Not Alone Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to jits games today I'll be reviewing not alone this is a two to S player game that was designed by Gand Manan and in it you have everybody around the table except for one as crash landed survivors onto this planet that is just teaming with life they're going to have to work cooperatively in order to get the rescue ship to this planet as fast as possible because they are not alone the one other player plays the creature right here who is just ominously stalking them and trying to catch them every single turn of the game and when they do they just lose their will to leave the planet and they just get assimilated into this ecosystem it is a race between a simulation and this rescue ship zooming towards the planet so I will explain how the game plays in a little more detail first and then I'll jump into my review here we have the table fully set up for a four-player game of not alone for starters we have this track up here and we put the rescue token down where it says four because it's a four player game and same thing with this assimilation token over here these cards here represent the planet in all the locations that the hunted can go to and you can see that each hunted player starts with one card for each of the top layer of locations this means that they can each go to only this top player and the bottom row is inaccessible to them they have to first explore each of the hunted is also going to get a random one of these Survivor cards they have three will and the player who is playing the creature is going to take these three tokens start with a hand of three of these hunting cards and you're ready to go each game turn is split into four different phases and the first one involves all the hunted simultaneously choosing one of their locations and putting it face down on the table to choose that spot to go to they can also all play one of these survival cards on each of their turns in the given phase so this says phase one
so this player for instance could play this Ingenuity they show it to the table and we see it says place the marker counter onto the beach well that is this marker right here it begins the game off of the beach so they can put this down onto the beach and now maybe they decide they want to go to the beach because if you look at the text on this card we see that it says that you either place the marker onto the beach or you remove it from the beach and move the rescue counter forward one space it's important to note that if multiple survivors go to this spot then it's only going to happen once per turn regardless of how many people go there but they figure that this is a pretty good move once all hunted players have selected the location they're going to go to we move into phase two where the creature is now going to go on the prowl they have these three tokens that are available to them they can use this one every single turn and they're going to put this down onto one location where they think one of these hunted players have gone for instance they might say well you know this looks like a really good spot now uh for somebody to go because they can pull this token off so they're going to go to the beach but the creature is also allowed to play one of their hunt cards from their hand on each of their turns now you can see that there are these symbols up at the top and if they play a card with this symbol then they will unlock the ability to use one of these two uh markers uh to a couple different effects the first one right here is the arpia marker and the text down at the bottom here says no survival cards may be played or drawn for the render of this turn which is really nice to stop all of those hunted players from drawing more survival cards and playing them and this means they get to place this token down and if they put this on a spot that one of the hunted goes to then not only does this location not work so it stops them from using the ability but they're also going to have to discard a card
face up into their area making it harder for them to choose new locations on future turns however let's pretend that the uh creature decided to play this Mirage instead this allows them to use this Target and we see it says targets to adjacent spaces both are ineffective so in this case maybe they would go ahead and put this right here they would do this so that now if any of these players chose one or two well nothing bad would happen to them but they would not be able to do any of the abilities on those spots now that the creature has done everything they want to in phase two we move to phase three where we reveal all of the cards that everybody went to and we now evaluate them going clockwise from the creature player around all of the hunted players so we can see that both of these hunted players went to the Rover and the text on the bottom says that you can take from the reserve one place card and you do not own and you add it to your hand and since this position does not have a 1x both of these players will be able to do this and they can essentially do this simultaneously here we have the reserve and one of the players is going to grab this one right here and the other one decides to grab this these cars now go Direct into their hand now that they have these cars in hand these hunted players will be able to go to these new locations that they were not able to go to before and it's important to note that there are only two cars available for each of these locations so all three hunted will never be able to go to one of these specific locations and they do all sorts of great stuff like the wreck right here just says move the rescue counter forward once per space uh a maximum of once per turn so it's essentially twice as fast as the beach and then this right here the source it says that the hunted of your choice can regain a will or you could draw a new survival card and as we saw before those cards can be quite effective now that
both of these players have evaluated the spot they went to we have the beach and we can see that the creature went to the beach which means this spot is not only ineffective but this hunted person has been caught once this happens they actually lose one of their will entirely and now the assimilation marker moves one forward if the creature is ever able to get this purple marker all the way to this spot they will win immediately having fully assimilated all of these Crash Crew onto the planet's ecosystem however as you can see this track over here shows the rescue ship it's quite a bit longer for them we now move into the fourth and Final Phase of the turn where the creature player is going to pull up all of their tokens they're going to draw cards from the top of the deck until they have three in their hand and most importantly this rescue track is going to move forward once this happens at the end of every single turn to signify the rescue ship getting closer and closer to this planet which is part of the reason why their track is so much longer than the assimilation one and we now start a new turn with phase one where all the hunters would pick a new card in this instance though they now have cards on the table that they cannot quite pull back so once they choose a new card they might put it right here and the creature is going to know that this player for instance is not able to go to the four spot anymore because it is currently face up on the table during phase one the hunted have two more options available to them they can resist and when they do this they lose one will but they're able to pull back any two cards they want to that have been played on the table back to their hand they can do this as many times as they want to spending multiple of these uh Wills or they could just give up by losing all of their cubes and then they get to take all their cards back into their hand after they do that they go back to three will and this seems pretty great but anytime a hunted gives up in Phase One the assimilation marker moves
one forward which makes it that much closer for them to lose the game it's important to note that when the creature goes to a location with multiple hunted on it the assimilation marker is only going to move forward once essentially for just catching at least one person also when these people lose their last will they are forced to give up however if multiple people give up at the same time during phase three then this marker is only going to move forward once again and these players are going to pull all their cards back and of course gain their will backup three I'd also like to note that once this rescue ship hits any of these six spots here as they get closer to this planet they have unlocked this timia token every single turn for the creature player they don't have to play cards with that symbol on them anymore even if they play this one they can throw this down onto the board and at this point we keep playing until one of these tokens is able to get to this Final End spot right here if this token gets here then immediately the game ends and all the hunted are rescued by the ship and they make it off the planet or if instead it's this one right here then they become fully assimilated into the planet and the creature itself is the one who wins let's now begin the review for Not Alone by covering a few positive points the first of these relates to the two different ways that you can play the game with the creature and also as being a hunted Survivor on the planet now as a hunted you are in a Cooperative game you're trying to win collectively with everybody around the table except for one person but you're not allowed to communicate anything that the creature does not also hear and you are trying to consider where does the creature think that I'm going to go and maybe I don't go to that spot but then you also need to think well where does the creature think that I might go instead of that spot because they're assuming that I'm not going to go to that spot so maybe I just go to that spot and they'll just
whiff and go to another thing spot thinking that I wasn't going to go to the really good area that's just one of those thinking and double thinking type situations but the hunted also need to consider that they want to spread out and hit as many of these different spots as they can because if they're clumped up and the creature goes onto that spot then everybody on that spot is going to lose will and will is an important resource for trying to keep that assimilation track back and it's also an important resource just for just getting the cards back in your hand you often times want to resist and give up a one of your wheel cubes in order to pull those cards back it's very important to do that but if you're all clumped on one spot and the creature goes there the simulation marker only goes up once even even if multiple people lose all their will when that go to that spot um well that would be a second marker jump but it's not like four jumps on the track so you almost want to Clump together because if you spread out it's going to be much more likely that the creature does hit somebody and that marker will go forward but if you have six people around the table and only two locations are grabbed then there's a really good chance the monster is just going to with so all these things you're thinking about all at the same time and at the same time as you're doing this the creature player is doing the same kind of calculations but they are trying to catch the people in this way and I've been amazed at the number of times where as the creature I have completely whiffed like even in a seven player game I played where I was the creature there's six different hunted out there and the beginning of the game there are five locations on the board and I missed everyone on that very first turn they all kind of like clumped into different spots and locations I wasn't expecting and it's not like they were secretly collaborating behind the scenes they just worked out really well for them they played that round very well uh so it's fun trying to be the creature and trying to hunt all these people out
although sometimes you get a bit exasperated you're like how did I go three turns with catching nobody when there are six people scurrying around this planet where the heck are you guys and it definitely plays into the theme of the game but both of these U positions to play the game have been super fun for me positive number two relates to the great amount of tension that is created by this game pretty much from the moment you take your first turn all the way to the very end I have not seen any blowouts with this game every single game has been quite close in fact two of the games were absolute photo finishes where the simulation token and the rescue token were both one tick away from getting to the very end and in one of those scenarios the creature won and in the other one the rescue team won and whenever you lose this game you really feel like you could trace back to pretty much any turn that you've had and be like oh if I could have done this slightly differently then that would have done this one thing we would have gotten one more tick and it's just great having every single action that you take in a game feels so consequential um as long as you enjoy that in games I mean obviously there uh with tension there comes a little bit of stress and this is a fun kind of stress for me I think it creates a wonderful atmosphere around the table of just interesting decisions the whole way through and if that is something that you're looking for you're definitely going to find it in heaps with this game and now for positive number three which has to do with the great theme of the game and how well it comes through while you're actually playing it obviously I already talked about tension and you are going to be tense if you are screwing around the planet trying to run away from something that's hunting you but even more than that you have thematic Titans with the locations that you're going to go to for instance you can go into the Rover and explore around and find a new location
that is going to be better for you probably and it increases the number of spots that you can go to and hide and do things uh trying to get away from the creature you have the Shipwreck that you can go to which it with its really powerful antennas that's going to really help hone in that rescue ship because I think thematically the rescue ship isn't just heading straight to the planet it doesn't really know where you are and so the more you talk to it the more it's able to hone in on exactly what planet you're at and it gets there faster um you also have all those uh those Survivor cards that you can play that will do a ton of different things and a lot of them feel very thematic with the text that are on the top and the resolution that can happen down the bottom and they also give the game almost a cinematic feeling where you know things are looking bad and then suddenly you play this one card and it gets you out of a jam and oh man that was so close and you just barely squeak by and then the creature is like oh dang it when that happens and on the flip side you have the creature who really feels like they're trying to hunt people they're trying to figure out you know where are these dastardly survivors going to try and hide I need to jump on them and you know assimilate them into this planet so they hang out with me forever and uh it's amazing how often you can just straight up Miss and you get this emotion of frustration it's it's kind of fun frustration but it's also just like exasperation like there are six hunted around the table and five locations how did I not get any of you three turns in a row you know I've seen that happen where you just you keep missing and it feels like you're just offset and then suddenly you just start hitting more and more there just all these things that play in together and also those hunting cards the ones that the creature has you know they have great thematic ties in as well not all of them in particular I'm not really sure what ascendency means with the action that it does but there's a card
where you just say you know scream and there's another card that says you know force field and all these things and you really feel like okay there's a force field now we can't go into those locations or you hear this terrifying scream off in the distance and I think that's one that makes you have to discard a couple locations it just kind of reduces the amount of options you can go to because you know you are terrified so um I think that is pretty much how all these thematic things in together to make a really great little package that plays into the tension that I mentioned already it's just you really feel like you're not alone on this planet let's Now cover a couple neutral points and the first of these relates once again to those Survivor cards and those hunting cards that I just talked about in the Thematic area sure they bring out the theme of the game but mechanically they are also incredibly interactive and you need to know that when you go into this game this is not one of those games where you as a player look at the situation and just outplay your opponents knowing all the different options available to you you are probably going to come up with plans and they are going to be upended specifically as the creature all those Survivor cards really mess with the plans that you can have they are very situational but in that situation they can be hugely impactful for instance one game as the creature as my first turn I played a hunting card that said I could play two hunting cards on my next turn instead of one well that seems great I had a couple great cards in my hand I was going to do a really explosive turn on that next round well we started the next round and one of the survivors played a card that said nope the creature can't actually play any cards at all so I lost out on essentially two different turns worth of card play and that was a little bit frustrating in that moment like kind of exasperating but thematically it kind of ties in well
with the tension of the creature you're trying to catch all these people but you never know when they're going to at the last minute kind of turn the tables on you and as the survivors you have these cards in your hand you're trying to figure out the moment when you are going to use them for the to the best of your ability and it plays into the Cinematic nature of the game where you're constantly being chased being chased then you just at the last minute you're like nope never mind you know you actually you know this was a decoy and you go over there instead and that kind of stuff is really fun and it feels necessary to create that tension without having the uncertainty of what all the other what the other team can do against you specifically when you are the creature player I think you would lose most of the tension in the game so uh you got to know all the stuff going in you could definitely commit to enjoying this stuff but try not to get frustrated by the different cards that can be played because they really pull together to make the game better as a whole neutral number two is a pretty simple one I've noticed that analis is can definitely pop up while you're playing this game specifically as the creature player now this might be a people problem uh specifically with me when I'm playing as the creature I am um known for falling into AP when I'm playing games in general but I found many times where I'm trying to figure out what I'm going to do and there's like four to six people staring at me just waiting for me to make my decision where do I go and like I'm like I'll go here nope no I'll go there actually and I'm just kind of like going back and forth trying to figure out what I'm doing and you know it's kind of fun in the moment but also at a certain point you got to commit to it and just go to a spot and I think people who are not prone to AP are not going to have a problem with playing the creature they're probably just going to be like ah I go here and they just keep playing the game but if you are
susceptible to it at all man that thinking and double thinking and triple thinking can really wor your brain up into slowing the situation down a little bit it's not a bad thing I just want you to know that it's a possibility next up is the negative section and I only have one and I'm not fully committed to it being a negative but I want to talk about the artifact location this is is one of the 10 that come in the game it's one of the ones you need to explore and there is a general vibe from most of the people that I played with that this is a very weak spot and I think I agree with them when you go to this location you um are allowed to on your next turn evaluate two different locations from your hand and what that means is instead of doing uh one action this turn one location this turn and one location next turn you're essentially doing no location this turn and two next turn and it feels like you might be more likely to get caught by the creature by doing two different locations on the next turn and the turn where you actually activate the artifact you don't get any benefit maybe if there was something attached to it like pick up a card from your discard pile and next turn you get to play two cards it would be much more incentivized and this hasn't really negatively impacted the games that I've played which in general is a criteria for a negative uh point because people have just kind of avoided that card but I guess to a certain degree going from 10 options down to nine options does negatively impact the overall experience because it would be fun to have more different locations that you can go to so I'm not vilifying the card I'm not saying it's the worst thing ever but it does seem like in general it's the worst pick and I don't think it's a surprise
that it's been largely ignored in all the games that I've played let's now discuss the variability for not alone and unfortunately it is definitely below average when you sit down to play this game either as the creature or as the hunted you sitting down to the same game that you played last time it's the same exact locations that are available to you and sure you might draw different Survivor cards or different hunt cards but those are going to subtly tweak the each play and maybe they might modify how you do specific actions to try and make one of these situations work out for you but I would not say that that is a big enough effect on the overall variability of the game I think this game would be easily expandable by put um giving out expansions with new locations I just kind of wish that the game itself came with alternate options maybe not for the first five like having those always be the first five kind of makes sense but for the second five that you can go and explore it feels like a opportunity to not have an alternate for all of those different spots to kind of mix up every single every single gam play so you don't find yourself always going for the shelter because that works out really well for you and you enjoy going for the shelter if that makes any sense so there's lots of room for the variability to get expanded in this game but as it comes in this box it's kind of low not alone plays two to seven players and I've played the four six and seven player game and I'm happy to report that it was great at all of those player counts I was actually surprised uh the first game I played was the four player game and it worked really well it was a great time everybody really enjoyed it and I remember thinking ah this is probably going to scale well but I don't know maybe at seven that's just so many people trying to find Spots I'm sure
that it's going to be a lot easier for the creature player in order to just find people every turn and with every increase of player count you're going to move the little tokens farther back on the board which I guess will make the game last a little bit longer but when I ended up playing that seven player game as a as the creature I was shocked to find how easy it was to still completely whiff and miss all these people around the table and when you have that many hunted people around the table that is all those people having those cards in their hand the Survivor cards and they're situational but the more people with those cards the more likely one of them is going to have the card that matches the current situation so it was maybe almost a little bit more frustrating in the seven player game as the creature versus the four player game where there were only three of the uh people that they were trying to hunt but it was still great I still really enjoyed all of those different player counts I think that five is likely great as well um I worry about the low levels I think the two-player game probably works but I think you are going to lose a lot of the tension because it's going to be really hard to find somebody I think as the creature I think it'd be a much less fun game as the creature and I think same kind of goes for the three-player game four would be my suggested minimum for a great tense uh experience around the table but I'm not saying don't play those other counts it's just it's great to see that so many of these player counts are bounced in such a way that it is tense and fun the whole way through in conclusion I've play play Not Alone three times at this point and every one of those plays have been tense interactive thematic and super fun for me and pretty much everyone else around the table it is true that this is a tense game and if you don't like your games to be somewhat
stressful and have most of your decisions be really impactful this might not necessarily be the game for you but for most of the people that I have played this game with they've really been taken in with the theme with the atmosphere with everything that's going on in here and honestly I'm pretty surprised by how much I enjoy it this is a review copy of the game that was sent to me by the publisher and when I first read about it I thought well that looks kind of neat I might like it hopefully I'll like it but I was not expecting to fall for it this much I think halfway through the first game I played I kind of uttered under my breath oh my gosh this game is so cool and everybody around the table just nodded agree like yeah this is really great and in fact this game has been played a whole bunch by my play group I've played it three times but there was a game night where it was played three times in that one night by several of the same people in fact two of those games were back toback people have been really excited about this game and have really enjoyed it and that um is a good thing because the variability is somewhat low as I mentioned before that is definitely the biggest weakness of the game that you are crash landing on this planet and you go to explore and you find the same thing every single time so I'm really hoping they come out with more content for the game there actually is a promo for an alternate artifact card which came with the game that was sent to me I don't know if that's going to be sent out with every copy of the game that's why I can't commit to it but it looks like they already know that their artifact that ship with this game maybe is a bit weak and they are adding some some more variety adding a new artifact uh option I think that is just a great opportunity for them to make even more maybe just as uh promos or just a fullon expansion to add new locations that you can go to and explore I think that it actually makes sense for the top five
locations to always be those top five locations but those down in the bottom when you jump into a Rover and you go to see what you find in this Wilderness you kind of like to have one game be a little bit different from the next with the card options you available to you and maybe how they can potentially interact back and forth with each other if multiple people are activating these on the same turn so there's a huge uh window of opportunity for increased content for what is a really good framework for a game that has just uh gone over really well with all of us it is a the box says that it is a 30 to 45 minute game and from my experience it's been more like an hour every time I've played it although they've been four to seven player games I think if you play the two-player game it might actually be 30 minutes but for that 60 Minutes that you get I think it is has a great Pace like I enjoy how the tension just uh ratchets up until you get to the very end you have this big Climax and then one side wins and the other side loses then as you're packing the game up people are talking about oh this one turn where I could have done this one thing differently and oh my gosh I can't believe you did that it just leads itself to stories which makes sense considering how thematically tied in everything is and yeah it's just been a really great experience every time I've sat down to play it I'm looking forward to playing it more I'm a little concerned about getting burned out with these locations so I don't think I'm going to try to get it out at every single game day I am hoping they put out more content for the game but but all those things considered I still hardly recommend this one it's been a super fun time for me and odds are good it'll be a great time for you at this point I'd like to thank everybody who's been supporting this Channel Through patreon including the producer level pledges if you too would like to directly support
all these videos that I make here you could do so at patreon.com jongetsgames and I'd really appreciate it also if You' like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching