Traders of Osaka Review
Transcript
welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing traders of Osaka in this game players play Japanese martians who are acquiring money in order to purchase Goods at a market and then ship them off to be sold for a profit of victory points the problem is that ships have a tendency to get lost and sunk in storms at Sea and your opponents have a way of affecting the weather on those ships so first I'm going to go through a bunch of turns to show you how the game actually feels while you're playing it and then I'll jump into my review here's the starting setup for a three-player game of traders of Osaka we have the three player colors down here each player has a starting hand of cards whose values equal to or exceed eight when you sum up the numbers players also begin with a bonus chip of their choosing there are four different colors which correspond to the four colors of goods out here so the gray player chose red pink chose yellow and then the tan player chose red as well that's fine they don't have to be different colors from each other on each turn a player must choose one out of three different options to evaluate their whole turn the first of these options is to buy the goods on the market and that is this row here but in order to do that they have to discard cards from their hands with the values that sum up to the total number of the goods on the whole Market you can't pick and choose so right now the cost to buy everything on the market is 12 and the gray player only has nine buying power in their hands so that is not an option for their turn the second action option for your turn is to simply draw one card from the market and pull it into your hand as gold so it is no longer the suit that it
is it's just the number and the third action option is a player can take their reservation token and put it down on any card either in the market or here in the future Farms these cards will be shifted down once the market depletes so you have some idea of what's coming in the future so our gray player could for instance put this token down here and what this means is no other player can ever take this card either through buying cards on the market or just drawing Cards into their hand for money so now it's the pink players turn and they have 10 buying power in their hand which is still not quite enough for the 12 out here on the market so they might choose just to draw this three value card into their hand and now they have 13 buying power for their next turn you'll notice that the market does not automatically replenish that happens at predefined times which I'll get to in a minute it's now the tan player's turn and you'll notice that the market is much cheaper it only costs nine total to grab because the pink player took that one card and the tan player actually has 12 buying power in their hand so they're going to choose to buy the cards on the market in order to do this you have to discard the buying power equal to or greater than that sum so in this case they could discard these three cards which totals 10 value which is more than nine to the discard pile and then the tan player is going to take all these cards and display them in front of them at this moment I would like to point out that there is a bit of a graphical glitch with only the red 3 in the game one corner is fine you see a little three that's great but the other Corner appears to have a two underlaid underneath that three making it kind of look like a backward six it's not a big deal but it threw us off a couple times so these Goods that were purchased go into little columns in front of that
player and these are now not in their hand and they're not able to use the gold value of these instead they're going to try and ship these for victory points every time a player buys from the market we're going to go to the farms in order to replenish the market for the next players so these cards shift down but there's always got to be up to five cards in the market so we draw two more randomly from the top of the deck and then we draw three more for the next future Farm cards the last part of the market purchase phase for a player is we need to move up the associated ships down the coast of Japan that means we move the red yellow and green ships the yellow and green ships both move once because there's one of each of those cards the red ship is gonna move twice because of the two red cards it's important to note that if the tan player had purchased three red cards on the market this ship would still only move two that is the maximum movement value of these ships it's once again the gray player's turn they have nine buying power in their hands still and the market now costs 20 because well they still have to get this card it's theirs they put the reservation token down so instead they're just going to go ahead and grab this five power card and now on their following turn they'll have 14 buying power to potentially buy stuff on the market and now it's the pink player's turn and the market only costs 10 for pink because gray put this reservation disc down that means pink has no way to get this card so it effectively does not exist so they can go ahead and spend 10 power from their hand into the discard Pile in order to purchase all of these cards and put them into their area in front of them this would of course move the blue ship twice and the yellow ship once and lastly because a market purchase phase happened these cards are going to slide down we would draw one more from
the top and then three more again for the Farms at this point I'm going to skip forward a few turns so I can show you how selling your resources work all right so our pink player is going to spend these two cards to the bank in order to purchase the market because they put the reservation token down this is going to move the yellow ship and the blue ship up once this puts the yellow ship in to Harbor at Edo and this is the moment that we are going to sell our Goods the first thing that happens is that each player is going to sell all of their yellow Goods because the yellow ship is the only one that went into Harbor there's a bit of an equation to go through to figure out how many victory points you're going to get so let's jump right into it the first thing you do is you look to see what your highest card is in this case it would be five so that is the price for yellow for the pink player however they have this yellow bonus chip which adds one to the price so we have five plus one or six for the total price now we multiply six by the number of cards that we have taken to Edo so in this case six times two is twelve now we round that number to the closest Five divisor going up so 12 turns into 15 and then we divide that number by five again bringing this down to three which means they score three points or three cards in this case they only had two goods so they draw one more from the top of the deck doesn't matter what it is it gets put face down underneath the small chip here to show that they have three victory points in the bank for the tan player they just have this single two so two is the price two times one is two you round that up
to five and then divide by five and you only get one so they just score this single card here because their bonus chip was red and that doesn't apply to Yellow sales and finally the gray player over here they also don't have a yellow bonus so their price is three three times two is six you round that up to ten and divide by five means you score two cards here so the pink player definitely made out best out of all this with three points and then two for gray and one for Tan next up each player is going to get a bonus chip of the ship that they just sold good for so now the pink player S2 and everybody else has one and now it's time for the black tide if you look over here you'll see that there are three different locations on this map that are on the mainland but two of them are outlined middle of the ocean well the black tide hits every time a sale happens in Edo that means all the ships that are out at Sea get pushed back to Inori but even worse they lose all of their goods in that process so every single player is going to lose all of their red and blue cards that they have purchased however some cards have these little Insurance icons on them the twos all have two of these icons the three value cards have one and the five value cards have none so the pink player can discard this card right here in order to protect two of their blue Goods in this case they'll probably protect the five and the three and this uh two blue is Lost at Sea the tan player has no red cards at all so they cannot ensure these two goods so they are lost at sea and finally our great player here they could discard this three that has a single Insurance icon on it so they will in order to protect
this card right here but unfortunately their one red card is a five it has no insurance tokens so this really nice red good is lost finally our yellow ship will travel all the way back to Osaka to make the route again and then we would shift these cards down fill up the market and it would then go on to be the tan player's turn and this is pretty much the entire game you're going to keep doing this until at the end of a Payday where people sell if one player has eight or more of these little bonus chips then the game ends immediately at that point you're gonna count up all of the cards that are underneath these little tokens and these are just victory points one to one for the cards and you'll see who has the most cards and that person wins so let's start the review section off with the first positive point and this has to do with the fact that there are a very small amount of things that you can do on your turn but how you do those is still interesting to think about you know the first thing is you could use a reservation token and it seems like those are rarely used so maybe you look at the board and you're like I don't need the reservation token I'm not going to worry about that the second thing you look at the board you say can I even buy all these cards maybe you don't have enough money in your hand so don't worry about it you can't do that so the third thing that you could do do pretty much the only thing you're going to want to do in this one hypothetical turn is you're going to draw one card from the market and put it in your hand for money well which card do you draw do you grab that five because it gives you a much a lot more buying power to buy Cards in the market on your next turn or maybe you grab that red too because you could see the next person in line the next person who's going to take their turn just needs a single red to push that
ship into Harbor and they have a bunch of cards in their hand they can probably buy them so you might take that card specifically because you don't want that red ship to move because it'll sink a blue ship and you have a bunch of blue goods and you can't insure them and there's just all these things to think about or maybe you just look over and you say oh I don't really care nobody's in Jeopardy I'm going to take the five that was a pretty simple turn what this ends up meaning is most turns are pretty quick like you can just do some quick math can you even buy from the market and usually if you're in a situation where you can buy from the market it'll only take you I don't know 10 seconds to look at your area and look at the boats and decide whether that makes sense to you now of course somebody could tunnel down really hard but you know thinking about oh well what's this whether what are the odds we've seen a lot of this car to that card but in general that hasn't happened most turns tend to take about 10 seconds so it just runs around the table and it just feels like the game has a very good pace and quite a good number of things to think about positive Point number two is that I wasn't really expecting a push your luck vibe to this game but I think it's there you know when you are making these purchases you take these goods and you put them into your area you are essentially gambling to a certain extent you're looking at the ships and I mean sometimes you do that and it immediately puts a ship into the dock and you sell and there's no Randomness there but if you're not in that situation if you're pushing ships out into that black-tied area well you are you're hoping that that ship is going to make it and it's not going to sink and you're going to lose those goods maybe you have some insurance cards in your hands so you can kind of hedge your bets but using those as insurance makes you lose some buying
power in your hand which is not great either now you can look at the farms and you can see three out of the five next cards to come out so you can make an educated guess as to whether buying this set from the market is a good idea you know if that red ship is about to go there and all three of those cards are red well maybe you don't buy from the market in such a situation so that you're gonna lose all those with the red ship Docks but maybe they're are no red chips out there and you feel safe and you take those well you push those cars down but you reveal two more random cards from the top of the deck and that's kind of where this push your luck Vibe comes in those could be two red cards right there and right away that thing that you just spent all that money on a bunch of that stuff might just wash away in the tide and you feel kind of bummed out about that but maybe that doesn't happen and you need to push your luck in order to have these Goods to sell if you play Super conservative conservatively it doesn't seem like you are going to get as many points so in the end the kind of push you luck looking at the Futures market and making some educated guesses is a fun aspect of the game that I wasn't really expecting so now let's move into the neutral points and the first of these is that I'm not really sure how you go about doing well at this game and that sentiment has been mirrored by most of the people that played the game was so far I did just mention that if you take no risks that you probably won't do very well but beyond that I'm not really sure how you go about consistently doing very well or winning at this game uh Laura often than not it seems like the person who has won has been surprised by that they feel like they were doing terribly and well really I'm the person who won I kept losing Goods to the black tide and
ultimately everybody has been losing Goods to the black tide kind of all game long so everybody's constantly feeling like they're not doing very well and one of those people ends up winning the game and I play the game a few times now and even the last time I played it I just felt like I was in the same situation I was in the first game where I'm making educated decisions I'm you know looking at the boats on the in the black ties and the ones that aren't I'm buying things from the market like trying to hedge my bets and trying to pull cards up and even use that reservation token I'm really not sure how to do that well but try to use it to my advantage and it just it doesn't seem like it works out that well specifically that reservation token it seems like half the time that gets used it bites that person uh back instead of giving them a bonus because now everybody else is getting a discount to buying things from the market because they can't buy that one card they put the token down on but that person doesn't get a discount they have to buy this huge thing out there and so ultimately they usually just end up pulling into their hand for money to kind of get out of a vicious cycle of of giving everybody discounts on the market and that's usually when they they're bummed about that when they put the reservation token down specifically to try and purchase that card into their player area so I think with time I will likely get better at the game but at this point I don't directly see the avenue to that and it's already turned off a couple of the people I play games with and neutral number two is pretty simple there are a couple annoying Design Elements to this game that make playing the game a little bit harder first of all as I showed in the gameplay example one of the cards just straight up has a sort of typo on it where the three is
overlapped on top of the two and you can kind of tell it's a three because the other one is visible but I'm if you're just looking at it from afar it's kind of a convoluted mess of numbers and then on top of that just all the numbers in general They Don't Really jump off the card as well as I'd like as being the number that they are you know the two and the five if you just glance down man just the way the iconography works out they look so similar and just I think that they went with far too blocky of numbers for those cards if they had gone with much more swoopy numbers it would jump out at what exactly those cards are specifically trying to be now this hasn't like really screwed up the game nobody's taken a card because they thought it was something else but it's just something that's kind of scratched at me from the background as I'm playing the game it's just a little annoyance when and I'm trying to read what these cards are so now let's go into the one negative I have for the game and that is that I really dislike the math you have to do when you are finally selling your goods in for victory points for a couple reasons the first reason is that teaching this game is much harder because of it the game is so elegant as you're teaching it oh just put this token down your turn is done or just draw a car and your turn is done buy everything from the market just do some simple addition and your turn is done but then you get to the point where you're selling Goods at the market and it's like you slapped everybody at the table in the face they'll wait what did you just say was that a joke you're like no that's not actually a joke you find the big one and then you add and then you multiply and then you round and then you divide and that's actually what you do and more often than not you end up
just cashing in the points for those cards like you have three cards you're probably gonna score three cards you have four cards you're probably gonna score four cards occasionally you will score one less occasionally you will score one more but in general it's just the number of cards and I feel like there could have been a solution out there that they could have designed and that maybe would have been like 70 or 80 percent as good as the currently one in the box but that would be like three times more streamlined you know maybe just icons on the card to find the card with the most icons and add that to the achievement tokens you have and that's what you score or something much simpler that doesn't have all these different steps along the way now once you do this a couple times you do it quite quickly the math is not difficult it's just annoying that you have to jump through all these hoops to usually just score the number of cards it feels like an inside joke that made it into the game and ultimately I just I just like it I feel like they could have done better so let's discuss replayability now traders of Osaka is one of those games where you're pretty much going to be doing the same thing every turn of every game you know the third turn is going to be very similar to your 25th turn within a specific game but when it is your turn you do have interesting decisions and you have some risks you can take and cards that you can grab and things that you can look out to your all the other players so I enjoy that turn that you are having pretty much every single turn and there is an ebb and flow where you're going to be taking a couple turns to grab money and then you cash out and get some goods and then a couple turns to cat to grab money but in general it is a bit samey feeling and I played the game a couple times now and I've enjoyed playing it each time but I haven't
unlocked or seen anything too much deeper in there as I mentioned before I don't really know how to play the game well so hopefully with another couple plays I'll start to see patterns in the way I can do much better at the game maybe trying to Target specific achievement tokens more often than not in general at the end of the day I think the replayability in this game is tolerable it's okay I don't think it's that great if anything it's a little less than average but I can still see myself playing it at least five or six more times alright so now let's discuss player count traders of Osaka place two to four players and I think that the best player count is probably three so let's talk about the two player game first it plays quite well but it seems like the reserve token is pretty much non-existent I'm that might be because I'm playing the game poorly and I'm not really sure how to do well but every time it got used and it only got used like maybe once or twice in the two player game I played it just backfired on the person it just didn't really seem to make sense um beyond that the game made sense because you're just going back and forth there's not that much chaos but I think that the three-player game played a little bit better that Reserve token felt a little more important and there was more to bounce off of you have two different opponents that might be going for different types of goods so there's a little bit more interesting things going on with the ships Out on the Ocean and then the four player game it worked pretty well I would not have a problem playing four player again but those ships and the way they move was a little bit more chaotic because there are three different terms that are going to happen before your next turn so it seems like more often than in the other player counts You're Gonna Lose Goods to the ocean because those ships just move a
lot faster when there's so many turns between your next turn in conclusion traders of Osaka intrigues me it is a interesting game to play I have enjoyed playing it but at the same time as I mentioned a couple times I I haven't really felt like I've done well in the game and I'm not really sure how to get too much better this has gone over kind of average with my play group there have been a couple players who just really didn't like it and there were a couple people who are like me where they they finish the game they don't know why they lost or why they won but they're like I want to play it again to try and figure it out because it's an odd little game you have that weird math you have to do when you're selling Goods which I obviously didn't like I went into quite a bit but you have a lot of really cool decisions to make it's a very simple game in general with the options that you have available to you on your turn to grab from that market and I like that I like simple turns because it just makes the game play relatively quickly I will say that the four player game felt a little longer than I wanted to be like it probably got like 45 to 50 minutes and for a game where you're kind of doing the same thing throughout the whole game I wish it was a little bit shorter and I think that's another reason why I like the three player game a little bit better so all in all I'm interested to keep trying this game to try and see where I'm going wrong and how to get better at it but ultimately it has a a couple weirdnesses and a couple flaws that I dislike that has also turned off a couple people in my group so I would suggest you give this game a try if it sounds interesting to you but this is not a wholehearted endorsement if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please
subscribe to my channel thanks for watching