances are they're winning because they got at that good spot yeah I've won games without trading at all I've just sat there and turtled and and still won but yeah that's actually I think in some ways the trading can be one of the weaknesses of this game because if you have somebody who's very experienced and somebody who isn't the experienced player can take advantage of the one of the person who isn't experienced and get them to make trades that they really shouldn't help yeah and I think of a lot of what a lot of people like about carcasson is that you can it can screw people over by like you were saying you want to get that one child that can really Make It or Break It for you and then someone else gets it and or they get a different tile and put it in the spot that you want right like you have a night in a city and you're trying to close it off and someone just keeps expanding and expanding and expanding or the AL yeah you want to get something going really big and someone just shuts it down shuts it down or or groups together two um pastures right for the farms at the end that maybe they have two guys on and then yeah but again that all comes up it's so luck it's so in the luck of the of the
the tile that you're draw I don't know if it's I I'd say they're both pretty equal of luck and Katan you can go that's pretty average length but carcasson is nice and short yeah Katan can drag if people tend if they spend too much time trading and they insist that they need more time to trade they don't want to stop trading and that can that can be a problem but another good thing is that you can decrease the number of points or increase the the game's going really fast you can say oh we'll play to 12 yeah carcassone though you you feel the end coming you can feel it in the bag yeah and that's it is it is quite quick yeah it's definite fin you play it the way I play it is as soon as you lay a towel you take another towel from the bag so you have your everybody else's turn you don't have to wait on no that makes sense and it's almost literally cuts the game and a half yeah I could see that yeah it's already not that long in the game so that would be good but as far as what game I'd rather play I'd always rather play carass right is I've just seen too many people get to go first get the awesome spot and then they win it but then shouldn't that be up to the other players so then not to trade with them or if they do trade with them to make sure that they I was saying sometimes they're winning cuz they got that awesome spot and like if they're
the only one who can get wood then you have to trade with them see what you're saying they like that it's like a monopoly right and arone one of the other things I like about it is that there's you don't know who's going to win till the end because then you do all the scoring whereas Katan it's like I won and that's the game over h a good hidden scoring element is always gives you a little adrenaline boost at the end whereas the that's like right yeah see I feel more in car it's almost random it's like well I'm laying down tiles and oh who won wow okay we that was let's do something else it's pure strategy I mean it's luck getting the ti off but it's where where you put it is pure strategy well sometimes you have no choice but to put it in only one spot very very rare yeah cuz sometimes you're watching and you're thinking okay I know exactly where the person I'm going to put this tile and they put it somewhere ridiculous and it's it's way more fun like that see now I would say that settlers is more of a thinking person's game and Katan is more of a Mindless activity sorry carcasson is more of carcasson is more of thinking on your feet whereas katan's more work with what you got yeah I could see that yeah settlers is more about uh uh managing and
carcassone is more about what do I do now carcasson is a manly game that I would definitely not agree age with Katan lady's Choice I'm not even sure what to say to that exactly when I first got carcassone I liked so much that I started getting the expansions mhm and then all of a sudden it was a three-hour game right and what I liked originally was totally disappeared in the Meer of all the rules and pieces so that's when I got hunters and gatherers and they they distilled it back I found my original Love of the Game mhm so I I never play that one I always play after together right Katan I think should not go more than four players definitely not should never go more than four players five is maybe okay if everybody knows exactly no anything over four six is uh is a nightmare is pretty brutal yeah cuz well you you can build on everyone's term which I really don't like which yeah it kind of it loses something but it also really slows the game down because every turn everybody's trying to decide what they're going to do it makes it a bit too easy because a lot of the strategy is getting your hand WT down yeah
absolutely and uh watching out for those thieves if you can build every turn then that's rarely a problem yeah this you can definitely go younger I think you could have six seveny olds play this easily whereas this I wouldn't play with anyone well I mean it depends on on your person obviously but this I think is a harder game with more subtlety to it than this I mean this this can have subtle strategies of you know where you're going to place your to you can play this very pass you can be almost brain dead and play car son like just get your tile and play it where it's where it'll go and you know that's it and you can have fun doing that whereas in Settlers you have to to a certain degree at least know what you're doing and otherwise it's not going to be any fun at all um but if I'm just going to sit down with some people that like games but they're not used to playing games I would choose s of over enement