Skip to main content
Loading video...

Black Rose Wars: Rebirth - Discussion

Transcript 29:40

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlock and Brad and I are doing a discussion over black rose Wars rebirth um this is the soft reboot essentially of black rose Wars um it's essentially the same game now you have never played the original Black Rose Wars um so it'll be mainly me doing a lot of comparisons uh but to be honest there's not really a lot uh that's different so yeah cuz from what I understand the original you're you're tearing down the place that's when you're building it back up yeah they really kind of made this more of a thematic thing where yeah the original every room had these uh you know abilities on it that could be used but when you're placing instability uh you still get points um well actually you get trophy you basically collect these um and then the room's destroyed so the ability is gone uh yeah this one is in the opposite all rooms of the same color have the same ability to begin with and then it's when they're restored that they get a unique one which I actually don't mind I no it's it's nice it's kind of just like oh okay I know what the gray rooms do I know what the purple rooms do it's a lot easier to just come into this one knowing that versus okay what does every single room do and you know they had specific player aids for the

activation of rooms alone uh and this one it's it's just cleaner from the get-go even though ludus Magnus Studios is not a clean company their games are kind of um I don't know like poorly written isn't really what I'd say it just feels like that they're like 75% of the way there like they they need probably like I I don't know if they do but if they don't or if they do they need to get someone else they just need to bring a third party in to kind of like proof you know proof read like this is worded weird you missed this just to kind of clean it up even though rebirth does a pretty good job um of being a little bit more streamlined so with all that being said well what do you think of black rose Wars um not like I not playing the original you know it looks daunting I've never really you know everybody always says it's it's uh um war on steroids I can see that I play I've played w wiiz war MH um and the first time I played this it took me half the game yeah to start really getting the gist of it mhm um but I mean yeah I mean it it it picked up pretty well now it's never going to be one that I'm I don't think I'll ever be able to play this with with my wife just cuz I she didn't like was like this would be too much for her I think I mean I might try it but but uh there is I don't know if there's

Cooperative in this box um I know the I know the original had the The Inferno yeah it came it had like solo scenarios as well as Co-op stuff so I'll have to look into that to see how much yeah uh play I'll get out of it I think some expansions like the apocalypse expansion I think came with Co-op scenarios I know there is that available or you can play against the the Avatar um which we did play so we didn't just do a two-player game because I just played Black Rose Wars Duel and that was that was hot [ __ ] um so I was like I don't want to do that because again with black rose Wars it it's the chaos of everyone's spells going off and traps and protections and dividing and conquering on who you're trying to attack so having the AI at least diverted some attention versus you and me just standing here the entire time I was worried about how that was going to go um are there more than one Avatar in the core game there is just this one so like I could like so technically if there was another like I could play a game against two avatars yeah yeah I think there's actually a video that someone's like oh solo play with three avatars so that's how I would probably get a played mostly I I mean that that would be it yeah the core game uh only has the possessed um but I think uh expansions bring in more right um so yeah you could have multiple uh AI yeah uh running the game um but anyway so yeah uh overall thoughts you liked it

yeah yeah I liked I I mean it was it was what I it didn't blow me out of the water cuz I I didn't know what to expect I it actually cuz I knew it was going to be a cool game I just didn't know um you know I like the different schools of magic and I know there's tons more of those when you get into cuz you can bring the schools the other game into this as well from my understanding everything is backwards compatible um even the I the the only thing that's kind of weird is the tiles because instability is basically reversed mhm um so I don't I don't think you can combine the rooms I would think the biggest thing to bring over would be all your magic because you have so many spells to choose from yeah and I like I like how you get that I like how you choose one at the beginning mhm to be your focus but then you can really start like cuz I chose uh nightmare in this last play I chose nightmare found out later on that it was okay but it wasn't so I just went all Agony like I I was just grabing four Agony four AG yeah the deck halfway through yeah and I chose and yeah that's the great thing about Black Rose Wars is they have schools of magic that are just unheard of they have your traditional ones but then like um I went with hex that's the one I picked just randomly and it dealt with a lot of jinx cards that you assigned to players and they have to you know oh your movement's reduced every time you take a jinx or every time you're you take a damage just a bunch of like hindering cards but yeah they all play different and that's the thing about this that is

immediately better I honestly would say I mean yeah black rose of Wars Duel is way cheaper it's 50 bucks but it's a far inferior game as two it's like this at two was wasn't bad I still like it with more I still think three actual players uh for actual players is where this game shines um cuz then you're competing for damage and this the the AI just kind of everyone I mean it really just focused me because it just happened to be near me the whole time M um I kept my distance right but whenever you're having to be like okay who do I want to attack like can I try and beat them out on damage for that for that person can I try and kill him um competing for quests and and events affecting multiple players is just better um but you also just feel unique with how your deck is going um cuz a lot of mine were I I I was actually kind of starting to do Agony as well but like going back through my deck it ended up being hex and technomancy yeah I had so much red that was that was my my go cuz I was like I wasn't early in the game I was going that way because it was you know any any any game when you're when you're still learning the minutia of it dealing damage feels like you're doing something right so like if I was going to get more plays in I know the minutia now I would

look at hex I would look at stuff like that and stuff this one's one of those that definitely uh rewards a lot of plays yeah because then you know you can start understanding yeah how each deck works and back of each uh card that tells you kind of what like the rules for that um which helps but most of the time I just pick a a cool school and start with there and I mean you just have so much Freedom like again in in Black ORS Wars Duel you will only ever have one school yeah and it's like okay so we're basically the same exact Mage like that's just extremely boring dueling hufflepuffs it's like and like the school was so lame all it did was like bring in skeletons that's like pretty much all it did it was so boring um but here again it's like I'm just going to focus like you could just go all in like pick Agony from the beginning and only take those cards and it's it's going to work uh the ones we didn't really touch I looked a little bit at shamanic and Alchemy um but they just didn't synergize with the rest of my cards yeah the only shamanic card I used was the totem that that time came out of there yeah but that was yeah yeah no for sure this is um it's a cool one for sure and um it's not intuitive like even rebirth like black original Black Rose Wars had a lot of like I had to actually

print off like player AIDS because I was like man this is kind of all over the place if you're looking to get one or the other I would honestly say get rebirthed it's a cleaner game yeah that's what I've heard uh like this is a good jumping entry point and then look at getting all the other stuff just for the sheer variety for it cuz again you're just going to have 30 schools of magic like something like that I'd have to count them all again but it's an insane amount and that's the thing it's like like uh you you focused on Agony and I focused on packs uh and we still have like there's T four 6 8 10 12 14 17 cards left in agony uh there now every single card is not unique um but there's a good variety and I would actually not really like it if they all were 100% unique because then you don't really get a combo yeah there there was definitely a lot of creativity put into those decks you know and some and the cards are well thought out like that one I had where I was uh anytime that one person I put that spell on gained or lost victory points they were taking two damage every time so so it's like and it happened to work with me cuz I kept stealing points from him or like I was like I'll give him points and that Dam a neat little thing right yeah it's just like like I said it's a more complex whiz War like I wouldn't go

into this game I like I still wouldn't go into this game taking it super seriously but I'm not going to be all goofy haha like whiz war is meant to be um so what did you think of the actual AI um it wasn't super predictable which I like cuz some some games like this you know it's they're predictable what they're going to do you know I mean I know he has a small deck and different stuff and I like how some of the the tops of the cards show that they were defense yeah so you kind of had to think like okay I'm going to do this is it going to hit me back is it going to uh block most of my attack you know what's it going to do yeah um which is like an actual player cuz it's like not every protection spell is reducing damage not every trap spell is countering something and they were every time you took damage from uh from um pain or whatever it would help him out yeah um I don't think it's it's I'll put it this way it's not the best AI I've played against but it's not definitely not the worst say probably on the on the top third of AI type stuff you know it's like yeah I didn't really think he was he doesn't replace another player like it's not like oh this is just like having a third player but it is a better alternative than just playing it at two it serves his purpose exactly if you were playing I think this would actually be better if you had three players and the and then the AI to round it out at four which is all you can do in the with the core box

you can because it has to use a model from and then use Mage now you can play this game up to six so if you have um if you have the expansion a deadly mask I think which gives you six players um you could have five players and the and the AI right uh so I I actually I'll kind of like what you're saying is I like that it's included uh versus not at all because then it's this game is not good at two um and black rose Wars Duel is a good example of that but um he's a little weird there's there's they didn't like overe explain like kind of how he works like there's a lot of things where it's like okay so he doesn't have a number for his targeting system so it just says he moves towards the nearest Green Room like if he's next to two green rooms I guess the person could has the CR marker get get the to move towards you or away and then yeah and this game has always kind of done something really cool one I think that they do a really good job with kind of its lore I mean it's not like a narrative game but they do put in lore of around what the Black Rose war or the Black Rose Lodge is but I've always loved the inclusion of the Black Rose in the original it was just kind of the lodge mhm my understanding was thematically It was kind of dictating who was worthy of becoming the next Arch Mage so if the Black Rose actually got the most points no one was worthy of

being it so everyone loses but it's not everyone versus the launch it's just basically it's a glorified timer like Hey we're all and diing just points uh so we're only getting one one one stuff like that and it's like eventually the game will end if someone just can't get to 30 and that's what the AI does um it can kill you you can Target it you can just do more stuff to interact with it but it's still gaining points completing quests doing event cards the one thing I don't like about it though is it the AI completely replaces the event deck um with his own which would originally be fine but there's only five cards each yeah so it's so it's very minimal I wonder if there's more in some of the and there might be like in some of the boxes some of the other expansion stuff uh that could very well be the case but at the core level it's five first moon phases 5 Second and 53d uh even though we didn't go through all of them um like and then this particular game it got to 21 points which is kind of the highest I've seen but I've also never had the Black Rose win I've played Black Rose Wars a ton and it's never won um yeah but this last play I didn't I didn't score a point until you you were at 18 before I even scored a my first that's what I was telling you but then you yeah you got the Black Rose which got you six points you killed someone you got four that's 10 points right there I kind of end up this thing was [ __ ] me over the whole game stealing points from me so I'm just like oh I was like there was a point where I'm like is he going to

[ __ ] catch up I wasn't too far behind no I was like am I really just going to like have this huge early lead then you were like oh hey I'm starting to get it um but but I mean I guess that's a a you know tribute to the to the AI like kind of makes thematic sense I'm the one sticking next to an enemy so why wouldn't he Target me the whole time right uh versus like well he's really far away plus my dude's ugly he didn't want to come close to my D well I'm like this weird Phantom of the Opera wannabe guy uh so maybe he just want to see your face he CH us the gross half of your face um but yeah also what's great about this game and not Black Rose Wars Duel is they have the inclusion of the quest cards and the quest cards are actually these feel a little bit different um because in the original the quest cards were basically like here's a condition do it you complete it right uh all the quest cards in this one uh kind of have you work for it but you get the points and you also get the like this one is Elementalist so I resolve basically a carard with an element and I have to do that four times if I do I get to place four in stability in a room and I also get three points I really like the quest cards in this a lot more I like that it's not just you can't necessarily top deck a quest right you can't just be like I'm going to use this to draw a quest and oh hey I can immediately do that Five Points the only way I think you could

would be like the ones like these that have the symbols so if you resolve an effect on one of your spells that has these two different symbol you know yeah then you get to but you're still you still have to do that multiple oh yours was yeah mine was that oh yours was an immediate oh okay so I mean you could get lucky if you put the Spells down this one even says one of your spells and you have three of those symbols on the active side so you would have had to actually play so that you could get lucky I mean it would be extremely lucky if you happen to do that but it's possible yes if but for the most part A lot of the quests are you're you putting cubes on them to get them completed which I I enjoy I think that's a smart smart change uh other additions that are in the core set that I don't really recall in the original was upgrades so they have a lot of cards that you can actually put upgrades on your evocations giving them unique like hey this has extra attack this has extra movement this heals um uh I mean some like corrosive they're not all good corrosive plasma the target of this model's attack becomes Target zero so it can only hit things in its spot I think that's neat makes evocations a little bit more exciting versus just oh this thing just does two damage moves and does two damage but I don't think there's really a change they did that I don't like what did your big spell do cuz you

you got one of those yeah the Forgotten spells it was uh yeah it was a six damage one oh that's right okay just inflict six damage to anyone in the room anywhere anywhere six damage uh and the other one was to any room put five in stability oh that's cool see I never really used the dark sides of my cards and that was another thing I was going to bring up like like when you I was looking at all these it almost seemed like the light sides were easier to understand to me like cuz the yes the dark sides were more convoluted a little bit you seem or like hypers specific right so so that's why I went Light Side on majority funny enough my character was a huge counter against a nightmare school or a huge benefit because he his specific spell was called wanderer's dream and it's remove up to two Nightmares From The Lodge for each removed nightmare I can assign a nightmare to any Mage uh those nightmares activate under my control um but I didn't realize that the umbros were nightmares whenever I was like so I never use them and then as you were putting them out I'm like oh [ __ ] I should probably use my own spell um yeah I don't I don't really know if they fixated on the light vers dark I think that could have just been a thematic effect it could just be happen stand well at the beginning when I was first learning this I thought maybe there were certain places that you had to be to fire off the dark side like a massive Darkness yeah like they're better if you're in the dark you know dark versus light or something but but yeah I think it was just a way to get multi-use cards yeah cuz like one of the

hex things is black feather um steal one point assign the weakness Jinx to the Target I can move myself up to one but the dark side is I can place myself in a in the same room as the Target and if it has at least one assigned Jinx I get to steal a point and then I can place the Target in a blue or yellow room um again I I really still do not think even with the AI that this is a two-player game right because fun stuff like that is like hm we're all pretty far away from each other but what would be funny is if I teleport across the room and you next to next to no third player and then now he gets to go and he might just straight up attack you or vice versa be like I'm going to you know bounce on out of here which is one of the biggest worries I have with this because I have the retail version of the original and the and the Inferno and then I have the kickstarter of this yeah if it plays three or four at the best I don't know if I'm going to ever get that right so that's that's my that's my worry like like no I agree if it's going to get played a whole lot as much as I do like it m like I don't I just don't know that'll be something I have to think about and stuff sure nope that uh that totally makes sense because it does it does definitely makes sound like more of a three or four player experience wizo would be the same way playing whis with two people is pretty lame you just like never move right um so rebirth people say yeah best at four

yeah 16 people say it's best at four let's look at OG cuz this game just came out so OG one that came out in 2019 sitting at an eight uh also best at four that's 75 people and I would agree I I do think three is good um just because of the sheer nature of gathering points um normally in three player fighting games one person just gets caught in the middle and [ __ ] I've played this where you just are like well I've done six damage to you they're not going to beat me out on that so then like we'll just like you'll just start trading points back and forth um but still more games like this four I've never played six um but I have played six would be insane cuz it's the same size a lodge isn't it cuz you just put the yep just now rooms crap that' be [ __ ] flying you'd be dying all the time like the game's probably and maybe that's why people don't recommend it because it might just be like super quick yeah like if you're dying all the time you're never really getting to do spells probably move the moons up more possibly I don't think so is it always I really don't think so I think the 30 this was a five like it wasn't it was at six well no I know but like why is there a Five Spot up there you know what I'm saying like oh that's true know way moved if there was a way it shov around and that might be uh a variant actually now that you say that I think there are rules that you could kind of adjust when the phases pop off um but I I I do think four is probably the sweet spot so looks like it it's uh

it's definitely a game worth getting this game is I I still think Super unique like they really put in and L Magnus doesn't do a whole lot of games I do think this is very much their best one mhm and the other cool thing is all their stuff they actually put on their store yeah you know like all the stuff that I missed out on uh on their store and it's like oh cool even during their um the current pledge that was going off um someone asked hey I just need expansions and they're like it's on our store go get it yeah I thought that was interesting how they just pop right back onto game found just for like the Allin everything play that was it you did it all in but I wish you could do I think they just kind of had they just had overstocked copies and they're like hey for a cheaper price get it all cuz Kickstarter won't let you do that unless you add new content oh I knew that was with I thought it was with all of them rabit game found must let you put on rep put on there because they didn't add anything new I guess so Kickstarter won't let you do that that's true so that was interesting yeah that's why it's always like second print and like a mini expansion on Kickstarter yeah I thought that was a crowdfunding thing but I guess it might just be exclusive to Kickstarter but yeah I mean it's it's well worth the money um to get the extra stuffed after that I think I paid a little bit more but they were available um they like to combine their worlds cuz this is technically called Nova adus novais yeah that's some Renaissance game that they've made I don't know anything about it and then

they have their C tempore game which is just [ __ ] up that that game is just all over the place I I've tried it so many times and I'm like no NOP the best thing about that game is they you can do a party of all the characters from Space Balls oh yeah um funny so yeah again if you have to if you can get if you have the choice between the rebirth or the OG I say go rebirth oh yeah I would too I mean not even played the other one but no and mhm if this is if this is more streamlined yeah then I wouldn't even mess with the other one now yeah well yeah to be fair the the other they basically kind of did a that was like one of their first games and with the expansions The Inferno and the Seder box they did clean it up uh and the rules for my understanding on how the turn structures work is pretty much exactly the same kind of just once you understand that casting your spells the three you place on the bottom are programmed essentially so you have to put them in a certain order that you hope they trigger um and then you get two act two actions a turn and you cannot cast ready spells twice in a row so it's just kind of little things like that that you just kind of have to understand and then understanding like oh [ __ ] like I put a I put like a trap card as my very last one and everyone's already passed so no one's going to be doing it right so you kind of just learn things as you go

but yeah it's great it's great and there's a [ __ ] ton of I mean just the six schools alone are good to have like and then the like the madness last Dynasty Silk Road Antiquities North winds and once upon a time I don't think they all add schools of magic but I think quite a few of them do yeah cuz all I got was just the regular like I didn't get the apocalypse on it stuff I just got the rebirth box that you know what I have that and then the character yeah I haven't didn't buy all the other stuff that you right so that's adding a bunch of more schools I just like having all the schools yeah it's so cool um but yeah on a scale of 1 to 10 what you giving Black Rose Wars rebirth I think I'm going to give it a solid seven seven yeah good game because you're never getting this played yeah I know I know that that's that's the reason I mean if it had more of a bigger Cooperative element and it might I just don't remember um than it would be a point or so higher mhm um but right now and Seven's good yeah I mean seven Seven's still a great game I know to a lot of people whenever it's like cuz every time like Dice Tower someone gives things an eight they're like I know that's low it's like what are you talking about there's seven other numbers lower than that it's not like you gave this game A two uh but yeah yeah just to remind a lot of people who have not seen my channel

as far as I'm aware everyone agrees with me on my ranking five is average five is average six is slightly above average Seven's good eight 8 n and it really doesn't matter at the end of the day but um so yeah yeah I was wondering if you'd give a seven or an eight yeah that was it was it could be easily pushed to an eight sure like depending on what else I explore mhm so with the caveat it could be an eight if it has good co-op Sol Co-op stuff that throw tosses in there but as currently where it stands what we've played I'll do a seven yeah uh I'm keeping it out a nine like I I just I love dueling Mages as a theme and there's more and more of those coming out but they're typically card games and the only other game that's close to this is ion which is like a it's like a skirmish like you yeah heard of it um and that game is close but they wanted it to be like they give you a pamphlet as the rules and it's like so with a game that has a a lot of Nu on and it I just felt like it wasn't clean and I was constantly asking questions this one still I'm it's it's not clean I'm conly ask some questions but at least the questions I have can be answered uh and yeah just a sheer amount of schools now that because now I will have everything I'll just have [ __ ] what just I'm count whenever we're done with this I'm going to count how many schools there are uh but yeah I'm keeping it at nine still a blast because I have played at three and four and it's chaos and it's

just super fun yeah so that's our thoughts on Black Rose Wars rebirth let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful what every time ofd is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you

Progress saved