San Juan 1897 Review: Puerto Rico's Scrappy Cousin
Transcript
Hey everybody, Zee Garcia here and today I'm taking a look at the latest printing of San Juan. This is San Juan 1897 special edition, the one that Awaken Realms printed to go along with their new Puerto Rico 1897 printing sometime ago. So this is the Puerto Rico card game, right? And in fact, I have my own printing of San Juan right here. This is my version that already replaced a previous version I had of San Juan. Point being, I've liked San Juan for a long time and still uh keep it. In here is the basic game as is in here plus some extra buildings that came out sometime ago and they included that uh is basically an expansion that they included in the box. Those buildings are also in here. So we're going to take a look at how the game works. If you don't know anything about San Juan or Puerto Rico, it doesn't matter. I'm going to show you how this works. I'll give you a hopefully brief overview here. We'll come on back and I'll tell you what I think of the game and what I think of this printing. Is this a good one? If you don't have the original printing, should you get this? Let's check it out.
So here we've got the game set up for three players. Everybody begins with one of these corn cottages and a hand of four cards. One person is given the governor card, they'll be the starting player. And we're going to be going around and around the table until someone triggers the end of the game by building 12 cards in front of them at the end of that builder phase, game's over. We're going to count up some victory points mainly from the points printed on the cards in front of you and a couple of other things. So starting from me cuz I have the governor card, I'm going to pick one of these five roles and we, all of the players, are going to do that role, but I get an advantage for being the one who picked it. So for example, let's say I want to do builder. Builder says build one building. My advantage is I get to pay one less. So I'm going to take this card and I am going to say, "Okay, we are all building. I will build a chapel." The chapel is going to have a special ability here that at the beginning of every round I get to tuck a card under it and that's worth victory points. It has a cost of three. It's going to be worth two victory points at the end of the game. That cost is paid with other cards from my hand. In this case, I get a discount of one. So, I am going to discard a two cards from my hand and I will do so over here. We'll just leave a messy pile to differentiate that from the draw deck. Having done that myself, the other players would do that or they could pass. This player could build say this one. It's going to cost them three, so everything they're holding. And then this player, let's say they don't want
to build, they'll pass on building. With that all done, we go to the next player who will pick one of the remaining abilities and we will all get to do that. And then finally, we'll go to this player who will pick one of the remaining ones. We'll all get to do that. That all done, we put these roles back into the middle and I pass the governor card to this player and we do it again. So, let me go ahead and explain what these various abilities do. Builder, we've already seen. You're going to be building buildings in front of you. They come in two different flavors. You have the ones that produce something, such as the corn cottage here, or the tobacco storage, or the fruit depot. They are all going to make a thing, one of these things. And then all of the other buildings, which are the chapel and the assembly hall and the fortress and all of those, which are going to have some special ability. They do something, generally speaking, during one of these phases.
So, that's what they do. Now, uh the recruiter here is going to allow you to draw cards and then keep one of them. You draw two and keep one. If you're the one who picked this, you get to look at three more. So, you'd be looking at five cards and keeping one of those. The uh craftsman is going to allow you to produce goods on these kinds of buildings. If you're the one who picked it, you get to produce on two goods. Normally, everybody else produces on one. What does producing mean? It means taking a card from here and producing that type of thing by putting this card on it like so. Now, this tobacco storage has tobacco on it. And it can only ever have one. It either is loaded or is not loaded. Now, going over to trader, that's how we sell these things from here. If you pick seller, the uh trader, then you get to trade two things. Uh normally, everybody else gets to sell one. That entails flipping over this card and seeing how much that thing sells for. And so, if I was selling my tobacco from the tobacco storage, I would discard this card and I would take two cards from the top of the deck and add those to my hand. In this game, you have a hand limit at the end of the round. Uh and so, you need to check it then.
There's a reminder for it when you pass a governor card written right on here. And so, that is trading. And then, the last one I have not explained yet is simply adventurer. No action, but if you pick it, you get to draw a card. No one else does anything. And so, that's the idea. Once this is done, by the way, we're going to tuck it at the bottom. And so, it is possible for you to learn the order of these cards. And they will vary uh based on the flip. Sometimes, the market's not so good. Sometimes, it's better than that. And you just have sort of have to be able to uh think about when the selling price is going to be high and strike at the right moment. Now, many of the cards, like I said, are going to affect these phases. And in fact, that's sort of the meat and potatoes of the game. The fact that uh the cards are going to have a symbol up here which corresponds to the symbol there, plus it tells you when it matters in the text. And so, if I have a distillery, for example, well, when the builder phase is triggered, I will check all of the buildings in front of me and realize, "Oh, hey, this matters when the builder phase is happening." And it says I pay one card less for production buildings. That's this kind of building.
So, while I have this in front of me, I pay one less for all of these kinds of cards. And if I am the one who triggered builder, by the way, I get that discount, and I get that discount, if applicable. And so, that card matters during the builder phase, this card matters during the adventurer phase, there's even the publishing house here matters during all of the phases. I don't just give you that advantage all of the time. And so, that's something to be aware of. Also, mix in here, right now, you see the cathedral set up here because there's an expansion that comes in the box that's shuffled in the deck already. All the expansion cards have that symbol there. And the cathedral, being the most expensive building in the entire game at a cost of seven, actually begins on the table, and anybody could build that thing. Whoever builds it first, they're the only one who gets it, but it is a very, very hard it to build because it is so expensive. And so, that begins there, but there's many other cards that have been shuffled into this deck that are new from the original core box of San Juan, the card game. These are traditional or original cards. The ones with that symbol come from that expansion, which was available after the fact. So, there we go. That should give you an idea of how the whole thing operates. Let's go ahead and go back up top.
Now, I have not personally played the new printing of Puerto Rico. In fact, I always liked San Juan better than Puerto Rico, so I probably won't play the new Awaken Realms version of Puerto Rico, but I will say I think this version of San Juan is good. I think it is well put together. The game is really largely the same. There's very little that changed here. They changed the number of cards a little bit, uh the distribution of of the buildings that make resources to the other kinds of buildings, that changed a little bit. And then the titles of things changed quite a bit. Uh I took the two rule books and sort of went back and forth to see what was different. Not with a fine-tooth comb or anything, but just to see what I could spot. And the changes largely seem to be just what the buildings are called, which is fine if you don't you're not comparing them side by side, and you shouldn't be, it's not going to matter what they're calling the buildings. The building names are uh are logical and they're they're just fine. As far as the componentry in here, I think the cards are good quality.
Uh everything is cards in this box. There is nothing else in it. You are going to get a rule book. You are going to get a little plastic cover that goes over two wells filled with cards. Now, if you're a sleever, I think you're going to be in trouble here. Uh I don't think this will literally fit back in here if you sleeve it. If you're not, then you're fine. Uh the original game had some things that were not card, uh and they were cardboard instead. The tiles for the character selection, the role selection rather, those are cardboard tiles. When you went to the trading house, those are little cardboard tiles, and those listed the prices. Same thing Same idea, you'd still tuck one underneath after you Everybody was able to trade, but now in the new printing, it's all just cards.
And that's fine. It works very, very well. In In it might even be more portable. You can now take all these cards, put them in your quiver or in some carrying case with other card games and take it with. That's all you need, right? So, I like that. I think it's well done. The the writing, the language, I noticed a couple of small issues with quality control, but nothing particularly egregious. Overall, this is the same game and I like this game. I think it's a very well put together game. So, if you cannot get your hands on the original printing of San Juan or you like this new look or you already have the Puerto Rico and want to check out the card game version, I certainly am not going to discourage you cuz I like San Juan a lot.
And I think this printing is ultimately comparable to my printing and it's a smaller box to boot, which you know, might be good for those of us that have issues keeping our shelves clear of games, right? It's a good issue to have, but it is a consideration. So, for me, I'm going to come down on San Juan 1897 special edition here at an eight out of 10. Same thing I rate the other one, in fact. And it's going to get a seal of approval. So, there you go. That is San Juan, the new printing of it. Check the game out if you never have. It's an oldie, but it's still a goodie and I for one I'm glad that it is back in print and maybe more people will get a chance to experience it. So, that's it for me, folks. Thank you very much for tuning in and checking this out with me. My name is Zee Garcia. I'll see you on the next one.
Hey, thanks for watching another video here on The Dice Tower. We really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at The Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support The Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description of this video. We have links to lots of other things we do down there, so definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watch us. Tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vasel, and I hope you enjoyed this video.