Skip to main content
Loading video...

Viticulture: Bordeaux Review – This Fixes Viticulture’s Biggest Problem

Transcript 7:42

What is going on everybody and welcome back to Tantrum House. Today we're taking a look at the newest expansion of Vidiculture. It's called Bordeaux. This is an alternative board expansion for Viticulture. And right up front, I want to be super clear. If you already own Viticulture, then this expansion is aimed directly at you because this is not a beginner product. This is not Viticulture Plus. This is Viticulture Refined.

Viticulture, in my opinion, has always been a great game, but longtime players know it has a few pain points, right? It starts pretty slow. You've got pretty repetitive strategies if you played more than once. And there are lots of games where you can go through the whole game and you kind of like barely make any wine until you get to the very end. But Bordeaux was designed to address those issues directly and it absolutely does. Okay. So, Viticulture Bordeaux is a full replacement board. Now, you still use the same core rules, the same visitors, the same wine- makingaking process, but the board itself changes how the game flows. So, you now play through four full worker placement seasons, right? Spring, summer, fall, and winter where every single one matters, right? Each one offers meaningful decisions. So, here's what comes in the box. Inside this expansion, you're going to get one double-sided game board with the entire Bordeaux layout. You're going to get 24 cubes which are going to be used for experts. We'll touch on that in a second. Six reference cards and really that's it, right? So, there's no like bloat, no unnecessary extras. Everything in this box serves a purpose. One of the first changes that you're going to notice is face up cards, right? So, there's always two vine cards and two wine order cards available on the board.

And you can still draw from the deck, but now you also have visibility. And that fixes actually a major vidiculture issue. You no longer feel stuck hoping for the right card. You can plan, you can pivot, you can have agency. That actually small change was a big deal. The second thing you'll notice is a wakeup chart in Bordeaux. Now, this is one of my favorite changes because it's packed with a bunch of benefits. It's not just turn order anymore. You'll actually see icons for aging grapes, aging wine, refreshing the face up cards, uh drawing any card type, retrieving a worker early, and even choosing between a card or a victory point. Every year, your wake up choice absolutely matters and it matters actually immediately. That was to me one of the biggest changes, one of the things that I'll talk about just in a second. You'll also notice the residual track. It's another really quiet improvement. When you cross certain thresholds on the residual track, you immediately actually gain victory points, and they're one-time bonuses, not endofear effects. Now, this rewards kind of steady progress as you move it, and it encourages players to actually engage with the wine- making process a lot earlier than normal, which of course viticulture is supposed to be able to do. Now, Bordeaux introduces a trade market, and this lets you exchange resources in a really structured way.

It's another thing that you're going to find on the game board. Trades can be blocked. Timing matters, and coins suddenly matter way more than they ever did before. The first time I played the game, I thought from the very beginning, how am I going to have enough coins to get all this done? How is this possible? But I think it gives players another viable path forward when your hand kind of just doesn't cooperate. Now, let's talk about one of the biggest, it's optional, but biggest changes to this game. Let's talk about experts. Experts are actually placed by using the hire an expert action. So, new action. Each expert enhances a specific action. So, they're super powerful and super flexible. But here's the interesting part. In my very first game of Bordeaux, the winning player actually didn't even use experts at all, where I, who was using a bunch of the experts because I wanted to try them out. Uh, four to be exact, uh, didn't even come close to winning the game. I was like five or six victory points behind.

Experts are actually not mandatory either. Um, which means they're not really a trap. They're more of like an optimization layer. So, if you want them, they're there. You don't have to play with them. Of course, if you don't play with even if you're playing with them, but you don't use them, you can still win. And to me, that's like really excellent design because it gives another avenue of the game, but you don't have to do it in order to to feel like you have to win. So, Bordeaux feels faster to me. It feels more intentional. It feels more interactive. You make really meaningful decisions really early in the game instead of later. And you're rewarded for adapting. If you are pushed toward making wine instead of like, you know, looping visitor cards forever, then at three and four players, the board really shines.

And here's what I mean by that. The turns feel really light. The downtime stays pretty low. Momentum stays pretty high, and I love that. So now, let me compare a little bit to bass vidiculture. In my opinion, bass vidiculture is charming. Of course, it's clean. It's approachable, but once you've played Bordeaux, the baseboard feels super limited because you've got really slow starts, less flexibility, less incentive to pivot. For experienced players, Bordeaux is going to be like your clear upgrade. But again, let's compare a little bit to Tuskanyany. Everyone loves Tuskanyany. Tuscanany added a lot, right? Structures and extended board concepts. It added more depth. But Tuscanany sometimes feel a little bit heavy. Bordeaux, my opinion, does something different. It focuses, it trims, it sharpens the experience. And for me, the ranking is pretty clear.

Base viticulture, then you're going to go Tuskanyany, and then you're going to go Bordeaux. And yes, I know I left out Viticulture World, but for me, the cooperative element to the game just was not my thing. If it's yours, I totally understand it. But for me, I'm okay. If I'm choosing one board to play Vidiculture on, I'm going to play the Bordeaux board every time, probably. Okay. So, who is this for? If you are an experienced viticulture player and you want a little bit more agency, faster start, less repetition, more meaningful decisions, and if viticulture already kind of works for your group, then this is going to make it better. So, that's who it's for. If viticulture sometimes stalls in your mind, this expansion fixes it. You should totally give it a try. This is also a really great example of what Stonemer Games, in my opinion, does really well. They don't just add content. They iterate. They refine. They listen to what people actually said, the people who play it. And Bordeaux feels really purposeful and not super excessive. So, in my opinion, Viticulture Bordeaux is a keep. And more than that, it's actually with the board, it's probably my preferred way to play Vidiculture. Now, it fixes Vidiculture's biggest problems without losing any of its identity. So, if you own Vidiculture and you want to keep playing it for years, this expansion is absolutely worth your time. So, here's my question for you. Have you tried Viticulture Bordeaux yet or are you planning to?

Right? Do you prefer it over Tuscanyany? So, I'd like to know. Let me know in the comments. Right? And then do me a favor. You got to like this video. You got to subscribe to the channel. That really helps us out. And we'll see you here next time at Tantrum House.

Progress saved