Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 18:42

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. into damn doing a discussion over Flamecraft Duel, which is uh one of the newest iterations in like the duel genre that apparently is kind of the ongoing thing now. Whenever you don't know what to do with your IP, it's like, hey, make a two-player variant of it or version of it. Um, and this was honestly one that I was I mean, I I am a fan of of Flamecraft. I do really enjoy it and funny enough, I think it works perfectly fine at two. So when they announced this, I was like really like okay I guess every game is just getting a dual version. Uh and sometimes that's for the best because like for example Splender Duel I really enjoy even though I don't actually like Splendor. And here I was very curious as to what they were actually going to do with the game because like I said, their base game already works perfectly fine at two. And I'm actually pleasantly surprised. You might be wondering, normally I have a box, you know, right here to showcase the game. I don't have one because the board like the the that you play on is actually the box itself. and I'll show you in a sec. Um, but this is honestly probably the best produced dual game out there. It's like incredibly high quality. All of the cards are plastic. Uh, like I said, the board that

you play on is the box. Like you open it up. Like it literally has like it's like a chest that you open up and the two sides of the board are magnetically locked to hold the components. The coins are metal. The bag is very nice. It is a really good production. Oh, and the the tokens that you place are plastic, screen printed on and plastic. So, those are also incredibly nice. This easily could have just been a uh you know, a cardboard, you know, cardboard tokens that you pull from a bag and it would have been uh disgusting to touch. But, how does it play? Well, I can honestly tell you it plays nothing like Flamecraft. It literally is not the same game. Um, it has the same artwork.

So, if you love the art, it's got the same thing here. Um, it utilizes the same icons in the sense that it's bread and anvil and leaf and potion and stuff like that. Um, but it honestly, funny enough that I mentioned Splender Duel, it gives that kind of vibe because it's a little bit about spatial awareness and placing these tokens in a specific order to fulfill orders. Now, overall, I would say this game is good. Like, I'm not coming out and say it's it's, you know, it's high intelligence or it's high strategy or it's complex. It it's really none of that. It is almost a go through the motions game there, but not quite. You're not sitting here just going, "No, no thought. Places here, score, places here, score." But it does kind of have that element when you're starting out. So, there's a little bit of layers to the game. Um, the the orientation of the symbols that you need are basically straight line or triangle. There's nothing else about that. And it's all literally just different iterations. There's an entire stack of shop cards.

And it's either going to be three orders of the same like this one requires three meat to be in a triangle. That's all it's ever going to be. It's going to be three meat or three potions or three leaves. It's never any combination of like you need a leaf here and you need an anvil here and you need a bread here. Um, and then the the ones that go in the line are always going to be two of one item and one of another. Two bread and an anvil for this one. Two bread and a and a diamond for this one. Two potions and an anvil for this one. And honestly, I kind of think that they missed the mark a little bit on this. I think this game could have been like I think you could have done two sets. I could you could have had one where it was just this where it's like more beginner friendly and a little bit more just not so [snorts] strict on the uh on the placement. But then you could have had like another deck of shop cards where it was a little bit more realist or not realistic, a a lot more tactile and strategic and specific and strict on where what you needed because at the end of the day the ones that are in a straight line are two points. The ones that are in a triangle are three points.

There's nothing to actually add any depth to that. Um, now where the depth kind of comes from is that each of the tokens that you place uh have an ability that on your turn you draw from a bag and you place one down and then you activate that ability. And that's where the nuance is going to come in. Like I mean you're not necessarily trying to block your opponent in any any way that you would be able to actually predict. you might do something that's like, "Oh, dang it. I almost was able to score that, but I can't now." Uh, and the abilities are nice. You know, play another dragon. I If I'm I'd have to grab the flame craft uh cards to see if those abilities are the same. But the bread lets you play another dragon. The potion let you swap dragons. The the the meat lets you move an adjacent dragon.

So, there is positioning on this tiny board, but ultimately I haven't found this to ever be that difficult to score a card, but if you do, then they have these coins that you can spend to draw two cards from the deck and then discard two cards cuz you always have two shop cards available. So, it gives you some flexibility. But yeah, like the cards score the same. I think each game I've played, I've had roughly around the the same um the same score just because there's not like any fivepointers that you're aiming to do. It's always two or three points. Um, so yeah, I think it would have been nicer to actually have like really high-end uh spatial positioning of these tokens to get really cool combos off to be like, oh, okay, if I do this and I can activate this token, which lets me then move it here, which will then trigger this and that means I get this five pointer. Boom, that's awesome. No, it has that a little bit, but for two or three points and sometimes I mean I guess five points total because if you can position it to where you score both of them, then that's something.

Uh but that's this is all from the base game. Luckily, the if that was it, I'd be like, "Okay, this is fine. I'm not going to keep it because I'd rather play Flamecraft 2 at at two." Uh, but they do have two variants that you can add in or combine uh together uh that do kind of add a little more flavor to the pot. The first one is fancy mode. Uh there's not that many, but there's I think it was eight, two, four, six. Yeah, there's eight dragons that have special abilities to them. Half of them are passive and half of them are active abilities. Um, the rules say you pick which one you want. Uh, I personally would just rather shuffle these together and be like, I got Taylor this time. And these are nice. Again, they're not amazing, but uh they are they add a little bit more to the game. The active ones mean that you now have a new ability with your coins. And these coins are worth a point at the end of the game for each one you have. But now you can actually spend them to do an ability.

Like one lets you move a dragon on the board to any other space. Another one lets you pull two dragons from the bag and place one and fire it up, which means you use its ability. Another one lets you draw a card from the score deck and if you can score it immediately, you can and you draw another one. So just something a little bit extra for the the fancy cards. Others are passives. Um like sterling when a coin is spent flip it. If it's heads you keep it. If it's tails you discard it. Um but so that's one thing. Another is um each player begins with three shops. At the end of each player's turn they draw until they have three. So they're just kind of rule changing. But I would have I really would have liked to see more of these instead of eight. like literally like three or four times as much would have really added some some nice variety to the game. And then last is the fountain. Now, between the two variants, funny enough, I actually typically like player powers a lot more in any kind of game. You add player powers and unique player powers, then it enhances the game dramatically. But for this game, I actually like the fountain module. It says it's for experienced players. I don't know what constitutes as experienced for this um considering

this game definitely feels like it's on the gateway side. So, it's like okay as experience. You've played the game once. I don't know. But basically, again, it's just a little bit more complex. But you now have these fountain cards that have four in a row of each type. So four potions, four meat, four leaves, yada yada yada. And during scoring, whenever you have four in a row, you get to take one of the fountain cards. And it has to you can only take one and you score it. These are worth three points. But what it does is it allows you to take the fountain miniature and place it anywhere on the board. And if you place it on a stack, um, you get to keep one of the ones in the stack and then put the others back in the bag. And then on your next turn, the one that you kept is the one you place. This I actually really liked because one, it kind of not necessarily prolonged the game because it actually removes for if you're playing with this, you remove one of each type from the um from the bag, but it added an element of control besides just drawing from the bag and hoping you get something. Uh, it allowed you to basically pick a stack and also have some uh like like I said, control on your next turn to be like, I

kept this meat one, therefore that's going to allow me to do the setup for my next turn. So, I thought that was really cool. It also counts as a blocker. So, if you could see what your opponent might be trying to set up and that there's there's three leaves in a row, uh, and you know, you just put a leaf back in the bag, you can place the you can place the fountain in a spot to where even if they draw the leaf, they're not going to be able to complete that to get the fountain. So, just added a little bit more kind of player interaction than just randomly moving stuff around. Um, so yeah, like that's those are the two modules that the game added. I mean, in terms of negatives, like I said, this game is not that like complex. It's not that I guess strategic. Uh, pretty easy to go about getting your uh getting your your shops, you know, your shop orders done. Uh if you're looking for a specific token that you really need to like it's like I really need a meat to try and get this. You are drawing from a bag. So there might not be any in there at that time or you might have just not drawn it. So it is a little bit luck dependent. However, like I said, most of the abilities are going to get you to position something in a way that you're going to be able to score. So it does feel good though whenever you are constantly scoring

something. And half the time if you're playing, since this is a two-player game, half the time when it comes back to you, it's like, "Oh, look at that. I just scored that. I didn't even do anything that you either put me in a position to score or my the one I scored last time. I drew a new card and oh, would you look at that? It's automatically there and no one modified it." So, yeah, it is it it's just that kind of game. Now, if you own Flamecraft and you play Flamecraft at two and you like it at two, do you need to go out and get Flamecraft DS? I really don't think so. I don't think that this is a game that's necessarily worth owning for both. I mean, the spatial awareness of the game is very clean. It's a very succinct game, like I said, because now I can show you.

Just pour all those down. This is This is the box. Boom. Like it's almost it almost looks like a lunch pail. The only thing you need is the handle. But it's extremely cute. Uh in fact, whenever I whenever I got it, my uh my girlfriend was like, "Oh, is are you keeping the the game in that?" And I was like, "Yeah, like this is it's that you keep the game you keep board games in a box." And I cuz I hadn't seen the clasp. So, I was like, "Oh, I see now why you asked me that because this looks like it would just be a storage chest." But, nope. Like, this is this is the this is the game box, which is kind of neat. I don't think I've ever seen any game do something like this. But, yeah, like you just unclasp it, open it up, then you got it there, and like here's the storage for the card holders and the cards. And then you have this side that is for the Oops.

You have this side that is for the for the bag. And I mean it literally holds everything and then you put it up. So I mean if you really really like Flamecraft but and you travel a lot then yeah this one you could play like on a train or hell you could even play it on a plane. You could uh play it in in a boat. You could play it on a goat. Um, I don't know what I just you can you can play while reading Dr. Seuss apparently. Um, but that's the only plus side I can see to actually owning this over regular Flamecraft. Now, if you hate Flamecraft at two, uh, then I don't know. I that's the weird thing about these games is it's like okay if you really like Flamecraft for what it is this is such a far departure from that that it's not the same thing but now you can kind of play something similar in a two-player version. But if you don't like Flamecrafted 2, then uh then I guess get this because you might like the way this plays because it doesn't play like FL. It's just it's such a weird weird thing like I don't know. I think for me personally if I if I mean I love the art. I love the the compactness. Um it's not completely dull, but it's also not super

stimulating for me. Uh, even with all the additional stuff, like combining the fountain with a special player power still isn't quite enough for me to be excited to play this and be like, "Oh, this has a lot of depth to it surprisingly as a two-player game." Not really. But, I mean, I guess if I just am not in the mood for that kind of game and it's like, ah, sure we can play something, then this could be just one of those games. It doesn't take long to play either, which is a benefit. I don't think this game is bad. I just kind of wish there was a little bit more to it. Uh but yes, so that's it. Um on a scale of 1 to 10, um I think I'm going to give this h what do I want to give you? I think I'm going to give it a seven. I still think it's good. Uh I don't think it's great by any means, but it it it keeps you engaged enough. I guess the production quality of the game of it does kind of elevate it a little bit.

Um, so yeah, if the I have to I it's been a hot minute since I played Flamecraft. I I want to say that the fire up of the of the tokens is the same abilities when you trigger them in Flamecraft. Uh, and one thing that is actually kind of cool, which I know they added with the latest expansion to Flamecraft, are these dual tokens that count as both of the icons. Um, that's nice. And this does end up being like our very first game of this, uh, the stacking of the tokens. I was like, why would you ever do that? And then every subsequent game after that um has been less like less of the board filled up and more stacking going on because of just actual blocking and maybe positioning of that. So that's kind of cool.

So it could just be one of those games where it gets a little bit more in depth the more you play it with um someone else. So I'm going to go with a seven. Like I I do not I do not hate it. And that's it. That's my thoughts on Flamecraft Duels. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved