Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 27:05

thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games online and Brad and I are doing a discussion over Earth one of the most uh critically acclaimed games that was coming out in 2023 uh and I mean here's the thing this game was I think because there's so many of these games that come out now uh I'm not even like attributing any of it to wingspan just because that's about birds and it's like yeah that might have done like the nature like the nature thing but I mean if we're just taking games that have pretty pictures uh Meadow has it Arc Nova uh it's real life and then I mean I don't really know if you would call this game but a game called Keepers which is literally based off some dude's photography we call it the coffee table book game because it's just ooh look at the pretty pictures uh so it was kind of like when I saw this I initially was gonna back it but then I backed out because then I'm like really like do I need another one of these and eventually uh this is your copy that you got but then I'm like yeah sure I'll late pledge and I gotta say I'm super glad I did I think this game has some pretty significant legs and more depth to it than you would actually think uh so it's not just a game that has an amazing cover with beautiful and

gorgeous artwork I mean well I guess sorry not artwork because it's just photos that are most likely enhanced through Photoshop but man it is just so nice to see and I appreciate when games like this put little facts uh just to be like just if you're waiting for someone's turn and you're like I already did all my actions it's your turn I'm just gonna read what these oh that's pretty neat so I very much enjoy it as scratches uh really really good part of my brain so what do you think of Earth I really like it um it was kind of daunting when you first started kind of looking at it because there's a lot of symbology and stuff but then they do a good job of showing the stuff you know yeah once you learn the routine like this is one of those games that you just need to get it to the table and play it because once you start playing it then you understand the rhythm of the game yeah uh the the thing that is really cool about this game is uh well it has a [ __ ] ton of cards but then like it says in the rule book you know like it brings up that deal because there's all these different cards the way you set up your initial setup and there's there's all there's 25 600 possible setups yeah and because every one of those cars is double-sided when you're doing this stuff so all the fauna cards all the environment cards or ecosystem cards you you put them out and then they're double-sided so it's like they're yeah there's only uh What uh 60

90 104 cards yeah because 64 and two sets is two sets of 20. oh yeah but it's in half of that so it'd be 10 it'd be 10 20. and 32 sets 52 cards double-sided yeah is all it is but it's like that just changes the whole setup and then you have your huge deck of cards just massive cards with uh with just different ways that you're gonna build out your Tableau because I love Tableau Builders I mean everdel like shot up in my top 100 just because it it just always works verdant is another one that's about plants and that's what you're mainly putting down over in your Tableau like in my head I thought you were gonna be doing Animals as well as just everything right but I'm actually glad I like I like the way they did it but there's a bunch of other games that I can see them like piecing apart because um Cascadia has like your animals as like your scoring objectives that's the exact same thing here with your fauna um of like oh that's those are ways you can score and then you have your ecosystem cards which I just love personal objectives that you have one and then in the standard game you get two public ones um and then you're doing a lot of stuff with the actual Flora in your Tableau and then there's also terrain which is just end game victory points as well it's kind of like a mishmash of a bunch of different stuffs that really synergizes together that it's like hmm yeah everything here works and the best part about it which might

be a negative to some people is the uh uh the fact that it's pretty much multiplayer Solitaire yeah like you're the only thing and I love this is I choose an action everyone else gets to do that like there's so many games that we've played over the last few years with like uh uh what's that one yeah that one uh Boone Lake oh yeah and all these different where you pick an action and then the other person gets a lesser version of that yeah so that so the downtime isn't there you know like you talked about reading the cards yeah when your turn's over but yet you really don't have that much time because when your turns over then you're waiting as soon as they pick an action because you don't have to sit and wait the first few rounds we did yeah we were waiting to see how things were going but then once we pick an action it's like okay he's playing this too so I'm gonna plant my one draw my card be ready so it's like their down time is pretty minimal it is yeah because in this it's not just you get a you get a lesser secondary action you get that on top of the fact that you also get to run off everything so there are times where you're kind of like you hope he picks green hope you pick screen like because I would like to plant also and I have some things that do well with green hope he picks blue because that's what I need to pop off for uh and it just feels nice this is a very feel-good game I I think this would be one of those games that's like next level it's not Gateway there's way more going on but

it's like it's like if you're wanting something that's a little bit more crunchier that you can keep track of with but with the icons all making sense this isn't a bad one to jump out especially because you don't have to do the ecosystem cards right like that's just if you want extra weights to score I would say this would be a step under Arc Nova yeah just because there's multiple scoring tracks yeah like if you were doing like Cascadia then this one then Arc Nova if you're just doing a fun uh Earth game yeah and I just think that's awesome like just tons of different ways to score like it even says 25 000 different scoring opportunities because it's like yeah you're fauna then your Island and your climate um like the the strategies that you and I went for based off what we had were just radically different and I'm like hey this is what's working for me these are the cards that I've decided to place and I'm gonna try and go for two of these well I got ended up getting three of them but it's like okay well that one's about bushes that's a Siberian tiger I'ma get bushes because they hold a [ __ ] ton of sprouts that I want and the uh great whatever uh the great step steep step step is all about uh bushes as well sure let's just let's go for that it's amazing uh and it just again

just having the artwork makes it that much more Lush and pretty like I don't really have any negatives honestly I don't really either I was trying to think if there was anything I I everything's worth points yeah I mean like even just throwing making a compost pile you don't do anything with this pile it's just getting cards out of your hand yeah or out of the deck or out of your um is there some stuff that takes out of this yeah things but but yeah it's and then the events were cool some of them were really powerful events but they would cause negative points to the end of the game yeah you know so I mean there's just a lot of different stuff and I like that the events weren't like as in like terraforming Mars they have like events that like dick over other players oh yeah these were all just they're all like for whatever you want to do to give you something like yeah the solar flare that I was going to possibly do it was get rid of a sprout and take down two growth okay and then I could draw three cards yeah you know it's like just just different stuff like that yeah that was also well it was it was worth zero victory points yeah one that would have been great for me is Hurricane it's like it's negative one point I lose three growth but gets six sprouts and that's essentially six points yeah because I ditched I had a whole hand of them at once I had tsunami that was four minus four victory points yeah but it was minus five growth drop five cards okay you know and and there's just a lot of different a lot of different stuff with that but and I think this game does something a little bit better than Arc

Noah does because I know a major complaint of Arc Nova is just that market deck there's like no real way to cycle through it you might just be like man I'm glad I have all these abilities that are none of the animals that are coming out this game like just lets you oh I mean a specific action is just drawing four cards like oh do that hurricane I'm gonna use this you play the hurricane and get nine cards there's no okay because there's no hand limit yeah um you could get cards out you know like this that gets carts out of your hand which they become victory points then so you want to get a bunch of cards in your hand so you can get them over there exactly yeah because my opening hand was basically based off of they were all really cheap so my but for this game uh funny enough we both scored the same amount 36 points just from what we had but I I finished mine yeah so they were all pitily ass points but I was going for other strategies I was basically going for a massive Sprout run because one of them was like Hey getting a sprout on each bush in this row so I like that there's stuff that works within your tableau uh yeah I mean it's surprising because I I expected this game to be kind of like keepers just so hey here's pretty pictures we don't really have a game behind it just look at the nice pictures uh but inside of who have they done anything else inside up yeah they've done uh I can't think of anything off my head but yeah they've done some uh while

you're looking that up um the one thing that I thought was cool was these terrain cards because I had two of them that could be pretty detrimental in a game because like I use this one and actually used your red cards yeah that was really weird it cost me nine dirt both of these kind though because I had two very they were nine dirt each okay but it's like I get two per Red Zone in anything and then mine is and then I also had the yellow ones so I was able to use that to kind of go but I think that's another thing with this is it also brings the puzzle because some cards that is what this was there's little arrows so it's like oh yeah like so like you need to really pay attention to where you're putting stuff yeah as well to maximize your point so there's a puzzle as far as setting stuff up well because you have to go from top left to bottom right when you activate right so if you put someone in the in the wrong order where it's like you have to spend like oh spend a sprout to do this oh I don't have one but the next card I have gives me one it's like dang it I should have put them uh okay so they did the only is gorus Maximus that's it no no they did another game called uh block and key oh yeah which I did not like block and key it was cool like 3D abstract Tetris kind of game but it was it was just kind of weird I knew I'd seen it on something yeah recent but inside up did sound familiar but like this is most likely they're definitely

most popular game this will be their Evergreen probably you know like it's just this is like a centerpiece like you want to showcase that box cover right it's so pretty and if I'm not mistaken I could just be pulling this out of my ass but I and I feel like every nature game does this but I think they did a lot of I think they planted trees for each copy that they sold because I feel like I got an email of like hey we planted 20 000 trees or something yeah it was either this or earthboard Rangers did something like that all the fun nature games kind of do sure and for me like that's a massive win in my book uh now earthborn Rangers did they were everything was local they were the ones they didn't do shipping they made the hubs in every country so they would have all the fossil fuel burnings yes I know I got an email something about some game that sold that planted a [ __ ] ton of trees yeah which is like yay uh so yeah this game has a massive amount of replayability if now here's the question if you have Cascadia Burton Arc Nova Meadow keepers is this worth getting I don't know Keepers that one's just more uh pictures it's not really a game so the other four I haven't played verdant okay uh Cascadia I feels a lot lighter than this um I would say

I think so I like like if I had to choose like if I had to make my decision off of those games yeah like Cascadia would be gone okay this one's higher than Cascadia for me just because yeah it's more it's not as abstract that you kind of like how Cascadia is you know like this one's more you're building out your your Tableau and you get to have some control on where you're placing stuff and building stuff and everything scores I mean like you were in the 200 you know I actually I did forget I was the first one okay so let me let me hold on let me add my support 258. 2 30. whatever but I mean I'll go to 250 but let's give me some more but yeah I mean it's like there's just so many ways correcting it there's so many so many ways to score on this and there's so much replayability I mean like with all those cards how you start and how those are going to be different every time that's so cool the deck's so big so you're not gonna get the same layout of the cards every time I think this one is better than those just because of the yeah I I still like Arc Nova better uh I do too as far as like I don't know what this would be like for player yeah you know I don't know how that would change because we've only played this by the way at two right um being a solo-ish type experience I think that would just take two I mean of course it might not take that long because if everybody's familiar with the game everybody's doing it at the same time yeah but I wonder how that works like this so everybody everyone does the secondary in the next one but that's why

it's all simultaneous so it's like it's like okay do action every time you'd be like loading up on dirt between your next turn I think it goes up to five dude yeah because it says one to five yeah could you imagine though like it's like I'm gonna do the this action and you're gonna be like just dirt everywhere yeah all right everyone let's uh let's I gotta do all my red stuff yeah uh but yeah and I like that I like the fact that you don't really hinder anyone because these are all the you know terrain and stuff cards you're just like oh we have five people okay this is [ __ ] yeah you just throw them in this is the deck you draw from this is the deck you draw from Michelle them better uh yeah yeah I don't want to hear it they were all sleeved I could have shuffled them God can you imagine how big this guy could be sleeping I think all my arc Nova cards all right I kind of do the Millennium blades and have like a stack it's like I didn't look through all those let's just keep those out yeah that would probably be my only gripe and it's very minor I have the same with Arc Nova is that that's just [ __ ] annoying to shuffle like you played a bunch eventually just gonna kind of self-shuffle but oh man well and I'm not gonna sleeve a game like this because it's not like you're I mean you're pretty much putting them out yeah it's not like you're constantly like aeon Zen like deck build yeah stuff like that you know but yeah but no I like I said this one this one and Arc Nova are probably my favorite two of the the whole nature the nature games games

um yeah I mean I like a ball this is a theme that really works for me um I usually am one that is kind of very uh like liberal about a lot of like stuff this is kind of like I don't I don't [ __ ] care like I I just this is yeah these are my beliefs but do whatever the [ __ ] you want just don't affect me kind of like mentality um but nature is something that does it's like oh cool like more animals going extinct that's [ __ ] amazing uh so I'm like really big on like nature themes uh and it's really nice to read a fact where it's not like there were only three Siberian tigers Left Alive it's like I don't want to play anymore I'm [ __ ] depressed um because like this one says it's fur coat it's paler and has fewer Stripes than other species to help it blend in with the snow that's nice that's a nice fact about this very very to know do I know there's not a lot of Siberian tigers left uh then then yeah but I don't have to think about it because I have that fun fact to know how it Blends in with the snow and it also tells you when you're going and this is something other games do but it's very much appreciated when you're looking for strategies and you're like I think maybe Arc Nova does this I know for a fact wingspan does it it shows you the percentage how much how many percent like what percentage of cards are bushes yeah not apparently 19 and I got them all uh because I've I got a bunch of bushes yeah because there's 25 percent have brown yeah I didn't get any of them I

got one some like like I got those but that's the thing is if I wanted to go for that then I started putting cards in my Tableau that let me draw right I started doing this action to start cycling yeah yeah in here too so yeah it was it was so yeah I would I would agree with you I think Arc Nova if the nature themes is still up there because I like the idea of a zoo but at the same time thematically I hate zoos in my life of the conservation part of North Nova yeah yeah there are a lot of leaders now that are definitely more for preservation or conservation of like save hey by the way we kind of kind of keep them here otherwise they'll all die from coachers who need to be executed uh this one's like oh they're out there that's nice so it it works I I this is kind of like that I love cats thing where it's like a bunch of just different stuff that just yeah there's a lot of stuff but it's not too crazy um I will say that this is one of those games just like an arc Nova or anything like that that will highly favor somebody that plays has played it before or has played it more I think at least at least early in the game until it's alike you know you know how to set up and know how to roll oh you know like like the uh you know if I've played it five times and I'm teaching somebody I'm gonna be

able to steamroll them at least for the first half until they get a grasp of it based off of like yeah how you what which ones you choose right and stuff like that how this works and how the the Synergy because there's there is a there's a an overall Synergy to this game knowing like how to place your cards and and what actions to do that's gonna fire off everything you know so once I'm not saying that's gonna be the entire game but I'm just being like you could get a good leg up playing with me yeah that are an experience because you could get a good setup early and right you know I mean just off the island like you're saying it's like my Santorini Island was nine points but I only get started with four cards in four soil and mine was eight and I started off with six cards put three in here yeah and then uh five dirt and five dirt yeah so I I basically benefited from one point but did yours have a ability on the uh the Brianna Brown and the brown ability yeah and then the other ones that helped me get the bear the other one oh I get it now it's a brown bear and it was based on Brown ability that's stupid from event cards um yeah the event cards what was this one the ability because I never did it because we don't have a brown I guess that went to the brown abilities are conditional because mine was like draw a card slash lightning bolt um yeah because remember I had the one that was like a barrel oh draw a card per draw a card per event card I played I

bet yeah so I wasn't doing that yeah and then the bear or not like my other option was a baron Island it's one point but I draw ten cards cycle two and I get six soil yeah and then mine was uh only worth two points but it was draw eight uh put three in there and get eight or yeah but then you're also looking at certain icons of like okay whether this is sunny wet Rocky or snow and man yeah that that arctic fox needed eight cards and I was like I was like looking for him and I got exactly eight it's like haha that makes a point to say in here that you pay attention to these before you select your because to know which one you want to go for if you need the winter you know which I didn't have anything that was Winter I you know funny enough either oh I did my other side was a tundra but it I because I saw the arctic fox uh and I picked my thing I was like okay yeah like Santorini tropical Monsoon Thai Islands or Thai Highlands yeah that's all nice that's like warm climate and then it's like how am I gonna get eight snow over here uh and I'm just glad this isn't restrictive I'm glad it's not like oh you can't you know get plants because you don't have like icons or some weird you're always able to do something yeah yeah it's very it's very free and not all and it's also not that long yeah like it feels like it goes by quick because you're only building a four by four you can't remove them and every

time this takes you're giving two cards at least two there was one time I actually chose not to right because you were yeah because I was I finished stuff for you yeah well my plan I was like I I planted one because I didn't think you were gonna do a green so I was hoping to do blue again to fill up even more sprouts and then end it uh but yeah it's I'm actually surprised at how good this game is uh because they could have just chalked it up as pretty pictures and then just half-ass it with an actual theme but they got it here uh Maxime tardiff and Connor presented Bike by Conor mcgui I wonder what presented means uh

we just see him in a thong at Gen Con he's just like holding up earth like with a help me yeah holding up he's like like coded in bronze he's shredded I'd be like damn I already got a copy I'll buy another one can you lick it I would hope he's like that yeah just all bronzed and gunked up because he's gooey gosh uh anyway uh you got anything else you have any negatives I can't really think of anything I really think so I mean yeah like I said once like there's just a tiny bit of a curve of getting to figuring out the flow early once you get that though yeah like the more you play it I mean you're just gonna know this is how this goes yeah this does the same thing as kind of uh if you watch my review of Darwin's journey is that it looks busier than it actually is like both of those games are kind of like oh my God there's just so much stuff and then you play like one round and you're like all right never mind I got it yeah and then you're really into it yeah so yep um on scale of one to ten what are you giving earth oh gosh I think I've got a creep all the way up to nine I'm at nine as well yeah I mean it's solid and I want to see what the solo is like you know just to see yes art Nova's solo so good yeah you know I just just to see but I mean even it too like like with this being like you had said The more or less I'm solo

multiplayer solitary game I mean you know yeah I mean they do have some stuff but it's like because Arc Nova is very multiplayer Solitaire and the only there's a stupid fight yeah it's so dumb it's so dumb it feels forced yeah this one that didn't feel forced whenever you had your Tundra and you're like hey I get two points right it didn't affect you no yeah yeah it's not like you took away anything from me you didn't hurt me in any way you're just like hey how many Reds you got over there I'm like uh eight you're like cool yeah I'm like oh but that's the thing is I'm over here I'm not like okay I guess I'll stop playing Reds you know no no it's not that kind of game well and I put it at the end anyway so that's true that's true you know um but even then it's like this is kind of like not the atmosphere to be like well I didn't know you could do I wouldn't have oh no it's like a little yeah dude can you calm down uh beautiful beautiful game elegant very smart enjoyed it a lot so uh you got anything else no I don't think so all right well that's our thoughts on Earth let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other

run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved