Skip to main content
Loading video...

Lord of the Rings - Duel for Middle Earth First Impressions

Transcript 22:44

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this video I'm going to be sharing my first impressions of Lord of the Rings The Duel for middlee uh this is a one of the latest hotness and newest games from Antoine Baza and Bruno catala as based off of seven or not um what's it called Seven Wonders duel the very popular two-player game that this is based off of utilizing the Lord of the Rings theme this was announced and talked about during Gen Con this year and released in at around essent time I believe here in the states and so I think this game is readily available if you want to purchase it in person and there have been a lot of videos and posts about this game already so I look forward to sharing my two cents for what it's worth before we get into this like I mentioned before this is heavily based off of Seven Wonders duel and so if you do not know that game in particular that is a dual two-player version of Seven Wonders and those games those games have been around for quite a while and have received a lot of Praise And so I recommend that you check out a Channel or a Blog Post online about those games or just look for them as well I believe they're probably pretty cheap or fairly cheap to play and you can see for yourself what those are like but essentially in those games all of these games these are card-based games that that you're trying

to achieve Victory conditions rather than points well I should say conditions in this game with the others you can win by in Seven Wonders you can win by points but in Seven Wonders duel there are conditions that you can meet such as uh advancing your military across the track all the way to one end or collecting you know all the science tokens Etc and so uh you're essentially drafting cards building up uh a resource engine to be able to achieve one of those Victory conditions first before your opponent otherwise it goes down to points that's all I'm going to say about seven wonders duel and now focusing on uh the Dual for Middle Earth so uh so this game Where Do We Begin so it's utilizing the same mechanisms as Seven Wonders duel the way that you lay out your cards to draft from is the same the and a lot of the iconography and the ways that you play the game are here as well I will say that the coinage system is simplified to any icon that you're missing is reduced to just one coin that you're missing you don't really need to pay attention to what your opponent has for example the additions to this game reflect the theme of Lord of the Rings pretty well starting off with the main board in this game the military red cards that you would normally use to advance along a track in Seven Wonders duel is used to place and uh in with future cards move these uh Army tokens around the board and as

you can see here I I quickly played this game as a learning game against myself uh utilizing a dice to you know make choices in in a pinch when I needed to for the my own OPP opponent but as you can see I did win this game by uh reaching one of the victory conditions of having a presence in all of these regions of Middle Earth and so the uh uh so there's a there's component of the game that you have to pay attention to in order to uh you know Place units and move them around represented by the military red cards you have this uh I guess the ring track I suppose is what you could call it which looks really neat in person but it essentially represents the nasgul chasing down froto and Sam as and and they almost won the uh the Sauron and his allies almost won this game by catching up to froto but essentially you're moving along until they meet or cross up and if you do that you win the game and I'll just move over to the other condition this reflects the science tokens that you would collect in Seven Wonders duel but you are racing to also gather allies in this game if you collect six of these different icons you immediately win the game and if you collect multiple sets of them such as I did here with two sets of elves you will be able to draw and choose from these special tiles that will give you some ongoing effects or some immediate ones

uh such as this uh if you do gather three different ones you'll be able to utilize you know draw three of those tokens and then choose one to keep and utilize so uh other than that you know just based off of the coloring of the cards you have your yellow cards for money the blue cards will advance you along this track in the third age when things start to ramp up more on my thoughts of how this game progresses later the a lot of these purple cards allow you to uh you know take away coins from your opponent to or take away uh troops from their opponents as well and then move your own to uh to a different region or adjacent region by the way combat is pretty simple if you happen to move a unit over and you have a conflict where there are opposing units in each territory in this particular territory you simply remove each uh of those units until uh you know some units remain so it's kind of a onetoone kind of pickoff type of situation that you have there finally you have these landscape tiles these replace the Wonders that you are that you draft and play in Seven Wonders duel this is available for anyone to purchase at any time on their turn rather than uh pick drafting a card from the central area here if you meet all of the requirements for the resources quote unquote resources that you need which are reflected in the gray cards here you will be able to take this landscape tile on your turn which

usually gives you a big bonus effect but they are quite expensive and the more landscape tiles you have the more costly in Gold they will be as well and so these are revealed three of them are revealed at the beginning of the game the Shire and uh I forgot this one it's called Grand it's the the battering ram these are shuffled in after the first three of this deck is shuffled and so you have a bunch of different landscape tiles that will be variably offered to you from game to game and from round to round you don't real you don't refill this until the beginning of a round and both my opponent and myself had built two of those and they were very impactful and that's basically it so obviously the comparison to this game that I make first is with seven wonders duel most of the mechanisms here are the same the biggest caveats I think are that Seven Wonders duel one has a endgame Victory condition of points where you do would add up a lot of points which kind of reflects how Seven Wonders duel took the mechanisms of Point scoring from Seven Wonders the base game and so in addition to these conditions that you can meet in Seven Wonders duel with the uh the science tiles that you're collecting as well as the military track you can always kind of end in a stalemate until you kind of come down to points at the end of the third age versus in Seven Wonders or SE uh the The Duel the Lord of the Rings

duel um it's a mouthful to to say and to remember you only have the conditions that you can meet here so there are no points that are seen in this game you can either reach Mount Doom or catch FR and Sam you can collect all of the green or you know all six of the different green symbols and you can also conquer Middle Earth by having a presence in each of these regions it doesn't matter if it's a Fortress or if it's a military unit so with that there I mean the implementation of what the cards do in particular the card colors may be the same and the general idea may be the same when you compare this game to Seven Wonders duel but their execution is different based off of the Thematic integration with the centralized map of Middle Earth as well as this uh ring track so yep those are the biggest differences oh and the way that the wonders of course are handled and in this game the quote unquote wonders are shared and offered in a market rather than drafted at the beginning of the game for you to personally build at your own time and and these wonders can be built without having to draft a card and so uh compare it that to Seven Wonders duel where you would have to discard a card or at least take that card purchase the wonder that you've built and slide that card underneath to show that you've taken your turn you don't have to do that in this game that option that you have left to instead take a landscape tile remains on the board and so that strategically may make a difference the other game that I'm going to compare this to is war of the Ring the card game

so both are Lord of the Rings themed uh card games primarily card games that really approach the storytelling of Lord of the Rings in kind of a different way in this game there is more of an abstraction in seven in uh Lord of the Rings duel there is more of an abstraction of the story itself you can see the elements of the story as you look at the cards and you know I mean some of these are like uh okay this looks like Helms Deep versus this this looks like you know the Return of the King era or you know part part of the the books where Gondor is involved right and I had built this card before taking the uh Helm steep card so the opportunity to kind of mix and match what the story kind of looks like in your own terms based off of how the cards appear and and in what order you do so could you know retell Lord of the Rings in a different way in this game I I feel like however you are taking more of an abstracted type of approach to that when you play this game I think it's more heavily focused on the mechanisms from Seven Wonders duel and then applying the theme on top of that to make some changes thereof whereas with war of the Ring the card game which is also based off of a system which I believe is called Quarter Master General the uh mechanisms are fairly similar between the two but the linear storytelling element is very much intact with war Waring the card game where you do follow the locations and events in a chronological order and you will uh play

cards and make small alterations to what you might understand and know from the the books and the movies themselves but you you know some characters might be a touch out of place and you might use a character where they weren't uh necessarily there at that period of time in regards to the books but they do go to that location for example uh you won't have you know characters that were completely not at a certain location in the books whatsoever in that game and so it's it's a really interesting I think more thematic based game with the mechanisms applied to it in in reverse order uh very much the opposite of I what I feel this game seven wonders or uh Lord of the Rings duel and the approach to developing this game was which was take the mechanisms of Seven Wonders duel and then add the story and the theme of Lord of the Rings on top of it it's done very beautifully uh Vincent D Tree Art of course and uh for example I love the ring track which carries a lot of the uh iconography or the uh the sceneries you know the the iconic places that you see throughout all three of the books are represented here and so it's it's just a very beautiful piece and everything just goes well together uh of course the art in War of the Ring duel uh warther ring the card game is fantastic as well but um and and then in general the the system that is in place with warther ring the card game is a lot more intense it's a longer game you could probably play this game in about

half an hour uh seven Wonder or seven wonders duel right uh Lord of the Ring stool you can play this in about half an hour once you understand the rules and everything whereas with war of the Ring the card game it will tend to be longer I haven't played the solo version of that game yet or the Cooperative version that came out with expansions but I believe even so it would it would take a longer time to do that than it would to play this game in front of you uh War of the Ring the card game can can play uh not just solo but also up to four players and so another big difference is that this is a two strictly two-player game so take that for what what it's worth the the other thing that I wanted to mention too was that seven wonders duel since it's haven't had a lot of time to uh be available for purchase and for development does have additional expansions available for that game and so the variability can really uh be altered and increased with different modules and different cards that you can add to that game versus with now Lord of the Rings duel as a base game the uh what you see is what you get with the box and while there is Inbox variability from game to game it it's reminiscent of what's Seven Wonders duels duel was like when it was first released with uh just the base game and the slight variabilities that are offered and this game in particular it's three-fold the way that the cards are uh set and uh

offered to you at the beginning of each round uh this is shuffled and dealt out in a similar fashion with cards face up and face down in this game you do have the alterations of the landscape tels that are available for you to use to Place Fort fortresses on or to take advant of different effects and then of course when you are dealing out this uh series of cards to draft from from round to round three of them will be discarded and so there are you'll never see all of the cards in each game you can play them through different effects from the discard pile but you won't be able to draft them and that's also very similar to seven wers duel so going into my concluding thoughts or I should say first impressions of what I thought about this game I mean it was very similar to what I felt about seven wonders duel when I first played it I thought that it was a great distillation of Seven Wonders at the sacrifice of course of not being able to play it with multiple people more than two players right uh the uh ability to play Seven Wonders with seven people in still about 30 to 40 minutes or so was fantastic right and it was very much a staple game that I pulled out many times since and many times now as well it's it's a big hit with a lot of the groups that I have played with recently I I can't do that essentially with seven with Lord of the Rings duel since it is limited to two players and yeah sure I could play against myself and still have a fun time battling myself you know uh the war within my mind or you know as it were while

playing this game but it's it's it's not the same experience that you would have sharing with multiple friends across a whole table rather than just having a more competitive experience against another player which is still fun and I you know intend to play a lot of games online for example with uh just another person so that way we can take as you know many turns and go quickly go quickly through the game uh but it's also a an enjoyable competitive experience to understand what your opponent is trying to do it's easier to manage their board and their Tableau with your own and predict what they might do right and so that aspect of gaming if you do enjoy that that is here as well and if you enjoy Seven Wonders duel the way that that's set up this is here as well you might miss out on the variability and the modularity that seven wonders duel has with all of the expansions but um I I suppose you might substitute that with the enjoyment of this theme in the way that it's Incorporated so just like how I felt if I reminisce back to what my thoughts and feelings were when I played Seven Wonders duel for the first time I thought well okay I have this Mar especially in the first round right I have this Market of cards sometimes there are like two or three cards sometimes there are more than that four cards to choose from sometimes there's only one card that you might choose from and you either can play it or have to discard it right and so seemingly at first glance the decision space isn't as Grand but you do when you do play this

game you understand that wait you can look ahead and look at the cards that are ahead of you in in in play order uh keeping in mind that some of these are face down as well and so there's always the element of the unknown but there is an element overall of planning ahead and Counting which cards you might want to play in the future that are face up that you can plan for and therefore affect your decisions now to kind of force your opponent to take other cards and so there is a lot more that goes on behind this game if you want to play it well uh very very much like seven wonders duel right and I I I get the same strategic depth that you know this Lord of the Rings duel has as compared to its base game it's its parent game in in the fact that you are wanting to strategically draft according to the information that is given to you and with the resources that you have but now applying that to different conditions that are represented in different ways the the weight of this game is about the same as Seven Wonders duel um once again I really enjoyed the simplification of the resources and the coins uh not having to really compare yourself to your opponent in that regard makes it a little bit easier but um and and then this game as you I should go back to my thought with the first round it doesn't seem like you're accomplishing much you're kind of building a foundation of say you know resources and some troops on this map as well maybe advancing along this track a little bit and then you slowly slowly start to get more resources to afford these landscape ties these will give you a lot of different resources and play a

big impact on the central board or on this track Etc uh by the time you reach the third round you will start to I guess have the opportunity at first build all of these units but then to move them in the third round and really take a lot of the conflict that is uh climaxed in the books as well I I feel there there are obviously contentions and conflicts earlier on in the game but it really comes to a head in the last book and that's kind of how this is represented as well so another nod to thematic integration for how these purple cards which were originally Guild cards in Seven Wonders duel and gave you some endgame objectives to pursue for points or what have you and so I I really like how that was mented here um but yeah so it it really ramped up by the end of the third round you could end the game before all the cards were were drafted and it the game should end because there are no ways to score points at the end of the game if you do happen to get to the end and no one has won via the endgame Victory conditions then whoever has the most presence on the board wins and so so there is a way to end the game after all the carts are drawn but I I feel like it might not happen as often as it does with seven wonders duel I think it's this game is set up to really uh end somewhere in the middle of this third uh this third age or the the third book rather so would I play I guess the question that's left for me is would I play this game versus seven Waters duel uh probably I think I would play this game more often than I

would seven wers duel for the theme I think it offers the same experience it's it's a very strategic game but very streamlined and easy to teach easy to learn and so I really appreciate that that we kind of all knew that going into this game the designers would present a game that is very similar in strategy and learnability as Seven Wonders duel and so I think this game accomplishes that and does it in a very thematic way that I really just enjoy looking at the cards playing the cards playing the the movie and the books in my mind as I build up my Tableau and so it was it was very enjoyable to look at and to think about uh thematically as well as mechanically would I play this game over War The Ring of the card game I don't know I think I would if I'm only playing it's it's very different to say like uh if I only have another person to play with if I could play this game on board game arena for example then sure uh I think I would play this game more often if I had more of a regular group who wanted to play warther Ring the card game and had more time to do so I think that game is richer in terms of complexity and strategy and so that game would take precedence if I had a more uh regular you know scheduled playthrough of that game over with you know replayability so Lord of the Rings duel is going to be more replayable for me because it's easier to bring out and to learn and to teach and to play with other people and the fact that seven wonders duel is already on board game Arena says at least it tells me that

there's a higher chance that this game would be implemented digitally as well and with the popularity that it has garnered in the last couple of you know months then I think that is a very strong possibility so uh very different games very different situations but I feel like I'm more inclined the situation that I'm in with my board gaming life right now to play seeven uh Lord of the Rings duel so take that for what what it's worth I really enjoyed this game and look forward to playing it more perhaps there will be some expansion material as well to include like The Hobbit or things like that to make the game as variable and fresh and perhaps a little bit more complex like it's parent game seven wonders duel and I would look forward to that but yeah so I it's a high recommend for me especially if you like seven wonders duel and if you enjoy Lord of the Rings as well this is probably a very condensed yet uh rich and fulfilling experience if you do enjoy that theme so those are my my concluding uh first impressions of Seven Wonders uh duel the Lord of the Rings version right the Lord of the Rings duel uh the uh fate of middle sorry I forgot what it's called in English and here it is in French uh thank you for listening to to this and uh thank you for Consulting with me hope that you schedule an appointment with me real soon and I'll catch you on the next one take care

Progress saved